JONES v. PANIAGUA

Randy L. JONES, a citizen and qualified elector of the City of Phoenix, Plaintiff/Appellee, v. Mario PANIAGUA, in his official capacity as the Phoenix City Clerk; Phil Gordon, in his official capacity as Mayor of the City of Phoenix; Peggy Neely, in her official capacity as member of the Phoenix City Council and Vice Mayor; Thelda Williams, in her official capacity as member of the Phoenix City Council; Maria Baier, in her official capacity as member of the Phoenix City Council; Tom Simplot, in his official capacity as member of the Phoenix City Council; Claude Mattox, in his official capacity as member of the Phoenix City Council; Greg Stanton, in his official capacity as member of the Phoenix City Council; Michael Nowakowski, in his official capacity as member of the Phoenix City Council; Michael Johnson, in his official capacity as member of the Phoenix City Council; Frank Fairbanks, in his official capacity as City Manager of the City of Phoenix; and the City of Phoenix, Defendants/Appellants. Holl Ander Properties, an Arizona limited liability company, Intervenor.