TAPPER v. HEARN

Marlene TAPPER; Yvette Velazquez Bennett; Vivianna Vazquez-Hernandez; Robert Perez; Fran Reiter; Sheila Andersen-Ricci; Martina Franca Associates LLC; Reiter Begun Associates, LLC; Denis Gittens; Oscar Perez; The Kings County Committee of The New York State Conservative Party; The New York State Conservative Party; and Martin Dilan, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. ROSE Gill HEARN, in her official capacity as a New York City Campaign Finance Board Chair; Art Chang, Richard J. Davis, Courtney C. Hall, and Mark S. Piazza, in their official capacities as New York City Campaign Finance Board members; Mark Davies, in his official capacity as New York City Conflicts of Interest Board Executive Director; Richard Briffault, in his official capacity as New York City Conflicts of Interest Board Chair; Fernando Bohorquez, Jr., Anthony Crowell, Andrew Irving, and Erika Thomas-Yuille, in their official capacities as New York City Conflicts of Interest Board members; and Michael McSweeny, in his official capacity as New York City Clerk, Defendants-Appellees.