U.S. v. EDUCATION MANAGEMENT LLC

No. 2:07-cv-461.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA et al., Plaintiffs, v. EDUCATION MANAGEMENT LLC et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, W.D. Pennsylvania.

June 18, 2014.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

RICHARD A. LEVIE, Special Master, represented by Richard A. Levie , JAMS.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ex rel., Plaintiff, represented by Christy C. Wiegand , United States Attorney's Office, Colin J. Callahan , U.S. Attorney's Office - Western District of Pennsylvan, Elizabeth C. Nelson , Office of the Illinois Attorney General, Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm, Paul E. Skirtich , United States Attorney's Office, Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC, Valerie M. Antonette , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC, Jay D. Majors , United States Department of Justice, Michael A. Comber , United States Attorney's Office, Rene D. Harrod , Office of the Attorney General, State of Florida & Richard Cutler , California Office of the Attorney General.

LYNNTOYA WASHINGTON, Plaintiff, represented by Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm, Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC, Trent A. Echard , Strassburger McKenna Gutnick & Gefsky, Valerie M. Antonette , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC, Emily McNally , Farrell & Reisinger, LLC, Eric R. Havian , Phillips & Cohen LLP, H. Yale Gutnick , Strassburger, McKenna, Gutnick & Gefsky, Jay K. Reisinger , Farrell & Reisinger LLC, John P. Cooney , McKool Smith, Mary H. Chu , McKool Smith, Robert Palmer , McKool Smith & Stuart M. Rennert , McKool Smith.

CALIFORNIA, Plaintiff, represented by Alexius M. Markwalder , Office of the Attorney General, Courtney Towle , State of California, Department of Justice, Office of the At, Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm, Richard Cutler , California Office of the Attorney General & Thomas J. Farrell , Farrell & Reisinger LLC.

FLORIDA, Plaintiff, represented by Rene D. Harrod , Office of the Attorney General, State of Florida, Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm, Mark S. Hamilton , Florida Office of the Attorney General & Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC.

ILLINOIS, Plaintiff, represented by Kate Pomper Costello , Office of the Illinois Attorney General, Elizabeth C. Nelson , Office of the Illinois Attorney General, Harpreet K. Khera , Office of the Illinois Attorney General, Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm, Jennifer M. Zlotow , Office of the Illinois Attorney General & Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC.

INDIANA, Plaintiff, represented by Patricia O. Erdmann , State of Indiana Office of the Attorney General, Corinne W. Gilchrist , Office of the Indiana Attorney General, Gina M. Venturelli , State of Indiana Office of the Attorney General, Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm & Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC.

MASSACHUSETTS, Plaintiff, represented by Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm & Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC.

STATE OF MINNESOTA, Plaintiff, represented by Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm, Jason T. Pleggenkuhle , Minnesota Attorney General's Office & Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC.

MONTANA, Plaintiff, represented by Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm & Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC.

NEW JERSEY, Plaintiff, represented by Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm & Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC.

NEW MEXICO, Plaintiff, represented by Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm & Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC.

NEW YORK, Plaintiff, represented by Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm & Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC.

TENNESSEE, Plaintiff, represented by Albert L. Partee, III , State of Tennessee Office of Attorney General and Reporter, George S. Bell , Tennessee Attorney General's Office, Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm & Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC.

THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, each ex rel., Plaintiff, represented by Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm, Jane Drummey , Office of Attorney General of the District of Columbia & Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC.

MICHAEL T. MAHONEY, Plaintiff, represented by Trent A. Echard , Strassburger McKenna Gutnick & Gefsky, Emily McNally , Farrell & Reisinger, LLC, Eric R. Havian , Phillips & Cohen LLP, H. Yale Gutnick , Strassburger, McKenna, Gutnick & Gefsky, Harry P. Litman , Litman Law Firm, Jay K. Reisinger , Farrell & Reisinger LLC, Mary H. Chu , McKool Smith, Robert Palmer , McKool Smith, Stuart M. Rennert , McKool Smith, Thomas J. Farrell , Reich, Alexander, Reisinger & Farrell, LLC & John P. Cooney , McKool Smith.

STATE OF INDIANA, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by Corinne W. Gilchrist , Office of the Indiana Attorney General & Patricia O. Erdmann , State of Indiana Office of the Attorney General.

STATE OF ILLINOIS, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by Charles F. Godbey , Illinois Attorney General's Office.

EDUCATION MANAGEMENT LLC, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Scott W. Brady , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, David S. Torborg , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Mark P. Rotatori , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP & Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF PITTSBURGH, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF ATLANTA, GA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF CALIFORNIA, INLAND EMPIRE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF CALIFORNIA, LOS ANGELES, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ART INSTITUTE OF CALIFORNIA, ORANGE COUNTY, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF CALIFORNIA, SAN FRANCISCO, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF CHARLESTON, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF CHARLOTTE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF COLORADO, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF DALLAS, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF FORT LAUDERDALE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF HOUSTON, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF INDIANAPOLIS, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF JACKSONVILLE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF LAS VEGAS, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF NEW YORK CITY, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF OHIO - CINCINNATI, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF PHILADELPHIA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF PHOENIX, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF PORTLAND, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF SEATTLE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF TAMPA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF TENNESSEE - NASHVILLE, TN, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF VANCOUVER, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF WASHINGTON - NORTHERN VIRGINIA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTES INTERNATIONAL MINNESOTA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ILLINOIS INSTITUTE OF ART - CHICAGO, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ILLINOIS INSTITUTE OF ART - SCHAUMBURG, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

MIAMI INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF ART & DESIGN, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE NEW ENGLAND INSTITUTE OF ART, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - AKRON, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - ATLANTA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - CINCINNATI, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - FINDLAY, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKEY COLLEGE - HOPKINSVILLE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - KANSAS CITY, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - MERRILLVILLE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - MIAMI, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - MICHIGAN CITY, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - MOLINE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - NORTH CANTON, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - NORTHERN KENTUCKY, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - SALINA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - SOUTH BEND, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - LOUISVILLE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

EDUCATION MANAGEMENT CORPORATION, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Albert L. Partee, III , State of Tennessee Office of Attorney General and Reporter, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, David S. Torborg , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Mark P. Rotatori , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

EDUCATION MANAGEMENT HOLDINGS LLC, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, David S. Torborg , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Mark P. Rotatori , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF CALIFORNIA - HOLLYWOOD, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF CALIFORNIA - SACRAMENTO, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF CALIFORNIA - SUNNYVALE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, INLAND EMPIRE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, ORANGE COUNTY, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, SAN DIEGO, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, SAN FRANCISCO, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, SANTA MONICA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

WESTERN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF LAW, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, SARASOTA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, TAMPA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

SOUTH UNIVERSITY/WEST PALM BEACH, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

SOUTH UNIVERSITY/TAMPA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, CHICAGO, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, SCHAUMBURG, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - FORT WAYNE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - INDIANAPOLIS, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, TWIN CITIES, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - ALBUQUERQUE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, NASHVILLE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF ATLANTA - DECATUR, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF AUSTIN, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF FORT WORTH, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF HOUSTON - NORTH, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF MICHIGAN, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF RALEIGH - DURHAM, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF SALT LAKE CITY, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF SAN ANTONIO, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF TUCSON, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF VIRGINIA BEACH, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF WASHINGTON, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF WISCONSIN, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTE OF YORK - PENNSYLVANIA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

THE ART INSTITUTES INTERNATIONAL - KANSAS CITY, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, ATLANTA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, DALLAS, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, DENVER, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

ARGOSY UNIVERSITY, HONOLULU, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

SOUTH UNIVERSITY/COLUMBIA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

SOUTH UNIVERSITY/MONTGOMERY, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

SOUTH UNIVERSITY/SAVANNAH, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

SOUTH UNIVERSITY/NOVI, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

SOUTH UNIVERSITY/RICHMOND, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

SOUTH UNIVERSITY/VIRGINIA BEACH, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - BOISE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - PHOENIX, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - TUCSON, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - TULSA, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - GREENVILLE, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - SAN ANTONIO, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

BROWN MACKIE COLLEGE - ST. LOUIS, Defendant, represented by Charles H. Moellenberg, Jr. , Jones Day, Jeffrey J. Bresch , Jones Day, Laura E. Ellsworth , Jones Day, Thomas S. Jones , Jones Day, Amy K. Pohl , Jones Day, Anderson T. Bailey , Jones Day, Iden G. Martyn , Cozen O'Connor, James M. Jones , Jones Day, Jennifer B. Saulnier , Jones Day, Katelyn M. Matscherz , Jones Day, Laura A. Meaden , Jones Day, Margaret C. Gleason , Jones Day, Matthew R. Divelbiss , Jones Day, Peter D. Laun , Jones Day, Daniel E. Reidy , Jones Day, Nikesh Jindal , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Timothy J. Hatch , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS, Movant, represented by Glenn S. Kaplan , Office of the Attorney General, Massachusetts.


MEMORANDUM ORDER

TERRENCE F. McVERRY, District Judge.

Pending before the Court is MOTION TO DISMISS RELATORS' FALSE CLAIMS ACT CLAIMS WITH PREJUDICE PURSUANT TO FED. R. CIV. P. 12(B)(1) (ECF No. 378) filed by EDMC, with brief and exhibits in support. The governmental Plaintiffs filed a Notice of Opposition to the motion (ECF No. 395) and Relators Lynntoya Washington and Michael Mahoney filed a brief in opposition to the motion with...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases