ADAM v. BENJAMIN


426 Pa.Super. 543 (1993)

627 A.2d 1186

Thomas ADAM, Thomas Bailey, Andrew Bakaysa, Charles Bakaysa, John Bakaysa, Edward Barrett, Carl Baum, Clair Baum, Jack Baum, Jack Baumgartner, James Beatty, Carl Beck, Evertt Bell, Gregg Bell, Thomas Bell, Albert Bell, Donald Bennett, Fred Bennett, Raymond Bennett, Richard Bennett, Ronald Bennett, Barney Bensky, Robert Berlin, John Bishop, Harry Biss, L. Carl Blake, Walter Blume, William Blume, Gray Bond, Dennis Bouch, Ronald Bouch, Darryl Bowser, Paul Bracken, Robert Bracken, Christopher Bracken, Christopher Brink, Daniel Brink, Glen Brink, James Brink, Dale Brooks, Edgar Brothers, James Buck, William Buck, Richard Byers, Ernest Cauldwell, Brian Cameron, Jeff Cameron, Kevin Cameron, Albert Chiplis, Franklin Clark, Roy Clark, William Clark, James Clutter, William Collins, Joseph Craft, John Curry, Edwin Daugherty, Edward Davies, Terry Davies, Richard Delp, Bernard Diehl, Norman Diehl, Charles Dillon, Donald Dimmick, Robert Dufour, David Eger, William Eneminger, Gary Farmery, William Farmery, Douglas Feaster, Irvin Feaster, Jay Fishel, William Fleming, Delwyn Fry, Donald Fyock, Gregory Gardner, Myrel Gardner, Thomas Gardner, Roger Geist, Kenneth Gilbert, Ronald Gill, Joseph Glass, Jr., Joseph Glass, Sr., John Gowin, Andrew Haag, Charles Haag, Leslie Hamilton, Russell Harpster, Walter Hauck, Daniel Hewitt, John Hewitt, David Hoover, Richard Hurd, Gerald Hutton, Robert Hutton, Robert Johns, James Johnson, Ronald Johnston, Thomas Kawa, Clair Keller, Jeffrey Kelly, Albert Kitchen, Arthur Kitchen, David Kitchen, George Kitchen, Guy Kitchen, Larry Kitchen, Sherman Kitchen, Jerry Kline, Paul Kovalchik, Sherman Krause, Barry Kruise, Donald Kruise, Ronald Kruise, Terry Kruise, George Kurtz, Danny Kutruff, Melvin Leamer, Andrew Lechene, Robert Lee, Terry Lender, Alan Lewis, David Lewis, Theron Lewis, William Lewis, David Lightner, Kevin Lockett, Byron Long, David Long, Paul Long, Douglas Lucas, Charles Lunger, David Lydic, Ernest Lyons, Thomas Mahaffey, Sterry Mahaffey, Jr., Leonard Martin, Willis Maruna, John Matia, Joseph Mazenko, Jack McCraken, Thomas McCraken, Thomas McElleny, Eldon McGarry, Donald McGarvey, John Thomas McGee, William Wallace McGee, Ronald Meckley, Terry Miller, James Mills, David Moore, James Mowery, Martin Mulhollen, Thomas Nellen, Jerome Nevling, Joel Martin Passmore, Charles Peach, Robert Pearce, Robert Pearce, Charles Pennington, Robert Pennington, Ronald Phillipi, Ivan Pierce, Thomas Pontzner, David Queen, Richard Queen, Robert Reitz, Dennis Robbins, Eugene Romagna, John Rose, Charles Ross, John Ross, Thomas Ross, Randy Rowles, Harry Rogh, Donald Sheeder, Larry Schomo, Robert Schomo, Vernon Simmons, Robert Sinclair, Donald Smeal, Garry Smeal, Phillip Smeal, Robert Smeal, Dennis Smith, John Smith, Robert Smith, Raymond Smyers, Richard Snyder, Joseph Soltys, Thomas Spangle, Duane Spencer, Ronald States, Arthur Stiver, Harold Stiver, Irvin Stiver, Duane Strong, Donald Sunderland, Thomas Swauger, James Taylor, Gerald Timchak, Edward Tkacick, Jerbert Von Scoyoc, Lewis Wagner, Michael Wagner, Ronald Wagner, Russell Wallace, George Warholic, Robert Washic, John Weaver, Daniel Webster, Ellis Westover, Gordon Westover, James Westover, Lemoine Westover, Joseph Whitton, Charles Wilkinson, Frank Williams, Thomas Williams, Robert Witherite, Robert Woods, Michael Wright, Robert Wright, Dale Yarger, Gary Yarger, Kenneth Yarger, Dennis Young, John Young and Larry Young v. David BENJAMIN, Harry Benjamin and Sally Benjamin, a/k/a Sally Gold v. INTERNATIONAL UNION, UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, Appeal of David BENJAMIN.

Superior Court of Pennsylvania.

Filed June 30, 1993.

Reargument Denied August 31, 1993.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Carl A. Belin, Jr., Clearfield, for appellant.

Claudia Davidson, Pittsburgh, for appellees.

Before WIEAND, POPOVICH and HESTER, JJ.


POPOVICH, Judge:

We are asked to review the appeal of an order (reduced to judgment1) of the Court of Common Pleas of Blair County granting a motion for summary judgment against the defendant/appellant, David Benjamin.2 We affirm.

As an appellate court, the standard by which we assess the propriety of a motion for summary judgment is well-established...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases