GRIFFITH v. BOWER

Keith GRIFFITH and Terry Williams, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. Glen BOWER, Director of Revenue, Defendant-Appellee (Patty Redpath, in Her Own Behalf and as Natural Guardian of Her Children Joey Redpath, Jesse Redpath, and Alex Redpath; Dr. Matthew Kuhn, in His Own Behalf and as Natural Guardian of His Children Alexis Kuhn and Andrew Kuhn; Mary Ellen Lovell, in Her Own Behalf and as Natural Guardian of Her Children Ryan Lovell and Hayley Lovell; Maria Razo, in Her Own Behalf and as Natural Guardian of Her Children Cecilia Razo and Gloria Razo; Rabbi David Schnell, in His Own Behalf and as Natural Guardian of His Children Tzvi Schnell, Aviva Schnell, Devora Schnell, Shmuel Schnell, Nechama Schnell, Ephraim Schnell, and Esther Schnell; Silvia Espinoza, in Her Own Behalf and as Natural Guardian of Her Children Daniel Espinoza, Onyx Espinoza, and Christopher Espinoza; Dr. Shakir Moiduddin, in His Own Behalf and as Natural Guardian of His Children Abed Moiduddin and Akif Moiduddin; Anne Sapienza, in Her Own Behalf and as Natural Guardian of Her Children Christina Sapienza, Andrea Sapienza, Gerard Sapienza, Maria Sapienza, Phillip Sapienza, and Gina Sapienza; Steven Pancer, in His Own Behalf and as Natural Guardian of His Children Joshua Pancer, Ari Pancer, and Meir Pancer; Michael Riordan, in His Own Behalf and as Natural Guardian of His Children Brian Riordan and Kevin Riordan; Dalyn Dye, in His Own Behalf and as Natural Guardian of His Child Nathan Dye; and Helen Mixon, in Her Own Behalf and as Natural Guardian of Her Child Termaine Mixon, Intervening Defendants-Appellees).