CROWN HEIGHTS SHOMRIM VOLUNTEER SAFETY PATROL, INC. v. THE CITY OF NEW YORK

No. 11-CV-329 (KAM).

CROWN HEIGHTS SHOMRIM VOLUNTEER SAFETY PATROL, INC., ARON HERSHKOP, CHAIM HERSHKOP, YEHUDA HERSHKOP, BENJAMIN LIFSHITZ, SCHNEUR PINSON and NECHEMIZ SLATTER, Plaintiffs, v. THE CITY OF NEW YORK, CROWN HEIGHTS SHMIRA, INC., LEIB SKOBLO, PAUL HUEBNER, PETER SIMONETTI, BOBBY TROISE, JOHN HAMMAD, LENNY WHITE, BRIAN DUFFY, WAYNE MANGAN, TIMOTHY KELCH, SEAMUS McHUGH, YITZCHOK SHUCHAT, EFRAIM OKONOV, YOSSI STERN, ELI POLTORAK, JOHN DOES A-M, JANE DOES 1-5, Defendants.

United States District Court, E.D. New York.

September 25, 2014.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Crown Heights Shomrim Volunteer Safety Patrol, Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Aron Hershkop, Plaintiff, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Chaim Hershkop, Plaintiff, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Yehuda Hershkop, Plaintiff, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Benjamin Lifshitz, Plaintiff, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Schneur Pinson, Plaintiff, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Nechemiz Slatter, Plaintiff, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

City of New York, Defendant, represented by Erica Michelle Haber , New York City Law Department.

Crown Heights Shmira, Inc., Defendant, represented by Boris Kogan , Boris Kogan & Associates & Marc Illish , Barry R. Feerst & Associates.

Leib Skoblo, Defendant, represented by Boris Kogan , Boris Kogan & Associates & Marc Illish , Barry R. Feerst & Associates.

Paul Huebner, Defendant, represented by Elie C. Poltorak , Poltorak PC.

Peter Simminetti, Defendant, represented by Erica Michelle Haber , New York City Law Department.

Bobby Troise, Defendant, represented by Erica Michelle Haber , New York City Law Department.

John Hammad, Defendant, represented by Erica Michelle Haber , New York City Law Department.

Lenny White, Defendant, represented by Erica Michelle Haber , New York City Law Department.

Brian Duffy, Defendant, represented by Erica Michelle Haber , New York City Law Department.

Wayne Mangan, Defendant, represented by Erica Michelle Haber , New York City Law Department.

Timothy Kelch, Defendant, represented by Erica Michelle Haber , New York City Law Department.

Seamus McHugh, Defendant, represented by Erica Michelle Haber , New York City Law Department.

Eli Poltorak, Defendant, represented by Elie C. Poltorak , Poltorak PC.

Eli Poltorak, Counter Claimant, represented by Elie C. Poltorak , Poltorak PC.

Paul Huebner, Counter Claimant, represented by Elie C. Poltorak , Poltorak PC.

Crown Heights Shomrim Volunteer Safety Patrol, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Aron Hershkop, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Chaim Hershkop, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Yehuda Hershkop, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Benjamin Lifshitz, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Schneur Pinson, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Nechemiz Slatter, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Eli Poltorak, Counter Claimant, represented by Elie C. Poltorak , Poltorak PC.

Paul Huebner, Counter Claimant, represented by Elie C. Poltorak , Poltorak PC.

Crown Heights Shomrim Volunteer Safety Patrol, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Aron Hershkop, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Chaim Hershkop, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Yehuda Hershkop, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Benjamin Lifshitz, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Schneur Pinson, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Nechemiz Slatter, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Eli Poltorak, Counter Claimant, represented by Elie C. Poltorak , Poltorak PC.

Paul Huebner, Counter Claimant, represented by Elie C. Poltorak , Poltorak PC.

Crown Heights Shomrim Volunteer Safety Patrol, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Aron Hershkop, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Chaim Hershkop, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Yehuda Hershkop, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Benjamin Lifshitz, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Schneur Pinson, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Nechemiz Slatter, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Eli Poltorak, Counter Claimant, represented by Elie C. Poltorak , Poltorak PC.

Paul Huebner, Counter Claimant, represented by Elie C. Poltorak , Poltorak PC.

Crown Heights Shomrim Volunteer Safety Patrol, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Aron Hershkop, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Chaim Hershkop, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Yehuda Hershkop, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Benjamin Lifshitz, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Schneur Pinson, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .

Nechemiz Slatter, Counter Defendant, represented by Tedd Bertram Blecher .


MEMORANDUM & ORDER

KIYO A. MATSUMOTO, District Judge.

On January 21, 2011, plaintiffs, Crown Heights Shomrim Volunteer Safety Patrol, Inc. ("Shomrim") and six of its members, filed the instant case. Plaintiffs filed the operative, Second Amended Complaint pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983 ("Section 1983") and state law on June 8, 2012, alleging violations of plaintiffs' rights pursuant to the First, Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases