TIDEWATER AREA CHARITIES v. HARBOUR GATE

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Allen J. Gordon (Mark D. Brynteson; Chesapeake, J. Wayne Sprinkle, Portsmouth, on briefs), for appellant.

Michael A. Inman, McCardell, Inman, Benson, Strickler & Koch, Virginia Beach, for appellee Harbour Gate Owners Ass'n, Inc.

Ann B. Brogan (Thomas E. Cabaniss, Patrick L. Hayden, McGuire, Woods, Battle & Boothe, Norfolk, on brief), for appellees Lilliam Snow Adams, Leannor Baker, Robert C. Baker, Joseph H. Beland, Virginia L. Beland, Joyce W. Boger; Barbara B. Boggs; Beryl G. Brown, Beverly J. Burlage, Helen H. Christie, Constance C. Constant, Theodore F. Constant, Eleanor M. Coutre, Richard E. Coutre, Charles J. Donlan, Marguerite P. Donlan, Samuel Q. Eure, Yvonne M. Eure, Morgan P. Gibson, Eunice S. Gladstone, Shayle V. Gladstone, Betty Griffin, Judith M. Hechtkoff, Michael J. Hechtroff, Margaret Hofheimer, Flora L. Hudson, Ronald R. Hudson, Richard M. Jacobson, Josephine C. Joyner, Ilhi Kang, Yaegin Kang, Cecelia C. Kaufman, Murray S. Kaufman, Lloyd O. Kessler, Marian H. Kessler, Margaret M. Kohl, William W. Kohl, Thelma W. Kyrus, George O. Laberge, Emma Sue Lindell, Richard L. Lindell, Bessie C. Lira, Thomas Lira, Irene P. Malbon, Amanda V. Marshall, Lawrence E. Marshall, Ardith M. Maxwell, Vivan T. McElven Springborn, Shinayo O. Miner, Mabelle W. Mitchell, Florence E. Molella, Frederick A. Molella, Jr., Dorsel S. Moyers, Pearl M. Moyers, Fletcher Lee Nance, Everett S. Norris, Martha B. Norris, Mildred P. Palmieri, Ralph A. Palmieri, Maxine M. Piland, Harry Edward Pitt, Olga E. Pitt, Gladys L. Prell, Raymond B. Prell, Barbara W. Price, Timothy H. Pugh, Evelyn J. Rivenbark, Alyce B. Schaff, Donald G. Schaff, Priscilla W. Schuttler, Audrey E. Sedath, Howard Smith, Janice Smith, Willie Kate Snow, Martin N. Southern, Leontina Southern, Ohan Tabakian, George D. Terry, Kenneth D. Tetlow, Martha L. Thompson, Virginia H. Turpin, William J. Tuttle, Elsie C. Tuttle, Nancy J. Vaden, James T. Vail, Cornelius Van Heest, Elizabeth B. Van Heest, James C. Van Pelt, Mary A. Van Pelt, James E. Whipkey, Guido Wilde, Susanna Wilde, Ralph Z. Williams.

Gary P. Arsenault, Mercer, Grey & Arsenault, Norfolk, on brief, for appellees Valerie Jove, Henry Burkhardt and Neil Burkhardt.

No briefs or argument for appellees Louise G. Abraham; Eugene C. Barnhardt, III; Frances R. Barhardt; Grace S. Bihr; Richard A. Bihr; William Birhle, Jr.; Ernestine L. Bonds; Robert L. Bonds, Jr.; Fred Burg; Greta Burg; Chris A. Christie; Paul T. Cohoun, Jr.; Muriel A. Crimmins; Paul T. Crimmins; James D. Culpepper; Gerald Dascher; Selma Dascher; A. Earl Dairs; Diane Dairs; M.F. Davis; Herbert C. Doss; Vila F. Doss; Aura K. Eagan; William C. Eagan; John A. Fitzgerald; Ernie J. Gasser, Jr.; Rose Mae Gibson; B.C. Hack; Jane H. Heard; John H. Heard; William C. Heard, III; Marie Ann Hinderliter; Albert F. Holub; Daris M. Humphreys; Wilmine L. Humphreys; Gary P. Janii; Helene S. Johnson; Richard Kelly; Alexander P. Kotarides; Diane F. Lamb; Myron C. Lamb; Abraham Lapin; Susan L. Linn; Andrew T. Lymna; Dorothy R. Lyman; Virginia M. Mahler; Lee R. Marks, et al., Trustees; Carolyn McCowley; Barbara J. McGregory; Bruce J. McGregor; Donald C. Meekins; John A. Meekins; JoAnn Olson; Winston L. Olson; Leslie B. Oppleman; Norma K. Palacio; William B. Palacio; Gerald P. Pulley; Mary V. Pulley; Dorothy Hillsman Robbins; James T. Robinson; Phyllis P. Robinson; Oscar B. Saunders; Sally B. Saunders; Brian L. Schoenfeld; Renee Binder Schoenfeld; Carl H. Sell; Marquerite S. Sell; Henry Lawrence Shutwell; Dolores R. Talbot; Guy F. Trefether, Sr.; Lorriane G. Trefether; George R. Waterman; Athena E. Yeonas.

Present: CARRICO, C.J., and COMPTON, STEPHENSON, RUSSELL, WHITING, and LACY, JJ., and COCHRAN, Retired Justice.