CHAPIN v. GREAT SOUTHERN WOOD PRESERVING, INC.

Civil No. 2012-77.

CARY CHAPIN, et al., Plaintiffs, v. GREAT SOUTHERN WOOD PRESERVING, INC., et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, D. Virgin Islands, Division of St. Thomas and St. John.

September 19, 2014.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Cary Chapin, Plaintiff, represented by Bonnie Prober , Cuneo Gilbert LaDuca, LLP, Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Terri L. Griffiths , Jordan S. Cohen , Wicker Smith O'Hara McCoy & Ford & Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter.

Barbara Douma, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Emily J Bratton, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

John Baldwin, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter, Terri L. Griffiths & Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Dean Baldwin, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter, Terri L. Griffiths & Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Terry R Whitham, Plaintiff, represented by Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter, Terri L. Griffiths & Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Ann McCrave, Plaintiff, represented by Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter, Terri L. Griffiths & Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Jeffrey J McCrave, Plaintiff, represented by Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter, Terri L. Griffiths & Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Celso Principaal, Plaintiff, represented by Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter, Terri L. Griffiths & Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Harry Eisener, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Cynthia Sauers, Plaintiff, represented by Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter, Terri L. Griffiths & Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Elisa Adams, Plaintiff, represented by CHARLES J LADUCA , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Michael James Flannery , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Denise Barbier, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter, Terri L. Griffiths & Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Truman Barbier, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter, Terri L. Griffiths & Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Jean Cottrell, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Stephen Cottrell, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Nancy Nemeth, Plaintiff, represented by Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter, Terri L. Griffiths & Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Jozsef Nemeth, Plaintiff, represented by Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter, Terri L. Griffiths & Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Irene Patton, Plaintiff, represented by Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter, Terri L. Griffiths & Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Mark Anderson, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Richard Hathaway, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Conch Villa Condominium Association, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Concordia Campgrounds, Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Jerry Daly, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Carlos Di Blasi, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

John Ftizgerald, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Rune Fremlin, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Birgitta Fremlin, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Nina C Hahler, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Rick Hoy, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Susan Hoy, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Barbara Jakobsen, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Arne Jakobsen, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Avis James, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Lee J Rohn , Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Oscar James, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Philip Jones, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Marjorie Jones, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Dan Near, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Rudy Patton, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Ed Pieper, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Barbara Pieper, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Deborah Ramsay, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Bonita Corbeil, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel M Cohen , Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

UPPER DECK VILLAS ASSOCIATION, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Michael Barry, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates & Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter.

Barbara Barry, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates & Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter.

Donald Sussman, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates & Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter.

Emicar LLC, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates & Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter.

Douglas R. Benton, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Michael L. Kridnik, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Barry Devine, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Dominic Watson, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Susan Greer-Littlefield, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Patricia Mertenson, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Elliot C. Hooper, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Jeffrey A. Smock, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Jay Goldman, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Vicky Brown-Goldman, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Gloria P Samuel, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Maria Applewhite, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Warren Family LLC, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Denise Veldman, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Burt Veldman, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Donald L. Robinson, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Molly J. Robinson, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Great Caribbean LLC, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates.

Sharon Schott, Plaintiff, represented by Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates, Rhea Lawrence , Rohn & Carpenter & Terri L. Griffiths .

Great Southern Wood Preserving, Incorporated, Defendant, represented by Daryl C Barnes , Bryant, Barnes, Moss & Beckstedt, John Stewart Baker , Lightfoot, Franklin & White, LLC, Lee M Hollis , Lightfoot, Franklin & White, Stewart Andrew Kelly , Lightfoot,Franklin & White, LLC, Sunshine S. Benoit , Bryant, Barnes, & Blair & Terri L. Griffiths .

Putnam Lumber & Export Company, Defendant, represented by Lana M Naghshineh , Lee Hernandez Laundrum Garofalo & Blake, Lisa M Komives , Bolt Nagi PC, Robert A Carlson , Lee, Hernandez, Landrum, Garofalo and Blake APC, Ryan M Charlson , Lee, Hernandez, Landrum, Garofalo & Blake & Terri L. Griffiths .

Putnam Family Properties, Inc., Defendant, represented by Lana M Naghshineh , Lee Hernandez Laundrum Garofalo & Blake, Lisa M Komives , Bolt Nagi PC, Robert A Carlson , Lee, Hernandez, Landrum, Garofalo and Blake APC & Terri L. Griffiths .

Putnam Family Properties, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Lisa M Komives , Bolt Nagi PC, Robert A Carlson , Lee, Hernandez, Landrum, Garofalo and Blake APC & Terri L. Griffiths .

Great Southern Wood Preserving, Incorporated, Cross Defendant, represented by Daryl C Barnes , Bryant, Barnes, Moss & Beckstedt, John Stewart Baker , Lightfoot, Franklin & White, LLC & Terri L. Griffiths .

Putnam Family Properties, Inc., ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Lisa M Komives , Bolt Nagi PC & Terri L. Griffiths .

Msi Building Supplies, Defendant, represented by Alex Moskowitz , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig & Terri L. Griffiths .

WHITECAP INVESTMENT CORP. d/b/a PARADISE LUMBER, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Chad C. Messier , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig.

Putnam Lumber & Export Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Lisa M Komives , Bolt Nagi PC, Robert A Carlson , Lee, Hernandez, Landrum, Garofalo and Blake APC & Terri L. Griffiths .

Great Southern Wood Preserving, Incorporated, Cross Defendant, represented by Daryl C Barnes , Bryant, Barnes, Moss & Beckstedt, John Stewart Baker , Lightfoot, Franklin & White, LLC & Terri L. Griffiths .

Putnam Lumber & Export Company, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Lisa M Komives , Bolt Nagi PC & Terri L. Griffiths .

Msi Building Supplies, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Terri L. Griffiths .

WHITECAP INVESTMENT CORP. d/b/a PARADISE LUMBER, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Alex Moskowitz , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig & Chad C. Messier , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig.

Msi Building Supplies, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Alex Moskowitz , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig & Terri L. Griffiths .

Msi Building Supplies, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Alex Moskowitz , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig & Terri L. Griffiths .

Msi Building Supplies, Counter Claimant, represented by Alex Moskowitz , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig, Lee J Rohn , Lee J. Rohn and Associates & Terri L. Griffiths .

Msi Building Supplies, Counter Defendant, represented by Alex Moskowitz , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig & Terri L. Griffiths .

WHITECAP INVESTMENT CORP. d/b/a PARADISE LUMBER, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Alex Moskowitz , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig & Chad C. Messier , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig.

WHITECAP INVESTMENT CORP. d/b/a PARADISE LUMBER, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Alex Moskowitz , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig & Chad C. Messier , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig.

WHITECAP INVESTMENT CORP. d/b/a PARADISE LUMBER, Counter Claimant, represented by Alex Moskowitz , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig & Chad C. Messier , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig.

WHITECAP INVESTMENT CORP. d/b/a PARADISE LUMBER, Counter Defendant, represented by Alex Moskowitz , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig & Chad C. Messier , Dudley Topper & Feuerzeig.

Putnam Family Properties, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Lisa M Komives , Bolt Nagi PC, Robert A Carlson , Lee, Hernandez, Landrum, Garofalo and Blake APC & Terri L. Griffiths .

Great Southern Wood Preserving, Incorporated, Cross Defendant, represented by Daryl C Barnes , Bryant, Barnes, Moss & Beckstedt, John Stewart Baker , Lightfoot, Franklin & White, LLC & Terri L. Griffiths .

Putnam Lumber & Export Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Lisa M Komives , Bolt Nagi PC, Robert A Carlson , Lee, Hernandez, Landrum, Garofalo and Blake APC & Terri L. Griffiths .

Great Southern Wood Preserving, Incorporated, Cross Defendant, represented by Daryl C Barnes , Bryant, Barnes, Moss & Beckstedt, John Stewart Baker , Lightfoot, Franklin & White, LLC & Terri L. Griffiths .


REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION

RUTH MILLER, Magistrate Judge.

Before the Court are the motion to strike, to enforce settlement and for sanctions [DE 339] of Whitecap Investment Corp. d/b/a Paradise Lumber ("Whitecap"), and the motion for sanctions [DE 343] of Putnam Lumber & Export Company and Putnam Family Properties, Inc. (collectively, "Putnam"), stemming from defendant Great Southern Wood Preserving, Inc.'s ("Great Southern") motion...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases