EX PARTE PUBLIC NATIONAL BANK OF NEW YORK

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Mr. Martin Saxe, with whom Messrs. Henry L. Moses, Robert C. Beatty, Herman G. Kopald, and Edward F. Colladay were on the brief, for petitioner.

Mr. Wm. H. King, with whom Messrs. George P. Nicholson and Eugene Fay were on the brief, for Mr. Andrew B. Keating, as Receiver of Taxes of the City of New York, and Mr. William Reid, Jr., as City Collector.

Mr. Henry S. Manley, with whom Mr. Albert Ottinger, Attorney General, was on the brief, for the State of New York.

Honorable Learned Hand and Honorable Augustus N. Hand, Circuit Judges, and Honorable William Bondy, District Judge, submitted on printed return for themselves.