ROBERTSON v. WHITE

Nos. 85-2044, 85-2096, 85-2155 and 85-2259.

633 F.Supp. 954 (1986)

Thomas E. ROBERTSON, Jr., As Trustee of the Farmer's Co-Op of Arkansas and Oklahoma, Inc.; Bob Reves; Frances Graham; Robert H. Gibbs, individually; Robert H. Gibbs, as natural guardian of his minor children Thomas A. Gibbs and Robert H. Gibbs, Jr.; and Robert H. Gibbs, as Trustee of the Muskogee Internal Medicine Group Profit Sharing Funds, Plaintiffs, and Intervening Plaintiffs v. Jack E. WHITE; J.E.W., Inc.; Valley Feeds, Inc.; Gene Kuykendall and Fred Kuykendall, individually and d/b/a Kuykendall & Kuykendall, a partnership; Oran Moody, Jr. and Michael O. Moody, individually and d/b/a Moody & Moody, a partnership; Arthur Young & Company; Harry C. Erwin; Billy Joe Cabaniss, Jr.; Joseph F. Drozal, Jr.; Charles M. Hanson; Hal Brewer; Waldo Price; Truman O. Boatright; J.O. McClure; Hugh Winfrey, Jr.; M.V. Creech; Charles Bane; E.H. Pritchett, Jr.; Robert Plunkett; Ralph McClure; Jimmy Don Gooch; Jerry Metzger; W.J. Rimmer; Don Sebo; Joe Wayne Harris; James Willis; Dan Ray Core; Harold Davis; Jay Freeman; Jay Neal, Jr.; George Wagnon; Raymond (Jack) Clark; Carl Creekmore and Morril H. Harriman, Jr., individually and d/b/a Creekmore & Harriman, a partnership; E.J. Ball, Kenneth R. Mourton, and Stephen E. Adams, individually and d/b/a Ball, Mourton & Adams, a partnership; Kirit Goradia; Eddie Joe Smith; and John Does 1-20, Defendants.

United States District Court, W.D. Arkansas, Fort Smith Division.

April 4, 1986.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Gary M. Elden, Daniel A. Edelman, John R. McCambridge, Kevin J. Waite, Reuben & Proctor, Christopher J. Doherty, Isham, Lincoln & Beale, Chicago, Ill., for plaintiff, Thomas E. Robertson, Jr., As Trustee of the Farmer's Co-op of Arkansas and Oklahoma.

Robert R. Cloar, Fort Smith, Ark., for intervening plaintiffs: Bob Reves, Frances Graham, Robert H. Gibbs, as Natural Guardian of His Minor Children, Thomas A. Gibbs and Robert H. Gibbs, Jr., and Robert H. Gibbs, as Trustee of the Muskogee Internal Medicine Group Profit Sharing Funds, and Bob Reves, Frances Graham, and Robert H. Gibbs as Class and Subclass Representatives.

Carl Liggio, John Matson, New York City, for Arthur Young & Co., Harry C. Erwin, Billy Joe Cabaniss, Jr., Joseph F. Drozal, Jr., Charles M. Hanson.

James M. Roy, Jr., Roy, Mashburn & Lambert, Springdale, Ark., for Arthur Young & Co.

Fred H. Harrison, University of Arkansas, Little Rock, Ark., for W.J. Rimmer.

Fines F. Batchelor, Jr., Van Buren, Ark., for Truman O. Boatright, Hugh Winfrey, Jr., Jimmy Don Gooch, Ralph McClure, Joe Wayne Harris, James Willis, Dan Ray Core, Harold Davis, Jay Freeman.

Mr. Carl Creekmore, Mr. Morril H. Harriman, Jr., Van Buren, Ark., for Carl Creekmore and Morril H. Harriman, Jr., Ind. and d/b/a Creekmore & Harriman, a partnership.

Jerry Lee Canfield, Daily, West, Core, Coffman & Canfield, Fort Smith, Ark., for Citizens Bank & Trust Co.

Robert L. Jones, III, Jones, Gilbreath & Jones, Fort Smith, Ark., for Gene Kuykendall and Fred Kuykendall, Ind. and d/b/a Kuykendall & Kuykendall, a partnership.

Thomas B. Pryor, Pryor, Robinson and Barry, Fort Smith, Ark., for Oran Moody, Jr. and Michael O. Moody, Ind. and d/b/a Moody and Moody, a partnership.

Eddie N. Christian, Christian & Beland, Fort Smith, Ark., for Jack E. White, J.E.W., Inc., Valley Feeds, Inc.

Jim Jones, Sallisaw, Okl., for M.V. Creech, Charles Bane, Jerry Metzger.

Jerry D. Pruitt, Pruitt & Hodnett, Fort Smith, Ark., for Hal Brewer, Don Sebo, E.H. Pritchett, Jr.

Kenneth R. Mourton, Ball, Mourton and Adams, Fayetteville, Ark., for Ball, Mourton & Adams, a partnership.

Mark A. Grober, Sandlin, Payne & Grober, Muskogee, Okl., for Robert Plunkett.

S. Walton Maurras, Harper, Young, Smith & Maurras, Fort Smith, Ark., for George Wagnon, Raymond (Jack) Clark, Eddie Joe Smith, Waldo Price, J.O. McClure.

Ronald D. Harrison, Harrison and Hewett, Fort Smith, Ark., for Kirit Goradia.

James B. Blair, Springdale, Ark., for E.J. Ball, Kenneth R. Mourton and Stephen E. Adams, Ind. and d/b/a Ball, Mourton & Adams.

James A. Arnold, II, Shaw, Ledbetter, Hornberger, Cogbill & Arnold, Fort Smith, Ark., for Jay Neal, Jr.

Gary D. Corum, Wilson, Engstrom, Corum & Dudley, Little Rock, Ark., for Harry Erwin.


MEMORANDUM OPINION

H. FRANKLIN WATERS, Chief Judge.

Defendants have filed numerous objections to Magistrate Ned A. Stewart, Jr.'s Proposed Findings and Recommendations denying their motions challenging the sufficiency of the plaintiffs' consolidated complaint, under Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (FRCP) Rule 12(b)(6). These objections are before this court pursuant to 28 U.S.C. Sec. 636(b)(1).

Plaintiffs in this action are Thomas Robertson, Jr...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases