LEBLANC v. TEXAS BRINE CO., LLC

Civil Action No. 12-2059 Consolidated and Cases.

LISA T. LEBLANC, ET AL. v. TEXAS BRINE CO., LLC, ET AL, SECTION: "A" (5).

United States District Court, E.D. Louisiana.

February 4, 2020.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 33 U.S.C. § 1319
Cause: 33 U.S.C. § 1319 Clean Water Act
Nature of Suit: 360 P.I.: Other
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Alton Shelby Easterly, Special Master, represented by A. Shelby Easterly, III , Easterly Law Office.

Lisa T. Leblanc, Plaintiff, represented by Autumn Alycia Town , Law Office of Autumn Town, LLC, Calvin Clifford Fayard, Jr. , Fayard & Honeycutt, David Blayne Honeycutt , Fayard & Honeycutt, Jennifer L. Crose , Jim S. Hall & Associates, Kevin Patrick Klibert , Becnel Law Firm, LLC, Lana Ourso Chaney , Lana Ourso Chaney, Attorney at Law, Lawrence J. Centola, III , Martzell & Bickford, Matthew B. Moreland , Jim S. Hall & Associates, Richard Gerard Perque , Law Office of Richard G. Perque, LLC & Salvadore Christina, Jr. , Becnel Law Firm, LLC.

Nathan J. Leblanc, Beverly S. Vaughn & Jay M. Vaughn, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, Plaintiffs, represented by Autumn Alycia Town , Law Office of Autumn Town, LLC, Jennifer L. Crose , Jim S. Hall & Associates, Kevin Patrick Klibert , Becnel Law Firm, LLC, Lana Ourso Chaney , Lana Ourso Chaney, Attorney at Law, Matthew B. Moreland , Jim S. Hall & Associates, Richard Gerard Perque , Law Office of Richard G. Perque, LLC & Salvadore Christina, Jr. , Becnel Law Firm, LLC.

John Hill, Katherine Blanchard, Cherie Blanchard, Ginger Vaughn, Allen Hill, Ethel Gaudet, David Blanchard, Ross Blanchard, Clint Vaughn, Louis Altizan, III & Linda Cavalier, Plaintiffs, represented by Calvin Clifford Fayard, Jr. , Fayard & Honeycutt, Lawrence J. Centola, III , Martzell & Bickford, Matthew B. Moreland , Jim S. Hall & Associates & Richard Gerard Perque , Law Office of Richard G. Perque, LLC.

Betty Cedotal & Trinity Guilliot, individually and on behalf of Slade Guilliot 12-2246, Consol Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey Michael Heggelund , Heggelund Law, LLC & Marvin Gros , Law Office of Marvin Gros.

Charlotte Hebert, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey Michael Heggelund , Heggelund Law, LLC, Brian P. Marcelle , Huber, Thomas and Marcelle, LLP, Marvin Gros , Law Office of Marvin Gros & Stephen M. Huber , Huber, Thomas and Marcelle, LLP.

John Hill, Linda Hill, Ronnie Bryant, Ronnie Thibodaux, Betty Thibodaux, Wallace P. Cavalier & Linda Cavalier, Consol Plaintiffs, represented by Scott R. Bickford , Martzell & Bickford, Gregory Alan Koury , Koury & Hill, APLC, Lawrence J. Centola, III , Martzell & Bickford & Spencer R. Doody , Martzell & Bickford.

Brandon Alleman, 12-2363, individually and on behalf of his minor children, Ashley Alleman, 12-2363, individually and on behalf of her minor child, Abbie Hue, 12-2363, individually and on behalf of her minor children, Henry Welch, Carolyn Welch, Grady Alleman, 12-2363, individually and on behalf of his minor child, Carla Alleman, 12-2363, individually and on behalf of her minor child, Jason P. Charlet, 12-2363, individually and on behalf of his minor children & Jason Hue, 12-2363, individually and on behalf of his minor child, Consol Plaintiffs, represented by Calvin Clifford Fayard, Jr. , Fayard & Honeycutt, David Blayne Honeycutt , Fayard & Honeycutt, Hobart O. Pardue, Jr. , Law Office of Hobart Pardue, LLC & Wanda Jean Edwards , Fayard & Honeycutt.

Ernest Boudreaux, Jr., Scotty Bourg, Tammy Coupel, Warren Coupel, Sr., Nick Daigle, Zachary Fifer, Debbie Ishmael, Amber Kern, Cherish Kraemer, Brad Rohman, Tanner Rivere, Deborah Rousseau, Thomas Rousseau, Telesia Simoneaux, Diamond Gustave, Penny Hebert, Aimee Hebert, Mona Branum, Donald Calamia, Marla Calmia, Debra M. Charlet, Herman Charlet, Warren Coupel, Jr., Joelle M. Cox, May H. Daigre, Mike Daigre, Carl Dugas, Ramona Dugas, Clint A. Dupre, April Gaspard, Jonathan Gaspard, Jason Gregoire, Jennifer Gregoire, Cassie Gros, Alvin Gros, Preston P. Guilbeau, Victoria C. Guilbeau, Tina Guillot, Wesley Guillot, Bethany Hayden, Charlie Hayden, Christine Landry, Joseph Landry, Kenneth Marrory, Jim Parks, Patricia Parks, Donna Pipsair, Hayes Pipsair, Kai Pipsair, Rhett Pipsair, Michelle Rousseau, Randy Rousseau, Norman Setlewe, Carole Vincent, Marvin Vincent, Jamie Weber, Laser Construction, Automotive Remodeling, Town & Country Mini Storage, John Ruiz, Vera Ruiz, Robbie Daigle, 13-5563, individually and on behalf of the minor child Karlie Daigle, Tina Cavalier, 13-5563, individually and on behalf of the minor child Karlie Daigle, Tee's Silkscreening & Erica Lynn North, Consol Plaintiffs, represented by Stephen M. Huber , Huber, Thomas and Marcelle, LLP & Brian P. Marcelle , Huber, Thomas and Marcelle, LLP.

Grand Bayou Management, LLC, Super Stop Enterprises, Inc., Robert Sunshine, L.L.C. & Roland J. Robert Distributor, Inc., Consol Plaintiffs, represented by Timothy J. Poche , Taylor, Porter, Brooks & Phillips LLP & Thomas D. Gildersleeve , Taylor, Porter, Brooks & Phillips LLP.

Dianne Sanchez, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Calvin Clifford Fayard, Jr. , Fayard & Honeycutt, David Blayne Honeycutt , Fayard & Honeycutt, Heidi M. Gould , Heidi Mabile Gould, Attorney at Law, Lana Ourso Chaney , Lana Ourso Chaney, Attorney at Law, Lawrence J. Centola, III , Martzell & Bickford, Matthew B. Moreland , Jim S. Hall & Associates & Richard Gerard Perque , Law Office of Richard G. Perque, LLC.

Michael Stewart, Casey Gilliot, Gertrude Sanchez, Justin Frey, Dorothy Blaine, Leah Payne, Robert Payne, Wineva Sanchez, Iris Alleman, Donna Alleman, Mary Elizabeth Rodriguez Russo, Henry Blanchard, Jacqueline Blanchard, Louis Blanchard, Edna Blanchard, Gerald Blanchard, Jeannette Blanchard, Courtney Sanchez, Dennis Sanchez, Angela Blanchard, Roberta Crochet, Lee Ann Crochet, Warren Blanchard, Jonell Blanchard, Helena Rivere, Dorren Landry, Circuit Grand Bayou, LLC, Donaldson Cavalier, Russell Cavalier, Sr., Larry Hue, Joe Daigle, Carolee Woodward, Evelyn Landry, Michael Landry, Lorraine Delatte, Arnold Blanchard, Sharon Blanchard, Arthur Blanchard, Justin Blanchard, Michael Blanchard, Elora Blanchard, Hubert Aucoin, Alicia Aucoin, Russell Aucoin, Sandra Aucoin, Fred Fernandez, Winnie Fernandez, Preston Landry, Terry Leonard, Christin Leonard, Lynn Mabile, Wilma Scioneaux, Katina Smith, Henry Christman, Russell Porrier & Pam Porrier, Consol Plaintiffs, represented by Calvin Clifford Fayard, Jr. , Fayard & Honeycutt, Lawrence J. Centola, III , Martzell & Bickford, Matthew B. Moreland , Jim S. Hall & Associates & Richard Gerard Perque , Law Office of Richard G. Perque, LLC.

Ervin Alberado, Julie Alberado & Russ Mabile, Consol Plaintiffs, represented by Patrick Wayne Pendley , Pendley, Baudin & Coffin, LLP & Jessica A. Perez , Pendley, Baudin & Coffin, LLP.

Mary Mabile, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Patrick Wayne Pendley , Pendley, Baudin & Coffin, LLP, Jessica A. Perez , Pendley, Baudin & Coffin, LLP & Lawrence J. Centola, III , Martzell & Bickford.

Eloise D. Brown, James Clyde Gremillion, John Timothy Rathburn, Linda S. Rathburn, Donnie F. Gauthier, Melinda F. Gauthier, Elaine H. Dupre & Harley C. Brown, Consol Plaintiffs, represented by Harley M. Brown , Harley M. Brown, APLC.

Neil P. Landry, Jr., Elmira M. Landry, Dennis P. Landry, Inc., Dickie J. Esquivel, Joyce D. Esquivel, Mary W. Deaton, Scott Anderson, Louise Anderson, Teleca Donachricha, D. Michael Medine, Donna Medine, Ronald T. Brown, Kathryn Macaluso Brown, Richard S. Bourgoyne, Leslie O. Bourgoyne, Joseph E. Bourgoyne, Jacqueline L. Bourgoyne, Sanford Junot, Judy Junot, William N. Overby, James F. Looney, Myrna D. Looney, Lucy Saia, Donald Ruiz, Patricia S. Ruiz, Michael J. Pourciau, Pamela D. Pourciau, Wilfred J. Foret, Jr., Sandy B. Foret, Sterling P. Leonard, Vicky R. Leonard, Lindsey Blanchard, Susan Blanchard, Yvonne Litton, Nicholas Blanchard, Matthew Blanchard, Shaun Berthelot, William W. Vice, Catherine M. Vice, Michael N. Latino, Jamie C. Latino, Krystal Latino, Shelby Latino, Robert Deaton, Sr. & Sheila D. Overby, Consol Plaintiffs, represented by Sidney Albert Marchand, III , Sidney A. Marchand, III, Attorney at Law.

Bernard R. Kannon, Jr., Consol Plaintiff, represented by Donald G. Cave , Cave Law Firm.

Nolan J. Benoit, Jr. & Elizabeth Talbot Benoit, Consol Plaintiffs, represented by Jerald P. Block , Block Law Firm & Kendall J. Krielow , Block Law Firm.

Occidental Chemical Corporation, Defendant, represented by Christoffer C. Friend , Jones Walker, Angus Joe Dodson , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, pro hac vice, Grant Davis-Denny , Munger, Tolles & Olson, LLP, pro hac vice, Kathy Dawn Patrick , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, Laura Kissel Cassidy , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, Meghan Elizabeth Smith , Jones Walker, Nicole M. Duarte , Jones Walker LLP & Tarak Anada , Jones Walker.

Agricultural Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by George James Richaud , Young, Richaud & Myers, LLC.

American Guarantee & Liability Insurance Co, Steadfast Insurance Company & Zurich American Insurance Company, Defendants, represented by Glen Mercer , Salley, Hite, Mercer & Resor LLC & Kourtney Twenhafel French , Salley, Hite, Mercer & Resor LLC.

Chubb Custom Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by John Powers Wolff, III , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Fireman's Fund Insurance Company, Fireman's Fund Insurance Company of Ohio & National Surety Corporation, Defendants, represented by James A. Rowell , Degan, Blanchard & Nash, Sidney W. Degan, III , Degan, Blanchard & Nash & Nicholas J. Cenac , Degan, Blanchard & Nash.

Great American Assurance Company, Defendant, represented by Robert John Young, III , Young, Richaud & Myers, LLC & George James Richaud , Young, Richaud & Myers, LLC.

Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania, Defendant, represented by Mary S. Johnson , Johnson, Gray, McNamara, LLC, Chadwick J. Mollere , Johnson, Gray, McNamara, LLC & S. Suzanne Mahoney , Johnson, Gray, McNamara, LLC.

Lexington Inscurance Company, National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pa. & AIG Specialty Insurance Company, formerly known as American International Surplus Lines Insurance Company, American International Specialty Lines Insurance Company, Defendants, represented by Mary S. Johnson , Johnson, Gray, McNamara, LLC, Chadwick J. Mollere , Johnson, Gray, McNamara, LLC, Ingrid Kemp Laurendine , Johnson Gray McNamara & S. Suzanne Mahoney , Johnson, Gray, McNamara, LLC.

Liberty Insurance Underwriters, Inc., Defendant, represented by Judy Y. Barrasso , Barrasso, Usdin, Kupperman, Freeman & Sarver, LLC, David N. Luder , Barrasso, Usdin, Kupperman, Freeman & Sarver, LLC, Kyle W. Siegel , Barrasso, Usdin, Kupperman, Freeman & Sarver, LLC & Stephen L. Miles , Pipes Miles Beckman, LLC.

TIG Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Jay M. Lonero , Larzelere, Picou, Wells, Simpson, Lonero, LLC, Angie Arceneaux Akers , Larzelere, Picou, Wells, Simpson, Lonero, LLC & Thomas H. Peyton , Phelps Dunbar, LLP.

Zurich Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Glen Mercer , Salley, Hite, Mercer & Resor LLC.

Travelers Indemnity Company, Defendant, represented by Daniel B. Centner , Lugenbuhl, Wheaton, Peck, Rankin & Hubbard & Seth Andrew Schmeeckle , Lugenbuhl, Wheaton, Peck, Rankin & Hubbard.

Occidental Chemical Corporation, Consol Defendant, represented by Christoffer C. Friend , Jones Walker, Angus Joe Dodson , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, pro hac vice, Grant Davis-Denny , Munger, Tolles & Olson, LLP, pro hac vice, Kathy Dawn Patrick , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, Meghan Elizabeth Smith , Jones Walker & Tarak Anada , Jones Walker.

Texas Brine Company, LLC, Consol Defendant, represented by Christopher Chocheles , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, James M. Garner , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Jeffrey D. Kessler , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Jonathan B. Cerise , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Leopold Z. Sher , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Peter L. Hilbert, Jr. , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Ryan O'Neil Luminais , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC & Dane S. Ciolino , Dane S. Ciolino, LLC.

Miller Engineers & Associates, Inc., Consol Defendant, represented by Kirk A. Patrick, III , Donohue, Patrick & Scott & Blake Anthony Altazan , Donohue, Patrick & Scott.

Occidental Chemical Corporation, #129, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Christoffer C. Friend , Jones Walker, Angus Joe Dodson , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, pro hac vice, Grant Davis-Denny , Munger, Tolles & Olson, LLP, pro hac vice, Kathy Dawn Patrick , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, Meghan Elizabeth Smith , Jones Walker & Tarak Anada , Jones Walker.

Reliance Petroleum Corporation, formerly known as Retrust Oil & Gas Corp, Third Party Defendant, represented by Ashley Gill Gable , Bradley, Murchison, Kelly & Shea, LLC, Joseph Lawrence Shea, Jr. , Bradley, Murchison, Kelly & Shea, LLC, Katherine S. Baker , Bradley, Murchison, Kelly & Shea, LLC & Joshua Steven Chevallier , Bradley, Murchison, Kelly & Shea, LLC.

Legacy Vulcan Corp., formerly known as Vulcan Materials Company, Third Party Defendant, represented by Roy Clifton Cheatwood , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Adam Bennett Zuckerman , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Antonio M. Clayton , Clayton, Fruge & Ward, LLC, Christopher A. Mason , Breazeale, Sachse & Wilson, L. L. P, Douglas K. Williams , Breazeale, Sachse & Wilson, L. L. P, Kent A. Lambert , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Matthew S. Chester , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Michael Charles Luquet , Breazeale, Sachse & Wilson, L. L. P & Tyler Weidlich , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz.

Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania, AIG Specialty Insurance Company, formerly known as American International Surplus Lines Insurance Company, American International Specialty Lines Insurance Company, AIG Specialty Insurance Company, Solely in its capacity as an alleged insurer of Adams Resources Exploration Corporation, Lexington Insurance Company, solely in its capacity as alleged insurer of Adams Resources Exploration Corporation, National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pa., solely in its capacity as an alleged insurer of Adams Resources Exploration Corporation, National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pa., solely in its capacity as an alleged insurer of Occidental Chemical Corporation, Occidental Petroleum Corporation, and/or Oxy USA, Inc., New Hampshire Insurance Company, solely in its capacity as an alleged insurer of Occidental Chemical Corporation, Occidental Petroleum Corporation, and/or Oxy USA, Inc., AIG Specialty Insurance Company, solely in its capacity as an alleged insurer of Occidental Chemical Corporation, Occidental Petroleum Corporation, and/or Oxy, Inc., Lexington Insurance Company & National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pa., Third Party Defendants, represented by Mary S. Johnson , Johnson, Gray, McNamara, LLC, Ingrid Kemp Laurendine , Johnson Gray McNamara & Nichole M. Gray , Johnson Gray McNamara.

Travelers Indemnity Company & Travelers Indemnity Company of Connecticut, Third Party Defendants, represented by Daniel B. Centner , Lugenbuhl, Wheaton, Peck, Rankin & Hubbard & Seth Andrew Schmeeckle , Lugenbuhl, Wheaton, Peck, Rankin & Hubbard.

Occidental Petroleum Corporation, Occidental VCM, LLC, Oxy USA Inc & Basic Chemical Company, LLC, Third Party Defendants, represented by Christoffer C. Friend , Jones Walker, Meghan Elizabeth Smith , Jones Walker & Nicole M. Duarte , Jones Walker LLP.

Sol Kirschner, Third Party Defendant, represented by Reid A. Jones , Wiener, Weiss & Madison, A Professional Corporation, Frank H. Spruiell, Jr. , Wiener, Weiss & Madison, A Professional Corporation, John M. Madison, III , Kracht Madison Huddleston, LLC & Seth M. Moyers , Wiener, Weiss & Madison.

Colorado Crude Company, Browning Oil Company, Inc. & LORCA Corporation, Third Party Defendants, represented by Matthew J. Randazzo, III , Randazzo Giglio & Bailey, LLC, Christopher B. Bailey , Randazzo Giglio & Bailey, LLC & Shawn A. Carter , Randazzo Giglio & Bailey, LLC.

RLI Insurance Company, Third Party Defendant, represented by Alan David Ezkovich , Ezkovich & Co. & Kristin M. Lausten , Scott, Vicknair, Hair & Checki.

Chicago Insurance Company, Third Party Defendant, represented by Sidney W. Degan, III , Degan, Blanchard & Nash, Julia Ann Dietz , Degan, Blanchard & Nash, Matthew F. Morgan , Degan, Blanchard & Nash & Wade B. Hammett , Degan, Blanchard & Nash.

Gemini Insurance Company, Third Party Defendant, represented by Susan A. Daigle , Daigle Rayburn, LLC, Gregory John Laborde , Daigle Rayburn, LLC, John Daniel Rayburn, Jr. , Daigle Rayburn, LLC & Kristen A. Hernandez , Daigle Rayburn, LLC.

Aspen Insurance UK Limited, Third Party Defendant, represented by Richard Nelson Dicharry , Phelps Dunbar, LLP, Ashley Ward Hinton , Phelps Dunbar, LLP & Jeremy T. Grabill , Phelps Dunbar, LLP.

National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, Third Party Defendant, represented by Mary S. Johnson , Johnson, Gray, McNamara, LLC.

Starr Surplus Lines Insurance Company, Third Party Defendant, represented by Jennifer E. Michel , Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith LLP & Danielle M. Smith , Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith LLP.

North America Capacity Insurace Company, Third Party Defendant, represented by Doris Theresa Bobadilla , Galloway, Johnson, Tompkins, Burr & Smith, Andrea Leigh Albert , Galloway, Johnson, Tompkins, Burr & Smith & Ryan Daniel O'Connor , Galloway, Johnson, Tompkins, Burr & Smith.

Legacy Vulcan, LLC, formerly known as Legacy Vulcan Corp., Vulcan Materials Corp, Third Party Defendant, represented by Roy Clifton Cheatwood , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Adam Bennett Zuckerman , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Antonio M. Clayton , Clayton, Fruge & Ward, LLC, Colleen Carr Jarrott , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Kent A. Lambert , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Lauren Brink Adams , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Leopoldo J. Yanez , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Matthew S. Chester , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz & Matthew C. Juneau , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz.

Vulcan Materials Company, Third Party Defendant, represented by Adam Bennett Zuckerman , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Roy Clifton Cheatwood , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Kent A. Lambert , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Matthew S. Chester , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz & Tyler Weidlich , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz.

National Fire Insurance Company of Hartford, Successor by Merger to Transcontinental Insurance Company, Improperly named as Transcontinental Insurance Company (doc. 1303), Third Party Defendant, represented by Paula Marcello Wellons , Taylor, Wellons, Politz & Duhe, APLC, D. Ashbrooke Tullis , Preis PLC & Travis Brendon Wilkinson , Taylor, Wellons, Politz & Duhe, APLC.

Sirius International Insurance Corporation, as successor to Sirius Insurance Company UK Ltd; erroneouusly referred to as Sirius UK Insurance, PLC, Yorkshire Insurance Co. Ltd., (doc. 669), Ocean Marine Insurance Co., Ltd., (doc. 669), Hansa Marine Insurance Company, Ltd., (doc. 669) & Northern Assurance Company, Ltd., (doc. 669), Third Party Defendants, represented by Gustave A. Fritchie, III , Irwin Fritchie Urquhart & Moore, LLC & McDonald Provosty , Irwin Fritchie Urquhart & Moore, LLC.

Vulcan Materials Company, All Cases, #229, Consol Counter Claimant, represented by Roy Clifton Cheatwood , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Adam Bennett Zuckerman , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Kent A. Lambert , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Matthew S. Chester , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz & Tyler Weidlich , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz.

Texas Brine Company, LLC, #229, Counter Defendant, represented by Leopold Z. Sher , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Christopher Chocheles , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, James M. Garner , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Jeffrey D. Kessler , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Jonathan B. Cerise , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Peter L. Hilbert, Jr. , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC & Ryan O'Neil Luminais , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC.

Texas Brine Company, LLC, All cases, #229, Consol Counter Defendant, represented by Leopold Z. Sher , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Christopher Chocheles , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, James M. Garner , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Jeffrey D. Kessler , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Jonathan B. Cerise , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Peter L. Hilbert, Jr. , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC & Ryan O'Neil Luminais , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC.

Occidental Chemical Corporation, #129, Consol Cross Claimant, represented by Christoffer C. Friend , Jones Walker, Angus Joe Dodson , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, pro hac vice, Grant Davis-Denny , Munger, Tolles & Olson, LLP, pro hac vice, Kathy Dawn Patrick , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, Meghan Elizabeth Smith , Jones Walker & Tarak Anada , Jones Walker.

Texas Brine Company, LLC, #129, Cross Defendant, represented by Christopher Chocheles , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, James M. Garner , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC & Ryan O'Neil Luminais , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC.

Pontchartrain Natural Gas System, K/D/S Promix LLC & Acadian Gas Pipeline System, Movants, represented by James Conner Percy , Jones Walker, Brett S. Venn , Jones Walker, Kevin O. Ainsworth , Jones Walker & Marjorie Ann McKeithen , Jones Walker.

Kean Miller, LLP, Troy J. Charpentier & Bradley C. Meyers, Movants, represented by Connell Lee Archey , Butler Snow.

Vulcan Construction Materials LLC, Florida Rock Industries, Inc. & CalMat Co., Movants, represented by Kent A. Lambert , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz.

PB Energy Storage Services, Inc., Movant, represented by Howard Louis Murphy , Deutsch Kerrigan & Stiles LLP & Darrell K. Cherry , Deutsch Kerrigan & Stiles LLP.

Texas Brine Company, LLC, Doc. 123 & 125, Texas Brine Company, LLC, Doc. 124 & Texas Brine Company, LLC, Third Party Plaintiffs, represented by Christopher Chocheles , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, James M. Garner , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Jeffrey D. Kessler , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Jonathan B. Cerise , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Leopold Z. Sher , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Peter L. Hilbert, Jr. , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC & Ryan O'Neil Luminais , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC.

Vulcan Materials Company, Doc. 123 & 125, Third Party Defendant, represented by Roy Clifton Cheatwood , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Adam Bennett Zuckerman , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Kent A. Lambert , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Matthew S. Chester , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz & Tyler Weidlich , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz.

Adams Resources Exploration Corporation, Third Party Defendant, represented by Jason Marechal Cerise , Locke Lord.

Vulcan Materials Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Roy Clifton Cheatwood , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Adam Bennett Zuckerman , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Kent A. Lambert , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Matthew S. Chester , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz & Tyler Weidlich , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz.

Texas Brine Company, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Christopher Chocheles , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Dane S. Ciolino , Dane S. Ciolino, LLC, James M. Garner , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Jeffrey D. Kessler , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Jonathan B. Cerise , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Leopold Z. Sher , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Peter L. Hilbert, Jr. , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC & Ryan O'Neil Luminais , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC.

Legacy Vulcan Corp., formerly known as Vulcan Materials Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Roy Clifton Cheatwood , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Adam Bennett Zuckerman , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Antonio M. Clayton , Clayton, Fruge & Ward, LLC, Christopher A. Mason , Breazeale, Sachse & Wilson, L. L. P, Douglas K. Williams , Breazeale, Sachse & Wilson, L. L. P, Kent A. Lambert , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Michael Charles Luquet , Breazeale, Sachse & Wilson, L. L. P & Tyler Weidlich , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz.

Occidental Chemical Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Christoffer C. Friend , Jones Walker, Angus Joe Dodson , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, pro hac vice, Grant Davis-Denny , Munger, Tolles & Olson, LLP, pro hac vice, Kathy Dawn Patrick , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, Meghan Elizabeth Smith , Jones Walker & Tarak Anada , Jones Walker.

Legacy Vulcan Corp., formerly known as Vulcan Materials Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Roy Clifton Cheatwood , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Adam Bennett Zuckerman , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Antonio M. Clayton , Clayton, Fruge & Ward, LLC, Christopher A. Mason , Breazeale, Sachse & Wilson, L. L. P, Douglas K. Williams , Breazeale, Sachse & Wilson, L. L. P, Kent A. Lambert , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Michael Charles Luquet , Breazeale, Sachse & Wilson, L. L. P & Tyler Weidlich , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz.

Texas Brine Company, LLC, (Doc. 433), Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Christopher Chocheles , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Dane S. Ciolino , Dane S. Ciolino, LLC, James M. Garner , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC, Peter L. Hilbert, Jr. , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC & Ryan O'Neil Luminais , Sher, Garner, Cahill, Richter, Klein & Hilbert, LLC.

Agricultural Insurance Company & Great American Assurance Company, Third Party Defendants, represented by Robert John Young, III , Young, Richaud & Myers, LLC & George James Richaud , Young, Richaud & Myers, LLC.

American Guarantee & Liability Insurance Co, Steadfast Insurance Company, Zurich American Insurance Company & Zurich Insurance Company, Third Party Defendants, represented by Glen Mercer , Salley, Hite, Mercer & Resor LLC & Kourtney Twenhafel French , Salley, Hite, Mercer & Resor LLC.

Chubb Custom Insurance Company, Third Party Defendant, represented by John Powers Wolff, III , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd, Brian Timothy Butler , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd, Nancy B. Gilbert , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd & Richard W. Wolff , Keogh, Cox & Wilson Ltd.

Fireman's Fund Insurance Company, Fireman's Fund Insurance Company of Ohio, National Surety Corporation & National Surety Company, Third Party Defendants, represented by Sidney W. Degan, III , Degan, Blanchard & Nash, James A. Rowell , Degan, Blanchard & Nash & Nicholas J. Cenac , Degan, Blanchard & Nash.

Gulf Insurance Company, Third Party Defendant, represented by Celeste D. Elliott , Lugenbuhl, Wheaton, Peck, Rankin & Hubbard.

TIG Insurance Company, successor by merger to Fairmont Specialty Insurance Company, Third Party Defendant, represented by Jay M. Lonero , Larzelere, Picou, Wells, Simpson, Lonero, LLC, Angie Arceneaux Akers , Larzelere, Picou, Wells, Simpson, Lonero, LLC & Thomas H. Peyton , Phelps Dunbar, LLP.

Occidental Chemical Corporation, Third Party Defendant, represented by Christoffer C. Friend , Jones Walker, Angus Joe Dodson , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, pro hac vice, Grant Davis-Denny , Munger, Tolles & Olson, LLP, pro hac vice, Kathy Dawn Patrick , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, Meghan Elizabeth Smith , Jones Walker & Tarak Anada , Jones Walker.

Scottsdale Insurance Company, Third Party Defendant, represented by Katherine Karam , Phelps Dunbar, LLP, Douglas M. Kleeman , Phelps Dunbar, LLP, Katherine L. Wyly , Phelps Dunbar, LLP, Katie Whitman Myers , Phelps Dunbar, LLP & Pablo Gonzalez , Phelps Dunbar, LLP.

Occidental Chemical Corporation, #129, Cross Claimant, represented by Christoffer C. Friend , Jones Walker, Angus Joe Dodson , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, pro hac vice, Grant Davis-Denny , Munger, Tolles & Olson, LLP, pro hac vice, Kathy Dawn Patrick , Gibbs & Bruns LLP, Meghan Elizabeth Smith , Jones Walker & Tarak Anada , Jones Walker.

Vulcan Materials Company, Doc. 123 & 125, Cross Defendant, represented by Roy Clifton Cheatwood , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Adam Bennett Zuckerman , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Kent A. Lambert , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz, Matthew S. Chester , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz & Tyler Weidlich , Baker Donelson Bearman Caldwell & Berkowitz.

Oxy USA Inc, Occidental Petroleum Corporation, Occidental VCM, LLC & Basic Chemical Company, LLC, Third Party Plaintiffs, represented by Christoffer C. Friend , Jones Walker & Meghan Elizabeth Smith , Jones Walker.

Reliance Petroleum Corporation, formerly known as Retrust Oil & Gas Corp, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Ashley Gill Gable , Bradley, Murchison, Kelly & Shea, LLC, Joseph Lawrence Shea, Jr. , Bradley, Murchison, Kelly & Shea, LLC, Joshua Steven Chevallier , Bradley, Murchison, Kelly & Shea, LLC & Katherine S. Baker , Bradley, Murchison, Kelly & Shea, LLC.

Sol Kirschner, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Reid A. Jones , Wiener, Weiss & Madison, A Professional Corporation.


FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

REF: 13-5227 (Sanchez—Saizon)

This bellwether case was tried to the Court sitting without a jury on December 3-4, 2019, as to the issue of damages only. Having considered the testimony and evidence at trial, the arguments of counsel...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases