1. Home
  2. Browse Decisions
  3. IN RE ASBESTOS LITIGATION
 

IN RE ASBESTOS LITIGATION

Civ. No. 17-00251-VAC-SRF.

IN RE: ASBESTOS LITIGATION. MICHAEL R. HARDING and SALLY HARDING, Plaintiffs, v. A.O. SMITH CORPORATION, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, D. Delaware.

September 14, 2017.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 28 U.S.C. § 1441
Cause: 28 U.S.C. § 1441 Notice of Removal - Asbestos Litigation
Nature of Suit: 368 P.I. : Asbestos
Source: PACER

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Michael R. Harding, Plaintiff, represented by Bartholomew J. Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A..

Michael R. Harding, Plaintiff, represented by Adam Balick , Balick & Balick, LLC, Andrew Caulfield Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Ipek Kurul Medford , Dalton & Associates, P.A. & Michael Collins Smith , Balick & Balick, LLC.

Sally Harding, Plaintiff, represented by Bartholomew J. Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Adam Balick , Balick & Balick, LLC, Andrew Caulfield Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Ipek Kurul Medford , Dalton & Associates, P.A. & Michael Collins Smith , Balick & Balick, LLC.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

Burnham LLC, Defendant, represented by Robert S. Goldman , Phillips, Goldman, McLaughlin & Hall, P.A..

Carrier Corporation, Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

CBS Corporation, Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Crane Co., Defendant, represented by Nicholas E. Skiles , Swartz Campbell LLC & Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Crosby Valve LLC, Defendant, represented by Paul A. Bradley , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC & Donald Robert Kinsley , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC.

Dominion Nuclear Connecticut, Inc., Defendant, represented by Jason A. Cincilla , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP & Ryan William Browning , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Excelon Corporation, Defendant, represented by James J. Horning, Jr. , Wilbraham Lawler & Buba & Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

FMC Corporation, Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Foster Wheeler LLC, Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Gardner Denver, Inc., Defendant, represented by Matthew P. Donelson , Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott, LLC.

General Electric Company, Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Georgia-Pacific LLC, Defendant, represented by Irina N. Luzhatsky , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP & Whitney L. Frame , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

ITT Corporation, Defendant, represented by Kelly A. Costello , Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP.

Peerless industries, Inc., Defendant, represented by Amaryah K. Bocchino , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP, Ann Marie Kashishian , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP, Jason A. Cincilla , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP & Whitney L. Frame , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Rheem Manufacturing Company, Defendant, represented by Jonathan L. Parshall , Murphy, Spadaro & Landon.

Sequoia Ventures, Inc., Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Spirax Sarco, Inc., Defendant, represented by Antoinette D. Hubbard , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC & Paul A. Bradley , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc, Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

Warren Pumps, LLC, Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Marley-Wylain Company, Defendant, represented by Matthew P. Donelson , Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott, LLC.

FMC Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

FMC Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

Burnham LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert S. Goldman , Phillips, Goldman, McLaughlin & Hall, P.A..

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Nicholas E. Skiles , Swartz Campbell LLC & Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Dominion Nuclear Connecticut, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jason A. Cincilla , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Excelon Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

Foster Wheeler LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Georgia-Pacific LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Whitney L. Frame , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Kelly A. Costello , Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP.

Rheem Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jonathan L. Parshall , Murphy, Spadaro & Landon.

Sequoia Ventures, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Spirax Sarco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Antoinette D. Hubbard , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC & Paul A. Bradley , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Sequoia Ventures, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Sequoia Ventures, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

Burnham LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert S. Goldman , Phillips, Goldman, McLaughlin & Hall, P.A..

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC.

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Nicholas E. Skiles , Swartz Campbell LLC & Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Dominion Nuclear Connecticut, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jason A. Cincilla , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Excelon Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

FMC Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Foster Wheeler LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Georgia-Pacific LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Whitney L. Frame , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Kelly A. Costello , Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP.

Rheem Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jonathan L. Parshall , Murphy, Spadaro & Landon.

Spirax Sarco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Antoinette D. Hubbard , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC & Paul A. Bradley , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc, Cross Claimant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

Superior Boiler Works, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

Burnham LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert S. Goldman , Phillips, Goldman, McLaughlin & Hall, P.A..

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Nicholas E. Skiles , Swartz Campbell LLC & Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Dominion Nuclear Connecticut, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jason A. Cincilla , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Excelon Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

FMC Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Foster Wheeler LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Georgia-Pacific LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Whitney L. Frame , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Kelly A. Costello , Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP.

Rheem Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jonathan L. Parshall , Murphy, Spadaro & Landon.

Sequoia Ventures, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Spirax Sarco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Antoinette D. Hubbard , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC & Paul A. Bradley , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Claimant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

Burnham LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert S. Goldman , Phillips, Goldman, McLaughlin & Hall, P.A..

CBS Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Carrier Corporation, individually and as successor in interest to Bryant Heating & Cooling Systems, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Nicholas E. Skiles , Swartz Campbell LLC & Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Dominion Nuclear Connecticut, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jason A. Cincilla , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Excelon Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

FMC Corporation, individually and as successor through acquisition of Northern Pump Company, Chicago Pump Company, and Peerless Pump Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Foster Wheeler LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Georgia-Pacific LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Whitney L. Frame , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Kelly A. Costello , Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP.

Rheem Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jonathan L. Parshall , Murphy, Spadaro & Landon.

Sequoia Ventures, Inc., f/k/a Bechtel Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Spirax Sarco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Antoinette D. Hubbard , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC & Paul A. Bradley , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

Superior Boiler Works, Inc, Cross Claimant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

Superior Boiler Works, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, individually and as wholly-owned subsidiary of AMPCO-Pittsburgh, Individually and as Successor in interest to Buffalo Pumps, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

Burnham LLC, individually and as successor to Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert S. Goldman , Phillips, Goldman, McLaughlin & Hall, P.A..

CBS Corporation, a Delaware Corporation, f/k/a Viacom, Inc., successor by merger to CBS Corporation a Pennsylvania Corporation, f/k/a Westinghouse Electric Corporation, as successor in interest to The Bryant Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Carrier Corporation, individually and as successor in interest to Bryant Heating & Cooling Systems, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Nicholas E. Skiles , Swartz Campbell LLC & Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Dominion Nuclear Connecticut, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jason A. Cincilla , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP & Ryan William Browning , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Excelon Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

FMC Corporation, individually and as successor through acquisition of Northern Pump Company, Chicago Pump Company, and Peerless Pump Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Foster Wheeler LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Georgia-Pacific LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Whitney L. Frame , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Kelly A. Costello , Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP.

Marley-Wylain Company, Individually and as successor in interest to The Weil-McLain Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Matthew P. Donelson , Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott, LLC.

Rheem Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jonathan L. Parshall , Murphy, Spadaro & Landon.

Sequoia Ventures, Inc., f/k/a Bechtel Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Spirax Sarco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Antoinette D. Hubbard , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC & Paul A. Bradley , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, individually and as wholly-owned subsidiary of AMPCO-Pittsburgh, Individually and as Successor in interest to Buffalo Pumps, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

Burnham LLC, individually and as successor to Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert S. Goldman , Phillips, Goldman, McLaughlin & Hall, P.A..

CBS Corporation, a Delaware Corporation, f/k/a Viacom, Inc., successor by merger to CBS Corporation a Pennsylvania Corporation, f/k/a Westinghouse Electric Corporation, as successor in interest to The Bryant Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Carrier Corporation, individually and as successor in interest to Bryant Heating & Cooling Systems, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Nicholas E. Skiles , Swartz Campbell LLC & Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Dominion Nuclear Connecticut, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jason A. Cincilla , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP & Ryan William Browning , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Excelon Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

FMC Corporation, individually and as successor through acquisition of Northern Pump Company, Chicago Pump Company, and Peerless Pump Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Foster Wheeler LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Georgia-Pacific LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Whitney L. Frame , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Kelly A. Costello , Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP.

Marley-Wylain Company, Individually and as successor in interest to The Weil-McLain Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Matthew P. Donelson , Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott, LLC.

Rheem Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jonathan L. Parshall , Murphy, Spadaro & Landon.

Sequoia Ventures, Inc., f/k/a Bechtel Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Spirax Sarco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Antoinette D. Hubbard , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC & Paul A. Bradley , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, individually and as wholly-owned subsidiary of AMPCO-Pittsburgh, Individually and as Successor in interest to Buffalo Pumps, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

Burnham LLC, individually and as successor to Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert S. Goldman , Phillips, Goldman, McLaughlin & Hall, P.A..

CBS Corporation, a Delaware Corporation, f/k/a Viacom, Inc., successor by merger to CBS Corporation a Pennsylvania Corporation, f/k/a Westinghouse Electric Corporation, as successor in interest to The Bryant Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Carrier Corporation, individually and as successor in interest to Bryant Heating & Cooling Systems, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Nicholas E. Skiles , Swartz Campbell LLC & Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Dominion Nuclear Connecticut, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jason A. Cincilla , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Excelon Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

FMC Corporation, individually and as successor through acquisition of Northern Pump Company, Chicago Pump Company, and Peerless Pump Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Foster Wheeler LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Georgia-Pacific LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Whitney L. Frame , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Michael R. Harding, Cross Defendant, represented by Bartholomew J. Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Adam Balick , Balick & Balick, LLC, Andrew Caulfield Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Ipek Kurul Medford , Dalton & Associates, P.A. & Michael Collins Smith , Balick & Balick, LLC.

Sally Harding, Cross Defendant, represented by Bartholomew J. Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Adam Balick , Balick & Balick, LLC, Andrew Caulfield Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Ipek Kurul Medford , Dalton & Associates, P.A. & Michael Collins Smith , Balick & Balick, LLC.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Kelly A. Costello , Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP.

Marley-Wylain Company, Individually and as successor in interest to The Weil-McLain Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Matthew P. Donelson , Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott, LLC.

Rheem Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jonathan L. Parshall , Murphy, Spadaro & Landon.

Sequoia Ventures, Inc., f/k/a Bechtel Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Spirax Sarco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Antoinette D. Hubbard , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC & Paul A. Bradley , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, individually and as wholly-owned subsidiary of AMPCO-Pittsburgh, Individually and as Successor in interest to Buffalo Pumps, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

Burnham LLC, individually and as successor to Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert S. Goldman , Phillips, Goldman, McLaughlin & Hall, P.A..

CBS Corporation, a Delaware Corporation, f/k/a Viacom, Inc., successor by merger to CBS Corporation a Pennsylvania Corporation, f/k/a Westinghouse Electric Corporation, as successor in interest to The Bryant Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Carrier Corporation, individually and as successor in interest to Bryant Heating & Cooling Systems, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Nicholas E. Skiles , Swartz Campbell LLC & Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Dominion Nuclear Connecticut, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jason A. Cincilla , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Excelon Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

FMC Corporation, individually and as successor through acquisition of Northern Pump Company, Chicago Pump Company, and Peerless Pump Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Foster Wheeler LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Georgia-Pacific LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Whitney L. Frame , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Michael R. Harding, Cross Defendant, represented by Bartholomew J. Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Adam Balick , Balick & Balick, LLC, Andrew Caulfield Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Ipek Kurul Medford , Dalton & Associates, P.A. & Michael Collins Smith , Balick & Balick, LLC.

Sally Harding, Cross Defendant, represented by Bartholomew J. Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Adam Balick , Balick & Balick, LLC, Andrew Caulfield Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Ipek Kurul Medford , Dalton & Associates, P.A. & Michael Collins Smith , Balick & Balick, LLC.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Kelly A. Costello , Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP.

Marley-Wylain Company, Individually and as successor in interest to The Weil-McLain Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Matthew P. Donelson , Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott, LLC.

Rheem Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jonathan L. Parshall , Murphy, Spadaro & Landon.

Sequoia Ventures, Inc., f/k/a Bechtel Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Spirax Sarco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Antoinette D. Hubbard , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC & Paul A. Bradley , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Air & Liquid Systems Corporation, individually and as wholly-owned subsidiary of AMPCO-Pittsburgh, Individually and as Successor in interest to Buffalo Pumps, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

Burnham LLC, individually and as successor to Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert S. Goldman , Phillips, Goldman, McLaughlin & Hall, P.A..

CBS Corporation, a Delaware Corporation, f/k/a Viacom, Inc., successor by merger to CBS Corporation a Pennsylvania Corporation, f/k/a Westinghouse Electric Corporation, as successor in interest to The Bryant Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Carrier Corporation, individually and as successor in interest to Bryant Heating & Cooling Systems, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Crane Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Nicholas E. Skiles , Swartz Campbell LLC & Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Dominion Nuclear Connecticut, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jason A. Cincilla , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Excelon Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy A. Sullivan, III , Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba.

FMC Corporation, individually and as successor through acquisition of Northern Pump Company, Chicago Pump Company, and Peerless Pump Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Foster Wheeler LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

General Electric Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Allison L. Texter , Swartz Campbell LLC & Beth E. Valocchi , Swartz Campbell LLC.

Georgia-Pacific LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Whitney L. Frame , Manion Gaynor & Manning LLP.

Michael R. Harding, Cross Defendant, represented by Bartholomew J. Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Adam Balick , Balick & Balick, LLC, Andrew Caulfield Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Ipek Kurul Medford , Dalton & Associates, P.A. & Michael Collins Smith , Balick & Balick, LLC.

Sally Harding, Cross Defendant, represented by Bartholomew J. Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Adam Balick , Balick & Balick, LLC, Andrew Caulfield Dalton , Dalton & Associates P.A., Ipek Kurul Medford , Dalton & Associates, P.A. & Michael Collins Smith , Balick & Balick, LLC.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Kelly A. Costello , Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP.

Marley-Wylain Company, Individually and as successor in interest to The Weil-McLain Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Matthew P. Donelson , Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott, LLC.

Rheem Manufacturing Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jonathan L. Parshall , Murphy, Spadaro & Landon.

Sequoia Ventures, Inc., f/k/a Bechtel Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Partick Daly , Kelley Jasons McGowan Spinelli & Hanna LLP.

Spirax Sarco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Antoinette D. Hubbard , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC & Paul A. Bradley , Maron Marvel Bradley & Anderson LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Eileen M. Ford , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C. & Megan Trocki Mantzavinos , Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, P.C..

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jessica Lee Tyler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION

I. INTRODUCTION

Presently before the court in this asbestos-related personal injury action is a motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(2), filed by defendant Exelon Corporation ("Exelon"). (D.I. 60) For the reasons set forth below, the court recommends granting Exelon's motion to dismiss.

II. BACKGROUND

A. Procedural History

Michael and Sally Harding ("plaintiffs") filed this asbestos action in the Delaware Superior Court against multiple defendants on January 20, 2017, asserting claims arising from Mr. Harding's alleged harmful exposure to asbestos. (D.I. 1, Ex. 1 at 2) Defendant Crane Co. removed the action to this court on March 10, 2017. (D.I. 1) Exelon filed a motion to dismiss based on lack of personal jurisdiction on May 22, 2017. (D.I. 60) Plaintiffs did not respond to the motion.

B. Facts

Plaintiffs allege Mr. Harding developed lung cancer as a result of exposure to asbestos-containing products during his career with various employers, including the United States Navy, where Mr. Harding worked as a pipe fitter from 1963 to 1967. (D.I. 1, Ex. 1 at ¶¶3, 13) Plaintiffs contend defendants manufactured, sold, removed, installed, or distributed asbestos-containing products. (Id. at ¶ 8) Accordingly, plaintiffs assert negligence, willful and wanton conduct, strict liability, and loss of consortium claims. (D.I. 1, Ex. 1 at ¶¶ 14-32)

Plaintiffs have resided in Darien, Connecticut since 1983. (D.I. 1, Ex. 1 at ¶ 2) Exelon is not a Delaware business entity and does not have a principal place of business in Delaware. (D.I. 60 at ¶ 3)

III. LEGAL STANDARDS

Rule 12(b)(2) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure directs the court to dismiss a case when the court lacks personal jurisdiction over the defendant. Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(2). When reviewing a motion to dismiss pursuant to Rule 12(b)(2), a court must accept as true all allegations of jurisdictional fact made by the plaintiff and resolve all factual disputes in the plaintiffs favor. Miller Yacht Sales, Inc. v. Smith, 384 F.3d 93, 97 (3d Cir. 2004); Traynor v. Liu, 495 F.Supp.2d 444, 448 (D. Del. 2007). Once a jurisdictional defense has been raised, the plaintiff bears the burden of establishing, with reasonable particularity, that sufficient minimum contacts have occurred between the defendant and the forum to support jurisdiction. See Provident Nat'l Bankv. Cal. Fed. Sav. & Loan Ass'n, 819 F.2d 434, 437 (3d Cir. 1987). To meet this burden, the plaintiff must produce "sworn affidavits or other competent evidence," since a Rule 12(b)(2) motion "requires resolution of factual issues outside the pleadings." Time Share Vacation Club v. Atl. Resorts, Ltd., 735 F.2d 61, 66 n.9 (3d Cir. 1984). A plaintiff "need only establish a prima facie case of personal jurisdiction" when the court has not held an evidentiary hearing. O'Connor v. Sandy Lane Hotel Co., 496 F.3d 312, 316 (3d Cir. 2007).

To establish personal jurisdiction, a plaintiff must produce facts sufficient to satisfy two requirements by a preponderance of the evidence, one statutory and one constitutional. See Time Share, 735 F.2d at 66; Reach & Assocs. v. Dencer, 269 F.Supp.2d 497, 502 (D. Del. 2003). With respect to the statutory requirement, the court must determine whether there is a statutory basis for jurisdiction under the forum state's long-arm statute. See IMO Indus., Inc. v. Kiekert AG, 155 F.3d 254, 259 (3d Cir. 1998); Reach & Assocs., 269 F. Supp. 2d at 502. The constitutional basis requires the court to determine whether the exercise of jurisdiction comports with the defendant's right to due process. See id.; Int'l Shoe Co. v. Washington, 326 U.S. 310, 316 (1945).

Pursuant to the relevant portions of Delaware's long-arm statute, 10 Del. C. § 3104(c)(1)—(4), a court may exercise personal jurisdiction over a defendant when the defendant or its agent:

(1) Transacts any business or performs any character of work or service in the State; (2) Contracts to supply services or things in this State; (3) Causes tortious injury in the State by an act or omission in this State; (4) Causes tortious injury in the State or outside of the State by an act or omission outside the State if the person regularly does or solicits business, engages in any other persistent course of conduct in the State or derives substantial revenue from services, or things used or consumed in the State.

10 Del. C. § 3104(c)(1)-(4). With the exception of (c)(4), the long-arm statute requires a showing of specific jurisdiction. See Shoemaker v. McConnell, 556 F.Supp.2d 351, 354-55 (D. Del. 2008). Subsection (c)(4) confers general jurisdiction, which requires a greater extent of contacts, but allows the exercise of personal jurisdiction even when the claim is unrelated to the forum contacts. See Applied Biosystems, Inc. v. Cruachem, Ltd., 772 F.Supp. 1458, 1466 (D. Del. 1991).

If a defendant is found to be within the reach of the long-arm statute, the court must then analyze whether the exercise of personal jurisdiction comports with due process by determining whether the plaintiff has demonstrated that the defendant "purposefully avail[ed] itself of the privilege of conducting activities within the forum State," such that it should "reasonably anticipate being haled into court there." World-Wide Volkswagen Corp. v. Woodson, 444 U.S. 286, 297 (1980) (citations omitted). The court may exercise specific personal jurisdiction consistent with due process when the plaintiffs cause of action arises from the defendant's activities in the forum state. See Burger King Corp. v. Rudzewicz, 471 U.S. 462, 472 (1985). The court may exercise general personal jurisdiction consistent with due process when the plaintiffs cause of action is unrelated to the defendant's activities in the forum state, so long as the defendant has "continuous and systematic contacts with the forum state." Applied Biosystems, Inc., 772 F. Supp. at 1470.

In Daimler AG v. Bauman, the Supreme Court stated that the "paradigm all-purpose forums for general jurisdiction are a corporation's place of incorporation and principal place of business." 134 S.Ct. 746, 749 (2014). The Supreme Court did not hold that a corporation may be subject to general jurisdiction only in one of these locations, but rejected the notion that "continuous and systematic" contacts alone could confer general jurisdiction, clarifying that the role of general jurisdiction is to "afford plaintiffs recourse to at least one clear and certain forum in which a corporate defendant may be sued on any and all claims." Id. at 760-62.

IV. DISCUSSION

The court should grant Exelon's motion to dismiss based on lack of personal jurisdiction because plaintiffs have not met their burden of establishing, with reasonable particularity, that sufficient minimum contacts have occurred between Exelon and the forum to support jurisdiction. See Provident Nat'l Bank, 819 F.2d at 437.

When a defendant raises the defense of the court's lack of personal jurisdiction, the burden shifts to plaintiff to prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, facts sufficient to establish jurisdiction. IMO Industries, Inc., 155 F.3d at 257; Carteret Sav. Bank, F.A. v. Shushan, 954 F.2d 141, 146 (3d Cir. 1992), cert. denied, 506 U.S. 817 (1992). To satisfy its burden, plaintiff may not rely on the bare pleadings, but must establish jurisdictional facts through sworn affidavits or other competent evidence., Time Share Vacation Club, 735 F.2d at 66 n. 7. In their complaint, plaintiffs state Exelon is "a foreign business entity that does business in Delaware." (D.I. 1, Ex. 1 at ¶ 7) However, this statement is conclusory and falls short of demonstrating either specific or general jurisdiction that comports with due process. See Provident Nat'l Bank, 819 F.2d at 437. Moreover, as mentioned supra, plaintiffs did not respond to Exelon's motion to dismiss and have not produced the necessary evidence to meet their burden of proof. Although a court must accept as true all allegations of fact made by plaintiff and resolve all factual disputes in plaintiffs favor, plaintiffs may nofsimply rely on conclusory statements made in the bare pleadings.

Specific personal jurisdiction over Exelon does not exist in the present case. Plaintiffs allege Mr. Harding was exposed to asbestos-containing products during his work-related activities, all of which occurred in Connecticut and outside Delaware. (D.I. 1, Ex. 1 at ¶ 3) Plaintiffs' complaint does not specify that any of the alleged exposures which occurred while Mr. Harding was in the U.S. Navy occurred in Delaware. (Id.) In addition, plaintiffs do not allege that any wrongful conduct by Exelon occurred in Delaware. Moreover, Mr. Harding is a resident of Connecticut, not Delaware. (D.I. 1, Ex. 1 at 9 ¶ 2) Thus, there is no nexus between the alleged injurious conduct, the defendant, and the State of Delaware. See Burger King, 471 U.S. at 472.

General jurisdiction also does not exist over Exelon in the present case. Exelon is not a Delaware business entity and does not have a principal place of business in Delaware. (D.I. 60 at ¶ 3) Therefore, Exelon is not "at home" in Delaware. Daimler, 134 S. Ct. at 749. Moreover, the Delaware Supreme Court has noted that the Daimler Court rejected the notion that "a corporation is subject to general jurisdiction in every state in which it `engages in a substantial, continuous, and systematic course of business' calling that position `unacceptably grasping.'" Genuine Parts Co. v. Cepec, 137 A.3d 123, 136 (Del. Apr. 18, 2016) (quoting Daimler, 134 S. Ct. at 761).

V. CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, the court recommends granting Exelon's motion to dismiss.

This Report and Recommendation is filed pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(l)(B), Fed. R. Civ. P. 72(b)(1), and D. Del. LR 72.1. The parties may serve and file specific written objections within fourteen (14) days after being served with a copy of this Report and Recommendation. Fed. R. Civ. P. 72(b)(2). The objection and responses to the objections are limited to ten (10) pages each. The failure of a party to object to legal conclusions may result in the loss of the right to de novo review in the District Court. See Sincavage v. Barnhart, 171 F. App'x 924, 925 n.1 (3d Cir. 2006); Henderson v. Carlson, 812 F.2d 874, 878-79 (3d Cir. 1987).

The parties are directed to the court's Standing Order For Objections Filed Under Fed. R. Civ. P. 72, dated October 9, 2013, a copy of which is available on the court's website, http://www.ded.uscourts.gov.

Comment

1000 Characters Remaining

Leagle.com reserves the right to edit or remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.

User Comments

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases