MANDIGO v. STOLMAN

Nos. 2-18-0466 & 2-18-0525.

137 N.E.3d 859 (2019)

2019 IL App (2d) 180466

Denise MANDIGO; John E. Mandigo; Bluff Lake Venture LLC; Spring Lake Marina, Limited; Jack Noonan, Trustee; Karen Noonan Trlpj Real Estate, LLC; Lake Homes LLC; Chicago Title Land Trust Company; Edward E. Jandrey, Trustee; Mary L. Jandry, Trustee; Mark Friel; Debbie Friel; Rick Garnett; Beth Garnett; Tauke Properties Inc.; Tauke Ventures LLC; Samuel Cheberenchick; Suzanne Cheberenchick; Richard Wohn; Debra A. Campbell; George Forero; Nancy Valangeon; Mark Giaimo; Antoinette Giaimo; James Stewart; Donna Stewart; Kathleen S. Stewart; George L. Stewart Jr., Trustee; Joseph B. Weber; Lea P. Weber; Gregory S. Simonini; Tracy H. Simonini; David W. Merrill; Angela Rae Merrill; Angeline M. Walther, Trustee; Amber M. Gore; Roger J. Gore; Kristine Gore; Mark B. Gilday; George T. Schur; Crystal A. Schur; Lori Heywood; Vincent J. Heywood; Timothy D. Gwinn; Robin W. Gwinn; Robert Hietikko; Cheryl L. Hietikko; Kenneth D. Hensel; Barbara A. Hensel; Robert Kraus; Barbara Kraus; Jerry E. Drue; Richard Vanderwerker; Patricia Vanderwerker; John L. Schultz; Diane Schultz; Corrine C. Parker; Kenneth S. Parker; Sandra L. Giorgi; Randolph B. Giorgi; Arun Sharma; Atula Sharma; Dennis Loe; Therese Loe; Linda L. Kader, Trustee; Lewis McGuire; Georgian N. McGuire; Maria Smoody; Linda Larson; Lee Kratochvil; Joseph Holoubek; Cecelia Holoubek; Heather Holoubek; Russel A. Page; Diane L. Page; Diane M. O'Leary; Scott Hansen; Lori Hansen; Craig Hejny; Denise Hejny; Paul Hejny; Kimberly Gail Bye, Trustee; Michael Wyatt; Robert A. Norten; John W. Kaufman; Nancy C. Butler; Pamela A. Worklann; Edward Ambacher; Marytherese Ambacher; William A. Anderson; Rich Andrews; Carol Andrews; Thomas Andrews; Rosemary Andrews; Jeff Baryl; Gino Battistoni; Karen Battistoni; Rudolph S. Benacka; Nancy L. Benacka; Gary W. Benning; Dennis J. Bergl; Craig Bieganowski; William H. Blowers; Toma Lee Blowers; Martin Bodnar; Alonzo Boulanger; Debra Boulanger; Frederick Brendel; Sharon Brendel; Richard A. Brenner; Jenny A. Brenner; Joel Burns; R. Brenner; C. Buscemi; Lawrence H. Burke; Sandra L. Burke; Tammy Burow; Andrew G. Butterbrodt; Christopher M. Calabria; Mary Anne Calabria; Charles E. Canning; Roberto G. Cecchini; Thomas Chamberlain; Michael Chimela; Gina Chimela; Nick J. Chiusolo; Christopher E. Clausen; Susan M. Clausen; Dennis Coomes; Robert Cote; J. Cromwell; A. Geibel; Thomas K. Davis; Deborah L. Davis; Edward J. Dembski; Robert Domas; Roberta Domas; Bruce W. Donnelly, Trustee; Jennifer B. Donnelly, Trustee; Valentin Dorosan; Mirela Dorosan; Brian D. Eames; Norman Ericksen; Linda Ericksen; Suzanne K. Ericksen; Benjamin Falcone, Trustee; Phyllis A. Fay; Frank J. Flavin; Paulett S. Flavin; Terry G. Forsythe; Sherry L. Forsythe; Theodore T. Frydrychowic; Patricia A. Frydrychowic; Milliard P. Frazier; Elizabeth K. Frazier; Clayton Frita; James R. Gawall, Trustee; Brett G. Gladish; Debra A. Gladish; Donald Gunther; Mary Ann Gunther; Gust. A. Mustafson; Susan M. Gustafson; Geoffrey Guttschow; Anne Guttschow; Timothy Haislet; Lisa Loweth; Michael J. Harmon; Karen L. Tewell-Harmon; Barbara G. Hayskar; Michael Holmes; Sung Hong; Soon Hong; David C. Jefferies; Ronald G. Jenczewski; Delores Jendrycki; Francis J. Jirmacek; Helen Jirmacek; William Johnson; Linda Johnson; Robyn Eicher Karnes; Jeff Karnes; Mr. C. Kelley; Mrs. C. Kelley; Susan A. Kelley; Timothy S. Knutson; Thomas J. Kolk; Susan M. Kolk; David W. Kosner; Lavonne L. Kosner; William R. Koziel; Dorothy Krause; Cathy Van Alstin; Szymon Kurzynowski; Mary L. Lamping; John A. Larsen; Crystal L. Larsen; James E. Lass; James M. Laurino; Linda Laurino; Diane Lawrence; Katherine A. Loomis, Trustee; Travis A. Lutze; John S. Macko; Nicholas Mapson; Jacqueline M. Mapson; Stanley A. March; Elizabeth M. March; Mario Maselli; Marisa Maselli; Stanley E. Mastalerz; Gerard A. McHugh; Susan F. McHugh; Joseph P. McKeown; Donna L. McKeown; John Miroballi; Barbara Miroballi; Joseph Mitchell; Louise Mitchell; James Morrison; Tammy Morrison; Christina Murar; Donald A. Muscolino; Phyllis A. Muscolino; Francis W. Nash; Catherine C. Nash; Andrew D. Obecny; Susan M. Obecny; Christopher Pacelli; Patricia Pacelli; Michael Pawluk; Karen Pawluck; Donna Peluso; Ryan W. Pendergast; Margaret E. Pendergast; Joseph S. Pino; Lynn R. Pino; Thomas J. Prost; Diane L. Prost; Frank Quirk; Raymond Ratajczak; Michael Ray; Penny Jean Peterson; Lawrence C. Replogle, Trustee; Nancy K. Replogle, Trustee; Theresa L. Resetar; Kathy L. Rieb; Nick Rossodivito; Florence Rossodivito; Russell Building Corporation; Karen Lynn Sachs; Charles J. Sachs III; William Schroeder; David R. Shaffer; Gina K. Meyer Shaffer; Stephen G. Shaw; Jill Ball Shaw; Ryan G. Shea; Randolph E. Simale; Janelle Simale; Robert Simone; Debra Simone; Mary Ann Sjoerdsma; Gary P. Slazes, Trustee; J. Thomas Spooner; Sheryl Spooner; Robert Spran; Betty Sprovieri; Lisa M. Swiderek; Szachnitowski Joint Trust; Mary Ann Thompson; Dennis Thompson; Curtis W. Tortorella; Jill G. Tortorella; Stephen Ursino; R. Walker; R. Mehnert; Charles J. Wilberg; Karen D. Wilberg; Todd D. William Jr.; Sally B. Todd; Andrew F. Williams; Lori J. Williams; Larry D. Williams; Ann M. Williams; Bernard Winkler; Maria Winkler; Jerry Winslow; Diane Donaldson; Thomas F. Zawada; Joseph Zeien, Trustee; Patricia J. Zein, Trustee; Rolf D. Ziemann; Eileen T. Ziemann; Dorothy L. Zika; Robert Zuiker; Patricia Zuiker; Eddie Okrzesik; Ramona Okrzesik; Tom Kanas; Tom A. Kanas; William A. White; Richard J. Dowd; Stephen M. Vrabik; Joann Vrabik; Wojciech Maciolek; Crighton Rentals; Bluff Lake Lodges Inc.; and Diane Stalmark, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. David STOLMAN, in His Official Capacity as Lake County Treasurer and ex officio Lake County Collector, Defendant-Appellee (Antioch Township and Antioch Road District, Intervenors-Appellees).

Appellate Court of Illinois, Second District.

Opinion filed April 18, 2019.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Timothy P. Dwyer , of Chicago, for appellants.

Michael G. Nerheim , State's Attorney, of Waukegan ( Joy C. Fitzgerald , and John P. Christensen , Assistant State's Attorneys, of counsel), for appellee David Stolman.

Keri-Lyn J. Krafthefer , and Kurt S. Asprooth , of Ancel Glink, P.C., of Chicago, for intervenors-appellees.


OPINION

¶ 1 The plaintiffs, Denise Mandigo and other tax objectors, own real property in Lake County and are obligated to pay Lake County real estate taxes. On November 8, 2016, the plaintiffs filed a tax-objection complaint seeking a refund from Lake County (County...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases