OFFICE OF CONSUMERS' COUNSEL, OHIO v. F.E.R.C.

Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100, 84-1135, 84-1142, 84-1143, 84-1146, 84-1179 and 84-1444.

783 F.2d 206 (1986)

OFFICE OF CONSUMERS' COUNSEL, STATE OF OHIO, Petitioner v. FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION, Respondent Public Service Commission of the State of New York, Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Process Gas Consumers Group, Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, UGI Corporation, Dayton Power and Light Company, Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Pennsylvania Gas and Water Company, Consumer Advocate For the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Washington Gas Light Company, Interstate Natural Gas Association of America, Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company, et al., Baltimore Gas and Electric Company, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Texas Eastern Transmission Corporation, Transwestern Pipeline Company, Exxon Corporation, Maryland Office of People's Counsel, Intervenors. ASSOCIATED GAS DISTRIBUTORS, Petitioner, v. FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION, Respondent, Public Service Commission of the State of New York, Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Pennsylvania Gas and Water Company, Process Gas Consumers Group, Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, UGI Corporation, Dayton Power and Light Company, Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Washington Gas Light Company, Interstate Gas Association of America, Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Office of Consumers' Counsel, Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company, et al., Baltimore Gas and Electric Company, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Texas Eastern Transmission Corporation, Transwestern Pipeline Company, Exxon Corporation, Maryland Office of People's Counsel, Intervenors. PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION of the STATE of NEW YORK, Petitioner, v. FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION, Respondent, Washington Gas Light Company, Baltimore Gas and Electric Company, Exxon Corporation, Maryland Office of People's Counsel, Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company, Office of Consumers' Counsel, Process Gas Consumers Group, Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors. CITIES OF CHARLOTTESVILLE AND RICHMOND, VIRGINIA, Petitioner, v. FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION, Respondent, Dayton Power and Light Company, Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company, et al., Maryland Office of People's Counsel, Baltimore Gas and Electric Company, Process Gas Consumers Group, Washington Gas Light Company, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors. CITIZEN/LABOR ENERGY COALITION, Petitioners, v. FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION, Respondent, Dayton Power and Light Company, Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company, et al., Baltimore Gas and Electric Company, Maryland Office of People's Counsel, Consumers' Counsel, State of Ohio, Process Gas Consumers Group, Washington Gas Light Company, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors. BALTIMORE GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY, Petitioner, v. FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION, Respondent, Dayton Power and Light Company, Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company, et al., Office of Consumers' Counsel, Maryland Office of People's Counsel, Process Gas Consumers Group, Washington Gas Light Company, Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors. PROCESS GAS CONSUMERS GROUP, Petitioner, v. FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION, Respondent, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Office of Consumers' Counsel, Baltimore Gas and Electric Company, Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Washington Gas Light Company, Maryland Office of People's Counsel, Pennsylvania Department of Commerce, Association of Businesses Advocating Tariff Equity, American Iron and Steel Institute, Georgia Industrial Group, Intervenors. COLUMBIA GAS TRANSMISSION CORPORATION, Petitioner, v. FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION, Respondent, UGI Corporation, Dayton Power and Light Company, Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Process Gas Consumers Group, Public Service Commission of the State of New York, Pennsylvania Gas and Water Company, Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, Ohio Office of Consumers' Counsel, Washington Gas Light Company, Associated Gas Distributors, Baltimore Gas and Electric Company, Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Interstate Natural Gas Association of America, Transwestern Pipeline Company, Texas Eastern Transmission Corporation, Maryland Office of People's Counsel, The Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company and Union Light, Heat & Power Company, Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors.

United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit.

Decided February 4, 1986.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Jennifer N. Waters, with whom Frederick Moring and Roger B. Cooper were on brief for petitioner, Associated Gas Distributors in No. 84-1100 and intervenor in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1135, 84-1142, 84-1143, 84-1146, 84-1179 and 84-1444; and with whom Hodges B. Childs was on brief for petitioner, Baltimore Gas and Electric Company in No. 84-1146 and intervenor in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100, 84-1135, 84-1142, 84-1143, 84-1179 and 84-1444.

William H. Penniman, with whom Edward J. Grenier, Jr. and Glen S. Howard were on brief for petitioner, Process Gas Consumers Group, et al. in No. 84-1179 and intervenors in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100, 84-1135, 84-1142, 84-1143, 84-1146 and 84-1444. JoAnne Morris also entered an appearance for Process Gas Consumers Group.

Stephen J. Small, with whom William I. Harkaway, R. Clyde Hargrove and Giles D.H. Snyder were on brief for petitioner, Columbia Gas Transmission Corp. in No. 84-1444 and intervenor in Nos. 84-1099 and 84-1100.

Joel M. Cockrell, Atty. F.E.R.C., for respondent. William H. Satterfield, Gen. Counsel, Jerome M. Feit, Sol., and Michael E. Small, Atty., F.E.R.C. were on brief for respondent in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100, 84-1135, 84-1142, 84-1143, 84-1146, 84-1179 and 84-1444. Thomas F. Hirsch, III, Atty. F.E.R.C. also entered an appearance for F.E.R.C.

Margaret Ann Samuels was on brief for petitioner, Office of Consumer's Counsel, State of Ohio in No. 84-1099 and intervenor in Nos. 84-1100, 84-1135, 84-1146, 84-1179 and 84-1444.

David E. Blabey, Richard A. Solomon and Robert W. Kneisley were on brief for petitioner, Public Service Com'n of State of New York in No. 84-1135 and intervenor in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100 and 84-1444.

Stanley W. Balis and Susan N. Kelly were on brief for petitioners, Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Va., et al. in Nos. 84-1142 and 84-1143 and intervenors in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100, 84-1135, 84-1146, 84-1179 and 84-1444.

J. Evans Attwell, James W. McCartney, Judith M. Johnson, Kathleen C. Lake, Bolivar C. Andrews and Cheryl M. Foley were on brief for intervenors, Texas Eastern Transmission Corp., et al. in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100 and 84-1444. David T. Andril also entered an appearance for intervenors, Texas Eastern Transmission Corp., et al.

John H. Cheatham, III and Edward B. Myers were on brief for intervenor, Interstate Natural Gas Ass'n in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100 and 84-1444.

John K. Keane, Jr. and Thomas C. Gorak were on brief for intervenor, Maryland People's Counsel in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100, 84-1135, 84-1142, 84-1143, 84-1146, 84-1179 and 84-1444.

Robert P. Haynes, III was on brief for intervenor, Consumer Advocate for the Com. of Pennsylvania in No. 84-1099.

Frank P. Saponaro, Jr. and Jennifer K. Walter were on brief for intervenor, UGI Corp. in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100 and 84-1444.

Donald J. MacIver, Jr., Richard Owen Baish, Scott D. Fobes, C. Frank Reifsnyder and Richard C. Green were on brief for amicus curiae, El Paso Natural Gas Co. in Nos. 80-1099, 84-1100, 84-1135, 84-1142, 84-1143, 84-1146, 84-1179 and 84-1444, urging reversal.

Richard M. Merriman and Stephen G. Kozey entered appearances for intervenor, Dayton Power and Light Co. in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100, 84-1142, 84-1143, 84-1146 and 84-1444.

Glenn W. Letham and Channing D. Strother, Jr. entered appearances for intervenor, Pennsylvania Gas and Water Co. in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100 and 84-1444.

Robert R. Rodecker and Denise C. Goulet entered appearances for intervenor, Public Service Com'n of West Virginia in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100, 84-1135 and 84-1444.

Lewis Carroll entered an appearance for intervenor, Washington Gas and Light Co. in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100, 84-1135, 84-1142, 84-1143, 84-1146, 84-1179 and 84-1444.

Edmund Travis, Jr., Sherman S. Pland and John P. Gregg entered appearances for intervenor, Exxon Corp., in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100 and 84-1135.

James J. Mayer entered an appearance for intervenor, Cincinnati Gas & Elec. Co., et al. in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100, 84-1135, 84-1142, 84-1143, 84-1146 and 84-1444.

Martin J. Marz and Robert S. Tongren entered appearances for intervenor, Public Utilities Com'n of Ohio in Nos. 84-1099, 84-1100, 84-1135, 84-1142, 84-1143, 84-1146, 84-1179 and 84-1444.

Before WALD, MIKVA and EDWARDS, Circuit Judges.


Opinion for the Court filed by Circuit Judge HARRY T. EDWARDS.

HARRY T. EDWARDS, Circuit Judge:

This case involves several petitions for review of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's ("FERC" or "Commission") interpretation of subsection 601(c)(2) of the Natural Gas Policy Act of 1978 ("NGPA"), which guarantees that interstate pipelines can pass through the cost of purchasing natural gas to their customers "except to the extent the Commission determines...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases