AVILES v. S&P GLOBAL, INC.

17-CV-2987 (JPO) (KHP) 17-CV-6087 (JPO) (KHP) 17-CV-7034 (JPO) (KHP) 18-CV-128 (JPO) (KHP) 18-CV-2416 (JPO) (KHP).

583 F.Supp.3d 507 (2022)

Luis Ramiro AVILES, et al., Plaintiffs, v. S&P GLOBAL, INC., et al., Defendants. Fernando Raul Benedetto, et al., Plaintiffs, v. ATC Realty Fifteen, Inc., et al., Defendants. Horacio Nestor Acebedo, et al., Plaintiffs, v. ATC Realty Fifteen, Inc., et al., Defendants. Frederico Alvarez, et al., Plaintiffs, v. ATC Realty Fifteen, Inc., et al., Defendants. Hector Jorge Areco, et al., Plaintiffs, v. ATC Realty Fifteen, Inc., et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, S.D. New York.

Signed February 2, 2022.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Charles S. Siegel , Paul Lawrence, Wm., II , Waters & Kraus, LLP, Dallas, TX, Diane M. Paolicelli , Levy, Phillips & Konigsberg, LLP, Victoria Elizabeth Phillips , District Attorney, New York County, Yitzchak M. Fogel , Phillips & Paolicelli, LLP, New York, NY, for Plaintiffs Fernando Raul Benedetto in 17-CV-6087, Blambus Group Inc. in 17-CV-6087, Martin Arturo Carmona in 17-CV-6087, Graciela Cassutti in 17-CV-6087, Eduardo Maximo Del Torto in 17-CV-6087, Ricardo Juan Garbarino in 17-CV-6087, Jorge Luis Germino in 17-CV-6087, Ana Ester Giordani in 17-CV-6087, Iject, Inc. in 17-CV-6087, Manual Atilio Iturralde in 17-CV-6087, Maria Rita Lopez Provera in 17-CV-6087, Maria Beatriz Lopez Provera in 17-CV-6087, Beatriz Julia Megy in 17-CV-6087, Francisco Miguel in 17-CV-6087, Anna Maria Jorgelina Noguerol in 17-CV-6087, Daniel Alberto Passaro in 17-CV-6087, Antonio Emilio Pergomet in 17-CV-6087, Plaza Asset Management Co., LTD in 17-CV-6087, Jose Rispau Vinas in 17-CV-6087, Maria Pia Saure in 17-CV-6087, Diana Ana Maria Severin in 17-CV-6087, Nelida I. Vazquez in 17-CV-6087, Maria Cristina Villanueva in 17-CV-6087.

Colleen Elizabeth Noonan , Jayant W. Tambe , Kelly A. Carrero , Jones Day, New York, NY, for Defendant ATC Realty Fifteen, Inc. in 17-CV-6087, 17-CV-7034, 18-CV-128 and 18-CV-2416.

John Gerard McCarthy, Sr. , Smith, Gambrell & Russell, LLP, New York, NY, for Defendants Portsmouth Settlement Company I, LLC, Roy G. Smith, John Marcum in 17-CV-6087, 17-CV-7034, 18-CV-128 and 18-CV-2416.

Diane M. Paolicelli , Levy, Phillips & Konigsberg, LLP, Victoria Elizabeth Phillips , District Attorney, Yitzchak M. Fogel , Phillips & Paolicelli, LLP, New York, NY, for Plaintiffs Horacio Nestor Acebedo in 17-CV-7034, Jorge Aidar Bestene in 17-CV-7034, Rafael Argul in 17-CV-7034, Silvano Luis Arnaldi in 17-CV-7034, Adrien Vicente Aspromonte in 17-CV-7034, Vincenzo Aspromonte in 17-CV-7034, Veronica Micaela Barbera in 17-CV-7034, Vera Domtea Baylon in 17-CV-7034, Magdalena Maria Becu in 17-CV-7034, Humberto Nebar Bellocchio in 17-CV-7034, Federico Bersaiz in 17-CV-7034, Maria Ines Ernestina Bossisio Verdaguer in 17-CV-7034, Delmo Francisco Cadario in 17-CV-7034, Pedro Charquia Aguirre, Emiliano Chaud in 17-CV-7034, Congrats Networking Corp. in 17-CV-7034, Patricia Noemi Delistovich in 17-CV-7034, Patricio Devoto in 17-CV-7034, Victor Angel Di Buccio in 17-CV-7034, Vicente Di Loreto in 17-CV-7034, Aldo Pedro Duscher in 17-CV-7034, Estela Susana Elena in 17-CV-7034, Norberto Fermani in 17-CV-7034, Romina Fermani in 17-CV-7034, Sergio Daniel Fermani in 17-CV-7034, Ernesto Fernandez LLorente in 17-CV-7034, Raul Daniel Fernandez in 17-CV-7034, Gustavo Armando Figuerola in 17-CV-7034, Felipe Fiorellino in 17-CV-7034, Maria Cristina Frova in 17-CV-7034, Carlos Daniel Gandulfo in 17-CV-7034, Julio Garcia Garcia in 17-CV-7034, Jose Luis Ghiggia in 17-CV-7034, Eduardo Jorge Gnecco in 17-CV-7034, Enrique Jose Goldaracena in 17-CV-7034, Maria Irma Gonzalez in 17-CV-7034, Concepcion Marta Grillo in 17-CV-7034, Teresa Moschini in 17-CV-7034, Jose Mesropian in 17-CV-7034, Maria Rosa LaPlacette in 17-CV-7034, Clide Esther Martinez in 17-CV-7034, Florencia Maria Murray in 17-CV-7034, Lentaun S.A. in 17-CV-7034, Beatriz Gladys Gualdoni in 17-CV-7034, Jorge Perez Jureidini in 17-CV-7034, Leonardo Juan Ionfrida in 17-CV-7034, Luis Sebastian Mogno in 17-CV-7034, Celia Maria Perez in 17-CV-7034, Jose Maria Pena Fernandez in 17-CV-7034, Matias Sebastian Mena in 17-CV-7034, Lucas Matias Licht in 17-CV-7034, Guilermo Omar Iribarren in 17-CV-7034, Renato Salvador Materia in 17-CV-7034, Emilio Enrique Martinez Granados in 17-CV-7034, Matias Juan Mendy in 17-CV-7034, Juan Pablo Perez Candreva in 17-CV-7034, Gabriel Marino in 17-CV-7034, Pablo Maccarone in 17-CV-7034, Roberto Omar Ricci in 17-CV-7034, Roberto Raul Sanjuro in 17-CV-7034, Carlos Adrian Rodriguez in 17-CV-7034, Anibel Ratibel in 17-CV-7034, Warne Financial Corp. in 17-CV-7034, Jorge Luis Speroni in 17-CV-7034, Eduardo Sogno in 17-CV-7034, Fernando Nicolas Serra Rojas in 17-CV-7034, Mario Alejandro Speroni in 17-CV-7034, Roberto Raul Zapata in 17-CV-7034, Zulema Noemi Ramona Romano in 17-CV-7034, Juan Manuel Vaguer in 17-CV-7034, Alex Adolfo Sraier in 17-CV-7034, Oscar Alberto Varde in 17-CV-7034, Ricardo Hector Valls in 17-CV-7034, Laura Cecilia Wrobel in 17-CV-7034, Norberto Oscar Tonanti in 17-CV-7034, Marcelo Redlich in 17-CV-7034, Eduardo Rodriguez in 17-CV-7034, Alfredo Federico Rossi in 17-CV-7034, Raquel Silvia Zaifrani in 17-CV-7034.

Diane M. Paolicelli , Yitzchak M. Fogel , Phillips & Paolicelli, LLP, Victoria Elizabeth Phillips , District Attorney, New York, NY, for Plaintiff Emiliano Rodriguez in 17-CV-7034.

Diane M. Paolicelli , Yitzchak M. Fogel , Phillips & Paolicelli, LLP, Victoria Elizabeth Phillips , District Attorney, New York, NY, for Plaintiffs Frederico Alvarez in 18-CV-128, Sabino Javier Alvarez in 18-CV-128, Sabino Alvarez Salgueiro in 18-CV-128, Fabian Eduardo Angelilli in 18-CV-128, Dario Osmar Ascune in 18-CV-128, Nancy Carlota Bain in 18-CV-128, Maria Balsano in 18-CV-128, Hugo Baquerin in 18-CV-128, Osvaldo J. Barrionuevo in 18-CV-128, Basic Fly Ltd. in 18-CV-128, Hugo Basilotta in 18-CV-128, Carlos Jose Benassi in 18-CV-128, Eva M.V. Berkes de Kolb in 18-CV-128, Aldo Bertolozzi in 18-CV-128, Erika Bienek in 18-CV-128, Gustavo Cachiarelli in 18-CV-128, Marta Susana Cadario in 18-CV-128, Bryant Line Corp. in 18-CV-128, Maximiliano Calp in 18-CV-128, Patricia Boorman De Solari Loudet in 18-CV-128, Alejandra Maria Bossetti in 18-CV-128, Carlos Jorge Campioni in 18-CV-128, Adriana Cappone in 18-CV-128, Norma Beatriz Cianciarulo in 18-CV-128, Kim Dai San in 18-CV-128, Miguel Angel Cirio in 18-CV-128, CBM Agente de Valores S.A. in 18-CV-128, Juan Jose Comerio in 18-CV-128, Diego Esteban Chami in 18-CV-128, Alfredo M. De Baisio in 18-CV-128, Marcelo Mario De Angelis in 18-CV-128, Maximiliano Costa in 18-CV-128, Enrique Pedro Coscia in 18-CV-128, Beatriz Edith De La Torre in 18-CV-128, Silvia Del Rosal in 18-CV-128, Daniel Enrique De Cabo in 18-CV-128, Mario Rafael De Dona in 18-CV-128, Francisco Alberto Di Maio in 18-CV-128, Lucas Gustavo De Feo in 18-CV-128, Carlos Armando Donino in 18-CV-128, Enrique Alberto Fuertes in 18-CV-128, Jorge Esteves in 18-CV-128, Flint Consultant Ltd. in 18-CV-128, Juan Jose Etala in 18-CV-128, Dora N. Escribano in 18-CV-128, E-Sense Ltd. in 18-CV-128, Martin Furlong in 18-CV-128, Miriam Beatriz Fratini in 18-CV-128, Jurge Luis Fernandez in 18-CV-128, Alfonso Eduardo Espino Paz in 18-CV-128, Foxtom Assets Inc. in 18-CV-128, Flowyard Overseas Ltd. in 18-CV-128, Eva Friedman in 18-CV-128, Fernando Juan Fernandez in 18-CV-128, Raul Oscar Ferrari in 18-CV-128, Alejo Gonzalez Garano in 18-CV-128, Pablo Fabian Gomez in 18-CV-128, Mirta Garcia De La Fuente in 18-CV-128, Fernando Lucas Luis Garcia Urrutia in 18-CV-128, Maria De La Caridad Gurnbaum in 18-CV-128, Arnaldo Manuel Gomez in 18-CV-128, Jorge Enrique Gilardi in 18-CV-128, Claudio Javier Glazman in 18-CV-128, David Fabian Huberman in 18-CV-128, Jelifl Corp. in 18-CV-128, Claudio Daniel Husain in 18-CV-128, Juan Carlos Guaita in 18-CV-128, Ricardo Jose Hermida in 18-CV-128, Maria Clotilde Josefi Lami Hernandez in 18-CV-128, Ruth Naomi Ladner in 18-CV-128, Rut Veronica Ladanyi in 18-CV-128, Maria Isabel Jankowski de Sym Smith in 18-CV-128, Alan Jose Horwitz in 18-CV-128, Ines Maria Iturraldo in 18-CV-128, Daniel Nicolas Juansaras in 18-CV-128, Miguel Angel Lopez in 18-CV-128, Joaquin Martinez Tenreiro in 18-CV-128, Jorge Lopez Nunez in 18-CV-128, Miguel Angel Lecuna, Gladys Leoni in 18-CV-128, Diego Milberg in 18-CV-128, Sandra Griselda Mendez in 18-CV-128, Carlos Alberto Mastronardi in 18-CV-128, Viviana Rut Minteguiaga in 18-CV-128, Daniel Esteban Martin in 18-CV-128, Miguel A. Morello in 18-CV-128, Martin Lizaso Bilbao in 18-CV-128, Daniel Rodolfo Lugo in 18-CV-128, Eduardo Pedro Martin in 18-CV-128, Margarita Munoz Vargas in 18-CV-128, Mystic Point Holding in 18-CV-128, Ana Orsola Moretti in 18-CV-128, Claudia Isabel Morrone in 18-CV-128, Juan Gregorio Navarro Flo is in 18-CV-128, Cristina Alicia Morrone in 18-CV-128, Marcelo Carlos Nacucchio in 18-CV-128, Luis Angel Parenti in 18-CV-128, Maria Celina Pilato in 18-CV-128, Maria Carmen Parise in 18-CV-128, Hugo Benjamin Nicolli in 18-CV-128, Enrique Juan Carlos Paborell in 18-CV-128, Ana Maria Pereira in 18-CV-128, Nestor Perez Ponsa in 18-CV-128, Rafael Perez De La Fuente in 18-CV-128, Antonia Peyrani in 18-CV-128, Antonio Ivan Podrzaj in 18-CV-128, Miguel Gregorio Podrzaj in 18-CV-128, Martin Rodrigo Pardo in 18-CV-128, Elena Pedotti in 18-CV-128, Jose Alberto Picado in 18-CV-128, Ana Maria Rogatti in 18-CV-128, Random Corp. in 18-CV-128, Roberto Mario Pugliese in 18-CV-128, Laura Beatriz Rosso Lastra in 18-CV-128, Alberto Ruben Santos in 18-CV-128, Jose Ramon Rey in 18-CV-128, Selltas Trader Inc. in 18-CV-128, Santos Oscar Sarnari in 18-CV-128, Jorge Raccoursier Heisinger in 18-CV-128, Micaela Puig in 18-CV-128, Roracio Rotta in 18-CV-128, Graciela Roldan Perez in 18-CV-128, Delia Haydee Schiappapietra in 18-CV-128, Ida Alicia Sasso de Fernandez in 18-CV-128, Virginia Maria Ravenna in 18-CV-128, Diego H. Pulgar in 18-CV-128, Ricardo Simon Rodriguez in 18-CV-128, Luis Tiphaine in 18-CV-128, Roxana Tagliaferro in 18-CV-128, Rodolfo Jorge Solis in 18-CV-128, Mario Oscar Varela Ortiz in 18-CV-128, Graciela Villanueva in 18-CV-128, Elida Alicia Taramasso in 18-CV-128, Tomas Ramon Zapata in 18-CV-128, Edith Karina Volkmann in 18-CV-128, Amanda Ana Zocchi in 18-CV-128, Haydee Noemi Tacta de Rodino in 18-CV-128, Edgardo Luis Spina in 18-CV-128, Adrian Gino Venturi Aravena in 18-CV-128, Ramon Tuma in 18-CV-128, Mario Alberto Yampolsky in 18-CV-128, Roberto Eduardo Wubbe in 18-CV-128, Walter A. Tagliavini in 18-CV-128, Marcela Nora Tacchella in 18-CV-128, Daniel Gustavo Tedesco in 18-CV-128, Hector Jorge Areco in 18-CV-2416, Veronica Balbiani in 18-CV-2416, Sonia Maricel Baravalle in 18-CV-2416, Claudio Bruno Bartoli in 18-CV-2416, Torcuato Luis Battaglia in 18-CV-2416, Gonzalo Blaquier in 18-CV-2416, Alejandro Molina Carranza in 18-CV-2416, Dante Leone in 18-CV-2416, Maria Fabiana Zanelli in 18-CV-2416, Southern Services Company Corp. in 18-CV-2416, Maria Candela D'Angelo in 18-CV-2416, Luis Maria Games in 18-CV-2416, York Venture Capital in 18-CV-2416, Monica Patricia Morena in 18-CV-2416, Maria DeMiguel in 18-CV-2416, Maria Laura Travella in 18-CV-2416, Norberto Rene Serenelli in 18-CV-2416, Maria Teresa Borrell Fortuny in 18-CV-2416, Osvaldo H. Scandola in 18-CV-2416, Nicolas Eduardo Bowen in 18-CV-2416, Jorge Carlos Macellaro in 18-CV-2416, Adriana Mabel Nieto in 18-CV-2416, Mirta Edit Longhini in 18-CV-2416, Alicia S. Negreira in 18-CV-2416, Diego Grimaldi in 18-CV-2416, Maria Cristina Fabricant in 18-CV-2416, Paz Veronica Charter Campagne in 18-CV-2416, Carlos Alfredo Grimaldi in 18-CV-2416, Jorge Norberto Garcia Cozzi in 18-CV-2416, Cecilia Inchausti in 18-CV-2416, San Goal in 18-CV-2416, Martina Galli in 18-CV-2416, Daniel Floreal Fognini in 18-CV-2416, Milda Beatriz Maseras in 18-CV-2416.


OPINION AND ORDER ON VARIOUS DISCOVERY MOTIONS

Presently before this Court are several discovery-related motions. As many of them are substantially related, the Court addresses them together below. Specifically: (i) Defendants Smith Estate and Wells Fargo,

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases