L & R EXPLORATION VENTURE v. GRYNBERG

L & R EXPLORATION VENTURE; Ann L. Bronfman; Judith L. Chiara; Peter Dixon, as Executor of the Estate of W. Palmer Dixon; Margaret L. Kempner; Thomas L. Kempner; Jerome A. Manning and John A. Levin, Trustees of the Carl M. Loeb Trust f/b/o Ann L. Bronfman; Jerome A. Manning and John A. Levin, Trustees of the Carl M. Loeb Trust f/b/o Judith L. Chiara; Jerome A. Manning and John A. Levin, Trustees of the Carl M. Loeb Trust f/b/o Deborah L. Brice; Jerome A. Manning and John A. Levin, Trustees of the Frances L. Loeb Trust f/b/o John L. Loeb, Jr.; Estate of Henry A. Loeb; John L. Loeb, Jr., John Rodgers, and Mal L. Barasch, as Trustees of the Virginia Bloomgarden Trust; Trof, Inc., formerly known as Marshall Petroleum; Larry C. Serr, as Trustee of the Robineau Trusts; John S. Rodgers and Mal L. Barasch, as Trustees of the Audrey Holly Trust, LLC; Columbia University Trust Administration, as Executor of the Estate of Daniel Silberberg; M.M. Wellman, as Trustee of the Mark J. Millard Trust; Frederick Lubcher and Ann B. Lesk, as Trustees of the Diana Von Muffling Trust, Charles Von Muffling Trust, and William Von Muffling Trust; John L. Loeb, Jr.; and John S. Rodgers, Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. Jack J. GRYNBERG, Defendant-Appellant.