TUVELL v. PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION OF DIVE INSTRUCTORS

Case No. 1:12-cv-00128-DB-DBP.

CHRISTOPHER JOSEPH TUVELL, SHERRY LYNN TUVELL, individually and as heirs of David Christopher Tuvell, and THE ESTATE OF DAVID CHRISTOPHER TUVELL Plaintiffs, v. PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION OF DIVE INSTRUCTORS ("PADI"), BLUE WATER SCUBA, LOWELL HUBER, CORBETT DOUGLAS, Defendants.

United States District Court, D. Utah, Northern Division.

May 22, 2015.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Christopher Joseph Tuvell, Plaintiff, represented by Alton J. Hall, Jr. , DELISE & HALL & Robert G. Gilchrist , EISENBERG GILCHRIST & CUTT.

Sherry Lynn Tuvell, Plaintiff, represented by Alton J. Hall, Jr. , DELISE & HALL & Robert G. Gilchrist , EISENBERG GILCHRIST & CUTT.

Estate of David Christopher Tuvell, Plaintiff, represented by Alton J. Hall, Jr. , DELISE & HALL & Robert G. Gilchrist , EISENBERG GILCHRIST & CUTT.

Professional Association of Dive Instructors, Defendant, represented by Mark A. Hruska , VERNIS & BOWLING, Roger H. Bullock , STRONG & HANNI & S. Spencer Brown , STRONG & HANNI.

Blue Water Scuba, Defendant, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC, Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC & Meghan A. Sheridan , W & LAW.

Lowell Huber, Defendant, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC, Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC & Meghan A. Sheridan , W & LAW.

Corbett Douglas, Defendant, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC, Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC & Meghan A. Sheridan , W & LAW.

Kim LaMotte-Malone, M.D., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Jaryl L. Rencher , STUCKI RENCHER & Patricia Egan Daehnke , BONNE BRIDGES MUELLER O'KEEFE & NICHOLS.

Brian K. Shrawder, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Patricia Egan Daehnke , BONNE BRIDGES MUELLER O'KEEFE & NICHOLS.

LaMotte Pediatrics LLP, dba Anthem Hills Pediatrics, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Patricia Egan Daehnke , BONNE BRIDGES MUELLER O'KEEFE & NICHOLS.

Kim LaMotte-Malone PC, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Patricia Egan Daehnke , BONNE BRIDGES MUELLER O'KEEFE & NICHOLS.

Blue Water Scuba, Cross Defendant, represented by Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Corbett Douglas, Cross Defendant, represented by Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Lowell Huber, Cross Defendant, represented by Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Professional Association of Dive Instructors, Cross Defendant, represented by Mark A. Hruska , VERNIS & BOWLING, Roger H. Bullock , STRONG & HANNI & S. Spencer Brown , STRONG & HANNI.

Blue Water Scuba, Cross Defendant, represented by Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Lowell Huber, Cross Defendant, represented by Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Corbett Douglas, Cross Claimant, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Blue Water Scuba, Cross Claimant, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Lowell Huber, Cross Claimant, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Professional Association of Dive Instructors, Cross Defendant, represented by Mark A. Hruska , VERNIS & BOWLING, Roger H. Bullock , STRONG & HANNI & S. Spencer Brown , STRONG & HANNI.

Professional Association of Dive Instructors, Cross Claimant, represented by Mark A. Hruska , VERNIS & BOWLING, Roger H. Bullock , STRONG & HANNI & S. Spencer Brown , STRONG & HANNI.

Blue Water Scuba, Cross Defendant, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Corbett Douglas, Cross Defendant, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Lowell Huber, Cross Defendant, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Lowell Huber, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Corbett Douglas, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Blue Water Scuba, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Kim LaMotte-Malone PC, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Jaryl L. Rencher , STUCKI RENCHER & Patricia Egan Daehnke , BONNE BRIDGES MUELLER O'KEEFE & NICHOLS.

LaMotte Pediatrics LLP, dba Anthem Hills Pediatrics, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Jaryl L. Rencher , STUCKI RENCHER.

LaMotte Pediatrics LLP, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Patricia Egan Daehnke , BONNE BRIDGES MUELLER O'KEEFE & NICHOLS.

Kim LaMotte-Malone, M.D., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Patricia Egan Daehnke , BONNE BRIDGES MUELLER O'KEEFE & NICHOLS.

Brian K. Shrawder, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Patricia Egan Daehnke , BONNE BRIDGES MUELLER O'KEEFE & NICHOLS.

Lowell Huber, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Blue Water Scuba, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Corbett Douglas, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Kim LaMotte-Malone PC, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Jaryl L. Rencher , STUCKI RENCHER & Patricia Egan Daehnke , BONNE BRIDGES MUELLER O'KEEFE & NICHOLS.

LaMotte Pediatrics LLP, dba Anthem Hills Pediatrics, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Jaryl L. Rencher , STUCKI RENCHER & Patricia Egan Daehnke , BONNE BRIDGES MUELLER O'KEEFE & NICHOLS.

Kim LaMotte-Malone, M.D., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Jaryl L. Rencher , STUCKI RENCHER & Patricia Egan Daehnke , BONNE BRIDGES MUELLER O'KEEFE & NICHOLS.

Brian K. Shrawder, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Patricia Egan Daehnke , BONNE BRIDGES MUELLER O'KEEFE & NICHOLS.

Professional Association of Dive Instructors, Cross Claimant, represented by Mark A. Hruska , VERNIS & BOWLING, Roger H. Bullock , STRONG & HANNI & S. Spencer Brown , STRONG & HANNI.

Blue Water Scuba, Cross Defendant, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Corbett Douglas, Cross Defendant, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.

Lowell Huber, Cross Defendant, represented by David G. Concannon , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC, Gainer M. Waldbillig , W & LAW, Jonathan Z. Cohen , JONATHAN Z COHEN LTD, Katy R. M. Strand , BERRETT & HANNA LC & Matthew T. Charles , LAW OFFICE OF DAVID G CONCANNON LLC.


MEMORANDUM DECISION

This matter was referred to the Court under 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1)(A). (Dkt. 213.) This lawsuit arises from a July 2011 scuba diving accident and resultant death of David Christopher Tuvell. Plaintiffs bring the present motion to strike portions of Dr. Thomas Powell's expert report...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases