ARRINGTON v. ANA P. HALL CONSTRUCTION, L.L.C.

Civil Action No. 2:15cv711-PCH.

WALTER ARRINGTON, III, An Individual, et al., Plaintiffs, v. ANA P. HALL CONSTRUCTION, L.L.C., an unregistered foreign limited liability corporation; et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, M.D. Alabama, Northern Division.

August 12, 2016.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Walter Arrington, III, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Danita Brown, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Lyndon Baldwin, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Nathaniel Bloodsaw, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Beverly Moultry, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Melanie Blue, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Jasmine Blue, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Santana Bren, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Dominique Brittin, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Destiny Broaden, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Jaquarrie Bean, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Candice Brown, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Jarvis Quinn, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Deborah Brown, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Kiaris Brown, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Sharon Brown, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Houston Henderson, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Eloris Chislom, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Jasmine Cook, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Benneton Hawkins, Plaintiff, represented by David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Beverly Crumpton, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Jerical Davis, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Cory Powell, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Kristi Faire, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Brittany Gholsten, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Eric Harris, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Erin Hoskins, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Latoya Hoskins, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Curtis Julius, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Barbra Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Printice Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Sabrina Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Shawn Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Jamie Williams, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Robert Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Barbara Burke, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Kenya Burke, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

David Island, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Aaryon Island, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Jadarius Jones, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Emma Julius, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Marie Julius, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Jurveskie Julius, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Laquetta Lamar, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Denardo Laster, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Willie Lawrence, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Sharon Knight, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Deldrick Knight, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Kanavius Knight, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Thomas Lee, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Althea Lewis, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Bronica Lewis, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Christine Lewis, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Melissa Lewis, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Donna McCall, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Sheoka McCall, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Rotwanda McGhee, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Raven McMillian, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Nakeyta McQueen, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Frederick Ligon, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Willie K. Mills, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Tamela Moore, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Latisha Moore, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Lachandra Orum, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Latonya Orum, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Nadine Orum, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Shanteria Orum, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Crystal Phillips, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Laura Phillips, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Tonya Simmons, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Dameon Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Willie Simmons, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Ashley Smith, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Tabitha Stinson, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Gloria Thomas, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Natalie Thomas, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Arnold Ramson, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Pamela Tucker, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Jawaun Tucker, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Ashley Young, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Guardian Ad Litem, on behalf of B.H. a minor (son of R.L., a minor), Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

All Plaintiffs, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Erica Hoskins, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Allen Colvin, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Tomica Jernigan, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Elnora Jernigan, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Jackie Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Tetrina Johnson, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Rickey Oliver, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC.

Rickey Oliver, Plaintiff, represented by David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Tiffany Flynn, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Cheryl Simmons, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

All Intervenor Plaintiffs, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Arielle Surles, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Derek Surles, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Porsha Freeman, Plaintiff, represented by David Craig Allred , Allred & Allred, PC, David Earl Allred , Allred & Allred, PC & Norman Osaygefo Grubbs , Reed & Associates, LLC.

Ana P. Hall Construction, L.L.C., Defendant, represented by Bradford J. Griffin , The Law Offices of Vickers & White, PLLC, Lindsay C. Ronilo , The Law Offices of Vickers & White, PLLC, Caroline Thomason Pryor , Carr Allison, Jonathan R. Maples , Carr Allison & Matthew Bruce Hall , Carr Allison.

Ana Paula Olinquevi Hall, Defendant, represented by Bradford J. Griffin , The Law Offices of Vickers & White, PLLC, Lindsay C. Ronilo , The Law Offices of Vickers & White, PLLC, Caroline Thomason Pryor , Carr Allison, Jonathan R. Maples , Carr Allison & Matthew Bruce Hall , Carr Allison.

Southern Holdings, II, L.L.C., Defendant, represented by John Edward Goodman , Bradley Arant Boult Cummings LLP, Michael Robert Lunsford , Porterfield Harper Mills Motlow & Ireland PA, Joseph Mitchell Hastings , Porterfield Harper Mills Motlow & Ireland PA & Larry William Harper , Porterfield Harper Mills Motlow & Ireland PA.

John R. Hurst, Defendant, represented by John Edward Goodman , Bradley Arant Boult Cummings LLP, Michael Robert Lunsford , Porterfield Harper Mills Motlow & Ireland PA & Joseph Mitchell Hastings , Porterfield Harper Mills Motlow & Ireland PA.

Barbara Provitt, Defendant, represented by Bradford J. Griffin , The Law Offices of Vickers & White, PLLC, Caroline Thomason Pryor , Carr Allison, Jonathan R. Maples , Carr Allison, Lindsay C. Ronilo , The Law Offices of Vickers & White, PLLC & Matthew Bruce Hall , Carr Allison.

Jessica Brown, Defendant, represented by Michael Robert Lunsford , Porterfield Harper Mills Motlow & Ireland PA & Joseph Mitchell Hastings , Porterfield Harper Mills Motlow & Ireland PA.

Alfonso Santos, Defendant, represented by Bradford J. Griffin , The Law Offices of Vickers & White, PLLC, Lindsay C. Ronilo , The Law Offices of Vickers & White, PLLC, Caroline Thomason Pryor , Carr Allison, Jonathan R. Maples , Carr Allison & Matthew Bruce Hall , Carr Allison.


OPINION

The approximately 200 plaintiffs in this case brought a number of contract and tort claims against the corporate and individual defendants in state court. The plaintiffs alleged that they all lived in an apartment complex owned, operated, or managed by the defendants, and suffered various harms as...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases