IN RE OHIO EXECUTION PROTOCOL LITIGATION

Case No. 2:11-cv-1016,

In re OHIO EXECUTION PROTOCOL LITIGATION, This Order relates to Plaintiff Romell Broom,

United States District Court, S.D. Ohio, Eastern Division.

January 24, 2020.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 42 U.S.C. § 1983
Cause: 42 U.S.C. § 1983 Civil Rights Act
Nature of Suit: 535 Death Penalty - Habeas Corpus
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Ohio State Board of Pharmacy, Interested Party, represented by Henry G. Appel , Ohio Attorney General.

Stanley Adams, Plaintiff, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office & Vicki Ruth Adams Werneke , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio.

Tyrone Ballew & William Sapp, Plaintiffs, represented by Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office & Andrew P. Avellano .

Richard Bays, Plaintiff, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, Erin Gallagher Barnhart , Federal Public Defender for the Southern District of Ohio, James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Melvin Bonnell, Plaintiff, represented by Kimberly S. Rigby , Ohio Public Defender, Alan C. Rossman , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio Capital Habeas Unit, Erika M. LaHote , Office of the Ohio Public Defender, Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office & Vicki Ruth Adams Werneke , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio.

Quisi Bryan & Kareem Jackson, Plaintiffs, represented by Vicki Ruth Adams Werneke , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio, Alan C. Rossman , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio Capital Habeas Unit & Lori Riga , Office of the Federal Public Defender.

Davel Chinn, Plaintiff, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, Erin Gallagher Barnhart , Federal Public Defender for the Southern District of Ohio, James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur, Rachel Troutman , Ohio Public Defender & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Douglas Coley, Plaintiff, represented by Sharon A. Hicks , Federal Public Defender Capital Habeas Unit & Vicki Ruth Adams Werneke , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio.

Roland Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, David C. Stebbins , Federal Public Defenders Office Capital Habeas Unit, Erin Gallagher Barnhart , Federal Public Defender for the Southern District of Ohio & James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur.

Archie Dixon, Edward Lang & Jeronique Cunningham, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael J. Benza & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

John Drummond, Plaintiff, represented by Vicki Ruth Adams Werneke , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio, Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur. & Lori Riga , Office of the Federal Public Defender.

Antonio Sanchez Franklin, Plaintiff, represented by S. Adele Shank & James P. Fleisher , Bieser, Greer & Landis.

James Frazier & Stanley Fitzpatrick, Plaintiffs, represented by Lisa M. Lagos , Federal Public Defender Office.

Clarence Fry, Plaintiff, represented by Kimberly S. Rigby , Ohio Public Defender, Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office & Richard Allen Cline , Ohio Public Defender.

Larry Gapen, Plaintiff, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, Adam Michael Rusnak , Federal Public Defender's Office Capital Habeas Unit, James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur. & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Delano Hale, Plaintiff, represented by Lisa M. Lagos , Federal Public Defender Office & Jordan S. Berman , Federal Public Defender.

James Hanna, Plaintiff, represented by David L. Doughten , Paul Rudolph Bottei , Federal Public Defender & Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender.

Warren K Henness, Plaintiff, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, David C. Stebbins , Federal Public Defenders Office Capital Habeas Unit, Justin C. Thompson , Federal Public Defender, Paul Rudolph Bottei , Federal Public Defender & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Danny Hill, Warren Waddy, Andre Williams & David Sneed, Plaintiffs, represented by Vicki Ruth Adams Werneke , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio, Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender & James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur. .

Timothy Hoffner, Plaintiff, represented by Stephen M. Kissinger , Federal Defender Services of Eastern Tennessee, Inc. & Stephen A. Ferrell , Federal Defender Services of Eastern Tennessee, Inc..

Percy Hutton, Plaintiff, represented by Vicki Ruth Adams Werneke , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio, Alan C. Rossman , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio Capital Habeas Unit, Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender & James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur. .

Andre Jackson, Juan Kinley, Lawrence Landrum, Cedric Carter, Gary Hughbanks, Donald Ketterer, David Allen, Gregory Osie & Denny Obermiller, Plaintiffs, represented by Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Cleveland Jackson, Plaintiff, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, Adam Michael Rusnak , Federal Public Defender's Office Capital Habeas Unit, Dale Andrew Baich , Office of the Federal Public Defender, Lisa M. Lagos , Federal Public Defender Office, Paul Rudolph Bottei , Federal Public Defender, Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office, Richard Allen Cline , Ohio Public Defender & Theodore C. Tanski , Federal Public Defender.

Keith LaMar, Plaintiff, represented by Stephen M. Kissinger , Federal Defender Services of Eastern Tennessee, Inc. & Dana C. Hansen Chavis , Federal Defender Services of Eastern Tennessee, Inc., pro hac vice.

Carl Lindsey, Charles L Lorraine, Walter Raglin, Bobby T. Sheppard, Kenneth W Smith & Jerome Henderson, Plaintiffs, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur. & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Jose Trinidad Loza, Plaintiff, represented by Laurence E. Komp .

Ralph Lynch & James Trimble, Plaintiffs, represented by Theodore C. Tanski , Federal Public Defender & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Freddie McNeill, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, Justin C. Thompson , Federal Public Defender & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Samuel Moreland & Timothy Dunlap, Plaintiffs, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur, Justin C. Thompson , Federal Public Defender & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Jason Robb & John David Stumpf, Plaintiffs, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, David C. Stebbins , Federal Public Defenders Office Capital Habeas Unit & James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur. .

Duane Short, Plaintiff, represented by Kimberly S. Rigby , Ohio Public Defender, Erika M. LaHote , Office of the Ohio Public Defender & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Warren Spivey, Robert Williams & James Mammone, Plaintiffs, represented by Vicki Ruth Adams Werneke , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio.

Raymond Twyford, Plaintiff, represented by Vicki Ruth Adams Werneke , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio, Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, Carol Ann Wright , Federal Public Defenders Office & James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur. .

James Were, Plaintiff, represented by Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office & Dennis Lyle Sipe .

Abdul Awkal, Plaintiff, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur, Kevin Cafferkey , pro hac vice, R. Brian Moriarty , R. Brian Moriarty, LLC, pro hac vice & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

David Braden, Plaintiff, represented by Theodore C. Tanski , Federal Public Defender & Steven Martin Brown .

Sean Carter, Plaintiff, represented by Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office, Kandra Roberts , Office of the Ohio Public Defender & Rachel Troutman , Ohio Public Defender.

August Cassano, Plaintiff, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, David C. Stebbins , Federal Public Defenders Office Capital Habeas Unit & Erin Gallagher Barnhart , Federal Public Defender for the Southern District of Ohio.

Kerry Perez & Nathaniel Jackson, Plaintiffs, represented by Adrienne M. Larimer , Office of the Ohio Public Defender & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

George Skatzes & Jonathan Monroe, Plaintiffs, represented by Vicki Ruth Adams Werneke , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio, Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur. & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Michael Turner, Plaintiff, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, David C. Stebbins , Federal Public Defenders Office Capital Habeas Unit, James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur. & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Jeffrey Wogenstahl, Plaintiff, represented by Kimberly S. Rigby , Ohio Public Defender & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Kevin Scudder, Plaintiff, represented by S. Adele Shank & Gary Wayne Crim .

Romell Broom, Plaintiff, represented by Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office, Theodore C. Tanski , Federal Public Defender & Richard Allen Cline , Ohio Public Defender.

James T Conway, Plaintiff, represented by James P. Fleisher , Bieser, Greer & Landis & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Phillip Elmore, Plaintiff, represented by David C. Stebbins , Federal Public Defenders Office Capital Habeas Unit.

James O'Neal, Plaintiff, represented by Lawrence Joseph Greger , Greger Law Office & S. Adele Shank .

Ahmad Fawzi Issa, Plaintiff, represented by Richard Allen Cline , Ohio Public Defender & S. Adele Shank .

Michael Webb, Plaintiff, represented by Kimberly S. Rigby , Ohio Public Defender, Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur. & Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office.

Gerald Hand, Plaintiff, represented by Jennifer M. Kinsley , The Law Office of Jennifer Kinsley.

Gregory Lott, Plaintiff, represented by Stephen M. Kissinger , Federal Defender Services of Eastern Tennessee, Inc., W. Joseph Edwards & Stephen A. Ferrell , Federal Defender Services of Eastern Tennessee, Inc..

Gregory Esparza, Plaintiff, represented by Vicki Ruth Adams Werneke , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio, Alan C. Rossman , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio Capital Habeas Unit, Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur, Keith A. Yeazel & Lori Riga , Office of the Federal Public Defender.

Wayne Powell, Plaintiff, represented by Randall Lee Porter , Ohio Public Defender Office & Erika M. LaHote , Office of the Ohio Public Defender.

Lamont Hunter, Plaintiff, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, Erin Gallagher Barnhart , Federal Public Defender for the Southern District of Ohio & James A. King , Porter Wright Morris & Arthur. .

Hersie Wesson, Plaintiff, represented by Vicki Ruth Adams Werneke , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio, Alan C. Rossman , Federal Public Defender, Northern District of Ohio Capital Habeas Unit & Rachel Troutman , Ohio Public Defender.

Michael Dean Scott, Plaintiff, represented by David L. Doughten & Adrienne M. Larimer , Office of the Ohio Public Defender.

Anthony Belton, Plaintiff, represented by Jessica Leigh Houston , Office of the Ohio Public Defender.

Steven Cepec & Willie Wilks, Plaintiffs, represented by Kelle Anne Hinderer .

Dawud Spaulding, Plaintiff, represented by Erika M. LaHote , Office of the Ohio Public Defender & Rachel Troutman , Ohio Public Defender.

Clifford Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Richard Allen Cline , Ohio Public Defender.

James Tench, Plaintiff, represented by Erika M. LaHote , Office of the Ohio Public Defender & Kimberly S. Rigby , Ohio Public Defender.

Caron Montgomery & Ashford Thompson, Intervenor Plaintiffs, represented by Kimberly S. Rigby , Ohio Public Defender.

Anthony Sowell, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Gamso , GAMSO, HELMICK & HOOLAHAN & Erika B. Cunliffe .

Von Clark Davis, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by Allen L. Bohnert , Office of the Federal Public Defender, Erin Gallagher Barnhart , Federal Public Defender for the Southern District of Ohio & Jordan S. Berman , Federal Public Defender.

Calvin McKelton, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by Stephen A. Ferrell , Federal Defender Services of Eastern Tennessee, Inc. & Michael J. Benza .

Willie Wilks, Intervenor Plaintiff, pro se.

Willie Wilks, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by Kelle Anne Hinderer & Erika M. LaHote , Office of the Ohio Public Defender.

Governor Mike DeWine, Governor, State of Ohio, Defendant, represented by Charles L. Wille , Office of the Ohio Attorney General Capital Crimes Unit, Anne Berry Strait , Court of Claims Defense, Brian M. Kneafsey, Jr. , Ohio Attorney General's office, Charles Allen Schneider , Ohio Attorney General's Office, Christopher D. Schroeder , Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office, Katherine E. Mullin , Ohio Attorney General's Office, Margaret S. Moore , Office of Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost, Mark David Landes , Isaac Wiles Burkholder & Teetor, LLC & Thomas E. Madden , Office of the Ohio Attorney General Criminal Justice Section, Capital Crimes Unit.

Donald Morgan, Defendant, represented by Erika B. Cunliffe , Charles L. Wille , Office of the Ohio Attorney General Capital Crimes Unit, Anne Berry Strait , Court of Claims Defense, Christopher L. Bagi , OH Attorney General, David M. Henry , State of Ohio Office of the Attorney General, Katherine E. Mullin , Ohio Attorney General's Office, Mark David Landes , Isaac Wiles Burkholder & Teetor, LLC & Margaret S. Moore , Office of Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost.

Donald Morgan, Defendant, pro se.

Anonymous Execution Team Members #1-50, c/o Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, Charles Bradley, Warden, Franklin Medical Center, Stephen Gray, Chief Counsel, ODRC, Christopher LaRose, Warden, Ohio State Penitentiary, Richard Theodore, Pharmacist, c/o ODRC, Edwin Voorhies, Managing Director of Operations, ODRC, John Coleman, Warden, Toledo Correctional Institution, Ronald Erdos, Warden, Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, Timothy Shoop, Warden, Chillicothe Correctional Center & Annette Chambers-Smith, Director, Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Corrections, Defendants, represented by Erika B. Cunliffe , Charles L. Wille , Office of the Ohio Attorney General Capital Crimes Unit, Anne Berry Strait , Court of Claims Defense, Christopher L. Bagi , OH Attorney General, David M. Henry , State of Ohio Office of the Attorney General, Katherine E. Mullin , Ohio Attorney General's Office, Mark David Landes , Isaac Wiles Burkholder & Teetor, LLC & Jocelyn K. Lowe , Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction.

Anonymous Execution Team Members #1-50, c/o Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, Defendant, pro se.

Charles Bradley, Warden, Franklin Medical Center, Defendant, pro se.

Stephen Gray, Chief Counsel, ODRC, Defendant, pro se.

Christopher LaRose, Warden, Ohio State Penitentiary, Defendant, pro se.

Richard Theodore, Pharmacist, c/o ODRC, Defendant, pro se.

Edwin Voorhies, Managing Director of Operations, ODRC, Defendant, pro se.

John Coleman, Warden, Toledo Correctional Institution, Defendant, pro se.

Ronald Erdos, Warden, Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, Defendant, pro se.

Unnamed and Anonymous Execution Team Members, Defendant, represented by Erika B. Cunliffe , Mark David Landes , Isaac Wiles Burkholder & Teetor, LLC & Jocelyn K. Lowe , Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction.

Timothy Shoop, Warden, Chillicothe Correctional Center, Defendant, pro se.

Annette Chambers-Smith, Director, Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Corrections, Defendant, pro se.

Executive Director Steven Schierholt, Steven Schierholt, Executive Director, the Ohio State Board of Pharmacy, Movant, represented by Charissa Diane Payer , Ohio Attorney General Worker's Compensation Unit & Jeffrey Jarosch , Office of Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine.

The Cincinnati Enquirer, Movant, represented by John Charles Greiner , Graydon Head & Ritchey LLP.

The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, Movant, represented by Stephanie Swiger , Office of the Ohio Attorney General.


DECISION AND ORDER EXCEPTING PLAINTIFF BROOM FROM THE SCHEDULE FOR FILING AN AMENDED INDIVIDUAL SUPPLEMENTAL COMPLAINT

This consolidated capital § 1983 case is before the Court on Plaintiff Romell Broom's Motion for an Exception to the requirement imposed in the Decision and Order of Nov. 20, 2019...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases