PPL ENERGY PLUS, LLC v. HANNA

Civil Action No. 11-745 (PGS).

PPL ENERGY PLUS, LLC, et al., Plaintiffs, v. ROBERT M. HANNA, in his official capacity as President of the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, D. New Jersey.

December 30, 2014.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

PJM INTERCONNECTION, L.L.C., Objector, represented by ARLEIGH P. HELFER , Schnader Harrison Segal & Lewis LLP.

PPL ENERGYPLUS, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC & DAVID JOHN FIOCCOLA , MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP.

PPL BRUNNER ISLAND, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC & DAVID JOHN FIOCCOLA , MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP.

PPL HOLTWOOD, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC & DAVID JOHN FIOCCOLA , MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP.

PPL MARTINS CREEK, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC & DAVID JOHN FIOCCOLA , MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP.

PPL MONTOUR, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC & DAVID JOHN FIOCCOLA , MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP.

PPL SUSQUEHANNA, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC & DAVID JOHN FIOCCOLA , MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP.

LOWER MOUNT BETHEL ENERGY, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC & DAVID JOHN FIOCCOLA , MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP.

PPL NEW JERSEY SOLAR, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC & DAVID JOHN FIOCCOLA , MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP.

PPL NEW JERSEY BIOGAS, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC & DAVID JOHN FIOCCOLA , MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP.

PPL RENEWABLE ENERGY, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC & DAVID JOHN FIOCCOLA , MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP.

CALPINE ENERGY SERVICES L.P., Plaintiff, represented by JUSTIN TAYLOR QUINN , GIBBONS PC, LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC, ROBERT C. BRADY , GIBBONS, PC & WILLIAM P. DENI, JR. , GIBBONS, PC.

CALPINE MID-ATLANTIC GENERATION, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by JUSTIN TAYLOR QUINN , GIBBONS PC, LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC, ROBERT C. BRADY , GIBBONS, PC & WILLIAM P. DENI, JR. , GIBBONS, PC.

CALPINE NEW JERSEY GENERATION, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by JUSTIN TAYLOR QUINN , GIBBONS PC, LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC, ROBERT C. BRADY , GIBBONS, PC & WILLIAM P. DENI, JR. , GIBBONS, PC.

CALPINE BETHLEHEM, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by JUSTIN TAYLOR QUINN , GIBBONS PC, LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC, ROBERT C. BRADY , GIBBONS, PC & WILLIAM P. DENI, JR. , GIBBONS, PC.

CALPINE MID-MERIT, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by JUSTIN TAYLOR QUINN , GIBBONS PC, LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC, ROBERT C. BRADY , GIBBONS, PC & WILLIAM P. DENI, JR. , GIBBONS, PC.

CALPINE VINELAND SOLAR, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by JUSTIN TAYLOR QUINN , GIBBONS PC, LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC, ROBERT C. BRADY , GIBBONS, PC & WILLIAM P. DENI, JR. , GIBBONS, PC.

CALPINE MID-ATLANTIC MARKETING, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by JUSTIN TAYLOR QUINN , GIBBONS PC, LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC, ROBERT C. BRADY , GIBBONS, PC & WILLIAM P. DENI, JR. , GIBBONS, PC.

CALPINE NEWARK, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by JUSTIN TAYLOR QUINN , GIBBONS PC, LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC, ROBERT C. BRADY , GIBBONS, PC & WILLIAM P. DENI, JR. , GIBBONS, PC.

EXELON GENERATION COMPANY, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by JUSTIN TAYLOR QUINN , GIBBONS PC, LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC, ROBERT C. BRADY , GIBBONS, PC & WILLIAM P. DENI, JR. , GIBBONS, PC.

GENON ENERGY, INC., Plaintiff, represented by JUSTIN TAYLOR QUINN , GIBBONS PC & LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC.

NAEA OCEAN PEAKING POWER, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by JUSTIN TAYLOR QUINN , GIBBONS PC, LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC, ROBERT C. BRADY , GIBBONS, PC & WILLIAM P. DENI, JR. , GIBBONS, PC.

PSEG POWER, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC, ROBERT C. BRADY , GIBBONS, PC, WILLIAM P. DENI, JR. , GIBBONS, PC & WILLIAM J. O'SHAUGHNESSY , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

ATLANTIC CITY ELECTRIC COMPANY, Plaintiff, represented by LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC, PHILIP JOSEPH PASSANANTE , PEPCO HOLDINGS, INC, ROBERT C. BRADY , GIBBONS, PC & WILLIAM P. DENI, JR. , GIBBONS, PC.

PUBLIC SERVICE ELECTRIC AND GAS COMPANY, Plaintiff, represented by LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG , GIBBONS, PC, ROBERT C. BRADY , GIBBONS, PC, WILLIAM P. DENI, JR. , GIBBONS, PC & WILLIAM J. O'SHAUGHNESSY , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

LEE A. SOLOMON, in his official capacity as President of the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities, Defendant, represented by ALEX MOREAU , OFFICE OF THE NJ ATTORNEY GENERAL, BRIAN O. LIPMAN , OFFICE OF THE NJ ATTORNEY GENERAL, JENNIFER S. HSIA , NEW JERSEY OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, RICHARD FRANCIS ENGEL , DEPARTMENT OF LAW & PUBLIC SAFETY DIVISION OF LAW & LISA J. MORELLI , STATE OF NEW JERSEY.

JEANNE M. FOX, in her official capacity as Commissioner of the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities, Defendant, represented by ALEX MOREAU , OFFICE OF THE NJ ATTORNEY GENERAL, JENNIFER S. HSIA , NEW JERSEY OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, RICHARD FRANCIS ENGEL , DEPARTMENT OF LAW & PUBLIC SAFETY DIVISION OF LAW, BRIAN O. LIPMAN , OFFICE OF THE NJ ATTORNEY GENERAL & LISA J. MORELLI , STATE OF NEW JERSEY.

JOSEPH L. FIORDALISO, in his official capacity as Commissioner of the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities, Defendant, represented by ALEX MOREAU , OFFICE OF THE NJ ATTORNEY GENERAL, BRIAN O. LIPMAN , OFFICE OF THE NJ ATTORNEY GENERAL, JENNIFER S. HSIA , NEW JERSEY OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, RICHARD FRANCIS ENGEL , DEPARTMENT OF LAW & PUBLIC SAFETY DIVISION OF LAW & LISA J. MORELLI , STATE OF NEW JERSEY.

NICHOLAS V. ASSELTA, in his official capacity as Commissioner of the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities, Defendant, represented by ALEX MOREAU , OFFICE OF THE NJ ATTORNEY GENERAL, BRIAN O. LIPMAN , OFFICE OF THE NJ ATTORNEY GENERAL, JENNIFER S. HSIA , NEW JERSEY OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, RICHARD FRANCIS ENGEL , DEPARTMENT OF LAW & PUBLIC SAFETY DIVISION OF LAW & LISA J. MORELLI , STATE OF NEW JERSEY.

HESS NEWARK, LLC, Defendant, represented by BRIAN J. MOLLOY , WILENTZ GOLDMAN & SPITZER, PA.

PJM INDUSTRIAL CUSTOMER COALITION, Intervenor Defendant, represented by STEPHEN R. KERN , MCNEES WALLACE & NURICK LLC.

CPV POWER DEVELOPMENT, INC., Intervenor Defendant, represented by SEAN J. KIRBY , SHEPPARD MULLIN RICHTER & HAMPTON LLP.

NEW JERSEY, DIVISION OF RATE COUNSEL, Intervenor Defendant, represented by BRIAN WEEKS , NEW JERSEY DIVISION OF RATE COUNSEL.

NRG ENERGY, INC., Intervenor, represented by DAVID R. KING , HERRICK, FEINSTEIN LLP.

NEW JERSEY POWER DEVELOPMENT LLC, Intervenor, represented by DAVID R. KING , HERRICK, FEINSTEIN LLP.

GEMMA POWER SYSTEMS, LLC, Intervenor, represented by RICHARD P. MAGGI , McDERMOTT & McGEE, ESQS..

Marketing Analytics, Interested Party, represented by DWAYNE FRANKLIN STANLEY , HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP.


CLERK'S OPINION GRANTING IN PART AND DENYING IN PART PLAINTIFFS' MOTION TO TAX COSTS

This matter has come before the Clerk on the motion [Dkt. Entry 324] of Plaintiffs The PPL Parties1, The Calpine Companies2, Exelon Generation Company, LLC, Essential Power, LLC, Atlantic City Electric Company, PSEG Power, LLC, and Public Service Electric and Gas Company (collectively, "Plaintiffs") to tax costs against Defendants...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases