D.G. EX REL. BONILLA v. COUNTY OF KERN

Case No. 1:15-CV-00760-JAM-JLT.

D.G., a minor, by and through his guardian ad litem, Denise Bonilla, individually and as successor-in-interest to David Garcia, deceased; D.E.G., a minor, by and through her guardian ad litem, Denise Bonilla, individually and as successor-in-interest to David Garcia, deceased; G.D., a minor, by and through her guardian ad litem, Denise Bonilla, individually and as successor-in-interest to David Garcia, deceased; RAMONA RAMIREZ NUNEZ, individually, Plaintiffs, v. COUNTY OF KERN; DOES 1 THROUGH 10, Defendants.

United States District Court, E.D. California.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 42 U.S.C. § 1983
Cause: 42 U.S.C. § 1983 Civil Rights Act
Nature of Suit: 440 Civil Rights: Other
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

D. G., Plaintiff, represented by Dale K. Galipo , Law Offices of Dale K. Galipo.

D. G., Plaintiff, represented by Matthew C. Clark , Chain & Cohn & Stiles, Neil K. Gehlawat , Chain & Cohn & Stiles, Melanie Tara Partow , Law Offices Of Dale K. Galipo & David K. Cohn , Chain Cohn Stiles.

D. E. G., Plaintiff, represented by Dale K. Galipo , Law Offices of Dale K. Galipo, Matthew C. Clark , Chain & Cohn & Stiles, Neil K. Gehlawat , Chain & Cohn & Stiles, Melanie Tara Partow , Law Offices Of Dale K. Galipo & David K. Cohn , Chain Cohn Stiles.

G. D., Plaintiff, represented by Dale K. Galipo , Law Offices of Dale K. Galipo, Matthew C. Clark , Chain & Cohn & Stiles, Neil K. Gehlawat , Chain & Cohn & Stiles, Melanie Tara Partow , Law Offices Of Dale K. Galipo & David K. Cohn , Chain Cohn Stiles.

Ramona Ramirez Nunez, Plaintiff, represented by Dale K. Galipo , Law Offices of Dale K. Galipo, Matthew C. Clark , Chain & Cohn & Stiles, Neil K. Gehlawat , Chain & Cohn & Stiles, Melanie Tara Partow , Law Offices Of Dale K. Galipo & David K. Cohn , Chain Cohn Stiles.

County of Kern, Defendant, represented by Andrew C. Thomson , Office of County Counsel, County of Kern.

Robert Reed, Defendant, represented by Andrew C. Thomson , Office of County Counsel, County of Kern.


ORDER APPROVING COMPROMISE FOR MINORS D.G., D.E.G and G.D.

JOHN A. MENDEZ, District Judge.

The Petition of Denise Bonilla, as Guardian ad Litem for Plaintiffs, D.G., D.E.G, and G.D., minors, for an Order approving Compromise of the Claim of Plaintiffs, D.G., D.E.G. and G.D. came on regularly for hearing on June 20, 2017 at 9:30 a.m., in Courtroom 6, 14th Floor of the Robert T. Matsui United States Courthouse located at 501 I Street, Sacramento, California before the Honorable Judge, John A. Mendez.

Neil K. Gehlawat appeared on behalf of Plaintiffs, D.G., D.E.G. and G.D. who were present with petitioner, Denise Bonilla, their guardian ad litem. There was no appearance by anyone on behalf of Defendants.

No opposition having been submitted by Defendants, and good cause appearing therefore,

IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED:

1. Defendant County of Kern agrees to pay the combined sum of $400,000.00 (hereinafter "settlement money") on behalf of all defendants County of Kern and Deputy Robert Reed in consideration of a full and final release and discharge of and from all claims, charges, and demands of Plaintiffs, D.G., D.E.G. and G.D. arising from this action. Petitioner is hereby authorized and directed to execute and deliver to defendants a full, complete, and final release and discharge of and from any and all claims and demands of herself and Plaintiffs, D.G, D.E.G, and G.D. by reason of the incident described herein and resulting injuries, upon receipt of the settlement money.

2. From the above settlement money, the County of Kern agrees to pay $55,000.00 for the purchase of an annuity on behalf of plaintiff, D.G., with a guaranteed benefit of $70,462.87, as more fully described in the Settlement Proposal attached hereto as Exhibit "A". The parties have arranged for the purchase of a tax-free structured settlement annuity policy for D.G. from Metropolitan Life Insurance Company through broker Tom Stevenson of Atlas Settlements. The defendants County of Kern and Deputy Robert Reed (hereinafter collectively referred to as "County") agree to execute a Settlement Agreement and Release and execute a "Qualified Assignment" of their obligation to make periodic payments pursuant thereto in compliance with I.R.C. Section 104(a)(2) and Section 130(c) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended. Said assignment shall be made to Metlife Tower Resources Group ("Assignee"). Upon doing so, the County will no longer be obligated to make further periodic payments and the Assignee will be the plaintiff's sole obligor with respect to the future periodic payments. Assignee shall purchase a structured settlement annuity for $55,000.00 through Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, which is rated A+, Class 15 through A.M. Best Insurance Rating Service. The payments shall be assigned to Metlife Tower Resources Group, Inc. by way of a Qualified Assignment by the County. The payments will be guaranteed through the issuance of a Letter of Guarantee from Metlife Tower Resources Group, assumed under the Qualified Assignment. In accordance with the structured settlement agreement, the assignee will fund the obligation to make payments through the purchase of an Annuity from Metropolitan Life Insurance Company. Said annuity shall provide guaranteed periodic payments (subject to annuity rates in effect at the time of purchase) made according to the schedule found in the Settlement Proposal attached hereto as Exhibit "A".

Such assignment shall be accepted by the Plaintiff without right of rejection and shall completely release and discharge the Defendants from such obligations hereunder as are assigned to Assignee(s).

No part of the said $55,000.00 may be paid to the Petitioner Denise Bonilla and this court having determined that a tax-free structured settlement is in the best interest of the minor. D.G. by and through his guardian ad litem, Denise Bonilla, is authorized to settle this claim on behalf of D.G. and receive and negotiate funds on behalf of the minor. No bond shall be required of D.G., by and through her guardian ad litem, Denise Bonilla. Receipt of purchase of annuity is to be filed with the Court within sixty (60) days.

3. From the above settlement money, the County of Kern agrees to pay $55,000.00 for the purchase of an annuity on behalf of plaintiff, D.E.G., with a guaranteed benefit of $73,526.87, as more fully described in the Settlement Proposal attached hereto as Exhibit "B". The parties have arranged for the purchase of a tax-free structured settlement annuity policy for D.E.G. from Metropolitan Life Insurance Company through broker Tom Stevenson of Atlas Settlements. The Defendants County of Kern and Deputy Robert Reed (hereinafter collectively referred to as "County") agree to execute a Settlement Agreement and Release and execute a "Qualified Assignment" of their obligation to make periodic payments pursuant thereto in compliance with I.R.C. Section 104(a)(2) and Section 130(c) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended. Said assignment hall be made to Metlife Tower Resources Group Inc. ("Assignee"). Upon doing so, County will no longer be obligated to make further periodic payments and the Assignee will be the plaintiff's sole obligor with respect to the future periodic payments. Assignee shall purchase a structured settlement annuity for $55,000.00 through Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, which is rated A+, Class 15 through A.M. Best Insurance Rating Service. The payments shall be assigned to Metlife Tower Resources Group, Inc. by way of a Qualified Assignment by the Defendants County of Kern. The payments will be guaranteed through the issuance of a Letter of Guarantee from Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, assumed under the Qualified Assignment. In accordance with the structured settlement agreement, the assignee will fund the obligation to make payments through the purchase of an Annuity from Metropolitan Life Insurance Company. Said annuity shall provide guaranteed periodic payments (subject to annuity rates in effect at the time of purchase) made according to the schedule found in the Settlement Proposal attached hereto as Exhibit "C". Such assignment shall be accepted by the Plaintiff without right of rejection and shall completely release and discharge the Defendant from such obligations hereunder as are assigned to Assignee(s).

No part of the said $55,000.00 may be paid to the Petitioner Denise Bonilla and this court having determined that a tax-free structured settlement is in the best interest of the minor D.E.G., by and through her guardian ad litem, Denise Bonilla, is authorized to settle this claim on behalf of D.E.G. and receive and negotiate funds on behalf of the minor. No bond shall be required of D.E.G., by and through her guardian ad litem, Denise Bonilla. Receipt of purchase of annuity is to be filed with the Court within sixty (60) days.

4. From the above settlement money, the County of Kern agrees to pay $55,000.00 for the purchase of an annuity on behalf of plaintiff, G.D., with a guaranteed benefit of $64,039.69, as more fully described in the Settlement Proposal attached hereto as Exhibit "C". The parties have arranged for the purchase of a tax-free structured settlement annuity policy for G.D. from Metropolitan Life Insurance Company through broker Tom Stevenson of Atlas Settlements. The defendants County Of Kern, and Deputy Robert Reed (hereinafter collectively referred to as "County") agree to execute a Settlement Agreement and Release and execute a "Qualified Assignment" of their obligation to make periodic payments pursuant thereto in compliance with I.R.C. Section 104(a)(2) and Section 130(c) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended. Said assignment shall be made to Metlife Tower Resources Group, Inc. ("Assignee"). Upon doing so, the defendants will no longer be obligated to make further periodic payments and the Assignee will be the plaintiff's sole obligor with respect to the future periodic payments. Assignee shall purchase a structured settlement annuity for $55,000.00 through Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, which is rated A+, Class 15 through A.M. Best Insurance Rating Service. The payments shall be assigned to Metlife Tower Resources Group, Inc. by way of a Qualified Assignment by the Defendants County. The payments will be guaranteed through the issuance of a Letter of Guarantee from Metropolitan Life Insurance Company assumed under the Qualified Assignment. In accordance with the structured settlement agreement, the assignee will fund the obligation to make payments through the purchase of an Annuity from Metropolitan Life Insurance Company. Said annuity shall provide guaranteed periodic payments (subject to annuity rates in effect at the time of purchase) made according to the schedule found in the Settlement Proposal attached hereto as Exhibit "D". Such assignment shall be accepted by the Plaintiff without right of rejection and shall completely release and discharge the Defendant from such obligations hereunder as are assigned to Assignee(s).

No part of the said $55,000.00 may be paid to the Petitioner Denise Bonilla, and this court having determined that a tax-free structured settlement is in the best interest of the minor. G.D., by and through her guardian ad litem, Denise Bonilla is authorized to settle this claim on behalf of G.D. and receive and negotiate funds on behalf of the minor. No bond shall be required of G.D. by and through her guardian ad litem, Denise Bonilla. Receipt of purchase of annuity is to be filed with the Court within sixty (60) days.

5. From the above stated settlement money, the County of Kern agrees to pay the sum of $165,000.00 which shall immediately be paid to Metlife Tower Resources Group, Inc.

6. From the above stated settlement money, the County of Kern agrees to pay the sum of $235,000.00 to Ramona Ramirez Nunez and Chain Cohn Stiles.

7. Payment to Chain | Cohn | Stiles and the Law Office of Dale K. Galipo in the sum of $211,350.56 is approved for the payment of attorney fees, costs and reasonable expenses incurred in connection with the prosecution of this action.

THE COURT GRANTS THE PETITION FOR MINORS' COMPROMISE.

IT IS SO ORDERED.


Comment

1000 Characters Remaining

Leagle.com reserves the right to edit or remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.

User Comments

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases