1. Home
  2. Browse Decisions
  3. P.3d
  4. 149 P.3d
  5. 149 P.3d 142 (2006)
 

SCHERZINGER v. PORTLAND CUSTODIANS CIV. BD.

0208-08154, 0210-09876, 0302-01196; A120712 (Control), A120713, A122865.

149 P.3d 142 (2006)

209 Or. App. 394

James SCHERZINGER and Portland School District No. 1J, Respondents, v. PORTLAND CUSTODIANS CIVIL SERVICE BOARD, Respondent, and Tamara McWilliams, Henry Shambry, and 90 Civil Service Custodians, Appellants. State ex rel. Tamara McWilliams, Henry Shambry, and 90 Civil Service Custodians, Appellants, v. Portland Public School District No. 1J; Multnomah County, Oregon; Portland Board Of Education; Marc Abrams; Lolenzo Poe; Sue Hagmeier; Derry A. Jackson, Sr.; Debbie Goldberg Menashe; Julia Brim-Edwards; Karla Wenzel; and James Scherzinger, Respondents. Portland Public School District, No. 1J, an Oregon Public School District, Respondent, v. Portland Custodians Civil Service Board, Defendant, and Donald W. Strong; David P. Vecsi; Lynda M. Anderson; Mary J. Anderson; Robert L. Anderson; Steven R. Armony; Glenn E. Armstrong; Wayne L. Arneson; Daniel Arnold; Phillip L. Bartlett; William K. Beatty; Patrick S. Beckmeyer; William P. Blackmon; Daniel E. Blanchard; Edward J. Borne; Lonnie L. Bowden, Sr.; Gerald C. Brandon; Shawn H. Briggs, John W. Brooks; Sarah E. Brophy; Eric A. Brown; John W. Bryant; Hugh A. Burgett; William L. Camp; Parlor G. Campbell; Richard R. Carlson; Robert H. Carron; Clyde R. Chamberlain, Jr.; Huyen D. Chu; Troy C. Classen; Robert J. Clausen; Ray D. Clay; Marshall W. Collins; Gordon C. Corda; Timothy J. Curtin; Wayne A. Curtin; Larry D. Cushman; Antonio L. Dasilva; Timothy D. Davidson; Danny J. Davis; James L. Davis; James R. Dean; Phyllis J. Dean; Kenneth D. Deweese; Richard P. Dobas; Carl A. Donaldson; Francis J. Duncan; Matthew B. Dutton; Richard W. Ehrhart; William C. Endicott; Daniel L. Esmond; Ronald J. Fahey; Gary Ferns; Edward E. Flagler; Lonnie D. Flemming; Belinda G. Fosnot; Elliott R. Fosnot; Michelle R. Fosnot; Steven R. Fraiser; Mark W. Freimark; Kenneth D. Fry; Felipe C. Fuentes; Jeffery W. Furlow; James L. Granville; Donald D. Graves; Clifford L. Green; Paul F. Grignon; James W. Grinnell; David F. Guinn; Hannelore Gyden; Douglas G. Halenbeck; Mark A. Hamilton; Jeffrey C. Haner; Brian G. Hardin; Bruce W. Harris; Ronald L. Haselwood; Roger D. Hastings; Robert A. Hazeltine; Kenneth L. Herring; Duane R. Hill; Harold A. Holm; Ronald Hoodye; Curtis D. Hughes; Victoria R. Ibarra; Craig S. James; Stetson N. James; Randall L. Jarvis; Alan C. Jelkrem; Jack M. Jensen; Brent L. Johnson; Howard S. Johnson; Ray N. Johnson; Frank C. Jones; Calvin B. Kaiser; Joseph G. Keenon; Bertha M. Kirk; Richard L. Kreitz; Keith E. Kvernvik; Drew M. Letang; Lowell K. Linstrom; Douglas I. Lorenson; Terry Q. Luper; Daniel J. Markey; Richard G. Martin; Terry C. Martin; Rodney D. Mathiesen; James P. McMahon; Ken Migaki; Kevin G. Miller; Bryce D. Mitseff; Frank E. Morgan; Barbara J. Muller; Scott E. Myers; Paul D. Neighorn; Bernard E. Nelson; Michael A. Nelson; Nicholas W. Newcomer; Thang V. Nguyen; Donald R. Niece; Paul D. Nyman; Vincent O. Oniah; Debi L. Paige; William R. Park; Shirley A. Payton; Ann E. Pimentel; John H. Pollard; Lee R. Pommerville; John M. Pont; Thomas I. Posey; Frank R. Powers; Kenneth P. Pray; Clayton W. Price; Barry D. Pullen; David B. Pullen; John R. Rider; Charles J. Rinehart; Elizabeth Rodgers; Mark A. Rogers; Richard R. Rogers; Craig M. Rothschild; Alan L. Rudy; Henry L. Schamel, Jr.; David P. Schieiger; Mark J. Schnoor; Steven A. Scott; Julian J. Sebastian; Samuel N. Shalkowsky; Vincynthia Shepard; Mitsutoshi Shibuya; Leon C. Slider; Kenneth W. Smith; Pearlie M. Smith; David D. Steward; Michael L. Strand; Ronald R. Streeter; Thomas M. Summerfield; Randall B. Suva; Bobby L. Sykes; Keven C. Test; Michael A. Thomas; Raymond C. Thomas; Cynthia J. Vanortwick; Dale A. Vanortwick; Brad J. Vincent, Sr.; Michael F. Vodka; Gerald D. Wallace; Derthal G. Walter; Douglas K. Warner; Karen J. Waters; Michael T. Webb; Michael A. Weinberger; Dennis D. Wiley; David F. William; James M. Williams; Major S. Willis; Ronald Willoughby; Keith L. Witherspoon; William R. Wolfe; Sui L. Wong Ao; Kenneth A. Yambra; Mason L. Young; Timothy G. Young, Individuals (the "Individual Defendants"), Appellants.

Court of Appeals of Oregon.

Decided December 6, 2006.

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

William D. Brandt and Mark E. Griffin, Washington, D.C., for appellants.

William H. Walters, Bruce L. Campbell, and Miller Nash LLP, Portland, for respondents James Scherzinger; Portland School District No. 1J.; Multnomah County, Oregon; Portland Board of Education; Marc Abrams; Lolenzo Poe; Sue Hagmeier; Derry A. Jackson, Sr.; Debbie Goldberg Menashe; Julia Brim-Edwards; and Karla Wenzel.

No appearance for respondent Portland Custodians Civil Service Board.

Before LANDAU, Presiding Judge, and BREWER, Chief Judge, and ARMSTRONG, Judge.

BREWER, C.J.

The Supreme Court remanded these cases to us with instructions to reconsider them in light of Walter v. Scherzinger, 339 Or. 408, 121 P.3d 644 (2005). Scherzinger v. Portland Custodians Civil Serv. Bd., 340 Or. 483, 135 P.3d 318 (2006); Portland Public School District No. 1J v. PCCSB, 340...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases