U.S. v. BOARD OF HAMILTON COUNTY COMMISSIONERS

Case No. 1:02-cv-107.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, et al., Plaintiffs, v. BOARD OF HAMILTON COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, S.D. Ohio, Western Division.

September 4, 2018.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 33 U.S.C. § 1319
Cause: 33 U.S.C. § 1319 Clean Water Act
Nature of Suit: 893 Environmental Matters
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Amanda Toole, OMBUDSMAN, Interested Party, pro se.

USA, Plaintiff, represented by Donetta Donaldson Wiethe , Atrium II U.S. Department of Justice, Leslie Allen , Environmental Enforcement Section Environment and Natural Resources Div, United States Department of Justice, Matthew Joseph Horwitz , United States Attorney's Office for the Southern Distri & Thomas L. Sansonetti , Assistant Attorney General Environment and Natural Resources Div, United States Department of Justice.

State Of Ohio, Plaintiff, represented by Lawrence Scott Helkowski , Ohio Attorney General's Office, Gary Prichard , Associate Regional Counsel & Lee Allan Slone , Ohio Attorney General's Office.

The Sierra Club & Marilyn Wall, Plaintiffs, represented by Albert J. Slap , Amy Jo Leonard , D David Altman Co LPA, Dennis David Altman , AltmanNewman Co LPA, Lance D. Himes , D David Altman Co LPA & Justin Derek Newman .

Ohio River Valley Water Sanitation Commission, Plaintiff, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

Terry Rath, Petitioner, pro se.

Board Of County Commissioners, Hamilton County, Ohio, Defendant, represented by Mark Alan Norman , Vorys Sater Seymour and Pease LLP, Mark Alan VanderLaan , Dinsmore & Shohl, Nee Fong Chin , Hamilton County Prosecutor's Office Environmental Division, Andrew B. Barras , Dinsmore & Shohl LLP, Anthony L. Osterlund , Great American Tower Vorys Sater Seymour & Pease, Charles Wood Anness , Hamilton County Prosecutor's Office, James Warren Harper , Hamilton County Prosecuting Attorney, Michael J. Friedmann , Hamilton County Prosecuting Attorney's Office & Roger Edward Friedmann , Hamilton County Civil Division.

City Of Cincinnati, Defendant, represented by Aaron Mark Herzig , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP, Andrew L. Kolesar , Thompson Hine LLP, Donnell Joseph Bell , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, Fay Dupuis , Cincinnati City Solicitor, Christopher David Wiest , Diana R. Christy , City of Cincinnati, Lauren DeGoricia , City of Cincinnati, Louis L. McMahon , McMahon DeGulisn LLP, Nicole Lashon Sanders , City of Cincinnati & Terrance A. Nestor , City of Cincinnati.

Metropolitan Sewer District of Greater Cincinnati, Defendant, represented by Nee Fong Chin , Hamilton County Prosecutor's Office Environmental Division, Sanna-Rae Taylor , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP, Suzanne M. Fisher-Edwards , Frost Brown Todd, LLC, Charles Wood Anness , Hamilton County Prosecutor's Office, Michael J. Friedmann , Hamilton County Prosecuting Attorney's Office & Lauren DeGoricia , City of Cincinnati.

City of Loveland Ohio, Defendant, represented by Alan G. Starkoff , Ice Miller LLP, Franklin August Klaine, Jr. , Strauss Troy, Joseph J. Braun , The Federal Reserve Building, Kevin L. Murch , Perez & Morris, LLC & Richard Guy Taft , The Federal Reserve Building.

Elaine Howard, Claimant, pro se.

Katherine Schnur, Claimant, pro se.

Jo Ann Fridy, Claimant, pro se.

Yarnell McKenzie, Claimant, pro se.

Charles Huebsch, Claimant, represented by Christine Carey Steele , Faulkner & Tepe, LLP.

Roger P. Mersch, Claimant, pro se.

Martha Thomas, Claimant, pro se.

Marlia Southers, Claimant, pro se.

Wardell Hill, Claimant, pro se.

Kenneth J. Gilkey, Claimant, pro se.

Robert J. Miles, Claimant, pro se.

Shirley Miles, Claimant, pro se.

Margaret Augustine & Todd Augustine, Claimants, represented by John L. O'Shea , Cohen Todd Kite & Stanford, LLC.

Gated Properties III LLC, Claimant, represented by Bradley D. McPeek , Lindhorst & Dreidame.

Bryan Stockelman, Claimant, pro se.

Woodside CR LLC & CHS-Ohio Valley, Inc., Claimants, represented by John L. O'Shea , Cohen Todd Kite & Stanford, LLC & Richard Campbell , Cohen Todd Kite & Stanford LLC.

House Calls LLC and Darrell & Stephanie Harden, Claimant, represented by Richard Campbell , Cohen Todd Kite & Stanford LLC.

Barbie Jones, Claimant, represented by Christopher J. Dutton , Porter Wright Morris and Arthur.

Al Gammarino, Movant, pro se.

Kelvin Jenkins, Movant, represented by Arthur Walter Harmon, Jr. , Arthur W Harmon Jr LLC.

Wardell W. Hill, III, Movant, pro se.

Betty J Brown, Movant, pro se.

Betty J Brown, Movant, represented by Caleb Brown, Jr.

Ada Washington, Movant, pro se.

Stephanie Mueller, Movant, pro se.

Charles Thompson, Movant, pro se.

Victoria Putman, Movant, pro se.

Walter Meinert, Movant, pro se.

Eric Radtke, Movant, pro se.

Bruce N Patanelli, Movant, pro se.

Cheryl H Patanelli, Movant, pro se.

Kevin Rainey, Movant, pro se.

Barbara Rainey, Movant, pro se.

Daniel W Nebert, Movant, pro se.

Terence Cook, Movant, pro se.

Carla Bradshaw, Movant, pro se.

Darlene Lynn Hughes, Movant, pro se.

James P. Ryan, Movant, pro se.

Tom W. Knosp, Movant, pro se.

Danyel Wells, Movant, pro se.

Jackie Hopper, Movant, pro se.

Richard Cotton, Movant, pro se.

Dorothy Dupee, Movant, pro se.

Robert M Spratt, Movant, pro se.

Kathryn M. Roeding, Movant, pro se.

Carolyn Cann, Movant, pro se.

Woody Gudat, Movant, pro se.

Thomas Lloyd, Movant, pro se.

Robert L. Wells, Sr., Movant, pro se.

Wilber Lee Sanford, Movant, pro se.

Dennis Oder, Movant, pro se.

Margaret Oder, Movant, pro se.

Zina Harris, Movant, pro se.

Vernon Wiethe, Movant, pro se.

Marilyn Eisbrouch, Movant, pro se.

Louis M. Kohus, Movant, represented by Carl Joseph Stich, Jr. , White, Getgey & Meyer Co., LPA, David Paul Kamp , WHITE GETGEY & MEYER CO LPA & Jean Geoppinger McCoy , White, Getgey & Meyer Co., L.P.A.

Robert Meyer, Movant, pro se.

Ada Barnes, Movant, pro se.

Steve Verkley, Movant, pro se.

Harry Pearce, III, Movant, pro se.

Michael Isaacs, Movant, pro se.

Cheryl Isaacs, Movant, pro se.

Robert Buckner, Movant, pro se.

Daniel D Smith, Movant, pro se.

Mary Helen Smith, Movant, pro se.

Simon Ben-Hur, Movant, pro se.

William Dattilo, Movant, represented by Robert Brand Newman , Newman & Meeks Co LPA.

Lawrence J. Kreimer, Jr., Movant, pro se.

Ruth L. Kreimer, Movant, pro se.

Thomas R. Stahlheber, Movant, represented by Daniel Gerard Spraul , Spraul & Doan, LLC.

Ethelene Blue, Movant, pro se.

James A. Hudson, Movant, pro se.

Joseph Campbell, Movant, pro se.

Wonderlyn Jean House, Movant, pro se.

Allen Sheff, Movant, represented by Herbert Jaime Haas , The Citadel, LLC.

Aurelio DiCristofaro, Movant, represented by Robert Gregory Kelly .

Paul Zlatic, Movant, pro se.

Amy Lanzit, Movant, pro se.

William Lanzit, Movant, pro se.

Adrick Ceasar, Movant, pro se.

Kelly Ceasar, Movant, pro se.

Shelley A Dreyer, Movant, pro se.

Bradford Ogle, Movant, pro se.

Eileen Ogle, Movant, pro se.

Kenneth McNeal, Movant, pro se.

Pamela M Newport, Movant, pro se.

Carmel Presbyterian Church, Movant, represented by Justin Derek Newman .

Willa Russell, Movant, pro se.

James Clark, Movant, pro se.

Sharell Clark, Movant, pro se.

Douglas Barnett, Movant, pro se.

Michael - Olson, Movant, pro se.

Betti J Hinton, Movant, pro se.

Johnda Keuffer, Movant, pro se.

Angela Schell, Movant, pro se.

Herbie Schell, Movant, pro se.

Sherrice Harrison, Movant, pro se.

Thomas E. Kennedy, Movant, pro se.

Carol E Evans, Movant, pro se.

Heidi B. Jark, Movant, pro se.

Steven Kenat, Movant, pro se.

Gretchen Aichele, Movant, pro se.

David Guerdan, Movant, pro se.

Donte Brooks, Movant, pro se.

Regina Brooks, Movant, pro se.

Louise Chambers, Movant, pro se.

Mary Dale, Movant, pro se.

Neil Hill, Movant, pro se.

Vivian Hill, Movant, pro se.

Patricia Ann Lindsay Anderson, Movant, pro se.

Yithzak Bashari, Movant, pro se.

James Busick, Movant, pro se.

James Calloway, Movant, pro se.

Shirley Saunders, Movant, pro se.

Tim Finke, Movant, pro se.

Timothy D Langmeyer, Movant, pro se.

Charles A Rall, Movant, pro se.

Felicia Rall, Movant, pro se.

Susan J. Cook, Movant, pro se.

Phillip G. Cargile, Movant, pro se.

Michael Mattox, Movant, pro se.

Doug Huff, Movant, pro se.

Scott Schlotterbeck, Movant, pro se.

Sylvia Nelson, Movant, pro se.

Robin Lynn Mitchell, Movant, pro se.

Shielah Smith, Movant, pro se.

Erin Hanley, Movant, pro se.

DG and PG Rental Properties, Daniel R. Gertz, doing business as & Bid and Win It, LLC, Movants, represented by Daniel Joseph Wenstrup , Heis & Wenstrup Co LPA.

Timothy Farrell, Movant, pro se.

Clare Sillett, Movant, pro se.

Bryan Stockelman, Movant, pro se.

Kimberly Turnbow, Movant, pro se.

Diane Henson, Movant, pro se.

Robert C Zacharias, Movant, pro se.

Ella Thomas, Movant, pro se.

Joseph Flack, Movant, pro se.

Laura L. McCreadie, Movant, pro se.

Ronnie Cobb, Movant, pro se.

Djuna Whitehead, Movant, pro se.

Frank Whitehead, Movant, pro se.

Jethro N. Copeland, Movant, pro se.

Karen Marie Wagner, Movant, pro se.

Carol Stone, Movant, pro se.

Meredith Lee Moser, Movant, represented by Patrick M. O'Neill , Benjamin, Yocum & Heather, LLC & Richard David Weber , Cors & Bassett, LLC.

Charles Shor, Movant, represented by Matthew C. Curran , Lindhorst & Dreidame.

Roy C. Jones, Movant, pro se.

VanClint Carlton, LLC, Movant, pro se.

Kimya Moyo, Movant, pro se.

Philip Miazga, Movant, pro se.

Doris Brown, Movant, pro se.

Mark A. Bryan, as Trustee & Trevor C. Bryan, as Trustee, Movants, represented by Steven C. Davis , Barron Peck Bennie & Schlemmer.

Michelle Lynett Bruce, Movant, pro se.

Garry Lester, Sr., Movant, pro se.

Carol Roehling, doing business as, Movant, pro se.

John Neal, Michael Neal, Rodney Neal, Patricia Neal-Miller & Angela Washington, Movants, represented by Donyetta Dionne Bailey , Bailey Law Office, LLC.

Russell Smith, Movant, pro se.

Delta Association, doing business as, Movant, pro se.

Lisa Jones, doing business as, Movant, pro se.

Jonathan Smith, Movant, pro se.

Shelia Moore, Movant, pro se.

Tellers of Hyde Park, Ltd., Movant, represented by James Francis McCarthy, III , Katz Teller Brant & Hild.

Ayham Odeh, Movant, represented by Justin William Bartlett , Bartlett & Weigle.

Clyde Pitts, H., Movant, pro se.

Greenlee Garage, INC, Movant, represented by Stephen G. Lawson , Stephen Lawson, Attorney at Law.

Rita Clark, Movant, pro se.

Letitia A James, Movant, pro se.

Casey Hamlyn, Movant, pro se.

Darrell Hardin & Stephanie Hardin, Movants, represented by Richard Campbell , Cohen Todd Kite & Stanford LLC.

Mary Campany, Movant, pro se.

Glenn Riefle, Movant, pro se.

Callie Grant, Movant, pro se.

Yvonne E. Collins, Movant, represented by Justin Derek Newman & Robin Burgess , AltmanNewman Co LPA.

Charles J Koller, Movant, pro se.

Irma TR Koller, Movant, pro se.

Mark Simcoe, Movant, pro se.

Shawntee Brown, Movant, pro se.

Anthony McBride, Movant, pro se.

Brionna McBride, Movant, pro se.

Eric Lett, Movant, represented by Thomas Daniel Molony .

Thomas Vaccariello, Movant, pro se.

Nicole Mancini, Movant, pro se.

Joseph McCauley, Movant, represented by Christopher P. Finney , Finney Law Firm, LLC.

Charles Hughes, Movant, pro se.

Kimberly Witte, Movant, pro se.

Stephanie Jones-Taylor, Movant, pro se.

Margarita Kolaj, Movant, pro se.

Dorothy Moore, Movant, pro se.

Dwendolyn I. Chester, Movant, pro se.

John Marshall Smith, Movant, pro se.

Travis Likes, Movant, pro se.

Gilbert Nolan, Movant, pro se.

Yolanda J. Landrum, Movant, pro se.

Robert Mosley, Movant, pro se.

Frank M Cogliano, Movant, pro se.

Globetrotters VFW Post 6428, Movant, pro se.

City Of Cincinnati, Cross Claimant, represented by Andrew L. Kolesar , Thompson Hine LLP, Fay Dupuis , Cincinnati City Solicitor, Christopher David Wiest , Louis L. McMahon , McMahon DeGulisn LLP, Nicole Lashon Sanders , City of Cincinnati & Terrance A. Nestor , City of Cincinnati.

City of Loveland Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by Alan G. Starkoff , Ice Miller LLP, Franklin August Klaine, Jr. , Strauss Troy, Joseph J. Braun , The Federal Reserve Building, Kevin L. Murch , Perez & Morris, LLC & Richard Guy Taft , The Federal Reserve Building.


ORDER RE: REQUEST FOR REVIEW BY DOROTHY MOORE

This matter is before the Court on the Request for Review of the denial of a Sewer Backup ("SBU") claim by Dorothy Moore (Doc. 1334), the response of the Metropolitan Sewer District of Greater Cincinnati ("MSD") (Doc. 1401), and the parties' supplemental...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases