IN RE AMERICAN MEDICAL SYSTEMS, INC. PELVIC REPAIR SYSTEM PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION

Civil Action No. 2:14-cv-07382, MDL No. 2325.

IN RE: AMERICAN MEDICAL SYSTEMS, INC. PELVIC REPAIR SYSTEM PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION. THIS DOCUMENT RELATES TO: Vincent, et al. v. American Medical Systems, Inc., et al.

United States District Court, S.D. West Virginia, Charleston Division.

February 8, 2019.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 28 U.S.C. § 1331
Cause: 28 U.S.C. § 1331 Fed. Question: Personal Injury
Nature of Suit: 365 Personal Inj. Prod. Liability
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Susan Petkovich & Judy Anna Winegardner, Plaintiffs, represented by Amy Eskin , LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS, pro hac vice, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE & Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice.

David Petkovich, Terry Winegardner & David Perlingieri, Plaintiffs, represented by Amy Eskin , LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS, pro hac vice, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice.

Cathy Hoppe, an individual, Plaintiff, represented by Bartholomew J. Dalton , DALTON & ASSOCIATES, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Laura J. Simon , DALTON & ASSOCIATES.

Lisa Berry, Plaintiff, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, John P. Zelbst , ZELBST HOLMES & BUTLER & Mark R. Mueller , MUELLER LAW, pro hac vice.

Evelyn Bonilla, Plaintiff, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, James D. Barger , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Thomas R. Kline , KLINE & SPECTER.

Winston Bonilla, as Wife and Husband, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, James D. Barger , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Thomas R. Kline , KLINE & SPECTER.

Connie Susanne Erwin & David Robert Erwin, Plaintiffs, represented by Darius F. Rafie , MORTENSON & RAFIE, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Jason M. Peck , MORTENSON & RAFIE & Peter B. Mortenson , MORTENSON & RAFIE.

Jill Engledow, an individual & Susan Nosal, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Heather Kent , GIRARDI KEESE, Amy Fisch Solomon , GIRARDI KEESE, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE.

Donna Painter & Ernest Painter, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS, Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & David P. Matthews , MATTHEWS & ASSOCIATES.

Michael Anthony Newton, Plaintiff, represented by Amy Eskin , LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS, pro hac vice, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.

Sue Hoffart & William Hoffart, Plaintiffs, represented by Ashley M. Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, Bonnie Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, David Lee Augustus , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, Dawn R. Meade , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM & Gregory J. Finney , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM.

Glenda Thibodeaux, Bernice Thibodeaux, Nancy Marnel Lee Thompson, Jeannette Beal, Owen Beal, Jean Mills, Robert Mills, Jenny Cerelli, Jason Cerelli, Ethel Moore-Warren, Gwendolyn Bailey, William Bailey, Cynthia Chatelain, John Chatelain, Patricia Deltenre, Doris Simmons, Nancy Cameron, Ken Cameron, Eileen Harris, Dahrel Harris, Dianna Ward, Leona Hoeffner, Mary Zarate, Angie Z. Medellin, Antonio V. Medellin, Joan Charles, Loretta Clark, Walter Clark, Sharon Harlan, Lydia Martinez, Doris Pryor, Linda Bolton, Donald Bolton, Jan Long, Bob Long, Karen Turick, Daniel Turick, Beverly Wright, Betty Mott, Wilson Mott, Florence Skillern, Barbara Engelke, Bridget Hajjar, Bill Hajjar, Thoral Haskell, Patricia Carwile & William Carwile, Plaintiffs, represented by Ashley M. Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, Bonnie Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM & Dawn R. Meade , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM.

Beverly Jacobs & Dan Jacobs, Wife and Husband, Plaintiffs, represented by Dianne M. Nast , NASTLAW, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Christine Lee, Theresa Deal, Linda Durham, Paul Durham, Sarabeth Gouveia Stockman, Joyce Eklund & Vincent Eklund, Plaintiffs, represented by Theodore Oshman , OSHMAN & MIRISOLA.

Jean Ronstadt & Jerry Ronstadt, Plaintiffs, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Pauline Toboulidis , LOPEZ MCHUGH & Regina S. Johnson , LOPEZ MCHUGH.

Shirley Jean Norman, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew Judson Hill, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Gary B. Blasingame , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, James B. Matthews, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Josh B. Wages , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Steven R. Maher , THE MAHER LAW FIRM.

Robert Norman, Plaintiff, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Josh B. Wages , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Steven R. Maher , THE MAHER LAW FIRM.

Kenneth W. Soutamire, Plaintiff, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Teresa Frazier, an individual, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Heather Kent , GIRARDI KEESE, Amy Fisch Solomon , GIRARDI KEESE, Bartholomew J. Dalton , DALTON & ASSOCIATES, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Laura J. Simon , DALTON & ASSOCIATES & Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE.

Mimi Triant & Stavros Triant, Plaintiffs, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Robert Enrique Pastor , HARALSON MILLER PITT FELDMAN & MCANALLY, Stanley G. Feldman , MILLER PITT FELDMAN & MCANALLY, Stephen T. Portell , HARALSON MILLER PITT FELDMAN & MCANALLY & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Judith DiMatteo, Plaintiff, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE, Harry F. Bell, Jr. , THE BELL LAW FIRM, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.

Susan Blair, John Blair, Nancy Henson, Bobby Henson, Darlena Walker, Jim Walker & Sharon Vess, Plaintiffs, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Sean Patrick Tracey , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM & Shawn P. Fox , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM.

Sandra Zenor, Edmund Zenor, Sr. & Colleen Cantwell, Plaintiffs, represented by Gayle M. Blatt , CASEY GERRY SCHENK FRANCAVILLA BLATT & PENFIELD, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Patricia L. Zlaket , CASEY GERRY SCHENK FRANCAVILLA BLATT & PENFIELD & Wendy Michelle Behan , CASEY GERRY SCHENK FRANCAVILLA BLATT & PENFIELD.

Rezina O'Dell, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Neil D. Overholtz , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

LaVerba Hunsicker, David Hunsicker, Brenda Pedroza, Elaine Michalik & Edward Michalik, Plaintiffs, represented by Ashley M. Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, Bonnie Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, Dawn R. Meade , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM & Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice.

Irene Ramirez, Plaintiff, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Hunter J. Shkolnik , NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK & ASSOCIATES.

Teresa Lee & Kenneth Lee, Plaintiffs, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice.

Karen Sherer-Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Mikal C. Watts , WATTS GUERRA CRAFT, Paige Nicole Boldt , WATTS GUERRA & Ryan L. Thompson , WATTS GUERRA CRAFT.

Michelle Klinker & David Klinker, Plaintiffs, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Hunter J. Shkolnik , NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK & ASSOCIATES & Wilson Sikes , NAPOLI SHKOLNIK.

Norma Nicholson, Plaintiff, represented by Gregory Neil McEwen , MCEWEN LAW FIRM & Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice.

Jordan David Lutz, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew Judson Hill, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Tara L. Gibbons , LAW OFFICES OF STACI M. YANDLE, Gary B. Blasingame , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, James B. Matthews, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY & Josh B. Wages , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice.

Robin L. Spalding, Plaintiff, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & John A. Zick , DEBRINCAT PADGETT KOBLISKA & ZICK.

Jesse Acosta, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Tom Sexton, Plaintiff, represented by Gayle M. Blatt , CASEY GERRY SCHENK FRANCAVILLA BLATT & PENFIELD, Patricia L. Zlaket , CASEY GERRY SCHENK FRANCAVILLA BLATT & PENFIELD & Wendy Michelle Behan , CASEY GERRY SCHENK FRANCAVILLA BLATT & PENFIELD.

Shauna McDaniel & Traunza Hodges, Plaintiffs, represented by Edward F. Blizzard , BLIZZARD MCCARTHY & NABERS & Holly W. Gibson , BLIZZARD MCCARTHY & NABERS.

Tammara Craven, Jana Swanson, an individual, Genevieve Liebowitz, an individual, Eric Nieber, Robin McAlpine, an individual & Earl D. McAlpine, her husband, an individual, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Heather Kent , GIRARDI KEESE, Amy Fisch Solomon , GIRARDI KEESE, Bartholomew J. Dalton , DALTON & ASSOCIATES, Laura J. Simon , DALTON & ASSOCIATES & Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE.

Kathaleen Russell, Plaintiff, represented by Michael John Sobieray , STEWART & STEWART, Elizabeth M. Wilkins , SCHLICHTER BOGARD & DENTON & Kristine K. Kraft , SCHLICHTER BOGARD & DENTON.

Theresa M. Curry, Plaintiff, represented by Khaldoun A. Baghdadi , WALKUP MELODIA KELLY & SCHOENBERGER.

Victoria G. Wilkins & Thomas D. Wilkins, Plaintiffs, represented by Eric T. Chaffin , CHAFFIN LUHANA, pro hac vice & Roopal P. Luhana , CHAFFIN LUHANA.

Charloette Lovell, Susan Musaus, Carolina Aldana, Cheryl Thorp & Aileen Angel, Plaintiffs, represented by Jacob Plattenberger , TOR HOERMAN LAW & Tor A. Hoerman , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

Lawana Hart, Linda Argier, Joseph Argier, Veronika Vaessen & Theodoor Vaessen, Plaintiffs, represented by Matthew J. Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, Melissa Erin Mielke , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH & Steven James Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH.

Sharon Klippert & Robert Klippert, Plaintiffs, represented by Hunter J. Shkolnik , NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK & ASSOCIATES.

Janet Barkley, Plaintiff, represented by Bill Robins, III , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK & Justin R. Kaufman , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK.

Maya Fournier, Plaintiff, represented by Edward Seth Goodman , SIMONSON HESS LEIBOWITZ & GOODMAN.

Michael Oar, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Christopher Michael Placitella , COHEN PLACITELLA & ROTH & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Martha Springer, Debra Enrietti, Christina Malango, Deborah Durst, Robert Durst, Maria Martins, Antonio Martins, Sylvia Ortiz, Eduardo Ortiz, Anntoinette Smokler, Howard Corwin, III, Linda Windham, Gene Windham, Lynda Newsome, Joe Newsome, Wanda Vallance, Marvin Vallance, Lynnmarie Barcomb, Jennifer Cramer, Tonia Gerber, James Gerber, Clara Ives, Elizabeth Moseley, Frank Moseley, Susan Parker, William Parker, Michelle Roth, Shirley Sistar, Sharon Baker, Ralph Baker, Patricia Bowen, Julie Chandler, Judy Loughry, Louis Loughry, Natalie Rose Maes, Jean Van Kirk, Terry Van Kirk, Syble Warbington, Joseph Truitt, Lisa Roberts, Stephanie Young, Gary Young, Tina Davis, Eddie Davis, Ruth Carlton, Susan Rhoads-Sidote, Barbara Peck, Monte Peck, Cindy Lance, Daniel Lance, Heidi Wheeler, Gary Wheeler, Janice Hunsberger, Craig Hunsberger, Annette MacDougall, David MacDougall, Monica Garcia, Juan Garcia, Jr., Priscilla Siemiesz, Margaret Johnson, Dwight Johnson, Patricia Magyar, James Magyar, Pamela Rylant, Susanne Corcorran, Althea Swait, Mary Leathers, Samie Leathers, Nancy Behme, Jack Behme, Wilma Richardson, Paul Richardson, Roberta Dixon, Rose Magda, Chester Magda, Shirley Wallace, Randy Wallace, Cynthia Kasey, Dennis Kasey, Judy C. Stewart, Kenneth D. Stewart, Rebecca Burke, Russell Burke, Jennifer Howard, Marian McGuire, Glenna Plane, Robert Plane, Glorious Davis Robinson, Stephanie Sue Spires, Mona Raygoza, Ignacio Raygoza, Robin Mahurin, Gary Mahurin, Wanda Cates, Jo Ann Crooks, Linda Hamilton, Patricia Hetzel, Ronald Hetzel, Jr., Laura Lee Jones, Gerald Allan Jones, Angela Pardue, Alice Pena, Leopold Pena, Donna Rae Sager, Lisa Pasini, Philip Pasini, Veta Yvonne Sturdevant, Wayne Sturdevant, Anglea McKay, Nora Webber, Manford Webber, Sherry Ann Howard, Clarence Howard, Susan Haapaniemi, Peter Happaniemi, Mary Vanacor, Gloria Galvis, Nancy Wilson, Corbie Wilson, Brenda Rojas, John Rojas, Catherine Markert, John Rollins, Sheila Eldridge, Daniel Eldridge, Esther Angerbrandt, Sharyn E. Scalese, Joyce Young, David Young, Stephanie Cofer, Barry Cofer, Kimberly LaFleur, Mary Nealy, Brenda Gilbert, Jennifer Gibbs, Jeremy Gibbs, Deborah Cloherty, Alan Cloherty, Susan Griffin, Theresa Riley, Glenda Crockett, Rickey Crockett, Frances Ciccotto, Joseph Ciccotto, Patricia Bantel, Lisa Hoefer, Diane Bourque, Donald Bourque, Amber Kilroy, Gail Maxson, Ronald Maxson, Maureen Brandt, Denise Papendik, Charles Papendik, Geraldine Pohs, Desiree Bruce, Candace Ricketts, Janet Phillips, Ronald Phillips, Phyllis Thackrah, Anita Kallus, Lawrence Kallus, Donette Vincent, Ellen Mister, Roger Mister, Ann Gaulke, Greg Gaulke, Kim Copper, Dourell Donovan, Vern Donovan, Joyce Sullivan, Charles Sullivan, Esther Quinones, Adalberto Cruz, Rickie Simpson, Charles Simpson, Patsy Crumpton, Holly Bardsley, David Bardsley, Lesley Beed, Kelli Jones, Michael Jones, Stephanie Sherrill, Sylvia Ann Schladweiler, Henry Frank Schladweiler, Cynthia Gower, Wayne Gower, Vicki Detwiler, Theresa Allen, Colleen Larreau, Todd Larreau, Debra Nutter, Stacy Nichols, James Nichols, Michelle Himes, Barbara Gosman, Rochelle Quintoa, Maria Razo, Helen Shuey, Michael Shuey, Debra McGowan, Deborah Rich, Jennice Blankenship, Elizabeth Browne, Barbara Loyed, Melissa Escobar, Jose Luis Escobar, Rita Corbitt, Marvin Eddie Corbitt, Annette Craddock, Roger Craddock, Carol Macefield, Louise Brandenburg, Henry Brandenburg, Jackie Lee, Jean D. Johansen, Kris W. Johansen, Alicia T. Boyce, Rex A. Boyce, Hilda Acosta, Pablo Rodrigo Acosta, Anne Biggers Ellington, Carl M. Ellington, Kelly Muncy, John Muncy, Angela Smallin, Karl Ekes, Susan Murray, Carl Murray, Esmerelda Trevino, Ruben Trevino, Frances McCeldry, Jaime Corbett, John Corbett, Susan Robbins, Mark Robbins & Mary Bolen, Plaintiffs, represented by Sean Patrick Tracey , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM & Shawn P. Fox , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM.

Larry Dillon, Wanda Jacob, Nicole Warren, Debra L. Burlton, Andrew J. Burlton, Joyce Moore-Leggett, Cindy Harrell, Felicia Cooley, Johnna R. Rogers, William S. Rogers, Mitzi Shedd, Rodney Shedd, Cheryl Machia, Ronald Machia, Delores Buford, Cedrick Buford, Pamela Weber, James Weber, Phyllis A. Grant, Joe A. Grant, Faye Theriot, Angela Anderson, Betty Brewer, Lucia Alfaro, Connie Sutter, Peggy Thierry, Thelma Carlson & Derrick Carlson, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Peggy D. McCloud, Plaintiff, represented by Andrea Little Gentle , DANIELS & GENTLE & Douglas A. Daniels , DANIELS & GENTLE.

Stephen Clark & David Hening, Plaintiffs, represented by Mark R. Mueller , MUELLER LAW, pro hac vice.

Edward Sanders, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Amy Eskin , LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS, pro hac vice & Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, pro hac vice.

Anna Mary Perez, Plaintiff, represented by Kay L. Van Wey , VAN WEY LAW.

Linda M. Griffith, Plaintiff, represented by Donald Douglas Grubbs , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM, Douglas C. Monsour , THE MONSOUR LAW FIRM, James D. Barger , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Katharine Gale Krottinger , THE MONSOUR LAW FIRM.

Eileen Yeager, Plaintiff, represented by Mikal C. Watts , WATTS GUERRA CRAFT, Paige Nicole Boldt , WATTS GUERRA & Ryan L. Thompson , WATTS GUERRA CRAFT.

Elva Elizondo, an individual, Plaintiff, represented by Amy Fisch Solomon , GIRARDI KEESE, Bartholomew J. Dalton , DALTON & ASSOCIATES, Laura J. Simon , DALTON & ASSOCIATES & Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE.

Rachel Marshall, Plaintiff, represented by Donald Douglas Grubbs , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM, Douglas C. Monsour , THE MONSOUR LAW FIRM & James D. Barger , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Ruth Clement, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, represented by Stephen Dennis Behnke , WRIGHT & SCHULTE, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, Ben E. Stewart , BRYANT LAW CENTER, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, David G. Bryant , SALES TILLMAN WALLBAUM CATLETT & SATTERLEY, Emily Ward Roark , BRYANT LAW CENTER & Kenneth L. Sales , BUBALO GOODE SALES & CRONEN.

Daphne A. Collins & Denesa L. Segrest, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Donald Douglas Grubbs , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM, Douglas C. Monsour , THE MONSOUR LAW FIRM & James D. Barger , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

James Ellis, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Donald Douglas Grubbs , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM, Douglas C. Monsour , THE MONSOUR LAW FIRM, James D. Barger , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Thomas O. Plouff , COSTELLO MCMAHON BURKE & MURPHY.

Dorothy Fine, Deborah Williams & Wick Williams, Plaintiffs, represented by John W. Pate , HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON & C. Andrew Childers , CHILDERS SCHLUETER & SMITH.

Sandra Hicks, John Hicks, Jeri Orr, Matt Orr, Marietta Eway, Jeanette Hemphill, Jon Hemphill, Pamela Heidinger, Lance Heidinger, Brenda Back, Clifford Back, Cheryl Barber, Spurgeon Barber, III, Tamara Potter, Debora Gordon, Carolyn Gouge, Charles Gouge, Sharon Hunnicutt, Cherie Rogillio, Georgena Beamon, Tracy Beamon, Dennis Katz, Donna Katz, Christine Homer, Don Homer, Louise Maldonado, Gayla Roberson, John Roberson, Joyce Aguirre, Kenneth Aguirre, Kimberly Willms, Deloris Butler, Dewey Butler, Donna Van Wettering, Henry Van Wettering, Lois Adams, Nora Castro, Albert Castro, Margaret Jackson, Wayne Jackson, Dawn Watts, Gary Watts, Amy Wells, Cindy A. Bunn, Shawn Bunn, Cynthia Gardner, Robert Gardner, Sharrie Morris, Craig Heffelfinger, Amanda Roos, Brent Roos, Laura Ojeda-Dellutri, Schon Ojeda, Bette Jo Lawson, Patrick Lawson, Sherrie Monticello, Richard Monticello, Joan Kay Stevens, Philip Aubrey Stevens, Pamela Dumas, Patrick Dumas, Josephine Schibilia, Grant Schibilia, Catherine Hunt, Jeffrey Hunt, Cathy Walker, Hampton Mills-White, James White, Cheryl Baker, Moze Zell Boone, Sr., Susan Kasmauski, Stanley Kasmauski, Alexius Sacaloff, Alex Sacaloff, Imogene Brandenburg, Vinita Loftis, Jo Ann Lindenlaub, Yvonna Khuri, Rita Miller, LeRoy Kane, Sr., Irene Guzman, Theresa Green, Karen Tenschert, Joseph Tenschert, Angela Gentile, Kristina Smith-Becker, Wesley Becker, Marjorie Ledford, Jerry Ledford, Lisa Forcier, Rose Callaway, Tim Callaway, Emma Marquez, Michele Lloyd, Debra Moe, Gregory Moe, Wilma Shannon, Patricia Hewins, Glenn Hewins, Diana Westbrook, Ernestine Church, Eugene Church, Matthew Richardson, Darlene Ackley, Gerald Ackley, Francis Moss, Bernadine Host, Leon Host, Carol DeJarlais, Jamie Yarberry, Jason Yarberry, Charles R. Stoneman, Connie Stoneman, Karel Steil, Thomas Steil, Megan Steinbach, Phillip R. Erke, Tina Brooks, Crecencia Peal, Michael J. Peal, Sheila Bowman, Patrick M. Bowman, Estella Horton, Amy Hall, Maria Rosales, Michelle Mizell & Ae Sook Matsuoka, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Alma Tean Rainey & Tim Nelson, Plaintiffs, represented by Jason Nabors , LANGSTON & LANGSTON, Rebecca M. Langston , LANGSTON & LANGSTON & Shane F. Langston , LANGSTON & LANGSTON.

Vernone Rainey, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Christopher T. Kirchmer , PROVOST UMPHREY LAW FIRM, Jason Nabors , LANGSTON & LANGSTON & Rebecca M. Langston , LANGSTON & LANGSTON.

Lashunda Mitchell & Bonnie C. Curtis, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee A. Cirsch , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Dianne M. Nast , NASTLAW & Daniel N. Gallucci , NASTLAW.

Candy L. Callaghan & Thomas Callaghan, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrew J. Cross , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, pro hac vice & Jeffrey J. Lowe , CAREY DANIS & LOWE.

Amy Smith, an individual, Plaintiff, represented by Bartholomew J. Dalton , DALTON & ASSOCIATES & Laura J. Simon , DALTON & ASSOCIATES.

Lance Grundl, Arlene Bair, Arlene Blair, Mary E. Grimes, Camilla F. Smith, Annette Milton, Aliza Albritton, Elsa I. Jaime & Russell J. Middlemist, Plaintiffs, represented by Andy Dow Birchfield, Jr. , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, P. Leigh O'Dell , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES & Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES.

Janeen Bond, Matthew Bond, Theresa Trojan & Justin Trojan, Plaintiffs, represented by Carmaletta L. Henson , HENSON & FUERST & Christin DiMartino , THE WALTERS LAW FIRM.

Mary M. Busse, Darlene Rogers, Robert Rogers & Robert H. King, Plaintiffs, represented by G. Sean Jez , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ & Rand Patrick Nolen , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Kimberly LaRosa, Frank LaRosa, Mona Kimmelman & Lisa Temple, Plaintiffs, represented by Joseph A. Osborne, Jr. , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LE CLAINCHE.

Ruby Villarreal, Josefina Hernandez & Michael Hernandez, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Heather Kent , GIRARDI KEESE.

Diane Hicks, Ida Williams, Jerri Case & Richard Case, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert E. Price , LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL RAFFERTY & PROCTOR.

Ricky Winston, Melissa Copeland-Bowman, Billy Bowman, Robert Farmer, Jr., Ryan Davis, Susan C. Hewett, Thomas Dixon, Jr., John Rudy Lopez, Sr., Lucia M. Ferrer, Rene Ferrer, Linda Faye Ratliff-Newman, Charles Newman, Cassandra Sutton, also known as Cassandra McPherson, Timothy Marich, Mary Catherine Kasal, Roger Kasal, Resa R. Daniel, Jeffrey Sarrow & Antonio Diaz, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrew Judson Hill, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Gary B. Blasingame , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, James B. Matthews, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY & Josh B. Wages , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice.

Catherine Hoffman, George Hoffman, Carolyne McCall, Melissa Rodriguez, Elias Rodriquez, Patricia Macumber, Harold Macumber, Glenda Packett, William Packett, Nakia Natali, Marcella Covarrubias, Antonio Covarrubias, Maria de Lourdes DeLeon & Lisa Morton, Plaintiffs, represented by G. Sean Jez , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

David Moran, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Jason Nabors , LANGSTON & LANGSTON & Rebecca M. Langston , LANGSTON & LANGSTON.

Sandra Ameen, Plaintiff, represented by Adam J. Blake , PERDUE & KIDD, Donald H. Kidd , PERDUE & KIDD & G. Sean Jez , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Stephen Ameen, Julia Tyler, Jan Tyler, Peggy Hermann, Shawn Hermann & Mary Almaraz, Plaintiffs, represented by W. Lewis Garrison, Jr. , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS, William L. Bross , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS & G. Sean Jez , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Sherry Jo Brown, Nancy Juanita Whitaker, Nancy June Whitaker, Michelle Meinhold, Nathan Frederick Mautz, Nancy J. Filbert, Dawn Andrea McAllister, Toni Kay Noblitt, Samantha Diane Johnson, Amy Briggs Sullivan, Michele Lynn Hanson, Lucy Maldonado, Belinda Miller, Elizabeth C. Olivo, Elizabeth K. Alo, Carol Lambert, Julia Helen Bassett, Rita M. Millenbine & Onel E. Millenbine, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Julie Sadowski, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Leslie C. MacLean , WATERS & KRAUS.

Joseph Sadowski, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Stephen J. Litchfield , BERRIGAN LITCHFIELD SCHONEKAS MANN & TRAINA.

Bobbie G. Strickland, Plaintiff, represented by Don K. Ledgard , CAPRETZ & ASSOCIATES, Amy Collignon Gunn , THE SIMON LAW FIRM, Frank Jacob D'Amico, Jr. , LAW OFFICES OF FRANK J. D'AMICO, JR. & Jeffrey A. Mitchell , THE MITCHELL FIRM.

Barbara S. Tripp, James J. Tripp, Sr., Judy C. Rowland, Jessie D. Rowland, Jacolyn F. Mally-Rupe, Steven Rupe, Sr., Beverly S. Parsons, Bennie Parsons, Ruth E. Wisecarver, Betty Turner, Patricia McNew, Suzanne Neary, Margaret Gorum, Joseph Gorum, Terri Brzazowsky, Todd Brzazowsky, Cynthia McLaughlin & Dawn Bigelow, Plaintiffs, represented by Mark W. Davis , DAVIS & CRUMP.

Terry A. Morrill, Plaintiff, represented by Alfred T. Catalfo, III , CATALFO LAW.

Gerald S. Morrill, Plaintiff, represented by Jeff S. Gibson , COHEN & MALAD.

Christy Sabotnik, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, John Raymond Wrona , GARDINER KOCH WEISBERG & WRONA, Micah Jon Hughes , GARDINER KOCH WEISBERG & WRONA, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas G. Gardiner , GARDINER KOCH WEISBERG & WRONA.

Tamera Stewart, Plaintiff, represented by Laurel Simes , LEVIN SIMES, Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, pro hac vice & William Levin , LEVIN SIMES.

Heather Sherrod, Valorie Quick, Michael Quick & Tammye Holloway, Plaintiffs, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Susan Harmon & Larry Harmon, Plaintiffs, represented by Lawrence L. Jones, II , JONES WARD & Thomas Richard Anapol , ANAPOL WEISS.

Dana L. Smith, Larry E. Smith, Sr., Shaun Sutton, Jean A. DaSilva, Carlos H. DaSilva & Martha A. Rainey-Burchfield, Plaintiffs, represented by Wendy R. Fleishman , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN & Andrea Little Gentle , DANIELS & GENTLE.

Shannon Gomez, Plaintiff, represented by Valerie Ann Conzo , SHELDON J. SCHLESINGER.

Frances Miller, Plaintiff, represented by Michael S. Krzak , CLIFFORD LAW OFFICES & Shannon Marie McNulty , CLIFFORD LAW OFFICES.

Dale Miller, Ewa Liszka & Wojciech Liszka, Plaintiffs, represented by Nolan Edward Awbrey , RILEY JACKSON & Waldon Michael Hingle , MICHAEL HINGLE & ASSOCIATES.

Teresa Wood, Plaintiff, represented by Gregory D. Bentley , ZONIES LAW & Joseph J. Zonies , ZONIES LAW.

William Wood, Angie Ratajczak, Daniel Ratajczak & Rebecca A. Mathews, Plaintiffs, represented by Matthew John Morrison , HARRISON DAVIS STEAKLEY MORRISON & Joseph J. Zonies , ZONIES LAW.

Allen Henry Cox & Dorothy Cox, Plaintiffs, represented by George M. Fleming , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, Lee Lawrence Coleman , HUGHES & COLEMAN, G. Sean Jez , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ & Rand Patrick Nolen , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Jennifer M. Bartee & Richard Bartee, Plaintiffs, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Kay Baker, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Leah Mason , EDELMAN & THOMPSON, Melissa L. Steed , EDELMAN & THOMPSON, Ronald L. Edelman , EDELMAN & THOMPSON & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

William Baker & Sarah Hatchel, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Leah Mason , EDELMAN & THOMPSON & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

William Baker, Plaintiff, pro se.

Sarah Hatchel, Plaintiff, pro se.

Judy A. Belk, Charles S. Belk, Angela Ward, Cathleen Collins, Robin Hamling, Daniel Hamling, Eddie Stark, Cruz Ybarra, Timothy Metcalf & Brenda L. Rogers, Plaintiffs, represented by Andy Dow Birchfield, Jr. , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, P. Leigh O'Dell , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES & Yvonne M. Flaherty , LOCKRIDGE GRINDAL NAUEN.

Michelle Young, Administrator, Ellen Anderson, Regina Gardner, Kenneth Hanks, Fred Cooper, Jr., Susan Finkey, Wendy Shoop, Rick Shoop, Nicole Rodriguez, Douglas Dykstra, Sean Gwynn & Connie Bigelow, Plaintiffs, represented by Aimee H. Wagstaff , ANDRUS & WAGSTAFF, Marc D. Grossman , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN & Randi Kassan , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN.

Velma Archuleta, Plaintiff, represented by Aimee H. Wagstaff , ANDRUS & WAGSTAFF.

Billy W. Williams, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin A. Gastel , BRANSTETTER STRANCH & JENNINGS & Christopher W. Cantrell , DOYLE LOWTHER.

Betty Jean Moore & Hilton Friedman, Plaintiffs, represented by Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Kathy Zamecki, Plaintiff, represented by A. Craig Eiland , THE LAW OFFICES OF A. CRAIG EILAND & Bret Daniel Stanley , THE LAW OFFICES OF A. CRAIG EILAND.

Walter Zamecki, Carol Degrasso, Fred Degrasso, Kerry Arnold, Deborah Rodriguez, Joe Rodriguez, Donna Allen, Kurt Allen, Debra Garner, Priscilla Hufnagel, Brenda Lancaster, Yolanda Ballesteros, Jose Ballesteros, Merrily Carey, Robert Carey, Christine Stricklin, Shella J. Wilkinson, Lee Worswick, Thomas Worswick, Kathy Zerby, Leslie Gould, Craig Gould, Antonio Cuffaro, Gillian Cuffaro & Leona Poe, Plaintiffs, represented by James A. McKowen , JAMES F. HUMPHREYS & ASSOCIATES & Clint E. McGuire , THE LAW FIRM OF ALTON C. TODD.

Gregory Van, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph A. Osborne, Jr. , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LE CLAINCHE & Thomas Richard Anapol , ANAPOL WEISS.

Daniel Gallagher, Plaintiff, represented by Brian A. Goldstein , CELLINO & BARNES.

Ellison L. Reed, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Lisa Baron Blue , BARON & BLUE & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Mitzi Nelson, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher T. Kirchmer , PROVOST UMPHREY LAW FIRM, Shane F. Langston , LANGSTON & LANGSTON, Jason Nabors , LANGSTON & LANGSTON & Rebecca M. Langston , LANGSTON & LANGSTON.

Megan Haun, James Haun & Martha Cole, Plaintiffs, represented by Jacob Plattenberger , TOR HOERMAN LAW, Raymond Joseph Kramer , TORHOERMAN LAW & Tor A. Hoerman , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

John Deltenre, Evelyn Johnson & Fonzell Johnson, Plaintiffs, represented by Ashley M. Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, Bonnie Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, David Lee Augustus , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM & Dawn R. Meade , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM.

Laurie Connelly & Padaric Connelly, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert J. Evola , SL CHAPMAN & Casey A. Kaufman , THE BRANDI LAW FIRM.

Stacy Smith, Rachel Ann Lolley, Lois Torbush & Carmelo Montalvo Perez, Plaintiffs, represented by Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, pro hac vice.

Margaret Murchison & Martha Boren, Plaintiffs, represented by Douglas C. Monsour , THE MONSOUR LAW FIRM & Thomas O. Plouff , COSTELLO MCMAHON BURKE & MURPHY.

Virginia Davenport, Daisy Ward-Roman, John Roman, Jennifer M. Bell, Sean Bell, Dalena White, Joy Perry, Ronald Perry, Stella Johnson, Paula Benjamin, Robert Benjamin, Sharon K. Banks, John Gaffney, Jr., Norma Holland, Rosa A. Cordova, Maria V. Urias, Santiago Urias, Bettye V. Hogan, Eddie M. Hogan, Meredith C. Brinkley, Melody K. Hankins-Rhyne, Arlene M. Condelario, Ronald L. Condelario, Anna Sumberlin, Emery Sumberlin, Jr., Catherine Chevalier-Thompson, Gidget L. Crossett, Andrew J. Crossett, Diane M. Lucciarini, Beverley E. Colson, Opal L. Ellis, Wanda M. Ashley, Wesley G. Ashley, Kali D. Dobbins, Betty Webb, Christina F. Cosetti, Eric Cosetti, Marsha Humphrey, Ricky Humphrey, Carolyn S. Jordan, Herlinda A. Villabisencio, Santiago Villabisencio, LaDonna E. Williams, Dale F. Williams, Arlene J. Rose, Gerald Rex Rose, Yolanda J. Waynauskas, Yolanda Waynauskas, Kenneth Waynauskas, Emma L. Hull, Maria Ledesma, Maxie Stapleton, Linda Glasser, Russell Glasser, Maria Robles, Lisa Carlyle, Jeanette Hernandez, Hilda Munoz, Guillermo Munoz, Cindy L. Davison, Gladys Lopez, John Phares, Linda Phares, Adriana E. Ayala, Rosa Olivares, Rene M. Holmes, Melissa Kopfman, Melanie J. Sterling, Steve W. Sterling, Linda Gaspar & Laura Lee, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Charles W. Harkcom, Plaintiff, represented by Don K. Ledgard , CAPRETZ & ASSOCIATES, Amy Collignon Gunn , THE SIMON LAW FIRM, John G. Simon , THE SIMON LAW FIRM & Frank Jacob D'Amico, Jr. , LAW OFFICES OF FRANK J. D'AMICO, JR.

Tina Renee Fletcher, Plaintiff, represented by Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly E. Reardon , THE REARDON LAW FIRM, pro hac vice, Peyton P. Murphy , MURPHY LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Fred Allen Fletcher, Plaintiff, represented by Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly E. Reardon , THE REARDON LAW FIRM, pro hac vice, Doralee Idleman Chandler , MATTHEWS SANDERS & SAYES & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Linda F. Brown, Lisa K. Buckner, Bobby Joe Buckner, Melissa A. Ingram, Nathaniel Ingram, David MacDonald, Lynne H. Gulitz, Donna L. Smith, Donanne Swartz, Sharon L. Ulam, Robert Ulam, Teresa B. Westphal & Milton Westphal, Plaintiffs, represented by Jayne Conroy , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, John J. Foley , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, Paul Hanly , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY & Trent B. Miracle , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Shirley Stack, individually and on behalf of Shirley Stack & Joseph Stack, her husband, Plaintiffs, represented by Everette S. Verhine , VERHINE & VERHINE & John D. Sileo , THE LAW OFFICE OF JOHN D. SILEO.

Laura Boone, Herman Boone, Erica Peoples, Patrice Crook & Donald Crook, Plaintiffs, represented by John D. Ray , FABIAN & CLENDENIN.

Ellen Smith Perricci & Michael Anthony Perricci, Plaintiffs, represented by James F. Green , ASHCRAFT & GEREL & Michelle A. Parfitt , ASHCRAFT & GEREL.

Michelle Amen & Vincent Carl Maniaci, Plaintiffs, represented by Mark E. Burton, Jr. , HERSH & HERSH, pro hac vice & William M. Audet , AUDET & PARTNERS.

Paul Martin, Nelson Lau-Jaen, Ted Miller & Katie Childress, Plaintiffs, represented by John Fabry , MUELLER LAW & Mark R. Mueller , MUELLER LAW, pro hac vice.

Martha Wesley, Annemarie Tuffner, Nancy L. Lockridge, Diana Nimmo, Andrew Nimmo, Tina Buskirk, Linda Berryhill, Rawleigh Berryhill, Heather Slater, Charles Slater & Dorothy Escobedo, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Thomas R. Kline , KLINE & SPECTER.

Dorothy M. Hickey, Paul B. Hickey, Beverly J. Martin, Ralph E. Martin, Sheila Ruf & Gary Ruf, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey S. Grand , BERNSTEIN LIEBHARD.

Billie Rice, Barclay Rice, Russell Leaf, Scott Graves, Shelia D. Woods, Charles Woods & Mary Phyllis Latassa, Plaintiffs, represented by James T. Capretz , CAPRETZ & ASSOCIATES.

Melinda K. Spencer, Michelle R. Carvell, Amy Ann Cook, Rosemarie Stormant, Peggy L. Young, Wendy Free, Sabina Dominguez, Sharon R. Overton, Laura Reese, Jennifer D. Dean, Christina L. Jones & Olga V. Wilson, Plaintiffs, represented by Kevin M. Fitzgerald , LEWIS SAUL & ASSOCIATES & Alexandra V. Boone , MILLER WEISBROD.

Melinda K. Spencer, Plaintiff, pro se.

Valerie G. Whelton & Tori Whelton, Plaintiffs, represented by Jayne Conroy , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, John J. Foley , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, Paul Hanly , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Trent B. Miracle , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Amy C. Sandulli, Matthew Sandulli, Elena Y. Ivanenko & Leonid Ivanenko, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrea Solomon Hirsch , HERMAN GEREL, James F. Green , ASHCRAFT & GEREL, Joseph A. Kott , HERMAN HERMAN & KATZ & Michelle A. Parfitt , ASHCRAFT & GEREL.

Michelle R. Carvell, Plaintiff, pro se.

Donna St. Amour, Ida I. Lawson, Frances DeArman & Susan Biddle, Plaintiffs, represented by Charles H. Johnson , LAW OFFICES OF CHARLES H. JOHNSON & Jonathan R. Mencel , LAW OFFICES OF CHARLES H. JOHNSON.

Howard Ray Smith, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Andrew Judson Hill, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Gary B. Blasingame , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, James B. Matthews, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Josh B. Wages , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & W. Todd Harvey , BURKE HARVEY.

Rafael Romo, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Donald Eric Lawson .

Bridget R. Hamby, Plaintiff, represented by Chaim Shaun Setareh , SETAREH LAW GROUP, Helen Zukin , KEISEL & LARSON & Paul Kiesel , KIESEL & LARSON.

Bobbie Richardson, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph H. Saunders , SAUNDERS & WALKER.

Linda Poirier & Richard Poirier, Plaintiffs, represented by William L. Bross , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS & G. Sean Jez , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Ollie Mannino & Carl Thomas Mannino, Plaintiffs, represented by Pauline Toboulidis , LOPEZ MCHUGH & Regina S. Johnson , LOPEZ MCHUGH.

Hannah Guzman, Plaintiff, represented by J. Thomas Rhodes, III , TOM RHODES LAW FIRM, Laura Reeves Pazin Porter , TOM RHODES LAW FIRM, Paige Nicole Boldt , WATTS GUERRA, Taylor Lauren Brzezinski , TOM RHODES LAW FIRM & Wayne L. Colodny , TOM RHODES LAW FIRM.

Daniel Guzman, Loretta Padilla, Leroy Padilla, Ivory I. Watson & Amparo Garcia, Plaintiffs, represented by Don Gamble , GORDON LAW FIRM, Jeffrey G. Blackwell , BLACKWELL LAW FIRM, Paige Nicole Boldt , WATTS GUERRA, Blair Bertram Matyszczyk , BERTRAM & GRAF & J. Thomas Rhodes, III , TOM RHODES LAW FIRM.

Iman Guirguis & Hani Guirguis, Plaintiffs, represented by Peyton P. Murphy , MURPHY LAW FIRM & Ashley White Creech , MCGOWAN HOOD & FELDER.

Karen Whiles, Plaintiff, represented by Douglas F. Welebir , WELEBIR TIERNEY & WECK.

Bob Whiles, Plaintiff, represented by Laura Reeves Pazin Porter , TOM RHODES LAW FIRM.

Angelina Freire, Judith Hill & Christopher Hill, Plaintiffs, represented by Bradley Z. Schulman , MOTHERWAY & NAPLETON.

Wilson Freire, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Patrick Barton , BARTON LAW FIRM.

Bobbie Lamaack, Plaintiff, represented by Mark T. Sadaka , SADAKA ASSOCIATES.

Kathryn A. Wilhelm & Leonard Wilhelm, Plaintiffs, represented by Harry James Forrest , GROSS SHUMAN BRIZDLE & GILFILLAN.

Tammy Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Sean Patrick Tracey , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM, Shawn P. Fox , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM, Brent J. McIntosh , BILBO LAW OFFICE & Daniel William Clanton , BILBO LAW OFFICE.

Gayle Johnson, Maria Smith, Melda Taylor, Karen Tharp & Jennifer Collins-Fleming, Plaintiffs, represented by Stacy L. Kelly , TERRY BRYANT, Tommy Wilbourn Gillaspie , TERRY BRYANT & Virginia Anello , DOUGLAS & LONDON.

Natercia Amaya, Meaghan Lenhauser, Tony Lenhauser & Janelle Caracci-Siddons, Plaintiffs, represented by Paige Nicole Boldt , WATTS GUERRA & Ryan L. Thompson , WATTS GUERRA CRAFT.

Amy Ann Cook, Plaintiff, pro se.

Gregory Jackson, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Juanita Hayworth, Albert Hayworth, Jackie Guenther, Dennis Guenther, Beverly Gallimore, Verna Martin, Jacqueline Sargent & Michael Sargent, Plaintiffs, represented by Leslie C. MacLean , WATERS & KRAUS, pro hac vice & Theodore Oshman , OSHMAN & MIRISOLA.

James D. Fields & Ricardo Garza, Plaintiffs, represented by Thomas W. Pirtle , LAMINACK PIRTLE & MARTINES, Anne M. Tarvin , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA & Kevin L. Chaffee , GOZA & HONNOLD.

Karianne Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Jerrold S. Parker , PARKER WAICHMAN, Melanie H. Muhlstock , PARKER WAICHMAN & Raymond C. Silverman , PARKER WAICHMAN.

Amy Eng & Joyce Price, Plaintiffs, represented by John M. Black , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK.

Bonnie J. Conklin, Douglas Conklin & Mitzi G. Hanes, Plaintiffs, represented by Douglas F. Welebir , WELEBIR TIERNEY & WECK & Aaron Clark Johnson , SUMMERS & JOHNSON.

Pat Bard, Plaintiff, represented by Douglas D. Small , FOLEY & SMALL.

Pamela Sue Dowdell, Cynthia Stewart, Melanie Schrebvogel, Marilee F. Schaller, Kevin Schaller & Beverly A. Moran, Plaintiffs, represented by Jon C. Conlin , CORY WATSON & Stephen R. Hunt, Jr. , CORY WATSON.

Donna Cutshaw, Cathy Shadwick & Reginald Shadwick, Plaintiffs, represented by K. Camp Bailey , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY & T. Scott Allen, Jr. , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY.

Susan Evert, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Braulia Echeverria, Jorge Trevino, Agustin Ramirez, Della Massey, David Rocha, Petra Vasquez, Gonzalo Vasquez, Robin Orefice, Michael Orefice, Ana Segovia, Mario Medrano, Diana Gutierrez, also known as Diana Gonzalez-Gutierrez, Maria Candida-Diaz, Edgar Lopez, Teodora Rojas, Domingo Rojas, Kara Wheeler, Maria Maldonado, Juan Maldonado, Diana Rodriguez, Roseudo Rodriguez & Rita Ramirez, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael A. Stratton , STRATTON FAXON TRIAL LAWYERS.

Janice Flannagan, Plaintiff, represented by David F. Miceli , SIMMONS BROWDER GIANARIS ANGELIDES & BARNERD & John J. Foley , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Jeffrey Flannagan, Plaintiff, represented by Stephen B. Murray, Sr. , MURRAY LAW FIRM & John J. Foley , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Donna R. Waugh, Tom E. Johnson, Michelle McLaughlin Cherland, Rodney Cherland, Ana B. Vallejo-Tirado & Robert Tirado, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert Jay Goldman , FINKELSTEIN & GOLDMAN, Donald S. Edgar , SMITH DOLLAR & Donte' O. Mills , MILLS EDWARDS PARIS & CHAIKIN.

Connie Remick, Plaintiff, represented by Robert Jay Goldman , FINKELSTEIN & GOLDMAN & Donte' O. Mills , MILLS EDWARDS PARIS & CHAIKIN.

Diane Thomas-Lanska, Plaintiff, represented by Peter de la Cerda , EDWARDS & DE LA CERDA & Stewart R. Albertson , ALBERTSON & DAVIDSON.

Michael J. Lanska, Plaintiff, represented by Peter de la Cerda , EDWARDS & DE LA CERDA & Richard A. Capshaw , CAPSHAW & ASSOCIATES.

Clara Smith, Michael Smith, Sr., Anna Jo Ewing, Todd H. Ewing & LeeAnn Hudson, Plaintiffs, represented by Karren Schaeffer , ANDREWS & THORNTON, pro hac vice, Cecilia Han , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, Sarah R. London , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, Mark Abramowitz , DICELLO LEVITT GUTZLER & Adam D. Peavy , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY.

Gladys Martinez, Plaintiff, represented by Alyson Oliver , OLIVER LAW GROUP.

Evelyn Holley, deceased, Plaintiff, represented by Todd E. Hilton , STUEVE SIEGEL HANSON, Stacey K. Skillman , BRANSTETTER STRANCH & JENNINGS & Merritt E. Cunningham , SMITH STAG.

Jaime Corniel, Sebastian Corniel, Lois Burrell, Kenny Burrell, Terry Stichter, Frankie Arthur, Juan Cortez, Diane Gustin, Vaughn Gustin, Kathleen Thorvaldson, John Thorvaldson, Corinna Hulse, Jeffery Hulse, Deloris Groth, Robert Groth, Diana Peyovich, Michelle Mulvehill, Leah Edman & Jonathan Edman, Plaintiffs, represented by David F. Miceli , SIMMONS BROWDER GIANARIS ANGELIDES & BARNERD & Angel L. Reyes, III , REYES BROWNE REILLEY.

Michael Duffy, Plaintiff, represented by Rand Patrick Nolen , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Pauline Wyche & Eileen Wilcox, Plaintiffs, represented by Clay Robbins, III , MAGANA CATHCART & MCCARTHY & John F. Baker , MAGANA CATHCART & MCCARTHY.

Nipie E. Whatley, Plaintiff, pro se.

Lisa Morgan, Plaintiff, pro se.

Tammy Madison, Gregg Madison, Shirley Ross, Samuel Ross, Sr. & Ronald Borden, Plaintiffs, represented by Erin K. Copeland , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON.

Rosalie Jensen, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Bland Patrick , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES.

Rosemarie Stormant, Plaintiff, pro se.

Kathleen Stinson, Plaintiff, represented by Carasusana B. Wall , ZOLL KRANZ & BORGESS.

Kurt Stinson, Alta Juanita Carpenter & Gary Carpenter, Plaintiffs, represented by Jacqueline Anne Olson , ZIMMERMAN REED.

Maria Pazos & Ramon Pazos, Plaintiffs, represented by T. Ernest Freeman , THE FREEMAN LAW FIRM.

Aron Oseguera, Plaintiff, represented by Richard Alan Gurfein , GURFEIN DOUGLAS.

Deborah Contestabile, Plaintiff, represented by Jacqueline Anne Olson , ZIMMERMAN REED & Hadley L. Matarazzo , FARACI LANGE.

Kevin Contestabile, Plaintiff, represented by Jacqueline Anne Olson , ZIMMERMAN REED & Louis Koory , MISSION LAW CENTER.

Judith Reiner, Donald Reiner, II, Charlotte Thomas, Maurice Thomas, Lorie Shreve & Asa Shreve, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael J. Miller , THE MILLER FIRM.

Abdelhamid Elmissiry, Pamela Lujan & JoAnn Lloyd, Plaintiffs, represented by Taylor Lauren Brzezinski , TOM RHODES LAW FIRM & Wayne L. Colodny , TOM RHODES LAW FIRM.

Salvador Cortez, Tina Gregorie, Brian Gregorie, Ralph Hernandez, III, Nancy K. Walker & Timothy Pack, Plaintiffs, represented by Stephen J. Litchfield , BERRIGAN LITCHFIELD SCHONEKAS MANN & TRAINA.

Connie Gallegos, Plaintiff, represented by Anne Andrews , ANDREWS & THORNTON, Chaim Shaun Setareh , SETAREH LAW GROUP, Helen Zukin , KEISEL & LARSON & Matthew J. Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH.

Lori Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Jason T. Brown , JTB LAW GROUP & Zijian Guan , JTB LAW GROUP.

Wanda L. Valencia & William Payne, Plaintiffs, represented by Russell G. Burwell, III , BURWELL NEBOUT TRIAL LAWYERS.

Sarah E. Palazzo, Plaintiff, represented by Stuart E. Scott , SPANGENBERG SHIBLEY & LIBER.

Daniel KP. Palazzo, Plaintiff, represented by Zijian Guan , JTB LAW GROUP.

Cara Anderson & David Anderson, Plaintiffs, represented by Preston J. Dugas, III , PARKER MCDONALD.

Charlotte Ann Kinney, Plaintiff, represented by J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM.

Gerald D. Turner, Plaintiff, represented by T. Robert Hill , HILL BOREN.

Bertha E. Wages, Denver Wages & Gracie M. Messina, Plaintiffs, represented by Koren Leslie Cohen , DOUGLAS & LONDON & Jason T. Brown , JTB LAW GROUP.

Sharon Pottier, Gail McQueen, Dorothy V. Ely, Michael D. Kavanagh, Trudie Cudney, Gwendalynn Sanders, Lakita M. Hill, Lia Rigsby, Bunnie Piehowski, Janet Aherens, Margaret Gilley, Sharyl Black, Billy Clark, Frances Cross, Barbara Fantozzi-Stockton, Lori Griffith, Julie Gutierrez, Mary Hammond, Gloria Jensen, Celia Kroeger, Jacqueline Morrow, Melissa Novicki, Barbara Potkay, Maryann Pressman, Cathy Stewart, Wendy Vargas, Catherine Vernon, Dawn Vinson, Carmela Alberta, Sandra Dahl, Emma Delarosa, Roxanne Demars, Jessica Friedeborn, Louann Garcia, Ruth Green, Roas Henriquez, Michele Hinkle, Sherrell Holloway, Rose Hopper, Angel Hutton, Dorothy Johnson, Patricia McKiver, Teresa Michon, Lisa Miller Ryan, Joanne O'Toole, Goldie Prestjohn, Alma Ramirez, Peggy Reblin, Bernice Rivera, Rebecca Stanley, Mary Wood & Sandra Zale, Plaintiffs, represented by Robin M. Myers , MURRAY LAW FIRM.

Sonia Tubbergen, Ann M. Pitchford, Jennifer Stobart, David Stobart & Jeanne M. Walters, Plaintiffs, represented by Lina B. Melidonian , KABATECK BROWN KELLNER & Mark Alan Milstein , MILSTEIN ADELMAN.

Will Supplement, Plaintiff, represented by Tonya L. Melnichenko , FRANKLIN D. AZAR & ASSOCIATES.

Patricia A. Lester, Bill C. Lester, Gwendolyn C. Wright & Steven L. Wright, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas G. Wilson , WILSON LAW OFFICES.

Susan F. Case, Jon Case, Vicki Boro, Stephen Boro, Vera Miller & Dennis Miller, Plaintiffs, represented by Alex Barlow , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK.

Rosita Ledesma, Plaintiff, represented by Robert Jay Binstock , REICH & BINSTOCK.

Samuel E. Ledesma, Pamela Ann Courson, Christine Grauman & Debra Trinidad, Plaintiffs, represented by Shezad Malik , DR. SHEZAD MALIK LAW FIRM.

Kathleen Bykerk, Rebecca L. Bonacci, Eucebia Flores Cortinas & Elise Acosta, Plaintiffs, represented by Rayna Elizabeth Kessler , LOPEZ MCHUGH & Daniel A. Raniere , KELL LAMPIN.

Veronica Neaves Zamorano, Plaintiff, represented by Peter J. McNulty , MCNULTY LAW FIRM.

Melita Keeler, Plaintiff, represented by Paul L. Sadler , CARABIN & SHAW.

Karl Allen Keeler, Plaintiff, pro se.

Summer Reeves, Plaintiff, represented by Larry D. Helvey , LARRY HELVEY LAW FIRM.

Christy Borden, Plaintiff, represented by Erin K. Copeland , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON & Melissa Erin Mielke , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH.

Peggy L. Young, Plaintiff, pro se.

Wendy Free, Plaintiff, pro se.

Darrell Shaffer, Plaintiff, represented by Rodney E. Miller , MCCALLUM METHVIN & TERRELL.

Harold Kenneth Midgett, Jr., Administrator of the Estate of Harold Kenneth Midgett, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Joseph R. Johnson , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LECLAINCHE, Joseph A. Osborne, Jr. , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LE CLAINCHE, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Carol R. Midgett, Plaintiff, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Rhett A. McSweeney , MCSWEENEY LANGEVIN, Joseph A. Osborne, Jr. , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LE CLAINCHE, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Sonia Hentnik, William Hentnik, ElDenna Horton, Tommy Horton & Staci Harbert, Plaintiffs, represented by Peyton B. Burkhalter & Maurice J. Bernard, III , MAURICE J. BERNARD, III.

Rene Thibault, Plaintiff, pro se.

Susan M. Tallant, Plaintiff, represented by Beverly B. Bates , BATES & BAUM.

Perry L. Tallant, Plaintiff, pro se.

Kay Reynolds, Plaintiff, represented by Douglas G. Bellon , DALTON CHASSANOIL & BELLON & Lon L. Walters , THE WALTERS LAW FIRM.

Nancy Lee Dalrymple, Curtis Dalrymple, Rodney Day, William Roy, Donna Sims, Stephanie Crum, Glenn Crum & Maria Olivia Aguilar, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE & Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.

Vera L. Hindes, Plaintiff, represented by Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE & Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE.

Tabitha Latson, Plaintiff, represented by Larry D. Helvey , LARRY HELVEY LAW FIRM, Stephen I. Leshner , STEPHEN I. LESHNER, Christina A. Humphrey , MARLIN & SALTZMAN & Craig S. Pynes , MARLIN & SALTZMAN.

Marjorie Harkness, John Harkness, Janet M. DeRuvo, Cathy Oglesby, Christopher Oglesby, Cindy Wolinski, Gloria Whitaker-Brady, Vickie Lassan, Margaret Morrison, Theodore D. Morrison, Vickie True, Clarence Hildenbrand, Jr., Cristi Connolly, Kathy A. Shepard, Kim Plassmeyer, Michael Plassmeyer, Lisa Martinello, Frederick Martinello, Debra J. Daniels & Loretta J. Treece, Plaintiffs, represented by Joseph J. Zonies , ZONIES LAW.

Kathy S. Carter, Plaintiff, represented by David Bricker , WATERS KRAUS & PAUL, Michael L. Armitage , WATERS KRAUS & PAUL, Paul C. Cook , WATERS KRAUS & PAUL & Valex Amos, Jr. , VALEX AMOS JR. LAW OFFICE, pro hac vice.

Mr. Carter, Plaintiff, represented by Charles S. Siegel , WATERS & KRAUS, Grant Lavalle Davis , DAVIS BETHUNE & JONES, Shawn Gayland Foster , DAVIS BETHUNE & JONES & Valex Amos, Jr. , VALEX AMOS JR. LAW OFFICE, pro hac vice.

Daphne Lanise Holland, Plaintiff, pro se.

Ricky Holland, Plaintiff, pro se.

Brenda K. Chamberlain, Plaintiff, pro se.

Jodee L. McVey, Donald McVey & Fannie Oma Fisher, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert Joseph Gaudet, Jr. , RJ GAUDET & ASSOCIATES & John J. Driscoll , THE DRISCOLL FIRM.

Elsa Lehky, Plaintiff, represented by Kim Loutey , TORHOERMAN LAW, Roger Nail , GOZA & HONNOLD, Steven D. Davis , TOR HOERMAN LAW & Tyler Joseph Schneider , TORHOERMAN LAW.

Tammy E. Carter, Constance Duckworth, Brandon Duckworth, Betty Jones-Rosa, Victor M. Rosa, Dana M. Stanfield, Jessie Stanfield, Davina Spencer, Sean Curtis Spencer, Pulchara Wilkerson, James Wilkerson, Kim Reich, Diane Ritter-Gardner, Dennis Gardner, Mary Ellen Civita, Joseph Civita, Rosemary Mitchell, Maria Benedetto & Kathleen Mellow, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Tamera Williams & Michael Williams, Plaintiffs, represented by Regina S. Johnson , LOPEZ MCHUGH.

Laura Zacks, Tracy Alterio, Dennis Alterio, Albertina Esteves, Miguel Esteves, Marinet Perez, Edward Perez, Valerie Martin, Henry Martin, Lynn Mangini & Steven Mangini, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Joyce Ann Conner, Plaintiff, pro se.

Phyllis Snater, Plaintiff, pro se.

Rosaire Gauthier, Jennifer Watkins & Robert Watkins, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael L. Armitage , WATERS KRAUS & PAUL & Paul C. Cook , WATERS KRAUS & PAUL.

Isaac Matthews, Plaintiff, represented by David M. Bernard , KOSKOFF KOSKOFF & BIEDER & Mark Andrew Tate , TATE LAW GROUP.

Laura Morse-Davis, George Davis, Ruben Soto, Lisa Jane Sims, Sheila Ann Ross, Lisa Ellen Stewart, Lisa Ellen Montanus & Antonia E. Clark, Plaintiffs, represented by Lawrence J. Centola, III , MARTZELL & BICKFORD.

Ted Poole, Cornell Clay, Vickie Spencer, Willie Spencer, Brenda Farmer, Melody Hughes, Jeff Hughes, Claudette Kobelin, Stephen Kobelin & Barbara Zurmuhle, Plaintiffs, represented by Michele S. Burkholder , NASTLAW.

Brandi Montellier, Kerry Land, Dwight Land, Robin Howard & Jamie Howard, Plaintiffs, represented by Maxwell S. Kennerly , TOR HOERMAN LAW, Bill Robins, III , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK & David G. Summers , SUMMERS & JOHNSON.

Jewel Barnette & Floyd Bapp, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS.

Cecelia Barfield & Ronnie Barfield, Plaintiffs, represented by William H. Barfield , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Jeffrey S. Grand , BERNSTEIN LIEBHARD & David S. Ratner , MORELLI ALTERS RATNER.

Cindy Sanders, Gregory Sanders, Walton Stinson, Sr. & Pamela Dunn, Plaintiffs, represented by William H. Barfield , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & David S. Ratner , MORELLI ALTERS RATNER.

Sharon Rose Lawler, Dennis J. Lawler, Constance Simeon & Elmer Simeon, Plaintiffs, represented by David M. Zevan , ZEVAN & DAVIDSON LAW FIRM.

Adelaide Schaap, Plaintiff, represented by Jason K. Gamsby , FAXON LAW GROUP.

Gwendolyn C. Key, James Key, Scott Pitman, Lana Watkins, Natalie Jackson, Peggy Ann Dunn, Johnny Dunn, Brenda Cooley, Yancy M. Rodgers, Sandra Parrott, Donna Johnson, Bruce W. Johnson, Tonya Usrey, Vincenza Donato & Gertrude Nielsen, Plaintiffs, represented by Cecilia Han , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Sarah R. London , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Laura Neet, Dennis Neet, Hope Baker & Michael Baker, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Erin K. Copeland , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON.

Darryl Smith & William Ross, Sr., Plaintiffs, represented by Allan Berger , ALLAN BERGER & ASSOCIATES.

Sabina Dominguez, Plaintiff, pro se.

Brenda S. Pittman & Gary Pittman, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, Joseph M. Kar , LAW OFFICE OF JOSEPH M. KAR & Douglas William Crandall , CRANDALL LAW OFFICE, pro hac vice.

Grazyna Dworakowski, Tina Blair, Shirley Ray, Elaine Kiff, Lilly Ellis, Sylvia Moore, Louise Putorek, Michelle Taylor, Tina Dowling, Glenda Stohs, Carol Duby & Janet Lansing, Plaintiffs, represented by Thomas R. Behm , GRUEL MILLS NIMS & PYLMAN & Martha M. McBrayer , MORELLI ALTERS RATNER.

Verna K. Whenu, Plaintiff, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Michael G. Rousseau , MOTLEY RICE, Anthony M. Pezzani , ENGELMEYER & PEZZANI & Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Carol Ann Rogers, Raymond Rogers, Cathy Estes Coplen, Deborah Ann Frisbie, Katherine Bartell & Rodney B. Bartell, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael R. Hance , HANCE & SRINIVASAN.

Carol Ann Rogers, Plaintiff, pro se.

Raymond Rogers, Plaintiff, pro se.

Elizabeth Louise Damato, Michael Damato, Dalton Pugh & Sarah V. Bates, Plaintiffs, represented by Matthew J. Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, Melissa Erin Mielke , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, Howard L. Nations , THE NATIONS LAW FIRM & Steven James Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH.

Veona Ackerman, Marianne Ali, Rhonda Allen, Mary Aplaca, Vicky Arnold, Norma Atwood, Beth Ball, Shirley Ball, Pamela Bart, Eula Barton, Barbara Benigno, Samantha Beyer, Brenda Bishop, Lydia Blinkinsop, Kari Blunda, Anna Boccuti, Sharon Bortz, Gail Browalski, Machelle Buckles, Helen Burchfield, Colleen Canizares, Brenda Carter, Peggy Chafart, Vanessa Chandler, Patricia Clark, Jeannettea Coffman, Chloe Cornell, Lynn Dressler, Wynn Duffie, Judy Farris, Madeline Fatteross, Lora Featherston, Dorothy Giannaris, Cheri Gillis, Christina Gribble, Hilary Harris, Mikki Heehn, Shelly Holman, Jo Hutchinson, Wanieta Iness, Helen Jacobus, Barbara J. Jean, Edwena Kees, Janet Kelly, Patricia King, Kellie Klesel, Sharon Kowalski, Helen Lampley, Nancy Locklar, Phyllis Long, Jacqueline Lopez, Vilma Lusader, Mary Anne Martin, Terri Matney, Kerri McEntire, Brenda McNutt, Mabel Mead, Karen Minnema, Shelley Moen, Maria Montano, Judith Moss, Lori Nelson, Jennifer Palmer, Theresa Panther, Rosemary Pearce, Angela Platner, Eva Renteria, Annette Richard, Betty Rounds, Karen Sanderson, Mary Scanlon, Paula Schaefer, Eunice Scott, Barbara Smith, Christina Smith, Danielle Solorzano, Nancy Stickler, Diane Sullivan, Gloria Thwaits, Althea Truitt, Evelyn Turner, Rosemary Ventura-Parris, DeAnn Watkins, Linda West, Dena Whited, Denise Williford, Armatha Woods, Sherry Wright, Vietta Jean Dillon, Shemeka Jackson, Tonia Dyas, Willilene Sims, Sherry Hess, Sybil Phillips, Shalanda Doss, Rhonda Cobb, Zakina Henderson, Susan Wint, Rhonda Hugo, Sharon Bramlett, Stela Saenz, Rosetta Johnson, Thelma Dulin, Sheila Frere & Tena Ellis, Plaintiffs, represented by Keith M. Jensen , JENSEN & ASSOCIATES, Rhonda Baker Debevec , SPANGENBERG SHIBLEY & LIBER, William E. Cannon, III , CANNON MIHILL & WINKLES & Michael Leslie Hodges , HODGES LAW FIRM.

Regina Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Keith M. Jensen , JENSEN & ASSOCIATES, Rhonda Baker Debevec , SPANGENBERG SHIBLEY & LIBER, William E. Cannon, III , CANNON MIHILL & WINKLES, Michael Leslie Hodges , HODGES LAW FIRM, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Marianne C. LeBlanc , SUGARMAN & SUGARMAN & Riley L. Burnett, Jr. , BURNETT LAW FIRM.

Wanda Taylor, Plaintiff, represented by Keith M. Jensen , JENSEN & ASSOCIATES, Rhonda Baker Debevec , SPANGENBERG SHIBLEY & LIBER, William E. Cannon, III , CANNON MIHILL & WINKLES, Michael Leslie Hodges , HODGES LAW FIRM & Tomislav G. Antunovich , BISNAR CHASE.

Cherrie Schulte, Plaintiff, represented by Ashley Elizabeth Norman , JOHNSON VORHEES & MARTUCCI & Edward J. Hershewe , THE HERSHEWE LAW FIRM.

Scott Schulte, Plaintiff, pro se.

Scott Schulte, Plaintiff, represented by George Tharin Williamson , FARR FARR EMERICH HACKETT & CARR.

Annette Carol Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Michael P. McGartland , MCGARTLAND LAW FIRM.

Cindy Baker & Robert Baker, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeremy R. Fietz , ADAMS FIETZ & Joseph Preston Strom, Jr. , STROM LAW FIRM.

Stephanie Clarke, Plaintiff, represented by Jayne Conroy , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, John J. Foley , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY & Trent B. Miracle , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Cathy Estes Coplen, Plaintiff, pro se.

Wilma Tokarczyk, Plaintiff, represented by Marcus J. Bradley , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Sejal K. Brahmbhatt , WILLIAMS KHERKHER HART BOUNDAS, Caroline Underwood Hollingsworth , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS, W. Todd Harvey , BURKE HARVEY & Gayle L. Douglas , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS.

August Tokarczyk, Margaret Weckerly, James Weckerly & Sandra L. Moore, Plaintiffs, represented by Marcus J. Bradley , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Sejal K. Brahmbhatt , WILLIAMS KHERKHER HART BOUNDAS, Caroline Underwood Hollingsworth , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS & Gayle L. Douglas , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS.

Patricia Foltz, Plaintiff, represented by Robert E. Price , LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL RAFFERTY & PROCTOR & Emanuele Robert Cicchiello , CICCHIELLO & CICCHIELLO.

Larry D. Crouch, Jr., Plaintiff, pro se.

Larry D. Crouch, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & Andrew W. Hutton , HUTTON & HUTTON.

Sharon R. Overton, Plaintiff, pro se.

Nancy Lynn Smith-Pugh, Plaintiff, represented by Kevin M. Fitzgerald , LEWIS SAUL & ASSOCIATES, Matthew J. Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, Melissa Erin Mielke , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, Howard L. Nations , THE NATIONS LAW FIRM & Steven James Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH.

Nancy Lynn Smith-Pugh, Plaintiff, pro se.

Dalton Pugh, Plaintiff, pro se.

Saundra Brown, Norma Oubre & Catherine A Grimes, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Heather Kent , GIRARDI KEESE, Amy Fisch Solomon , GIRARDI KEESE, Joseph F. Archer , JOSEPH F. ARCHER, Rhonda Baker Debevec , SPANGENBERG SHIBLEY & LIBER, William E. Cannon, III , CANNON MIHILL & WINKLES, Mark A. Cox , LAW OFFICE OF MARK A. COX, Michael Leslie Hodges , HODGES LAW FIRM & Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE.

Saundra Brown, Plaintiff, pro se.

Dorothy Aretta Golden, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Heather Kent , GIRARDI KEESE, Amy Fisch Solomon , GIRARDI KEESE, Rhonda Baker Debevec , SPANGENBERG SHIBLEY & LIBER, William E. Cannon, III , CANNON MIHILL & WINKLES, Mark A. Cox , LAW OFFICE OF MARK A. COX, Michael Leslie Hodges , HODGES LAW FIRM & Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE.

Dorothy Aretta Golden, Plaintiff, pro se.

Norma Oubre, Plaintiff, pro se.

Catherine A Grimes, Plaintiff, pro se.

Barbara Ufland, Faye M. Alexander, Radine Burch & Roxanna McDonald, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Heather Kent , GIRARDI KEESE, Amy Fisch Solomon , GIRARDI KEESE, Mark A. Cox , LAW OFFICE OF MARK A. COX & Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE.

Barbara Ufland, Plaintiff, pro se.

Faye M. Alexander, Plaintiff, pro se.

Radine Burch, Plaintiff, pro se.

Roxanna McDonald, Plaintiff, pro se.

Priscilla O'Fiel, Olga Ibarra, Cesar Ibarra & Lorraine C. Martino, Plaintiffs, represented by Maxwell S. Kennerly , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

Cathy Schartzer, Paula Boesswetter, Donna Canfield, Dana Campbell, Arthur Campbell, Anna Fisher, Jennifer Penrose, Elizabeth Plumlee & Heather Walker, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Heather Kent , GIRARDI KEESE, Amy Fisch Solomon , GIRARDI KEESE & Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE.

Ann L. Phinney, Katherine Ware-Perosi, Raymond Perosi, Victoria Bisignano & Anthony Bisignano, Plaintiffs, represented by Doralee Idleman Chandler , MATTHEWS SANDERS & SAYES.

Patricia Galindo & Luis Galindo, Plaintiffs, represented by Benjamin A. Gastel , BRANSTETTER STRANCH & JENNINGS, Andrew J. Geiger , ALLAN BERGER & ASSOCIATES, pro hac vice & Christopher W. Cantrell , DOYLE LOWTHER.

Michael Kent Dawson, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by A. Craig Eiland , THE LAW OFFICES OF A. CRAIG EILAND, Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Bret Daniel Stanley , THE LAW OFFICES OF A. CRAIG EILAND, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE, Caroline L. Maida , MOSTYN LAW & Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.

Evalie Hunter, Plaintiff, pro se.

Linda Horton, Plaintiff, pro se.

Linda Tomlinson, John H. Tomlinson & Sherry Ashworth, Plaintiffs, represented by Garnett E. Hendrix, Jr. , FEARS NACHAWATI LAW FIRM & Matthew R. McCarley , FEARS NACHAWATI.

Estate of Sandra B. Shepherd, Deceased, by, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph B. Deacon , DEACON LAW FIRM & Whitney Deacon Lloyd , DEACON LAW FIRM.

Beth D. Davis, as Administrator of the Estate of Sandra B. Shepherd, Deceased, and on Behalf of the Wrongful Death Beneficiaries of Beth D. Davis, Plaintiff, pro se.

Beth D. Davis, as Administrator of the Estate of Sandra B. Shepherd, Deceased, and on Behalf of the Wrongful Death Beneficiaries of Beth D. Davis, Sandra B. Shepherd & Scottie M. Shepherd, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert A. Schwartz , BRENT COON & ASSOCIATES.

Sandra B. Shepherd, Plaintiff, pro se.

Scottie M. Shepherd, Plaintiff, pro se.

Linda Hammonds, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Joan M. Crandall Daugherty, Plaintiff, represented by Laurinda Lynne McDonnell , LAURINDA L. MCDONNELL.

Patrick Daugherty, Plaintiff, represented by James V. Doyle, Jr. , DOYLE LAW FIRM.

Samantha Mclean, Ricky Mclean, Sandra Galster & Gerard Galster, Plaintiffs, represented by Elise A. Waisbren , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice, Stephen D. Phillips , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice & Terrence M. Quinn , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice.

Leann Carter, Sara Fox, Gerald Fox, Reba Aman, Linda Murphy, Thomas Murphy, Tania Maestas, Toby Maestas, Joanne Armstrong, Jennifer Rogerson, Burrell Segars Rogerson, Jr., Tasha Lovejoy, Neilson Lovejoy, Joy Fryman, Timothy Fryman, Goldie Servin, Pauline Greenier, Lavelle Williams, Edgar Williams, Jacqueline Dolby, Barbara Douglas, Robert Douglas, Donna Jewell, Cynthia Johnson, Denise Gates, Terry Gates, Elizabeth Geeter, Judy Buzzell, Garry Buzzell, Christina Lowery, Patricia Trent, Brenda Carr, Bill Carr, Martha Mills, David Burckner, Cynthia Mims, Jimmie Ann Flake, Shirley Valentine, Sheri Van Hoogen, Jon Van Hoogen, Sequoya Prince, Virginia Groves, Bonni Bousman, Patricia Piehl Brown, Conrad Brown, Anna Carlo, Anthony Carlo, Anne Crockett, Joseph Crockett, Loretta Valdez, John Valdez, Dianna Rubenstahl, Catrena Holley, Scott Holley, Cheryl Robbins, Chris Robbins, Connie Hudson, Deborah Campbell, Paul Campbell, Samantha Walker, Isiac Walker, Beverly Hill, Charmaine Puttman, Richard Puttman, Betty Bennett, Patrick Bennett, Elizabeth Poole, Charles Poole, Patricia Kinsey, Travis Kinsey, Dennis Wright, Monica Wright, Gisele Michelsen, Michael Michelsen, Victoria Collins, Tina Ogle, James Ogle, Sharon Stenius, Johnnie Ferguson, Lori Deen, Kathy Hill, Daniel Hill, Petrita Reyes, Lakisha Backstrom, Adrienne Wilson, Leoma Short, Everett Short, Bambi Hayward, Danny Ray Hayward, Marjorie Elkins, Florida Casias, Joe B. Casias, Connie Jacks, Larry Jacks, Mattie Justice, Trudy Brannon, Teresa Williams, Cynthia McQuillan, Charles McQuillan, Linda Crane-Zavala, Carolyn Hawkins-Smith, Arthur Smith, Donna Erchak, David Erchak, Craig Walker, Denise Walker, Delaine Powell, Brian Powell, Debronetta McCoy, James McCoy, Linda Deitz, Harry Deitz, Mary Rebecca Jacobs, Cindy LaCounte, Dawnetta Geer, Corey Taylor, Rhonda Espeland, Minerva De Leon, Nicholas Susco, Sharon Jenkins, Lissett Vidal, Wallace De Oliviera, Janet Breault, Richard Breault, Cindy Marks, Ernest Marks, Pamela Earley, Max Earley, Cynthia Cruz, Melvin Moscat, Corinne Burnworth, Ralph Burnworth, Sr., Krystyna Orlean, Jerzy Orlean, Jane Bakerman, Debra Parkhurst, Tracey Compton, Tommie Magee, Denise Rancourt, Joseph J. Rancourt, Kathleen McKeon, Rachel Rocheleau, Rachel Hill, Johnathan Hill, Cynthia Ford, Troy Ford, Betty Altman, Wyley Altman, Danette Charnetzky, Daniel Charnetzky, Belinda Bush, Tina Cyr, Donn Cyr, Anna Spears, Andrew Spears, Lisa Marie Sobolik, Gary Sobolik, Cherie Coale, Christina Felis, Walter Felis, Ann Steffes, Robert Steffes, Dianne Birchmeier, Melissa Rines, Wesley Rines, Karen Reister, Dan Reister, Consuelo Pacheco, Cynthia Williams, Machan Williams, Esther Gomez, Anthony Gomez, Cora Huggard, Patsy Recla, Ken Recla, Gail Gioioso, Domenick Gioioso, Traci Beyer, Michael William Beyer, Jeneen Blackburn, Garry Blackburn, Linda Koch-Kious, Keri Doran, Jodie Barbosa, Guillermo Barbosa, Janet Goodwine, Melvin Goodwine, Carmen Melendez, Stephanie Polomis & James Polomis, Plaintiffs, represented by Brent J. McIntosh , BILBO LAW OFFICE & Daniel William Clanton , BILBO LAW OFFICE.

Teri Elliott, Plaintiff, pro se.

Kathleen M. Smith & Libbie D. Carden, Plaintiffs, represented by Douglas William Crandall , CRANDALL LAW OFFICE, pro hac vice.

Julia Henick, Plaintiff, represented by Cristina Yadira Hernandez , FITTS LAW FIRM.

Joseph M. Petro, Plaintiff, represented by Don K. Ledgard , CAPRETZ & ASSOCIATES, John W. Redmann , LAW OFFICE OF JOHN W. REDMANN & Teresa G. Castle , LAW OFFICE OF JOHN W. REDMANN.

Paulina Rooks, Kevin Spriggs, Rachel A. Spriggs, Barbara E. Silva & James Silva, Plaintiffs, represented by Joseph F. Archer , JOSEPH F. ARCHER, Keith M. Jensen , JENSEN & ASSOCIATES, Rhonda Baker Debevec , SPANGENBERG SHIBLEY & LIBER, William E. Cannon, III , CANNON MIHILL & WINKLES & Michael Leslie Hodges , HODGES LAW FIRM.

Rita Ard, Rena Price, Thelma Rodriguez, Carolyn Sande, Janice Haneef, Linda Peterson, Linda Wessel & Michele Gold, Plaintiffs, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Keith M. Jensen , JENSEN & ASSOCIATES, Marianne C. LeBlanc , SUGARMAN & SUGARMAN & Riley L. Burnett, Jr. , BURNETT LAW FIRM.

Rhonda Radeski, Plaintiff, represented by Carl N. Frankovitch , FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON & Shawn Khorrami , KHORRAMI BOUCHER SUMNER SANGUINETTI.

Bill Milne, Plaintiff, represented by Brett L. Rosenthal , MCNULTY LAW FIRM.

Lorri Venodola & Mary Lundin, Plaintiffs, represented by Don K. Ledgard , CAPRETZ & ASSOCIATES & Frank Jacob D'Amico, Jr. , LAW OFFICES OF FRANK J. D'AMICO, JR.

Laura Reese, Plaintiff, pro se.

Jennifer D. Dean, Plaintiff, pro se.

Laurie Dee Hawkins, Plaintiff, pro se.

Jesse D. Hawkins, Plaintiff, pro se.

Juanita Laird, Plaintiff, pro se.

Tanya S. Schneider-Wismar & Tom Wismar, Plaintiffs, represented by John David Roven , ROVEN-KAPLAN.

Claudia L. Delgado & Alvaro M. Gomez, Plaintiffs, represented by Ronald L. Edelman , EDELMAN & THOMPSON & Lexi J. Hazam , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Jeff Bigelow, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph Lyon , THOMAS & LYON, Aimee H. Wagstaff , ANDRUS & WAGSTAFF, Marc D. Grossman , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN & Randi Kassan , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN.

Flora T. Hernandez & David Antonio Hernandez, Plaintiffs, represented by Paige Nicole Boldt , WATTS GUERRA.

Flora T. Hernandez, Plaintiff, pro se.

David Antonio Hernandez, Plaintiff, pro se.

David Lemasters & Christina Lemasters, Plaintiffs, represented by Stephen Thomas Blackburn , BARON & BUDD & Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES.

Susan Nelson, Plaintiff, pro se.

John Nelson, Plaintiff, pro se.

Julia Dimas, Plaintiff, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Teresa G. Castle , LAW OFFICE OF JOHN W. REDMANN, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Rafael Nieves, Plaintiff, represented by Majd M. Ghanayem , FEARS NACHAWATI LAW FIRM.

Nora Jean Hamm, Plaintiff, pro se.

Stuart C. Hamm, Plaintiff, pro se.

Amy Millsap, Douglas Millsap & Rhonda Doherty, Plaintiffs, represented by John T. Kirtley, III , FERRER POIROT & WANSBROUGH.

Donna G. Boling, Plaintiff, represented by Brian Patrick Marcelle , HUBER SLACK HOUGHTALING PANDIT & THOMAS & Charles Marshall Thomas , HUBER SLACK HOUGHTALING PANDIT & THOMAS.

Richard Boling & Roland Modica, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael Shay Keating , KEATING LAW OFFICE & Thomas H. Peyton , THE PEYTON LAW FIRM.

Deanne L. Vonderohe & Arthur R. Vonderohe, Plaintiffs, represented by Joseph Hanson Malley , LAW OFFICES OF JOSEPH H. MALLEY.

Heidi S. Greidanus, Plaintiff, represented by John Brandon Bruce , BRUCE LAW GROUP.

Bobbie Miles, Plaintiff, represented by Brent J. McIntosh , BILBO LAW OFFICE.

Teresa Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel William Clanton , BILBO LAW OFFICE.

Kathy Almeida, Plaintiff, represented by Clayeo C. Arnold .

Lothar Goernitz, Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Trustee, Plaintiff, represented by Robert T. Dassow , HOVDE DASSOW & DEETS.

Christina L. Jones, Plaintiff, pro se.

Olga V. Wilson, Plaintiff, pro se.

Linda Dozier, Plaintiff, represented by Peyton P. Murphy , MURPHY LAW FIRM.

Claudia Sapien, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda M. Kent , SOCIAL SECURITY ADMINISTRATION Office of General Counsel, Amy Fisch Solomon , GIRARDI KEESE & Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE.

Mary McGuire, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, Caryn Brottman Sanders , LAW OFFICES OF WILLIAM H. NEWKIRK, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & William H. Newkirk , LAW OFFICES OF WILLIAM H. NEWKIRK.

Robert McQuire, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Lincoln Combs , GALLAGHER & KENNEDY.

Robert McQuire, Plaintiff, pro se.

Marcy Ringstaff & Jeffrey Ringstaff, Plaintiffs, represented by Keesha D. Middleton , LANGSTON & LANGSTON.

Connie Johns, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, James E. Shipley, Jr. , TATE LAW GROUP & Kim Loutey , TORHOERMAN LAW.

Curtis Johns, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Amanda M. Kent , SOCIAL SECURITY ADMINISTRATION Office of General Counsel & Kim Loutey , TORHOERMAN LAW.

Berline Willis & James Willis, Plaintiffs, represented by Diane E. Sammons , NAGEL RICE & Joseph J. Zonies , ZONIES LAW.

Cassandra Gibbs, Linda Beard, Ronald Beard, Aurelia Harvey, Johnny Harvey, Lauren Anastasopoulos & Peter Anastasopoulos, Plaintiffs, represented by Jordan M. Anderson , ANDERSON2X.

Erica King, Plaintiff, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Josh B. Wages , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Laura V. Yaeger , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ & Michael Goetz , MORGAN & MORGAN.

Cindy Brantley, Nicole Mayor, George Mayor, Beatriz Carvajal, Staci Harjo & Teri O'Neal, Plaintiffs, represented by Jacob Plattenberger , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

Delora Kahoali, Frances Carpenter, Glenda Banta, George Banta, Jr., Jayne Barfield, Cheryl K. Cronin, Marilyn Harrison, Michael H. Byrne, Janie M. Hudson, Bruce A. Hudson, Phyllis Jackson, John A. Jackson, Darlene Ternes, Lee Ternes, Charity Wilson, William Wilson, Karen Kowalik, Carl Belmont Kube, Carmela Frances Kube, Carolina Ponton, Melissa Vaughn, Robert G. Vaughn, Belinda Morgan, Kathy Cole & Pauline Holmes, Plaintiffs, represented by Laura J. Baughman , BARON & BUDD, pro hac vice.

Martha Guerrero, Plaintiff, represented by Jose Perez , LAW OFFICES OF JOSE PEREZ.

Amy Jamison, Plaintiff, represented by Jacob Plattenberger , TOR HOERMAN LAW & Raymond Joseph Kramer , TORHOERMAN LAW.

Deborah Ann Frisbie, Plaintiff, pro se.

Gayle Donners, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Heather Kent , GIRARDI KEESE & Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE.

Mari Underwood, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Thomas Paglialunga , PAGLIALUNGA & HARRIS & James Andrew Harris , PAGLIALUNGA & HARRIS.

Cheryl Kester, Plaintiff, represented by Joshua P. Wunderlich , THE ROBERT PAHLKE LAW GROUP.

Gweneth Glessner & Ronald Glessner, Plaintiffs, represented by Raymond L. Panneton , THE TALASKA LAW FIRM.

Alison Sherman, Plaintiff, pro se.

David Sherman, Plaintiff, pro se.

Carole Davis Phelps, Plaintiff, represented by Henry Shere Queener , LAW OFFICE OF HENRY S. QUEENER.

Richard Q. Phelps, Plaintiff, represented by Ashleigh Elizabeth Raso , MESHBESHER & SPENCE.

DeAnn Brierley & John Brierley, Plaintiffs, represented by Lawrence J. Scanlon , SCANLON & ELLIOTT & Michael J. Elliott , SCANLON & ELLIOTT.

Margaret Cladek, Gary Cladek, Evelyn R. Copeland, Thomas B. Copeland, Susan C. Naeve, Wally E. Naeve, Janice Aragon, Kimberly Cramer, Sean Cramer, Beverly Geraci, Gregory Geraci, Patsy Napier, Joan Nielsen, Elden D. Nielson, Jody Gough, Galina Flippin, Martin Flippin, Lena Joan Michaelis, Bonita Klein, Gerald L. Klein, Julie Phillips, John Phillips, Antje Crawford, Suzanne Miderski, Justine Groves, Michael Groves, Caroline Nowacki, Martin Nowacki, Evelyn Shill, Kimberly Wright, Gary Wright, Carole Aversa, Johnny Alonzo, Terese Boeck, Keri Flecther, Eric Fletcher, Mary Course, Elaine Langlois, Mark Langlois, Dawn Perreault, Realeene Chapin, Mary E. Kramer, Jo Ann Martin, Joseph Martin, Bonnie Bergstrom, Angela Hendricks, Michael Hendricks, Anna Carver, Luz Perez, Dario Perez, Beverly Kohr, Sharon Coley, Carolyn Bartley, Angela Hopewell, Doreen Barker, Paul Barker, Jennifer Born, Shelly Justensen, Debra Olsen, Luz Maria Carlos, Rodolfo Carlos, Darla Enzbrenner, Beatrice Dotson, Daria Gamble, Tremeka Woods, Earl Woods, Bonnie Krauskoff, Michael Belfy, Barbara Carter, Elaine Kouba, Juanita Alcin, Jennifer Wilson, James Wilson, Kathy Dover, Carol Smith, Jennifer Abbt & Jeff Abbt, Plaintiffs, represented by James Andrew Harris , PAGLIALUNGA & HARRIS.

Susan Eddleman, Plaintiff, represented by Annette Bulger Mathis , LANGSTON & LANGSTON, Christopher T. Kirchmer , PROVOST UMPHREY LAW FIRM, Jason Nabors , LANGSTON & LANGSTON & Rebecca M. Langston , LANGSTON & LANGSTON.

Gary Eddleman, Plaintiff, represented by James F. d'Entremont , MOORE THOMPSON & LEE, Christopher T. Kirchmer , PROVOST UMPHREY LAW FIRM, Jason Nabors , LANGSTON & LANGSTON & Rebecca M. Langston , LANGSTON & LANGSTON.

Kelly Blum, Plaintiff, pro se.

Robert Mabe, Plaintiff, represented by Thomas W. Pirtle , LAMINACK PIRTLE & MARTINES.

Christine Ihrig, Plaintiff, represented by Adam David Breit , JUSTICE LAW & Cam F. Justice , JUSTICE LAW.

Gail Stephenson, Plaintiff, represented by Britt Alicia Birkenbuel , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY & James Andrew Harris , PAGLIALUNGA & HARRIS.

Ronald Stephenson, Lana Chapman, Robert Chapman, Ann Crawford, Krista Krug & Everett Krug, Plaintiffs, represented by R. Christopher Gilreath , GILREATH & ASSOCIATES & James Andrew Harris , PAGLIALUNGA & HARRIS.

Clementina Roeder, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey L. Haberman , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES.

Ronald P. Roeder, Jr., Kimberly Aguero, Deborah Boneta, Diego Boneta, Cheryl Hines, Sharon Swintelski, Arthur Swintelski & Maria Puldon, Plaintiffs, represented by Russell L. Egli , EGLI LAW & ASSOCIATES.

Elizabeth Jimenez, Llen M. Jimenez, Sr. & Dorothy Dills-Filor, Plaintiffs, represented by E. John Litchfield , BERRIGAN LITCHFIELD SCHONEKAS MANN & TRAINA & C. Calvin Warriner, III , SEARCY DENNEY SCAROLA BARNHART & SHIPLEY.

Georgia A. Borg, Pirdy F. Nelson & Casey Rutter, Plaintiffs, represented by William H. Barfield , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & Jeffrey S. Grand , BERNSTEIN LIEBHARD.

Mona W. Oblak, Plaintiff, represented by Irwin B. Levin , COHEN & MALAD.

Katherine Bartell, Plaintiff, pro se.

Rodney B. Bartell, Plaintiff, pro se.

Debora Modica, Plaintiff, represented by Brian Patrick Marcelle , HUBER SLACK HOUGHTALING PANDIT & THOMAS & Thomas H. Peyton , THE PEYTON LAW FIRM.

Christine G. Harkins, Plaintiff, represented by Jayne Conroy , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, John J. Foley , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Trent B. Miracle , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Shirley White & Nelson C. White, Plaintiffs, represented by Amy Eskin , LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS, pro hac vice & Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE.

Alissa McGuire, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Eric William Gruenwald , THE MULLIGAN LAW FIRM & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Tina L. Stone, Diane Castillo, April M. Zambrano & Jimmy Zambrano, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey L. Haberman , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES & Casey Langston Lott , LANGSTON & LOTT.

Susan Snyder, Plaintiff, represented by Deborah K. Palmer , VARNUM, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Dolores Burkhart-Givens, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan Scott Hofeld , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES & Russell L. Egli , EGLI LAW & ASSOCIATES.

Patricia Ornstein, Richard Ornstein, Brandie Wolvin, George Diaz Araiza, Deborah Cagle & Brenda Garcia-Valadez, Plaintiffs, represented by David A. Pearlman , HELMSDALE LAW & Ronald R. Parry , PARRY DEERING FUTSCHER & SPARKS.

Irene Camarillo, Plaintiff, represented by Marlon E. Branham , BRANHAM LAW OFFICES.

Armando Garate, Plaintiff, represented by Jonathan L. Nielsen , NIELSEN PETERSON & NIELSON LLP.

Virginia Roberts & Jack Roberts, Plaintiffs, represented by Joseph Preston Strom, Jr. , STROM LAW FIRM.

Karen Wagner, Plaintiff, represented by Melissa L. Steed , EDELMAN & THOMPSON.

Margaret Sciara, Plaintiff, represented by Ruth Rizkalla , KIRTLAND & PACKARD.

Vincent Sciara, Plaintiff, represented by Babak Bobby Saadian , WILSHIRE LAW FIRM.

Marie Spangler & Leslie Davis, n/k/a Leslie Kaldenberg, Plaintiffs, represented by Christopher M. Grimes , GRIMES LAW GROUP & Brian Patrick Marcelle , HUBER SLACK HOUGHTALING PANDIT & THOMAS.

Linda Conyers, Plaintiff, represented by Lee Paul Mankin , THE LAW OFFICE OF L. PAUL MANKIN.

Lystra Lennard Ramnarine, Plaintiff, represented by William H. Barfield , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Delilah Domenech & Ander Calvo, Plaintiffs, represented by Ronald L. Edelman , EDELMAN & THOMPSON, John C. Thornton, III , ANDREWS & THORNTON & Lexi J. Hazam , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Maria Eugenia Garcia de Vega, Fernando R. Vega & Sylvia Nance, Plaintiffs, represented by John C. Thornton, III , ANDREWS & THORNTON & Lexi J. Hazam , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Rita Daniel, Plaintiff, represented by Katherine Lindsey Cornell , BLIZZARD & NABERS.

Helen Rogerson, Plaintiff, represented by Bobby Saadian .

Brian S. Rogerson, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew Callahan , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Ashley Wiegand, Plaintiff, represented by B. T. Dunken, Jr. , DUNKEN LAW GROUP & Daniel Vincent Kohls , HANSEN KOHLS SOMMER & JACOB.

David Binelli & Michelle Binelli, Plaintiffs, represented by Keith M. Jensen , JENSEN & ASSOCIATES, Rhonda Baker Debevec , SPANGENBERG SHIBLEY & LIBER, William E. Cannon, III , CANNON MIHILL & WINKLES, Mark A. Cox , LAW OFFICE OF MARK A. COX & Michael Leslie Hodges , HODGES LAW FIRM.

Lena M. Fitzgerald, Plaintiff, pro se.

Michael Fitzgerald, Plaintiff, pro se.

Carol Daus, as Heir of the Estate of Carol Daus, Plaintiff, pro se.

Patricia Law, deceased, Plaintiff, pro se.

Patricia A. Harmon, Individually and as Administrator and Heir of the Estate of Patricia Law, deceased, Plaintiff, pro se.

Adam Steiner, as Heir of the Estate of Patricia Law, deceased, Plaintiff, pro se.

Debra Garcia, Ruben Garcia & Patricia Nelson, Plaintiffs, represented by Ryan Keith Haun , BARTON LAW FIRM.

Yvette Gayfield, Plaintiff, pro se.

Evelyn Adler, Plaintiff, represented by Paulina do Amaral , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, John C. Thornton, III , ANDREWS & THORNTON & Lexi J. Hazam , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Shirley Turner, Plaintiff, represented by Justin Leonard Groen , MESSA & ASSOCIATES & Michele S. Burkholder , NASTLAW.

Cynthia Renee McLendon, Elaine R. Smidt & Amy Osborne, Plaintiffs, represented by Allan R. Tarleton , THE VAN WINKLE LAW FIRM.

Pamela Ann Courson, Plaintiff, pro se.

Christine Grauman, Plaintiff, pro se.

Debra Trinidad, Plaintiff, pro se.

Sherry Crew, Plaintiff, pro se.

Robbie Price, Plaintiff, represented by Justin Leonard Groen , MESSA & ASSOCIATES & Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Betty Ward, Plaintiff, represented by Diane K. Watkins , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Periann Hughes, Plaintiff, pro se.

Kerri A. Clark, Plaintiff, represented by Ashley M. Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, Bonnie Spencer , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, David Lee Augustus , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM, Dawn R. Meade , THE SPENCER LAW FIRM & Jeffery B. Badders , BADDERS LAW FIRM.

Claire Strickland, Plaintiff, represented by Brittany S. Cates , FAXON LAW GROUP.

Patricia Boasso, Linda Pelham & Sheron Smith, Plaintiffs, represented by James Devlan Geddes , GOETZ BALDWIN & GEDDES, Ted G. Meadows , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Lisa Lattanzi, Plaintiff, represented by Maria S. Diamond , DIAMOND MASSONG.

Greg Fry, Plaintiff, represented by Kyle W. Nelson , GOETZ BALDWIN & GEDDES.

John Nichol, Plaintiff, represented by Alex Barlow , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK & Maria S. Diamond , DIAMOND MASSONG.

Tricia Lee Delmas, Plaintiff, represented by James Lamar Porter , THE BRAD HENDRICKS LAW FIRM.

Rachel M Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Susan Lynne Becker , PAUL MCINNES.

Carmen Cruz-Berrios, Plaintiff, pro se.

Desiree Busby, Deborah Arnold & Rosa Pontillo, Plaintiffs, represented by Kevin M. Pearl , FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON & Michael Cory Bradley , PITTMAN DUTTON & HELLUMS.

Janeen Kissinger, Plaintiff, represented by Kevin M. Pearl , FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON.

Brenda Coates, Plaintiff, represented by Peter A. Kraus , WATERS & KRAUS.

Linda Butler, Plaintiff, represented by Brian D. Chase , BISNAR CHASE & Tomislav G. Antunovich , BISNAR CHASE.

Cheryl Brown, Plaintiff, pro se.

Patricia Springer & William Springer, Plaintiffs, represented by Marc E. Lipton , LIPTON LAW CENTER.

Irma Saffell, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher R. LoPalo , NAPOLI SHKOLNIK & Jennifer R. Liakos , NAPOLI SHKOLNICK & ASSOCIATES.

Olivia Neece, Laura Reneau, Treva McCarthy, Karen Hellerstein, Amy Jones, Sandra Agrella, Kim Lovell, Yvonne Cicero, Diane Landreth, Helen McCollum, Helen B. Austin, Carolyn Green, Gladys Morales, Joan Porch, Shirley Guthrie, Sherrie S. Foley, Cinda Tyler, Cathryn Gordon, Tempie Pierce, Toni Shiver, Shirely Schapmire, Betty Dehaven, Joretta Black, Barbara Phillips, Sherry Corbin, Susanne A. Terrill, Patricia Shea, Darlene A. Dean, Debbie A. Ernst, Judith Webster, Marlene Hitchens, Wanda Waldon, Sally M. Biron, Christine Bachmann, Deborah Preville, Kaye Turner, Carmela Quartararo, Madonna Watermon, Debra Bird, Laura Engellant Voegele, Mary Hewett, Helen Gaye Murrary, Donna Holt, Melodie E. Estes, Annie Bowens Scott, Peggy Lowe, Barbara Stubblefield, Mickey Gowler, Aldeena Lopez, Heather Jean Ducksworth, Connie Payne, Barbara Miranda, Barbara Zellers, Rosa McMillen, Linda Bowden, Marilyn Miller, Bonnie Curley, Carmen C. Sintron Casillas, Katherine C. Bergelt, Marsha Kavanagh, Clara J. Pressley, Betty Howard, Donna Kestler, Mary Sue Booth, Judy A. Reid, Gladis Elena Lopez, Marcia Dixon, Linda Barnett, Juanita Whittington, Judith Jordan, Andrea Adam Owens, Justina Tango, Margaret Palmer, Deborah Howard, Mary Martin, Barbara Devore, Linda Schutzer, Linda Jean Dishno, Mary Wolf, Sandra Foster, Ellen Cross, Karen Keene, Barbara Wiley, Berthalene Sullivan, Patricia Ward, Alice Jane Eaton, Bernice S. Owens, Judith Simmons, Kathleen Bigler, June Ulrich, Joan Madden, Isabelle Walsh, Sara Johnston, Debra McFalls, Peggy A. Gunter, Eddie R. Robbins, Lisa Bunch, Mary Christensen, Bonita Fairchild, Mary Anne Harlan, Brenda Story, Shirley Desalvo, Barbara E. Tracey, Deborah Juarascio, Susan Herbert, Janine Parnell, Penny Hustead, Christine Brown, Teresa Mathis, Janet Morris, Recurreccion Martinez, Yvonne Gioka, Susan Dennis, Robin N. McClellan, Judith Hartle, Sharon Lynn Hardwick, Elsie Nickles, Mary Sellers, Cheryl Carr, Julie McCarty, Celia Estrada, Deborah Jones, Rosemary Ragsdell, Tammy Sue Brown, Maria Tovar & Patty Jouett, Plaintiffs, represented by Tomislav G. Antunovich , BISNAR CHASE.

Gloria L. Brown, Plaintiff, pro se.

Kennneth E. Brown, Plaintiff, pro se.

Benjamin Knapp, Individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Benjamin Knapp, Plaintiff, represented by Pia R. Lederman , LEDERMAN LAW FIRM & Thomas D. Murphree , MURPHREE LAW FIRM.

Becky Lynn Spiares & Michael Porter, Plaintiffs, represented by Daniel C. Burke , BERNSTEIN LIEBARD & Christopher R. LoPalo , NAPOLI SHKOLNIK.

Marie DeMari, Plaintiff, represented by Martin G. Rubenstein , LEVY BARDANTE FINNEY RUBENSTEIN COHEN & CHIZMAR.

Judith A. Graham, Plaintiff, represented by Charles S. Siegel , WATERS & KRAUS, Stephen J. Litchfield , BERRIGAN LITCHFIELD SCHONEKAS MANN & TRAINA, Grant Lavalle Davis , DAVIS BETHUNE & JONES & Shawn Gayland Foster , DAVIS BETHUNE & JONES.

Kaylan Pendleton, Plaintiff, represented by Charles S. Siegel , WATERS & KRAUS, Grant Lavalle Davis , DAVIS BETHUNE & JONES & Patrick S. Nagler , WATERS KRAUS & PAUL.

Shelby Ballew & Kevin Ballew, Plaintiffs, represented by Charles S. Siegel , WATERS & KRAUS, Stephen J. Litchfield , BERRIGAN LITCHFIELD SCHONEKAS MANN & TRAINA, Nabil Majed Nachawati, II , FEARS NACHAWATI LAW FIRM, Grant Lavalle Davis , DAVIS BETHUNE & JONES & Mary Elizabeth Graham , GRANT & EISENHOFER.

Joyce E. Bryant, Plaintiff, pro se.

Larry E. Bryant, Plaintiff, pro se.

Estella Baylor, Plaintiff, pro se.

Belinda Wright, Plaintiff, pro se.

John L Wright, Plaintiff, pro se.

Bonnie L. Summerfield, Jeanne McCarthy & Stephanie A. Weaver, Plaintiffs, represented by Thomas D. Murphree , MURPHREE LAW FIRM, Martin G. Rubenstein , LEVY BARDANTE FINNEY RUBENSTEIN COHEN & CHIZMAR & Thomas D. Haklar , LAW OFFICES OF THOMAS D. HAKLAR.

Martha Dubrava, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher Montes de Oca , LAW OFFICES OF CHRISTOPHER MONTES DE OCA.

Nancy Salcido, Plaintiff, represented by Michael Joseph Anderson , ANDERSON AGOSTINO & KELLER & John David Roven , ROVEN-KAPLAN.

Dolores A. Martinez, Plaintiff, pro se.

Tabetha Roberts, Plaintiff, represented by Mollie Katherine Wellins , MARC J. BERN & PARTNERS & Jessica Donna Keller , SLATER SLATER SCHULMAN.

Sandra Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Ian Ward, II , FISCHER REDAVID & John Phillip Fischer , FISCHER REDAVID.

Carol J. Clark, Plaintiff, pro se.

Nancy Johns, Plaintiff, represented by John A. Leslie , THE LESLIE LAW FIRM.

Kristin Kopplin, Doreen Johnson, Kenneth Johnson, Krystina Lucas, Linda Young, Nicole Zaragoza & Janet Perkins, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael G. Daly , POGUST BRASLOW & MILLROOD.

Lisa E. Cherry, Plaintiff, pro se.

Teresa Baldassaro, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph H. Saunders , SAUNDERS & WALKER & Bruce Cook , BRUCE COOK & ASSOCIATES.

Bonnie S. Butterbaugh, Plaintiff, represented by Thomas Jeffrey Beausay , BEAUSAY LAW FIRM.

Alan N. Butterbaugh, Plaintiff, represented by Charlotte A. Gulewicz , FEARS NACHAWATI.

Paula Conway, Plaintiff, represented by Michael J. Miller , THE MILLER FIRM & Shayne K. Hodge , THE MILLER FIRM.

Earl Conway, Plaintiff, represented by Michael J. Miller , THE MILLER FIRM & John A. Leslie , THE LESLIE LAW FIRM.

American Medical Systems, Inc., Defendant, represented by Alex G. Gross , REED SMITH, Alfred E. Donohue , WILSON SMITH COCHRAN DICKERSON, Robert J. Gingras , GINGRAS CATES & LUEBKE, Bart C. Sullivan , FOX GALVIN, Brian M. Rostocki , REED SMITH, Bridget Kellogg Smitha , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Brooke G. Malcom , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE, Camille N. Johnson , SNOW CHRISTENSEN & MARTINEAU, Clifford L. Schaffer , SCHAFFER LAX McNAUGHTON & CHEN, Cooper S. Ashley , MASLON EDELMAN BORMAN & BRAND, David Odalis Batista , GREENBERG TRAURIG, David Rodman Cooper , MARSHALL & MELHORN, Denise M. Ware , REED SMITH, Eric W. Swanis , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Erica Yen , REED SMITH, Erik W. Legg , FARRELL FARRELL & FARRELL, G. Dewey Hembree, III , MCGLINCHEY STAFFORD, George E. McDavid , REED SMITH, Graeme Hancock , FENNEMORE CRAIG, Harlan I. Prater, IV , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE, Janet H. Kwuon , REED SMITH, Jill Ann Franklin , SCHAFFER LAX McNAUGHTON & CHEN, John K. Londot , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Joseph P. Griffith , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Joseph J. Leghorn , NIXON PEABODY, Junga P. Kim , REED SMITH, Kara B. Hendricks , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Kathleen Ceglarski Burns , NIXON PEABODY, Kathleen A. Manning , MCGLINCHEY STAFFORD, Kathy Ann Cochran , WILSON SMITH COCHRAN DICKERSON, Keiko L. Sugisaka , MASLON EDELMAN BORMAN & BRAND, Ken Matthew Markowitz , KENNEY & MARKOWITZ, Kevin R. Knight , ICE MILLER, Kimberly Irene McIntyre , KENNEY & MARKOWITZ, Kymberly E. Speer , KENNEY & MARKOWITZ, Lori G. Cohen , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Louis W. Schack , REED SMITH, Marcella Coladangelo Ducca , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Mary-Olga Lovett , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Maryanne C. Woo , REED SMITH, Melody H. Eagan , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE, Michael J. Farrell , FARRELL WHITE & LEGG, Michael Aaron Hersh , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Michael C. McCarthy , MASLON EDELMAN BORMAN & BRAND, Michael T. Scott , REED SMITH, Michelle Lee Miller , MCGLINCHEY STAFFORD, Natasha Sung , REED SMITH, Nolan L. Reichl , PIERCE ATWOOD, P. William Stark , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Peter W. Culley , PIERCE ATWOOD, Peter S. Wahby , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Philip M. Hymanson , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Phillip Howard Babich , REED SMITH, R. Scott Campbell , GREENBERG TAURIG, Rachel K. Marcoccia , REED SMITH, Rachel B. Weil , REED SMITH, Raymond E. Zschiesche , PHILLIPS MURRAH, Richard G. Merrill , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Richard C. Sullivan, Jr. , REED SMITH, Robert J. Herrington , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Robert D. Mason, Jr. , WOMBLE CARLYLE SANDRIDGE & RICE, pro hac vice, Samantha Davies Hilton , KENNEY & MARKOWITZ, Sean P. Jessee , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Stephen Todd Fowler , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Suzanne Lorraine Diaz , FENNEMORE CRAIG, Tamela J. White , FARRELL WHITE & LEGG, Tara M. Williams , GREENBERT TRAURIG, Thomas M. Levinson , REED SMITH, Veronica Kuiumdjian , REED SMITH, William J. Knapp , KNAPP OHL & GREEN, Lyn Peeples Pruitt , MITCHELL WILLIAMS SELIG GATES & WOODYARD & Krista Schmid , REED SMITH.

C. R. Bard, Inc., Defendant, represented by Carrie Schadle , HARRISON BETTIS STAFF MCFARLAND & WEEMS, D. Mitchell McFarland , HARRISON BETTIS STAFF MCFARLAND & WEEMS, Marc E. Williams , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Melissa Foster Bird , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Corrie Johnson Yackulic , CORRIE YACKULIC LAW FIRM, pro hac vice & Taylor Tapley Daly , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, pro hac vice.

Cook Incorporated, Defendant, represented by Douglas B. King , WOODEN & MCLAUGHLIN, James M. Boyers , WOODEN & MCLAUGHLIN, Jere Ann Rosebrock , WOODEN MCLAUGHLIN & Justin Andrew Kashman , WOODEN MCLAUGHLIN.

Boston Scientific Corporation, Defendant, represented by Alison Anne Verret , MCAFEE & TAFT, Archibald T. Reeves, IV , MCDOWELL KNIGHT ROEDDER & SLEDGE, Brannon Jones Arnold , WEINBERG WHEELER HUDGINS GUNN & DIAL, Bryan Pratt , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Eric M. Anielak , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Eva Marie Mannoia Weiler , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Johnathan T. Krawcheck , WEINBERG WHEELER HUDGINS GUNN & DIAL, pro hac vice, Jon A. Strongman , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, pro hac vice, Joseph M. Price , FAEGRE BAKER DANIELS, Matthew D. Keenan , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Robert T. Adams , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Thomas E. Steichen , MCAFEE & TAFT, Vani R. Singhal , MCAFEE & TAFT & William C. Roedder, Jr. , MCDOWELL KNIGHT ROEDDER & SLEDGE.

Ethicon, Inc., doing business as Gynecare, Inc. doing business as Ethicon Women's Health and Urology, Defendant, represented by Amy Sherry Fischer , FOLIART HUFF OTTAWAY & BOTTOM, Anita Modak-Truran , BUTLER SNOW, Kenneth A. Murphy , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Larry D. Ottaway , FOLIART HUFF OTTAWAY & BOTTOM, Melissa A. Merk , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Michael L. Brown , BUTLER SNOW O'MARA STEVENS & CANNADA, pro hac vice, Stephen Robert Lewis, Jr. , LEWIS & WILLIAMS, Susan M. Robinson , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

Caldera Medical, Inc., Defendant, represented by Barry J. Koopmann , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Beth S. Rose , SILLS CUMMIS & GROSS, William R. Stuart, III , SILLS CUMMIS & GROSS & Kim M. Schmid , BOWMAN & BROOKE.

Desarrollo e Investigacion Medica Aragonesa, S.L., Defendant, represented by Carolyn Purwin , CIPRIANI & WERNER & Ernest F. Koschineg , CIPRIANI & WERNER.

Boston Scientific, Inc., Defendant, represented by Elmore James Shepherd , SHOOK HARDY & BACON & Michael Bonasso , FLAHERTY SENSABAUGH & BONASSO.

CHCA Mainland L.P., Defendant, represented by Christopher M. Knudsen , SERPE JONES ANDREWS CALLENDER & BELL, John S. Serpe , SERPE JONES ANDREWS CALLENDER & BELL & Nicole G. Andrews , SERPE JONES ANDREWS CALLENDER & BELL.

CHCA Clear Lake L.P., doing business as Mainland Medical Center, Inc., Defendant, represented by Carolyn Purwin , CIPRIANI & WERNER, Ernest F. Koschineg , CIPRIANI & WERNER & Elmore James Shepherd , SHOOK HARDY & BACON.

Ethicon Endo-Surgery Services, L.P. & Johnson & Johnson, Inc., Defendants, represented by Vani R. Singhal , MCAFEE & TAFT & Larry D. Ottaway , FOLIART HUFF OTTAWAY & BOTTOM.

Dr. Lee A. Hutton, Defendant, represented by Frank N. Luccia , LUCCIA & EVANS.

Tyco Healthcare Group, L.P., Defendant, represented by David Scott Hartnett , SHOOK HARDY & BACON & Deborah A. Moeller , SHOOK HARDY BACON.

Cook Biotech, Inc., Defendant, represented by D. Mitchell McFarland , HARRISON BETTIS STAFF MCFARLAND & WEEMS, Marc E. Williams , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Taylor Tapley Daly , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH & Douglas B. King , WOODEN & MCLAUGHLIN.

Cook Medical, Inc., Defendant, represented by Andrew Cookingham , THOMPSON & KNIGHT, D. Mitchell McFarland , HARRISON BETTIS STAFF MCFARLAND & WEEMS, Marc E. Williams , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Taylor Tapley Daly , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH & Douglas B. King , WOODEN & MCLAUGHLIN.

Cook, Inc., Defendant, represented by D. Mitchell McFarland , HARRISON BETTIS STAFF MCFARLAND & WEEMS & Taylor Tapley Daly , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH.

Ethicon, LLC, Defendant, represented by Melissa A. Merk , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH.

James M. Fellows, M. D., Defendant, represented by E. Frederick Straub, Jr. , WHITLOW ROBERTS HOUSTON & STRAUB & James R. Coltharp, Jr. , WHITLOW ROBERTS HOUSTON & STRAUB.

Raymond T. Quatro, M.D. P.S.C., Defendant, represented by Andrew D. Pellino , O'BRYAN BROWN & TONER & Gerald R. Toner , O'BRYAN BROWN & TONER.

Neely and Quatro, P.S.C., Defendant, represented by Deborah A. Moeller , SHOOK HARDY BACON & Andrew Cookingham , THOMPSON & KNIGHT.

Urology Partners of Western Kentucky, P.S.C., Defendant, represented by Frank N. Luccia , LUCCIA & EVANS & David Scott Hartnett , SHOOK HARDY & BACON.

CL Medical Inc., Defendant, represented by Paul J. Cosgrove , ULMER & BERNE & Jennifer J. Hageman , ULMER & BERNE.

Mentor Worldwide LLC, Defendant, represented by Dustin B. Rawlin , TUCKER ELLIS & WEST & Heleina Lorraine Formoso , KING & SPALDING.

Coloplast Corp., Defendant, represented by Steven Alan Denny , LAW OFFICE OF STEVEN A. DENNY & Ronn B. Kreps , FULBRIGHT & JAWORSKI.

Neomedic, Inc., Neomedic International, S.L. & Specialties Remeex International, S.L., Defendants, represented by Barry J. Koopmann , BOWMAN & BROOKE & Beth S. Rose , SILLS CUMMIS & GROSS.

American Medical Solutions, Inc., Defendant, represented by Robert J. Gingras , GINGRAS CATES & LUEBKE & Tiffany M. Bui , REED SMITH.

American Medical Systems, Defendant, represented by Robert J. Gingras , GINGRAS CATES & LUEBKE & Erik W. Legg , FARRELL FARRELL & FARRELL.

Johnson & Johnson, Defendant, represented by Laura H. Dixon , BUTLER SNOW & Melissa A. Merk , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH.

Neomedic Inc., Defendant, represented by Beth S. Rose , SILLS CUMMIS & GROSS.

Agustin Martinez, M.D., Defendant, represented by Ronald G. Hole , HOLE & ALVAREZ.

Lifecell Corporation, Defendant, represented by David W. Field , LOWENSTEIN SANDLER & Michael Andrew Kaplan , LOWENSTEIN SANDLER.

M.D. Sam Siddighi, Defendant, represented by Christopher Carl Cannon , LAFOLLETTE JOHNSON DEHAAS FESLER & AMES & Marissa Ann Warren , LAFOLLETTE JOHNSON DEHAAS FESLER & AMES.

Monisha S. Crisell, Defendant, represented by Kyle A. Cruse , SCHMID & VOILES, Robert B. Fessinger , SCHMID & VOILES & Stephanie Rae Hanning , SCHMID & VOILES.

Dawn Iverson, Interested Party, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Christopher Walker, Interested Party, represented by Bertha Lidia Burruezo , BURRUEZO & BURRUEZO & Carlos Juan Burruezo , BURRUEZO & BURRUEZO.

Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Interested Party, represented by Andrew M. Williamson , BLANK ROME.

Broward Outpatient Medical Center, Interested Party, represented by Gerald M. Titus, III , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Mitchell J. Rhein , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE & Neva G. Lusk , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE.

Beth Israel Outpatient Surgery Center, Interested Party, represented by Stephanie Rae Hanning , SCHMID & VOILES, Bertha Lidia Burruezo , BURRUEZO & BURRUEZO & Carlos Juan Burruezo , BURRUEZO & BURRUEZO.

Daniel Christensen, Movant, represented by Alexander Macia , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, James S. Crockett, Jr. , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Matthew Stonestreet , THE GIATRAS LAW FIRM & Troy N. Giatras , THE GIATRAS LAW FIRM.

MedStar Funding, LC, Movant, represented by Andrew M. Williamson , BLANK ROME, David A. Bosak , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Gerald M. Titus, III , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Mitchell J. Rhein , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE & Neva G. Lusk , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE.

Garretson Resolution Group, Inc., Movant, represented by T. Matthew Lockhart , HUDDLESTON BOLEN.

David Hammer, Movant, pro se.

PRGI, Inc., Movant, represented by Paul DeCailly , DECAILLY LAW GROUP.

Mitchell Hammer, Movant, pro se.

Blake Barber, Michael Chhabra, Vincent Chhabra, Ronald Lasorsa, Law Firm Headquarters, LLC, Martindale Voight LLP, Pegasus Law LLP, Sigma Law Firm, LLP & The Law Offices of Albert J. Lazo, P.A., Movants, represented by Kevin A. Reck , FOLEY & LARDNER & Sean P. Smith , FOLEY & LARDNER.

Surgical Assistance, Surgical Assistance, Inc. & Medical Funding Consultants, LLC, Movants, represented by Jennifer Jo Hicks , DINSMORE & SHOHL.

Surgical Assistance, Movant, pro se.

Surgical Assistance, Inc., Movant, pro se.

Medical Funding Consultants, LLC, Movant, pro se.

Robert J. Fenstersheib & Associates, P.A., Movant, represented by Mark Goldstein , MARK GOLDSTEIN ATTORNEY AT LAW.

Alpha Law LLP, Movant, represented by Abbe D. Lowell , NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT, Michael A. Samalin , NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT & Stacey L. Trimmer , NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT.

Michael Chhabra, Movant, pro se.

Vincent Chhabra, Movant, pro se.

Ronald Lasorsa, Movant, pro se.

Law Firm Headquarters, LLC, Movant, pro se.

Martindale Voight LLP, Movant, pro se.

Pegasus Law LLP, Movant, pro se.

Sigma Law Firm, LLP, Movant, pro se.

The Law Offices of Albert J. Lazo, P.A., Movant, pro se.


MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

On December 5-7, 2018, the court conducted a Mandatory Settlement Conference as to the plaintiffs' claims against defendant American Medical Systems, Inc. ("AMS"). When the plaintiffs did not appear in person at the settlement conference as required...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases