LATIF v. LYNCH

No. 3:10-cv-10-00750-BR.

AYMAN LATIF; MOHAMED SHEIKH ABDIRAHMAN KARIYE; RAYMOND EARL KNAEBLE, IV; STEVEN WILLIAM WASHBURN; NAGIB ALI GHALEB; ABDULLATIF MUTHANNA; FAISAL NABIN KASHEM; ELIAS MUSTAFA MOHAMED; IBRAHEIM Y. MASHAL; SALAH ALI AHMED; AMIR MESHAL; STEPHEN DURGA PERSAUD; and MASHAAL RANA, Plaintiffs, v. LORETTA E. LYNCH, in her official capacity as Attorney General of the United States; JAMES B. COMEY, in his official capacity as Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation; and CHRISTOPHER M. PIEHOTA, in his official capacity as Director of the FBI Terrorist Screening Center, Defendants.

United States District Court, D. Oregon.

March 28, 2016.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Ayman Latif, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice, Catherine A. Wagner , American Civil Liberties, pro hac vice, Hina Shamsi , American Civil Liberties Union, pro hac vice, Hugh Handeyside , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, pro hac vice, Steven M. Wilker , Tonkon Torp LLP, Ahilan Arulanantham , ACLU Foundation of Southern California, pro hac vice, Alan L. Schlosser , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Julia Harumi Mass , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Mitchell P. Hurley , Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, pro hac vice & Reem Salahi , Salahi Law, pro hac vice.

Mohamed Sheikh Abdirahm Kariye, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice, Catherine A. Wagner , American Civil Liberties, pro hac vice, Hina Shamsi , American Civil Liberties Union, pro hac vice, Hugh Handeyside , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, pro hac vice, Steven M. Wilker , Tonkon Torp LLP, Ahilan Arulanantham , ACLU Foundation of Southern California, pro hac vice, Alan L. Schlosser , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Julia Harumi Mass , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Mitchell P. Hurley , Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, pro hac vice & Reem Salahi , Salahi Law, pro hac vice.

Raymond Earl Knaeble, IV, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice, Catherine A. Wagner , American Civil Liberties, pro hac vice, Hina Shamsi , American Civil Liberties Union, pro hac vice, Hugh Handeyside , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, pro hac vice, Steven M. Wilker , Tonkon Torp LLP, Ahilan Arulanantham , ACLU Foundation of Southern California, pro hac vice, Alan L. Schlosser , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Julia Harumi Mass , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Mitchell P. Hurley , Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, pro hac vice & Reem Salahi , Salahi Law, pro hac vice.

Steven William Washburn, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice, Catherine A. Wagner , American Civil Liberties, pro hac vice, Hina Shamsi , American Civil Liberties Union, pro hac vice, Hugh Handeyside , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, pro hac vice, Steven M. Wilker , Tonkon Torp LLP, Ahilan Arulanantham , ACLU Foundation of Southern California, pro hac vice, Alan L. Schlosser , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Julia Harumi Mass , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Mitchell P. Hurley , Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, pro hac vice & Reem Salahi , Salahi Law, pro hac vice.

Nagib Ali Ghaleb, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice, Catherine A. Wagner , American Civil Liberties, pro hac vice, Hina Shamsi , American Civil Liberties Union, pro hac vice, Hugh Handeyside , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, pro hac vice, Steven M. Wilker , Tonkon Torp LLP, Ahilan Arulanantham , ACLU Foundation of Southern California, pro hac vice, Alan L. Schlosser , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Julia Harumi Mass , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Mitchell P. Hurley , Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, pro hac vice & Reem Salahi , Salahi Law, pro hac vice.

Abdullatif Muthanna, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice, Catherine A. Wagner , American Civil Liberties, pro hac vice, Hina Shamsi , American Civil Liberties Union, pro hac vice, Hugh Handeyside , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, pro hac vice, Steven M. Wilker , Tonkon Torp LLP, Ahilan Arulanantham , ACLU Foundation of Southern California, pro hac vice, Alan L. Schlosser , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Julia Harumi Mass , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Mitchell P. Hurley , Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, pro hac vice & Reem Salahi , Salahi Law, pro hac vice.

Faisal Nabin Kashem, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice, Catherine A. Wagner , American Civil Liberties, pro hac vice, Hina Shamsi , American Civil Liberties Union, pro hac vice, Hugh Handeyside , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, pro hac vice, Steven M. Wilker , Tonkon Torp LLP, Ahilan Arulanantham , ACLU Foundation of Southern California, pro hac vice, Alan L. Schlosser , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice & Julia Harumi Mass , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice.

Elias Mustafa Mohamed, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice, Catherine A. Wagner , American Civil Liberties, pro hac vice, Hina Shamsi , American Civil Liberties Union, pro hac vice, Hugh Handeyside , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, pro hac vice, Steven M. Wilker , Tonkon Torp LLP, Ahilan Arulanantham , ACLU Foundation of Southern California, pro hac vice, Alan L. Schlosser , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice & Julia Harumi Mass , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice.

Ibraheim Y. Mashal, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice, Catherine A. Wagner , American Civil Liberties, pro hac vice, Hina Shamsi , American Civil Liberties Union, pro hac vice, Hugh Handeyside , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, pro hac vice, Steven M. Wilker , Tonkon Torp LLP, Ahilan Arulanantham , ACLU Foundation of Southern California, pro hac vice, Alan L. Schlosser , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice & Julia Harumi Mass , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice.

Salah Ali Ahmed, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice, Catherine A. Wagner , American Civil Liberties, pro hac vice, Hina Shamsi , American Civil Liberties Union, pro hac vice, Hugh Handeyside , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, pro hac vice, Steven M. Wilker , Tonkon Torp LLP, Ahilan Arulanantham , ACLU Foundation of Southern California, pro hac vice, Alan L. Schlosser , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice & Julia Harumi Mass , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice.

Amir Meshal, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice, Catherine A. Wagner , American Civil Liberties, pro hac vice, Hina Shamsi , American Civil Liberties Union, pro hac vice, Hugh Handeyside , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, pro hac vice, Steven M. Wilker , Tonkon Torp LLP, Ahilan Arulanantham , ACLU Foundation of Southern California, pro hac vice, Alan L. Schlosser , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice & Julia Harumi Mass , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice.

Stephen Durga Persaud, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice, Hina Shamsi , American Civil Liberties Union, pro hac vice, Hugh Handeyside , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, pro hac vice, William J. Genego , Law Office of William Genego, pro hac vice, Ahilan Arulanantham , ACLU Foundation of Southern California, pro hac vice, Alan L. Schlosser , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Julia Harumi Mass , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice & Joel P. Leonard , Elliott, Ostrander & Preston, P.C..

Mashaal Rana, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice, Catherine A. Wagner , American Civil Liberties, pro hac vice, Hina Shamsi , American Civil Liberties Union, pro hac vice, Hugh Handeyside , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, pro hac vice, Steven M. Wilker , Tonkon Torp LLP, Ahilan Arulanantham , ACLU Foundation of Southern California, pro hac vice, Alan L. Schlosser , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Julia Harumi Mass , ACLU of Northern California, pro hac vice, Mitchell P. Hurley , Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, pro hac vice & Reem Salahi , Salahi Law, pro hac vice.

United States Department of Justice, Defendant, represented by Adam D. Kirschner , Department of Justice, Amy Elizabeth Powell , US Department of Justice, Brigham J. Bowen , US Department of Justice & James E. Cox, Jr. , U.S. Attorney's Office.

United States Department of Justice, Defendant, represented by Samuel M. Singer , Department of Justice.

United States Department of Justice, Defendant, represented by Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice.

Federal Bureau of Investigation, Defendant, represented by Adam D. Kirschner , Department of Justice, Amy Elizabeth Powell , US Department of Justice, Brigham J. Bowen , US Department of Justice, James E. Cox, Jr. , U.S. Attorney's Office, Samuel M. Singer , Department of Justice & Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice.

Terrorist Screening Center, Defendant, represented by Adam D. Kirschner , Department of Justice, Amy Elizabeth Powell , US Department of Justice, Brigham J. Bowen , US Department of Justice, James E. Cox, Jr. , U.S. Attorney's Office, Samuel M. Singer , Department of Justice & Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice.

The Constitution Project, Amicus, represented by Devin N. Robinson , Law Offices of Devin Robinson, P.C., Rita M. Siemion , pro hac vice & Alexandra F. Smith , American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of New Mexico, pro hac vice.


OPINION AND ORDER

This "No-Fly List" case was filed nearly six years ago,2 has been before this Court on remand from the Ninth Circuit for nearly three years, and now comes before the Court on various Motions for Partial Summary Judgment as enumerated below. Although other courts...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases