IN RE ROUNDUP PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION

MDL No. 2741, Case No. 16-md-02741-VC.

IN RE: ROUNDUP PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION. This document relates to: Hardeman v. Monsanto, 3:16-cv-00525-VC.

United States District Court, N.D. California.

March 26, 2019.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 28 U.S.C. § 1332
Cause: 28 U.S.C. § 1332 Diversity - Product Liability
Nature of Suit: 365 Personal Inj. Prod. Liability
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Elaine Stevick, Plaintiff, represented by Curtis Hoke , The Miller Firm LLC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Brian Keith Brake , The Miller Firm LLC, Jeffrey Alan Travers , The Miller Firm LLC, Leland Humphrey Belew , Andrus Anderson LLP, Mark Etheredge Burton, Jr. , Audet and Partners, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Tayjes Matthew Shah , The Miller Firm LLC & Timothy Andrew Litzenburg , The Miller Firm, LLC.

Christopher Stevick, Plaintiff, represented by Curtis Hoke , The Miller Firm LLC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Brian Keith Brake , The Miller Firm LLC, Jeffrey Alan Travers , The Miller Firm LLC, Leland Humphrey Belew , Andrus Anderson LLP, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, pro hac vice, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C. & Timothy Andrew Litzenburg , The Miller Firm, LLC.

Christine Sheppard, Plaintiff, represented by Brian K. Mackintosh , Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Curtis George Hoke , The Miller Firm, LLC, Jeffrey Alan Travers , The Miller Firm LLC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, pro hac vice, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Timothy Andrew Litzenburg , The Miller Firm, LLC.

Kenneth Sheppard, Plaintiff, represented by Brian K. Mackintosh , Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Jeffrey Alan Travers , The Miller Firm LLC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, pro hac vice, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Timothy Andrew Litzenburg , The Miller Firm, LLC.

Ricky Gibbs, Plaintiff, represented by Katharine Crane Byrne , Cooney & Conway, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Kevin J. Conway , Cooney & Conway, Maja Lukic , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., pro hac vice, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Lawrence Gary Couey, Plaintiff, represented by Hunter William Lundy , Lundy, Lundy, Soileau and South, LLP, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, John H. Daniels, III , DYER, DYER, DYER & JONES, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Emanuel Richard Giglio, Plaintiff, represented by Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, David Jackson Wool , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, pro hac vice, John P. Fiske , Gomez Trial Attorneys, John H. Gomez , Gomez Trial Attorneys, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Enrique Ruiz & Stephanie Ruiz, Plaintiffs, represented by Bruce Don Burtoff , The Miller Firm, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Jeffrey Alan Travers , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

Mark Scheffer, Plaintiff, represented by John J. Roddy , Bailey and Glasser LLP, Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

Teri Michelle McCall, individually and as successor in interest for the estate of Anthony Jackson McCall, deceased & Peter Johansing, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael Lin Baum , Baum Hedlund Aristei and Goldman PC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Kevin J. Madonna , Kennedy & Madonna, LLP, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. , Kennedy & Madonna, LLP, Robert Francis Kennedy, Jr. , Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Ines Hernandez, Plaintiff, represented by Curtis Hoke , The Miller Firm LLC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Curtis George Hoke , The Miller Firm, LLC, Jeffrey Alan Travers , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg, Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC & Timothy Andrew Litzenburg , The Miller Firm, LLC, pro hac vice.

Maria Hernandez, Plaintiff, represented by Curtis Hoke , The Miller Firm LLC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Jeffrey Alan Travers , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg, Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C. & Timothy Andrew Litzenburg , The Miller Firm, LLC, pro hac vice.

John D. Sanders & Frank Tanner, Plaintiffs, represented by Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Kristie Marie Hightower , Lundy Lundy Soileau and South LLP, pro hac vice, Maja Lukic , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., pro hac vice, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

David Means, Plaintiff, represented by Anthony P. Ellis , Dolt, Thompson, Shepherd & Kinney PSC, Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Charles Bridgeman, Plaintiff, represented by Yvonne M. Flaherty , Lockridge Grindal Nauen PLLP, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Edward A. Wallace , Wexler Wallace LLP, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Douglas Harris, Plaintiff, represented by John Backes Prior , Hart McLaughlin & Eldridge, LLC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

Lynda K. Patterson, Plaintiff, represented by Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, David M. Hundley, II , Hundley Law Group, P.C., Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

Vicky Porath, Plaintiff, represented by Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Larry E. Domina, Frank Pollard, Robert L. Dickey & Royce D. Janzen, Plaintiffs, represented by David A. Domina , DOMINA LAW GROUP, Maja Lukic , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., pro hac vice, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., pro hac vice, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Clayton Janise, Plaintiff, represented by Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Vance R. Andrus , Andrus Hood Wagstaff, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

James M. Work, Plaintiff, represented by J. E. Cullens, Jr. , Walters, Papillion, Thomas, Cullens, LLC, Maja Lukic , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., pro hac vice, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Bradley A. Stevens , Edwards & Associates Law Firm, LLC, Hunter William Lundy , Lundy, Lundy, Soileau and South, LLP, Kathryn Jean Edwards , Edwards and Stevens Law Firm, Kristie Marie Hightower , Lundy Lundy Soileau and South LLP, Matthew Edward Lundy , Lundy & Davis, LLP, Max E. Guthrie , Lundy, Lundy Soileau & South, LLP, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., pro hac vice, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C. & Rudie Ray Soileau, Jr. , Lundy, Lundy Soileau & South, LLP.

Michael Tamburello, Plaintiff, represented by Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

Jennifer Abila, Marvin L. Carlock & John Holm, Plaintiffs, represented by David Jackson Wool , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, pro hac vice, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

Larry Goodbred, Plaintiff, represented by Richard M. Paul, III , Paul LLP, pro hac vice, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Christopher M. Ellis , Bolen Robinson & Ellis, LLP, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

John Cushman, Plaintiff, represented by Robert J. McLaughlin , Hart McLaughlin & Eldridge, LLC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, John Backes Prior , Hart McLaughlin & Eldridge, LLC, Kyle Pozan , Hart McLaughlin Eldridge, LLC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

Linda Jeanne Ricci & Gary Mancuso, Plaintiffs, represented by Brian Joseph McCormick, Jr. , Ross Feller Casey, LLP, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

Tonia Turner, Plaintiff, represented by Colin P. King , Dewsnup King and Olsen, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Paul M. Simmons , Dewsnup, King & Olsen & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

Matteo Anthony Russo & Goldie Perkins, Plaintiffs, represented by Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Kathryn Miller Forgie , Andrus Wagstaff PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

William White, Plaintiff, represented by Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Yvonne M. Flaherty , Lockridge Grindal Nauen PLLP.

Wendy Burdett, Plaintiff, represented by Kimberly A. Dougherty , Janet Jenner & Suggs, LLC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

Litton M. Walker, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by John Fletcher Romano , Romano Law Group, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

Eric Morris, Plaintiff, represented by Mark Herbert Schlein , Baum Hedlund Aristei, Goldman, P.C., Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

Mary Ford, Tina Trimpe & Mark Weddel, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert J. McLaughlin , Hart McLaughlin & Eldridge, LLC, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg.

Aaron Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Brian K. Mackintosh , Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg, Timothy Andrew Litzenburg , The Miller Firm, LLC, pro hac vice & James T. Corrigan , ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C.

Yolanda Mendoza, Plaintiff, represented by Hunter William Lundy , Lundy, Lundy, Soileau and South, LLP, PRO HAC VICE, Kristie Marie Hightower , Lundy Lundy Soileau and South LLP, pro hac vice, Maja Lukic , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., pro hac vice, Matthew Edward Lundy , Lundy & Davis, LLP, pro hac vice, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., pro hac vice, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Mark Pecorelli, Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Brian Moll , Moll Law Group, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Kurt D. Hyzy , The Law Group, Ltd., Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Neil Wilson, Terry Pindell, Michael Dowling, Ray Lee, Christopher Northover & Steven Royce Christensen, Plaintiffs, represented by Jacob A. Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM, LLC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Sioum Gebeyehou, Plaintiff, represented by Tesfaye Wolde Tsadik , Law Offices of Tesfaye Tsadik, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Leland Humphrey Belew , Andrus Anderson LLP, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg, Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Karen Wooten, Harley Wooten, III & Timothy Wooten, Plaintiffs, represented by Jennie Lee Anderson , Andrus Anderson LLP, Yvonne M. Flaherty , Lockridge Grindal Nauen PLLP, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Leland Humphrey Belew , Andrus Anderson LLP, Lori Erin Andrus , Andrus Anderson LLP, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Craig R. Butsch, Plaintiff, represented by Maja Lukic , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., pro hac vice, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Daniel R. Mordarski , Law Offices Of Daniel R. Mordarski LLC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Ron Gebo, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher Joseph Smith , Goldstein, Buckley, Cechman, Rice & Purtz, PA, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Hunter William Lundy , Lundy, Lundy, Soileau and South, LLP, Kristie Marie Hightower , Lundy Lundy Soileau and South LLP, Maja Lukic , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., pro hac vice, Matthew Edward Lundy , Lundy & Davis, LLP, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., pro hac vice & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

James Mitchell, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Travis Moore , MORGAN AND MORGAN PA, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Randall Dean Seidl, Plaintiff, represented by John Everett Tomlinson , Beasley, Allen, Crow, Methvin, Portis & Miles, PC, pro hac vice, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg, Rhon Eugene Jones , Beasley, Allen, Crown, Methvin, Portis & Miles, PC, pro hac vice, Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C. & W. Michael Workman , Workman Law Firm, PLLC.

Joseph E. Shipley & Margaret Shipley, Plaintiffs, represented by Brian P. Galligan , GALLIGAN & REID PC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, James Griffin O'Brien , O'Brien Law, LLC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Sabas Sanchez & Rosa Sanchez, Plaintiffs, represented by James Griffin O'Brien , O'Brien Law, LLC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Paul Galvan, Plaintiff, represented by Devin Lynn Bolton , Weitz& Luxenberg, P.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Bennierita Smith & Jr. Edward Smith, Plaintiffs, represented by Nicholas Ryan Rockforte , Pendley, Baudin & Coffin, LLP, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Christopher Luke Coffin , Pendley Bauldin Coffin, LLP, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC, Pearl Anna Robertson , Weitz and Luxenberg & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Larry J. Faschingbauer, Plaintiff, represented by James Griffin O'Brien , O'Brien Law, LLC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC & Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC.

Loretta I. Pennie, Pablo Aguero, Michael J. Allen, Kelly S. Baron, John Barton, Mark Barton, Jean E. Bevanmarquez, Mark J. Blackwelder, Donald E. Brenner, Deborah Brooks, individually and as successor in interest to the Estate of Dean D. Brooks, deceased, Denton L. Carender, Frank Chavez, Gina E. Davis, Richard D. D'Souza, Randy A. Ferber, Gary W. Hall, Patricia Hamilton, individually and as successor in interest to the Estate of Bruce Hamilton, deceased, John S. Henderson, Phil P. Hernandez, Ann E. Hinshelwood, Steven Louis McCormick, Sheila Mitchell, Tammy Moreno, individually and as successor in interest to the Estate of Andrew D. Moreno, deceased, Anthony Prince Munoz, Timothy J. Parker, Carolyn J. Pierce, Joanne Marie Plummer, Gary C. Puckett, Paulette M. Randall, Rhoda B. Rathkamp, Parviz Rezazadeh, Douglas Smith, John S. Stratton, Steven M. Strohm, Cheryl Y. Thresher, George T. Watson, Mercy O. Solorio, individually and as successor in interest to the Estate of Estanislao Solorio, deceased, Jeff Ingram, Charles Vannoy & Carolyn McCray, Plaintiffs, represented by Christopher Luke Coffin , Pendley Bauldin Coffin, LLP, Frances Margaret Phares , Baum Hedlund Aristei and Goldman, Kevin J. Madonna , Kennedy & Madonna, LLP, Michael Lin Baum , Baum Hedlund Aristei and Goldman PC, Nicholas Ryan Rockforte , Pendley, Baudin & Coffin, LLP, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. , Kennedy & Madonna, LLP, Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pedram Esfandiary , Baum Hedlund Aristei and Goldman.

Maria Bedolla, individually and as successor in interest to the Estate of David L. Bedolla, deceased, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher Luke Coffin , Pendley Bauldin Coffin, LLP, Frances Margaret Phares , Baum Hedlund Aristei and Goldman, Kevin J. Madonna , Kennedy & Madonna, LLP, Michael Lin Baum , Baum Hedlund Aristei and Goldman PC, Nicholas Ryan Rockforte , Pendley, Baudin & Coffin, LLP, Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Pedram Esfandiary , Baum Hedlund Aristei and Goldman.

Mikle Cooper, Plaintiff, represented by David Jackson Wool , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, pro hac vice, Robert J. McLaughlin , Hart McLaughlin & Eldridge, LLC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC & Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC.

Linda Crane, Larry Skillestad, Michael Naff & Juanita Maraman, Plaintiffs, represented by Jacob A. Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM, LLC, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC & Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC.

Frederick Smith, Rexford Martin, Ronald Matheny, Sherry Lynn Matheny, Royal Mathis, Katholyn Jean Mathis, Davien McCarty, Sharon McClurg, Mark McCowen, Debraa McCowen, Marcia McCray, Eileen Means, John A. Meeks, Eugene Merrell, Brandy Merrell, Becky Miller, Lorne Miller, Anne Mitchell, Robert Mitchell, Sami Mohammad, Henry Moore, Linda Moore, Terence Moore, Kristina Moore, Lisa Mulholland, Joseph Mulholland, Gordon Muller, Shawn Murphy, Janie Narczewski, James Narczewski, James David, Vickie Neal, Deanna Nelson, Donald Nelson, Earl Nelson, Paul Neumeyer, Rebecca Neuzil, Larry Niederer, Jayne Niederer, Richard Niewiadomski, David Nisbet, Marion Nottingham, John Novak, Timothy Nowicki, Barbara Nowicki, Daryl Ogden, Cynthia Ortiz, Mary Ortiz, John Otts, Emma Otts, James Palmer, John Parker, Wanda Parker, Ron Peperoni, Jr., Stacy Peperoni, Dennis Pfister, Patricia Pfister, Mark Pollum, Melvin Popinga, Ida Popinga, Janet Porteous, Robert Porteous, Michael Price, Loretta Price, Guy Pritchard, Warren Proctor, Greg Randolph, Rachel Randolph, Vicki Rapp, Dale Rapp, Dean Rasmussen, Daniel Redding, Phyllis Reith, Richard Reith, Edward Reynolds, Patricia Reynolds, Anthony Rezendes, Sharon Rezendes, Larry Richards, Donald Richardson, Donna Rizzo, Virgil Rizzo, Spirit Connell, Patrick Martin, Jack Watson, Robert Hoffman, Alan Gniadek, Melvin Costa, Stan Gerlach, David King, John Schoonover, Estel Butterfield, Donald Smith, Douglas Moss, Christopher Luetcke, Shalisha Robinson, James Aultman, Martha Whitford, Reginald Liggins, Bobby Joe Jones, Joseph Johnson, Jay Borum, James Sheldon, Suzanne Norgren, Andrew Gordon, Carol Sorensen & Marty Pinkard, Plaintiffs, represented by James T. Corrigan , ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC & Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC.

Mary Ellen Goodbred, Plaintiff, represented by Richard M. Paul, III , Paul LLP, pro hac vice, Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Christopher M. Ellis , Bolen Robinson & Ellis, LLP & Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC.

Rocky McIntosh, Donna McIntosh, Richard Lax, Leslie Shechter, Jacob Shechter, Claire Van Horn, Gary Van Horn, Donald Wetzel, Lori Wetzel, Kevin Kelly, Frederick Curts, Louise Stutes, Jan Huskey, Judy Huskey, Angel Sanchez, Daniel Sanchez, Raymond Saunders, Gloria Saunders, Patrick Gallagher, Melanie Gallagher, Rodney Pfeiffer, Boyd Hagaman, Arlene Hagaman, Keith Wimberley, Lily Wimberley, James Jernigan, Carol Jernigan, Sherri Zoller, Perry Minando, Maria Minando, Rodney Dean, Deborah Dean, Bobby Freeman, William Curtsinger, Wanda Curtsinger, Chester Mills, Doris Mills, Dennis Rowe, Gina Rowe, Lawrence Garvel, Linda Garvel, Zora Hartman, Wayne Hartman, Johnny Lawson, Sandra Lawson, Michele McLeod, William McLeod, Randy Roberts, Lloyd Roberts, Gary Deutsch, Katherine Deutsch, Frederick Gongoll, Daniel Koller, Laura Koller, Harold Mayhew, Kenneth McMillon, Onita McMillon, Tyrie Pickney, Anetra Pickney, Mary Picou, John Tramell, Philippa Tramell, David Brame, Jeanna B. Johnson, Larry G. Curts, Donald T. Zilmer & Joseph Shible, Plaintiffs, represented by Raeann Warner , Jacobs and Crumplar, P.A.

Johnny Hick Strickland & William H. Prince, Plaintiffs, represented by James L. Ward, Jr. , McGowan, Hood & Felder, LLC.

The Estate of Robert Cochran by Misty Hill, its Administrator, William Setzer, Pamela Setzer, Linda O'Neil, Marvin O'Neil & Catherine S. Cryan, Plaintiffs, represented by James Griffin O'Brien , O'Brien Law, LLC.

Anthony Harris, Plaintiff, represented by Jeremy C. Shafer , Miller Legal, LLP & Peter Andrew Miller , Miller DellaFera, PLC.

Estate of Rosemary Runyan, Ronald Runyan, Marilyn Van Steenberg, by and through his representative, surviving spouse of Estate of John Van Steenberg & Estate of Mary DiBeneditto, Plaintiffs, represented by David Jackson Wool , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, pro hac vice.

Virginia Freeman, Plaintiff, represented by Kirk John Goza , Goza Honnold Trial Lawyers & Raeann Warner , Jacobs and Crumplar, P.A.

Patricia Turner, Nadine Zook, Anthony Helderman, John Wiberg, Kathleen Wiberg, Johnny Robert, Emily Dyre, Michael Dyre, Myron Park, Jeffrey Volz, Paul Brisk, Joan Brisk, Jeffrey Suiter, Ralph Sliger, Randy Perkins, Joy Perkins, Lori Larson, Larry Larson, Ronald Hawkins, Donna Hawkins, Alaine Lowell, Peter Bell, Lori Burns, Neven Burns, Steven Taylor, Patricia Taylor, Barry Ford, Allen Burnett, Sharon Burnett, Sheila Solari, Brett Beavers, Tina Beavers, David Beaudet, Ramon Benacidez, Norman Benacidez, Ronald Brook, Charles Hartman, Sandra Hartman, Thomas Pentecost, Cecelia Pentecost, Michele Smolley, Robert M. Stark, Mark Stolzberg, William Stone, John Stringer, Deborah Stringer, Jon Thornton, Nancy Thornton, Janet Walton, David Webb, Ellen Webb, Marian Welker, Roger Welker, Jolene Rhodes, Valerie Gaither, Marvin L. Alden, Margaret T. Ambrose, John Nagao Aoki, Jeffrey Bailey, John Balaz, Robert R. Behrens, Max D. Berry, Richard J. Bogani, Eloy Brionez, Benjamin J. Carmon, Lawrence F. Clark, Anthony Berlin, Donna Berlin, Elizabeth Briggs, Paul Briggs, Todd Cella, Mary Ann Cheesman, George Chillak, Lisa Damerst, Richard Dulniak, Robert Finley, Lisa Fortner, Charles Fortner, Jonathan Giles, Robert Gould, Ann K. Graham, Daniel Greil, Howard Harmon, Karen Harmon, Harold Harris, Rhonda Harris, Leslie Harris, Sarah Hilker, Katherine Horne, Michael Horton, Debra Jacobsen, Benjamin Jacobsen, Tammy Jacobsen, Wendy Jones, Brian Junge, Richard Kranick, Glenn Laurie, Beverly Laurie, Derek Liddell, Robert Mahoney, Vincent Marsiglia, Jamie Martinez, Elliott Neuman, Phyllis Perry, Steven Perry, Daria Phillipi, Natalie Pieri, John Pieri, William Pointer, Dale Short, Theodore Shuler, Carla Shuler, Andrea Brook, Dean Brooks, Deborah Brooks, Marie Carlisle, Rosalinda Castro, Richard Colasuonno, Dianne Cox, Christopher Dannen, Jesus Gastelum, Isabelle Gastelum, Candy Glenn, Mark Golike, Becky Golike, Michael Grasso, Cecelia Hines, Sam Hoffman, Martha Hoffman, Dena Jones, Erwin Klaas, Kevin Kraner, Thomas Laguidice, Carol Laguidice, Timm Larson, Leanne Lathrop, Robydee Laumbach, Jonathan Machtemes, Richard Manegio, James Modisher, Susan Modisher, Jerry Pitman, Kaffle Pitman, Denise Pitts, Rhonda Powell, Jason Powell, Morris Price, Kathleen Price, Juan Rivera, Thomas Sampson, Renae Sampson, Frederick Sands, Timothy Scully, Daniel Shaw, Lewis Smith, III, Irene Springer, Dave Stephens, Barbara Stephens, Frederick Thornton, Fred Vanderlaan, Gary Walker, Rhonda Walker, Donald White, Denise White, Ben Zupan, Laura Zupan, Roy Eagleson, Judith Eagleson, Terry Briscoe, Larry Briscoe, Judy Dowell, Frederick Walton, Faye Walton, Holly McCrea, Thomas Gianotti, Lynn Foley, Cindy Foley, James Davidson, Wendell Owens, Thomas Krouse, Donna Krouse, Charles Strumsky, Jerry Rachels, Mieczyslawa Rachels, Cynthia Hubbard, Arthur Hubbard, Lisa Snaza, Ken Snaza, Kevin Bridges, Bernard Farney, Carolyn Farney, Theresa Malo, Vaughn Peak, Edward D'Ettore, Sandra Arbuckle, Samuel Arbuckle, Floyd Anderson, Roger Kane, Judith Kane, Jose Rosas, Laura Rosas, Jim Reilly, Patricia Reilly, Stephen Crane, Barry Odell, Charlene Napierala, Joyce Radokovitch, Ronald Radokovitch, Michael Lapone, Lisa Lapone, Anna O'Rourke, Patrick O'Rourke, Thelma Lewis, Linda Schrack, Myron Schrack, Antoine Cade, Victoria Lewis-Smith, Cathy Desomma, Louis Desomma, Paul Simmons, Ellen Simmons, Diana Martinez, Jerold Martinez, Michael Breda, Mary Breda, Denis Brogan, Briget Abraham, Patrick Abraham, Cynthia Abrogast, Donald Abrogast, Lori Fulton, Bruce Fulton, Lorena Arzate, Manuel Arzate, Sandra Klinger, William Klinger, Terry Belt, Andrew Bahia, Michael Hughes, Gloria Hughes, Rod Behrens, Cynthia Behrens, Lou Bilotto, Charles Blake, Laura Blake, Lonnie Blalock, Ann Blalock, Stanley Bland, Terry Bostater, Katheen Bostater, Pamela Mallery, Muriel Edwards, Jerry Bourg, Delores Boykin, Laureen McCart, Mary Jean Stephens, George Raney, Gretchen Raney, Warren Jacobs, Randy Brehmer, Claire McChristy, Christopher Breeden, Richard Bridwell, Marlene Brinker, Paul Brinker, Jerry Britton, Candace Britton, Randy Heckert, Dennis Brown, Jeff Kolb, Dennis Kolb, Robert Wright, Teri Wright, Mary Butts, James Farley, Nancy Cimino, Philip Greenwood, Mary Ann Higgins, Jerry Staley, Caroline Staley, Betty Zorn, William Zorn, Michael Capo, Thomas Carr, Jo Anne Capo, Ashanta Cruz, Michelle Cuff, David Villagomez, Rolando Castanada, Yolanda Castanada, Luis Torres-Santiago, Elizabeth Deiters, Richard Ulrich, Jo Lair, Donna Keen, James Geringer, Jr., Sherlene Ward, James Abbott, Victor Hernandez, Robert Wetz, Kerry G. Watts, Jack Heideman, Susan Higgins, Charles Dixon, Cindi Waynick, Renee I. Gall, David Kelly Jr., David L. Kelly, Michael Hoeing, Denise Hoeing, Tina Hoerner, Alan Goebel, Margaret Goebel, Charles Johnson, Kristin Johnson, Stuart Holiday, Shawn Holiday, Terry L. Smith, Jacqueline Safieh, Kathi Edward, Raymon Howard, Cheryl Howard, Shirley Hoyla, Lisa Hammock, John W. Hammock Jr., Sandy Allen Hudson, Premlata Rawat Hudson, Diana Wroblewski, Laurence J. Burns, Kurt Hysen, Adele Hysen, Joanne Iannucci, Patricia Jackson, Wayne James, Catherine James, Debra Jasper, Lonnie Davis, Jacqueline Johnson, Willie Johnson, Brandon Johnson, Jamaal Johnson, Richard Johnson, Diane Hayne-Johnson, Robert Johnson, Frances Johnson, Sandra Jolly, Ronald Jumper, Evelyn Kastan, Bryan Kenyon, Eunice Kenyon, Majeed Khan, Amy Khan, Michael Klein, Kimberly Klein, Brad Kliewer, Stanko Knezevic, Ray Kolosa, Gerald Kramer, Bruce Law, Ruth Law, Stephen Lee, Sharon Lee, Mary Lee, Warren Lee, Donald Lequieu, Minh Dung Lequieu, Gregory Lewis, Rocky Loggins, Laura Loggins, Paul Loidolt, Allen Lynn, Lois Lynn, Larry Maczko, Susan Maczko, Brook R. Madden, Chad Magstadt, Jody Magstadt, Phillip Cobb, Sylvia DiFranco, Theresa Dowd, Michael Mangone, Shannon Downes, Leo Duclos, Elva Duclos, Patricia Dunn, Ronnie McGowen, Eva Darnell, James Henderson, Nancy Morgan, Lawrence Morgan, Valerie Ebert, Lois Edelman, Harry Edelman, Heather Rittenberry, Gary Rittenberry, William Edwards, Kelly Ellis, Jacob Elwess, Max Fridman, Humbert Maggiacomo, Loise Maggiacomo, David Evans, Patricia Evans, Scott Falke, Cathleen Falke, Gerald Meyers, Sheila Meyers, Kathy Koll, Donald Woldt, Madonna Woldt, Douglas Farris, Burton Feldman, Noanna Feldman, Donna Leidig, Maureen Lentz, Todd Lentz, Lori Broussard, Dean Fish, Timothy Fisher, Mary Fisher, David Stiles, Gail Stiles, William Fleming, Jr., Delbert Lockhart, Betty Lockhart, Thomas Lopez, Roger Foebar, Darla Foebart, Leslie Foley, Richard Fortner, Susan Fortner, Amanda Minoza, James Murdock, Claudia Murdock, Mavis Franklin, Anthony Franklin, Roger Marti, Marsha Marti, Duane French, Margaret Fitzgerald, Otho Fitzgerald, Michael Lynn, Leann Lynn, David Froome, Donna Froome, Glenn Fuller, Pamela Fuller, Ronald Wilhelms, Kathy Wilhelms, Bryan Futch, Bonnie Bertram, Carl McNeal, Jr., William Mercer, Nancy Mercer, Greg Detweiler, John Detweiler, Larry Schad, David Mohr, Marina Mohr, Lonnie Harvey, Donald Raper, Patricia Raper, Ken Eazell, Catrina Eazell, John Chandler, Lorrie Chandler, David Repass, Staci Repass, Iasias Chavez, Ricky Estopinal, Mary Estopinal, Debbie Choate, Francis Ellis, Kevin Christian, Janet Christian, Peter Fareri, Mary Ann Clark, Vernon Clements, Veronica Clements, Pattilu Grogg, Ricky Buford, George Hulett, Sylvia Hulett, Christopher Cole, Dana Cole, Katheryn Holland, Lucas Holland, William Collins, Walsh Conmy, Toni Conmy, Armando Garcia, Sharron Garcia, Susan Glaser, Darrel Glaser, Michael Corkery, Edward Cotter, Elaine Cotter, Bob Kippley, Raymond Kippley, Maureen Farr, Linda Peterson, Jerry Greif, Larry Crupper, Mardi Crupper, Kelton Boulware, Alfred Boulware, Carol Rosenau, Harold Thornton, Michael Smith, Patrick Vandyke, Harry Davies, Carol Davies, Tamela Davis, Nicole Dean, Molly Yuille, Rodney Yuille, Albert Dattilo, Roseanne Dattilo, John Demajo, Mary Demajo, Estevan Perez, Carl Vendetti, Angela Vendetti, Monica Sherman, Robert Sherman, Scott Hilyard, Lisa Hoffman, Jacquelyn Dhoogie, John Dhoogie, Patrick Dicicco, Cheryl Klippa, Stephen Digiovanna, Davis Dixon, Ina Dixon, Phillip Dodson, Pauline Dodson, Glenda Hooker, Sharlie Weir, Avery Weir, Jafurl Parks, James Kovacs, Mike Kazmierczak, Milton Hayes, Gwenette Hayes, Clara Grimes, James Grimes, Richard Maddamma, Beth Gilmore, William Gilmore, Judith Sturzenbecher, Dean Sturzenbecher, Roel Samaniego, Scott Pease, Monica Harrison, David Arnold, Sandra Strauss, Clifton Palmer, Victoria Gonzalez, Peter White, Mark Warehime, Dennis Ziesman, Barbara Ziesman, Robert Ziegelmair, Latonya Zakzak, Gene Wyrick, Sharon Williams, Alfred Williams, Shavarsh Grigorian, Siran Grigorian, Vivian Wilburn, Robert Wilburn, Mark Wesel, Jana Wesel, Eduardo Zuniga, Vilma Zuniga, Michael Weir, Mary Weir, Gerhard Wehr, Myron Berney, Colleen Berney, Robert Alvarez, Michael Wisnovsky, Mark Supak, Betty Supak, Leslie Wellman, Paul Amore, Mazen Charafeddine, Racha Charafeddine, Robin Curry, Ritch Edelstein, Cherie Finley, Anthony Alessi, Emma Staszel, Donald Staszel, John Szymanski, Mary Szymanski, Monica Webb, Robert Fowler, Gisela Fowler, Ted Galloway, Shawnda Galloway, Jeffery Phillps, Sandra Phillips, Ronald Peterson, Martha Peterson, Cory Scott, Alicia Scott, Juanita Gradney, David Moe, Leann Moe, Mark Stopar, Mary Stopar, Phillip Thompson, Stacy Thompson, Susan Burrows, Randy Burrows, Shirley Skorr, Kermit Skorr, Jerralyn Neal, Elisabeth Johnston, James Decourcy, Roger Craft, Howard Montaigne, Cheryl Montaigne, Darrell Berger, Earl Hertel, Henry Gavin, Maria Gavin, Katherine Geary, John Reich, Merle Noll, Danny Olson, James Pawling, Kate Pawling, Kay Godby, William Cramer, Ruby Pemberton, Haykoush Kzlgezyan, Aram Aslanyan, George Connolly, Roger Lewis, Catherine Lewis, Mary Chalupsky, Laverne Chalupsky, Clyde Gosnell, Christopher Vining, Adelbert Reagan, Sandra Reagan, Marcia Coulter, Troy Coulter, Cristina Barnes, Carol Green, Marvin Green, Victoria Ring, Thomas Greenwood, Connie Greenwood, Edmund Grice, Robert Barry, Lori Barry, Mark Braswell, Charles Grimes, Sharon Hardy-Mills, Eric Roy, Curtis Heidel, Helen Heidel, Gerald Gross, Nanette Guillory, Steven Pitt, Donald Hensley, Linda Hensley, Bradley Kusik, Kerry Kusik, Claude Lipscomb, Carole Lipscomb, Catherine Hagemeier, Carlos Smith, Michele Smith, Katherine Smith, Rick Smith, David Prewett, Carla Prewett, Sandy Sorin, Robert Sorin, Larry Hansen, Denise Hansen, Dylan Hanson, Linda Soutsas, Peter Soutsas, Theresa Ross, William Wilkinson, Omar Tatman, Dale Harkins, Richard Harmeyer, Lenore Harmeyer, Cynthia Wilson, Ralph Wilson, Stephen Havis, Carlos Trevino, Angela Trevino, Joseph Robichaud, Ronald Rogers, Mary Rogers, Jill Rolland, Frank Rolland, Michael Rose, Lisa Rose, Frederick Rubik, Annette Rudy, Gary Rudy, Ralph Schmoller, Nancy Schmoller, Janet Schneider, Richard Schoonover, Allyn Schultz, Carolyn Scott, Robert Wayne Scott, Glenn Seifrit, Barbara Seifrit, Anthony Serva, Larry Shelton, Thomas Smith, Jeanne Smith, Gary Spaeth, Sandra Spaeth, Robert Spande, Janet Spande, David Stark, Gary Steck, Cheryl Stensrud, Bradley Stensrud, Brent Stephens, George Stephenson, Eddy Stitt, Brenda Stitt, Marilyn Stovall, Philip Strohmaier, Rosemary Strohmaier, Larry Sweatt, Wanda Holland, William Tamargo, Catherine Tamargo, Nancy Taylor, Richard Taylor, Patrick Thompson, Julius Tiarks, Joyce Tiarks, John Traver, Brenda Tyree, Terry Underwood, Tracy Underwood, Arizeder Urreiztieta, Dianne Iauco, Leonard Vanderwiede, Robert Watkins, John Webb, Sr., Cecilia Webb, Robert Otto, Colleen Otto, Jeff Hall, Darla Hawley, Randall Hawley, Brenda Huerta, James Huerta, James Altman, Brenda Lage, David Lage, Paul Almeida, Anne Almeida, Sherry Boyd, Kirk Boyd, Frank Boyd, Evelyn Boyd, Marshall Crow, Richard Foster, Brenda Foster, Michael Marniella, Robert Hempy, Phyllis Hempy, Roger Stanley, Paul W. Doles, Joseph Duppstadt, Jamie Duppstadt, Stephanie Gentile, Charles Gentile, Linda Grove, Thomas Grove, Steven Rangel, Sandra Rangel, Sergio Martinez, Jennifer Martinez, Kenneth Cavey, Bridget Cavey, Lyndell Wernsing, Albert Angel, Leslie Angel, Donald Bryner, Melanie Bryner, John Cain, Clara Cain, Keith Dalrymple, Ken Disney, Stephanie Gracayk, Michael Gracayk, Denise Hannusch, Donald Hannusch, Douglas Koch, Cynthia Koch, Cynthia Laney, Wayne Linnemier, Treasa Linnemier, Timmathy Noe, Dakota Noe, Gary Phillips, Robert Ross, Bruce Rutland, Kimberly Rutland, Stephen Salapata, Barbara Salapata, Carl Sanderson, Jeff Sosby, Tammy Sosby, Earl McCann, Maria McCann, James Van Oosten, Terri Van Oosten, Alejandro Castro, Rafael Castro, Pamela G. Kles, Jo Kles, Kathleen Kofler, Kevin Kofler, Bev Lindsay, Margaret Mallard-Agbo, Jip Nahale, Carol Evans, Susanne Simmons, Sandra Smith, Ulises Spanbauer, Jane A. Swartz, Michael Terry, Benita Trujillo, Pete Castillo, Frank Veloz, Rael Zaritsky, Eric Brown, George Bouzeanes, Michael Campbell, Olivier Durand, Johanne Durand, Hans Elmer, Kay Elmes, Steven Ezell, Angela Ezell, Warren Garnier, Richard Ham, Frank Lattimore, Daphnie Lattimore, Frank Morton, Charlotte Morton, Steve Vitale, Edward Zabolotny, Denton Bray, Frederick Forward, Donald Hurt, Freddie Martin, William Pelicot, Robert Rauh, Richard Richards, George Yackle, Danny White & Melissa White, Plaintiffs, represented by James T. Corrigan , ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C.

Keith Horn, Plaintiff, represented by Francisco Antonio Albites, Jr. , Parker Waichman, LLP & Jessica L. Richman , Parker Waichman.

Ronnie L. Turner, Charles Sowell, Arthur Sweat, CARMEN BATCH & David Ayres, Plaintiffs, represented by Eugene C. Brooks, IV , Brooks Law Firm, pro hac vice.

Robert W. Lewis, Barbara M. Lewis, Jeffrey F. Joffe & Laurie Rodetsky Joffe, Plaintiffs, represented by George T. Williamson , Farr, Farr, Emerich, Hackett, Carr and Holmes, PA.

Larry Donald Blakeney, Plaintiff, represented by John Raymond Tullos , TULLOS, TULLOS & TULLOS & Michelle Points , Points Law, PLLC.

Jessie Camarena, William Camarena, Earl Sessions, Gordon C. Hellwig, Karen Hellwig, Bryon Hackett, Donna Hackett, Demetrius Petropoulos, Sophia Petropoulos, Jose Rodriguez, Lillian Rodriguez, Barbara Stadsvold, Marie Tavormina, Clyde Zerba, John Vanda, Fabian Varela, Gabriela Varela, Victoria L. Bellio, Dean Bellio, John Lines, Karen Lines, Saul Rios, Maria Guadalupe Trujillo, Michael A. Bell, Deryl Lundy, Lesly Lundy, Daniel J. Palaschak, Elizabeth Palaschak, Teresa J. Osburn, Ralph H. Mauzy, David Hills, Consuelo R. Hills, Cheryl Hayes, Ovidio Felix, Elvia Felix, Ronald Gale, Genevieve Gale, Jack Capen, Jean Capen, John Gavelys, Kathy Gavelys, Valeria P. Fraser, Steven Fraser, Karen M. Flaherty, Dean T. Enomoto, Ronald L. Small, Karen S. Small, Deborah Thomas, Edward P. Schmit, Jr., Marie Schmit, Myra J. Buettner, Peter D. Buettner, Charles R. Norby, Denise A. Wurz, Lon Wurz, Judith A. Johnson, Donna Poulson, Charles Poulson, Donald Rhodes, Yvette Rhodes, Owen Dorman, Elizabeth Mena, Scott Trayer, Elizabeth Trayer, Stephen Thompson, William K. Johnson, Kathleen Hart, Billy Hart, Theodore Goldberg, Sybil Goldberg, Ted Lehr, Jay Cantor, Anthony S. Milbrandt, Gerald J. Surico, Rosalie L. Gold, Margie Tebbe, Donald Tebbe, Sylvia Ross, Arthur Riggle, Shelley Zavarella, Michael Deyesso, Helen Deyesso, Brian G. Maine, Gary Marcinkowski, Darlene Marcinkowski, Robert Rees, II, Shauna Rees, Richard R. Shelby, Linda M. Shelby, James Cerrachio, Linda Cerracchio, Gary A. Reichold, Edgar P. Ruiz, Gris Rivera, Lane E. Wise, Timothy W. Williams, Kimberly Williams, Dennis M. Anderson, Leslie Andrews, Robert J. Klimek, Sr., Dale Bauman, Frances Bauman, Donna Benenati, John Hickey, Pam Hickey, Willard Bothof, Jean Bothof, Robert Beste, Lachrisha L. Dourisseau, Devin Dourisseau, Margaret Jones, Gerald Jones, Louise E. Carlucci, Francisco Baez, Claudia Baez, Ann Marie Geiger, James Geiger, Robert Bilodeau, Rita Bilodeau, Melvin Goularte, Donna Goularte, Dorn Gruenhagen, Caroline Gruenhagen, Rosalie Castillo, Wayne A. Henderson, Frank J. Dusard, Douglas Johnson, Cindy Johnson, Robin Brown, Lamar Brown, Carl Jones, Diana Jones, Sandra Lee, Leonard Lotz, Lisa Lotz, Jason McNamara, Nicole McNamara, John Morris, Evelyn Morris, Judy O. Nelson, Mark Nelson, Lisa R. Otis, Lucinda Packard, Bruce Peterson, Che Phifer, Don Phifer, Brian Roberts, Mary Roberts, Barbara Braden, Sharron Howell, Richard Howell, Veronica Navarrete, Armando Navarrete, Delores Ross, Hope Solis, Eddie Solis, Kenneth Wiessner, Mary Wiessner, Timothy P. Johnson, Steven Harris, Shirley Harris, Ronald Parenti, Marilyn Parenti, Richard Ruelas, Nancy Workman, Tulion York, Carolyn York, Carolyn Collins, Lisa M. Sparks, David D. King, Sharon Spooner, Christopher Spooner, Ronald J. Rodrigues, Robin Sparks, Rebecca A. Bejarano, Rawleigh L. Marsh, John Gordon Young, Sally Crabtree, on behalf of the Estate of Edward L. Crabtree, James D. Baker, Valerie Wood, Armando Campos Meza, Edith Corrales, Albert James Palmer, John C. Buell, Gregory Johnson, Cathy Johnson, Kristen Miller, Linda J. Dennis, Jimmy G. Dennis, Patricia I. Fiddie, Stephen Fiddie, Gary Kellogg, Katherine Kellogg, Jay Logg, Estate of Sandra Askew, Estate of Roger Cramer, Gordon A. Monten, Jr., on behalf of the estate of Susan Monten, Charles Surls, Diane Surls, Jason Stone, Theresa E. Stuart, Robert M. Lachance, James Hamontree, Megan Hamontree, Debra Whitfill, Jimmy Whitfill, Mary Boardman, James Boardman, Donald R. Henry, Marlene Henry, Gene N. Hokenson, Charlene F. Hokenson, Carlos Lopez, Sheryl Antol, Rudy Fuentes, Aaron Miller, Elizabeth Duncan, John H. Mahler, Beatrice M. Mahler, Michael Garcia, Wesley W. Scatena, Sr., Jeanne Scatena, Leland A. Bottjen, Debra G. Bottjen, Delmar Romo, Donna Romo, Alexander Efimenko, Albert J. Fury, Carol Fury, Walter Kovaleski, IV, Deborah C. Kovaleski, Shelly Y. Lucas, Terry Lucas, Sandra Askew, Frederic D. Mushro, Loraine Mushro, Joseph K. Oletti, Evelyn Oletti, Eric F. Willis, Denise Willis, Edgar E. Hyde, Jorge E. Regalado, Maria Regalado, Brian Russell Jager, James F. Bachman, Sr., Maria Bachman, Terry Burchinal, Pauline Burchinal, Andrew J. Petersen, Joan T. Petersen, Frank G. Molina, Dorothy Molina, Marvin Pomerantz, Margaret Pomerantz, LeRoy W. Rapke, Gloria Adams-Rapke, Bartholomew F. Sheehan, Patricia A. Sheehan, Virgil Ray Dutton, Elizabeth Ann Dutton, Paula J. Egan, John Egan, Michael L. Leary, Sheila J. Leary, Edward E. Parker, Dorian Parker, Anton Bogs, Beth Bogs, Preston R. Pennell, Scott DeMent & Melody DeMent, Plaintiffs, represented by David J. Diamond , Goldberg and Osborne.

William Medlin, Plaintiff, represented by Jessica L. Richman , Parker Waichman.

Zella Medlin, Patricia Honaker, Charles Honaker, Robert King, Carlesa King, Randel White, Peggy White, Richard Miller, Alton McLendon, Beverly McLendon, Suzanne Simpson & Roger Simpson, Plaintiffs, represented by Jessica L. Richman , Parker Waichman & Eric Davis Holland , Holland, Groves, Schneller and Stolze.

Steve Salvaggio, Plaintiff, represented by James T. Corrigan , ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C., Pedram Esfandiary , Baum Hedlund Aristei and Goldman & Robert Brent Wisner , Baum Hedlund Aristei Goldman, PC.

Lynda Jean Wolters, Plaintiff, represented by Douglas W. Crandall , Crandall Law Office & Michelle Points , Points Law, PLLC.

Garry Marchman, Anthony Pearce, Elizabeth Bare, surviving heir of Stephanie Bare-Wheeler on behalf of all legal heirs of Stephanie Bare-Wheeler, Estate of Stephanie Bare-Wheeler, Beverly Rouse, Reno Votta, David Kearney, Estate of Bonnie E. Priem & Gerald Priem, Plaintiffs, represented by Jacob A. Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM, LLC.

Carolyn Doty, Jaime Andrade, Mildred Adams, Richard Bargamian, Ricky Birdsell, Judy Borde, Eric Burgess, Janice Camden, Cheryl Chapman, Carol Colucci, Colin Cunningham, Alfred DeLuca, Richard Fulgenzi, Barry Furse, Bradley Griffin, Ralph Lacaze, Sharon Luttrell, Kathy Malcolm, Michael O'Con, David Pastorello, Harold Roy, Jeffrey Smith, Robert Stump, Tina Thompson, Matthew Torres, Michelle Tyczki, Robert Veltri, Donald Wagner, Brett Mossotti & Lena Eberhardt, Plaintiffs, represented by Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC.

Marvin Ford, Virginia Platt & Steven Rochman, Plaintiffs, represented by Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC & Raeann Warner , Jacobs and Crumplar, P.A.

William Medlin, as Executor of the Estate of Billy Medlin, William Ritchie, James Suding, Cathleen Suding, Richard Parker, Virginia Parker, Faisal Abedeljalil, Tammy Abedeljalil, Brenda Acosta, Brian Anderson, Leif Arvidson, Kenny Beddington, Danny Binkley, Emery Bridgers, Matthew Brown, Deborah Buss, Chris Daniels, Michael Doyle, Patricia Ermeloff, Robert Esler, Laura Faraschuk, Jesse Gates, Ronald Gleysteen, Marvin Greenleaf, Richard Hansen, Richard Hendrickson, Norman Henson, Anthony Hoisington, Maureen Hubert, Lilian Humphries, Ken Irish, Michael Jackson, George Jennings, Linda Johnson, Lawrence Karns, Maxine Kelly, Boris Kofman, Lewis Lane, David Largent, Marcia Larson, Gary Lenna, Richard Lewis, Eugene Locken, Robert Marson, Michael Mason, Richard Mayes, Mitch Meunier, Timothy Miskinis, David Murray, Earnestine Nicholson, Jeffrey Olsen, Betty Peay, DeAnn Pinter, Robert Pruitt, Jason Ratliff, Arlie Raynor, Scott Reed, Joan Salogar, Barbara Schiltz, Peggy Sellers, Morgan Seymour, Betty Shadeck, Jennie Son, Lynn Soule, Winfred Spain, Clyde Stansell, Robert Stellflug, Norman Sundstrom, John Tanner, Darrell Tarte, Bill Theys, John Thompson, Cheryl Trowbridge, Eduardo Vazquez, Lucinda Whitley, Loren Wilhelm, Barry Willis, Thomas Zupa, Joe Coleman, Judith Keehn, Claude Smithhart, Tommy Lovett, Valetta Lovett, Stanley Czaplicki, Larry A. Smith, Judy Smith, John Edwards, Lynda Edwards, Larry E. Hyman, Mary C. Hyman, Brian E. Schade, Frankie R. Manes, Norman L. Boelter, RICHARD IRA RAY, DANIEL EDWARD RAY, Gayle Russ, Galen Noe, Jan Hiatt, Oscar Bingham, Carolyn Bingham & William Stewart, Plaintiffs, represented by Eric Davis Holland , Holland, Groves, Schneller and Stolze.

Wanda Clarke, Donald Shepherd & Esmeralda Hernandez, Plaintiffs, represented by Matthew James Sill , Sill Law Group, PLLC, Andrea R. Rust , Fulmer Sill PLLC, Harrison C. Lujan , Fulmer Sill PLLC, Jacob L. Rowe , Fulmer Sill PLLC, Katie E. Griffin , Fulmer Sill PLLC, Simone Fulmer , Fulmer Sill PLLC & Tara T. Tabatabaie , Sill Law Group, PLLC.

Mary L. Koehn, Plaintiff, represented by Hunter William Lundy , Lundy, Lundy, Soileau and South, LLP & Jackey W. South , Lundy Lundy et al.

Tara L. DiVittorio, Plaintiff, represented by Frank Joseph DiVittorio , Chehardy, Sherman, Williams, Murray, Recile, Stake, Preston Lee Hayes , Chehardy, Sherman, Williams, Murray, Recile, Stakelum&Hayes, LLC & Ryan Paul Monsour , Chehardy, Sherman, Williams, Murray, Recile, Stakelum&Hayes, LLC.

Shirley A. Hayes, Plaintiff, represented by Preston Lee Hayes , Chehardy, Sherman, Williams, Murray, Recile, Stakelum&Hayes, LLC & Ryan Paul Monsour , Chehardy, Sherman, Williams, Murray, Recile, Stakelum&Hayes, LLC.

Edwin Slominski, Plaintiff, represented by Albert N. Thiel, Jr. , Will Ferguson & Associates.

Thomas Baker & Marcia Baker, Plaintiffs, represented by James D. Heisman , Napoli Shkolnik LLC & Tate James Kunkle , Napoli Shkolnik PLLC.

Frank Gandolfo, Plaintiff, represented by Carlos Raul Diez-Arguelles , Diez-Arguelles & Tejedor, PA, Gregory John Pals , The Driscoll Firm, PC & John J. Driscoll , The Driscoll Firm, P.C.

Stacy F. Scott, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Reed Nowak , Harrell and Nowak, LLC & Shirin E. Harrell , Harrell & Nowak, LLC.

MARLENE A. PETTINATI, HENRY R. PETTINATI, JEFFREY B. JOHNSON, MELVIN JOHNSON & Kathy Johnson, Plaintiffs, represented by MICHAEL A. CANCELLIERE, JR. , NASS CANCELLIERE BRENNER & MICHAEL A. ROWE , NASS CANCELLIERE BRENNER.

John Bailey & Richard Garrison, Plaintiffs, represented by Richard William Schulte , WRIGHT & SCHULTE, LLC.

Clifford D. Little, Plaintiff, represented by David J. Diamond , Goldberg and Osborne & Scott R. Jackson , Martin Jean & Jackson.

Rodney Allen Woodruff, Plaintiff, represented by James W. Nobles, Jr. , JAMES W. NOBLES, JR., ATTORNEY.

Robert Brown, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Brion B. Doyle , Bridgewater Place.

Kevin McNew, Estate of Billy G. Rouse, Beverly Koons, Michael R. Fair & Philip Dean, Plaintiffs, represented by Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC & Jacob A. Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM, LLC.

Ralph A. Applegate, Plaintiff, pro se.

Debra McClain, Linda C. Rodgers, Francis E. Rodgers, Ricky Hoskins, Charlene Hoskins, Dorothy Ragland, Foster Mayo, Patricia Mayo, Neal Nahler, Mary Ann Nahler, Philip Boudreau, Viola Boudreau, Robert Simpson, Rosetta Boblitz, Gwendolyn Wilson, Edward Wilson, Keith W. Scott, Rebecca Scott, John Crowe, Rosetta Crowe, Bobby Coleman, David Beams, Ronald Toyer, Lawrence Sullivan, Andre White, Lisa White, Dennis Bedenbender, Henry Schwartz, Freeman DeHart, Joseph Ruffin, Holliday Ruffin, David Luckey, Carol Luckey, Cecil Williams, Alice Williams, Richard Wolfe, Phyllis Wolfe, Thurman Hudson, Joseph Pica, Matthew T. Rasey, James T. Conley, Margaret Conley, Marilyn Upshaw, James Upshaw, Amy Schmidt, Allen L. Schmidt, Ricky Hymas, Carol Hymas, Cliffton Pertuit, Doreen Pertuit, Gregory Brickey, Nina Brickey, Beverly Holstrom, Charles Holstrom, Kerry L. Pfleigier, Betty L. Bolyard, Larry Robbins, Guy Andriola, Patrick Litter, Debra Schreibeis, Neal Schreibeis, Timothy Butler, Cathy Butler, Ludie Johnson, Laura Frank, William Frank, Carl Bradley, Betty Bradley, Gilbert Torres, Belinola Torres, Barry Harley, Kelly Harley, Wayne Nelson, Arlene Nelson, Aida O'Brien, Lawrence Killmeier, Linda Killmeier, Jerry Luellen, Louisa Luellen, Kenneth Leckvold, Joan Leckvold, Janine C. Tyson, Billy Rievley, Judith Rievley, Bruce Moore, Delores Moore, Kimberly K. Clark, Kathy Hoffman, Harry Hoffman, Clifford Barnes, Patricia A. Barnes, Steve Boudreaux, Debra Boudreaux, Debra E. Vertz, Randall J. Vertz, Alphonse Leonard, Kathy Leonard, William Hurst, Brenda Dutton-Smith, Carol Bookout, Donnie Bookout, Agnes Osborne, Alvin F. Morrison, Sr., Richard A. Carroll, Pauletta S. Carroll, Jake Hachmeister, Roger C. Medlin, Rick Naranjo, George R. Sumner, Monica Sumner, Dennis Ransom, Patricia Wiseman, George Sparkman, Hyo Sparkman, Eddie Landry, Jr., Maxine Landry, June Hightower, Mack Johnson, Kimberly B. Thompson, Joyce C. Thompson, Amos L. Smith, Ruby Smith, Stacey Lasseigne, Jan Stevens, Marjorie Stevens, Angel Ocasio, Victoria Elfer, Warren Elfer, Vickie L. Awad, Samir Awad, Governor Walker, Sonda Walker, Rose M. Rice, Brenda Dotson, Dean C. Johnson, John Belew, Marilyn Belew, Andrew Achary, Barbara Achary, Faye Miller, Carl Merriett, Shelia Sonnier, Adrianne Martinez, John C. Davis, Wayne J. Karnis, Dan L. Sixbury, Martha Hogan, William E. Jarrett, John H. Wooley, Jerry D. Newton, Sarah C. Brunson, Nikita Simmons, Julie Mabus, Mary B. Singletary, Kathryn L. Hill, Annette A. Bindon, Donna W. Musso, Dennis Calkins, Mary Calkins, Brenda Anderson, Marie Strong, Alexander Kruppa, Dinah Kruppa, John J. Dailey, Jr., Dorothy A. Neville, Leslie A. Goodson, Wanda M. Goodson, Johnny W. Griffith, Sandra R. Griffith, Lindsay R. Hildebrand, Zachary Hildebrand, Jeffrey B. Shapiro, Debora Shapiro, Gregory Triplett, Susan Conn, Todd Conn, Charles Allen, Sheryl Allen, Theresa Dugger, Graciela Samaniego, Patricia McDaniel, Terry Anglin, Mary Jo Anglin, Martha James, Bobby James, James Hatmaker, Levenda Hatmaker, Jerry Whitmire, Paul Bargy, Debra Bargy, Harriet Belsome, Karen Belsome, Luz E. Richardson, Robert A. Shobe, Janet A. Hetherington, George Hetherington, Ray F. Weaver, Joyce E. Weaver, Elizabeth Hatfield, Robert L. Hatfield, Martin Manning, Sandra Manning, Mary Bernard, Charles A. Larke, Mary Jo Larke, David E. Sawyer, Sandra Sawyer, Marylou Weatherspoon, Wendell P. Martin, Phyllis Salamone, Arturo Raygoza, Charlene Raygoza, James T. Aldison, III, Kathy Aldison, David Anthony, Mary M. Anthony, Margaret P. Hans, James M. Outlaw, Karen Outlaw, Charles I. Peetz, Linda G. Peetz, Paul Allen Brown, Thomas Colombara, Cynthia Colombara, Dennis W. Smith, Jimmy Lombard, Frank Susak, Jennifer Susak, Andrew W. Agney, Amy S. Agney, Gloria L. Barnes, Edward Barnes, Leslie Bates, III, Terri J. Bever, Bruce A. Bever, Gary L. Bonzo & Melissa Bonzo, Plaintiffs, represented by Seth S. Webb , Brown and Crouppen P.C.

JOHN C. KIRSCH & RENAE L. KIRSCH, Plaintiffs, represented by Daniel E.P. Bausher , Stevens and Lee, P.C. & Jeffrey David Bukowski , Stevens and Lee, P.C.

Patricia Marcum, individually and on behalf of John Marcum, Plaintiff, represented by Frank M. Petosa , Morgan & Morgan PA, Jonathan A. Rabinowitz , Morgan & Morgan, P.A. & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., pro hac vice.

Bobby D. Ross, Plaintiff, represented by Christiaan A. Marcum , Richardson Patrick Westbrook and Brickman.

Phillip Skundrick, Plaintiff, represented by Jason L. Kafoury , Kafoury & McDougal.

Thomas Martin, Leslie Olson, Jr., Manuel Llamas, Richard Dahl, Joyce Brode, Allan Mehrens, Doris Whitlock, William Nero, Terry Hodges, Jerry D. Morrison, Raymond Hutchison, Harry C. Sharp, Neal Dovenmuehle, Nancy Ristow, Henry Kennedy, Chirvalarie Wilson, Hubert Ballard, Edward Martin, Bertha McRorie, Joyce Carter, Edmond Carter, The Estate of Riley Roosevelt, Ricky Sharp, Debra Torres, Shirley Lee, Harvey T. Curtis, Linda Montgomery, Philip Caminiti, Bert Bazert, Melissa Richardson, Isaiah D. Wilson, Ricardo Alaniz, Peggy Deese, Joseph McMillion, Estate of Donald W. Wood, by and through his Executor Debra Wood, Debra Wood, surviving spouse of Donald W. Wood on behalf of all legal heirs of Donald W. Wood, Donovan Darroh, Carl Overton, Donald Nickerson, Alfred Carroll, Cara M. King, Earnest Bolden, Kenneth Pool, David Carr, David Burman, Jerry Bonham, Caitlyn Loftis, Herbert Strunk, III, Nanci Strunk, Izetta White, George Gajdzik, Vernon Dunston, Ruth Dunston, Sarah Mae Young, Charles W. Young, Mae Latimer, Helen Green, Francis Eugene Hayden, Ruth Hayden, Kenneth Ray Booker, Tammy Booker & Anthony L. Gallimore, Plaintiffs, represented by Kirk John Goza , Goza Honnold Trial Lawyers.

PATRICIA LASHOCK, Jerry Tingle, SCOTT BROOMFIELD, REGINA SLUGG, ROBERT GREGG, SARAH BARNARD, Dorothy Mitchell, Bonnie Parrish, Mary Ann Yagy, Ronnie Stevenson, Drew Ballow, Herbert Zeman, Valerie Rump, Loretta Buckingham, Chantel Grant, James Hardy, Glenn Fogel, Craig Griffeth, Barbara Bernard, Administratrix of the Estate of Trina Gunnoe, Lisa Wiley, Gary Barnett, Gary Grunwald, Mary Arven, Barbara Goldenstein, John Johnson, Jr. & Kimberly Hummer, Plaintiffs, represented by D. Todd Mathews , GORI AND JULIAN, P.C. & Peter Andrew Miller , Miller DellaFera, PLC.

Warren Ahrent & Vicki Ahrent, Plaintiffs, represented by Thomas V. Ayala , Grant and Eisenhofer PA, pro hac vice.

Myrlon Edwards, Daniel Fink, Christopher Moore, Sara Partee & Ronald McCravey, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrew Scott Williams , Simmons Hanly Conroy, LLC.

Ruben Hernandez, Martha Hernandez, William R. Malin & Alicia Worth, Plaintiffs, represented by Deborah Susan Kerr , Goldberg and Osborne LLP.

Jarvis A. White, Parkeya Andrews, James F. Brown, Teresa Brown, Thomas E. Randall, Lavonne Randall, John R. Simmons, Elizabeth Simmons, Juanita Battles, Paul Palmer, Patricia Palmer, Christopher Lewis, Karen Lewis, Herb Peavy & Vicki Peavy, Plaintiffs, represented by Jonathan Wesley Johnson , Jonathan W. Johnson, LLC.

DENISE MANCINI, Plaintiff, represented by Jason M. Schiffman , Schiffman Firm, LLC.

Wilma L. Williams & Angela Matchett, Plaintiffs, represented by David Thomas Crumplar , Jacobs & Crumplar, P.A.

Timothy Roberts, Plaintiff, represented by Richard William Schulte , WRIGHT & SCHULTE, LLC & Tad Thomas , Thomas Law Offices, PLLC.

Larry Edwin Green & Sue Ellen Green, Plaintiffs, represented by Sherri Lee Mazur , Mazur & Phillips LLC & Wesley Shawn Walterscheid , Mazur Law.

Frank Manale, Plaintiff, represented by Conrad S.P. Williams, III , Williams Law Group & Meredith R. Durham , Williams Law Group.

Roger Ward, Plaintiff, represented by John Everett Tomlinson , Beasley, Allen, Crow, Methvin, Portis & Miles, PC, pro hac vice.

Lenvil Ramey & Helenka Ramey, Plaintiffs, represented by Philip J. Edwards .

Jimmy M. Jones, Plaintiff, represented by Mason Lee Boling , Keith Miller Butler Schneider Pawlik & Sean T. Keith , Keith, Miller, Butler, Schneider, Pawlik.

Michael Andrews, Plaintiff, pro se.

Bryan Brooks, Plaintiff, pro se.

Mildred Schroeder, Plaintiff, represented by KAREN HOPE BEYEA-SCHROEDER , Schroeder Law Office PLLC.

Beverly Jolly, Plaintiff, pro se.

KATHLEEN BURNS, Plaintiff, represented by ROBERT MICHAEL SILVERMAN , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ELMER JORDAN, Plaintiff, represented by James Dennis Young , Morgan and Morgan Complex Litigation Group & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Jeduthan McCoy, Plaintiff, represented by Patrick S. Wooten , SCHWARTZ & ASSOCIATES, PA.

Beneda F. Masters, Plaintiff, represented by Alexander Cubberly Davis , Jones Ward PLC & Jasper Duduley Ward, IV , Jones Ward PLC.

Sharon Berenfeld, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey Louis Haberman , Schlesinger Law Offices.

Karen Delmore-Barton, Plaintiff, represented by Frank M. Petosa , Morgan & Morgan PA & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.

Russell Baxter, Plaintiff, pro se.

Samuel Bloechl, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Gallagher Alholm , Vrdolyak Law Group, LLC.

David Keeler, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Brittany R. Ford , Abbott Law Group, PA & Steven William Teppler , Abbott Law Group, P.A.

Maurice Bone, Plaintiff, represented by Frank Michael Petosa , Morgan & Morgan, PA.

Walter J. Watson, Plaintiff, represented by Michael P. McGartland , MCGARTLAND & BORCHARDT LLP.

Zander Bray, Plaintiff, represented by Dennis Craig Reich , Reich and Binstock, LLP, Lindsay Anne Cordes , Thomas Law Offices, PLLC & Melissa Binstock Ephron , Reich & Binstock, LLP.

Lisa Breger, Plaintiff, represented by David C. Strouss , Thornton Law Firm LLP & Jotham C. Kinder , Thornton Law Firm LLP.

Anne Parker, Plaintiff, represented by Melissa Binstock Ephron , Reich & Binstock, LLP & Raeann Warner , Jacobs and Crumplar, P.A.

Gary Burton, Plaintiff, represented by Christina Teresa Natale , Jones Ward PLC, Douglas A. Dellaccio, Jr. , Cory Watson, PC, J. Curt Tanner , Cory Watson, PC, Lawrence L. Jones, II , Jones Ward PLC, R. Andrew Jones , Cory Watson, P.C., James Curtis Tanner , Cory Watson, P.C. & Robert Andrew Jones , Cory Watson, P.C.

Joseph Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Davis Holland , Holland, Groves, Schneller and Stolze, Curtis George Hoke , The Miller Firm, LLC & James T. Corrigan , ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C.

Deanna L. Gelder, Mark Hanson, Michael Furnice, Tracy Magee, Brenda Ashton, Olga Castro & Richard Cohn, Plaintiffs, represented by James T. Corrigan , ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C. & Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC.

Robert Rabbit, Derril Hayes, Randy Luff, Jeff Davis, Robert Belsey, Howard Bare, Randall Goskowicz, Maki Goskowicz, Christopher Pruett, Carlia Pruett, Brenda Ricker, Fred Robinson, Nancy Balcom, as Next of Kin for Robert Balcom, Kenneth Barker, Kari Barker, Angie Berberian, Ramro Castillo Torres, Tina Follett, Patrick Follett, Dina Gehring, Lyle Gehring, Mason Geisinger, Amy Jennings, Tiffany Kay, Tina Lawrence, Samuel Mendoza, Joanne Miller, Nancy Malloy, Douglas Nahale, David Polanco, Daniel Ramirez, Michael Randall, Susan Rustan, John Sanders, Laurence Simmons, Kenneth Smith & Janelle Spanbauer, Plaintiffs, represented by James T. Corrigan , ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C. & Curtis George Hoke , The Miller Firm, LLC.

John Gibson, Plaintiff, represented by Steven William Teppler , Abbott Law Group, P.A. & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C., pro hac vice.

Robert Barnes, Plaintiff, represented by James T. Corrigan , ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C. & John Edward Abaray , Thomas Law Offices.

Sterling Bates, Antonio Andrade, Jr., Barton Baron, Wayne Bolt, Joseph R. Bork, Jr., Maude Bradley, Faina Brainin, Warren Curtiss, Richard M. Daley, Joann Delfino Smith, Marilyn Denzine Morris, Geraldine Dimaio, Laurence B. Dittmer, Crystal Lynne Gray, Kurt Farenchak, Dennis L. Federle, Neil J. Hadley, Clifford Hall, Ernest D. Hendricks, Pamela A. Higgenbotham, Susan C. McNair, James M. Muter, David B. Ochab, Leatha J. Orr, Andrew J. Pollastro, Lori Ratzke, Jacob Ratzke, Taylor Ratzke, Ethan Ratzke, Donald G. Richardson, Irene Risner, Mary Ann Rogers, Norma Saltzman, Kyle J. Sanders, James Allen Strubinger, Michael Symons, Madeline Urwin, Robert A. Urwin, Michael J. Urwin, Joshua D. Wright, Lloyd Nelius, James Brown, Rose Byrne, Brett Everett, Cory Fisher, Beckett Jones, Kurt Knox, Joel MacDonald, Arthur Puckett, Pat Richard, Erwin Sikorski, Dennis Sorensen, Tim Hensley, Helena Jochaniewicz, Jim Moore, Tessie Thompson, Sally Richards, Josephine Ponella, Lisa Chain, John Webb, Gerald R. Feranec, Patricia Crawford, Michael L. Hoskin, Ouida M. Huber, Ryan C. Hudson, Daniel W. Hunnell, Jr., Bruce Inglese, Bernard Jackson, Carl E. James, Terri James, Andrew L. Jordan, Willa I. Kiddy, Doris E. King, James A. Knieling, Dorothy C. Koonce, Keith A. Krayer, Vicky Laybourne, Darrell L. Ledford, Jeffrey R. Lubonty, Susan K. Marra, Joseph J. McCarter, Jimmy D. McFarland, Daniel W. Miller, Timothy J. Niemiec, Mark E. Patten, Jan Patters, Diane C. Pellin, Constance L. Perkins, Lilian Ann Perkins, Bradley C. Pfaff, Philip P. Pirani, Mark A. Poteat, Alan Dean Randa, Vito F. Russo, Pamela J. Sanders, Derek J. Santoro, Ann E. Schiro, Corey A. Schott, Jane A. Simpson, Kenneth G. Smith, Phillip A. Sperl, Dana D. Spires, Moyle H. Surrette, Jess A. Suter, Douglas E. Swenson, Salina L. Tarantino, Samuel L. Thacker, Deborah Tietje, Matthew Tietje, Megan T. Primeau, Molly T. Mallet, Ree L. Tschetter, Troy Van Genderen, Jason Mack Vaughn, Flora Noel, Lance Noel, Delecia Scott, Curtis Campbell, Beverly Taylor-Adams, Elaine W. Sasser, Matt Dettlebach, Robert Poindexter, Angela Young, Sandra Watt, Barbara Beabout, Scott Marques, Brenda Smith, David Strenk, Martha Fiese, Janice Demadona, Karl Castille, Judy Castille, Tommy Lawson, Billie Jean Clayton, Donna M. Coker, Lance T. Conner, Robert E. Counselman, Tyler N. Crafton, Brian Crotts, Patricia B. Dover, Carmen K. Ellington, Paul J. Fieber, Hillard Hall, Jr., Dorothia R. Halligan, Rebecca Kidwell-Rowe, Duane Madsen, Edwin M. Mason, Thomas H. McLaughlin, Steven E. Merritt, Joann M. Meyhoefer, Douglas B. Moore, Lisa M. Pecora, Thomas L. Qualls, David W. Reagan, Kenneth A. Robertson, Edward J. Ruff, Scott Scharf, Gary R. Skeie, Kenneth A. Smith, Ladonna K. Sparks, John M. Struewing, James I. Taylor, Linda M. Verchereau, Carol Young Jones, Paul Acton, John T. Adams, Sandra Adkins, Barbara Baker, Roberto Balderas, Joseph Batiste, William Bloome, Jeffrey Bradley, Rodney Broussard, Tommy Byford, Jeffrey Byram, Wesley Cormican, Joshua Davis, Harold Davis, Jack Dominick, Russell Dunn, Jack Epstein, James Halacheff, Wayne Hardy, Ernest Hebert, Carol Jones, Robert Konopa, Beverly Mancini, Kevin McFarland, Stephen Meyer, Donna O'Brien, Beverly Perrin, Charles Rider, Daisy Robinson, Domingo Rodriguez, Robert Rydin, Steve Sabac, Karen Savant, Wayne Schmitz, Geoffrey Smith, Holly Staggs, Susan Tabone, Ronnie W. Walker, Harold Wallace, Steve Weintraub, Eddie Williams, Ruth Guthrie, Jimmy Turner, Janice Baty, Manuel Garcia, Gary Cordell & Joseph Saurini, Plaintiffs, represented by James T. Corrigan , ONDER AND SHELTON, L.L.C. & Pedram Esfandiary , Baum Hedlund Aristei and Goldman.

Patta A. Lane, Plaintiff, pro se.

Mark G. Larsen, Plaintiff, represented by Pedram Esfandiary , Baum Hedlund Aristei and Goldman.

Billy Worth, Plaintiff, represented by Larry F. Woods , Larry F. Woods Law Office & Anthony James Nemo, Sr. , Meshbesher & Spence, Ltd.

Alicia Worth, Plaintiff, pro se.

Stephen DiBeneditto, Plaintiff, represented by Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC & David Jackson Wool , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, pro hac vice.

Michael Klodzinski, Plaintiff, represented by Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC & Yvonne M. Flaherty , Lockridge Grindal Nauen PLLP.

Laurie Marniella, Plaintiff, pro se.

Dorothy J. Swisher, Plaintiff, represented by Dena Rachel Young , Ross Feller Casey, LLP.

Larry Tosi & A. Dana Dunne, Plaintiffs, represented by Melissa Binstock Ephron , Reich & Binstock, LLP.

Michael Adams & Jenni Martino, Plaintiffs, represented by Mason Lee Boling , Keith Miller Butler Schneider Pawlik.

William Terry, Plaintiff, represented by Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump, PC.

Justin R. Martino, Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth John Brennan , TorHoerman Law LLC.

Thelma Rowlee, Plaintiff, represented by Jay A. Urban , Urban Taylor s.c.

George D. Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Nicholas Ryan Rockforte , Pendley, Baudin & Coffin, LLP.

Dale Trappen, Plaintiff, pro se.

Aileen Trappen, Plaintiff, pro se.

Jean Kapolnek, Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth Thomas Lumb , Corboy and Demetrio.

William Ginger, Plaintiff, represented by Dennis Craig Reich , Reich and Binstock, LLP, Matt L. Lindsay , Odom & Elliott P.A. & Melissa Lauren Binstock-Ephron , Reich and Binstock, LLP.

Steven B. Coley, an individual, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Gallagher Alholm , Vrdolyak Law Group, LLC & Brittany R. Ford , Abbott Law Group, PA.

Clint M. Cuevas, Plaintiff, represented by Michael P. McGartland , MCGARTLAND & BORCHARDT LLP, Dennis Craig Reich , Reich and Binstock, LLP, Kenneth Thomas Lumb , Corboy and Demetrio & Rogen K. Chhabra , CHHABRA & GIBBS, PA.

Phillip J. Hobson, Plaintiff, pro se.

Janice Hobson, Plaintiff, pro se.

James O. King, III, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Rose Smith , Grossman & Moore, PLLC & Jennifer A. Moore , Grossman & Moore, PLLC.

Cara M. King, Plaintiff, pro se.

Sally J. Sobrepena, Plaintiff, pro se.

Robert R. Sobrepena, Plaintiff, pro se.

Albertine McCord, Plaintiff, represented by Christina Teresa Natale , Jones Ward PLC, Ann E. Rice Ervin , Motley Rice LLP, Lawrence L. Jones, II , Jones Ward PLC & R. Andrew Jones , Cory Watson, P.C.

Patricka Poythress, Plaintiff, pro se.

Greg S. Vanderlip, Plaintiff, pro se.

LEO NOBLE, Plaintiff, represented by Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Dennis Craig Reich , Reich and Binstock, LLP & Kenneth Thomas Lumb , Corboy and Demetrio.

Armando Vargas Chavez, Plaintiff, represented by Jonathan L. Nielsen , Nielsen Peterson and Nielsen LLP.

Gary O'Bryant, Plaintiff, represented by Christina Teresa Natale , Jones Ward PLC, Lawrence L. Jones, II , Jones Ward PLC, R. Andrew Jones , Cory Watson, P.C. & Robert Eugene Shuttlesworth , Shrader and Associates LLP.

Kenneth D. Braasch, Plaintiff, pro se.

Teresa Braasch, Plaintiff, pro se.

Andrew Moreau, Plaintiff, pro se.

Stephanie Moreau, Plaintiff, pro se.

John Brooks, Gene Magwire, Betty Nolan, Mary Fitch, Beth Campbell & Teresea Anderson, Plaintiffs, represented by Peter Andrew Miller , Miller DellaFera, PLC.

Sarah Mae Young, Plaintiff, pro se.

Charles W. Young, Plaintiff, pro se.

Linda Alexander, Plaintiff, represented by Christina Teresa Natale , Jones Ward PLC, Douglas A. Dellaccio, Jr. , Cory Watson, PC, John M. Rainwater , Rainwater, Holt & Sexton P.A., R. Andrew Jones , Cory Watson, P.C. & Lawrence L. Jones, II , Jones Ward PLC.

Jerry Logan & Tracy Green, Plaintiffs, represented by Brian Leighton Kinsley , Crumley Roberts, Christina Teresa Natale , Jones Ward PLC, Lawrence L. Jones, II , Jones Ward PLC & R. Andrew Jones , Cory Watson, P.C.

Timothy Ray Billingsley, (Deceased) by and through his mother, Sue Billingsley, Edgar McGee, Phillip Chierici, Marvin Kennedy, Tim Sinka, Dave Flynn, David Sterling, Edward Holmes, Mark Gossman, Alexander Schlink, Barbara Bizal, Robert Steadman, Mildred Coats, Connie Finneman, William Lis, Vickie Riordan, Dwight Alexy & Alonzo Martinez, Plaintiffs, represented by John Arthur Eaves, Jr. , Eaves Law Firm, LLC.

Timothy Lee Enis, Kristin Leigh Heath, Michael Jamison, Edna Dianne Jenkins, (deceased), by and through her widower, Charles Jenkins, Tommy Jones, Stacy Allen King, John Franklin Lumsden, (deceased), by and through his daughter, Lisa Holloway, Terry Dean Moore, Marsha Mundinger, Norman Mundinger, Debra Ann Pharr, Margaret H. Ricks, Danny Threet, (deceased), by and through his widow, Lisa Threet, Paul Daniel Warren, Ruth Ann Amanda Weaver, Mary Kathryn Keene Williams, Michael R. Williams, Bobby Joe Wooten, Jill L. Bourgeoris, Steven Bussard, Arthur Mac Clements, William Hambright, Willie Hill, Marla Rachel Hughes, L. Marie Jackson, Emily Dale Hasty Jones, Gloria J. McRaney, Linda J. Munn, Phyllis E. Parker, Gregory Watts Simms, (deceased), by and through his widow, Anita Dolanda McArthur Simms, Timothy M. Smith, (deceased), by and through his widow, Elaine Gordon Smith, Cecil Taylor & Judy Elaine W. Wright, (deceased), by and through her widower, Hershel Wright, Plaintiffs, represented by Brian Leighton Kinsley , Crumley Roberts.

Lillie Covington, Plaintiff, represented by Christina Teresa Natale , Jones Ward PLC, Dena Rachel Young , Ross Feller Casey, LLP, Lawrence L. Jones, II , Jones Ward PLC & R. Andrew Jones , Cory Watson, P.C.

Cynthia Duhon, Plaintiff, represented by Hunter William Lundy , Lundy, Lundy, Soileau and South, LLP, Jackey W. South , Lundy Lundy et al & Kristie Marie Hightower , Lundy Lundy Soileau and South LLP.

JOHN HENWOOD, Plaintiff, represented by Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC & Dena Rachel Young , Ross Feller Casey, LLP.

JANE HENWOOD & PETER GALOSI, Plaintiffs, represented by Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC.

JANE HENWOOD, Plaintiff, pro se.

Francis Eugene Hayden, Plaintiff, pro se.

Ruth Hayden, Plaintiff, pro se.

Jerald Carriere, Plaintiff, represented by Karen Barth Menzies , Gibbs Law Group LLP & Yvonne M. Flaherty , Lockridge Grindal Nauen PLLP.

Michael Thomas, Plaintiff, represented by David M. Zack , Blevins Sanborn Jezdimir Zack PLC.

Christopher L. Roberts, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph M. Bruno , Bruno & Bruno, Julie U. Quinn , Quinn Alsterberg LLC & Justin E. Alsterberg , Quinn Alsterberg LLC.

Jack Shorr, Melissa Fuller, William Barbour, Catherine Potter, Alfred Monares, Charles Friedman, William Perry, John Coviello, Arthur Capo, Michael Ploof, Samuel Vacante, Stephen Stanley Nash-Boulden, Dwight Wilkinson, Gordon Rice, Neil Kirsch, William Bordeaux, Chad Coulter & Steven Burchfield, Plaintiffs, represented by D. Todd Mathews , GORI AND JULIAN, P.C.

William A. Lamb, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Rose Smith , Grossman & Moore, PLLC & Kirk John Goza , Goza Honnold Trial Lawyers.

Sarah E. Lamb, Plaintiff, represented by Justin E. Alsterberg , Quinn Alsterberg LLC & Kirk John Goza , Goza Honnold Trial Lawyers.

Joni H. Freel & Sally Adelson, Plaintiffs, represented by Terry Wayne Yates , Terry W. Yates & Associates.

Louisa Underwood, Plaintiff, represented by Leslie W. O'Leary , Johnson Johnson Lucas & Middleton, P.C.

Russell Gines, Plaintiff, represented by Mason Lee Boling , Keith Miller Butler Schneider Pawlik & Tor Hoerman , TORHOERMAN LAW LLC.

Paul Rudisill & Donelda Smith, Plaintiffs, represented by Mason Lee Boling , Keith Miller Butler Schneider Pawlik & Ashton Rose Smith , Grossman & Moore, PLLC.

Bryan J. Madere & Sherrie Scott, Plaintiffs, represented by Matthew Benjamin Moreland , Jim S. Hall & Associates, LLC.

Klaus Krunnies, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Clinton Hunter , Hayes Hunter, PC, Dennis Craig Reich , Reich and Binstock, LLP & Kenneth Thomas Lumb , Corboy and Demetrio.

Gary E. Purdy, Plaintiff, represented by Russell W. Lewis, IV , Johnson Law Group.

Arnold Borreson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric S. Rossman , Rossman Law Group, PLLC, Erica S. Phillips , ROSSMAN LAW GROUP, Kenneth Brian Moll , Moll Law Group & Stephen Michael Cady , Moll Law Group.

Ray D. Harry & Charles Butt, Plaintiffs, represented by Brian P. Galligan , GALLIGAN & REID PC.

Charles Miracle, Individually and as Administrator of the Estate of Eva L. Miracle, Plaintiff, represented by Alex C. Davis , Jones Ward PLC & Jasper Duduley Ward, IV , Jones Ward PLC.

James Peterson & Christine Karman, Plaintiffs, represented by Kenneth Brian Moll , Moll Law Group & Eric S. Rossman , Rossman Law Group, PLLC.

Ronald Klock, Plaintiff, represented by Wilson D. Sikes , NAPOLI SHKOLNIK & Tate James Kunkle , Napoli Shkolnik PLLC.

Jean Klock, Plaintiff, represented by Alex C. Davis , Jones Ward PLC & Tate James Kunkle , Napoli Shkolnik PLLC.

Ronnie Ard, Sandi Ard, Henry Clark, Patricia Clark, Robert Kun, Richard Merna, Troy Mihalinac, Nancy Mucha, Robin Neal, Barbara Nichter, Paula Peck, Edward Perry, Carl Piazza, William Porta, Rose Powell, Mark Radominkski, Chris Remley, Allan Rickards, Deseri Roper, Marie Rynearson, Tim Sagarsee, Alisa Sharp, Earlynn Sheehan, Murtell Sligh, Lois Smith, Ernest Snyder, Robert Spada, Robert Sterling, Russel Tollefson, Sherman Trout, William Turner, Jr., Thomas Vanfossen, Israel Vega, Stephen Wayshak, Cathleen Wilk & Gerald Wybranski, Plaintiffs, represented by Alex C. Davis , Jones Ward PLC.

Delbert Lee Brooks, Plaintiff, represented by Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Jonathan Patrick Novak , Fears Nachawati & Matthew Ryan McCarley , Fears Nachawati PLLC.

Virgilio Eduardo Nurquez, Plaintiff, represented by Marc Andrew Chandler , Pape & Chandler, P.A. & Sagi Shaked , Shaked Law Firm, P.A.

Jajuane Muller, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Christopher Burke , Bernstein Liebhard LLP, Grant Maxwell Cofer , Beasley Allen Crow Methvin Portis and Miles P.C., John Everett Tomlinson , Beasley, Allen, Crow, Methvin, Portis & Miles, PC & Rhon Eugene Jones , Beasley, Allen, Crown, Methvin, Portis & Miles, PC.

Aubrey R. Aden, Plaintiff, pro se.

Brian Rickard, Plaintiff, represented by Larua C. Fellows , Paul LLP.

Michael Poulin, Plaintiff, represented by Michael P. McGartland , MCGARTLAND & BORCHARDT LLP & Kenneth Thomas Lumb , Corboy and Demetrio.

Jeribeth Subers, Personal Representative of the Estate of Raymond Subers, Deceased, Plaintiff, represented by Brian Joseph McCormick, Jr. , Ross Feller Casey, LLP.

Karen Evans, Plaintiff, represented by Kathryn Eidson Griffin , Fulmer Sill PLLC, Matthew James Sill , Sill Law Group, PLLC & Tara T. Tabatabaie , Sill Law Group, PLLC.

Nina Ottinger & David Campbell, Plaintiffs, represented by Kori Lynn Westbrook , Johnson Law Group & Matthew Benjamin Moreland , Jim S. Hall & Associates, LLC.

Rickey Peabody, Plaintiff, represented by Brian Joseph McCormick, Jr. , Ross Feller Casey, LLP & Mason Lee Boling , Keith Miller Butler Schneider Pawlik.

J.T. Cash, Plaintiff, represented by Beth E. Terrell , Terrell Marshall Law Group PLLC.

PETER GALOSI, Plaintiff, pro se.

NORMA GALOSI, Plaintiff, pro se.

Gary M. Gabor, Plaintiff, represented by Lee D. Cope , Peters Murdaugh Parker Eltzroth and Detrick PA.

Teresa A. Gabor, Plaintiff, represented by Kori Lynn Westbrook , Johnson Law Group.

Charles W. Larsen, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew L. Davick , Meshbesher & Spence, Ltd, Anthony James Nemo, Sr. , Meshbesher & Spence, Ltd & Ashleigh Raso , Meshbesher and Spence, Ltd.

Connie Larsen, Plaintiff, represented by Richard William Schulte , WRIGHT & SCHULTE, LLC, Lee D. Cope , Peters Murdaugh Parker Eltzroth and Detrick PA & Andrew L. Davick , Meshbesher & Spence, Ltd.

Patrick A. Petty, Plaintiff, represented by Tim L. Bowden , Law Offices of Tim Bowden, pro hac vice.

Sharon Petty, Plaintiff, represented by Anthony James Nemo, Sr. , Meshbesher & Spence, Ltd, pro hac vice.

Brenda Whitmire, Plaintiff, pro se.

James Edward Gardner, Lacadiette Cohen, Jeffery Van Camp, Sr., John Stenger, Thomas McAnnally & Frank Lerner, Plaintiffs, represented by Christopher Nemat Shakib , Terrell Hogan, PA.

Cynthia L. Gardner, Plaintiff, represented by Tim L. Bowden , Law Offices of Tim Bowden.

Jerry Keith Haney, Judy Theriot & Kent Berthelot, Plaintiffs, represented by Emily Jo Kirk , McCune Wright, LLP.

Ray Moore, Plaintiff, pro se.

Allowishes Dula Scott, Plaintiff, pro se.

Larry Singleton, Plaintiff, pro se.

Beverly Bray, Plaintiff, pro se.

Richard Garrott, Plaintiff, pro se.

Dennis Lindstrom, Plaintiff, pro se.

Dennis Ferris, Plaintiff, pro se.

Walter Holden, Plaintiff, pro se.

William Johnson, II, Plaintiff, pro se.

Darrel Mosely, Plaintiff, pro se.

Delbert Kazee, Plaintiff, pro se.

Michael Pettit, Plaintiff, pro se.

Mark Waligura, Plaintiff, pro se.

Cynthia Banks, Plaintiff, pro se.

Oliver McCain, Plaintiff, pro se.

Gabriel Hernandez, Plaintiff, represented by Stanley George Swiderski .

Kenneth Ray Booker, Plaintiff, pro se.

Tammy Booker, Plaintiff, pro se.

Anthony L. Gallimore, Plaintiff, pro se.

Joe Duncan, Plaintiff, represented by J. Burton LeBlanc, IV , Baron & Budd.

Raymond G. Jones, Plaintiff, represented by Emily Jo Kirk , McCune Wright, LLP & S. Ann Saucer , Baron & Budd.

Margaret F. Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Erica S. Phillips , ROSSMAN LAW GROUP & Stephen Michael Cady , Moll Law Group.

Virgenna Saunders, Plaintiff, pro se.

Robert Hooks, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph Ryan Riegerix , Andrus Wagstaff, P.C.

Douglas Damkroger, Cynthia Luce, Steven Sanders, Janis Sanders, James Morris, Ronald Vallieres, John Marshall, Nancy Creamer, Vincent Ballarino, Lisa Edwards, Warren Campbell, Donald O'Dell & Vaughn Clark, Plaintiffs, represented by S. Ann Saucer , Baron & Budd.

Martha Matlock, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew Kevin Gardner , Johnson Law Group.

Homero Muzquiz, Plaintiff, represented by Vincent Joseph Moccio , Bennerotte & Assoc.

Patricia Godsey, Plaintiff, represented by Wilson D. Sikes , NAPOLI SHKOLNIK, pro hac vice.

Edwin Hardeman, Plaintiff, represented by Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, David Jackson Wool , Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Jennifer A. Moore , Grossman & Moore, PLLC, Kathryn Miller Forgie , Andrus Wagstaff PC, Lori Erin Andrus , Andrus Anderson LLP, Vance R. Andrus , Andrus Hood Wagstaff & Leland Humphrey Belew , Andrus Anderson LLP.

Robert Cloutier, Plaintiff, represented by Francisco Antonio Albites, Jr. , Parker Waichman, LLP.

Alex McCrae, Plaintiff, represented by Shannon Marie McNulty , Clifford Law Offices, P.C.

Diane McCrae, Plaintiff, represented by Kathryn Miller Forgie , Andrus Wagstaff PC.

George W. Hans, Plaintiff, pro se.

LEWIS NASH, Plaintiff, represented by HEATHER K. D'ONOFRIO , THE D'ONOFRIO FIRM.

Jerry Nettles, Plaintiff, represented by Brigid E. Collins , Leger & Shaw, Marcus Adam Green , Green Law Firm & Walter John Leger, III , Leger & Shaw.

Charles Kast, Benjamin Cable, Max Coleman, Bobby Sheldon, Brent Carr, Laurene Miller, Eveline Paris, Lourdes Valle, Brad Perrault, Don Leonard, Samantha Taylor, Joseph Rykert, Denise Berger, Patricia Salgado, Jose Aguilera, Anthony Smith, Michael Ferguson, Nola Garcia, Dan King, David Mobley, Frances Gonzalez, Steven Kist, Laurie Loomis, Syble Gobron, Mike Mostipak, Steven Welch, James Nelson, Bobby Newton, Raymond Peck, Shanda Salim, Reynaldo Rivas, Rand Stammen, Robert Burg, Robert Hernandez, Janet Herdt, Jo Ann Carter, Robert Howe, Laura Shoebel, Evelyn Ruley, John Rabbers, Marques Jones, Dan Sellers, Michael Rietzke, Phyllis Bobrow, Joshua Freitas, Jodi Horyna & Camilla Kennedy, Plaintiffs, represented by Matthew James Sill , Sill Law Group, PLLC, Michael Lin Baum , Baum Hedlund Aristei and Goldman PC & Tara T. Tabatabaie , Sill Law Group, PLLC.

Robert Chaisson, Plaintiff, represented by Lawrence Joseph Centola, III , Martzell, Bickford, and Centola & Michael E. Lillis , Lillis Law Firm, LLC.

Jeffrey D. Baum, Joseph Calhoun, Emilio Cavazos, Charles Crouse, Keith Davie, Kathryn Dufore, Brynda Dunbar, Norman J. Flinn, Kenneth Grisler, John Kalfayan, Lawrence Krupinski, Bruce Lowe, James Eric Nelson, Jose Ochoa, Steven Oliveira, Terrence M. O'Neill, Anita Richardson, Lee Alan Rosichan, Robert Geoffrey Smith & Michael D. Winch, Jr., Plaintiffs, represented by Devin Lynn Bolton , Weitz& Luxenberg, P.C.

Marcia Barnes, Plaintiff, represented by Lawrence Joseph Centola, III , Martzell, Bickford, and Centola.

Larry Shoop, Plaintiff, represented by David L. Lutz , Handler Henning & Rosenberg & Jordan A. Marzzacco , Handler, Henning & Rosenberg, LLP.

Marsha Shoop, Plaintiff, represented by Michael E. Lillis , Lillis Law Firm, LLC & John Edward Abaray , Thomas Law Offices.

Ceceilia Ayon, Plaintiff, represented by Elizabeth Jean McLafferty , SCHROETER GOLDMARK BENDER & Sims G. Weymuller , SCHROETER GOLDMARK & BENDER.

NATALA POROZ, Plaintiff, represented by KEVIN M. NOONAN , MCTEAGUE, HIGBEE, CASE, COHEN, WHITNEY & TOKER, P.A. & PAUL M. DOMINGUEZ , DOMINGUEZ LAW FIRM LLC.

Monsanto Company, Defendant, represented by Aaron H. Levine , Arnold Porter Kaye Scholer LLP, Andrew K. Solow , Arnold and Porter Kaye Scholer LLP, Ann Elizabeth Blackwell , Thompson Coburn LLP, Bert L. Slonim , Arnold and Porter Kaye Scholer LLP, Bradford John Robinson , Hartline Dacus Barger Dreyer LLP, Carol D. Browning , Stites & Harbison, PLLC, Daniel S. Pariser , Arnold and Porter Kaye Scholer LLP, David P. Strup , Shumaker, Loop & Kendrick, Gregory J. Minana , Husch Blackwell LLP, Heather Ann Pigman , Hollingsworth LLP, James E. Hooper , Wheeler Trigg O'Donnell LLP, James Shelson , PHELPS DUNBAR LLP, Julie B. Du Pont , Arnold Porter Kaye Scholer LLP, Katharine Lester Mowery , Richards, Layton & Finger, PA, Kelly E. Farnan , Richards, Layton & Finger, PA, Michael F. O'Connor , Ogawa Lau Nakamura & Jew, Pamela Joan Yates , Kaye Scholer LLP, Randall H. Stefani , Ahlers & Cooney, P.C., Rebecca Elizabeth Reif , Ahlers & Cooney, P.C., Richard Alden Clark , Parker Milliken Clark O'Hara and Samuelian PC, Sandra A. Edwards , Farella Braun Martel LLP, T. Jay Seale, III , Seale & Ross, APLC, Wendy D. May , Hartline Dacus Barger Dreyer LLP, William Hoffman , Arnold Porter Kaye Scholer LLP, Andrew Charles MacNally , Bartlit Beck LLP, Barbara R. Light , Shook Hardy Bacon LLP, Brian S. Prestes , Bartlit Beck LLP, Brian L. Stekloff , WILKINSON WALSH ESKOVITZ LLP, Cali Cope-Kasten , WILKINSON WALSH ESKOVITZ LLP, Christine F. Miller , Husch Blackwell LLP, D. Matthew Moscon , STOEL RIVES, Donald McMinn , Hollingsworth LLP, E. James Shepherd , Shook Hardy Bacon L.L.P., Eric Gordon Lasker , Hollingsworth LLP, pro hac vice, Eskandar Alex Beroukhim , Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer LLP, Gary Ira Rubin , Hollingsworth LLP, George Carter Lombardi , Winston & Strawn LLP, Glen Ray Galbraith , Seale & Ross, James M. Hilmert , Winston & Strawn LLP, James Michael Sullivan , Hollingsworth LLP, Jerome C. Hafter , PHELPS DUNBAR LLP, Joe G. Hollingsworth , Hollingsworth LLP, pro hac vice, Julie Bendix Rubenstein , Wilkinson Walsh and Eskovitz, KELLY E. JONES , HARRIS BEACH PLLC, Katharine R. Latimer , Hollingsworth LLP, pro hac vice, Kirby T. Griffis , Hollingsworth LLP, Lauren E. Hosler , STOEL RIVES, Lindley James Brenza , Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott, MATTHEW J. JUNK , DEASEY, MAHONEY, VALENTINI, NORTH LTD., Mark S. Ouweleen , Bartlit Beck LLP, Martin C. Calhoun , Hollingsworth LLP, Matthew J. Malinowski , Hollingsworth LLP, Michael K. Huffer , CASSEM, TIERNEY LAW FIRM, Michael Xavier Imbroscio , Covington and Burling LLP, Paul William Schmidt , Covington and Burling LLP, Phyllis Alene Jones , Covington Burling LLP, Rakesh Kilaru , WILKINSON WALSH ESKOVITZ LLP, Ranjit Dhindsa , Hollingsworth LLP, Robert E. Johnston , Hollingsworth LLP, Robert Gregg Mayer , PHELPS DUNBAR LLP, Ronald F. Krause , CASSEM, TIERNEY LAW FIRM, Samuel Zachary Fayne , Arnold and Porter Kaye Scholer LLP, Sean Eskovitz , Wilkinson Walsh Eskovitz LLP, Spencer Hal Silverglate , Clarke Silverglate, P.A., Steven Derringer , Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott, Steven Robert Platt , Parker Milliken, et al., Tamarra Matthews Johnson , WILKINSON WALSH ESKOVITZ LLP & William James Cople , Hollingsworth LLP.

Ragan and Massey, Inc., Defendant, represented by Ernest Paul Gieger, Jr. , Gieger, Laborde & Laperouse, LLC, Eric Stewart Charleston , Gieger, Laborde & Laperouse, LLC & William A. Barousse , Gieger, Laborde & Laperouse, LLC.

Joint Glyphosate Task Force, LLC, Defendant, represented by John Francis Olinde , Chaffe, McCall, Phillips, Toler & Sarpy, Peter L. Gray , Dentons US, LLP, pro hac vice & Peter Joseph Rotolo, III , Chaffe McCall LLP.

Wilbur-Ellis Company, LLC & Wilbur-Ellis Feed, LLC, Defendants, represented by James Michael Sullivan , Hollingsworth LLP & E. James Shepherd , Shook Hardy Bacon L.L.P.

Osborn & Barr Communications, Inc., Defendant, represented by David G. Ott , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE LLP, John F. Cowling , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE LLP & Scott Timothy Jansen , Armstrong Teasdale, LLP.

Osborn & Barr Holdings, Inc., Defendant, represented by Peter L. Gray , Dentons US, LLP, Peter Joseph Rotolo, III , Chaffe McCall LLP & David G. Ott , ARMSTRONG TEASDALE LLP.

Lorna Zerba, Defendant, represented by David J. Diamond , Goldberg and Osborne.

Bayer Corporation, Defendant, represented by W. Jason Rankin , Hepler Broom LLC.

Walmart Inc., Defendant, represented by Priya Navaratnasingham , Phillips Spallas & Angstadt LLP & Robert Kirk Phillips, Esq. , Phillips Spallas & Angstadt LLP.

United States of America, Respondent, represented by Raven Marie Norris , US Attorneys Office Civil Division & Aimee Hall Wagstaff , Andrus Wagstaff, PC.

Michael J. Miller, Respondent, pro se.

Texas A&M University, Movant, represented by Kimberly Fuchs , Texas Office of the Attorney General Administrative Law Division.

Patricia Beldsoe, Movant, represented by Robert Kirk Phillips, Esq. , Phillips Spallas & Angstadt LLP, Michael Joseph Miller , The Miller Firm LLC & Robin Lynn Greenwald , Weitz and Luxenberg, P.C.


PRETRIAL ORDER No. 139: FINAL PHASE 2 INSTRUCTIONS

The final Phase 2 jury instructions are included below.

IT IS SO ORDERED.

INSTRUCTION NO. 1: CLAIMS FOR PHASE TWO AND DUTY OF THE JURY

Now that you have heard all of the evidence for the second (and final) phase, it...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases