CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYD'S v. NATIONAL RAILROAD PASSENGER CORPORATION

No. 14-CV-4717 (FB).

CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS at LLOYD'S, et al., Plaintiffs, v. NATIONAL RAILROAD PASSENGER CORPORATION, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, E.D. New York.

November 30, 2016.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 28 U.S.C. § 2201
Cause: 28 U.S.C. § 2201 Declaratory Judgement (Insurance)
Nature of Suit: 110 Insurance
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Peter Woodin, Special Master, represented by Peter H. Woodin , JAMS.

Certain Underwriters at Lloyds, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Co., Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company Of Winterthur, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company of Winterthur (No. 2 A/C), Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company of Winterthur (No. 3 A/C), Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Aegon NV, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

AG De 1830 Compagnie Belge D'Assurances Generales Incendie Accidents Et Risques Divers SA, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

American Home Insurance Company, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Amsterdan - London Verzekeering Maatschappij NV, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Ancon Insurance Company (UK) Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Argonaut Northwest Insurance Company, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Assicurazioni Generali SPA (UK Branch), Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Bishopsgate Insurance Company Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Britamco Pool, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

CNA Reinsurance Company, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

CNA Reinsurance Company Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Cornhill Insurance Company Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Credit De Namur, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Delta-Lloyd Non-Life Insurance Company Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Delta-Lloyd Schadeverzekering NV, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Stronghold Insurance Company Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC & Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC.

The Dominion Insurance Company Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC & Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Northwestern National Insurance Company, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC & Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Europeesche Verzekering Maatschappij Nv, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC & Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Excess Insurance Company Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC & Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Helvetia-accident Swiss Insurance Company (As Part of Gibbon "E" Group), Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC & Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Gresham Fire & Accident Insurance Society Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC & Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Gresham Insurance Society Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC & Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Harper Insurance Ltd F/k/a/Turegum Ins Co, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Instituto De Reasseguros Do Brasil (Irg) - London Branch, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Interlloyd Verzekering Maastschappij Nv, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Koning & Boeke Van 1819, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

La Belgique, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

L'assicurazioni D'Italia, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Le Assicurazioni D'Italia Spa, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Les Assurances Generales De France, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Les Proprietaires Reunis S.A. D. Assurances I.A.R.D., Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

L'Etoile, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

London & Edinbugh General Insurance Company, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

London and Edinburgh General Insurance Company Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Maas Lloyd Nv Schadeverzekeringsmaatschappu, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Mercator Algemene Verzekerings Maatschappu Nv, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

N.V. Rotterdamse Assurantiekas, N.V. Verz Mij De Noodern, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Namur Assurances du Credit, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

National Casualty Company, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

National Casualty Company of America Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Nissan Fire & Marine Insurance Company, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Noorholland Brandw, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Norwich Union Fire Insuarnce Socity Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Providential Insurance Company, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Rheinland Versicherungs Ag, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Royal Belge Sa, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Royal Nederland Schadeverzekering Nv, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Royale Belge Incendie Reassurances SA., Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Company, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

St Katherine Insurance Company PLC, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Taisho Marine & Fire Insurance Company Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Terra Nova Insurance Company, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

The Sumitomo Marine and Fire Insurance Company, Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Unionamerica Insurance Company Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Winterthur Swiss Insurance Company, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Wurttembergisch Feuerversicherrung AG, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Yasuda Fire & Marine Insurance Company(UK) Limited, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Diligentia, Plaintiff, represented by Aisha E. Bembry , Lewis Baach PLLC, Jessica Buckwalter , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC & Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC.

National RailRoad Passenger Corporation, Defendant, represented by Rhonda D. Orin , Anderson Kill & Olick LLP, Angela Singleton , Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, Daniel John Healy , Anderson Kill, LLP, Stephen D. Palley , Anderson Kill, LLP & Vivian Costandy Michael , Anderson Kill.

Allianz Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Anthony R. Gambardella , Rivkin Radler LLP, Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP, Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP & Robert A. Maloney , Rivkin Radler LLP.

American Home Assurance Company, Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Christopher Michael Quinlan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

American Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Anthony R. Gambardella , Rivkin Radler LLP, Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP, Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP & Robert A. Maloney , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Munich Reinsurance America, Inc., Defendant, represented by William Eugene Mcgrath, Jr. , Smith Stratton.

Argonaut Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Brian Michael Reid , Litchfield Cavo LLP, pro hac vice, Vincent J. Velardo , Litchfield Cavo LLP & Nicholas D. Butovich , Litchfield Cavo LLP.

Banco De Seguros Del Estado, Defendant, represented by Ernesto Palomo , Locke Lord LLP, Jeffrey Steven Kramer , Locke Lord LLP, Joseph N. Froehlich , Locke Lord LLP & Robert A. Badgley , Karbal Cohen Economou Silk Dunne LLC.

Continental Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by John S. Favate , Hardin Kundla McKeon & Poletto, Kathryn M. Frost , Elenius Frost & walsh, Arthur A. Povelones , Hardin, Kundla, McKeon & Poletto, P.A., George Richard Hardin , Hardin Kundla McKeon & Poletto, Greta Matzen , Elenius Frost & Walsh & William Patrick Lalor , Elenius Frost & Walsh.

Eurinco Allgemeine Versicherungs Aktiengesellschaft, Defendant, represented by Christopher Scott D'Angelo , Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads LLP.

Evanston Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Adam Daniel Krauss , Traub Lieberman Straus & Shrewsberry LLP.

First State Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Alison P. Baker , SHIPMAN AND GOODWIN LLP, Charles E. Leasure , Shipman & Goodwin LLP, pro hac vice & Katherine Hance , Shipman & Goodwin LLP.

Granite State Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Christopher Michael Quinlan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Insurance Company of The State of Pennsylvania, Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Christopher Michael Quinlan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Interstate Reinsurance Corporation, Defendant, represented by Anthony R. Gambardella , Rivkin Radler LLP, Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP, Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP & Robert A. Maloney , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Landmark Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Lexington Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Christopher Michael Quinlan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, PA, Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Christopher Michael Quinlan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Northbrook Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Anthony R. Gambardella , Rivkin Radler LLP, Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP, Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP & Robert A. Maloney , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Wausau International Underwriters, Defendant, represented by Claude N. Grammatico , Epstein, Gialleonardo, Frankini, Kristin S. Heres , Zelle Hofmann Voelbel & Mason LLP & Wm. Gerald McElroy, Jr. , Zelle LLP.

Yosemite Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Mark W. Zimmerman , Clausen Miller, Steven J. Fried , Clausen Miller PC & Elise D. Allen , Clausen Miller P.C..

Allstate Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Anthony R. Gambardella , Rivkin Radler LLP, Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP, Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP & Robert A. Maloney , Rivkin Radler LLP.

XL Insurance (Bermuda) Ltd, Defendant, represented by Whitney Morgan Smith , Cahill Gordon and Reindel.

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co., Defendant, represented by Claude N. Grammatico , Epstein, Gialleonardo, Frankini, Kristin S. Heres , Zelle Hofmann Voelbel & Mason LLP & Wm. Gerald McElroy, Jr. , Zelle LLP.

Certain London Market Insurance Companies, ThirdParty Defendant, Pro Se..

Munich Reinsurance America, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leah R. Bartlome , Smith Stratton Wise Heher & Brennan, LLP & William Eugene Mcgrath, Jr. , Smith Stratton.

Century Indemnity Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Leslie Davis , Crowell & Moring LLP, Anupama Prasad , Crowell & Moring LLP, pro hac vice, John N. Thomas , Crowell & Moring LLP & Michael J. Baughman , Cohn Baughman & Martin.

Stantec, Inc., Interested Party, represented by David J. Montag , Milber Makris Plousadis & Seiden, LLP.

National RailRoad Passenger Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Rhonda D. Orin , Anderson Kill & Olick LLP, Daniel John Healy , Anderson Kill, LLP & Vivian Costandy Michael , Anderson Kill.

Argonaut Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian Michael Reid , Litchfield Cavo LLP, pro hac vice & Nicholas D. Butovich , Litchfield Cavo LLP.

Landmark Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Continental Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Kathryn M. Frost , Elenius Frost & walsh.

National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, PA, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag & Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green.

Lexington Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag & Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green.

Yosemite Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven J. Fried , Clausen Miller PC.

Granite State Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag & Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green.

American Home Assurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag & Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green.

Insurance Company of The State of Pennsylvania, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

First State Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles E. Leasure , Shipman & Goodwin LLP.

National RailRoad Passenger Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Rhonda D. Orin , Anderson Kill & Olick LLP, Daniel John Healy , Anderson Kill, LLP & Vivian Costandy Michael , Anderson Kill.

AG De 1830 Compagnie Belge D'Assurances Generales Incendie Accidents Et Risques Divers SA, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Co., Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company Of Winterthur, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company of Winterthur (No. 2 A/C), Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company of Winterthur (No. 3 A/C), Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Aegon NV, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

American Home Insurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Amsterdan - London Verzekeering Maatschappij NV, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Ancon Insurance Company (UK) Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Argonaut Northwest Insurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Assicurazioni Generali SPA (UK Branch), Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Bishopsgate Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Britamco Pool, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

CNA Reinsurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

CNA Reinsurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Certain Underwriters at Lloyds, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Cornhill Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Credit De Namur, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Delta-Lloyd Non-Life Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Delta-Lloyd Schadeverzekering NV, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, pro hac vice, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

AG De 1830 Compagnie Belge D'Assurances Generales Incendie Accidents Et Risques Divers SA, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Credit De Namur, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

CNA Reinsurance Company Limited, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Delta-Lloyd Schadeverzekering NV, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Ancon Insurance Company (UK) Limited, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Argonaut Northwest Insurance Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Assicurazioni Generali SPA (UK Branch), Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

CNA Reinsurance Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Delta-Lloyd Non-Life Insurance Company Limited, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Co., Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Cornhill Insurance Company Limited, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Certain Underwriters at Lloyds, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Britamco Pool, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Bishopsgate Insurance Company Limited, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Aegon NV, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company Of Winterthur, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Amsterdan - London Verzekeering Maatschappij NV, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

American Home Insurance Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company of Winterthur (No. 2 A/C), Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company of Winterthur (No. 3 A/C), Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

American Home Assurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag & Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green.

Argonaut Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian Michael Reid , Litchfield Cavo LLP, pro hac vice & Nicholas D. Butovich , Litchfield Cavo LLP.

Astra S.A.Insurance and Reinsurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by David Leiter Ferstendig , Breindel & Ferstendig P.C..

Banco De Seguros Del Estado, Cross Defendant, represented by Ernesto Palomo , Locke Lord LLP, Jeffrey Steven Kramer , Locke Lord LLP, Joseph N. Froehlich , Locke Lord LLP & Robert A. Badgley , Karbal Cohen Economou Silk Dunne LLC.

Eurinco Allgemeine Versicherungs Aktiengesellschaft, Cross Defendant, represented by Christopher Scott D'Angelo , Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads LLP.

First State Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles E. Leasure , Shipman & Goodwin LLP & Katherine Hance , Shipman & Goodwin LLP.

Granite State Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag & Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green.

Insurance Company of The State of Pennsylvania, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Landmark Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green.

Lexington Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

National RailRoad Passenger Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Rhonda D. Orin , Anderson Kill & Olick LLP, Daniel John Healy , Anderson Kill, LLP & Vivian Costandy Michael , Anderson Kill.

National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, PA, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Railroad Association Insurance Limited, Cross Defendant, represented by Thorn Rosenthal , Cahill Gordon & Reindel, LLP.

The Hartford Accident and Indemnity Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Stanley A. Camhi , Jaspan Schlesinger LLP & Katherine Hance , Shipman & Goodwin LLP.

Wausau International Underwriters, Cross Defendant, represented by Claude N. Grammatico , Epstein, Gialleonardo, Frankini & Kristin S. Heres , Zelle Hofmann Voelbel & Mason LLP.

XL Insurance (Bermuda) Ltd, Cross Defendant, represented by Whitney Morgan Smith , Cahill Gordon and Reindel.

Yosemite Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven J. Fried , Clausen Miller PC.

First State Insurance Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Charles E. Leasure , Shipman & Goodwin LLP & Katherine Hance , Shipman & Goodwin LLP.

Landmark Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, PA, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Wausau International Underwriters, Cross Defendant, represented by Claude N. Grammatico , Epstein, Gialleonardo, Frankini & Kristin S. Heres , Zelle Hofmann Voelbel & Mason LLP.

American Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP & Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP.

American Home Assurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

National RailRoad Passenger Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Rhonda D. Orin , Anderson Kill & Olick LLP, Angela Singleton , Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, Daniel John Healy , Anderson Kill, LLP & Vivian Costandy Michael , Anderson Kill.

Argonaut Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian Michael Reid , Litchfield Cavo LLP, pro hac vice, Vincent J. Velardo , Litchfield Cavo LLP & Nicholas D. Butovich , Litchfield Cavo LLP.

Continental Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Kathryn M. Frost , Elenius Frost & walsh & William Patrick Lalor , Elenius Frost & Walsh.

Eurinco Allgemeine Versicherungs Aktiengesellschaft, Cross Defendant, represented by Christopher Scott D'Angelo , Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads LLP.

Interstate Reinsurance Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP & Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Lexington Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Allstate Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP & Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Yosemite Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven J. Fried , Clausen Miller PC.

Banco De Seguros Del Estado, Cross Defendant, represented by Ernesto Palomo , Locke Lord LLP, Jeffrey Steven Kramer , Locke Lord LLP, Joseph N. Froehlich , Locke Lord LLP & Robert A. Badgley , Karbal Cohen Economou Silk Dunne LLC.

Northbrook Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP & Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Allianz Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP & Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Granite State Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Claude N. Grammatico , Epstein, Gialleonardo, Frankini, Kristin S. Heres , Zelle Hofmann Voelbel & Mason LLP & Wm. Gerald McElroy, Jr. , Zelle LLP.

Insurance Company of The State of Pennsylvania, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

First State Insurance Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Charles E. Leasure , Shipman & Goodwin LLP & Katherine Hance , Shipman & Goodwin LLP.

AG De 1830 Compagnie Belge D'Assurances Generales Incendie Accidents Et Risques Divers SA, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Co., Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company Of Winterthur, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company of Winterthur (No. 2 A/C), Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company of Winterthur (No. 3 A/C), Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Aegon NV, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

American Home Insurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Amsterdan - London Verzekeering Maatschappij NV, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Ancon Insurance Company (UK) Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Argonaut Northwest Insurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Assicurazioni Generali SPA (UK Branch), Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Bishopsgate Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Britamco Pool, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

CNA Reinsurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

CNA Reinsurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Certain Underwriters at Lloyds, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Cornhill Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Credit De Namur, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Delta-Lloyd Non-Life Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Delta-Lloyd Schadeverzekering NV, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Stronghold Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC.

The Dominion Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC.

National RailRoad Passenger Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Rhonda D. Orin , Anderson Kill & Olick LLP, Angela Singleton , Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, Daniel John Healy , Anderson Kill, LLP & Vivian Costandy Michael , Anderson Kill.

Landmark Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Century Indemnity Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anupama Prasad , Crowell & Moring LLP, pro hac vice & John N. Thomas , Crowell & Moring LLP.

National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, PA, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Wausau International Underwriters, Cross Defendant, represented by Claude N. Grammatico , Epstein, Gialleonardo, Frankini & Kristin S. Heres , Zelle Hofmann Voelbel & Mason LLP.

American Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP & Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP.

American Home Assurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

First State Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Charles E. Leasure , Shipman & Goodwin LLP & Katherine Hance , Shipman & Goodwin LLP.

Argonaut Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian Michael Reid , Litchfield Cavo LLP, pro hac vice, Vincent J. Velardo , Litchfield Cavo LLP & Nicholas D. Butovich , Litchfield Cavo LLP.

Munich Reinsurance America, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by William Eugene Mcgrath, Jr. , Smith Stratton.

Continental Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Kathryn M. Frost , Elenius Frost & walsh & William Patrick Lalor , Elenius Frost & Walsh.

Interstate Reinsurance Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP & Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Lexington Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Allstate Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP & Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Yosemite Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Steven J. Fried , Clausen Miller PC.

Allianz Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP & Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Granite State Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Claude N. Grammatico , Epstein, Gialleonardo, Frankini & Kristin S. Heres , Zelle Hofmann Voelbel & Mason LLP.

Insurance Company of The State of Pennsylvania, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green, Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C. & Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC.

National RailRoad Passenger Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Rhonda D. Orin , Anderson Kill & Olick LLP, Angela Singleton , Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, Daniel John Healy , Anderson Kill, LLP & Vivian Costandy Michael , Anderson Kill.

AG De 1830 Compagnie Belge D'Assurances Generales Incendie Accidents Et Risques Divers SA, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Co., Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company Of Winterthur, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company of Winterthur (No. 2 A/C), Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company of Winterthur (No. 3 A/C), Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Aegon NV, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

American Home Insurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Amsterdan - London Verzekeering Maatschappij NV, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Ancon Insurance Company (UK) Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Argonaut Northwest Insurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Assicurazioni Generali SPA (UK Branch), Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Bishopsgate Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Britamco Pool, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

CNA Reinsurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

CNA Reinsurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Certain Underwriters at Lloyds, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Cornhill Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Credit De Namur, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Delta-Lloyd Non-Life Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Delta-Lloyd Schadeverzekering NV, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Stronghold Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC.

The Dominion Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC.

National RailRoad Passenger Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Rhonda D. Orin , Anderson Kill & Olick LLP, Angela Singleton , Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, Daniel John Healy , Anderson Kill, LLP & Vivian Costandy Michael , Anderson Kill.

Landmark Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, PA, Cross Defendant, represented by Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green.

American Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony R. Gambardella , Rivkin Radler LLP, Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP, Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP & Robert A. Maloney , Rivkin Radler LLP.

American Home Assurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

First State Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Alison P. Baker , SHIPMAN AND GOODWIN LLP, Charles E. Leasure , Shipman & Goodwin LLP & Katherine Hance , Shipman & Goodwin LLP.

National RailRoad Passenger Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Rhonda D. Orin , Anderson Kill & Olick LLP, Angela Singleton , Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, Daniel John Healy , Anderson Kill, LLP & Vivian Costandy Michael , Anderson Kill.

Continental Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John S. Favate , Hardin Kundla McKeon & Poletto, Kathryn M. Frost , Elenius Frost & walsh, Arthur A. Povelones , Hardin, Kundla, McKeon & Poletto, P.A., George Richard Hardin , Hardin Kundla McKeon & Poletto & William Patrick Lalor , Elenius Frost & Walsh.

Eurinco Allgemeine Versicherungs Aktiengesellschaft, Cross Defendant, represented by Christopher Scott D'Angelo , Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads LLP.

Interstate Reinsurance Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony R. Gambardella , Rivkin Radler LLP, Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP, Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP & Robert A. Maloney , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Yosemite Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Mark W. Zimmerman , Clausen Miller, Steven J. Fried , Clausen Miller PC & Elise D. Allen , Clausen Miller P.C..

Allianz Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony R. Gambardella , Rivkin Radler LLP, Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP, Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP & Robert A. Maloney , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Granite State Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Insurance Company of The State of Pennsylvania, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

XL Insurance (Bermuda) Ltd, Cross Defendant, represented by Whitney Morgan Smith , Cahill Gordon and Reindel.

Argonaut Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Brian Michael Reid , Litchfield Cavo LLP, Vincent J. Velardo , Litchfield Cavo LLP & Nicholas D. Butovich , Litchfield Cavo LLP.

Lexington Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Bryan , Jackson & Campbell, P.C., Steven Gary Adams , Law Offices of Michael F. Klag, Jeffrey A. Mathews , Law Offices of Beth Zaro Green & Kristen Vine , Jackson & Campbell, P.C..

Allstate Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony R. Gambardella , Rivkin Radler LLP, Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP, Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP & Robert A. Maloney , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Banco De Seguros Del Estado, Cross Defendant, represented by Ernesto Palomo , Locke Lord LLP, Jeffrey Steven Kramer , Locke Lord LLP, Joseph N. Froehlich , Locke Lord LLP & Robert A. Badgley , Karbal Cohen Economou Silk Dunne LLC.

The Dominion Insurance Company Limited, Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Northbrook Insurance Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Anthony R. Gambardella , Rivkin Radler LLP, Lawrence Adam Levy , Rivkin Radler LLP, Michael A. Kotula , Rivkin Radler LLP & Robert A. Maloney , Rivkin Radler LLP.

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Claude N. Grammatico , Epstein, Gialleonardo, Frankini & Kristin S. Heres , Zelle Hofmann Voelbel & Mason LLP.

National RailRoad Passenger Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Rhonda D. Orin , Anderson Kill & Olick LLP, Angela Singleton , Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, Daniel John Healy , Anderson Kill, LLP & Vivian Costandy Michael , Anderson Kill.

AG De 1830 Compagnie Belge D'Assurances Generales Incendie Accidents Et Risques Divers SA, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Co., Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company Of Winterthur, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company of Winterthur (No. 2 A/C), Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Accident & Casualty Insurance Company of Winterthur (No. 3 A/C), Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Aegon NV, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

American Home Insurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Amsterdan - London Verzekeering Maatschappij NV, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Ancon Insurance Company (UK) Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Argonaut Northwest Insurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Assicurazioni Generali SPA (UK Branch), Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Bishopsgate Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Britamco Pool, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

CNA Reinsurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

CNA Reinsurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Certain Underwriters at Lloyds, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Cornhill Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Credit De Namur, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Delta-Lloyd Non-Life Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Delta-Lloyd Schadeverzekering NV, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC, Mark J. Leimkuhler , Lewis Baach PLLC, Martin R. Baach , Lewis Baach PLLC & Ronald Abramson , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Northwestern National Insurance Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC.

Stronghold Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC.

The Dominion Insurance Company Limited, Counter Defendant, represented by Joseph L. Ruby , Lewis Baach PLLC.

National RailRoad Passenger Corporation, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Rhonda D. Orin , Anderson Kill & Olick LLP, Angela Singleton , Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, Daniel John Healy , Anderson Kill, LLP, Vivian Costandy Michael , Anderson Kill, Rhonda D. Orin , Anderson Kill & Olick LLP, Angela Singleton , Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, Daniel John Healy , Anderson Kill, LLP, Vivian Costandy Michael , Anderson Kill, Rhonda D. Orin , Anderson Kill & Olick LLP, Angela Singleton , Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, Daniel John Healy , Anderson Kill, LLP & Vivian Costandy Michael , Anderson Kill.


MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

In this declaratory judgment action, plaintiff-insurers seek, inter alia, a determination as to whether a series of liability insurance policies, issued to defendant National Railroad Passenger Corporation ("Amtrak") more than three decades ago,...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases