ACKERMAN v. EXXONMOBIL CORP.

No. 12-1103.

734 F.3d 237 (2013)

Kenneth ACKERMAN; James Ackerman; April Ackerman; Mary Ackerman, Individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Ackerman; Charles V. Adams; Christianne M. Adams; John Alexis; Charles J. Arkins; Lula M. Arkins; Thomas J. Arno; Amy H. Arno, Both individually and as next friends of A.A. and E.A.; Robert A. Askin; Helen V. Askin; Rick G. Astarita; Patsy L. Astarita, Both individually and as next friends of A. N.A. and G.M.A., E.A., Individually; Lionel J. Bane; Lou Ann Bane; Timothy Banks; Susan E. Banks; Kristin E. Banks; Debra L. Bare; Larry G. Bare; Cody Bare; Tonta Freund; Thomas J. Barger; Kristin C. Barger, Both individually and as next friends of K.B., F.B., G.B., N.B.; Sebastiano Barresi; Steve Bavett; Anna M. Bavett, As next friend of N.L. and as next friends of M.B.; Grace Bayne; Daniel Beauchemin; Stella E. Beauchemin; Joann K. Bellington, Individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of William B. Bellington; John G. Berger; Danny L. Blankenship; Renee D. Blankenship; Mary Blevins; Michael D. Blevins; Timothy R. Blevins; Jennifer M. Blevins, Both individually and as next friends of S.A.B.; Joshua R. Blevins; Howard H. Bond; Ronald Bonner; Ruth M. Bonner; Kenneth M. Bradley; Carol J. Bradley; Bernadette M. Brannon; Raymond E. Brehm, Jr.; Constance M. Brehm; Lois J. Brodowski; Paul J. Brooks; Michelle D. Brooks, Both individually and as next friends of S.D.B.; Zachary T. Brooks, Individually; Alexander M. Brooks, Individually; Peeble M. Brownlee; Donald C. Burke; Lisa A. Burke; Julia Burke; Matthew Burke; Edward C. Burton, Jr.; Candy L. Hobson-Burton, Both individually and as next friends of M.H-B.; Mark A. Burton, Individually; Charles D. Burton, Individually; Marcia Byrne; Paul P. Byrne; Ursula Cain-Jordan; Dale B. Jordan; John F. Callahan; Dorothy H. Callahan; Luke J. Canfield; Janelle M. Canfield, Both individually and as next friends of S.A.C.; Mark S. Canham; individually and as next friend of M.C.; James M. Cannella; Marcie G. Cannella; Charles David Cayce, IV; Randy Loughry, Individually and as next friends of C.S.L., C.D.L.; Kimberlee A. Loughry; Ronald A. Clark; Carol F. Clark; Albert P. Class; Carolyn L. Class; Michael Cofiell; Darlene S. Cofiell; Nancy L. Connolly; Mary D. Conway; Charles H. Coon, Jr.; Deborah A. Coon; Lauren Coon; Jordan Coon; Jameson Cooper; Katherine A. Cooper, Both individually and as next friends of I.C., E.C., R.C.; John L. Councilman; Deborah J. Councilman; Colleen Craven; Harry F. Craven; Elizabeth A. D'Angelo; Robert F. D'Angelo; Caroline Dascher, individually and as next friends of M.D., E.D. and N.D.; Kenneth W. Dascher, Jr.; Jesse L. Coleman; Patricia H. Coleman; John C. Colt; Frances H. Colt; John S. Combs; Sea UN Combs; Owen Connolly; Donna J. Davids; John H. Davids; Emily Glaser; Mark Glaser; Douglas W. Townsley, POA for Helen A. Crowe; John T. Ditillo; Richard W. Doyle; Shirley A. Doyle; Albert K. Dunstan; Alexander A. Dunstan; Celeste Dunstan; Christie E. Dunstan; Gloria Davis, individually and as next friend of C.D.; William F. Davis, individually and as next friend of C.D.; Christopher P.Delvecchio; individually and as next friend of J.D.; Pamela A. Delvecchio, individually and as next fried of J.D.; Jeffrey Difatta, Individually; Teresa L. Difatta, individually and as next friend of S.D.; Timothy Difatta, Individually; Vincent Difatta, individually and as next friend of S.M.D.; David P. Digiorgio, individually and as next friend of P.A.D. and M.L.G.; Mallory S. Leggedigiorgio, individually and as next friend of P.A.D. and M.L.D.; Barbara Duvall; James R. Eavers; Patsy A. Eavers; Elaine H. Ehrhardt; Jessica Carlozo; Joseph Carlozo; Nicole Carlozo; Larry L. Elliott; Laura Elliott; Paula A. Elliott; Beatrice Elmo; Peter Elmo; Ernesto Ercolano; Phyllis Ercolano; Cyrus R. Etemad-Moghadam, individually and as next friend of F.R.E-M. and R.A.E-M.; Melody A. Etemadmoghadam, individually and next friend of F.R.E-M. and R.A.E-M.; Anastasia Fakas, individually and as next friend of N.F.; John Fakas, Individually; William J. Fakas, individually and next friend of N.F.; Joan L. Falanga; Jerome K. Ferrara, as next friend of K.P.F. and N.J.F.; Kristina Ferrara, as next friend of J.L. and K.H.; Carol L. Fialkowski; George V. Fialkowski; Demetrios Filipidis, individually and as next friend of G.F.; Robin L. Filipidis, individually and as next friend of G.F.; Aileen Flanagan, as next friend of G.F.; John S. Flanagan, as next friend of G.F.; Damion M. Ford; Richard A. Ford, III; Kathleen Fox; Ronald L. Fox; Sodus Cynthia, individually and as next friend of G.G. and A.G.; Ralph M. French; Gerard Frey; John P. Fries; Barry G. Gabler, individually and as next friend of G.G. and A.G.; Audrey Gallo; Robert A. Gallo; Lynne M. Schmidt-Fries; Jo Ann E. Geare; Chelsea Gebhardt; Fred C. Gebhardt, individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Teri J. Gebhardt; Jocelyn Gebhardt, Individually; Peter C. Georgopoulos; Susan E. Georgopoulos; Bette L. Gill; Roxanna M. Guinan; Jeffrey Guinan; Fallon Guinan; William Gill; James D. Gilpatrick; Michaele A. Gilpatrick; Scott M. Golly; Judith H. Gould; Thomas H. Gould; Bonnie L. Grant; Robert F. Grant; Eileen M. Gretes; William G. Gretes; Melissa Griffith; Michael Griffith; Milton Griffith; Michael A. Guzman, individually and as next friend of T.G.; Stacey L. Guzman, individually and as next friend of T.G.; Shirley Hall; Steven Hall; Thelma E. Hamel; Michael Harmon, POA for William B. Harmon and individually and as next friend of Z.H.; Dawne Jabobs, individually and as next friend of Z.H.; Patricia O'Neill, Personal Representative of the Estate of Elizabeth C. Gendimenico; Megan Heagy; Michael Heagy; Patricia A. Heagy; Steven M. Heagy, Jr.; Steven M. Heagy, Sr.; Lisa R. Hesseltine, individually and as next friend of K.H.; Mark C. Hesseltine, individually and as next friend of K.H.; Barbara A. Holler; Jimmy J. Holler; Larry W. Hooper; Pamela E. Hooper; Gwyn Houston, as next friend of D.M.; Janice A. Houston, as next friend of D.M.; Rita Howarth, as next friend of P.H.; Steven E. Howarth, as next friend of P.H.; Dawne Jabobs, as next friend of K.H.; David J. Hoyt, individually and as next friend of E.E.H. and L.M.H.; Kethleen H. Hoyt, individually and as next friend of E.E.H. and L.M.H.; Virginia A. Hoyt, individually; Allison L. Hunter; Bonnie L. Hunter; James D. Hunter; Jeffrey M. Hunter; James D. Hunter, Jr.; Scott Iannantuono, as next friend of B.I., J.I. and M.I.; Kimberly S. Iannantuono, as next friend of B.I., J.I. and M.I.; Christopher Jamison, as next friend of C.J., Jr.; Michele R. Jamison, as next friend of C.J., Jr.; Harry J. Cimbolo; Arlene E. January; Glenn K. January; Stephen D. January; Michael C. Janus, individually and as next friend of A.J. and A.J.; Tammy L. Janus, individually and as next friend of A.J. and A.J.; Gregory B. Johnson, as next friends of R.J. and H.J.; Jennifer Johnson, as next friends of R.J. and H.J.; Barbara A. Jung; Walter G. Jung; Harriet F. Kahl; Henry V. Kahl; Travis Bowen, individually; ALP A. Kayabasi, individually and as next friend of C.A.K. and A.D.K.; Christy L. Kayabasi, individually and as next friend of C.A.K. and A.D.K.; Lourdes Z. Keiser; Randall S. Keiser; Colleen Kelly; Joan M. Kelly; Michael Kelly; Christina M. King, individually and as next friend of L.K.; Jacqueline M. King; Mark B. King, individually and as next friend of L.K.; Susan Kluge, as next friend of R.K. and M.K.; Brendan C. Kluge, III, individually; Brendan C. Kluge, Jr., as next friend of R.K. and M.K.; Carole A. Klunk, Individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph A. Klunk; Sterling Lytle, Personal Representative of Estate of Harold J. Kelly; Devin Portzko; Kelly Protzko; Ryan Protzko; Leah Langrill Childs; Erika Kolakowski; Gleela D. Kolakowski; Jan E. Kolakowski; Edward D. Kosiba; Judith A. Kosiba; Kenneth E. Krausz; Marie C. Krausz; John F. Kress; Sharon J. Kress; Kevin J. Krivacsy, Individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Ruth A. Krivacsy; James P. Kuhlman, individually and as next friend of S.A.; Julie C. Kuhlman, individually and as next friend of S.A.K.; Scott C. Kuhlman, Individually; Mary M. Langrall; Clarke Jr. Langrall; John S. Langrill; Joshua Langrill; Linda D. Langrill; Francis X. Lauer; Judith A. Lauer; Robert S. Lindsay, Individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Sharon V. Lindsay; HOPE Lookingland; Michael Lookingland; Carl R. Lupica, individually and as next friend of A.C.L. and V.J.L.; Dawn L. Lupica, individually and as next friend of A.C.L. and V.J.L.; Annabel E. Lusardi, individually and as next friend of M.L., N.L. and C.L.; Thomas J. Lusardi, individually and as next friend of M.L., N.L. and C.L.; Alicia Lynch; Michael J. Lynch; Joseph E. MacAtee; Samuel MacAtee; Beth G. MacMillan, individually and as next friend of K.M., J.M. and J.M.; Paul MacMillan, individually and as next friend of K.M., J.M. and J.M.; Frederick C. Manfra; Marlene F. Manfra; Stephanie J. Manfra; John W. Marshall, individually and as next friends of O.G-M.; Paula M. Marshall, individually and as next friends of L.G-M. and M.G-M.; Brian R. Masterson; Lynn M. Masterson, Both individually and as next friends of C.M., L.M.; Linda Mazziott; Vincent T. Mazziott; Evelyn J. McDermott; Tyler M. McDermott; Kathleen P. McGraw, Both individually and as next friends of J.W.M.; Lauren A. McGraw; Robert S. McGraw; Carl Wayne Mellott; Joan B. Mirarchi; Ralph J. Mirarchi; Barbara L. Moore; Charles J. Moore, III; Dennis J. Morrison; Nina Morrison; James Moulsdale; Pamela S. Moulsdale, Both individually and as next friends of M.G.M.; Isa Mufareh; Ruth E. Mufareh; Karen Nickel, Both individually and as next friends of G.N.; Scott D. Nickel; Scott Dennis Nickel, Personal Representative of the Estate of Celina M. Rossini; Laura Nocar; James M. Norman; Emily C. Novak, Both individually and as next friends of R.S.N., Jr., J.D.N., C.R.N.; Ronald S. Novak; Frances Nowacki; Louis M. Nowacki; David O'Neil; Fatemeh O'Neil; Sean Rodgers Owens; Katherine W. Parris; Wayne H. Parris; Lanell W. Patrick, Both individually and as next friends of R.L.P., III; Robert L. Patrick, Jr.; Margaret Peach; William Peach; Jessica Simms; Susan C. Marshall, Recovable Trust; Gertrude R. Pearson; Henry R. Pearson, Jr.; Anthony Perfetti; Sharon A. Perfetti, Individually and as next friends of M.P., G.P. and M.P.; Norma M. Perriello; Patrick J. Perriello; The Patrick and Norma Perriello Living Trust; Nicole M. Boryspirozzi, individually and as next friend of D.D.P., A.E.P., A.F.P., I.S.P. and X.K.P.; M. Jeorgea C. Peters, Individually and as next friend of M.V.P.; Steven G. Peters, Individually; Kurt Peterson, As next friend of S.P., C.P., R.P. and J.P.; Mary B. Peterson, As next friend of S.P., C.P., R.P. and J.P.; Judy R. Petralia; Anthony Petralia, Jr.; Jane L. Philpot; John W. Philpot, Sr.; Lee G. Pierce; Cynthia M. Piracci; Francis L. Piracci; Ralph J. Pirozzi, individually and as next friend of D.D.P., A.E.P., A.F.P., I.S.P. and X.K.P.; Ashley Plack, Individually; Harry J. Plack, individually and as next friend of H.J.P., III, E.P. and T.P.; Mary C. Plack, individually and as next friend of H.J.P., III, E.P. and T.P.; Avril D. Plunkett, individually and as next friend of C.P. and N.P.; Michael H. Plunkett, individually and as next friend of C.P. and N.P.; Alexandra Poneres; Christos Poneres; Elias Poneres; Evangelos Poneres; Donna L. Potter, individually and as next friend of B.M.P.; Robert K. Potter, individually and as next friend of B.M.P.; Margaret Pusateri, Individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of James Pusateri; David A. Rainey; Elizabeth S. Ainey; Lewis Ramage; Nancy C. Ramage; Nachlappan Raman; Vimala Raman; Caitlin Ramsey, Individually; Catherine A. Ramsey, individually and as next friend of A.R.; David K. Ramsey, individually and as next friend of A.R.; Emily Ramsey, Individually; Judy C. Ramsey; Kimberly B. Ramsey; Kristin D. Ramsey; Tyler Ramsey, Individually; William J. Ramsey; Roman E. Ratych; Beth A. Rhudy, individually and as next friend of P.R., G.R. and H.R.; Phillip Rhudy, individually and as next friend of P.R., G.R. and H.R.; Charles A. Ritchey, individually and as next friend of C.A.R. and C.A.R.; Joell L. Ritchey, individually and as next friend of C.A.R. and C.A.R.; Patricia A. Ritter; David P. Stollery; Caitlin Dail; Shelley Disharoon, as next friend of C.D.; Anita E. Hansen, Individually; Gaylen D. Roberts; Ronald H. Roberts; Jane A. Rodano; Salvatore J. Rodano; Ellen M. Romanko; Thomas A. Romanko; Kathy Roubal; Chelsea Rouse; Stephen R. Rouse; Glenn O. Rubel, individually and as next friend of M.R. and C.R.; Maria L. Rubel, individually and as next friend of M.R. and C.R.; Michael E. Rudasill, individually and as next friend of C.R.; Barbara Ruggiero; Mark A. Ruggiero; Janice Meyer; Linda C. Ruth; Richard A. Ruth; Berneatha J. Sample; Dale H. Sample; Gregory H. Sample, individually and as next friend of H.S., J.S. and A.S.; Harvey F. Sample; Scott A. Sample; Steven D. Sample; Tina Sample, individually and as next friend of H.S., J.S. and A.S.; Alexander Sapienza; Angelina Sapienza; Nicholas Sapienza; Salvatore Sapienza; Amanda R. Schabdach; Bruce J. Schabdach; Mary M. Schabdach; Beth F. Scheir, individually and as next friend of E.S. and A.S.; Scott W. Scheir, individually and as next friend of E.S. and A.S.; John G. Schenk; Patricia F. Schenk; Frank Schlosser; Gloria R. Schlosser; Robert Schmid; Joycelyn B. Quaranta; Maria Schmidt, individually and as next friend of A.S. and A.S.; Michael T. Schmidt, individually and as next friend of A.S. and A.S.; Christine M. Schueler; Robert W. Schueler, Jr.; Clifford E. Schulte; Francine Scott, individually and as next friend of T.S. and A.S.; Jeremy Scott, individually and as next friend of T.S. and A.S.; Kathleen D. Scott; Paul C. Scott; Gregory N. Seltzer; Judith A. Seltzer; Andrew D. Shaff; Marisa Shaff; Natalie A. Shaff; Wayne D. Shaff; Irma C. Shanahan; Joseph V. Shanahan; Kenneth M. Simmons, individually and as next friend of S.M.S.; Michael R. Simmons, individually; Victoria B. Simmons, individually and as next friend of S.M.S.; Vincent B. Simmons, individually; Charles B. Singleton; Virginia L. Singleton; Caitlin M. Sonn; Jonathon D. Sonn; Letitia A. Sonn; Linda Kay Fisher, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward S. Stifler and Co-Personal Representative of the Estate of Katherine L. Stifler; Michael Henley; Milissa Lester; Therese M. Sorrentino; Marc A. Spataro; Terri Spataro; Armand M. St. Croix; Barbara A. St. Croix; Henry Stanley, individually and as next friend of J.S.; Joanne Stephen, individually and as next friend of B.S. and S.S.; Harry C. Stephen, Jr., individually and as next friend of B.S. and S.S.; Lester E. Stewart, individually and as next friend of A.A.S.; Cynthia L. Warner, as Co-Personal Representative of the Estate of Katherine L. Stifler; Alicia C. Woodman, individually and as next friend of A.A.S.; Colleen B. McDonough; Carol Lee Story; Richard W. Story; Carol A. Swam; Hendrik J. Theuns; Susan L. Theuns; Durel C. Thomas; Patricia L. Thomas; Elaine Thompson, individually and as next friend of J.T. and G.T.; Jeffrey Thompson, individually and as next friend of J.T. and G.T.; Wayne Paul Thompson, Jr.; Catherine C. Thrappas, individually and as next friend of A.T. and L.T.; Vincent J. Thrappas, individually and as next friend of A.T. and L.T.; Joseph R. Tito; Mary Ellen Tracey; Allen Roger Tracey, Jr.; Carolyn M. Turner, individually and as next friend of G.T.; Steven E. Turner, individually and as next friend of G.T.; Joseph R. Twanmoh; Valerie H. Twanmoh; Andrea L. Tyminski; Joseph J. Tyminski; Tina M. Valmas, individually and as next friend of F.G.V.; Theodore P. Valmas, IV, individually and as next friend of F.G.V.; Theodore P. Valmas, V, Individually; Heather L. Warner; Stanley B. Warner; Lidia J. Guzman; Dina N. Vendelis, individually and as next friend of J.V., A.V. and C.V.; Manuel A. Vendelis, individually and as next friend of J.V., A.V. and C.V.; Pat Villavicencio; Eleanor M. Vollerthum; William Vollerthum; Stephen Wagner, as next friend of J.W. and T.W.; Traci A. Wagner, as next friend of J.W. and T.W.; Courtnay Walker, individually and as next friend of G.W. and K.W.; Kenneth D. Walker, individually and as next friend of G.W. and K.W.; Stephen E. Waltermyer; Theresa K. Waltermyer; John J. Walters; Patricia J. Walters; Karen Wasielewski; Theodore M. Wasielewski; Geralyn Weinberger; Richard Weinberger; Maija Wentworth; Michael E. Wentworth, Jr.; Michael C. Whitacre; Verna Billingslea White; Kelly Stracke, individually and as next friend of M.C.; Novella Wiegand, individually and as next friend of K.L.W. and J.W.; Tony M. Wiegand, individually and as next friend of K.L.W. and J.R.W.; Howard Willis, individually and as next friend of K.W.; Margaret S. Winkelman, individually and as next friend of K.W.; William R. Winkelman, individually and as next friend of K.W.; Charles D. Winkler; Lynn A. Winkler; Donna M. Wolff; John P. Wolff, Jr.; Mark D. Wollenweber, individually and as next friend of M.W., Jr. and M.W.; Mary C. Wollenweber, individually and as next friend of M.W., Jr. and M.W.; Cynthia Wursta; Jay P. Wursta; Eileen M. Yancone; Victor Yancone; Ching Chu Yeh; Homer Ren Yeh; Sherwood Yelton, Jr., individually and as next friend of N.Y. and D.Y., Plaintiffs-Appellees, John G. Schenk; Patricia F. Schenk; Frank Schlosser; Gloria R. Schlosser; Robert Schmid; Joycelyn B. Quaranta; Maria Schmidt, individually and as next friend of A.S. and A.S.; Michael T. Schmidt, individually and as next friend of A.S. and A.S.; Christine M. Schueler; Robert W. Schueler, Jr.; Clifford E. Schulte; Francine Scott, individually and as next friend of T.S. and A.S.; Jeremy Scott, individually and as next friend of T.S. and A.S.; Kathleen D. Scott; Paul C. Scott; Gregory N. Seltzer; Judith A. Seltzer; Andrew D. Shaff; Marisa Shaff; Natalie A. Shaff; Wayne D. Shaff; Irma C. Shanahan; Joseph V. Shanahan; Kenneth M. Simmons, individually and as next friend of S.M.S.; Michael R. Simmons, individually; Victoria B. Simmons, individually and as next friend of S.M.S.; Vincent B. Simmons, individually; Charles B. Singleton; Virginia L. Singleton; Caitlin M. Sonn; Jonathon D. Sonn; Letitia A. Sonn; Linda Kay Fisher, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward S. Stifler and Co-Personal Representative of the Estate of Katherine L. Stifler; Michael Henley; Milissa Lester; Therese M. Sorrentino; Marc A. Spataro; Terri Spataro; Armand M. St. Croix; Barbara A. St. Croix; Henry Stanley, individually and as next friend of J.S.; Joanne Stephen, individually and as next friend of B.S. and S.S.; Harry C. Stephen, Jr., individually and as next friend of B.S. and S.S.; Lester E. Stewart, individually and as next friend of A.A.S.; Cynthia L. Warner, as Co-Personal Representative of the Estate of Katherine L. Stifler; Alicia C. Woodman, individually and as next friend of A.A.S.; Colleen B. McDonough; Carol Lee Story; Richard W. Story; Carol A. Swam; Hendrik J. Theuns; Susan L. Theuns; Durel C. Thomas; Patricia L. Thomas; Elaine Thompson, individually and as next friend of J.T. and G.T.; Jeffrey Thompson, individually and as next friend of J.T. and G.T.; Wayne Paul Thompson, Jr.; Catherine C. Thrappas, individually and as next friend of A.T. and L.T.; Vincent J. Thrappas, individually and as next friend of A.T. and L.T.; Joseph R. Tito; Mary Ellen Tracey; Allen Roger Tracey, Jr.; Carolyn M. Turner, individually and as next friend of G.T.; Steven E. Turner, individually and as next friend of G.T.; Joseph R. Twanmoh; Valerie H. Twanmoh; Andrea L. Tyminski; Joseph J. Tyminski; Tina M. Valmas, individually and as next friend of F.G.V.; Theodore P. Valmas, IV, individually and as next friend of F.G.V.; Theodore P. Valmas, V, Individually; Heather L. Warner; Stanley B. Warner; Lidia J. Guzman; Dina N. Vendelis, individually and as next friend of J.V., A.V. and C.V.; Manuel A. Vendelis, individually and as next friend of J.V., A.V. and C.V.; Pat Villavicencio; Eleanor M. Vollerthum; William Vollerthum; Stephen Wagner, as next friend of J.W. and T.W.; Traci A. Wagner, as next friend of J.W. and T.W.; Courtnay Walker, individually and as next friend of G.W. and K.W.; Kenneth D. Walker, individually and as next friend of G.W. and K.W.; Stephen E. Waltermyer; Theresa K. Waltermyer; John J. Walters; Patricia J. Walters; Karen Wasielewski; Theodore M. Wasielewski; Geralyn Weinberger; Richard Weinberger; Maija Wentworth; Michael E. Wentworth, Jr.; Michael C. Whitacre; Verna Billingslea White; Kelly Stracke, individually and as next friend of M.C.; Novella Wiegand, individually and as next friend of K.L.W. and J.W.; Tony M. Wiegand, individually and as next friend of K.L.W. and J.R.W.; Howard Willis, individually and as next friend of K.W.; Margaret S. Winkelman, individually and as next friend of K.W.; William R. Winkelman, individually and as next friend of K.W.; Charles D. Winkler; Lynn A. Winkler; Donna M. Wolff; John P. Wolff, Jr.; Mark D. Wollenweber, individually and as next friend of M.W., Jr. and M.W.; Mary C. Wollenweber, individually and as next friend of M.W., Jr. and M.W.; Cynthia Wursta; Jay P. Wursta; Eileen M. Yancone; Victor Yancone; Ching Chu Yeh; Homer Ren Yeh; Sherwood Yelton, Jr., individually and as next friend of N.Y. and D.Y., Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. EXXONMOBIL CORPORATION, f/k/a Exxon Corporation, d/b/a Crossroads Exxon; John R. Hicks, d/b/a Crossroads Exxon, Defendants-Appellants.

United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit.

Decided: August 7, 2013.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

ARGUED: Andrew Gendron , Venable, LLP, Baltimore, Maryland, for Appellants. Paul D. Raschke , Law Offices of Peter G. Angelos, Baltimore, Maryland, for Appellees. ON BRIEF: Michael J. De Vinne , Venable, LLP, Baltimore, Maryland, James F. Sanders , Neal & Harwell, PLC, Nashville, Tennessee, for Appellant Exxon Mobil Corporation; Paul W. Ishak , April C. Ishak , Stark and Keenan, P.A., Bel Air, Maryland, for Appellant John R. Hicks. H. Russell Smouse , Joyce R. Lombardi , Law Offices of Peter G. Angelos, Baltimore, Maryland, for Appellees.

Affirmed by published opinion. Chief Judge TRAXLER wrote the opinion, in which Judge GREGORY concurred. Judge DUNCAN wrote a separate opinion concurring in the judgment.


TRAXLER, Chief Judge:

ExxonMobil Corporation ("Exxon") and John R. Hicks (together, "Defendants") appeal a district court order abstaining from exercising jurisdiction under the Colorado River doctrine in a case brought against Defendants. See Colorado River Water Conservation Dist. v. United States, 424 U.S. 800, 96 S.Ct. 1236, 47 L.Ed.2d 483 (1976). Finding no reversible error, we affirm.

I.

In June...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases