COMMONWEALTH BY SHAPIRO v. UPMC

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Claude Joseph Hafner II, Esq. , Ronald N. Jumper Jr., Esq. , Pennsylvania State Senate, Lee Ann Hagenbarth-Murray, Esq. , Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, Tara Lynn Hazelwood, Esq. , Pennsylvania House of Representatives, Matthew S. Salkowski, Esq. , for House and Senate Democratic Caucuses, Amicus Curiae.

Joseph Stephen Betsko, Esq. , John Bartley Delone, Esq. , James A. Donahue III, Esq. , Michael Timothy Foerster, Esq. , Neil Mara, Esq. , Keli Marie Neary, Esq. , Mark A. Pacella, Esq. , Joshua D. Shapiro, Esq. , Jennifer Ann Thomson, Esq. , Heather Jeanne Vance-Rittman, Esq. , Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General, Jonathan Scott Goldman, Esq. , Tracy Wright Wertz, Esq. , for Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Shapiro, Appellants.

Anderson Thornton Bailey, Esq. , Kimberly A. Brown, Esq. , Leon F. DeJulius Jr., Esq. , S. Rebekah Byers Kcehowski, Esq. , Paul Michael Pohl, Esq. , Jones Day, Jared Dimock Bayer, Esq. , Stephen A. Cozen, Esq. , Andrew David Linz, Esq. , Stephen Aaron Miller, Esq. , Thomas Michael O'Rourke, Esq. , Cozen O'Connor, W. Thomas McGough Jr., Esq. , UPMC, for UPMC, Appellee.

Daniel I. Booker, Esq. , Conor Michael Shaffer, Esq. , Kim M. Watterson, Esq. , Jeffrey Michael Weimer, Esq. , Reed Smith LLP, Douglas E. Cameron, Esq. , Thomas L. Van Kirk, Esq. , Highmark Health, for Highmark, Inc., Highmark Health, UPE, Appellees.

Amy Joseph Coles, Esq. , Kevin Michael Eddy, Esq. , Blank Rome LLP, for Department of Insurance, Department of Health, Appellees.

Amy Griffith Daubert, Esq. , Pennsylvania Department of Insurance, for Department of Insurance, Appellee.

Mary Abbegael Giunta, Esq. , Office of General Counsel, for Department of Insurance, Department of Health, Levine, Rachel, Appellees.

Kenneth Lawson Joel, Esq. , for Department of Insurance, Department of Health, Altman, Jessica K., Levine, Rachel, Appellees.

SAYLOR, C.J., BAER, TODD, DONOHUE, DOUGHERTY, WECHT, MUNDY, JJ.