PERSHING LLC v. KIEBACH

Civil Action No. 14-2549, No. c/w 16-15220.

PERSHING LLC, v. THOMAS KIEBACH ET AL., SECTION I.

United States District Court, E.D. Louisiana.

April 6, 2017.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 09 U.S.C. § 1
Cause: 09 U.S.C. § 1 U.S. Arbitration Act
Nature of Suit: 896 Other Statutes: Arbitration
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Pershing LLC, Plaintiff, represented by Lana Davis Crump , Kean Miller.

Pershing LLC, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Howard Lowe , Kean Miller LLP, Jeffrey L. Chapman , McGuire Woods LLP, pro hac vice, Katie Deranger Bell , Kean Miller & Thomas M. Farrell , McGuire Woods, LLP, pro hac vice.

Thomas Kiebach, represented by Executory of his estate, Thomas J. Moran; Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Thomas Kiebach, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Mamie Helen Baumann, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Joseph Becker, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

AmeriTrust Corporation, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Terence Beven, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Elizabeth Beven, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Linda Boyd, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Jerry Burris, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Anita Carter, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Jim Chisholm, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Patrick Comeaux, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Kevin Courville, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Monica Courville, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Kenneth Daniel, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Carolyn Daniel, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

William Dawson, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Fred Demarest, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Cindy Dore, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Leah Farr, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Martin Fischer, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Kendall Forbes, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

May Giambrone, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Lynn Gildersleeve, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Jon Goeckel, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Loretta Goeckel, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Jason Graham, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Robert Graham, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Charles Gruenwald, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Patrick Haney, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Charles Hart, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Patsy Hebert, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Donald Kenaley, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Don Landers, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Daniel Landry, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Dianna Landry, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Merrill LaPlante, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Ruth Lessing, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Gregory Magee, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Ronald Marston, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Jean Anne Mayhall, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Microchip ID Systems Pension Fund, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Jacqueline Millet, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Arthur Ordoyne, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Lonnie Ordoyne, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Bennie O'Rear, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Mary Ann Paternostro, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Lynn Philippe, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Power Packing Co. Inc. Agency, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Richard Rathbone, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

James Roland, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Susan Roland, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Jessie Romig, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Julie Savoy, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Robert Schwendimann, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Bruce Smith, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Harriet Smith, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Robert Smith, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Rodney Starkey, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

James Stegall, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Carol Stegall, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Walter Stone, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Terry Tarver, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Lewis Unglesby, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Gail Unglesby, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

John Wade, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Charles White, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Kenneth Wilkewitz, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Stephen Wilson, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Martha Witmer, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Sharon Witmer, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Bobby Nix, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Margaret Nix, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Kathleen Melilli, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Robert Gildersleeve, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Ralph D'Amore, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Mallory D'Amore, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Royce Beauchamp, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Roderick Danielson, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Wallace DeHay, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Tommy Gentry, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Cindy Gentry, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Gordon Gill, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Nancy Gill, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Barney Hallman, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

John Hutcherson, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Kirk Oliver, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Mary Oliver, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC & Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC.

Pershing LLC, Consol Defendant, represented by Lana Davis Crump , Kean Miller, Amanda Howard Lowe , Kean Miller LLP, Jeffrey L. Chapman , McGuire Woods LLP, pro hac vice, Katie Deranger Bell , Kean Miller & Thomas M. Farrell , McGuire Woods, LLP, pro hac vice.

Thomas Kiebach, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Marcel Dumestre, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Margaret Dumestre, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Mamie Helen Baumann, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Joseph Becker, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

AmeriTrust Corporation, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC, John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd, Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Terence Beven, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Linda Boyd, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jerry Burris, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Anita Carter, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jim Chisholm, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Patrick Comeaux, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Kevin Courville, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Monica Courville, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Carolyn Daniel, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Kenneth Daniel, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

William Dawson, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Fred Demarest, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Cindy Dore, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Leah Farr, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Martin Fischer, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Kendall Forbes, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

May Giambrone, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Lynn Gildersleeve, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jon Goeckel, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Loretta Goeckel, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jason Graham, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Robert Graham, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Charles Gruenwald, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Patrick Haney, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Charles Hart, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Patsy Hebert, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Donald Kenaley, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Don Landers, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Daniel Landry, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Dianna Landry, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Merrill LaPlante, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Ruth Lessing, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Gregory Magee, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Ronald Marston, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

AmeriTrust Corporation, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jean Anne Mayhall, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Microchip ID Systems Pension Fund, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jacqueline Millet, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Arthur Ordoyne, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Lonnie Ordoyne, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Bennie O'Rear, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Claudia O'Rear, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Mary Ann Paternostro, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Lynn Philippe, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Power Packing Co. Inc. Agency, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Richard Rathbone, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

James Roland, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Susan Roland, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jessie Romig, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Julie Savoy, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Robert Schwendimann, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Bruce Smith, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

G. Rogers Smith, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Harriet Smith, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Robert Smith, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Rodney Starkey, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

James Stegall, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Carol Stegall, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Walter Bruce Stone, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Terry Tarver, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Lewis Unglesby, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Gail Unglesby, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

John Wade, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Charles White, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Kenneth Wilkewitz, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Stephen Wilson, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Martha Witmer, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Sharon Witmer, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Bobby Nix, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Margaret Nix, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Kathleen Melilli, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Robert Gildersleeve, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Mallory D'Amore, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Ralph D'Amore, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Royce Beauchamp, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Roderick Danielson, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Wallace DeHay, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Cindy Gentry, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Tommy Gentry, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Gordon Gill, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Nancy Gill, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Barney Hallman, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

John Hutcherson, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Kirk Oliver, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Mary Oliver, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Monroe Rathbone, Defendant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Donald Kenaley, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Patsy Hebert, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

James Stegall, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Kirk Oliver, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Martin Fischer, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Kenneth Wilkewitz, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Terence Beven, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Loretta Goeckel, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Ralph D'Amore, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Fred Demarest, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Stephen Wilson, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Kenneth Daniel, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Microchip ID Systems Pension Fund, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jessie Romig, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Sharon Witmer, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jason Graham, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Cindy Gentry, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Robert Schwendimann, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Robert Smith, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Leah Farr, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Monroe Rathbone, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

John Hutcherson, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Anita Carter, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Charles Hart, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Don Landers, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jim Chisholm, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Mary Oliver, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Robert Gildersleeve, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

G. Rogers Smith, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Claudia O'Rear, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Nancy Gill, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Kathleen Melilli, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Lonnie Ordoyne, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Walter Bruce Stone, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Charles Gruenwald, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Lynn Philippe, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Ruth Lessing, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Carol Stegall, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Bruce Smith, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Ronald Marston, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Patrick Comeaux, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Carolyn Daniel, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Richard Rathbone, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Royce Beauchamp, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Harriet Smith, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Julie Savoy, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Martha Witmer, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Terry Tarver, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jacqueline Millet, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Margaret Nix, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Gordon Gill, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Cindy Dore, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Rodney Starkey, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Susan Roland, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Lewis Unglesby, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Charles White, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Gail Unglesby, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

William Dawson, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Margaret Dumestre, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Barney Hallman, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Roderick Danielson, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jon Goeckel, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Robert Graham, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Wallace DeHay, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Gregory Magee, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Bobby Nix, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Monica Courville, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

John Wade, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Mary Ann Paternostro, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Lynn Gildersleeve, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Marcel Dumestre, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

James Roland, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Mallory D'Amore, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Kendall Forbes, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

AmeriTrust Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Arthur Ordoyne, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

May Giambrone, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Kevin Courville, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Patrick Haney, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

AmeriTrust Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Tommy Gentry, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Mamie Helen Baumann, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Daniel Landry, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Power Packing Co. Inc. Agency, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jerry Burris, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Bennie O'Rear, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Linda Boyd, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Merrill LaPlante, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Joseph Becker, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Thomas Kiebach, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Dianna Landry, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Jean Anne Mayhall, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

AmeriTrust Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Phillip W. Preis , Preis Gordon, APLC, Caroline Graham Graham , Preis Gordon, APLC, Charles Malcolm Gordon , Preis Gordon, APLC, Crystal DiBenedetto Burkhalter , Preis Gordon, APLC, Jennifer Rae Dietz , Preis Gordon, APLC & John N. Grinton , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Pershing LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Lana Davis Crump , Kean Miller, Amanda Howard Lowe , Kean Miller LLP, Jeffrey L. Chapman , McGuire Woods LLP, Katie Deranger Bell , Kean Miller & Thomas M. Farrell , McGuire Woods, LLP.


ORDER AND REASONS

I.

In this consolidated action, Pershing LLC seeks to confirm an arbitration panel's decision in its favor. The defendants, "Louisiana Retirees," Dr. Thomas J. Kiebach, et al., seek to vacate the arbitration panel's decision. Since the lawsuits were consolidated...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases