ALOHACARE v. ITO

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Edward C. Kemper , for petitioner/appellant-appellant.

James F. Nagle , Deputy Attorney General, for respondent/appellee-appellee.

John F. Molay , Deputy Attorney General, for respondent/intervenor-appellee-appellee Department of Human Services.

Dianne W. Brookins , (Alston Hunt Floyd & Ing.) for respondent/intervenor-appellee-appellee United Healthcare Insurance Co.

Lorraine H. Akiba , ( McCorriston Miller Mukai MacKinnon ,) for respondent/intervenor-appellee-appellee Wellcare Health Insurance of Arizona, Inc., dba Ohana Health Plan.

RECKTENWALD, C.J., DUFFY, J., Circuit Judge NISHIMURA, assigned in place of NAKAYAMA, J., Recused, and Circuit Judge LEE, assigned by reason of vacancy, with ACOBA, J., concurring and dissenting separately.