MULLINS v. ETHICON, INC.

Civil Action No. 2:12-CV-02952.

TERRESKI MULLINS, et al., Plaintiffs, v. ETHICON, INC., et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, S.D. West Virginia, Charleston Division.

December 7, 2015.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Terreski Mullins, and, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Merritt E. Cunningham , SMITH STAG, Michael G. Stag , SMITH STAG, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE, Philip Jay Starr , LAWCO USA & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Brian Mullins, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Merritt E. Cunningham , SMITH STAG, Michael G. Stag , SMITH STAG, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE, Philip Jay Starr , LAWCO USA & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Rebecca S. Sprout, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Mark W. Davis , DAVIS & CRUMP, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Richard H. Sprout, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Mark W. Davis , DAVIS & CRUMP, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Kathie Iquinto, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, J. Mark Kell , KELL LAMPIN, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Debra Daniel, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Karen H. Beyea-Schroeder , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Randy Daniel, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Karen H. Beyea-Schroeder , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Reta J. Dillon, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Gregory L. Laker , COHEN & MALAD, Irwin B. Levin , COHEN & MALAD, Jeff S. Gibson , COHEN & MALAD, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Perry E. Dillon, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Gregory L. Laker , COHEN & MALAD, Irwin B. Levin , COHEN & MALAD, Jeff S. Gibson , COHEN & MALAD, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Janet Webb, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Aimee H. Wagstaff , ANDRUS & WAGSTAFF, Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Marc D. Grossman , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN, Randi Kassan , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Kenneth Webb, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Aimee H. Wagstaff , ANDRUS & WAGSTAFF, Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Marc D. Grossman , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN, Randi Kassan , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Patricia Bernice Martinez, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Paul D. Stevens , MILSTEIN ADELMAN, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Deidre McIntyre, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Breanne Vandemeer Cope , MOTLEY RICE, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Harry F. Bell, Jr. , THE BELL LAW FIRM, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

James McIntyre, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Breanne Vandemeer Cope , MOTLEY RICE, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Harry F. Bell, Jr. , THE BELL LAW FIRM, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Nancy Oxley, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Breanne Vandemeer Cope , MOTLEY RICE, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Harry F. Bell, Jr. , THE BELL LAW FIRM, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Janet Atkins, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, James A. McKowen , JAMES F. HUMPHREYS & ASSOCIATES, Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Richard Atkins, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, James A. McKowen , JAMES F. HUMPHREYS & ASSOCIATES, Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Carolyn Garcia, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Sean Michael Cleary , LAW OFFICES OF SEAN M. CLEARY, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Leslie D. Lowe, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Jason J. Thompson , SOMMERS SCHWARTZ, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Wanda Dameron, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, John Fabry , MUELLER LAW, Mark R. Mueller , MUELLER LAW, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Robert Dameron, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, John Fabry , MUELLER LAW, Mark R. Mueller , MUELLER LAW, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Theresa Vanbuskirk, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Aaron Clark Johnson , SUMMERS & JOHNSON, Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, David G. Summers , SUMMERS & JOHNSON, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

David Masoka, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Aaron Clark Johnson , SUMMERS & JOHNSON, Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, David G. Summers , SUMMERS & JOHNSON, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Elizabeth Mullens, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, James A. McKowen , JAMES F. HUMPHREYS & ASSOCIATES, Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Bobby Mullens, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, James A. McKowen , JAMES F. HUMPHREYS & ASSOCIATES, Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Judith A. Shears, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Charles Bland Patrick , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Jeffrey L. Haberman , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Gary F. Shears, Jr., Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Charles Bland Patrick , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Carol J. Javins, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Carl N. Frankovitch , FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Kevin M. Pearl , FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Quincy R. Javins, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Carl N. Frankovitch , FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Kevin M. Pearl , FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Crystal Barr, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE, Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

James Barr, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE, Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Angie Lee Lambert, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Rebecca G. Cook, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Kyla Cole , WATERS & KRAUS, Leslie C. MacLean , WATERS & KRAUS, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Loretta Stevens, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, David M. Peterson , PETERSON & ASSOCIATES, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Nicholas S. Clevenger , PETERSON & ASSOCIATES, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Connie L. Harmon, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Andy Dow Birchfield, Jr. , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, P. Leigh O'Dell , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Judith Snodgrass, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Aimee H. Wagstaff , ANDRUS & WAGSTAFF, Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Marc D. Grossman , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN, Randi Kassan , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Alberta Miller, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Ryan L. Thompson , WATTS GUERRA CRAFT, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Carol Matney, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Deborah Kay Levy , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Harris Junell , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY, Patricia L. Campbell , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Larry E. Matney, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Deborah Kay Levy , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Harris Junell , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY, Patricia L. Campbell , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Kathy Jones, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Robert E. Price , LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL RAFFERTY & PROCTOR, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Richard Jones, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Robert E. Price , LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL RAFFERTY & PROCTOR, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Marianna Humbert, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, W. James Singleton , THE SINGLETON LAW FIRM, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Karen Sue Gillum, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Jason A. Itkin , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Kurt B. Arnold , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Mark C. Sparks , MOSTYN LAW FIRM & Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE.

Karen Sue Gillum, Consol Plaintiff, represented by

Samuel Gillum, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES.

Samuel Gillum, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Jason A. Itkin , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Kurt B. Arnold , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Carol Whisner, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Mark E. Burton, Jr. , HERSH & HERSH, Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, William M. Audet , AUDET & PARTNERS, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Vince Whisner, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Mark E. Burton, Jr. , HERSH & HERSH, Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, William M. Audet , AUDET & PARTNERS, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Cora Lynn Tomblin, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Ethan Lee Shaw , SHAW COWART, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Justin William Fishback , SHAW COWART, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Rebecca Schepleng, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Mark W. Davis , DAVIS & CRUMP, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Janice Tyler, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Sean Patrick Tracey , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM, Shawn Fox , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Robert Tyler, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Sean Patrick Tracey , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM, Shawn Fox , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Jane Kelly, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Jason A. Itkin , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Kurt B. Arnold , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Mark C. Sparks , MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Ronald Kelly, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Jason A. Itkin , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Kurt B. Arnold , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Irene M. Lundell, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Tamara L. Banno , FREESE & GOSS, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Sandra Cheshire, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, H. Philip Grossman , GROSSMAN & MOORE, Jennifer Ann Moore , GROSSMAN & MOORE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

James Cheshire, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, H. Philip Grossman , GROSSMAN & MOORE, Jennifer Ann Moore , GROSSMAN & MOORE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Janet Burgoyne, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Gregory Neil McEwen , MCEWEN LAW FIRM, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Danny Burgoyne, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Gregory Neil McEwen , MCEWEN LAW FIRM, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Teresa Bennett, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Sean Patrick Tracey , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM, Shawn Fox , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Kevin Bennett, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Sean Patrick Tracey , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM, Shawn Fox , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Lisa Russell, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bobby Jewell Bell, Jr. , HOLLIS WRIGHT & COUCH, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Michael Russell, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bobby Jewell Bell, Jr. , HOLLIS WRIGHT & COUCH, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Johnson & Johnson, Defendant, represented by Christy D. Jones , BUTLER SNOW, Daniel R. Higginbotham , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, David B. Thomas , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Nils Burton Snell , BUTLER SNOW, Philip J. Combs , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Susan M. Robinson , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Susanna Moore Moldoveanu , BUTLER SNOW, Kari L. Sutherland , BUTLER SNOW & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

Ethicon, Inc., Defendant, represented by Christy D. Jones , BUTLER SNOW, Daniel R. Higginbotham , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, David B. Thomas , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, James M. Campbell , CAMPBELL CAMPBELL EDWARDS & CONROY, Nils Burton Snell , BUTLER SNOW, Philip J. Combs , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Susan M. Robinson , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Susanna Moore Moldoveanu , BUTLER SNOW, Kari L. Sutherland , BUTLER SNOW & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

Ethicon, LLC, Defendant, represented by Daniel R. Higginbotham , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, David B. Thomas , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Philip J. Combs , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN & Susan M. Robinson , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN.


MEMORANDUM & OPINION ORDER

(Plaintiffs' Motion to Permit Live Trial Testimony via Contemporaneous Transmission)

Pending is the plaintiffs' Motion to Permit Live Trial Testimony via Contemporaneous Transmission [ECF No. 170] ("Pls.' Mot."). The defendants filed their Response [ECF...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases