SHEET METAL EMPLOYERS INDUSTRY PROMOTION FUND v. ABSOLUT BALANCING CO., INC.

Case No. 2:12-10752.

SHEET METAL EMPLOYERS INDUSTRY PROMOTION FUND and SHEET METAL EMPLOYERS INDUSTRY APPRENTICESHIP REIMBURSEMENT FUND, Plaintiffs/Counter-Defendants, v. ABSOLUT BALANCING CO., INC., ENVIRO-AIRE/TOTAL BALANCE COMPANY, AERODYNAMICS INSPECTING CO., AIRFLOW TESTING, INC., and BARMATIC INSPECTING CO., Defendants/Counter-Plaintiffs/Third-Party Plaintiffs, v. SMACNA, A Michigan corporation, STEFANSKY, HOLLOWAY & NICHOLS, INC., a Michigan corporation, BENESYS, INC., a Michigan corporation, SHEET METAL WORKERS INTERNATIONAL LOCAL 80, Third-Party Defendants.

United States District Court, E.D. Michigan, Southern Division.

May 31, 2013.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Sheet Metal Employers Industry Promotion Fund, Plaintiff, represented by Douglas M. Lash , Sullivan, Ward, Lyndsey Kitson , Sullivan, Ward, Asher, and Patton, P.C., Ronald S. Lederman , Sullivan, Ward & Anthony A. Asher , Sullivan, Ward.

Sheet Metal Employers Industry Apprenticeship Reimbursement Fund, Plaintiff, represented by Douglas M. Lash , Sullivan, Ward, Lyndsey Kitson , Sullivan, Ward, Asher, and Patton, P.C., Ronald S. Lederman , Sullivan, Ward & Anthony A. Asher , Sullivan, Ward.

Absolut Balancing Co. Inc., Defendant, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Enviro-Aire/Total Balance Company, Inc., Consolidated from 12-10761, Defendant, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Aerodynamics Inspecting Co., Consolidated from 12-10755, Defendant, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Airflow Testing, Inc., Consolidated from 12-10756, Defendant, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Barmatic Inspecting Co., Consolidated from 12-10759, Defendant, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

SMACNA, Defendant, represented by Anthony A. Asher , Sullivan, Ward, Douglas M. Lash , Sullivan, Ward & Lyndsey Kitson , Sullivan, Ward, Asher, and Patton, P.C..

Stefansky, Holloway & Nichols, Defendant, represented by Hope L. Calati , Sachs Waldman & Stuart S. Shoup , Sachs Waldman PC.

Benesys, Inc., Defendant, represented by Hope L. Calati , Sachs Waldman & Stuart S. Shoup , Sachs Waldman PC.

Sheet Metal Workers International, AFL, Local 80, Joint Trust Funds, Defendant, represented by Hope L. Calati , Sachs Waldman & Stuart S. Shoup , Sachs Waldman PC.

Enviro-Aire/Total Balance Company, Inc., Consolidated from 12-10761, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Airflow Testing, Inc., Consolidated from 12-10756, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Absolut Balancing Co. Inc., ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Aerodynamics Inspecting Co., Consolidated from 12-10755, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Barmatic Inspecting Co., Consolidated from 12-10759, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

SMACNA, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Anthony A. Asher , Sullivan, Ward, Douglas M. Lash , Sullivan, Ward & Lyndsey Kitson , Sullivan, Ward, Asher, and Patton, P.C..

Stefansky, Holloway & Nichols, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Hope L. Calati , Sachs Waldman & Stuart S. Shoup , Sachs Waldman PC.

Benesys, Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Hope L. Calati , Sachs Waldman & Stuart S. Shoup , Sachs Waldman PC.

Sheet Metal Workers International, AFL, Local 80, Joint Trust Funds, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Hope L. Calati , Sachs Waldman & Stuart S. Shoup , Sachs Waldman PC.

Barmatic Inspecting Co., Consolidated from 12-10759, Counter Claimant, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Enviro-Aire/Total Balance Company, Inc., Consolidated from 12-10761, Counter Claimant, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Airflow Testing, Inc., Consolidated from 12-10756, Counter Claimant, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Aerodynamics Inspecting Co., Consolidated from 12-10755, Counter Claimant, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Absolut Balancing Co. Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Sheet Metal Employers Industry Apprenticeship Reimbursement Fund, Counter Defendant, represented by Douglas M. Lash , Sullivan, Ward, Lyndsey Kitson , Sullivan, Ward, Asher, and Patton, P.C. & Anthony A. Asher , Sullivan, Ward.

Sheet Metal Employers Industry Promotion Fund, Counter Defendant, represented by Douglas M. Lash , Sullivan, Ward, Lyndsey Kitson , Sullivan, Ward, Asher, and Patton, P.C. & Anthony A. Asher , Sullivan, Ward.

Barmatic Inspecting Co., Consolidated from 12-10759, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Absolut Balancing Co. Inc., ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Aerodynamics Inspecting Co., Consolidated from 12-10755, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Airflow Testing, Inc., Consolidated from 12-10756, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Enviro-Aire/Total Balance Company, Inc., Consolidated from 12-10761, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Scott W. Rooney , Nemes Rooney, P.C. & Thomas C. Nemes , Nemes Rooney, P.C..

Benesys, Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Hope L. Calati , Sachs Waldman & Stuart S. Shoup , Sachs Waldman PC.

SMACNA, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Anthony A. Asher , Sullivan, Ward, Douglas M. Lash , Sullivan, Ward & Lyndsey Kitson , Sullivan, Ward, Asher, and Patton, P.C..

Stefansky, Holloway & Nichols, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Hope L. Calati , Sachs Waldman & Stuart S. Shoup , Sachs Waldman PC.


OPINION AND ORDER

AT A SESSION of said Court, held in the United States Courthouse, in the City of Port Huron, State of Michigan, on

PRESENT: THE HONORABLE LAWRENCE P. ZATKOFF UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

LAWRENCE P. ZATKOFF, District Judge.

I. INTRODUCTION

This matter is before the Court on Third-Party Defendant Sheet Metal and Air Conditioning Contractors' National Association's ("SMACNA") Motion for a More Definite Statement...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases