IN RE BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORP. PELVIC REPAIR SYSTEM PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION

MDL No. 2326.

IN RE: BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORP. PELVIC REPAIR SYSTEM PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION. THIS DOCUMENT RELATES TO Jennifer Munoz v. Boston Scientific Corporation Civil Action No. 2:14-cv-14017.

United States District Court, S.D. West Virginia, Charleston Division.

May 7, 2018.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 28 U.S.C. § 1331
Cause: 28 U.S.C. § 1331 Fed. Question: Personal Injury
Nature of Suit: 365 Personal Inj. Prod. Liability
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Jim B. Hockett & Gloria M. Hockett, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael Chadwick Smith , CHAD SMITH & ASSOCIATES.

Ava Kirkpatrick, Plaintiff, represented by C. Anthony Graffeo , WATSON GRAFFEO, pro hac vice & Jeffrey G. Blackwell , BLACKWELL LAW FIRM.

Michele Spence, Douglas Spence, Ines R. Alexander, Virgil Alexander, Natalie Schultz, Daniel Schultz, Lois Johnson, Fred A. Johnson, Jr., Sharon Carruesco, Gary Carruesco, Michelle Lawrie, Jason Lawrie, Kimberly Gabriel Hansen, Dwayne Hansen, Veronica Murillo & Roberto Murillo, Plaintiffs, represented by Casey A. Kaufman , THE BRANDI LAW FIRM & Thomas J. Brandi , THE BRANDI LAW FIRM.

Karen S. Weller, Anita M. Jolly, Chris Jolly, Minnie V. Mann, Amanda Powell, Daniel Powell, Terri S. Gregory, Ralph R. Gregory, Jr., Bette G. Waldroup, Lloyd Waldroup, Sharon Steward, Donna B. Colvin, Barbara Jeselink, Evelyn Mitchell, Rosie Tullos, John Tullos, Elsie E. Vercher, James Vercher, Annie L. Reardon, Mary C. Aldridge & Gary L. Aldridge, Plaintiffs, represented by Ronald L. Riggle , HOUCK & RIGGLE & Tracy W. Houck , HOUCK & RIGGLE.

LaRhonda Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Gary B. Homsey , HOMSEY COOPER HILL & CARSON & Joseph S. Carson , WARHAWK LEGAL.

Pamela Coleman, an individual, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Heather Kent , GIRARDI KEESE, Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE, Vincent James Carter , GIRARDI KEESE, pro hac vice & Michael M. Kowsari , GIRARDI KEESE.

Beverly Stone, Wesley Stone, Juanita Lopez, Alice Smith, Fred Smith, Rebecca Womack & James Womack, Plaintiffs, represented by Ashley M. Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, Bonnie E. Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, David Lee Augustus , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM & Dawn R. Meade , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM.

Ralph Springham, Plaintiff, represented by Michael Goetz , MORGAN & MORGAN.

Sherry Herkal, an individual, Adelina Tovar & Mary Ross, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Heather Kent , GIRARDI KEESE, Amy Fisch Solomon , GIRARDI KEESE & Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE.

Daleen Hendrickson & Gary Hendrickson, Plaintiffs, represented by Bret A. Clark , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Dusti Harvey , HARVEY LAW FIRM & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Beatrice J. Huddleston, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Joseph A. Osborne , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LE CLAINCHE, Michael S. Appel , SUGARMAN ROGERS BARSHAK & COHEN, Neil D. Overholtz , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Samuel M. Furgang , SUGARMAN ROGERS BARSHAK & COHEN.

Dina Chapman, James Chapman, Paul Foley, Mikkii Edmonds, Cody Lee Edmonds, Bonnie Greer, Marlene Williams, Tim Williams, James Comp, Patricia Comp, Pam Harroff, Aleisha Barnes, Gary Sparks, Linda Sparks, Tammie Graves & Elizabeth Lewis, Plaintiffs, represented by Andy Dow Birchfield, Jr. , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, P. Leigh O'Dell , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES & Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES.

Jamie Floyd, Wesley Floyd, Tyler Towry, Edward Benjamin, Brenda Nutt, Robert Nutt & Richard Dale, Plaintiffs, represented by Mark R. Mueller , MUELLER LAW, pro hac vice.

Sandra Williams, Eugene Williams, Trina Siders, Michael Deering, Teresa Young, Randall Young, Heather Smithson, Barry Neal Smithson, Carey Snow, Pamela Mosher, Fhaylen Terry, Anthony Ware, Joan Hooks, Michael Hooks, Ann Shannon, Jana Sheehan, Thomas McGrath, Glenda Wanamaker, John Wanamaker, Carol Underdal, Gregory Underdal, Mary Shepard, Veronica Sowder, Lorene Whitlow, Linda Yeckley, Mark Yeckley, Wilda Goforth, Alisa Kosina-Silva & Joyce Kasoff, Plaintiffs, represented by A. Donald C. Discepolo , DISCEPOLO.

Donna Amsden, Angela Bell, Steven Bell, Patricia Ramirez & Sonja Mitema, Plaintiffs, represented by David P. Matthews , MATTHEWS & ASSOCIATES, Julie L. Rhoades , MATTHEWS & ASSOCIATES, Kevin L. Edwards , EDWARDS & DE LA CERDA, Peter de la Cerda , EDWARDS & DE LA CERDA, Tamara L. Banno , FREESE & GOSS & Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS.

Jennifer Novotny & Jason Novotny, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert E. Price , LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL RAFFERTY & PROCTOR & Seth Alan Katz , BURG SIMPSON ELDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE.

JoAnne West, Edith Hoffer, Donald R. Hoffer, Francis Hinojosa, Sharon Lummus, Jann Lummus, Barbara J. King, James King, Christie Coleman, Marie Erickson, Raymond Erikson, Regina Walker, Donna Hopwood, Dennis Hopwood, Deborah Hurley, Barbara Michael, Monica Melendez, Melissa Scheer, Robert Scheer, Angela Oman, Donald Oman, Ida Murray, Ray Murray, Janice Salerno, Vincent Salerno, Sharon Polk, Antonio Polk, Beth Metzler & Steven Metzler, Plaintiffs, represented by Elise A. Waisbren , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice, Stephen D. Phillips , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice & Terrence M. Quinn , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice.

Donna Crossan, Charlene Duclos, Jean-Paul Duclos, wife and husband, Sharon Bonnier, Vernon Bonnier, Alice Duncan, Veronica Hernandez, Jorge Hernandez, Joanne Wilkey, Lawrence Wilkey, Yvonne Clark, Henry Clark, Jr., Debra Suwyn, Neal Suwyn, Alberta Wilson, Karen Judge, Charles Judge, Amanda Foster, Fred Foster, Shirley Whitson, Pauline Hurley, Andrew Boehm, Wendy Boehm, Dorothy Knapek, Mary Lou Nelson, Shawna Hall, Babette Choquette, Elizabeth Hutchinson, John F. Hutchinson, Jr., Elnora Henderson, Kathy Glover, Phyllis A. Ferrell-Skousen, Alma Skousen, Sheila A. Jenkins, Debra Thompson, Kim Thompson, Kathryn Hall, Tammy Tucker, Joe Tucker, Myrtle Allen, Leroy Wayne Allen, Lori Ann Gelgut, John Gelgut, Cheryl Patterson, Stephen Patterson, Robyn Williams, Patricia Rush, Randy Rush, Cynthia Thompson, Mary Ratliff, Brenda Reeves, Jason Reeves, Heshmat Nassirzadeh, Georgia Schilz, Rodney Schilz, Joyce Schachner, Christine Aylworth, Beverly Dunbar, Richard Dunbar, Gloria Casas, Edwardo Casas, Kimberly Barker, Tami Cornell, Olene Gibson, Julie Lee, Peter Lee, Linda McClure, Anna Manuel, Bruce Manuel, Sandra Sterne, Lori Yoder, Ramon Yoder, Marie Bumbalough, Larry Bumbalough, Sandra Murray, Gayla Quittner, Peter Quittner, Krista Miller, Mark Miller, Joy Burger, William Burger, Sheila Hopkins, James Hopkins, Sheila Harrouff, Bernard Harrouff, Kimberly Szydlo, Mark Szydlo, Barbara Peltier, Antoinette Apperson, Delmas Apperson, Martha Needham, John Needham, Linda Felix, Richard Felix, Nicole Hernandez, Lynette Roberts, Terrence Roberts, Sr., Nancy Ottersbach, Melanie Blunk, Cecilia Johnson, Marques Johnson, Margaret Johns, David Johns, Helen Ross, Joan Cook, Kirby Cook, Rachel Baker, Cheri Pickett, Michael Pickett, Denise Wilkerson, Barbara Evelyn Thomas, James Thomas, Rosie Voigts, Diane Douglas, Bobby Douglas, Tamara Kay Klingberg, Steven Klingberg, Marilyn Bradley, Cindy K. Brobst, Helen Desjardin & Paul Desjardin, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Thomas R. Kline , KLINE & SPECTER.

Zula Tipton, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan A. Pfleeger , MICHAEL HINGLE & ASSOCIATES & Waldon Michael Hingle , MICHAEL HINGLE & ASSOCIATES.

Diane Liddell, Roberta Brunetto & Sherry Thomas, Plaintiffs, represented by Theresa M. Walsh , BROWN CHIARI.

Karen K. Sarver, Doug Sarver, Belinda A. Carter, Jeffrey A. Carter, Wife and Husband, Carrie Browning, Stephen Browning, Charlene Dover, Eugene Dover, Karan Chancellor, Ronnie Chancellor, Verna Morgan, Harlin Morgan, Kathy A. Wells, Ronnie Wells, Dorothy Ann Heathscott, Roger Dale Heathscott, Barbara G. Vincent, Barry C. Vincent, Leslie J. Washburn, Brenda A. Smith, James G. Smith, Sylvia Joyce Guthrie, Cheryl A. Hickey, Kent Hickey, Donna J. Hyatt, Martha E. Johnson, Serena A. Floro, Nancy Crockett, Kara D. Jones, Janetta Diane Whitney, Mel Whitney, Theresia J. Gill, Tim W. Gill, Tabitha Nichols, Jason Nichols, Terri L. Freeman, Danny W. Hill, Clara Mae Sandner, Donna Rose, Darren Rose, Vanh Xayasaeng & Georgia Lowe, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Sean T. Keith , KEITH MILLER BUTLER SCHNEIDER & PAWLIK.

Sue Schafroth, Independent Executor of the Estate of, Eve Legnon, Amie Neighbors, Deborah Choate, Wendie Lowe, Cheryl Durham, Betty Woods, Gene Woods, Elizabeth Almgren, Denise Cordova, Angel Cordova, Trudy Miller, Sandy Beach, Lisa D. Little, Clarence Little, Margie Daniels, Holly DeRoca, Jensen DeRoca, Susan Hughes, Bryant Hughes, Patricia Worley, Theresa Boyer, Kelvin Boyer, Mary Henderson, Teresa Celaya, Lori Fletcher, John Fletcher, Martha Guerra, Jorge Guerra, Bobbie Jean Williams, William Hogg, Julie Johnson, Daniel Johnson, LaFonda Shutley, Samantha Danielson, Alan Danielson, Pamela Corum, Kathleen Centurione, John Centurione, Becki Parsons, Scott Parsons, Allie Smoot, Clarence Smoot, Janice Bright, Ann Wright, Stephen Wright, Maryhellen Medrano, Raul Medrano, Elizabeth Little, Marie Humphries, Teresa Schmotter, Trisha Shakespeare-Carr, Richard Carr, Chalane Kirchoff, Scott Kirchoff, Sanibel Mattos, Leidy Rosario, Janet Evans, Donald Evans, Donna Boylan, Patricia Gerling, Louis Gerling, Darlene Hayford, David Hayford, Deborah Holliday, Angel Raines, Hugh Raines, Rhonda Sardello, Anthony Sardello, Deborah Dzierzanowski, David Dzierzanowski, Patricia Evans, Patricia Ratliff, Brenda Sands, Nancy Burge, Thomas Burge, Gena Schimenti, Thomas Schimenti, Debra Pettinger, Daryl Pettinger, Wyvernia Tucker, Patsy Burroughs, John David Burroughs, Frances Elliott, Janet Pippin, Grover Pippin, Jr., Shannon Gibson, John Gibson, Denise Martinez, Carol Maynard, Mitchell Maynard, Kelly Moscato, Lawrence Moscato, Lorraine Rossi, Deborah Collins, Frances Reed, Courtney Satterthwaite, Mark Satterthwaite, Dorothy Vinson, Tina Hyatt, Donna Martin, Cathy Thompson, Kenneth Thompson, Alicia George, Charles George, Shannon Lyle, Heather Rosales, Jorge Rosales, Rebecca Serio, Joseph Serio, Serena Verdi, Vincent Verdi, Patricia Holmes, Jane Lucas, Amy Jernigan, Kacelia Flanders, Rodney Flanders, Sophia Ortiz, Carlos Ortiz, Teresa Hogan, Cindi Craig-Olson, Wade Blanchard, Jeanette Kelley, Tammy Moreau, Allen Moreau, Rita Amundsen, John A. Amundsen, Leslea C. Bates, Richard D. Bates, Denise Cairns, Timothy L. Cairns, Marilyn J. Catlin, David Catlin, Annette K. Cooter, Linda R. Dibbern, Richard D. Dibbern, Anne Hall, Allan Hall, Jacqueline Morrison, Martin Hoffman, Mildred Klopfer, Charles Klopfer, Teresa Harmon, Steven Harmon, Vicki Harper, Jamie Hoffman, Donald Hoffman (WVSD CA 2:13-12811), Jr., Phyllis Levinson, Joanna Lents, Terry Schuman, William Schuman, Luzviminda Mendoza, Ireneo-Dennes Mendoza, Katherine Juckett, Violet Wilson, Alfred Wilson, Connie Frazee, William D. Frazee (WVSD CA 2:13-13936), Jr., Amy Speer, Steven Alan Speer, Margaret Barclay, Paul Barclay, Veronica Nevarez, Paul Nevarez, Ellen Huminsky, James Huminsky, Diamona Graves, Milford Graves, Cynthia Hoffman, Rhonda Schell, Vincent Schell, Donna Willis, John Willis, Chris Myers, Elizabeth Perez, Kimberly Volpone, Carmen Wesley, Jeffery Wesley, Stella Dregney, Dolores Rios, Isabelo Rios, Christina Dawson, Earl Dawson, Rita Scholes, Merle Scholes, Sheila Wagner, Jon Wagner, Louvonda Harvey, Casina Maddox, Patsy Matti, Carolyn Hirschman-Pike, Paula Comer, Roy Wayne Comer, Martha L. Anglerau, Joseph Anglerau, Ollie Biggers, Kimberly J. Budkis, Jim Budkis, Helen Elliott, James Elliott, Treva Gilbreth, Bernice Bushway, Benita Hall, Anne Adams, Lisa Boland, Linda Delp, Randy Delp, Tamela Meadows, Michael Meadows, Patricia Stafford, Bill Stafford, Deann Torregano, Debra McClanahan, Linda McLeod, Kenneth McLeod, Fanchon Lambert, Willard Lambert, Beckey Gooden, Ronnie Gooden, Latasha Gray, Maurice Gray, Donna Terry, Marion Terry, Diane Brophy, Shawn Brophy, Ida Herdman, Jerry Herdman, Carolyn Johnson, James Johnson, Rebecca Webb, Dan Webb, Marian Prosser, Valerie Bishop, Jeneen Rockhold, Frances Venegas, Lavena Stokes, Cheryl Torrey, Thomas Torrey, Minka Latta, Jeff Latta, Sandra Washington, Nicole Graziani, Theresa Kuesel, John Kuesel, Autumn Kutschke, Betty Lou Webster, David Webster, Camille Druge, Anthony Vispetto, Angie Brandenburg, Bobby Ann Payne, Dunston Payne, Florence Eslick, Janice Blair, Elaine Radcliffe, Ronald Radcliffe, Rebecca Reel, Sheryl Ann Smith, Terry M. Smith, Stephanie Chapman, Dewayne Chapman, Burma English, Teresa Lesnick, Barbara McGregor, Peter McGregor, Terri Gibson, Robert Gibson, Bonnie Mays, Edwin Mays, Margaret Mondragon, Richard Mondragon, Elaine Ward, Pamela Brockus, Richard Brockus, Theresa Putthoff, David Putthoff, Shannon Sutton, Frances Wallace, George Wallace, Anna Barrow, Erma Copley, Clarence Copley, Mary Hines, Tamara Long-Carter, Irene Robinson, Betty Ann Rose, Ronald Rose, Grace Wellman, James Wellman, Belinda Wilson, Brenda Moody, Amanda McGuire, Doris Kochanek, Denise Gibson, Mark Gibson, Donna Crawford, Glenda Cantrell, Homer E. Cantrell, Tina Breedlove, Wanda Bragg, Vickie Fritsen, Jennifer Schuermann, Robert Schuermann, Mamie Bissonette, Michael Bissonette, Carolyn Barnhill, Stella Struggs, Ruby Ronimous, Theresa Linker, Rick Linker, Kristina Six, Frank Six, Jr., Cindy Harper, John H. Harper, Kimberly Parks, Marlon Parks, Elizabeth Tucker, Deborah Fortune, Patricia Martin, Hugh Martin, Rebecca Heath, Jason Heath, Jody Denning, Michael Denning, Shelley Fischer, Annie Walley, Casey Taylor, Carolyn Kilzer, Joanne Keyes, Anthony Keyes, Jr., Marian King-Smith, Troy Smith, Brenda Biesemeyer, Natalie Griggs, Daniel Griggs, Sharon Davidson, Eddie Davidson, Teresa Boyter, Richard Boyter, Mercy Bruce, Sarah Clifford, Jacqueline Hicks & Debra Sue Roe, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Paula L. Graham, Carol Davis, Walter Davis, Lamarr Berry, Charissa Roberts, Paul Roberts & Patricia A. Bennett, Plaintiffs, represented by Brian A. Goldstein , CELLINO & BARNES.

Peggy Greene, Mariana Scott, Mark Scott, Dorothy Tate, George Tate, Yolanda Gutierrez, Richard Gutierrez, Richard Lash, Jean Bush, Thomas Bush, Nancy Clark-Coller, Thomas Coller, Tracie Martinez, Chris Martinez, Michele Martini, Richard Martini & Rebecca Pluff, Plaintiffs, represented by Erin K. Copeland , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON.

Sarah Watson, Leon Watson, Jr., (H/W), Debra Meadows & Aubrey Ray Meadows, (H/W), Plaintiffs, represented by Lauren G. Barnes , HAGENS BERMAN SOBOL SHAPIRO & Regina S. Johnson , LOPEZ MCHUGH.

Donald K. Brown, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Adrienne Worsham Kim , GRAY & WHITE, Doris A. Kim , GRAY & WHITE, Mark K. Gray , GRAY & WHITE & Matthew L. White , GRAY & WHITE.

Tracy Begley, Plaintiff, represented by James B. Matthews, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY & Scott R. Melton , GRUEL MILLS NIMS & PYLMAN.

Greta Johnson, Timothy Johnson, Sheila Surrett, Clark Surrett, Cynthia Hastings, Evelyn Shackleford, William Shackleford, Cynthia Mills, Donna Russell, Lee Russell, Sandra Binger, Kevin Binger, Benita Miceli, Tiffany Ortega, Jose Ortega, Terri Tandle, Maria Davila, Javier Davila, Chantel Burrell, Lisa Knowles, Roger Knowles, Nancy Blesh, Margaret Marcum, Lewis Marcum, Sr., Barbara Nolen, Robert Nolen (WVSD CA 2:13-13689), Jr., Tammy Patterson, Landry Smith (WVSD CA 2:13-15180), Sr., Linda Kyle, Wade Kyle, Angela Watznauer, Steven Watznauer, Dava Gordy, Irwin Gordy, III, Deborah McCandless, Leiann Hall & Randy Hall, Plaintiffs, represented by Gregory Neil McEwen , MCEWEN LAW FIRM.

Jo Ann Banks & Michael Banks, (h/w), Plaintiffs, represented by Regina S. Johnson , LOPEZ MCHUGH.

Daryll MacKinnon, Mark Pforte, Oliver Ames, Jane L. Johnson & Raymond Johnson, Plaintiffs, represented by Jayne Conroy , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, John J. Foley , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, Paul Hanly , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY & Trent B. Miracle , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Janet M. Gardner, Plaintiff, represented by G. Sean Jez , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, Karen H. Beyea-Schroeder , BURNETT LAW FIRM & Rand Patrick Nolen , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Elizabeth Irene Lail-Moore, Lee Ann Brandon, Wesley Alan Brandon, Kathy Diane Allen, Wanda Abernathy & Annabelle Baca, Plaintiffs, represented by Jon C. Conlin , CORY WATSON & Stephen R. Hunt, Jr. , CORY WATSON.

Barbara Golding, Susan Wood, Donald Wood, Mary Hart, Lucia Gomez, Sara Kivett, Gordon Kivett, Marlene McCormick, Thomas Simons, Janet Shenep, Andrew Shenep, Lolita Babaran, Judy Denney, David Denney, Blanca Kamani, Rebecca Rahn, Laurence W. Rahn, Nancy Sill, David Sill, Sandra Kaye Riley, Rebecca Bialucha, Kimberly Ellefson, Debbie Harris, Stuart Harris, Brenda Kessler, Cecilia La Rosa, David La Rosa, Rebecca Ambrose, Stephen Ambrose, Robert Louis Lupean, Administrator of the Estate of, Stephanie Green, Eric Griffin, Tamara Stiles & Laura Glasse, Plaintiffs, represented by Jacob Plattenberger , TOR HOERMAN LAW & Tor A. Hoerman , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

Rose Barbara Pyotsia, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin H. Anderson , ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Robert Delattre, Plaintiff, represented by J. Graham Sturgis, Jr. , J. GRAHAM STURGIS, JR. & ASSOCIATES & James B. Matthews, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY.

Sandra Reedy, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Daniel S. Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS.

Ellen Guidry, Plaintiff, represented by Alex Barlow , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK, Bill Robins, III , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK & Justin R. Kaufman , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK.

Robert Stockert, Sylvia A. Williams, John Williams, Sr. & Charles Harvell, Jr., Plaintiffs, represented by Lina B. Melidonian , KABATECK BROWN KELLNER, Mark Alan Milstein , MILSTEIN ADELMAN & Steve M. Faries , KABATECK BROWN KELLNER.

Sherry Ratliff, Lillian L. Wagner, Doris Ulrich, Charles Ulrich, II, Bonnie Kimmons, Richard Kimmons, Sherry L. Rapp & Dennis R. Rapp, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE, Harry F. Bell, Jr. , THE BELL LAW FIRM & Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.

Sandra Adkins, Bethel Howard, Billy Howard, Zulee Banks, Lennest Banks, Linda Johnson, Patricia Weisslander, Marc Weisslander, Kesha Taylor, Misty Allen & Kimberly Raney, Plaintiffs, represented by Hunter J. Shkolnik , NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK & ASSOCIATES.

Michelle Laurin, Mr. Laurin, Mr. Wredt, Ginger McKinney & Jeffrey McKinney, Plaintiffs, represented by Benedict Vladislay James , FEARS NACHAWATI LAW FIRM.

Peggy Hebert, Carolyn Kelly, Margaret A. Fleming, Darrell Fleming, Emma Simmons, Joe Robert Simmons, Frances Belton, Sherry Zmorowski, John Zmorowski, Prima Herndon, Charlie Herndon, Kimberly Jackson, Donna Goble, Charlene Hamner, Sharon Humlick, Patricia Larsen, Cindy Burris, Amy Wiseman, Demetris McGhee, Nellie Dailey, Clennon Dailey, Cecilia A. Edson, Steven Edson, Jacqueline Fields, James Fields, Shelly Hollar, Carolyn Karr, John Karr, Kathy Kaufman, Roger Kauffman, Beverly Kodama, Nancy Kofman, Luminita Marie Murarescu, Ruby Kay Nicholson, Don Nicholson, Eva Rodriguez, Gustavo Rodriguez, Beatrice Saddlemire, John Saddlemire, Jennifer Sanchez, Mike Diebek, Patricia Miller, Lisa Sparks, Angel Seufert, Brenda Finley, Mary Lewis, Lowell Lewis, Shea Riggin & Heath Riggin, Plaintiffs, represented by Anne M. Tarvin , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA, Bradley D. Honnold , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA & Kirk J. Goza , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA.

Stephen Paul Grubb, Plaintiff, represented by Bill Robins, III , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK & Justin R. Kaufman , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK.

Elizabeth Traughber, Plaintiff, pro se.

Marvin Traughber, Plaintiff, pro se.

Sandra J. Skaggs & Billy G. Skaggs, Plaintiffs, represented by Chadler Ewalt Colgan , WHITE GOSS BOWERS MARCH SCHULTE & WEISENFELS.

Linda Dyer, Plaintiff, represented by Mark R. Mueller , MUELLER LAW.

Virginia Barnett, Nora Rednour, Martin Rednour, Jamie Lamb, Chris Cueves, Tracy Bundy, James Smith, Lois Measimer, Robin Warfield-Downing, Ernie Downing, Anita Alphin, Freeda Hall Barnes, Deborah Phillips, Peggy Smith & Charles Smith, Plaintiffs, represented by Christin DiMartino , THE WALTERS LAW FIRM & Lon L. Walters , THE WALTERS LAW FIRM.

Deana Naquin Puckett, Wesley Puckett & Debra Ghaster, Plaintiffs, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Shirley Shelmidine & John Shelmidine, Plaintiffs, represented by Colleen A. Clemons , GROSSMAN & MOORE, H. Philip Grossman , GROSSMAN & MOORE, Jennifer Ann Moore , GROSSMAN & MOORE, Wendy R. Fleishman , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN & Lexi J. Hazam , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Charlotte Wynn & Brody Wynn, Plaintiffs, represented by Laurel Simes , LEVIN SIMES, Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, pro hac vice & William Levin , LEVIN SIMES.

Patricia Oar & Michael J. Oar, Sr., Plaintiffs, represented by Christopher Michael Placitella , COHEN PLACITELLA & ROTH & Todd S. Payne , ZEBERSKY & PAYNE.

Babetta Jones, Timothy Jones, Rose Catherine Thornton, Dennis Thornton, Denise Plencner & Michael Plencner, Plaintiffs, represented by Douglas D. Small , FOLEY & SMALL.

Wilma McDaniel, Larry McDaniel, Jill D. Earp, Mark S. Hoffman, Corey Eiter, Dana Dollar, Theresa Dekker, Douglas Dekker, Tracy Garner & Hayward Garner, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & W. Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Michelle Montgomery, Judy Conlin & Timothy Conlin, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee Lawrence Coleman , HUGHES & COLEMAN & Steven James Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH.

Stacy Puckett, David Puckett, Patricia Watters, Keith Watters & Patricia A. Watters, Plaintiffs, represented by George M. Fleming , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, Karl N. Truman , KARL TRUMAN LAW OFFICE, G. Sean Jez , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ & Rand Patrick Nolen , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Rita Golden, Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth S. Byrd , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, Sarah R. London , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, Wendy R. Fleishman , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN & Lexi J. Hazam , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Rita Adams, Martha A. Fullen & Edwin See, Sr., Plaintiffs, represented by Everette S. Verhine , VERHINE & VERHINE & Phillip J. Wells , MCDANIEL & WELLS.

Donna Carver, Clarence Painter, Seba Luckett-Epps & Carrie Valdez, Plaintiffs, represented by Amy Collignon Gunn , THE SIMON LAW FIRM, pro hac vice & John G. Simon , THE SIMON LAW FIRM.

Tina Marie Stoltz, Jimmye Janice Newberry, April Marie Bedwell, Troy Bedwell, Mary E. Richardson, Debra J. Brooks, Marilyn J. Love, Douglas J. Love, Jane O. Tortola & Melissa Gail Pelletier, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey S. Grand , BERNSTEIN LIEBHARD.

Nancy Hundley & Tommy Hundley, Wife and Husband, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Thomas R. Kline , KLINE & SPECTER.

Mary Ruth Shelton-Dickerson, Bettie M. White & Loretta Morris, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Joseph A. Osborne , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LE CLAINCHE & Neil D. Overholtz , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Annette Cooper & Samuel Cooper, Plaintiffs, represented by Tayjes M. Shah , THE MILLER FIRM.

Karen Vinson, Plaintiff, represented by Bobby Jewell Bell, Jr. , HOLLIS WRIGHT & COUCH.

Frances E. Moore, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Valarie Hall & Dan Hall, Plaintiffs, represented by Alex Barlow , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK & Rebecca Lynn Phillips , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD.

Shirley Ann Reed, Plaintiff, represented by Catherine T. Heacox , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Dolores Leach & Joseph Leach, Plaintiffs, represented by Dino Privitera , EISENBERG ROTHWEILER WINKLER EISENBERG & JECK & Stewart J. Eisenberg , EISENBERG ROTHWEILER WINKLER EISENBERG & JECK.

Misty Owens, Rachel D. Thomas, Douglas E. Thomas, Nancy Higuera, Shelley Caltrider & Robert Caltrider (WVSD CA 2:13-11818), Jr., Plaintiffs, represented by Edward F. Blizzard , BLIZZARD MCCARTHY & NABERS & Holly W. Gibson , BLIZZARD MCCARTHY & NABERS.

Sara Jill Frank, also known as, Plaintiff, represented by Aimee R. Campbell , GRAHAM ERVANIAN & CACCIATORE, Shawn Smith , SMITH LAW FIRM, Wesley Timothy Graham , GRAHAM ERVANIAN & CACCIATORE & William W. Graham , GRAHAM ERVANIAN & CACCIATORE.

Dennis McMahon, Plaintiff, represented by Shawn Smith , SMITH LAW FIRM, Wesley Timothy Graham , GRAHAM ERVANIAN & CACCIATORE & William W. Graham , GRAHAM ERVANIAN & CACCIATORE.

Texanna M. Ferandez, Plaintiff, represented by James F. Green , ASHCRAFT & GEREL & Michelle A. Parfitt , ASHCRAFT & GEREL.

James Crummey, Linda Durieux, Steven Ryan Hawley, George Quinn, Shawn A. Gasgow, Mary Cohen & Marion D. Jester, Plaintiffs, represented by John Fabry , MUELLER LAW & Mark R. Mueller , MUELLER LAW, pro hac vice.

Robert B. Anglin, Deanna Clark Kirkland & Billy Kirkland, Plaintiffs, represented by Susan Elizabeth Hamm , LAW OFFICE OF SUSAN E. HAMM.

Marthine Ada Shelton & Sarah Gage Meadows, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Michael S. Appel , SUGARMAN ROGERS BARSHAK & COHEN, Samuel M. Furgang , SUGARMAN ROGERS BARSHAK & COHEN & Joseph A. Osborne , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LE CLAINCHE.

Tina Louise Genel, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Michael S. Appel , SUGARMAN ROGERS BARSHAK & COHEN, Samuel M. Furgang , SUGARMAN ROGERS BARSHAK & COHEN, Joseph A. Osborne , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LE CLAINCHE & Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Kimberly Monico, Peter Monico, Tanny Hernandez & David Hernandez, Plaintiffs, represented by Elise A. Waisbren , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice & Stephen D. Phillips , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice.

Theresa A. Keenan-Carr & Thomas E. Carr, Plaintiffs, represented by Catherine T. Heacox , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Wanda L. Russell, Raquel Garnica, Joseph Garnica, Margaret Lucero, Daniel Alvarez, Candelaria Garcia, Marco Antonio Estrada, Misty Blount, Jolene Neal, Edward Neal, Mercie Flores, Barbara Beneville, Edward Beneville, Arturo M. Aguirre, Mary Ann Aguirre, Olga Hernandez, Edward Hernandez, Roma Snavely, Wanda Swett, Ken Swett, Klaudia Cordova, Helen McConnell, Judith Hicks, James Hicks, Joanne Jackson, Lisa Esquivel, Josephine Nieto, Vincente Nieto, Kirstin Smith, John Smith, Donna Jensen, Heather Linder, Dave Linder, Sandra Jolley, Cindy Herrera, Louis Herrera, Nadine Sanchez, David Sanchez, Viviana Maldonado, Abel A. Maldonado, Monica Balbuena, Wesley Balbuena, Marilyn Dorlac, Michael Dorlac, Mary Lloyd-Marsden, Ronald Marsden, Joaquinita Sanchez, Jose Sanchez, Herlinda Vasquez, Marlene Whatley, Michelle Ravlin, Hayrkoohi Avedian, Seroj Avedian, Arminda Cabriales, Rudy Cabriales, Janelle Faircloth, Linda L. London, Barbara Ryan, Robert Ryan, Jennifer L. Dunn, Shirley Bailey, Debbie Stillwell, David Stillwell, Jennifer DeHoog, Scott DeHoog, Azniv Dervishian, Vahan Dervishian, Kim Meyer, Jeff Meyer, Marilyn McLintock, David McLintock, Gwynn Friesen, Kenneth D. Friesen, Shirley Combs, Mona Cabrera, Mary Pizinger, Kim Adams, Michael Halcomb, Rita Peschel, Ronald Peschel, Jr., Arlene Cabral, Lois Lomier, Rusty Lomier, Tina Baker, William Baker & Rue Timmons, Plaintiffs, represented by Alan S. Lazar , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Christina A. Humphrey , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Craig S. Pynes , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Kiley L. Grombacher , MARLIN & SALTZMAN & Marcus J. Bradley , MARLIN & SALTZMAN.

Wanda Russell, Plaintiff, represented by f Alan S. Lazar , MARLIN & SALTZMAN.

Wanda Russell, Plaintiff, represented by Christina A. Humphrey , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Craig S. Pynes , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Kiley L. Grombacher , MARLIN & SALTZMAN & Marcus J. Bradley , MARLIN & SALTZMAN.

Gladys M. Smith, John H. Smith, Sun W. Rasmussen, Lawnie D. Rasmussen, Pamela J. Karpus, Michael F. Karpus, Gail A. Tolley, Richard Glen Tolley, Carma J. Izatt, Bruce B. Izatt, Joyce Burdette, Patricia A. Rutz, Charlene Hampton & Clyde Hampton, Plaintiffs, represented by G. Sean Jez , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ & Rand Patrick Nolen , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Pamela Naderhoff, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Daniel S. Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Willard J. Moody, Jr. , THE MOODY LAW FIRM.

Sally Ortiz, Plaintiff, represented by Brett Shainfeld , SHAINFELD & ANVAR, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Jessica F. Anvar , SHAINFELD & ANVAR.

Deborah Davis & Johnny Davis, Plaintiffs, represented by Douglas Robert Plymale , PLYMALE LAW FIRM & Jeffrey D. Guerriero , GUERRIERO & GUERRIERO.

Annette Torres Ortiz, Plaintiff, represented by Andres W. Lopez , THE LAW OFFICES OF ANDRES W. LOPEZ, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Marc D. Grossman , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN & Randi Kassan , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN.

Janet Bresky & Paul Bresky, her husband, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee Delton Gunn, IV , GUNN LAW GROUP & Ryan Andrew Lopez , GUNN LAW GROUP.

Nita Karen Vickers, John L. Vickers & Theresa Norman, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, James A. McKowen , JAMES F. HUMPHREYS & ASSOCIATES & Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.

Jane Roberson, Barbara Major, Rhonda Renee McLarty, Linda Ransford, Bonnie Ranton, Donna J. Denton, Zusset Giannotta, Cathryn M. Finke & Alice Gardner, Plaintiffs, represented by Buffy K. Martines , LAMINACK PIRTLE & MARTINES, Richard N. Laminack , LAMINACK PIRTLE & MARTINES & Thomas W. Pirtle , LAMINACK PIRTLE & MARTINES.

Deborah C. Ackerman, Plaintiff, represented by Eric T. Chaffin , CHAFFIN LUHANA, pro hac vice & Roopal P. Luhana , CHAFFIN LUHANA.

Darla E. Clark, Plaintiff, represented by Jane Harris Perry , MICHAEL HINGLE & ASSOCIATES.

Constance Newman & Vern Newman, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE, Harry F. Bell, Jr. , THE BELL LAW FIRM, Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE, Michael G. Rousseau , MOTLEY RICE & Victoria L. Antion , MOTLEY RICE.

Patricia Segrest, Plaintiff, represented by Mikal C. Watts , WATTS GUERRA CRAFT, Paige Nicole Boldt , WATTS GUERRA & Ryan L. Thompson , WATTS GUERRA CRAFT.

Angela Salas, Ricardo Salas, Janet S. Wells, Marvin Wayne Wells, Jr., Tasha N. Wilson, Christopher Wilson, Roslyn Wood & Alan Wood, Plaintiffs, represented by Charles Bland Patrick , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES.

Edie Willis & Jeffrey Willis, Plaintiffs, represented by Douglas Robert Plymale , PLYMALE LAW FIRM.

Laurie Gaydos, Judith Goodman, Daniel Stuart Goodman, Nora Southern, Willie Southern, Alice Chambers, Curtis Chambers, Joan McDonald & Robert McDonald, Plaintiffs, represented by C. Andrew Childers , CHILDERS SCHLUETER & SMITH & Michael Brandon Smith , CHILDERS SCHLUETER & SMITH.

Norma Rhodes, Plaintiff, represented by Mark Andrew Tate , TATE LAW GROUP & Megan S. Helstowski , TATE LAW GROUP.

Rebecca Simpson, Plaintiff, represented by Brent William Bailey , LAW OFFICES OF BILL BAILEY & Howard A. Snyder , LAW OFFICES OF HOWARD A. SNYDER.

Vickie Joice, Plaintiff, represented by Frank E. Piscitelli, Jr. , PISCITELLI LAW FIRM.

Dianne Tate & Earnest Tate, Plaintiffs, represented by Benjamin A. Bertram , BERTRAM & GRAF, George Robert Wise, Jr. , THE BRAD HENDRICKS LAW FIRM, J. Scott Bertram , BERTRAM & GRAF & James Lamar Porter , THE BRAD HENDRICKS LAW FIRM.

Cleo Reed & Phillip Searles, Plaintiffs, represented by James G. Onder , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, Mark Edward Berns , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON, Mark R. Niemeyer , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON & Michael Joseph Quillin , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON.

Marilyn Cotney, Calvin Bishop & Jacqueline Brandon, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert E. Price , LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL RAFFERTY & PROCTOR.

DeAnn Taylor, Bernetta Taylor, Robert Taylor, Sheila Nichols-Nelson, Kimberly Garrett, Charles Garrett, Teresa Olney, Gerald Olney, Deborah Tye & Kenneth Tye, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Leah Mason , EDELMAN & THOMPSON, Melissa L. Steed , EDELMAN & THOMPSON, Ronald L. Edelman , EDELMAN & THOMPSON & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Deborah C. Aguirre, Max Matos & Shirley Ann Milton, Plaintiffs, represented by J. Mark Kell , KELL LAMPIN.

Dario E. Aguirre, Plaintiff, pro se.

Judy Lynn Brand, Plaintiff, represented by Mark Alan Milstein , MILSTEIN ADELMAN & Steve M. Faries , KABATECK BROWN KELLNER.

Roberta Herbertson, Plaintiff, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & James Bartimus , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA.

Teresa Maria Santos, Beth Erickson, Eric Erickson, Miroslava Mota & Victor Mota, Plaintiffs, represented by Mark T. Sadaka , SADAKA ASSOCIATES.

Marcia Schmierer, Plaintiff, represented by Wendy R. Fleishman , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Iris Martinez & Adam Martinez, Plaintiffs, represented by Adam Quentin Voyles , LUBEL VOYLES.

Tayne Slenker, Thomas Slenker & Kathie Hines, Plaintiffs, represented by J. Mark Kell , KELL LAMPIN & Mark Edward Berns , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON.

Kyle Mooney, Plaintiff, represented by Howard L. Nations , THE NATIONS LAW FIRM.

Deanna King & Thomas King, Plaintiffs, represented by James A. Morris, Jr. , PROVOST & UMPHREY LAW FIRM.

Nicole C. Wallace, Laurel E. Green, Juli Beth Alberts & James John Alberts, Plaintiffs, represented by Gregory L. Laker , COHEN & MALAD, pro hac vice, Irwin B. Levin , COHEN & MALAD, pro hac vice & Jeff S. Gibson , COHEN & MALAD, pro hac vice.

Herlinda Cortez, Margaret McCloud, Nancy Jean Evans, Chris Evans, Frances Hampton, Matthew Hampton, Barbara Lejeune, Susan Miller, Herbert Miller, Patricia Coulter, Gladys Leonard, Karen Mcpherson, Christopher Mcpherson, Concepcion Lopez, Mlrzeta Hirkich, Peggy Warnet, Laura Pace, Jay Pace & Elizabeth Gooch, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael Leslie Hodges , HODGES LAW FIRM.

Janet Merkle, Deceased, Betty Dye, Susan C. Caupp, Boyd T. Caupp & Charlotte Krueger, Plaintiffs, represented by Pauline Toboulidis , LOPEZ MCHUGH & Regina S. Johnson , LOPEZ MCHUGH.

Jane M. Heatherly, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey G. Blackwell , BLACKWELL LAW FIRM.

Roanna Carole Gardner-Onks & Brett Onks, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Sarah S. Ruane , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

R'Lena Blank, John Blank, Dorothy Carpenter, Betty Willis & Albee Willis, Plaintiffs, represented by Tamara L. Banno , FREESE & GOSS & Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS.

Stacy Powell & William Powell, Plaintiffs, represented by Nicholas Heiman , LAW OFFICE OF NICHOLAS HEIMAN.

Sara Jones, (Hertneck), Plaintiff, represented by Ashley M. Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, Bonnie E. Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM & Dawn R. Meade , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM.

Balinda Weekly, Plaintiff, represented by Scott Allan Kogen , THE LAW OFFICES OF SCOTT A. KOGEN AND ASSOCIATES.

Sandra Mastrogiuseppe & Chris Mastrogiuseppe, Plaintiffs, represented by Jerrold S. Parker , PARKER WAICHMAN, Matthew J. McCauley , PARKER WAICHMAN, Melanie H. Muhlstock , PARKER WAICHMAN & Raymond C. Silverman , PARKER WAICHMAN.

Robert Ross & David DeLanoy, Plaintiffs, represented by Mark E. Burton, Jr. , HERSH & HERSH, pro hac vice & William M. Audet , AUDET & PARTNERS.

Shelley Lorrain, Philip Lorrain, Phyllis Gruben, Clay Gruben, Jacqueline Johnson, Lynda Cannova, Lisa Cook, Dana Barnes, James Barnes, Laurie Bartomioli, Mary Berlin, David Berlin, Cindy Crum, Terry Crum, Tina Comer, Teresa Osborn & John G. Osborn, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Sherrill Mastin & Carl Mastin, Plaintiffs, represented by Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Lisa Baron Blue , BARON & BLUE & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Jimmie Fae Jolley, Neal Jolley, Theresa Carter, James Carter, Brenda Colburn, James Colburn, Tammy R. Roberts, Cecelia Mattingly & Virldean Baker, Plaintiffs, represented by Andy Dow Birchfield, Jr. , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, Marianne C. LeBlanc , SUGARMAN & SUGARMAN, P. Leigh O'Dell , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES & Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES.

Carol Hobart, Plaintiff, represented by J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM & Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM.

Jacqueline Cuthbertson & Luisa Mendez, Plaintiffs, represented by Amy Eskin , LEVIN SIMES, pro hac vice, Mark E. Burton, Jr. , HERSH & HERSH, pro hac vice, Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, pro hac vice & William M. Audet , AUDET & PARTNERS.

Barbara Sue Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Doralee Idleman Chandler , MATTHEWS SANDERS & SAYES, Gail O. Matthews , MATTHEWS SANDERS & SAYES, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & W. Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Maria Alba, Carol Ann Sylvia & Robert Sylvia, Plaintiffs, represented by Tonya L. Melnichenko , FRANKLIN D. AZAR & ASSOCIATES.

Sandra Lopez, Plaintiff, represented by Adam J. Blake , PERDUE & KIDD, Donald H. Kidd , PERDUE & KIDD & Jim M. Perdue, Jr. , PERDUE KIDD & VICKERY.

Sheila Barnes, William Barnes, Kathryn C. Sutton, Derrell Tonn Sutton & Genevieve Gonzales, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & W. Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Bertha Jimenez, Sharon Kay Pelkey, Bobbie J. Johnson, Earl Johnson, David G. Lyons & Sharon Sue Lyons, Plaintiffs, represented by Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Melissa M. Hood, Ann Marie Nieman, Dana J. Feld, Dianne W. Radeka & Carol Gezzi, Plaintiffs, represented by Alexandra V. Boone , MILLER WEISBROD, Les Weisbrod , MILLER WEISBROD & Luke Harrison Metzler , MILLER WEISBROD.

Ruth Moore, Valerie Settles, Laurie Beebe, Lorna Tracy & Vickie Burton, Plaintiffs, represented by Mark W. Davis , DAVIS & CRUMP.

Rita Ann Ramsey, John Ramsey, Kristina L. Gilbertson, Robert W. Gilbertson, Lauren E. Jones, Brenda A. Kellogg, John Huckabaa, Nancy H. Tan, Waltraud Tanaka, Darlene Anne Cox, Vernon Ray Cox, Jr., Ermelinda Sinsay, Arnel V. Sinsay, Melody Lynn Duncan, William Duncan, Ophelia M. Reynolds, Foy Otto Reynolds, Tammy Lorenz & Larry Lorenz, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald S. Edgar , SMITH DOLLAR.

Juan Jernandez, Plaintiff, represented by Andres F. Alonso , PARKER WAICHMAN ALONSO & David B. Krangle , ALONSO KRANGLE.

Jennifer Dorsey, formerly known as, Plaintiff, represented by Anne M. Tarvin , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA & James Bartimus , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA.

John Phillips, Plaintiff, represented by Christin DiMartino , THE WALTERS LAW FIRM, Lon L. Walters , THE WALTERS LAW FIRM, Brian Loncar , LONCAR & ASSOCIATES & Lisa S. Lee , JANET JENNER & SUGGS.

Orise Nezuh & Charles Nezuh, Plaintiffs, represented by Jason R. Fraxedas , THE MAHER LAW FIRM.

Coralia Galvez, Jorge Galvez, David Eller, Elizabeth Jean Loftly, Joseph Loftly & Kimala Houston, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE & Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.

Jill Schaeffer & Rosalie Traver, Plaintiffs, represented by Brent William Bailey , LAW OFFICES OF BILL BAILEY, Daniel S. Gruber , GRUBER & GRUBER & Howard A. Snyder , LAW OFFICES OF HOWARD A. SNYDER.

Lorenzo Kay Jenkins, Plaintiff, pro se.

Gloria Williams, Plaintiff, pro se.

Bobbie Jo Bard, Plaintiff, represented by Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE & Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE.

Sandra Irwin & Michael Irwin, Plaintiffs, represented by Kenneth E. Riley , FARRIS RILEY & PITT.

Sheila Rhyne, Randall Rhyne, Carri Hassell & Doug Hassell, Plaintiffs, represented by Alan Robertson , SLOAN BAGLEY HATCHER & PERRY LAW FIRM & M. Raymond Hatcher , SLOAN BAGLEY HATCHER & PERRY LAW FIRM.

Tracy Garrett, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg A. Anderson , TERRY BRYANT & Stacy L. Kelly , TERRY BRYANT.

Debra Risley & Bruce Risley, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrew J. Cross , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, pro hac vice.

Shawna Christine Fruecht, Plaintiff, represented by Michael Lewis Beckman , VILES & BECKMAN.

Christine Doucet & Christopher Doucet, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald S. Edgar , SMITH DOLLAR & Rex J. Grady , Fourth Floor.

Chaney Cornell, Plaintiff, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Thomas R. Kline , KLINE & SPECTER, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Lee A. Cirsch , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, pro hac vice & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Josie A. Cloy, Plaintiff, represented by P. Leigh O'Dell , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES & Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES.

Ronda Smith & Randy Smith, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael Cory Bradley , PITTMAN DUTTON & HELLUMS.

Linda Brown, John Brown, Deborah Cox & Brenda Williams, Plaintiffs, represented by Aimee H. Wagstaff , ANDRUS & WAGSTAFF, Marc D. Grossman , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN & Randi Kassan , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN.

Estean Bautista, Teresa Williiams & Stephen W. Chupik, Plaintiffs, represented by Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, pro hac vice.

Elizabeth Madzik Tarantino & Christopher E. Tarantino, Plaintiffs, represented by Ben Carl Martin , THE LAW OFFICES OF BEN C. MARTIN & Raymond L. Panneton , THE TALASKA LAW FIRM.

Debra Seals, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew J. Cross , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, pro hac vice & Jeffrey J. Lowe , CAREY DANIS & LOWE.

Anthony Mara, Suzan Jollett Mara, Lisa C. Johnson & Joe M. Johnson, Plaintiffs, represented by David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Kevin James, Plaintiff, represented by John Fabry , MUELLER LAW.

Ron Clark, Paula Keith, Wendy Ridenour, Brad Ridenour, Favia Medellin, Juan Carlos Medellin, Jo Ann Graves, Scott Graves, Bryan Winderweedle & Kim McCool, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert J. Fenstersheib , ROBERT J. FENSTERSHEIB & ASSOCIATES.

Norma Caceres, Retha McCarthy, Harry Knave, Cheryl Hays & David Cortez, Plaintiffs, represented by Craig D. Henderson , THE SNAPKA LAW FIRM & Kathryn Snapka , THE SNAPKA LAW FIRM.

Marla Ellen Heikila, Plaintiff, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE & Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.

Kathleen Johnson & Joseph Johnson, Plaintiffs, represented by Jessica Hanna Lerer , STROM LAW FIRM & Joseph Preston Strom, Jr. , STROM LAW FIRM.

Elizabeth Pendell, Plaintiff, represented by Charles R. Houssiere, III , HOUSSIERE DURANT & HOUSSIERE & Randal A. Kauffman , HOUSSIERE DURANT & HOUSSIERE.

Gail Berryhill, Chet Berryhill, Linda Atkinson, Mark Atkinson, Karen Brogdon, Betty Garcia, Robin Harvey-Anderson, Linda Hill, Jimmy Hill, Tammie Quales, Koreen Rider, Wanda Silver, Forest Silver, Georgia Stanush-Hotman, Thomas Hotman, Debra Wilkins, Stephanie Brown, Carla Eauslin, Michael Eauslin, Jayne Haith, Rodney Haith, Terry Holt, Robert Holt, Shellie Knight-Dantin, Claude Dantin, Jr., Roxanne Lancaster, James Lancaster, Marlene Lima, Barbara Nehl, Helen Skinner, Arnold Skinner, Anna Torres, Kimberly West, William West, Judy Adkisson, Jack Adkisson, Alvin Harlow, Rebecca Harlow, Amy Cubias, Recardo Cubias, Loretta Deseno, Rita Stanton, Sharon Mutzberg & Tod Mutzberg, Plaintiffs, represented by Aaron Clark Johnson , SUMMERS & JOHNSON & David G. Summers , SUMMERS & JOHNSON.

Jean Strobel, Plaintiff, represented by Elizabeth L. Dudley , THE DUDLEY LAW FIRM.

Debora K. Schouten, Plaintiff, represented by Jerrold S. Parker , PARKER WAICHMAN, Melanie H. Muhlstock , PARKER WAICHMAN & Raymond C. Silverman , PARKER WAICHMAN.

Loretta Angel, Thomas Robert Angel, Sandra Lee Cupp, Kenneth Ray Cupp, Cynthia Ann Thomin, William Charles Thomin, Luella Mae Johnson Voxland, Elizabeth Carol Thompson, Donald Ray Thompson, Roxana P. Hernandez & Gilberto Hernandez, Plaintiffs, represented by Paulina do Amaral , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN & Wendy R. Fleishman , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

William Chavez, Carolyn Fleenor, Dora Zornes & Harold Zornes, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert E. Price , LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL RAFFERTY & PROCTOR & Rochelle Rottenstein , ROTTENSTEIN LAW GROUP.

Christi Dawn Adams, Plaintiff, represented by Alex Barlow , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK, Bill Robins, III , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK & John M. Black , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK.

Maria L. Alarcon, Plaintiff, pro se.

Santos M. Alarcon, Plaintiff, pro se.

Elida Barrios & Michael Barrios, Plaintiffs, represented by Alan S. Lazar , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Carasusana B. Wall , ZOLL KRANZ & BORGESS, Christina A. Humphrey , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Craig S. Pynes , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Kiley L. Grombacher , MARLIN & SALTZMAN & Marcus J. Bradley , MARLIN & SALTZMAN.

Donna M. Baskette, Plaintiff, pro se.

Thomas J. Baskette, Plaintiff, pro se.

Michelle Burris, Claudia Denise Hernandez, James Voss & Melinda Voss, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael J. Miller , THE MILLER FIRM.

Tami L. Cornell, Plaintiff, represented by David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Lee A. Cirsch , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, pro hac vice & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Amber Cain, Vicki Bratlund, Amber Stewart, Mark Stewart, Stacey Jones, Lloyd Jones, Kimberley Smith, Craig Smith, Anita Yokley, James Yokley, Courtnie Foreman, Carol Osti, Sandro Osti, Teresa Allen, Lisa Snell, Marlys Ball, Charles Ball, Lenora Littlejohn, Ray Littlejohn, Vickie Harrison, Kenneth Harrison, Gretchen Petty, Jermane Petty, Alma Santos, Anthony Santos, Marilyn Hicks, Larry Hicks, Cindy Nall, Frank Nall, Virginia Dempsey, Nicole Oney, Charles Oney, Betty Windham, Cecil Windham, Angela Crawford, Patricia Thompson, Glenn Thompson, Cheryl Ferris, Sonia Rodriguez, Mauro Rodriguez, Linda Cross, Kenneth Cross, Deborah Sansom & Michael Sansom, Plaintiffs, represented by Ryan J. Browne , REYES BROWNE REILLEY & Spencer Paul Browne , REYES BROWNE REILLEY.

Claudette Beckwith & Donald Beckwith, Plaintiffs, represented by Marcia E. Gerston , GREENFIELD DRAA & HARRINGTON, Steven Bruce Stein , LAW OFFICE OF STEVEN B. STEIN & Tyler G. Draa , GREENFIELD SULLIVAN HARRINGTON & DRAA.

Virginia Butler, Plaintiff, represented by John Stanton Steward , MEYERKORD & MEYERKORD & Joseph D. Klenofsky , MEYERKORD & MEYERKORD.

Patricia Iaccino, Bette Gober & Bobby Gober, Plaintiffs, represented by Anne M. Tarvin , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA, Bradley D. Honnold , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA, Kevin L. Chaffee , GOZA & HONNOLD, Kirk J. Goza , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA & Roger Nail , GOZA & HONNOLD.

Alena Hoff, Bruce Hoff & Sandra Finley, Plaintiffs, represented by Christopher T. Kirchmer , PROVOST UMPHREY LAW FIRM.

Jodi Chandler, formerly known as, Plaintiff, represented by Larry D. Helvey , LARRY HELVEY LAW FIRM.

Jose Arnulfo Molina, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew Frank Sullo , SULLO & SULLO & Howard L. Nations , THE NATIONS LAW FIRM.

Helen Griffin, Tammie Jones & Danny Jones, Plaintiffs, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Hans H. Van Zanten , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Darlene Bubacz, Plaintiff, represented by Robin M. Myers , MURRAY LAW FIRM, Stephen B. Murray, Jr. , MURRAY LAW FIRM & Stephen B. Murray, Sr. , MURRAY LAW FIRM.

Theresa Hoalcraft & Christopher Hoalcraft, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS.

Elena Myers, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Elena Myers, Plaintiff, represented by Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Veronica Cortez & Alfred Cortez, Plaintiffs, represented by Carlos L. Guerra , GUERRA LAW GROUP, Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, David J. Lumber , GUERRA LAW GROUP, James Michael Moore , J. MICHAEL MOORE LAW FIRM, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & W. Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Alisa McClellan & Robert E. McClellan, Plaintiffs, represented by Brandon H. Steffey , JENSEN & ASSOCIATES & Keith M. Jensen , JENSEN & ASSOCIATES.

Terry Wireman, Plaintiff, represented by Angel L. Reyes, III , REYES BROWNE REILLEY & Spencer Paul Browne , REYES BROWNE REILLEY.

Iolene Croshaw & Lisa Richter, Plaintiffs, represented by Paige Nicole Boldt , WATTS GUERRA & Ryan L. Thompson , WATTS GUERRA CRAFT.

Salvador Castaneda, Plaintiff, represented by Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Lee A. Cirsch , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, pro hac vice, Michael A. Akselrud , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, pro hac vice & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Anita Gayle Holmes, Orval Holmes, Marjorie Ostroski, Amy Upchurch, Mark Upchurch, Edna Alvarez, Lucille Johnson & Terry Johnson, Plaintiffs, represented by Spencer Paul Browne , REYES BROWNE REILLEY.

Marcia Schimpf, Plaintiff, pro se.

Barbara Quartapella & Bernard Quartapella, Plaintiffs, represented by Martha M. McBrayer , MORELLI ALTERS RATNER.

Yolanda Navarro, Manuel Navarro, Jr., Julio Guevarra Barajas, Bennie Owen, George Owen, Rosa Maria Abascal, Ricardo Abascal, Jr., Arturo Hernandez, Elizabeth Zona & Josephina Perez, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrew J. Fink , SOLIS LAW FIRM.

Judy Wilson, Plaintiff, represented by Andy Dow Birchfield, Jr. , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, P. Leigh O'Dell , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES & Yvonne M. Flaherty , LOCKRIDGE GRINDAL NAUEN.

Karen Carlson, Gary Carlson, LaRene Cracraft, Sarah Soares, Greta Ambrose, Chelina Austin, Clara Chaplin, Linda Cherry & Mary Crance, Plaintiffs, represented by David M. Peterson , PETERSON & ASSOCIATES & Nicholas S. Clevenger , PETERSON & ASSOCIATES.

Peggy Hunter & Charles Hunter, Plaintiffs, represented by David M. Peterson , PETERSON & ASSOCIATES, Keith David Griffin , GIRARDI KEESE, Nicholas S. Clevenger , PETERSON & ASSOCIATES & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Susan Antonucci & Carl C. Antonucci, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan Scott Hofeld , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES & Charles Bland Patrick , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES.

Esmeralda C. Cantu, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher A. Seeger , SEEGER WEISS, Jeffrey S. Grand , BERNSTEIN LIEBHARD & Sindhu S. Daniel , SEEGER WEISS.

Dorothy A. Hyland, Plaintiff, pro se.

Kimberly Babb, Robert Babb, Melissa Barker, Chad Barker, Linda Culver, Karen Current, John Current, JoEllen Duran, David Duran, Kara Glass, Veronica Henderson, Vince Henderson, Angel Holscher, Donald Holscher, Norma Jarvis, Christopher Jarvis, Kriston Meyers, Patricia Phillips, Delores Rigby, Jennifer Stegall, Eddie Stegall, Karla Theroux, Dennis Theroux, Deanna Williams, Chris Williams, Amy Sagona, Kathleen Smithson, Ramona Battles, Troy Battles, Dolly Brunson, Hilda Espinoza, Jesse Espinoza, Cari Gans, Teresa Godsey, Cordeva Rose, Charles Rose, Shannah Mackey, Connie Martin, Regina Jones, Lucinda Pajak, Mary Dunekacke, Marissa Tagle, Trina Wise & William Wise, Plaintiffs, represented by Brian Loncar , LONCAR & ASSOCIATES & Lisa S. Lee , JANET JENNER & SUGGS.

Richard Trimble & Diana Whiteley, Plaintiffs, represented by Brian Loncar , LONCAR & ASSOCIATES.

Lou Montgomery, Plaintiff, represented by Brian Loncar , LONCAR & ASSOCIATES & Chad Haber Davis , LONCAR & ASSOCIATES.

Verl Justensen, Plaintiff, represented by Chad Haber Davis , LONCAR & ASSOCIATES.

Alicia Sperkacz & Yaroslaw Sperkacz, Plaintiffs, represented by Maxwell S. Kennerly , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

Jennifer Wicklund & Lance Wicklund, Plaintiffs, represented by Danny L. Curtis , DANNY L. CURTIS, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Remedios Consoli, Plaintiff, pro se.

Texanna Fernandez, Joe Fernandez, Constance Gilbert & Fred Gilbert, Plaintiffs, represented by John C. Thornton, III , ANDREWS & THORNTON & Karren Schaeffer , ANDREWS & THORNTON.

Kim Hamby, Plaintiff, represented by Genevieve M. Zimmerman , MESHBESHER & SPENCE, pro hac vice.

Michele E. Peele & Thomas H. Peele, Plaintiffs, represented by Leslie C. MacLean , WATERS & KRAUS.

Deanna Marie Bailey & Tammy Louise Dixon, Plaintiffs, represented by John T. Boundas , WILLIAMS KHERKHER HART BOUNDAS & Sejal K. Brahmbhatt , WILLIAMS KHERKHER HART BOUNDAS.

Tarra Carpenter, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew L. Davick , MESHBESHER & SPENCE, Anthony J. Nemo , MESHBESHER & SPENCE & Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Sheawna R. Rodriguez, Plaintiff, pro se.

Virginia Posey, Plaintiff, pro se.

Nancy Crowell, Plaintiff, represented by Brett Shainfeld , SHAINFELD & ANVAR, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Jessica F. Anvar , SHAINFELD & ANVAR & John P. Kristensen , KRISTENSEN WEISBERG.

Marcia Pesquera, Plaintiff, represented by Kay L. Van Wey , VAN WEY LAW.

Jennifer Elaine Lane, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew John Morrison , HARRISON DAVIS STEAKLEY MORRISON, Preston J. Dugas, III , PARKER MCDONALD, Ryan H. Anderson , PARKER MCDONALD, W. Bradley Parker , PARKER MCDONALD & Zollie C. Steakley , HARRISON DAVIS STEAKLEY MORRISON.

Patrice Ross, Plaintiff, represented by Richard A. Sandoval , SANDOVAL FIRM.

Patricia McDermott, Plaintiff, pro se.

Linda May & Bruce May, Plaintiffs, represented by Maura E. Scanlon , THE SCANLON GROUP CO.

Donna Mustard, Perry Mustard, Judy Ray, Russell Ray, Mildred Strong, Charles Strong & Paula Wilson, Plaintiffs, represented by Spencer Paul Browne , REYES BROWNE REILLEY & Timothy R. Reilley , REYES BROWNE REILLEY.

Cindy McIntosh, Susan M. Rhineberger, Brenda L. Holoubek & James Holoubek, Plaintiffs, represented by Lina B. Melidonian , KABATECK BROWN KELLNER & Mark Alan Milstein , MILSTEIN ADELMAN.

Tina Renee Mandrake, Leslie Hatfield, Jesse Hatfield, Jr., Melissa D. Montgomery, Jacinta Jo Brown, Larry Edward Brown, Deborah Kay Mobley, Corina Kay House, Treasure Thorpe, Deborah Pilley, Charles Pilley, Vanessa Perron & Blake Perron, Plaintiffs, represented by Carl N. Frankovitch , FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON & Kevin M. Pearl , FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON.

Pauline Dunn & James Dunn, Plaintiffs, represented by Ryan J. Browne , REYES BROWNE REILLEY, Spencer Paul Browne , REYES BROWNE REILLEY & Timothy R. Reilley , REYES BROWNE REILLEY.

Julie Jones & James Jones, Plaintiffs, represented by McDonald S. Worley , MCDONALD WORLEY & Michelle Rene Eddington , MCDONALD WORLEY.

Gwynesta Dukes, Plaintiff, represented by Richard A. Capshaw , CAPSHAW & ASSOCIATES.

Luz Aguilar & Wilfrido Aguilar, Plaintiffs, represented by Stuart E. Scott , SPANGENBERG SHIBLEY & LIBER.

Tina R. Norton, Plaintiff, pro se.

R.J. Norton, Jr., Plaintiff, pro se.

Michael Martinez, Personal Representative of the Estate of, Michael Martinez, Maria Martinez & Michael Anthony Martinez, Plaintiffs, represented by Sean Michael Cleary , LAW OFFICES OF SEAN M. CLEARY.

Vera Mehrtens & Elbert Mehrtens, Plaintiffs, represented by Benjamin A. Bertram , BERTRAM & GRAF, Blair Bertram Matyszczyk , BERTRAM & GRAF & J. Scott Bertram , BERTRAM & GRAF.

Crystal Long, Plaintiff, represented by Steven J. Brady , BRADY LAW GROUP.

Jose N. Vegerano, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher N. Shakib , TERRELL HOGAN ELLIS YEGELWEL.

Stephanie Brough & Sean Brough, Plaintiffs, represented by Erik Walker , HISSEY KIENTZ & Kathleen K. McGinn , HISSEY KIENTZ.

Alida Chewning & Mary Sirk, Plaintiffs, represented by J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Jason A. Itkin , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Kurt B. Arnold , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM & Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Nina Smith, Plaintiff, pro se.

Larry W. Smith, Plaintiff, pro se.

Adele Stukas, Plaintiff, pro se.

Richard Martinez, Plaintiff, pro se.

Julie Powell, Keith Knodle, Julia C. Lester & Karen Clark, Plaintiffs, represented by Paulina do Amaral , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, Wendy R. Fleishman , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN & Cecilia Han , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Laura E. Martin, Plaintiff, pro se.

Mitchell L. Martin, Plaintiff, pro se.

Shelley Goodell & Randall Goodell, Plaintiffs, represented by Zachary Peter Lowe , LOWE LAW GROUP.

Bernice Horton, Plaintiff, pro se.

Deborah Villarrial & Manuel Villarrial, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeremy R. Fietz , ADAMS FIETZ.

Clyde E. Roby, II, Plaintiff, represented by H. Philip Grossman , GROSSMAN & MOORE & Jennifer Ann Moore , GROSSMAN & MOORE.

Pamela Roth & Edna Martin, Plaintiffs, represented by Kenneth G. Gilman , GILMAN LAW.

Bessie Coleman, Plaintiff, represented by Kyla Cole , WATERS & KRAUS & Leslie C. MacLean , WATERS & KRAUS.

Franklin Viegas, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Amy Eskin , LEVIN SIMES, pro hac vice, Mark E. Burton, Jr. , HERSH & HERSH, pro hac vice & William M. Audet , AUDET & PARTNERS.

Karen Conerly-Wall, Joseph Patrick Wall, Joseph Nunez, Rebecca Duvall, Renee Perron, Dennis Perron, Teresa Brandt, William Edward Brandt, Sr., Dorothy Cole-Muchnick, Carla Ranshaw, Douglas Allen Ranshaw, Lillian McArdle, Jeanette Salmon, Patrick Salmon, Sharon Leonardi, George Leonardi, Regina West, Lori Lowenthal, Peter Lowenthal, Frances Potts & Rita Amacker, Plaintiffs, represented by Koren Leslie Cohen , DOUGLAS & LONDON & Michael A. London , DOUGLAS & LONDON.

Stephanie Rasco, Priscilla Copeland, Connie Ford, Terry Ford, Judy Anderson, Leona Sink, Faith Gatewood, Susan Andryewski, Michael Andryewski, Patricia Barnes, Gary Barnes, Donna Stubbs, Juanita Cornwell, Lori Kay Santi, Duane Santi, Ester Ray, David Ray, Stella Salazar, Laurel Cartwright, Gary Lynn Cartwright, Dolores Sue Parks, Ana Cristina Monge, Dorothy Thompson, Sherry Davis, Vania Valencia, Helen Oberdier, Randy Oberdier & Lisa Novella, Plaintiffs, represented by Christopher A. Seeger , SEEGER WEISS & Sindhu S. Daniel , SEEGER WEISS.

Rose Lee Stimer & Brian Stimer, Plaintiffs, represented by David F. DePasquale , FITZPATRICK & DEPASQUALE & R. Bryan Nace , NACE LAW OFFICE.

Linda Von Berg (WVSD CA 2:13-21837) & David Von Berg, Plaintiffs, represented by David Alexander Kleczek , KLECZEK LAW OFFICE.

Vera Novakovich-Reef, Plaintiff, represented by Andy Dow Birchfield, Jr. , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, Eric Howard Weinberg , THE LAW FIRM OF ERIC H. WEINBERG, P. Leigh O'Dell , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES & Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES.

Lori Reeves, Plaintiff, represented by John Charles Miller, Jr. , MILLER INJURYATTORNEYS.

George McKnight & Wrenda McKnight, Plaintiffs, represented by Anne M. Tarvin , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA, Brett Votava , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GORNY & James Bartimus , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA.

Inocencia Nerio, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Erin K. Copeland , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON.

Linda Luczak & Glenn Luczak, Plaintiffs, represented by Heath P. Straka , GINGRAS CATES & LUEBKE & Victoria M. Karcher , GINGRAS CATES & LUEBKE.

Kelli A. McGregor, Joseph McGregor, Eunice E. Ballard, Paul L. Ballard, Jessica Aten & Ronald Aten, Plaintiffs, represented by Thomas R. Behm , GRUEL MILLS NIMS & PYLMAN.

Betty J. Urban & George Urban, her husband, Plaintiffs, represented by Kenton Voges Sands , SANDS WHITE & SANDS.

Karen Boumnijel & Maher Boumnijel, Plaintiffs, represented by Scott Alan Campbell , LAW OFFICE OF SCOTT CAMPBELL.

Carmen Todd, Plaintiff, represented by Susan Elizabeth Burgess , LAW OFFICE OF THOMAS G. BUCHANAN & Thomas G. Buchanan , LAW OFFICE OF THOMAS G. BUCHANAN.

Kathleen Feeney, Judy Eichenbaum, Mort Eichenbaum, Susan Drew, Dale Henry Drew, Marie Antoinette Solorzano, Joyce Prizler, Paul Prizler & Diana Oberding, Plaintiffs, represented by Alan S. Lazar , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Christina A. Humphrey , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Kiley L. Grombacher , MARLIN & SALTZMAN & Marcus J. Bradley , MARLIN & SALTZMAN.

Dixie Bice, Plaintiff, pro se.

Virginia Odor, an individual & Kevin Odor, an individual, Plaintiffs, represented by Artemus W. Ham, IV , EGLET PRINCE & Erica D. Entsminger , EGLET PRINCE.

Donna Bleckler, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin A. Bertram , BERTRAM & GRAF & J. Scott Bertram , BERTRAM & GRAF.

Sharon Biesterfeld & William Biesterfeld, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Leah Mason , EDELMAN & THOMPSON, Melissa L. Steed , EDELMAN & THOMPSON & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Nikki Woodson, Travis Woodson & Eva Taylor, Plaintiffs, represented by Joseph S. Carson , WARHAWK LEGAL.

Abigale G. Romero, Plaintiff, represented by Brady Ryan Thomas , RICHARDSON PATRICK WESTBROOK & BRICKMAN.

Serap Shorter & Jerry Shorter, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Willard J. Moody, Jr. , THE MOODY LAW FIRM.

Benita Garcia, Plaintiff, represented by Scott Levensten , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM.

Susan Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Andrew L. Davick , MESHBESHER & SPENCE, Anthony J. Nemo , MESHBESHER & SPENCE, Daniel S. Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS.

Susan M. McQueen & Randy McQueen, Plaintiffs, represented by Norwood S. Wilner , THE WILNER FIRM, pro hac vice.

Mary Shumate, Plaintiff, represented by Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.


MEMORANDUM OPINION & ORDER

Pending before the court is the Defendant's Motion to Dismiss with Prejudice [ECF No. 13] filed by Boston Scientific Corporation ("BSC"). BSC seeks dismissal of the case with prejudice based on the plaintiff's failure to provide a completed Plaintiff Fact Sheet in accordance...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases