`O HALEAKALĀ v. UNIVERSITY OF HAWAI`I

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

David Kimo Frankel , Honolulu, Sharla Ann Manley ( Camille K. Kalama , Honolulu with them on the briefs) (Native Hawaiian Legal Corporation), for Plaintiff/Appellant-Appellant Kilakila `O Haleakalā.

Lisa Woods Munger , Lisa A. Bail , Adam K. Robinson , Christine A. Terada (Goodsill Anderson Quinn & Stifel), Honolulu, and Darolyn H. Lendio , University General Counsel, and Bruce Y. Matsui (Office of the General Counsel) with them on the brief, for Defendant/Appellee-Appellee University of Hawai`i, and Thomas M. Apple, in his official capacity as Chancellor of the University of Hawai`i at Manoa.

Julie H. China , Deputy Attorney General, ( Donna H. Kalama , Deputy Attorney General, with her on the brief), for Defendant/Appellee-Appellee Board of Land and Natural Resources, William Aila, in his capacity as the Interim Chairperson of the Board of Land and Natural Resources; and Department of Land and Natural Resources.

FOLEY, Presiding J., REIFURTH, J., and Circuit Judge NAKASONE, in place of NAKAMURA, C.J., FUJISE, LEONARD, and GINOZA, JJ., all recused.