IN RE ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR WAGE & HOUR EMPLOYMENT PRACTICES LITIGATION v. ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR COMPANY

MDL No. 2056, Misc No. 09-210, Civil No. 07-1687, No. 09-0815., 09-0816, 09-0824, 09-0832, 09-0833, 09-1188, 09-1321, 10-1003, 10-1189, 10-1456, 11-0071, 11-0333, 11-1024, 12-0659

IN RE: ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR WAGE & HOUR EMPLOYMENT PRACTICES LITIGATION. NICKOLAS HICKTON, et. al., Plaintiffs, v. ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR COMPANY, et. al., Defendants. THIS DOCUMENT RELATES TO Galia v. Enterprise Rent-A-Car Company, Civil No. 09-0816.

United States District Court, W.D. Pennsylvania.

July 19, 2012.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

NICKOLAS C. HICKTON, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, represented by Alfred G. Yates, Jr. , Law Offices of Alfred G. Yates, Jr., Peter Muhic , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A, James A. Maro , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP & Jason Conway , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP.

ELSA DEPINA, individually and on behalf of persons similarly situated, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A & Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JEFFREY GALIA, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A & Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

ROBERT BAJKOWSKI, individually and on behalf of persons similarly situated, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A & Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

TORI GAUDELLI, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey Brooks Kent , Bryman Clerke & Kent & Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

DONNASHEKIA RICHARD, individually and on behalf of persons similarly situated, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey Brooks Kent , Bryman Clerke & Kent.

MICHAEL KEITH AVERILL, JR., on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph A. Schreiber , Two Metroplex Drive, Marion V. Cruz , Cochran, Cherry, Givens, Smith & Montgomery LLC, Robert J. Camp , The Cochran Firm, P.C. & Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

WAYMAN F. GRAHAM, II, individually and on behalf of persons similarly situated, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A & Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

KRISTEN BENSON, Plaintiff, represented by Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MEGAN BERRYHILL, Plaintiff, represented by Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MICHELLE DANIELS, Plaintiff, represented by Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

CHRIS ENDRES, Plaintiff, represented by Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

KEVIN RHINESMITH, Plaintiff, represented by Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MICHAEL CRABTREE, Plaintiff, represented by Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MEGAN BERRYHILL, Plaintiff, represented by Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JEREMY EDWARDS, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JACQUES FENOLD, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

ERIC RIVERA, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

RYAN SMITH, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JOSH CUNNINGHAM, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

LUIS LABOY, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

REINALDO LAMADRIZ, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MAURICE HANSBERRY, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

SOLANGE HORDATT, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

DANIEL JACKSON, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

BEAU MCMANUS, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MADELYN MIGUEL, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

LAVAN PETTAWAY, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JAMES RICHARDSON, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

ROBERT RUBINO, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

NICHOLAS STEWART, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

KIMBERLY WHITE, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

YOLANDA WILLIAMS, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

DAVID ALTWERGER, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JOHN ANDERSON, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

SHANE BARNES, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

GERALD BENTLY, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MATTHEW FRAIER, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

TORI GAUDELLI, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MELANIE GIZEWSKI, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

TODD GODBEY, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MICHAEL HICKMAN, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JONATHON KING, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

BRANDON MCCUNE, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MELISSA OPOLINSKY, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

IAN PANTER, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

KIMBERLY RICKMAN, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MONA SHAH, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

TODD TREGO, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

PATRICK TUETH, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MICHAEL WASHINGTON, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

SHANE MCVEY, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

TRAVIS BEAU, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

RICK ALBURY, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MELINDA MCQUAIG, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JOE EDMONDS, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

GABRIEL MORA, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

TIMOTHY MCGOWAN, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

CARL SALERNO, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JARED LEEFERS, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JORDAN TAYLOR, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MARIO MIGUEL DURON, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

CHRISTOPHER CARROL, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

LINDSEY CARROL, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

SALLY BAKER, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

KAREN FISHER, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

ADAM GOLDSTEIN, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

SERGIO MENDEZ, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

MIQUEL MCDONALD, Plaintiff, represented by James A. Maro , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP & Jason Conway , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP.

KEVIN C. HAGLER, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A & Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JASMINE BROMFIELD, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

NILS HAGSTROM, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

SEAN HERBSTER, Plaintiff, represented by Alfred G. Yates, Jr. , Law Offices of Alfred G. Yates, Jr., Gerald D. Wells, III , Joseph H. Meltzer , Barroway Topaz Kessler Meltzer & Check, LLP, Peter Muhic , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP & Robert J. Gray , Barroway Topaz Kessler Meltzer & Check.

EMMANUEL BAYONNE, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

PRESTON M. FIRMIN, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

LAWRENCE SCOTT GRAHAM, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

SCOTT D. MACKENZIE, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

FRANK SIKES, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

RICCI WRIGHT, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

SHELLY HENLEY, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JASON SINK, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

STEWART ESTERVIL, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JERMIEL MCCASKILL, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

WILLIAM PHILLIP PALMISANO, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

AMBER GREENLAW, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

HEATHER BENTLEY, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

LAUREN BLEICH, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

ANGELA DUNCAN, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

KYLE A. PAYNE, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

ASHLEE THEOBALD, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

KATRINA TURNAGE, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

BRENT P. ZEVAN, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

TICHAONA MATEWA, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

SPENCER HARDY, Plaintiff, represented by James A. Maro , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, Jennifer S. Wagner , Stoll Berne, Joseph A. Schreiber , Two Metroplex Drive, Peter Muhic , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP & Peter M. Petro , Petro Law Firm.

MICHELLE MITCHELL STEEN, Plaintiff, represented by James A. Maro , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, Joseph A. Schreiber , Two Metroplex Drive, Peter Muhic , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP & Peter M. Petro , Petro Law Firm.

MICHAEL DOUTY, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A, Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A, James A. Maro , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP & Peter Muhic , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP.

KIA ROBERTS, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

KEN GEORGE, JR., Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

RYAN D. BELL, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

JACQUELYN FARMER, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

LAKEISHA WARD, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

ROBERT SANDERS, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A.

ROBERT SCHUTTE, Plaintiff, represented by Peter Muhic , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP.

SHAWN MODIRI, Plaintiff, represented by Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A, James A. Maro , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, Joseph A. Schreiber , Two Metroplex Drive, Peter Muhic , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP & Peter M. Petro , Petro Law Firm.

JOSEPH BISKI, Plaintiff, represented by Peter Muhic , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP.

BRANDON SINGLETON, Plaintiff, represented by Peter Muhic , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP.

BRANDY PEERY, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A, Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A, James A. Maro , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, Joseph A. Schreiber , Two Metroplex Drive, Peter Muhic , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP & Peter M. Petro , Petro Law Firm.

ROBERT SCHIESER, Plaintiff, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A, Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A, James A. Maro , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, Joseph A. Schreiber , Two Metroplex Drive, Peter Muhic , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP & Peter M. Petro , Petro Law Firm.

STEVEN LAMOTHE, Plaintiff, represented by Peter Muhic , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A, Hal B. Anderson , Shavitz Law Group, P.A & James A. Maro , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP.

BOBBY KELLEY, Plaintiff, represented by James A. Maro , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP & Peter Muhic , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP.

ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR COMPANY, INC, Defendant, represented by James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP, Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher, John R. Gotaskie, Jr. , Fox Rothschild LLP, Melanie L. Katsur , Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP, Patrick L. Abramowich , Fox Rothschild & Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP.

DOES 1-10 THROUGH 10, INCLUSIVE, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP.

ENTERPRISE LEASING COMPANY OF ORLANDO, Defendant, represented by James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP, Steven A. Siegel , Fisher & Phillips, Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP & Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher.

XYZ CORPORATION 1-5, (fictitious names of unknown liable entities), Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP.

ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR COMPANY - MIDWEST, an Iowa corporation, Defendant, represented by James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP, Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP & Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher.

ENTERPRISE LEASING COMPANY OF CHICAGO, a Nevada corporation, Defendant, represented by James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP, Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP & Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher.

XYZ ENTITIES 1-5, ficitious names of unknown liable entities, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP.

ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR COMPANY OF TENNESSEE, a Tennessee corporation, Defendant, represented by James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP, Mitchell Scott Allen , Bryan Cave Powell Goldstein & Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP.

XYZ ENTITIES 1-5, Defendant, represented by Mitchell Scott Allen , Bryan Cave Powell Goldstein.

ENTERPRISE LEASING COMPANY, a Florida Corporation, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP, James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP, Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Steven A. Siegel , Fisher & Phillips.

XYZ CORPORATION 1-50, (fictitious names of unknown liable entities), Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP, Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & Steven A. Siegel , Fisher & Phillips.

EDWIN PEREZ, Defendant, represented by Gregg I. Shavitz , Shavitz Law Group, P.A & Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP.

XYZ CORPORATION 2-5, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP.

ENTERPRISE LEASING COMPANY, SOUTH CENTRAL, INC., Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP, James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP & Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher.

ELRAC, INC., Defendant, represented by Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher.

ENTERPRISE HOLDINGS, INC., formerly known as ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR COMPANY, Defendant, represented by Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher, Christian M. Poland , Bryan Cave LLP, Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP, James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP, Mitchell Scott Allen , Bryan Cave Powell Goldstein & Steven A. Siegel , Fisher & Phillips.

ENTERPRISE LEASING COMPANY OF PHILADELPHIA, LLC, formerly known as ENTERPRISE LEASING COMPANY OF PHILADELPHIA, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP & Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher.

ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR COMPANY OF PITTSBURGH, LLC, formerly known as ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR COMPANY OF PITTSBURGH, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP, James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP, Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher, Melanie L. Katsur , Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP & Patrick L. Abramowich , Fox Rothschild.

ENTERPRISE LEASING COMPANY OF GEORGIA, LLC, Defendant, represented by James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP & Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher.

ENTERPRISE LEASING COMPANY-SOUTHEAST, LLC, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP, Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP.

EAN HOLDINGS LLC, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP, Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher & James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP.

ENTERPRISE RAC COMPANY OF MARYLAND, LLC, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP & Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher.

ELRAC, LLC, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP & Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher.

ENTERPRISE LEASING COMPANY OF FLORIDA, LLC, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP & Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher.

ENTERPRISE LEASING COMPANY WEST, LLC, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP & Jason C. Schwartz , Gibson Dunn & Crutcher.

ENTERPRISE LEASING COMPANY OF PHOENIX, LLC, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP & James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP.

ENTERPRISE LEASING CO. OF NORFOLK/RICHMOND, LLC, Defendant, represented by Daniel M. O'Keefe , Bryan Cave LLP & James R. Wyrsch , Bryan Cave LLP.


MEMORANDUM OPINION

JOY FLOWERS CONTI, District Judge.

I. Introduction

This opinion concerns sample plaintiff Robert Bajkowski ("Bajkowski"). Pending before the court are eight motions for summary judgment filed by the relevant operating subsidiaries (collectively "defendants") of defendant Enterprise Rent-a-Car Company ("ERAC") against sample plaintiffs1 selected from the cases consolidated in this multidistrict...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases