HOBART CORPORTION v. THE DAYTON POWER & LIGHT CO.

Case No. 3:13-cv-115.

HOBART CORPORTION, et al., Plaintiffs, v. THE DAYTON POWER & LIGHT CO., et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, S.D. Ohio, Western Division.

August 24, 2017.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 42 U.S.C. § 6901
Cause: 42 U.S.C. § 6901 Environmental Cleanup Expenses
Nature of Suit: 893 Environmental Matters
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Hobart Corporation, Plaintiff, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice.

Hobart Corporation, Plaintiff, represented by David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Plaintiff, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer, Toby K. Henderson , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Plaintiff, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer, Toby K. Henderson , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Defendant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Sommer Lynn Sheely , Bricker & Eckler LLP, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell, E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Defendant, represented by E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

City of Dayton, Ohio, Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Defendant, represented by Daniel E. Izenson , Keating Muething & Klekamp, Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, pro hac vice, Michael Thomas Cappel , Keating Muething & Klekamp, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, pro hac vice, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, pro hac vice & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP, pro hac vice & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Defendant, represented by Shane A. Farolino , Roetzel & Andress, Leighann Kathryn Fink & Stephen W. Funk , Roetzel & Andress.

DAP Products, Inc., Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Flowserve Corporation, Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

Harris Corporation, Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP, pro hac vice & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

YP Advertising and Publishing LLC, Defendant, represented by Orla Ellis Collier, III , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP.

P-Americas, LLC, Defendant, represented by Andrew W. Knuth, III , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, Steven A. Luxton , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP & William Brad Nes , pro hac vice.

PPG Industries, Inc., Defendant, represented by Joseph Jude Golian , Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C. & Peter T. Stinson , Dickie McCamey & Chilcote, P.C., pro hac vice.

Sherwin-Williams Company, Defendant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Standard Register Company, Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

University of Dayton, Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Fickert Devco Inc, Defendant, represented by David Philip Pierce , Coolidge Wall Co., L.P.A..

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

Newmark LLC, Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley .

Pharmacia LLC, a Delaware Limited Liability Company, Defendant, represented by James A. Bax , Boyle Brasher LLC, Allison Schaper , Polsinell PC, pro hac vice & Jane E. Fedder , Polsinelli PC, pro hac vice.

Dayton Power and Light Company, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler.

Sherwin-Williams Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Flowserve Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

University of Dayton, Counter Claimant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Standard Register Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Counter Claimant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

DAP Products, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Fickert Devco Inc, Counter Claimant, represented by David Philip Pierce , Coolidge Wall Co., L.P.A..

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP, pro hac vice, Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP, pro hac vice & Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, pro hac vice, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, pro hac vice, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, pro hac vice & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

P-Americas, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Andrew W. Knuth, III , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, Steven A. Luxton , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP & William Brad Nes .

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Dayton Board of Education, Counter Claimant, represented by Brian L. Wildermuth , Subashi & Wildermuth & Andrew Ethan Rudloff , The Greene Town Center.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

City of Dayton, Ohio, Counter Claimant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, pro hac vice, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP, pro hac vice, Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP, pro hac vice & Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Donald Jeffrey Ireland , Faruki Ireland & Cox PLL, Erin Rhinehart , Faruki Ireland & Cox PPL, Robert Perry Bartlett, Jr. , Faruki Ireland & Cox & Christopher Clayton Hollon , Faruki Ireland & Cox P.L.L..

Day International Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Ann M. Hunt , McDonald Hopkins, Erin K. Walsh , McDonald Hopkins, LLC, Jerome W. Cook , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP & Theodore J. Esborn , McDonald Hopkins Co LPA.

Dayton Board of Education, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian L. Wildermuth , Subashi & Wildermuth & Andrew Ethan Rudloff , The Greene Town Center.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Fickert Devco Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David Philip Pierce , Coolidge Wall Co., L.P.A..

Flowserve Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Cross Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

GlaxoSmithKline LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Harris Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Hewitt Soap Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

Newmark LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley .

P-Americas, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew W. Knuth, III , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, Steven A. Luxton , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP & William Brad Nes .

PPG Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph Jude Golian , Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C. & Peter T. Stinson , Dickie McCamey & Chilcote, P.C..

Pharmacia LLC, a Delaware Limited Liability Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James A. Bax , Boyle Brasher LLC, Allison Schaper , Polsinell PC & Jane E. Fedder , Polsinelli PC.

Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Standard Register Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

State Of Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Lee Stokes , Office of the Ohio Attorney General.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States Department of Energy, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

University of Dayton, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

YP Advertising and Publishing LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Orla Ellis Collier, III , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP.

A.E. Fickert, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Thomas Cappel , Keating Muething & Klekamp & Brian M. Babb .

Bradford Soap International, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Cargill, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Cintas Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

City of Dayton, Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

DAP Products, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Counter Claimant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Counter Claimant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

City of Dayton, Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Donald Jeffrey Ireland , Faruki Ireland & Cox PLL, Erin Rhinehart , Faruki Ireland & Cox PPL, Robert Perry Bartlett, Jr. , Faruki Ireland & Cox & Christopher Clayton Hollon , Faruki Ireland & Cox P.L.L..

DAP Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Flowserve Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Cross Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

Harris Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Hobart Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Cross Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

NCR Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Pharmacia LLC, a Delaware Limited Liability Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James A. Bax , Boyle Brasher LLC, Allison Schaper , Polsinell PC & Jane E. Fedder , Polsinelli PC.

Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Counter Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

City of Dayton, Ohio, Counter Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Counter Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Counter Defendant, represented by Donald Jeffrey Ireland , Faruki Ireland & Cox PLL, Erin Rhinehart , Faruki Ireland & Cox PPL, Robert Perry Bartlett, Jr. , Faruki Ireland & Cox & Christopher Clayton Hollon , Faruki Ireland & Cox P.L.L..

DAP Products, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Flowserve Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Counter Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

Harris Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Counter Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Sherwin-Williams Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Cargill, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Cintas Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

City of Dayton, Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Donald Jeffrey Ireland , Faruki Ireland & Cox PLL, Erin Rhinehart , Faruki Ireland & Cox PPL, Robert Perry Bartlett, Jr. , Faruki Ireland & Cox & Christopher Clayton Hollon , Faruki Ireland & Cox P.L.L..

DAP Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Day International Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Ann M. Hunt , McDonald Hopkins, Erin K. Walsh , McDonald Hopkins, LLC, Jerome W. Cook , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP & Theodore J. Esborn , McDonald Hopkins Co LPA.

Dayton Board of Education, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian L. Wildermuth , Subashi & Wildermuth & Andrew Ethan Rudloff , The Greene Town Center.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Fickert Devco Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David Philip Pierce , Coolidge Wall Co., L.P.A..

Flowserve Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Cross Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

GlaxoSmithKline LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Harris Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Hewitt Soap Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

P-Americas, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew W. Knuth, III , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, Steven A. Luxton , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP & William Brad Nes .

PPG Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph Jude Golian , Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C. & Peter T. Stinson , Dickie McCamey & Chilcote, P.C..

Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Standard Register Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

State Of Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Lee Stokes , Office of the Ohio Attorney General.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States Department of Energy, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

University of Dayton, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

YP Advertising and Publishing LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Orla Ellis Collier, III , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP.

A.E. Fickert, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Thomas Cappel , Keating Muething & Klekamp & Brian M. Babb .

Bradford Soap International, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Cargill, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Cintas Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

City of Dayton, Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Donald Jeffrey Ireland , Faruki Ireland & Cox PLL, Erin Rhinehart , Faruki Ireland & Cox PPL, Robert Perry Bartlett, Jr. , Faruki Ireland & Cox & Christopher Clayton Hollon , Faruki Ireland & Cox P.L.L..

DAP Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Day International Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Ann M. Hunt , McDonald Hopkins, Erin K. Walsh , McDonald Hopkins, LLC, Jerome W. Cook , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP & Theodore J. Esborn , McDonald Hopkins Co LPA.

Dayton Board of Education, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian L. Wildermuth , Subashi & Wildermuth & Andrew Ethan Rudloff , The Greene Town Center.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Fickert Devco Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David Philip Pierce , Coolidge Wall Co., L.P.A..

Flowserve Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Cross Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

GlaxoSmithKline LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Harris Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Hewitt Soap Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

P-Americas, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew W. Knuth, III , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, Steven A. Luxton , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP & William Brad Nes .

PPG Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph Jude Golian , Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C. & Peter T. Stinson , Dickie McCamey & Chilcote, P.C..

Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Standard Register Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

State Of Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Lee Stokes , Office of the Ohio Attorney General.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States Department of Energy, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

University of Dayton, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

YP Advertising and Publishing LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Orla Ellis Collier, III , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP.

A.E. Fickert, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Thomas Cappel , Keating Muething & Klekamp & Brian M. Babb .

Bradford Soap International, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Hobart Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Sherwin-Williams Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Dayton Power and Light Company, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

Bradford Soap International, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Cargill, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Cintas Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

City of Dayton, Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Shane A. Farolino , Roetzel & Andress.

DAP Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Day International Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Ann M. Hunt , McDonald Hopkins, Erin K. Walsh , McDonald Hopkins, LLC, Jerome W. Cook , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP & Theodore J. Esborn , McDonald Hopkins Co LPA.

Dayton Board of Education, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian L. Wildermuth , Subashi & Wildermuth & Andrew Ethan Rudloff , The Greene Town Center.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Sommer Lynn Sheely , Bricker & Eckler LLP, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Fickert Devco Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David Philip Pierce , Coolidge Wall Co., L.P.A..

Flowserve Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Cross Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

GlaxoSmithKline LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Harris Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Hewitt Soap Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

P-Americas, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew W. Knuth, III , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, Steven A. Luxton , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP & William Brad Nes .

PPG Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph Jude Golian , Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C. & Peter T. Stinson , Dickie McCamey & Chilcote, P.C..

Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Standard Register Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

State Of Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Lee Stokes , Office of the Ohio Attorney General.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States Department of Energy, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

University of Dayton, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

YP Advertising and Publishing LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Orla Ellis Collier, III , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP.

A.E. Fickert, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Thomas Cappel , Keating Muething & Klekamp & Brian M. Babb .

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

City of Dayton, Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Shane A. Farolino , Roetzel & Andress.

DAP Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Sommer Lynn Sheely , Bricker & Eckler LLP, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Flowserve Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Cross Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

Harris Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Cross Claimant, represented by Shane A. Farolino , Roetzel & Andress.

Bradford Soap International, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Cargill, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Cintas Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

City of Dayton, Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Shane A. Farolino , Roetzel & Andress.

DAP Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Day International Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Ann M. Hunt , McDonald Hopkins, Erin K. Walsh , McDonald Hopkins, LLC, Jerome W. Cook , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP & Theodore J. Esborn , McDonald Hopkins Co LPA.

Dayton Board of Education, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian L. Wildermuth , Subashi & Wildermuth & Andrew Ethan Rudloff , The Greene Town Center.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Sommer Lynn Sheely , Bricker & Eckler LLP, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Fickert Devco Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David Philip Pierce , Coolidge Wall Co., L.P.A..

Flowserve Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Cross Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

GlaxoSmithKline LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Harris Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Hewitt Soap Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

P-Americas, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew W. Knuth, III , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, Steven A. Luxton , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP & William Brad Nes .

PPG Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph Jude Golian , Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C. & Peter T. Stinson , Dickie McCamey & Chilcote, P.C..

Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Standard Register Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

State Of Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Lee Stokes , Office of the Ohio Attorney General.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States Department of Energy, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

University of Dayton, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

YP Advertising and Publishing LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Orla Ellis Collier, III , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP.

A.E. Fickert, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Thomas Cappel , Keating Muething & Klekamp & Brian M. Babb .

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

Bradford Soap International, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Cargill, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Cintas Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

City of Dayton, Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Shane A. Farolino , Roetzel & Andress.

DAP Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Day International Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Ann M. Hunt , McDonald Hopkins, Erin K. Walsh , McDonald Hopkins, LLC, Jerome W. Cook , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP & Theodore J. Esborn , McDonald Hopkins Co LPA.

Dayton Board of Education, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian L. Wildermuth , Subashi & Wildermuth & Andrew Ethan Rudloff , The Greene Town Center.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Sommer Lynn Sheely , Bricker & Eckler LLP, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Fickert Devco Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David Philip Pierce , Coolidge Wall Co., L.P.A..

Flowserve Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Cross Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

GlaxoSmithKline LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Harris Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Hewitt Soap Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

P-Americas, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew W. Knuth, III , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, Steven A. Luxton , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP & William Brad Nes .

PPG Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph Jude Golian , Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C. & Peter T. Stinson , Dickie McCamey & Chilcote, P.C..

Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Standard Register Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

State Of Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Lee Stokes , Office of the Ohio Attorney General.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States Department of Energy, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

University of Dayton, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

YP Advertising and Publishing LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Orla Ellis Collier, III , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP.

A.E. Fickert, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Thomas Cappel , Keating Muething & Klekamp & Brian M. Babb .

Harris Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

City of Dayton, Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Shane A. Farolino , Roetzel & Andress.

DAP Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Sommer Lynn Sheely , Bricker & Eckler LLP, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Flowserve Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Cross Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

A.E. Fickert, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Thomas Cappel , Keating Muething & Klekamp & Brian M. Babb .

Bradford Soap International, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Cargill, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Cintas Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

City of Dayton, Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Shane A. Farolino , Roetzel & Andress.

DAP Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Day International Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Ann M. Hunt , McDonald Hopkins, Erin K. Walsh , McDonald Hopkins, LLC, Jerome W. Cook , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP & Theodore J. Esborn , McDonald Hopkins Co LPA.

Dayton Board of Education, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian L. Wildermuth , Subashi & Wildermuth & Andrew Ethan Rudloff , The Greene Town Center.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Sommer Lynn Sheely , Bricker & Eckler LLP, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Fickert Devco Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David Philip Pierce , Coolidge Wall Co., L.P.A..

Flowserve Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Cross Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

GlaxoSmithKline LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Harris Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Hewitt Soap Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

P-Americas, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew W. Knuth, III , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, Steven A. Luxton , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP & William Brad Nes .

PPG Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph Jude Golian , Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C. & Peter T. Stinson , Dickie McCamey & Chilcote, P.C..

Standard Register Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

State Of Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Lee Stokes , Office of the Ohio Attorney General.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States Department of Energy, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

University of Dayton, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

YP Advertising and Publishing LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Orla Ellis Collier, III , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP.

Flowserve Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Kelsey-Hayes Company, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

NCR Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by David C. Ahlstrom , Law Offices, David E. Romine , Langsam Stevens, Silver & Hollaender, LLP, pro hac vice, Jennifer Graham Meyer , Langsam Stevens Silver & Hollaender, LLP, Larry Silver , Langsam, Stevens, Silver & Hollaender LLP, pro hac vice, Scott Sander Davies , Sebaly, Shillito, & Dyer & James Alan Dyer , Sebaly Shillito & Dyer.

Flowserve Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

DAP Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Sommer Lynn Sheely , Bricker & Eckler LLP, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Cross Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

Harris Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Cross Claimant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

A.E. Fickert, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Thomas Cappel , Keating Muething & Klekamp & Brian M. Babb .

Bradford Soap International, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Cargill, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Cintas Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

City of Dayton, Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP, pro hac vice.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Shane A. Farolino , Roetzel & Andress.

DAP Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Day International Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Ann M. Hunt , McDonald Hopkins, Erin K. Walsh , McDonald Hopkins, LLC, Jerome W. Cook , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP & Theodore J. Esborn , McDonald Hopkins Co LPA.

Dayton Board of Education, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian L. Wildermuth , Subashi & Wildermuth & Andrew Ethan Rudloff , The Greene Town Center.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Sommer Lynn Sheely , Bricker & Eckler LLP, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Fickert Devco Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David Philip Pierce , Coolidge Wall Co., L.P.A..

Flowserve Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Cross Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

GlaxoSmithKline LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Harris Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Hewitt Soap Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

P-Americas, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew W. Knuth, III , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, Steven A. Luxton , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP & William Brad Nes .

PPG Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph Jude Golian , Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C. & Peter T. Stinson , Dickie McCamey & Chilcote, P.C..

Reynolds and Reynolds Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Duke K. McCall, III , Bingham McCutchen LLP, James Joseph Dragna , Bingham McCutchen LLP, Jennifer L. Hurley McGay , Bingham McCutchen LLP & David Karl Brown , Bingham McCutchen LLP.

Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Standard Register Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

State Of Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Lee Stokes , Office of the Ohio Attorney General.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States Department of Energy, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

University of Dayton, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

YP Advertising and Publishing LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Orla Ellis Collier, III , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Cross Claimant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Bradford Soap International, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Bridgestone Firestone Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David T. Moss , Hanna Campbell & Powell & William Wick , Wactor and Wick, LLP, pro hac vice.

Cargill, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

Cintas Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

City of Dayton, Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by John C. Musto , City Attorney's Office.

Coca-Cola Refreshments USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leah J. Knowlton , Taylor English Duma LLP, Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Donald P. Boyle , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP, LeeAnn Jones , TAYLOR ENGLISH DUMA LLP & Keisha Oldacre Coleman , Ballard Spahr LLP.

Conagra Grocery Products Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John A. Andreasen , McGrath North Mullin & Kratz, PC LLP & Suzanne M. Fisher .

Cox Media Group Ohio Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Shane A. Farolino , Roetzel & Andress.

DAP Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by William E. Coughlin , Calfee Halter & Griswold.

Day International Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Ann M. Hunt , McDonald Hopkins, Erin K. Walsh , McDonald Hopkins, LLC, Jerome W. Cook , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP & Theodore J. Esborn , McDonald Hopkins Co LPA.

Dayton Board of Education, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian L. Wildermuth , Subashi & Wildermuth & Andrew Ethan Rudloff , The Greene Town Center.

Dayton Industrial Drum, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Shannon Lesley Costello , Coolidge Wall Womsley & Lombard.

Dayton Power and Light Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Drew H. Campbell , Bricker & Eckler, Sommer Lynn Sheely , Bricker & Eckler LLP, Daniel E. Gerken , Bricker & Eckler, LLP & Frank Leslie Merrill , Bricker & Eckler.

Fickert Devco Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by David Philip Pierce , Coolidge Wall Co., L.P.A..

Flowserve Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Franklin Iron & Metal Corp, Cross Defendant, represented by Laura Irene Hillerich , Crehan & Thumann, LLC & Robert Joseph Thumann , Crehan & Thumann, LLC.

GlaxoSmithKline LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Harris Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Bonni Fine Kaufman , Holland & Knight LLP & Robert Brent Sherwood , Goldenberg Schneider.

Hewitt Soap Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Jack Allen Van Kley & Christopher Allen Walker .

La Mirada Products Co., Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Kim Kenneth Burke , Taft Stettinius & Hollister & E. Chase Dressman , Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP.

P-Americas, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew W. Knuth, III , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, Steven A. Luxton , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP & William Brad Nes .

PPG Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph Jude Golian , Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C. & Peter T. Stinson , Dickie McCamey & Chilcote, P.C..

Pharmacia LLC, a Delaware Limited Liability Company, Cross Defendant, represented by James A. Bax , Boyle Brasher LLC, Allison Schaper , Polsinell PC & Jane E. Fedder , Polsinelli PC.

Reynolds and Reynolds Company, Cross Defendant, represented by David Karl Brown , Bingham McCutchen LLP, Duke K. McCall, III , Bingham McCutchen LLP, James Joseph Dragna , Bingham McCutchen LLP & Jennifer L. Hurley McGay , Bingham McCutchen LLP.

Sherwin-Williams Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Robert H. Eddy , Shumaker Loop & Kendrick, LLP.

Standard Register Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

State Of Ohio, Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Lee Stokes , Office of the Ohio Attorney General.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States Department of Energy, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Paul Dunsky , United States Attorney's Office.

University of Dayton, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Neal Haughey , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Thaddeus Henderson Driscoll , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Valley Asphalt Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph P. Koncelik & Melissa Z. Kelly , Tucker Ellis LLP.

Waste Management of Ohio, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael D. Dortch , Kravitz, Brown & Dortch LLC, Jennifer Nijman , Nijman Franzetti, LLP & Kristen Gale , Nijman Franzetti, LLP.

YP Advertising and Publishing LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Orla Ellis Collier, III , Benesch Friedlander Coplan & Aronoff LLP.

A.E. Fickert, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael Thomas Cappel , Keating Muething & Klekamp & Brian M. Babb .


DECISION AND ENTRY SETTING FORTH RULINGS FOLLOWING IN CAMERA REVIEW OF VARIOUS DISCOVERY DOCUMENTS

On July 14, 2017, the Court issued a Decision and Entry ruling on several discovery-related motions, and directed counsel to submit several documents for an in camera review. Doc. #701.

...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases