CITY AND COUNTY OF HONOLULU v. SUNOCO LP

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Theodore J. Boutrous, Jr. ,* Joshua D. Dick ,* Melvyn M. Miyagi , Ross T. Shinyama , Summer H. Kaiawe , Honolulu, Andrea E. Neuman ,* and Erica W. Harris ,* for appellants Chevron Corporation and Chevron U.S.A., Inc.

C. Michael Heihre , Michi Momose , J. Scott Janoe ,* Honolulu, Megan Berge ,* and Sterling Marchand ,* for appellants Sunoco LP, Aloha Petroleum, Ltd., and Aloha Petroleum LLC.

Paul Alston , John-Anderson L. Meyer , Claire Wong Black , Glenn T. Melchinger , Honolulu, Theodore V. Wells, Jr. ,* Daniel J. Toal ,* and Yahonnes Cleary ,* for appellants Exxon Mobil Corporation and ExxonMobil Oil Corporation.

Joachim P. Cox , Randall C. Whattoff , David C. Frederick ,* James M. Webster III ,* and Daniel S. Severson ,* for appellants Shell plc (f/k/a Royal Dutch Shell plc), Shell U.S.A. Inc. (f/k/a Shell Oil Company), and Shell Oil Products Company LLC.

Margery S. Bronster , Lanson K. Kupau , Honolulu, Kelly A. Higa Brown , Victor L. Hou ,* and Boaz S. Morag ,* for appellants Woodside Energy Hawaii Inc. (f/k/a BHP Hawaii Inc.) and appellee BHP Group Limited.

Lisa A. Bail , David J. Hoftiezer , Honolulu, Jonathan W. Hughes ,* Matthew T. Heartney ,* and John D. Lombardo ,* for appellants BP plc and BP America Inc.

Ted N. Pettit , Honolulu, Shannon S. Broome ,* Shawn Patrick Regan ,* and Anne Marie Mortimer ,* For appellants Marathon Petroleum Corporation.

Crystal K. Rose , Adrian L. Lavarias , Honolulu, Sharon Paris , Jameson R. Jones ,* Daniel R. Brody ,* Steven M. Bauer ,* Margaret A. Tough ,* and Katherine A. Rouse ,* for appellants ConocoPhillips, ConocoPhillips Company.

Crystal K. Rose , Adrian L. Lavarias , Honolulu, Sharon Paris , Steven M. Bauer ,* Margaret A. Tough ,* and Katherine A. Rouse ,* for appellants Phillips 66 and Phillips 66 Company.

Victor M. Sher ,* Dana M.O. Viola , Robert M. Kohn , Nicolette Winter , Jeff A. Lau , Matthew K. Edling ,* Corrie J. Yackulic ,* and Stephanie D. Biehl ,* for appellees City and County of Honolulu and Honolulu Board of Water Supply.

Anne E. Lopez , Ewan C. Rayner , for amicus curiae, Department of Attorney General.

Tara A. Buckley , for amicus curiae, Hawai`i State Association of Counties.

Chase H. Livingston , for amicus curiae, Legal Scholars.

Mark M. Murakami , Honolulu, for amicus curiae, Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America.

RECKTENWALD, C.J., McKENNA, AND EDDINS, JJ., CIRCUIT JUDGE JOHNSON AND CIRCUIT JUDGE TONAKI, ASSIGNED BY REASON OF VACANCIES, AND EDDINS, J., CONCURRING.