IN RE INSURANCE BROKERAGE ANTITRUST LITIGATION

Civil Action No. 04-5184 (CCC).

IN RE INSURANCE BROKERAGE ANTITRUST LITIGATION. MDL-1663 TAG-ALONG ACTION: INTERNATIONAL RISK INSURANCE CO., et al., Plaintiffs, v. MARSH USA INC., et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, D. New Jersey.

September 20, 2016.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 15 U.S.C. § 15
Cause: 15 U.S.C. § 15 Antitrust Litigation
Nature of Suit: 410 Anti-Trust
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

EAGLE PRODUCTS, INC., Movant, represented by HOWARD J. SEDRAN , LEVIN, FISHBEIN, SEDRAN & BERMAN.

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF PROFESSIONAL INSURANCE AGENTS, Movant, represented by WILLIAM F. MEGNA , MORRIS, MANNING & MARTIN, LLP.

INDEPENDENT INSURANCE AGENTS & BROKERS OF AMERICA, INC, Movant, represented by SHAFFIN ABDUL DATOO , THOMPSON WIGDOR & GILLY LLP.

STATE OF FLORIDA, Movant, represented by CHRISTOPHER R. HUNT , OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL.

DAN C.D. STURDEVANT, Objector, represented by STEPHEN TSAI .

IAAD O INC., Objector, represented by JOHN J. PENTZ , CLASS ACTION FAIRNESS GROUP, pro hac vice & DAVID MARC NIEPORENT , SAMUEL & STEIN.

ZORKESS LLC, Objector, represented by JOHN J. PENTZ , CLASS ACTION FAIRNESS GROUP, pro hac vice & DAVID MARC NIEPORENT , SAMUEL & STEIN.

ROMERO GENERAL CONSTRUCTION, Objector, represented by ANDREA J. LAWRENCE , COHEN TAUBER SPIEVACK & WAGNER P.C..

SHAPIRO & LODWICK CO. LPA, Objector, represented by IRA E. WEINER .

SPORTS & SPINE PHYSICAL THERAPY, INC., Objector, represented by IRA E. WEINER .

WILLIAM AKERS, Objector, represented by JOHN B.M. FROHLING .

HAROLD B. WOLFE, Objector, represented by JOHN B.M. FROHLING .

THE CHABA LAW GROUP, LLC, Objector, represented by JOHN B.M. FROHLING .

EMERALD FINANCIAL GROUP, INC., Objector, represented by ANDREA J. LAWRENCE , COHEN TAUBER SPIEVACK & WAGNER P.C..

CROSS & SIR, Objector, represented by IRA E. WEINER .

PRIVATE CARE, INC. ET AL, Objector, represented by THOMAS LARKIN .

CONNIE PENTZ REALTY COMPANY, Objector, represented by JOHN J. PENTZ , CLASS ACTION FAIRNESS GROUP, pro hac vice.

STANLEY H. EPSTEIN, Objector, represented by DANIEL A. OSBORN , BEATIE & OSBORN LLP, pro hac vice.

LAYN R. PHILLIPS, Mediator, Pro se.

STEPHEN LEWIS, Plaintiff, represented by ADAM J. LEVITT , GRANT & EISENHOFER P.A., FRED TAYLOR ISQUITH , WOLF HALDENSTEIN ADLER FREEMAN & HERTZ LLP, JAYNE ARNOLD GOLDSTEIN , Pomerantz LLP, KENNETH I. TRUJILLO , MARK C. RIFKIN , WOLF, HALDENSTEIN, ADLER, FREEMAN & HERZ, LLP, JOANNE M. CICALA , KIRBY MCINERNEY LLP, PETER S. LINDEN , KIRBY MCINERNEY LLP & RICHARD L. STONE , KIRBY MCINERNEY LLP.

DIANE PRUESS, Plaintiff, represented by ADAM J. LEVITT , GRANT & EISENHOFER P.A., FRED TAYLOR ISQUITH , WOLF HALDENSTEIN ADLER FREEMAN & HERTZ LLP, JAYNE ARNOLD GOLDSTEIN , Pomerantz LLP, KENNETH I. TRUJILLO , MARK C. RIFKIN , WOLF, HALDENSTEIN, ADLER, FREEMAN & HERZ, LLP & MARY JANE EDELSTEIN FAIT , WOLF HALDENSTEIN ADLER FREEMAN & HERTZ LLP.

OPTICARE HEALTH SYSTEMS INC, Plaintiff, represented by EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC, JOE R. WHATLEY , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLP, KENNETH I. TRUJILLO , PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP & RACHEL LYNN JENSEN , COUGHLIN, STOIA, GELLER, RUDMAN & ROBBINS, LLP.

MARYANN WAXMAN, Plaintiff, represented by KENNETH I. TRUJILLO & PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP.

SUNBURST HOSPITALITY CORPORATION, Plaintiff, represented by EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC, ELLEN MERIWETHER , CAFFERTY CLOBES MERIWETHER & SPRENGEL LLP, KENNETH I. TRUJILLO , MELODY FORRESTER , MILLER, FAUCHER & CAFFERTY, LLP, BRYAN L. CLOBES , CAFFERTY CLOBES MERIWETHER & SPRENGEL LLP, JENNIFER W. SPRENGEL , Cafferty Clobes Meriwether & Sprengel LLP & NYRAN ROSE PEARSON , Cafferty Clobes Meriwether & Sprengel LLP.

GOLDEN GATE BRIDGE, HIGHWAY AND TRANSPORTATION DISTRICT, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER L. LEBSOCK , HAUSFELD LLP, DANIEL B. ALLANOFF , MEREDITH, COHEN,GREENFOGEL & SKIRNICK, PC, EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC, FREDERICK P. FURTH , THE FURTH FIRM LLP, KENNETH I. TRUJILLO , MICHAEL P. LEHMANN , HAUSFELD LLP, STEVEN J. GREENFOGEL , JULIO J. RAMOS , FURTH, LEHMANN & GRANT, LLP & KAREN LOUISE JONES , FURTH, LEHMANN & GRANT, LLP.

REDWOOD OIL CO, Plaintiff, represented by EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC, FREDERICK P. FURTH , THE FURTH FIRM LLP, KENNETH I. TRUJILLO , MICHAEL P. LEHMANN , HAUSFELD LLP, JON T. KING , Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro LLP & JULIO J. RAMOS , FURTH, LEHMANN & GRANT, LLP.

SHELL VACATIONS LLC, Plaintiff, represented by DOUGLAS A. MILLEN , MUCH, SHELIST, FREED, DENENBERG, AMENT & RUBENSTEIN, PC, FREDERICK P. FURTH , THE FURTH FIRM LLP, KENNETH I. TRUJILLO , MICHAEL P. LEHMANN , HAUSFELD LLP, STEVEN A. KANNER , FREED KANNER LONDON & MIL, THOMAS P. DOVE , FURTH, LEHMANN & GRANT, LLP, WILLIAM HENRY LONDON , MUCH, SHELIST, FREED, DENENBERG, AMENT & RUBENSTEIN, PC, JON T. KING , Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro LLP & JULIO J. RAMOS , FURTH, LEHMANN & GRANT, LLP.

BAYOU STEEL CORP, Plaintiff, represented by AUSTIN B. COHEN , LEVIN, FISHBEIN, SEDRAN & BERMAN, EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC, HOWARD J. SEDRAN , LEVIN, FISHBEIN, SEDRAN & BERMAN & KENNETH I. TRUJILLO .

REDWOOD OIL COMPANY, Plaintiff, represented by EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC, JAMES S. SHEDDEN , BELLER, SCHAD & DIAMOND, PC, KENNETH I. TRUJILLO , LAWRENCE WILEY SCHAD , BEELER, SCHAD & DIAMOND, PC, MICHAEL S. HILICKI , BEELER, SCHAD & DIAMOND, PC, TONY KIM , BEELER, SCHAD & DIAMOND, PC & W. TIMOTHY NEEDHAM , JANSSEN MALLOY NEEDHAM MORRISON REINHOLTSEN & CROWLEY.

CLEAR LAM PACKAGING INC, Plaintiff, represented by EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC, KATHLEEN CURRIE CHAVEZ , CHAVEZ LAW FIRM, KENNETH I. TRUJILLO , ROBERT M. FOOTE , FOOTE, MEYERS, MIELKE & FLOWERS, LLC, HARVEY JOEL BARNETT & MARK ANTHONY BULGARELLI , FOOTE, MEYERS, MIELKE & FLOWERS, LLC.

DR ROBERT H KIMBALL, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES L. REED , LOOPER REED & MCGRAW & TRAVIS SCOTT CRABTREE , LOOPER REED & MCGRAW.

DAVID BOROS, Plaintiff, represented by CADIO ZIRPOLI , SAVERI & SAVERI, GEOFFREY C. RUSHING , SAVERI & SAVERI, GUIDO SAVERI , SAVERI & SAVERI, INC., KENNETH I. TRUJILLO & RICHARD ALEXANDER SAVERI , SAVERI & SAVERI, INC..

SHELDON LANGENDORF, Plaintiff, represented by KENNETH I. TRUJILLO & LARRY D. DRURY .

ESTELLE LANGENDORF, Plaintiff, represented by KENNETH I. TRUJILLO & LARRY D. DRURY .

CELLECT, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC & KENNETH I. TRUJILLO .

CITY OF STAMFORD, Plaintiff, represented by EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC & KENNETH I. TRUJILLO .

COMCAR INDUSTRIES, INC., Plaintiff, represented by EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC & KENNETH I. TRUJILLO .

GATEWAY CLUB APARTMENTS, LTD., Plaintiff, represented by EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC & KENNETH I. TRUJILLO .

MICHIGAN MULTI-KING CORP., Plaintiff, represented by DAN DRACHLER , ZWERLING SCHACHTER & ZWERLING LLP, EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC, KENNETH I. TRUJILLO , RACHEL LYNN JENSEN , COUGHLIN, STOIA, GELLER, RUDMAN & ROBBINS, LLP & DAVID M. FOSTER .

ROBERT MULCAHY, Plaintiff, represented by ALLYN ZISSEL LITE , LITE DEPALMA GREENBERG, LLC, EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC, ELLEN MERIWETHER , CAFFERTY CLOBES MERIWETHER & SPRENGEL LLP & MELODY FORRESTER , MILLER, FAUCHER & CAFFERTY, LLP.

GLENN SINGER, Plaintiff, represented by EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC & KENNETH I. TRUJILLO .

THE ENCLAVE, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC & KENNETH I. TRUJILLO .

THE OMNI GROUP OF COMPANIES, Plaintiff, represented by KENNETH I. TRUJILLO .

SIGNUM LLC, Plaintiff, represented by KENNETH I. TRUJILLO .

KLLM INC, Plaintiff, represented by JON STEPHEN KENNEDY , RICHARD F. YARBOROUGH , ROY H. LIDDELL , WELLS, MARBLE & HURST, PLLC & THOMAS M. LOUIS , WELLS, MARBLE & HURST, PLLC.

SLAY INDUSTRIES, Plaintiff, represented by JEFFREY J. LOWE & KENNETH I. TRUJILLO .

SLAY TRANSPORTATION CO INC, Plaintiff, represented by JEFFREY J. LOWE & KENNETH I. TRUJILLO .

EMERSON ELECTRIC CO., Plaintiff, represented by DOROTHY L. WHITE-COLEMAN , WHITE, COLEMAN & ASOCIATES, LLC, JOHN C. CABANISS & KENNETH I. TRUJILLO .

CAMERON OFFSHORE BOATS INC, Plaintiff, represented by H. ALAN MCCALL , STOCKWELL SIEVERT.

TRI-STATE CONTAINER CORP., Plaintiff, Pro se.

CONNECTICUT SPRING & STAMP CO., Plaintiff, represented by ROBERT M. PARKER , PARKER CLAYTON.

BELMONT HOLDINGS CORP., Plaintiff, represented by DOUGLAS A. ABRAHAMS , KOHN, SWIFT, & GRAF, PC.

AMERICAN STANDARD, INC., Plaintiff, represented by BARBARA T. SICALIDES , PEPPER HAMILTON, LLP, JOANNA J. CLINE , PEPPER HAMILTON, LLP & DAVID T. EMANUELSON , HOWREY, LLP.

AMERICAN STANDARD COMPANIES, INC., Plaintiff, represented by BARBARA T. SICALIDES , PEPPER HAMILTON, LLP, JOANNA J. CLINE , PEPPER HAMILTON, LLP & DAVID T. EMANUELSON , HOWREY, LLP.

SINCLAIR OIL CORP, Plaintiff, represented by J. ANDREW SJOBLOM , HOLME, ROBERTS & OWEN, LLP.

AL AMERICA HOLDINGS, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN S. DUMESNIL , BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP & ROBERT M. PARKER , PARKER CLAYTON.

AMERICAN AIR LIQUIDE HOLDINGS, INC., Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN S. DUMESNIL , BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP & ROBERT M. PARKER , PARKER CLAYTON.

AMERICAN AIR LIQUIDE, INC, Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN S. DUMESNIL , BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP & ROBERT M. PARKER , PARKER CLAYTON.

AMERICAN PLUMBING AND MECHANICAL, INC., Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN S. DUMESNIL , BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP & ROBERT M. PARKER , PARKER CLAYTON.

HUNTSMAN ADVANCE MATERIALS LLC, Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN S. DUMESNIL , BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP & ROBERT M. PARKER , PARKER CLAYTON.

HUNTSMAN CORPORATION, Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN S. DUMESNIL , BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP & ROBERT M. PARKER , PARKER CLAYTON.

HUNTSMAN HOLDINGS, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN S. DUMESNIL , BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP & ROBERT M. PARKER , PARKER CLAYTON.

HUNTSMAN LLC, Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN S. DUMESNIL , BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP & ROBERT M. PARKER , PARKER CLAYTON.

INTERNATIONAL RISK INSURANCE COMPANY, Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN S. DUMESNIL , BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP, ROBERT M. PARKER , PARKER CLAYTON & PHILIP J. BEZANSON , BRACEWELL & GIULIANI, LLP.

JOHN BAIRD, Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN S. DUMESNIL , BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP & ROBERT M. PARKER , PARKER CLAYTON.

PLAINT CORPORATION, Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN S. DUMESNIL , BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP & ROBERT M. PARKER , PARKER CLAYTON.

JACK THORNELL, Plaintiff, represented by ANDREW D. ARONS , CHILDRESS, DUFFY & GOLDBLATT, LTD. & RYAN A. HAAS , CHILDRESS, DUFFY & GOLDBLATT, LTD..

JUDY THORNELL, Plaintiff, represented by ANDREW D. ARONS , CHILDRESS, DUFFY & GOLDBLATT, LTD. & RYAN A. HAAS , CHILDRESS, DUFFY & GOLDBLATT, LTD..

HERITAGE CORPORATION OF SOUTH FLORIDA, Plaintiff, represented by GUY BURDETTE BAILEY, Jr. , BAILEY & DAWES, LC & OWEI BELLEH , BAILEY & DAWES, LC.

HAROLD FOLSOM JENSEN, Plaintiff, represented by ANDREA J. LAWRENCE , COHEN TAUBER SPIEVACK & WAGNER P.C..

PALOMAR GRADING AND PAVING, INC., Plaintiff, represented by ANDREA J. LAWRENCE , COHEN TAUBER SPIEVACK & WAGNER P.C..

HENLEY MANAGEMENT COMPANY, Plaintiff, represented by KELLY M. GLYNN , SCHOPF & WEISS LLP.

BIG BEAR PROPERTIES, INC., Plaintiff, Pro se.

NORTHBROOK PROPERTIES, INC., Plaintiff, Pro se.

RCK PROPERTIES, INC., Plaintiff, Pro se.

KITCHENS, INC., Plaintiff, represented by EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC.

ABERFELDY LP, Plaintiff, Pro se.

PAYROLL AND INSURANCE GROUP, INC., Plaintiff, Pro se.

CATERPILLAR INC., Plaintiff, represented by ANDREW M. REIDY , HOWREY LLP, DANIEL L. JOHNS , WESTERVELT JOHNSON NICOLL & KELLER, MICHELE A. MILLER , WESTERVELT JOHNSON NICOLL & KELLER & ROBERT G. ABRAMS , HOWREY LLP.

TYSON FOODS, INC., Plaintiff, Pro se.

SEARS ROEBUCK & CO., Plaintiff, Pro se.

PUBLIC SERVICE ENTERPRISE GROUP, Plaintiff, Pro se.

CONSOLIDATED ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTORS, INC., Plaintiff, represented by R. DOUGLAS REES , JENNER & BLOCK LLP.

EPIX Holdings Corporation, Plaintiff, represented by ROBERT GERARD GOODMAN , PALMISANO & GOODMAN, ESQS..

SEARS HOLDINGS CORPORATION, Plaintiff, represented by KELLY M. GLYNN , SCHOPF & WEISS LLP, DAVID ANTHONY SIRNA , KREVOLIN & HORST, JEFFREY D. HORST , KREVOLIN & HORST & KENNETH EMANUEL KRAUS , SCHOPF & WEISS, LLP.

KMART CORPORATION, Plaintiff, Pro se.

LANDS' END INC., Plaintiff, Pro se.

LINCOLN ADVENTURES LLC, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN A. MEDICI , DAN DRACHLER , ZWERLING SCHACHTER & ZWERLING LLP, PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP & RACHEL LYNN JENSEN , COUGHLIN, STOIA, GELLER, RUDMAN & ROBBINS, LLP.

SUPREME AUTO TRANSPORT, LLC, Plaintiff, Pro se.

Michigan Multi-King Inc., Plaintiff, represented by PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP & RACHEL LYNN JENSEN , COUGHLIN, STOIA, GELLER, RUDMAN & ROBBINS, LLP.

Texas Independent Energy, LLP, Plaintiff, Pro se.

NEW CINGULAR WIRELESS HEADQUARTERS, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by KELLY M. GLYNN , SCHOPF & WEISS LLP.

Aberfeldy Properties Inc., Plaintiff, Pro se.

AVERY DENNISON CORPORATION, Plaintiff, Pro se.

All Plaintiffs, Plaintiff Consolidated, represented by EDITH M. KALLAS , WHATLEY KALLAS, LLC.

MARK TOBEY, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by GREGG ABBOTT , OFFICE OF THE TEXAS ATTORNEY GENERAL.

KIM VAN WINKLE, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by GREGG ABBOTT , OFFICE OF THE TEXAS ATTORNEY GENERAL.

MARSH & MCLENNAN COMPANIES, INC., Defendant, represented by ANDREW T. BERRY , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP, C. LARRY CORBO, III , JACKSON WALKER LLP, CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP, DANIEL P. JORDAN , BUTLER, SNOW, O'MARA, STEVENS & CANNADA, PLLC, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , DAVID C. GUSTMAN , FREEBORN & PETERS, DONALD ARTHUR BLACKWELL , ANANIA, BANDKLAYDER, BLACKWELL & BAUMGARTEN, FRANCIS A. ANANIA , ANANIA, BANDKLAYDER, BLACKWELL & BAUMGARTEN, FREDERICK BARTLETT WULFF, Sr. , KONING RUBARTS LLP, GREGORY K. CONWAY , WILLKIE, FARR & GALLAGHER, LLP, JILL CHRISTINE ANDERSON , FREEBORN & PETERS, JOHN ROBERT OLLER , WILKIE, FARR & GALLAGHER, LLP, KEVIN F. HORMUTH , GREENSFELDER & HEMKER, KEVIN F. O'MALLEY , GREENSFELDER & HEMKER, MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP, P. RYAN BECKETT , BUTLER, SNOW, O'MARA, STEVENS & CANNADA, PLLC, PHILIP RITCHEY SIMS , CHAFFE MCCALL, WILLIAM F. GRACE , CHAFFE MCCALL & BRIAN J. OSIAS , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

MARSH INC., Defendant, represented by ANDREW T. BERRY , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP, CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP, DANIEL P. JORDAN , BUTLER, SNOW, O'MARA, STEVENS & CANNADA, PLLC, DAVID C. GUSTMAN , FREEBORN & PETERS, DONALD ARTHUR BLACKWELL , ANANIA, BANDKLAYDER, BLACKWELL & BAUMGARTEN, FRANCIS A. ANANIA , ANANIA, BANDKLAYDER, BLACKWELL & BAUMGARTEN, FREDERICK BARTLETT WULFF, Sr. , KONING RUBARTS LLP, JILL CHRISTINE ANDERSON , FREEBORN & PETERS, JOHN ROBERT OLLER , WILKIE, FARR & GALLAGHER, LLP, KEVIN F. HORMUTH , GREENSFELDER & HEMKER, KEVIN F. O'MALLEY , GREENSFELDER & HEMKER, MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP, P. RYAN BECKETT , BUTLER, SNOW, O'MARA, STEVENS & CANNADA, PLLC & BRIAN J. OSIAS , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

MARSH USA INC., Defendant, represented by ANDREW T. BERRY , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP, CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP, DANIEL P. JORDAN , BUTLER, SNOW, O'MARA, STEVENS & CANNADA, PLLC, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , DAVID C. GUSTMAN , FREEBORN & PETERS, DONALD ARTHUR BLACKWELL , ANANIA, BANDKLAYDER, BLACKWELL & BAUMGARTEN, FRANCIS A. ANANIA , ANANIA, BANDKLAYDER, BLACKWELL & BAUMGARTEN, GREGORY K. CONWAY , WILLKIE, FARR & GALLAGHER, LLP, JILL CHRISTINE ANDERSON , FREEBORN & PETERS, JOHN ROBERT OLLER , WILKIE, FARR & GALLAGHER, LLP, KEVIN F. HORMUTH , GREENSFELDER & HEMKER, KEVIN F. O'MALLEY , GREENSFELDER & HEMKER, MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP, P. RYAN BECKETT , BUTLER, SNOW, O'MARA, STEVENS & CANNADA, PLLC, PHILIP RITCHEY SIMS , CHAFFE MCCALL, WILLIAM F. GRACE , CHAFFE MCCALL & BRIAN J. OSIAS , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

SEABURY & SMITH, INC., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

BB&T CORPORATION, Defendant, represented by JAMES PAUL WEHNER, Jr. , SQUIRE, SANDERS & DEMPSEY, LLP & JACK LOUIS WUERKER , SQUIRE, SANDERS & DEMPSEY, LLP.

BB&T INSURANCE SERVICES INC., Defendant, represented by JAMES PAUL WEHNER, Jr. , SQUIRE, SANDERS & DEMPSEY, LLP & JACK LOUIS WUERKER , SQUIRE, SANDERS & DEMPSEY, LLP.

BRANCH BANKING & TRUST COMPANY, Defendant, represented by JAMES PAUL WEHNER, Jr. , SQUIRE, SANDERS & DEMPSEY, LLP.

UNUMPROVIDENT CORPORATION, Defendant, represented by ALEXANDER W. WOOD , PAUL HASTINGS LLP, DEBORAH E. HYRB , PAUL HASTINGS, JANOFSKY & WALKER, LLP, JENNIFER BATES MCINTYRE , PERKINS COIE LLC, PATRICK SHEA , PAUL HASTINGS, JANOFSKY & WALKER, LLP, RACHEL ROSS KRAUSE , OGDEN & SULLIVAN, PA, ROSEANN OLIVER , PERKINS COIE LLC, STEVEN P. DEL MAURO , MCELROY, DEUTSCH, MULVANEY & CARPENTER, LLP, TIMON V. SULLIVAN , OGDEN & SULLIVAN, PA & RANDI F. KNEPPER , MCELROY, DEUTSCH, MULVANEY & CARPENTER, LLC.

ACE INA HOLDINGS, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JEREMY J. BRANDON , SUSMAN GODFREY, LLP, LIZA M. WALSH , WALSH PIZZI O'REILLY FALANGA LLP, M. DUNCAN GRANT , PEPPER HAMILTON LLP & MARC D. HAEFNER , WALSH PIZZI O'REILLY FALANGA LLP.

ACE LIMITED, Defendant, represented by ALAN N. SALPETER , DANIEL J. LEFFELL , H. LEE GODFREY , SUSMAN GODFREY, LLP, JEREMY J. BRANDON , SUSMAN GODFREY, LLP, LIZA M. WALSH , WALSH PIZZI O'REILLY FALANGA LLP, MICHAEL P. GEISER , SUSMAN GODFREY LLP, ROBERT J. KRISS , MAYER, BROWN, ROWE & MAW LLP, VINEET BHATIA , SUSMAN GODFREY LLP & MARC D. HAEFNER , WALSH PIZZI O'REILLY FALANGA LLP.

ACE USA, Defendant, represented by ALAN N. SALPETER , DANIEL J. LEFFELL , FREDERIC STANLEY, Jr. , STANLEY, DEHLINGER & RASCHER, GRETHCHEN S. SWEEN , SUSMAN GODFREY, LLP, H. LEE GODFREY , SUSMAN GODFREY, LLP, JEREMY J. BRANDON , SUSMAN GODFREY, LLP, L. JANE RAY , SUSMAN GODFREY, LLP, LIZA M. WALSH , WALSH PIZZI O'REILLY FALANGA LLP, M. DUNCAN GRANT , PEPPER HAMILTON LLP, MICHAEL P. GEISER , SUSMAN GODFREY LLP, ROBERT J. KRISS , MAYER, BROWN, ROWE & MAW LLP, VINEET BHATIA , SUSMAN GODFREY LLP & MARC D. HAEFNER , WALSH PIZZI O'REILLY FALANGA LLP.

WILLIS GROUP HOLDINGS LIMITED, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JEFFREY T. SCOTT , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL LLP, ANASTASIA ANGELOVA , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

WILLIS GROUP LIMITED, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JEFFREY T. SCOTT , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL LLP, ANASTASIA ANGELOVA , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

WILLIS NORTH AMERICA INC., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JEFFREY T. SCOTT , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL LLP, ANASTASIA ANGELOVA , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL GROUP, INC., Defendant, represented by CARL H. POCDTKE , DLA PIPER RUDNICK GARY CARY US LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , KENNETH A. GALLO , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP, LAYALIZA KLEIN SOLOVEICHIK , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON LLP, MARK A. ARONCHICK , HANGLEY ARONCHICK SEGAL & PUDLIN, MARTIN FLUMENBAUM , PAUL WEISS RIFKIND WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP, ROBERTA A. KAPLAN , PAUL WEISS RIFKIND WHARTON & GARRISON LLP, SAMUEL BAYARD ISAACSON , DLA PUPER RUDICK GRAY CARY US LLP & STEPHEN W. SCHWAB , DLA PIPER RUDICK GRAY CARY US LLP.

THE ST. PAUL TRAVELERS COMPANIES, INC., Defendant, represented by MICHAEL J. GARVEY , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP.

BROWN & BROWN, INC., Defendant, represented by BARRY G. SHER , PAUL, HASTINGS, JANOFSKY & WALKER, LLP, KEVIN C. LOGUE , PAUL, HASTINGS JANOFSKY & WALKER, LLP, SARAH EMILY HAGANS , PAUL, HASTINGS, JANOFSKY & WALKER, LLP & VICTORIA ASHWORTH , PAUL, HASTINGS, JANOFSKY & WALKER, LLP.

ACORDIA INC, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

PRUDENTIAL FINANCIAL, INC., Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER C. GILBERT , UNGER LAW GROUP, PL & MARTIN B. UNGER , UNGER LAW GROUP, PL.

THE PRUDENTIAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA, INC., Defendant, Pro se.

U.S.I. HOLDINGS CORPORATION, Defendant, represented by RACHEL L. GERSTEIN , AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAUER & FELD, LLP, RICHARD B. ZABEL , AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAVER & FELD, LLP & ROBERT HARDY PEES , AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAUER & FELD, LLP.

ACE INA, Defendant, represented by FREDERIC STANLEY, Jr. , STANLEY, DEHLINGER & RASCHER, GRETHCHEN S. SWEEN , SUSMAN GODFREY, LLP, H. LEE GODFREY , SUSMAN GODFREY, LLP, JEREMY J. BRANDON , SUSMAN GODFREY, LLP, L. JANE RAY , SUSMAN GODFREY, LLP & MARC D. HAEFNER , WALSH PIZZI O'REILLY FALANGA LLP.

ACE INA HOLDINGS INC, Defendant, represented by ALAN N. SALPETER , DANIEL J. LEFFELL , H. LEE GODFREY , SUSMAN GODFREY, LLP, M. DUNCAN GRANT , PEPPER HAMILTON LLP, MICHAEL P. GEISER , SUSMAN GODFREY LLP, ROBERT J. KRISS , MAYER, BROWN, ROWE & MAW LLP, VINEET BHATIA , SUSMAN GODFREY LLP & MARC D. HAEFNER , WALSH PIZZI O'REILLY FALANGA LLP.

ACE LTD, Defendant, represented by M. DUNCAN GRANT , PEPPER HAMILTON LLP & MARC D. HAEFNER , WALSH PIZZI O'REILLY FALANGA LLP.

AON SERVICES GROUP, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & LESLIE M. SMITH , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP.

MARSH USA INC., Defendant, represented by ANDREW T. BERRY , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP & BRIAN J. OSIAS , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

HILB, ROGAL & HOBBS, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , SHAWN PATRICK REGAN , HUNTON & WILLIAMS, LLP, JONATHAN MICHAEL WILAN , HUNTON & WILLIAMS LLP, NEIL KEITH GILMAN , HUNTON & WILLIAMS LLP & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

LEXINGTON INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & KENNETH A. GALLO , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP.

U.S.I HOLDINGS CORP, Defendant, represented by ROBERT HARDY PEES , AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAUER & FELD, LLP & RICHARD B. ZABEL , AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAVER & FELD, LLP.

HARTFORD FINANCIAL SERVICES GROUP INC, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , GREGORY M. REISER , WILMER, CUTLER, PICKERING, HALE & DORR, LLP, JAMES E. FOSTER , AKERMAN SENTERFITT, MARCI A. EISENSTEIN , SCHIFF HARDIN, LLP, ROBIN L. ALPERSTEIN , WILMER CUTLER PICKERING HALE & DORR LLP, VIRGINIA B. TOWNES , AKERMAN SENTERFITT & WILLIAM M. HANNAY , SCHIFF HARDIN LLP.

HARTFORD FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JAMES E. FOSTER , AKERMAN SENTERFITT & VIRGINIA B. TOWNES , AKERMAN SENTERFITT.

PROPERTY & CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY OF HARTFORD, Defendant, represented by MARCI A. EISENSTEIN , SCHIFF HARDIN, LLP & WILLIAM M. HANNAY , SCHIFF HARDIN LLP.

TWIN CITY FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

AON GROUP INC, Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN R. OSTAPUK , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, DANIEL EDWARD LAYTIN , KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART, NICHOLSON, GRAHAM, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JILL M. STEINBERG , BAKER DONELSON BEARMAN CALDWELL & BERKOWITZ, JOHN ARMANDO BOUDET , GREENBERG TRAURIG, PA, LESLIE M. SMITH , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP & RICHARD C. GODFREY , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP.

AON DIRECT GROUP INC, Defendant, represented by DANIEL EDWARD LAYTIN , KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART, NICHOLSON, GRAHAM, LLP, JILL M. STEINBERG , BAKER DONELSON BEARMAN CALDWELL & BERKOWITZ, LESLIE M. SMITH , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP & RICHARD C. GODFREY , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP.

AFFINITY INSURANCE SERVICES INC, Defendant, represented by DANIEL EDWARD LAYTIN , KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART, NICHOLSON, GRAHAM, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JILL M. STEINBERG , BAKER DONELSON BEARMAN CALDWELL & BERKOWITZ, LESLIE M. SMITH , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, RICHARD C. GODFREY , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS SERVICE ORGANIZATION, Defendant, represented by DANIEL EDWARD LAYTIN , KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART, NICHOLSON, GRAHAM, LLP, JILL M. STEINBERG , BAKER DONELSON BEARMAN CALDWELL & BERKOWITZ, LESLIE M. SMITH , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP & RICHARD C. GODFREY , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP.

AMERICAN RE CORPORATION, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , DAVID GRAIS , GRAIS & ELLSWORTH LLP, EAMON O'KELLY , EAMON O'KELLY & MOLLY LEHR PEASE , GRAIS & ELLSWORTH LLP.

AMERICAN RE-INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , DAVID GRAIS , GRAIS & ELLSWORTH LLP, EAMON O'KELLY , EAMON O'KELLY, HOUSTON S. PARK, III , STEPHENS, LYNN, KLEIN, LA CAVA, HOFFMAN & MOLLY LEHR PEASE , GRAIS & ELLSWORTH LLP.

MUNICH-AMERICAN RISK PARTNERS INC, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , DAVID GRAIS , GRAIS & ELLSWORTH LLP, EAMON O'KELLY , EAMON O'KELLY & MOLLY LEHR PEASE , GRAIS & ELLSWORTH LLP.

AON RISK SERVICES COMPANIES INC, Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN R. OSTAPUK , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, DANIEL EDWARD LAYTIN , KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART, NICHOLSON, GRAHAM, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JOHN ARMANDO BOUDET , GREENBERG TRAURIG, PA, LESLIE M. SMITH , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

AON RISK SERVICES INC U.S., Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN R. OSTAPUK , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, DANIEL EDWARD LAYTIN , KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART, NICHOLSON, GRAHAM, LLP & LESLIE M. SMITH , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP.

AON SERVICES GROUP INC, Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN R. OSTAPUK , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, DANIEL EDWARD LAYTIN , KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART, NICHOLSON, GRAHAM, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JOHN ARMANDO BOUDET , GREENBERG TRAURIG, PA & LESLIE M. SMITH , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP.

UNIVERSAL LIFE RESOURCES, Defendant, represented by ERIC NEAL MACEY , NOVACK & MACEY, LLP & SCOTT L. METZGER , DUCKOR, SPRADLING, METZGER & WYNNE.

UNIVERSAL LIFE RESOURCES INC, Defendant, represented by ERIC NEAL MACEY , NOVACK & MACEY, LLP, NED GELHAAR , HANCOCK, ROTHERT & BUNSHOFT, LLP & SCOTT L. METZGER , DUCKOR, SPRADLING, METZGER & WYNNE.

WILLIS GROUP HOLDINGS LTD., Defendant, represented by ANASTASIA ANGELOVA , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP, FREDRICK H. MCCLURE , PIP RUDNICK LLP, JOHN L. WARDEN , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

WILLIS GROUP LTD., Defendant, represented by ANASTASIA ANGELOVA , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , FREDRICK H. MCCLURE , PIP RUDNICK LLP, JOHN L. WARDEN , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

BENEFITS COMMERCE, Defendant, represented by ERIC NEAL MACEY , NOVACK & MACEY, LLP & SCOTT L. METZGER , DUCKOR, SPRADLING, METZGER & WYNNE.

DOUGLAS P. COX, Defendant, represented by ERIC NEAL MACEY , NOVACK & MACEY, LLP & SCOTT L. METZGER , DUCKOR, SPRADLING, METZGER & WYNNE.

MUNICH REINSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by BRIAN PETER CALANDRA , SHEARMAN & STERLING LLP.

METLIFE INC, Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER C. GILBERT , UNGER LAW GROUP, PL, MARTIN B. UNGER , UNGER LAW GROUP, PL, PAUL JEFFREY RIEHLE , SEDGWICK DETERT MORAN & ARNOLD & MARGARET O'ROURKE WOOD , WOLFF SAMSON, PC.

ST PAUL TRAVELERS COS INC, Defendant, represented by BRYCE L. FRIEDMAN , SIMPSON, THACHER & BARTLETT, LLP & PAUL C. CURNIN , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT, LLP.

NATIONAL FINANCIAL PARTNERS CORPORATION, Defendant, represented by DONNA L. MCDEVITT , SKADDEN ARPS SLATE MEAGHER & FLOM LLP & TIMOTHY ALAN NELSEN , SKADDEN ARPS SLATE MEAGHER & FLOM LLP.

WELLS FARGO & CO, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

HILB ROGAL & HAMILTON CO, Defendant, represented by JEFFREY T. SCOTT , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL LLP, JONATHAN MICHAEL WILAN , HUNTON & WILLIAMS LLP & NEIL KEITH GILMAN , HUNTON & WILLIAMS LLP.

BB&T CORP, Defendant, represented by JAMES PAUL WEHNER, Jr. , SQUIRE, SANDERS & DEMPSEY, LLP & JACK LOUIS WUERKER , SQUIRE, SANDERS & DEMPSEY, LLP.

BRANCH BANKING & TRUST CO, Defendant, represented by JAMES PAUL WEHNER, Jr. , SQUIRE, SANDERS & DEMPSEY, LLP.

HUB INTERNATIONAL LTD, Defendant, represented by ALAN SETH RABINOWITZ , SHEARMAN & STERLING LLP.

MUNICH RE GROUP, Defendant, represented by BRIAN PETER CALANDRA , SHEARMAN & STERLING LLP & HENRY WEISBURG .

AMERICAN RE CORP, Defendant, represented by EAMON O'KELLY , EAMON O'KELLY.

MARSH USA INC., Defendant, represented by ANDREW T. BERRY , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL & BRIAN J. OSIAS , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

AMERICAN RE-INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & MOLLY LEHR PEASE , GRAIS & ELLSWORTH LLP.

AON BROKERS SERVICES INC, Defendant, represented by BENJAMIN R. OSTAPUK , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JOHN ARMANDO BOUDET , GREENBERG TRAURIG, PA, LESLIE M. SMITH , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

AON GROUP INT, Defendant, Pro se.

AMERICAN RE INSURANCE CO, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & EAMON O'KELLY , EAMON O'KELLY.

MERCER HUMAN RESOURCE CONSULTING INC, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & FREDERICK BARTLETT WULFF, Sr. , KONING RUBARTS LLP.

MERCER HUMAN RESOURCE CONSULTING OF TEXAS INC, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , FREDERICK BARTLETT WULFF, Sr. , KONING RUBARTS LLP & MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

ACE AMERICAN INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & MARC D. HAEFNER , WALSH PIZZI O'REILLY FALANGA LLP.

AIU INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & KENNETH A. GALLO , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP.

AMERICAN CASUALTY CO. OF READING, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , MICHAEL R. BLANKSHAIN , WILDMAN, HARROLD, ALLEN & DIXON, LLP, MICHAEL LEE MCCLUGGAGE , WILDMAN, HARROLD, ALLEN & DIXON, LLP & MATTHEW JOSEPH CACCAMO , WILDMAN HARROLD ALLEN & DIXON.

AMERICAN GUARANTEE & LIABILITY INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by KYMBERLY KOCHIS , ELIZABETH BARRY SANDZA , LEBOEUF, LAMB, GREENE & MACRAE, LLP, G. RICHARD DODGE, Jr. , Mayer Brown, LLP & JONATHAN E. RICHMAN , DEWEY & LEBOEUF LLP.

AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & KENNETH A. GALLO , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP.

AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & KENNETH A. GALLO , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP.

AON GROUP, INC., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

AON RE WORLDWIDE, INC., Defendant, Pro se.

AON RE, INC., Defendant, Pro se.

AON RISK SERVICES INC U S, Defendant, represented by JOHN ARMANDO BOUDET , GREENBERG TRAURIG, PA & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

AON RISK SERVICES OF TEXAS, INC., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

AON RISK SERVICES, INC. OF LOUISIANA, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

AON RISK SERVICES, INC. OF MARYLAND, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

AON RISK SERVICES, INC. OF MICHIGAN, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

AON SERVICES GROUP, INC., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

ASSURANCE CO. OF AMERICA, Defendant, represented by ELIZABETH BARRY SANDZA , LEBOEUF, LAMB, GREENE & MACRAE, LLP.

ATHENA ASSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by BRYCE L. FRIEDMAN , SIMPSON, THACHER & BARTLETT, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL & MICHAEL J. GARVEY , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP.

AXIS REINSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by WILLIAM F. CLARKE, Jr. , SKADDEN, ARPS, SLATE, MEAGHER & FLOM. LLP.

AXIS SPECIALTY INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & WILLIAM F. CLARKE, Jr. , SKADDEN, ARPS, SLATE, MEAGHER & FLOM. LLP.

AXIS SURPLUS INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & WILLIAM F. CLARKE, Jr. , SKADDEN, ARPS, SLATE, MEAGHER & FLOM. LLP.

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY, INC., Defendant, represented by JOSEPH J. SCHIAVONE , BUDD LARNER, PC.

BIRMINGHAM FIRE INSURANCE CO. OF PA, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & KENNETH A. GALLO , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP.

CHICAGO INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

CNA FINANCIAL CORP., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , MICHAEL R. BLANKSHAIN , WILDMAN, HARROLD, ALLEN & DIXON, LLP, MICHAEL LEE MCCLUGGAGE , WILDMAN, HARROLD, ALLEN & DIXON, LLP & MATTHEW JOSEPH CACCAMO , WILDMAN HARROLD ALLEN & DIXON.

COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & KENNETH A. GALLO , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP.

CONTINENTAL CASUALTY CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , MICHAEL R. BLANKSHAIN , WILDMAN, HARROLD, ALLEN & DIXON, LLP, MICHAEL LEE MCCLUGGAGE , WILDMAN, HARROLD, ALLEN & DIXON, LLP & MATTHEW JOSEPH CACCAMO , WILDMAN HARROLD ALLEN & DIXON.

CRUM & FORSTER HOLDINGS CORP, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , LOUIS G. CORSI , LANDMAN, CORSI, BALLAINE & FORD, CHRISTOPHER G. FRETEL , LANDMAN, CORSI, BALLAINE & FORD & STEPHEN JACOBS , LANDMAN, CORSI, BALLAINE & FORD.

EMPIRE FIRE & MARINE INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by KYMBERLY KOCHIS , ELIZABETH BARRY SANDZA , LEBOEUF, LAMB, GREENE & MACRAE, LLP & JONATHAN E. RICHMAN , DEWEY & LEBOEUF LLP.

EMPIRE INDEMNITY INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by ELIZABETH BARRY SANDZA , LEBOEUF, LAMB, GREENE & MACRAE, LLP.

EXECUTIVE RISK INDEMNITY INC., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & PETER RICHARD BISIO , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

FIDELITY & DEPOSIT CO. OF MARYLAND, Defendant, represented by KYMBERLY KOCHIS , ELIZABETH BARRY SANDZA , LEBOEUF, LAMB, GREENE & MACRAE, LLP & JONATHAN E. RICHMAN , DEWEY & LEBOEUF LLP.

GENERAL RE CORPORATION, Defendant, represented by JOSEPH J. SCHIAVONE , BUDD LARNER, PC.

GENERAL REINSURANCE CORP., Defendant, represented by JOSEPH J. SCHIAVONE , BUDD LARNER, PC.

GREENWICH INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by ALAN PATRICK SMITH , CAHILL, GORDON & REINDEL, LLP, AMY E. BARABAS , CAHILL, GORDON & REINDELL, LLP, CAROLINE SPINDLER WHITTEMORE , CAHILL, GORDON & REINDEL, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JUSTIN M. GIOVANNELLI , CAHILL, GORDON & REINDEL, LLP & TAMMY L. ROY , CAHILL, GORDON & REINDEL, LLP.

GULF INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by BRYCE L. FRIEDMAN , SIMPSON, THACHER & BARTLETT, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL & MICHAEL J. GARVEY , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP.

HARTFORD STEAM BOILER INSPECTION AND INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , KENNETH A. GALLO , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP & MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

ILLINOIS UNION INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

INDEMNITY INSURANCE CO. NORTH AMERICA, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

INDIAN HARBOR INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by ALAN PATRICK SMITH , CAHILL, GORDON & REINDEL, LLP, AMY E. BARABAS , CAHILL, GORDON & REINDELL, LLP, CAROLINE SPINDLER WHITTEMORE , CAHILL, GORDON & REINDEL, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JUSTIN M. GIOVANNELLI , CAHILL, GORDON & REINDEL, LLP & TAMMY L. ROY , CAHILL, GORDON & REINDEL, LLP.

LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & KEVIN JOSEPH FEE , Duane Morris LLP.

LIBERTY MUTUAL HOLDING CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & KEVIN JOSEPH FEE , Duane Morris LLP.

NATIONAL SURETY CORP., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

NATIONAL UNION FIRE INSURANCE CO. OF LOUISIANA, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & KENNETH A. GALLO , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP.

NATIONAL UNION FIRE INSURANCE CO. OF PITTSBURG, PA, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , KENNETH A. GALLO , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP & MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

NEW HAMPSHIRE INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & KENNETH A. GALLO , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP.

NUTMEG LIFE INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

PACIFIC INSURANCE CO., LTD, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

ST. PAUL FIRE & MARINE INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by BRYCE L. FRIEDMAN , SIMPSON, THACHER & BARTLETT, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL & MICHAEL J. GARVEY , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP.

ST. PAUL MERCURY INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by BRYCE L. FRIEDMAN , SIMPSON, THACHER & BARTLETT, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL & MICHAEL J. GARVEY , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP.

STEADFAST INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by ELIZABETH BARRY SANDZA , LEBOEUF, LAMB, GREENE & MACRAE, LLP.

SUMMIT GLOBAL PARTNERS OF FLORIDA, INC., Defendant, represented by ROBERT HARDY PEES , AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAUER & FELD, LLP.

THE CHUBB CORP., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & PETER RICHARD BISIO , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

THE CONTINENTAL INSURANCE GROUP, Defendant, represented by MICHAEL R. BLANKSHAIN , WILDMAN, HARROLD, ALLEN & DIXON, LLP, MICHAEL LEE MCCLUGGAGE , WILDMAN, HARROLD, ALLEN & DIXON, LLP & MATTHEW JOSEPH CACCAMO , WILDMAN HARROLD ALLEN & DIXON.

THE HARTFORD FIDELITY & BONDING, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

THE INSURANCE COMPANY OF THE STATE OF PENNSYLVANIA, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

TRAVELERS CASUALTY AND SURETY CO. OF AMERICA, Defendant, represented by BRYCE L. FRIEDMAN , SIMPSON, THACHER & BARTLETT, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , MICHAEL J. GARVEY , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP & MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

TRAVELERS INDEMNITY COMPANY, Defendant, represented by BRYCE L. FRIEDMAN , SIMPSON, THACHER & BARTLETT, LLP, MICHAEL J. GARVEY , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP, MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP & DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

UNITED STATES FIRE INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , LOUIS G. CORSI , LANDMAN, CORSI, BALLAINE & FORD, CHRISTOPHER G. FRETEL , LANDMAN, CORSI, BALLAINE & FORD & STEPHEN JACOBS , LANDMAN, CORSI, BALLAINE & FORD.

UNITED STATES FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , LOUIS G. CORSI , LANDMAN, CORSI, BALLAINE & FORD, CHRISTOPHER G. FRETEL , LANDMAN, CORSI, BALLAINE & FORD & STEPHEN JACOBS , LANDMAN, CORSI, BALLAINE & FORD.

USI INSURANCE SERVICES OF FLORIDA, INC., Defendant, represented by ROBERT HARDY PEES , AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAUER & FELD, LLP.

VIGILANT INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & PETER RICHARD BISIO , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

WAUSAU UNDERWRITERS INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & KEVIN JOSEPH FEE , Duane Morris LLP.

WESTCHESTER SURPLUS LINES INSURANCE CO., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

WILLIS OF NEW YORK, INC., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JEFFREY T. SCOTT , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL LLP & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

XL CAPITAL LTD., Defendant, represented by ALAN PATRICK SMITH , CAHILL, GORDON & REINDEL, LLP, CAROLINE SPINDLER WHITTEMORE , CAHILL, GORDON & REINDEL, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL & JUSTIN M. GIOVANNELLI , CAHILL, GORDON & REINDEL, LLP.

AON RISK SERVICES OF THE CAROLINAS INC, Defendant, represented by AMY D. HARMON , NEXSEN, PRUET, JACOBS & POLLARD, MARGUERITE S. WILLIS , NEXSEN, PRUET, JACOBS & POLLARD & RUSSELL THOMAS BURKE , NEXSEN PRUET JACOBS & POLLARD.

INSURANCE CO OF THE STATE OF PENNSYLVANIA, Defendant, represented by KENNETH A. GALLO , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP & DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

MARSH & MCLENNAN, INC., Defendant, represented by ANDREW T. BERRY , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP, DANIEL P. JORDAN , BUTLER, SNOW, O'MARA, STEVENS & CANNADA, PLLC & P. RYAN BECKETT , BUTLER, SNOW, O'MARA, STEVENS & CANNADA, PLLC.

RLI INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

DISCOVER RE MANAGERS, INC.,, Defendant, represented by MIRIAM THERESA DOWD , BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN, LLP.

DISCOVER REINSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by BARRY HASSELL , COPELAND, COOK, TAYLOR & BUSH, CHARLES GREG COPELAND , COPELAND, COOK, TAYLOR & BUSH, MICHAEL W. BAXTER , COPELAND, COOK, TAYLOR & BUSH & MIRIAM THERESA DOWD , BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN, LLP.

DISCOVERY MANAGERS LTD, Defendant, represented by BARRY HASSELL , COPELAND, COOK, TAYLOR & BUSH, CHARLES GREG COPELAND , COPELAND, COOK, TAYLOR & BUSH, MICHAEL W. BAXTER , COPELAND, COOK, TAYLOR & BUSH & MIRIAM THERESA DOWD , BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN, LLP.

UNITED STATES FIDELITY & GUARANTY COMPANY, Defendant, represented by BARRY HASSELL , COPELAND, COOK, TAYLOR & BUSH, CHARLES GREG COPELAND , COPELAND, COOK, TAYLOR & BUSH, MICHAEL W. BAXTER , COPELAND, COOK, TAYLOR & BUSH & MIRIAM THERESA DOWD , BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN, LLP.

UNITED STATES FIDELITY AND GUARANTY SPECIALITY INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by MIRIAM THERESA DOWD , BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN, LLP.

MARK A SMITH, Defendant, represented by KEVIN F. HORMUTH , GREENSFELDER & HEMKER, KEVIN F. O'MALLEY , GREENSFELDER & HEMKER & MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL GROUP, Defendant, represented by CHRIS S. COUTROULIS , CARLTON FIELDS, PA, JAMES E. FOSTER , AKERMAN SENTERFITT, STEVEN J. BRODIE , CARLTON FIELDS, PA, VIRGINIA B. TOWNES , AKERMAN SENTERFITT & DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

WILLIS NORTH AMERICAN INC, Defendant, represented by ANASTASIA ANGELOVA , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , FREDRICK H. MCCLURE , PIP RUDNICK LLP, JOHN L. WARDEN , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

HARTFORD INSURANCE CO OF THE SOUTHEAST, Defendant, represented by JAMES E. FOSTER , AKERMAN SENTERFITT & VIRGINIA B. TOWNES , AKERMAN SENTERFITT.

HARTFORD UNDERWRITER INS. CO., Defendant, represented by JAMES E. FOSTER , AKERMAN SENTERFITT & VIRGINIA B. TOWNES , AKERMAN SENTERFITT.

USI HOLDINGS INC, Defendant, represented by DENIS L. DURKIN , BAKER & HOSTETLER, LLP, RACHEL L. GERSTEIN , AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAUER & FELD, LLP & ROBERT HARDY PEES , AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAUER & FELD, LLP.

JOSEPH E LAMPEN, Defendant, represented by KEVIN F. HORMUTH , GREENSFELDER & HEMKER, KEVIN F. O'MALLEY , GREENSFELDER & HEMKER & MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

MARSH USA INC OF LOUISIANA, Defendant, represented by DANIEL P. JORDAN , BUTLER, SNOW, O'MARA, STEVENS & CANNADA, PLLC & P. RYAN BECKETT , BUTLER, SNOW, O'MARA, STEVENS & CANNADA, PLLC.

MARSHA USA INC, Defendant, represented by ANDREW T. BERRY , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP & DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

MARSH & MCLENNAN INCORPORATED, Defendant, represented by ANDREW T. BERRY , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

HARTFORD STEAM BOILER INSPECTION & INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

NATIONAL UNION FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY OF PITTSBURG PA, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

NAVIGATORS INSURANCE SERVICES OF TEXAS INC, Defendant, represented by ELTON F. DUNCAN , DUNCAN, COURINGTON & RYDBERG, JESSICA G. ROUX , DUNCAN, COURINGTON & RYDBERG, KELLEY SEVIN , DUNCAN, COURINGTON & RYDBERG & THOMAS A. FRENCH , DUNCAN, COURINGTON & RYDBERG.

THE CONTINENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & MATTHEW JOSEPH CACCAMO , WILDMAN HARROLD ALLEN & DIXON.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, Defendant, represented by JAMES B. CLARK, III , OFFICE OF THE US ATTORNEY.

GUY CARPENTER & COMPANY, INC., Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

MARSH & MCLENNAN COMPANIES, INC., Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL , MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP & BRIAN J. OSIAS , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

MARSH ADVANTAGE AMERICA, Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

MARSH GLOBAL BROKING, INC. (MISSOURI), Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

MARSH GLOBAL BROKING, INC. (NEW JERSEY), Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

MARSH GLOBAL PLACEMENT, Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

MARSH INC., Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP & BRIAN J. OSIAS , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

MARSH USA INC. (CONNECTICUT), Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL & MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

MARSH USA INC., Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL & BRIAN J. OSIAS , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

SEABURY & SMITH INC., Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP, DANIEL J. LEFFELL & MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

MARSH & MCLENNAN COMPANIES, INC., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP & BRIAN J. OSIAS , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

MARSH ADVANTAGE AMERICA, Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

MARSH INC., Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP & BRIAN J. OSIAS , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

MARSH USA INC. (CONNECTICUT), Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

MARSH USA INC., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP & BRIAN J. OSIAS , MCCARTER & ENGLISH, LLP.

SEABURY & SMITH INC., Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & CHRISTOPHER J. ST. JEANOS , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

MARSH & MCLENNAN, Defendant, represented by DARREN K. NELSON , PARR, WADDOUPS, BROWN, GEE & LOVELESS.

MARSH, Defendant, represented by DARREN K. NELSON , PARR, WADDOUPS, BROWN, GEE & LOVELESS.

MAX RE LTD., Defendant, represented by THOMAS F. BUSH , Locke Lord LLP & KATHRYN K. WYCOFF , LOVELLS.

USI CONSULTING GROUP, Defendant, represented by ROBERT HARDY PEES , AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAUER & FELD, LLP.

USI SERVICES CORPORATION, Defendant, represented by ROBERT HARDY PEES , AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAUER & FELD, LLP.

NAVIGATORS GROUP INC., Defendant, represented by KEVIN R.J. SCHROTH , Cole, Schotz, Meisel, Forman & Leonard.

GREAT AMERICAN ASSURANCE CO., Defendant, Pro Se.

AMERICAN PROTECTION INSURANCE CO., Defendant, Pro se.

LUMBERMENS MUTUAL CASUALTY CO., Defendant, Pro se.

MARSH PLACEMENT INC, Defendant, represented by DAVID C. GUSTMAN , FREEBORN & PETERS, JILL CHRISTINE ANDERSON , FREEBORN & PETERS & MITCHELL JAY AUSLANDER , WILLKIE FARR & GALLAGHER LLP.

MARSH USA INC (NEVADA), Defendant, represented by DAVID C. GUSTMAN , FREEBORN & PETERS & JILL CHRISTINE ANDERSON , FREEBORN & PETERS.

AIG LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL .

UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYD'S OF LONDON, ORGANIZED AS SYNDICATE 2001 (AML), Defendant, represented by JOHN M. TORIELLO , HOLLAND & KNIGHT, LLP & PAULINE TERRY HA .

AETNA INC., Defendant, represented by JOHN HERFORT , GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER & JAMES HALLOWELL , GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER.

THOSE CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYD'S LONDON, MEMBERS OF SYNDICATES 190 AND 282 FOR THE UNDERWRITING YEARS AT ISSUE, Defendant, represented by PAUL L. FIELDS, Jr. , STACEY SEXTON FARRELL & GREGORY L. MAST , FIELDS, HOWELL, ATHANS & MCLAUGHLIN.

MARSH RISK CONSULTING, Defendant, represented by DONALD ARTHUR BLACKWELL , ANANIA, BANDKLAYDER, BLACKWELL & BAUMGARTEN & FRANCIS A. ANANIA , ANANIA, BANDKLAYDER, BLACKWELL & BAUMGARTEN.

AFFILIATED FM INSURANCE COMPAMY, Defendant, represented by GEORGE BENNET FORBES .

ACE GROUP HOLDINGS, INC., Defendant, represented by MARC D. HAEFNER , WALSH PIZZI O'REILLY FALANGA LLP.

AXIS CAPITAL HOLDINGS LIMITED, Defendant, represented by WILLIAM F. CLARKE, Jr. , SKADDEN, ARPS, SLATE, MEAGHER & FLOM. LLP.

CHUBB & SON, INC., Defendant, represented by PETER RICHARD BISIO , HOGAN LOVELLS US LLP.

WILLIS OF MICHIGAN, INC., Defendant, represented by JEFFREY T. SCOTT , SULLIVAN & CROMWELL LLP & RICHARD C. PEPPERMAN, II , SULLLIVAN & CROMWELL, LLP.

Athena Assurance Company, Defendant, represented by PATRICK T. SHILLING , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP.

GULF INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by PATRICK T. SHILLING , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP.

ST. PAUL FIRE AND MARINE INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by PATRICK T. SHILLING , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP.

ST. PAUL MERCURY INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by PATRICK T. SHILLING , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP.

THE TRAVELERS COMPANIES, INC., Defendant, represented by PATRICK T. SHILLING , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP.

THE TRAVELERS INDEMNITY COMPANY, Defendant, represented by PATRICK T. SHILLING , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP.

TRAVELERS CASUALTY AND SURETY COMPANY OF AMERICA, Defendant, represented by PATRICK T. SHILLING , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP.

Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's, London Organized as Syndicate 2001, Defendant, represented by DUVOL M. THOMPSON , HOLLAND & KNIGHT LLP.

Donald R. Pierson, Defendant, Pro Se.

ARCH CAPITAL GROUP, LTD, Defendant, Pro se.

ARCH INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, Pro se.

ARCH REINSURANCE LIMITED, Defendant, Pro se.

ARCH SPECIALTY INSURANCE CO., Defendant, Pro se.

LLOYDS LONDON SYNDICATE 2791 MAP, Defendant, represented by THOMAS F. BUSH , Locke Lord LLP.

Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's of London Organized as Syndicate of 2001 (AML), Defendant, represented by ROBERT J. BURNS .

Certain Underwriters at Lloyds, London organized as syndicates 33, 102, 382, 435, 510, 623, 727, 958, 1003, 1084, 1096, 1183, 1245, 1886, 2003, 2020, 2623 and 2987, Defendant, represented by ANNE JOHNSON PALMER , MATTHEW M. BURKE , ROPES & GRAY LLP & ROBERT A. SKINNER .

Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's London organized as Syndicates 570 and 609, Defendant, represented by ABIGAIL NITKA , MESSNER REEVES,LLP & WENDY JEANNE LINDSTROM , Messner Reeves LLP.

Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's London organized as Syndicate 2020, Defendant, represented by WENDY JEANNE LINDSTROM , Messner Reeves LLP.

Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's London Organized as Syndicates 2488, Defendant, represented by MATTHEW M. BURKE .

Lloyd's Syndicate 1967, Defendant, represented by MATTHEW M. BURKE .

Lloyd's Syndicate 4020, Defendant, represented by WENDY JEANNE LINDSTROM , Messner Reeves LLP & ABIGAIL NITKA , MESSNER REEVES,LLP.

Lloyd's Syndicates 4040 and 4141, Defendant, represented by FELICE BETH GALANT , NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT US LLP & LAYNE EDWIN KRUSE , Norton Rose Fulbright US LLP.

Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's London Organized as Syndicates 4040 and 4141, Defendant, represented by FELICE BETH GALANT , NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT US LLP & LAYNE EDWIN KRUSE , Norton Rose Fulbright US LLP.

AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL SPECIALTY LINES INSURANCE CO., Defendant Consolidated, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL , JEFFREY MICHAEL COHEN , CARLTON FIELDS, KENNETH A. GALLO , PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND, WHARTON & GARRISON, LLP, STEVEN J. BRODIE , CARLTON FIELDS, PA & PATRICIA C. CROWLEY , PAUL WEISS RIFKIND WHARTON & GARRISON LLP.

LEXINGTON INSURANCE CO., Defendant Consolidated, represented by DANIEL J. LEFFELL & PATRICIA C. CROWLEY , PAUL WEISS RIFKIND WHARTON & GARRISON LLP.

INTERVENOR ATTORNEYS GENERAL, Intervenor, represented by GREGG ABBOTT , OFFICE OF THE TEXAS ATTORNEY GENERAL.

RSR Corporation, Intervenor, represented by DAVID THOMAS HENEK , BICKEL & BREWER.


NOT FOR PUBLICATION

OPINION

I. INTRODUCTION

This matter comes before the Court on the motion of Defendants Marsh & McLennan Companies, Inc., Marsh USA Inc., and Marsh Inc. (collectively, "Marsh" or "Defendants") to dismiss the Second Amended Complaint...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases