Karen CAMESI; Erin O'Connell; Lori Shaffer; Dinah Baker, on behalf of themselves and all other employees similarly situated, Appellants in Case No. 12-1446
v.
UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH MEDICAL CENTER; UPMC; UPMC Health System; UPMC Bedford Memorial Hospital; UPMC Braddock; UPMC McKeesport; UPMC Northwest; UPMC Passavant; UPMC Presbyterian; UPMC Presbyterian Shadyside; UPMC Shadyside; UPMC Southside; UPMC St. Margaret; Magee Women's Hospital of UPMC; Mercy Hospital of Pittsburgh; Montefiore Hospital; Montefiore University Hospital; Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic; Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh of the UPMC Health System; UPMC Lee; UPMC Horizon; UPMC Holding Company, Inc.; UPMC Health Network, Inc.; Jeffrey A. Ramoff; Gregory Peaslee; UPMC 401a Retirement Savings Plan; UPMC 403b Retirement Savings Plan; UPMC Basic Retirement Plan Andrew Kuznyetsov; Charles Boal; Marthann Heilman, Appellants in Case No. 12-1903
v.
West Penn Allegheny Health System, Inc; The Western Pennsylvania Healthcare System, Inc.; Alle-Kiski Medical Center; Allegheny General Hospital; Allegheny General Hospital-Suburban Campus; Canonsburg General Hospital; The Western Pennsylvania Hospital; Christopher T. Olivia; John Lasky; Retirement Plan for Employees of West Penn Allegheny Health System; Alle-Kiski Medical Associates; Alle-Kiski Women's Health; Allegheny Medical Practice Network; Allegheny Singer Research Institute; Allegheny Specialty Practice Network; Allegheny Valley Internal Medicine; Associated Surgeons of Western Pennsylvania; Associated Surgeons of Western Pennsylvania P.C.; Barry Segal, MD; Bellevue Medical Associates; Bellevue Pediatric Associates; Burn Care Associates, Ltd.; Burrell Internal Medicine; Cabot Medical Center; Canonsburg Community Healthcare Center; Center for Family Health Care; Century Medical Associates; Century III Medical Associates; Citizens School of Nursing; Corkery, Heise, Dainesi & Trapanotto; Crafton Medical Center; Creighton Medical Center; Dr. Francis J. Cavanaugh, MD; Dr. Mehernosh Khan; East End Medical Associates; East Suburban Family Practice; East Suburban Ob/Gyn; Family Nurse Midwives; Ferlan Group; Friendship Medical Associates; Forbes Hospice; Fuge Family Practice; Green Tree Medical Center Associates; Hampton Medical Center; Health Center Associates; Hussaini Medical Associates; Irwin Medical Center; Irwin Primary Care Associates; Mamatastragoor Khan Primary Care Associates; McDonald Primary Care; Meadowlands Primary Care; Medical Center Clinic, P.C.; Meta-Hilberg Hematology Oncology Associates, Inc.; Monroeville Medical Associates; M.H.V. Murthy, MD; Natrona Heights Ob/Gyn, Inc.; North Versailles Medical Associates; Paul Reilly, MD; Pediatric & Neonatal Associates; Pediatric & Neonatal Associates, Inc.; Penn Hills Medical Associates; Pennsylvania Comprehensive Care Associates; Pine Hollow Medical Associates; Pine Richland Medical Associates; Pittsburgh Cardio Thoracic Associates; Pittsburgh Cardiothoracic Associates; Plum Medical Associates; Primary Care Northside; Primary Care South; Riad Saradar, MD; Robert Baraff, MD; Frank E. Sessomsm.D., Inc; Sterling Medical Associates; Three Rivers Imaging Associates, P.C.; Tri County Cardiology; Tri County Cardiology, Inc.; United Physicians; Vascular Center Of Western Pennsylvania, Inc.; Waterdam Medical Associates; West Penn Allegheny Eye Associates, P.C.; West Penn Allegheny Foundation, LLC; West Penn Allegheny Health System, Inc. (Corp); West Penn Allegheny Health System, Inc. (Non Profit Corp); West Penn Allegheny Health System Primary Care Network; West Penn Allegheny Oncology Network; West Penn Allegheny Physicians, LLC; West Penn Allegheny Senior Care; West Penn Breast Surgery Practice; West Penn Comprehensive Health Care, P.C.; West Penn Corporate Medical Services, Inc.; West Penn Family Practice; West Penn Internal Medicine Associates; West Penn Physicians' Organization; West Penn Physician Practice Network; West Penn Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery; West Penn Plastic Surgery; West Penn Surgical Supply Co.; West Penn Specialty Mso, Inc.; West View Family Health Associates; The Western Pennsylvania Burn Foundation; Western Pennsylvania Cancer Institute; The Western Pennsylvania Cardiovascular Institute; Western Pennsylvania Diagnostic Clinic; Western Pennsylvania Heart Plan Inc.; The Western Pennsylvania Hospital Foundation; The Western Pennsylvania Hospital-Forbes Regional Campus; The Western Pennsylvania Hospital School of Nursing; The Western Pennsylvania Hospital Skilled Nursing Facility; Western Pennsylvania Ob/Gyn Associates; The Western Pennsylvania Research Institute; Wexford Medical Practice; Wexford Weight Loss.
United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit.https://leagle.com/images/logo.png
Argued March 6, 2013.
Opinion Filed: September 4, 2013.