Marvin O. WILSON, Jr., John A. Auten, III, Terry L. Austin, Phillip A. Johnston, Wendell M. Jolly, Jr., Sebron L. Thompson, Harvey W. James, Jr., Robert L. Honeycutt, Howard Darrell Key, Thomas Richard Craft, Steven L. Ridge, Oscar William White, Billy Wayne Oliver, Harry A. Rogers, Dick Newhouse, Tommy R. Wilburn, Charles E. Melton, Larry G. Metts, Clay E. Morris, Traci L. Morris, David G. Charles, John A. Auten, IV, David J. Black, E.E. Christenbury, Charles Alexander Roseburough, Carvie E. Woodard, George Lee White, K.R. Blake, S.D. Speaks, J.M. Clampitt, William T. Honeycutt, Barry L. Boyd, Darrell E. Furr, Jerome Martin Frederick, James C. Geer, J.L. Newell, Phillip E. Chiles, Ben Ray Norwood, Theresa R. Alexander, Ward S. Howie, Frank E. Reid, Michael T. Carleton, Connie William Morgan, William A. Strain, Michael J. Corigliano, Melvin D. Balles, Scott A. Dawkins, David Lee Newell, Michael Spath, William F. Lowe, T.A. McKenzie, Donald W. Taylor, Gary Lee Isenhour, Frank S. Pressley, William D. Henderson, Danny Jack Pharr, David Eugene Scott, Tom C. Harllee, Patrick F. Starnes, Clifton M. Mullis, Vincent T. Severn, David K. Ledbetter, Frederick O. Smith, Jerry A. Rodgers, William F. Freeman, Eli J. Robles, James F. Ellis, D.L. Ghorley, D.C. Nance, L.E. Black, J.C. Black, D.W. Stephens, C.D. Gaskin, J.D. Barefoot, D.C. Moore, Christopher D. Gordon, James Robert Shaffner, Garry E. McCormick, Richard L. Albaugh, Michael E. Saye, Robert W. McDonald, Ronald Leon Shumaker, Levi V. Steele, Doyle Neal, Fred B. Archie, Darrell R. Collins, Jackie C. Cress, William R. Brown, Sr., Jeffrey L. Campbell, Thomas A. Davis, Randy P. Mowrey, J. Michael Keffer, Calvin L. Fink, John A. Hawley, Jr., Phyllis S. Bost, William R. Summey, George Baxter Holmes, James Greg Taylor, Robert William Kennard, Gary Wayne Workman, Rex Donald Hovey, William Michael Stegall, Donald Parks Poplin, James David Thomas, James Louis Bradford, Ronald Lee Smith, Jerry Lynn Shope, Jerry W. Killian, Blair D. Carr, II, Andrew Preston Osborne, Sue N. Tarantino, R.L. Pharr, Gary Miller, Roy Kenneth Bradley, Allen Keith Middleton, Thomas Wayne Helms, Larry Malbourne Kepley, Jr., Robert J. Brishey, Johnny E. Wiley, Lindsay D. Keith, Edward Wayne Murray, Walter Clinton Caldwell, Jr., Sharon Beal Black, Homer Larry Holtzclaw, William Duncan Love, Van W. Sullivan, Everette A. Passaly, Jr., Charles E. Jarrell, Barry L. Brown, William B. Cochran, Nathan Douglas Hooks, Graylen D. Hare, Stephen S. Brotherton, Tommy Curtis Link, Cornice Alton Butler, Edward Rogers Funderburk, Jack Timothy Gettis, Anthony Dwayne McWhirter, Eugene Perry Forte, Bobby W. Davis, Kenneth D. Crump, Walter Randy Kinsey, Alan S. Hoffman, George Richard Parsley, Donald Cecil Mull, Roy Stuart Smith, III, Andrew Reid Pickens, Alfred Allen Davis, Jason William Boyd, John Lee Carothers, Moses David, Raymond Hugh Thrower, Frankie Wayne Greer, David Roe Lane, Jr., Lynn Chandler, Francis Marion McGowan, Plaintiffs-Appellees,
v.
CITY OF CHARLOTTE, N.C., Defendant-Appellant.