GARVIN v. AMERICAN TEL. & TEL. CO.

No. 98-6007.

174 F.3d 1087 (1999)

Terry A. GARVIN; John McGrail; Ferdnand Adamson; Edith Aitken; Marva Akins; Douglas R. Allen; Shirley Allen; Loren Alm; Sheila Altman; Cornelious Anderson; Peggy C. Anderson; Claudette B. Anterin; Esther Arnold; Kenneth G. Arsenault; Jerry M. Ashley; Lindy Ashley; Johnice M. Autrey; Roy Autrey; Wanda Bagley; Wanda Baglley; W.E. Baker; Marjean Baldini; Suzanne Barker; Dorothy J. Bass; Pedro P. Bejarano; Catherine A. Bellis; Jimmy Belvin; Steve Benisek; Hellen J. Bennett; Eunice F. Berry; Mark Bianchi; Mary Bigelow; Russell Bigelow; Esther B. Billiard; Carolyn K. Bishop; Frank Black; Jo Ann L. Black; Lyndel E. Blanton; Patsy H. Blemmel; Richard D. Blemmel; Letha Blevins; Bennie H. Bohannon; Lee Bowen; Dorthy Bowens; Joyce Boyd; Ruty W. Boyer; Jewel L. Boyles; Hardenia Bradford; Margaret B. Brady; Wyonna Brandt; Mary Brannon; Florrie L. Brant; Louise Branum; Mary Briggs; Paul C. Briggs; Linda A. Brim; Ernest W. Brower Jr.; Carol Gene Brown; Cecil R. Brown Charles Brown; Elsie Brown; Lottie B. Brown; Marion Brown; Stephen M. Brown; Carole Joan Browning; J.T. Brundage, A/K/A Jack Brundage; Georgianna Bruno; John W. Bryant; Mary Burton; Elmer Ray Button; Beverly Cagle; Tony Cagle; Al Cagle; Robert P. Campbell; Daniel T. Cantrell; Linda Cantrell; Ving Dang Cao; Bertha R. Carlton; Thelma Carmichael; Adrian Carter; Darlene Carter; Robert Carter; Fred Casteel; Glenda S. Casteel; Dale O. Cease; Quannah Chadwell; Betty J. Chadwick; Max E. Chance; Williette Teresa Childs; Mike Clay; Hulsuk Clevenger; Raymond Cobb; David G. Coleman; Tommy Coleman; Dan Coley; Rachel Colwell; Dave L. Comstock; Dianna Conner; Tim D. Conner; John Coogle; Norma S. Coone; Paul D. Cosby; Catherine Coulter; Charles L. Cox; Charlotte M. Cox; Deanna J. Cox; Ray L. Cox; Charlene Coyle; Donald D. Coyle; Rodger D. Craft; Betty Craig; Joe F. Craig; Benny Cramer; Michael Crandall; Maurice F. Crawford; Wilma M. Crisp; Bobbie Crump; Tilda Cummings; Winston Cutter; Carroll Darnall; Margaret Darnall; Orvelle Davis; Patricia A. Davis; Sandra L. Davis; Mildred De Busk; David Deerinwater; Carolyn C. Demoe; Dennis Demoe; Gary Dennis; Brenda R. Dezarn; Jimmy G. Dezarn; Gay L. Diamond; Van Ngo Dich; Mary Dick; Wayne Dinkins; Mossie F. Doku; James Don Dero; Joan Don Dero; Jean M. Dotson; Wesley P. Drabek; Elaine Duek; Martha L. Dunlap; Cong Thanh Duong; Rymon Earls; R.L. Edralin, a/k/a Eddie Edralin; Fay Lynn Edwards; Otis E. Edwards, Jr.; Joquitta Ek; Martha A. Ellis; Amanda Ellison; Zina English; Virginia Ervin; Beverly Estlinbaum; Fred Estlinbaum; R.W. Estlinbaum; Mary Eubanks; Eastman Joe Factor; Deboray Farrior; Ray Farrior; Charles Wayne Fawcett; Aaron Felix, Sr.; Janice Felix; Norma Lee Felix; Richard Ferguson; Reginald Fields; Doretha Sue Fike; Reginald J. Fike; Gerald Fincham; Abilene Fletcher; Martha Fletcher; Martha Jan Ford; Mary Ann Ford; Rita J. Foster; Kay F. Fowler; Mattie B. Frazier; Helen Freshour, A/K/A C.W. Freshour; Mary D. Frye; Phyllis M. Fuller; Erma J. Gage; Michael A. Gage; Daniel J. Gagnath; Betty J. Gaines; Domingo J. Garcia; Ruby Gardenhire; Mi Sun Gardner; Eric W. George; K.C. George; Barbara George-Reilly; Richard Gerber; Mel D. Gering; Robert Gibbs; Carolyn Gibson; Mary M. Gibson; Dixie Gilbert; Eva Jolene Gilbert; Joe W. Gilbert; Kamencita Gissandaner; Richard W. Glasco; Shirley Glover-knight; Elsie Golson; Donaciano S. Gonzales; Jerry Goodner; Lee P. Gorrell; Jo Goza; Lavoy L. Green; Shirley Green; Tommy Green; Kathleen Greer; Johnnie Gregory, Jr.; Emma Grider; Ann Griffith; Edward Griffith; Betty P. Griggs; Robert W. Griggs; Wesley Gude; Arthur Guess; Mary Haley; Barbara Hall; Roland E. Hambrook; Frances Colleen Hanneman; Ella P. Hanson; Carletta Hardon; Hope G. Hare; Francis Harker, Sr.; Imogene Harris; James E. Harris; James W. Harvin; Claudia Hash; Patricia B. Hauser; Archie Hawkins; Rick Hawkins; Virginia Hayes; Bellijim Head; Marilyn S. Heathman; Betty R. Hensley; Sherrie Hershel; Carolyn Hicks; Jeanie M. Hicks; Dorothy Hignite; John Hilderbrand; Carol Hill; Margaret S. Hinton; Dung Ngoc Ho; Shirley A. Holden; Herman Tyrone Holland; John David Holland; Gwendolyn M. Hood; Wanda L. Hood; Carol A. Horton; Mary Housner; C.R. Howard; Oma Howard; Connie Huff; Sandra Hughart; Sandy Humphery; Marion Hurley; William Hurt; Janice Hutchens; Jerry D. Hutchens; Darrell Hutton; Sheryl Hutton; C.P. Irby; Deborah Jackson; William L. Jackson; Jerry Jacobs; Frances L. James; Lillian James; Lindsey Jasmer; Douglas M. Johnson; Etta M. Johnson; Margaret L. Johnson; Mary Johnson; Minola H. Johnson; Georgia L. Jones; John E. Jones; Marcia Jones; Mattie L. Jones; Donald Keasler; Alvin Keith; Shirley A. Kelley; Connie Kellian; Joan E. Kennedy; A.E. Kent; Carol Keylon; Eddie Keylon; Katherine Kilby; Hazle King; Ruthie O. King; Roy A. Klepper; Ronald G. Klopfenstein; Gertrude Kroutil; Jacqueline Krutz; Jackie Lack; Mary J. Lambert; Esther B. Lampkin; Carl J.D. Lane; Ruth M. Lane; Ernie Lang; Genera M. Lattimore; Ruth Marie Lavalais; Beverly Lawson; Douglas Lawson; Ralph Lee; Amelia Lightner; William C. Locke; Glenn Logan; Carlos P. Lopez; SandraLorenzen; Ima Jean Lovelace; Donald Lowe, Sonja W. Lowery; Wanda Jean Lowry; Patricia W. Lytal; Don Maddox; Bertha Maker; Lana K. Manor; Sharon Marine; Merle A. Marsh; Sharon Faye Martin; Joe Martinez; Charles L. Mason; Richard S. Mason; John Massingale; A. Joan Mathes; Paul Mattingly; Linda B. McClish; Jerry L. McConnell; Joann B. McCracken; Judy C. McCracken; Geneva McCraw; Robert A. McDaniel; Carolyn McDonald; Mary McElyea; Doyle D. McEntire; Fines R. McEwen; Lola McEwen; Janet McGrail; Cary McMillian; Saundra McMillian; Bruce McNenney; Wilma G. McRee; Alter L. Means; Louis Mendoza; Charles W. Merrill, Jr.; Melba Jean Merrill; Benjaminemestanza; Jay D. Michael; Carolyn M. Miller; Charles S. Miller; Dwight Miller; Ralph K. Miller; Sara J. Miller; Earl K. Millus; Mary B. Millus; William S. Mims; Marga S. Miranda; Richard B. Miranda; Anthony D. Mixon; Alfred W. Mock; Maricela H. Montoya; Ceilia Mooney; Don Mooney; Alvin Moore; Bill W. Moore; John C. Moore, Jr.; Albert Moore, Jr.; Jorge L. Morales; William R. Morris; Raymond Morrissey; Dennis Morrow; Margaret Mosley; Bobbie Mount; Tim Mount; Sarah A. Mulkey; William M. Munch; Burlene Munro; Robert J. Munro; Ruby P. Murry; Ann Nalley; Alice Nealy; Gene Nelson; Emerald Ness; Shirley Ness; Carol Newman; Tommy E. Newman; Lonzetta Nolen; Ronald G. Norris; Jimmy E. Novotny; Helen Nowicki; Kennith Nowicki; Jack Gary Nowlin; Gloria O'Conner; Marcella Orr; Robert Osborn; John D. Owen; Charles W. Owens; Russell Owens; Lloyd Don Owrey; Tammy Sue Rains; Joseph D. Rajer; Jack Ramer; Fletcher Ramsey; Maria Irma Rangel; Patsy R. Readnour; Bertha Reaves; Arnold G. Rhodes; Linda B. Richardson; Alan D. Ridgely; Randolph E. Rinaca; Hellen R. Robbins; James R. Roberson; Catherine Roberts; Norma Jean Roberts; Beaulah Robinson; John E. Robinson; Vernon Robinson; Dorothy Robnett; Bobby Joe Rogers; Ethel C. Rogers; Paul R. Rolfes; Jo S. Ross; Mary A. Roy; William D. Roy; Janie Russell; Barbara M. Rust; Earnest Sagal; Paula Sagal; Ebbie E. Sanders; Ron Sanders; Ruth Ann Sanders; Alfredo L. Sauceda; Judy Padgett; John M. Page; Martina R. Page; Sandy H. Page; Susan S. Pannell; Donata Pardue; Donald Parks; Frances J. Parks; Coy N. Patterson; Diana Patterson; Frank Patterson; Willella Pauley; E.E. Percival; Ronnie Perkins; Jenice Perry; Edward R. Peters; Nancy F. Peyton; Ronald Pfortmiller; Ester B. Pickens; A.L. Pierce; Peggy Pierce; James L. Pike; Margaret Pitt; Connie Ponds; Lou Ann Porter; Priscilla M. Porter; David K. Powell; Betty Priest; Shirley B. Prim; Douglas A. Puckett; Esther Quntero; Max Ragland; Kennith Rainbolt; Connie E. Saulsberry; Avis Savage; Leroy D. Schein; Leta J. Schilling; Donna R. Schleicher; George H. Schleicher; Larry Schmidt; Constance T. Scott; Martha Sebring; Jerry Sexton; Michael A. Shaver; Faye S. Shaw; Judy Shaw; Carolyn Sheehan; Richard B. Sheffer; Evelyn M. Sheldon; Carl L. Shelton; Alma P. Shore; Michael Shrouf; Al Shuler; Evelyn W. Shultz; Jose E. Sigala; Ozetta M. Sloan; Sherl Slohn; Lelia M. Smiley; Mary D. Smiley; Bob Smith; Debra Z. Smith; Glen H. Smith; Gloria R. Smith; Mary D. Smith; Mildred A. Smith; Wanda Smith; Lois Sockwell; Dennis Spears; Clarissa B. Speight; Roy Spillman; Kathleen Starr; Emil J. Stejskal; Don Stevens; Jim L. Stewart; Earl D. Still; Elizabeth Stout; Carolyn W. Stramski; John M. Styles; Number R. Sutton; Shirley H. Sutton; Joyce Swanegan; Many Szczepka; Sonja Szczepka; Caroll Tarrant; Eva Thomas; Fred Tinsley; Johnny Tisdel; Murlene Tobler; Billie M. Todd; Ross P. Tomberlin; Howard Toyer; Clarence Trail; Karen Trail; Ronald Trower; Kelly Troyer; Marcus Tuck; Bruce Turner; Marva J. Turner; Deborah Upton; Pete Urias; Guynelle Uselton; Dana Valley; Walter Valley; Mark Vucknvich; Nancy Waidlich; Larry W. Walden; Marian J. Walden; Helen Walker; Charles Walsh, Jr.; William Walton; Herbert W. Ward; David Ware; Jayne Ware; Gary Warnke; Clint Wartchow; Helen Wartchow; Phyllis J. Way; Gary D. Webb; Talmage Webb, Jr.; John B. Weber; Hsiaoyen Welch; Violet J. Welch; Violet J. Wells; Walter Andrew Wells; Gloria Rice West; Elizabeth Whelan; Nathaniel White, Jr.; Ronnie White; Alice Whitlow; Barbara Wicker; Clifford Wilkerson; Karen C. Wilkins; Darlene Williams; Jacquita L. Williams; Martha F. Williams; Nelda Josephine Williams; Minnie Wilner; Melaine Wiloughby; Steven Wiloughby; Ardis D. Wilson; Fayona B. Wilson; Frank D. Wilson; Joyce Wilson; Savannah M. Wilson; George Winburn; Nick Wines; Mac R. Winkler; Gary Winter; Glenna Winter; Edwin C. Wise; Frederick Wise; Linda G. Wise; Robert Wood; J. H. Woodard; John H. Woodford, Jr.; Lena J. Woodruff; Bill Woodward; Bobby G. Woodward; Eddie Joce Woodward; Randi H. Woodward; Margaret A. Wooldridge; Norma Wooldridge; Billie Workman; Margie Wosika; Barbara Wyse; Gary Wyse; Patsy Yadon; Fred E. Yeager; Earlene J. Young; Sarah A. Young; Agnes Zamora; Roger G. Ziegerfuss, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. AMERICAN TELEPHONE & TELEGRAPH CO., a New York corporation as the successor in interest to AT&T Network Systems, Inc., Defendant-Appellee, Lucent Technologies, Inc., Intervenor-Appellee.

United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit.

March 5, 1999.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

James A. Ikard, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, (Michael A. Toups, Weller, Green, McGown & Toups, L.L.P., Beaumont, Texas, and A. Hoyt Rowell, III, Ness, Motley, Loadholt, Richardson & Poole, Charleston, South Carolina, with him on the briefs) for the appellants.

Charles C. Jackson, Seyfarth, Shaw, Fairweather & Geraldson, Chicago, Illinois, (Eric J. Gorman and Jill S. Mulderink, with him on the briefs) for the appellees.

Before TACHA, BARRETT, and HENRY, Circuit Judges.


BARRETT, Senior Circuit Judge.

Terry A. Garvin, et al., (collectively "Appellants") appeal from the district court's grant of summary judgment in favor of American Telephone and Telegraph Company (AT&T) on their claims to recover termination allowances brought pursuant to § 301 of the Labor Management Relations Act (LMRA), 29 U.S.C. § 185(a).

Facts

Appellants were employees of Oklahoma City Works of AT & T Network...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases