RIVERA CARRASQUILLO v. BHATIA-GAUTIER

Civil Nos. 13-1296, 13-1384, 13-1812, 13-1860 & 13-1896 (FAB). Civil Nos. 13-1560, 13-1862, 13-1820, 13-1895, & 15-2738 (FAB).

590 F.Supp.3d 444 (2022)

Elizaida RIVERA CARRASQUILLO, et al., Plaintiffs, v. Eduardo BHATIA-GAUTIER, et al., Defendants. Janice Torres-Torres, et al., Plaintiffs, v. Jaime Perelló-Borrás, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, D. Puerto Rico.

Signed March 9, 2022.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Claudio Aliff-Ortiz , Eliezer Aldarondo-Ortiz , Ivan M. Castro-Ortiz , Sheila J. Torres-Delgado , Amled Y. Perez-Ayala , Eliezer Alberto Aldarondo-Lopez , Aldarondo & Lopez Bras, PSC, Guaynabo, PR, David R. Rodriguez-Burns , Trujillo Alto, PR, for Plaintiffs Elizaida Rivera-Carrasquillo in CV 13-1296, Sonja Marcano-Rios in CV 13-1296, Jonel Gonzalez-Compre in CV 13-1296, Gil Ortiz-Perez in CV 13-1296, Manuel Velez-Santiago in CV 13-1296, Kathia Soto-Cepeda in CV 13-1296, Hector Medina-Gonzalez in CV 13-1296, Jose D. Garcia-Quinones in CV 13-1296, Lucila Rivera-Santana in CV 13-1296, Rolando Arroyo-Melendez in CV 13-1296, Josefina Cardona-De-Jesus in CV 13-1296, Glaris Kuilan-Marrero in CV 13-1296, Jenny Velez-Cintron in CV 13-1296, Glenda Ortega-Montanez in CV 13-1296.

Claudio Aliff-Ortiz , Eliezer Aldarondo-Ortiz , Ivan M. Castro-Ortiz , Sheila J. Torres-Delgado , Amled Y. Perez-Ayala , Aldarondo & Lopez Bras, PSC, Guaynabo, PR, David R. Rodriguez-Burns , Trujillo Alto, PR, for Plaintiffs John Rangel — Falu in CV 13-1296, Jorge Melendez — Rivera in CV 13-1296.

Amled Y. Perez-Ayala , Sheila J. Torres-Delgado , Ivan M. Castro-Ortiz , Aldarondo & Lopez Bras, PSC, Guaynabo, PR, David R. Rodriguez-Burns , Trujillo Alto, PR, for Plaintiff Noemi Muniz-Feliciano in CV 13-1296.

Amled Y. Perez-Ayala , Sheila J. Torres-Delgado , Eliezer Alberto Aldarondo-Lopez , Claudio Aliff-Ortiz , Ivan M. Castro-Ortiz , Eliezer Aldarondo-Ortiz , Aldarondo & Lopez Bras, PSC, Guaynabo, PR, David R. Rodriguez-Burns , Trujillo Alto, PR, for Plaintiffs in 13-1560.

Gittel Almonte-Duluc , Rafael B. Fernandez Castaner , Department of Justice, Federal Litigation Division, San Juan, PR, for Defendant Jaime Perrello-Borras in 13-1560.

David R. Rodriguez-Burns , Trujillo Alto, PR, Eliezer Aldarondo-Ortiz , Ivan M. Castro-Ortiz , Sheila J. Torres-Delgado , Eliezer Alberto Aldarondo-Lopez , Aldarondo & Lopez Bras, PSC, Guaynabo, PR, for Plaintiffs Lixmarie Gonzalez-Hernandez in CV 13-1296, Marillie Gonzalez-Hernandez in CV 13-1296.

David R. Rodriguez-Burns , Trujillo Alto, PR, Eliezer Aldarondo-Ortiz , Ivan M. Castro-Ortiz , Sheila J. Torres-Delgado , Aldarondo & Lopez Bras, PSC, Guaynabo, PR, for Plaintiffs Maria Camacho-Velez in CV 13-1296, Dirce Figueroa-Robles in CV 13-1296, Mr. Edwin Luciano-Echeandia in CV 13-1296, Francisco Pabon-Febus in CV 13-1296, Jose Perez-Otero in CV 13-1296, Rosa Robles-Lopez in CV 13-1296, William Rodriguez-Colon in CV 13-1296, Jorge Rodriguez-Morales in CV 13-1296, Cielo Angela Roman-Ayala in CV 13-1296, William Rosales-Concepcion in CV 13-1296, Mariangela Rosario-Ortiz in CV 13-1296, Edward Santana-Leon in CV 13-1296, Idelia Torres-Cadiz in CV 13-1296, Jose Torres-Torres in CV 13-1296.

David R. Rodriguez-Burns , Trujillo Alto, PR, Sheila J. Torres-Delgado , Ivan M. Castro-Ortiz , Aldarondo & Lopez Bras, PSC, Guaynabo, PR, for Plaintiffs Frances Abella-Padilla in CV 13-1296, Alexander Alvarez-Rivera in CV 13-1296, Ania Barreto-Reymundi in CV 13-1296, Blanca Cintron-Baez in CV 13-1296, Sydney Delgado-Garcia in CV 13-1296, Juan L. Fuentes-Marquez in CV 13-1296, Keysla Gonzalez-Dominguez in CV 13-1296, Julio M. Gonzalez-Garcia in CV 13-1296, Carmen Gonzalez-Rodriguez in CV 13-1296, Iris Hernandez-Ortiz in CV 13-1296, David Hernandez-Rodriguez in CV 13-1296, Margie Huertas-Gomez in CV 13-1296, Miguel D. Irizarry-Torres in CV 13-1296, Jose Maldonado-Torres in CV 13-1296, Mayna Y. Melendez-Berrios in CV 13-1296, Ivette Melendez-Quinones in CV 13-1296, Obdulio Morales-Colon in CV 13-1296, Nilsa Morales-Morales in CV 13-1296, Angel A. Morales-Vadi in CV 13-1296, Maria De Los A. Nater-Arvelo in CV 13-1296, Hector Perez-Alicea in CV 13-1296, Margarita Reyes-Ferrer in CV 13-1296, Nancy L. Rivas-Simmons in CV 13-1296, Nydia Rodriguez-Figueroa in CV 13-1296, Noel Rodriguez-Hernandez in CV 13-1296, Victor Roman-Rivera in CV 13-1296, Miguel Sanchez-Flores in CV 13-1296, Olga L. Verdejo-Boria in CV 13-1296, Jose I. Jimenez in CV 13-1296, Carlos A. Torres-Pagan in CV 13-1296, Jose A. Rivera-Negron in CV 13-1296, Luis F. Ortiz-Parrilla in CV 13-1296, Edgardo Castellano-Rodriguez in CV 13-1296, Wilfredo Colon-Marti in CV 13-1296, Eric S. Rondon-Rodriguez in CV 13-1296, Jose G. Torres-Raices in CV 13-1296, Efrain Carrasquillo-Rios in CV 13-1296, Carmen Hernandez-Soto in CV 13-1296, Brenda Y. Otero-Molina in CV 13-1296, Jessica Santiago-Bermudez in CV 13-1296, Luis Benitez-De Los Santos in CV 13-1296, Jacqueline Pagan-Nieves in CV 13-1296, Carlos Pacheco-Irizarry in CV 13-1296, Yanairalee Navarro-Vazquez in CV 13-1296, Aureliz Cabrera in CV 13-1296, Obrien Reyes-Lopez in CV 13-1296, Emerilia Santiago-Chico in CV 13-1296, Victor L. Castro-Figueroa in CV 13-1296, Sheyla Gonzalez-Irizarry in CV 13-1296, Juan J. Matias-Matias in CV 13-1296, Antonio J. Taboada-Collazo in CV 13-1296, Maritza Ramos-Sepulveda in CV 13-1296, Yara M. Torres-Marin in CV 13-1296, Griselle Encarnacion-Garcia in CV 13-1296, Edward Burgos-Torres in CV 13-1296, Emilio O. Martinez-Alamo in CV 13-1296, Luis G. Saunders-Torres in CV 13-1296, Edwin J. Reyes-Marrero in CV 13-1296, Irma Rodriguez-Diaz in CV 13-1296, Victor Rodriguez-Torres in CV 13-1296, Carlos F. Miro-Fuertes in CV 13-1296, Maria Mejias-De-La-Torre in CV 13-1296, Nancy Monserrate-Encarnacion in CV 13-1296.

Rafael B. Fernandez Castaner , Department of Justice, Federal Litigation Division, Jose L. Nieto-Mingo , San Juan, PR, for Defendant Eduardo Bhatia-Gautier in CV 13-1296.

Idza Diaz-Rivera , Rafael B. Fernandez Castaner , P. R. Department of Justice, Federal Litigation Division, Jose L. Nieto-Mingo , San Juan, PR, for Defendants Denisse M. Rivera-Gonzalez in CV 13-1296, Tania Barbarrosa-Ortiz in CV 13-1296, Luis A. Ramos-Rivera in CV 13-1296.

Idza Diaz-Rivera , Rafael B. Fernandez Castaner , P. R. Department of Justice, Federal Litigation Division, San Juan, PR, for Defendants Jose Hernandez-Arbelo in CV 13-1296, Juan Vazquez-Lopez in CV 13-1296, Maritza Alejandro-Chevres in CV 13-1296.

John Doe, Pro Se in CV 13-1296.


OPINION AND ORDER

Before the Court is Oscar Serrano-Negrón ("Serrano")'s motion to unseal confidential settlement agreements and records regarding indemnification costs associated with Act No. 9 of November 27, 1966 ("Law 9"). (Docket No. 454.) For the reasons set forth below, Serrano's motion to unseal is...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases