ROMERO v. ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY

Civil Action No. 01-3894, Consolidated With No. 01-6764 (Romero II), No. 03-6872 (Romero III)., 15-1049 (Abell), 15-3047 (Anzivine)

GENE R. ROMERO, et al., Plaintiffs, v. ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania.

January 29, 2018.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 29 U.S.C. § 1145
Cause: 29 U.S.C. § 1145 E.R.I.S.A.
Nature of Suit: 791 Labor: E.R.I.S.A.
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

GENE R. ROMERO, JAMES T. BEVER, RICHARD A. CARRIER, PAUL R. COBB, CRAIG K. CREASE, SYLVIA CREWS-KELLY, RONALD W. HARPER, MICHAEL P. KEARNEY, THOMAS A. KEARNEY, LARRY H. LANKFORD, SR., DAVID C. LAWSON, NATHAN R. LITTLEJOHN, II, REBECCA R. MASLOWSKI, JAMES E. MOOREHEAD, RICHARD E. PETERSON, PAUL L. SHIRLEY, DONALD L. TRGOVICH, RICHARD S. WANDNER, TIMOTHY WEISMAN, ANTHONY T. WIKTOR, JOHN W. WITTMAN, RALPH J. WOLVERTON & CAROLYN L. PENZO, Plaintiffs, represented by JOHN V. GORMAN , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS, MARY ELLEN SIGNORILLE , AARP FOUNDATION LIT., MICHAEL D. LIEDER , SPRENGER & LANG, MICHAEL WILSON , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, STEVEN H. DOTO , LAULETTA, BIRNBAUM, LLC., BRIAN M. ERCOLE , MORGAN LEWIS, COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, JAMES P. WALSH, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS, LLP, MARISEL ACOSTA , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS, PAUL ANTON ZEVNIK , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP & WILLIAM P. QUINN, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS.

JOSEPH L. BENOIT, Plaintiff, represented by COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, BRIAN M. ERCOLE , MORGAN LEWIS, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, MARISEL ACOSTA , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS, MICHAEL D. LIEDER , SPRENGER & LANG, PAUL ANTON ZEVNIK , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP & WILLIAM P. QUINN, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS.

MARY JANE PILCHAK, AS SUCCESSOR FOR THE ESTATE OF JAMES PILCHAK, Plaintiff, represented by DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP & WILLIAM P. QUINN, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS.

A. BURTON ENGLISH, SOLE HEIR OF DWIGHT F. ENGLISH, Plaintiff, represented by BRIAN M. ERCOLE , MORGAN LEWIS, COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, MICHAEL D. LIEDER , SPRENGER & LANG & WILLIAM P. QUINN, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS.

ROGER BOYD, SYLVIA KELLY, PAULA REINERIO, THOMAS ABELL, KATHARINE ADAMS-LOVE, JOHN P. AELLEN, III, CLYDE WILLARD ALLEN, JOSEPH ALLEY, THOMAS PAUL ALLISON, RICHARD G. ALTIERI, ANDREW ALAN ANDERSON, CARL ANGELL, EUGENIA ANNINO STEGER, DANIEL ANULARE, LINDA A. ANULARE, BRUCE WILLIAM ASHLEY, MAXINE BACHICHA, HAROLD E. BAKER, ROBERT G. BARZELAY, GARY L. BAUMGARDNER, JAMES A. BEARD, DEBORAH BECKER, RICHARD C. BENNETT, COLIN T. BENT, VERNON BENTLEY, HAROLD D. BERNSTEIN, HAROLD D. BERNSTEIN, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF SANDI BERNSTEIN, MONTELL BERRY, WALLACE BERRY, LINDA BEUCHER, STANLEY R. BINDER, CRAIG A. BOCK, GARY L. BOCK, DAVID P. BOHAN, ROLAND BOISIS, JANICE BOND, DWIGHT CHARLES BONDY, ROBERT F. BORTELL, JR., DANIEL BOSSIO, JAMES L. BRACHFELD, EUGENE BRANDON, JAY BROKER, FAYE D. BROWN, RICHARD A. BROWN, LESTER BROWN, SR., WILLIAM L. BROWN, JR., RICHARD A. BROWNSON, CHARLES R. BURNS, III, THOMAS C. BUSHEY, DAVE BUSSELL, GARY CALLAWAY, GEORGIANA CALLAWAY, ALBERT J. CANNIZZARO, RICHARD CARTER, VICTOR M. CATARISANO, PORTIA M. CHAMBLISS, MARK D. CHASE, AMY CHERRNAY, JIMMY C. CHIN, DON C. CHRISTENSEN, BRUCE W. CLOTFELTER, IRA CLOUD, MILTON COBB, MARK C. COLLIER, WANDA COLLINS-SMITH, JOSEPH P. CONBOY, RICHARD F. COOK, JANET COOLEY, JAMES CORNETT, BRUCE R. CRALLEY, JACK J. CRAPARO, JR., JAY CRYSTAL, JAY CRYSTAL, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF DIANE CRYSTAL, LONNIE MICHAEL CURTIS, BRENT L. DANNER, JOHN DARWISH, HAROLD E. DASKAM, JOHN DAVENPORT, LESLIE K. DAVIDSON, ZACHARIAH M. DAVIDSON, III, MICHAEL L. DAVIS, MARGARET DEAN, PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF ROBERT T. DEAN, STEPHEN W. DELLAPINA, ERNEST JACK DEMONTE, JAMES DEPIZZO, JOHN ANTHONY DEVITO, GAIL DICKMAN, MARK L. DIVINCENZO, MICHAEL DOHENY, JEFFREY M. DOMBECK, TERRANCE DONOGHUE, VALERY DORSHIMER, JOYCE DOUGLAS, RUFUS C. DOWELL, SUSAN DRAPEAU, RICHARD DROE, GEORGE F. DRUMMOND, WALTER J. DUBIEL, THOMAS R. DURAN, DENNIS R. DYKE, LARRY R. DYKSTRA, RONALD F. EATON, MICHAEL ECONOMOS, RONALD R. EDWARDS, RICHARD EIRICH, ROSLYN EISENSTARK, BRUCE ENGERT, JANE ESCHRICH-WALSH, BILLY B. ESTES, SANDY K. FABRICATORE, JOSEPH FALCONI, III, CHRISTIAN G. FARLEY, SHEILA FARMER, CURTIS FARRAR, RALPH V. FAULK, PHILIP DEAN FEISAL, CARL E. FIELDER, DORIS FIELDS, LARRY D. FINLEY, WILLIAM FLOOD, GERALD L. FLORES, ERIC A. FORD, JOHN R. FORREST, ROBERT FRANZ, BOSS ROBERT FRIES, III, JODENE GARDNER, ROBERT E. GARY, LARRY O. GENTRY, SAMUEL E. GILLETTE, RANDOLPH GOODWIN, JR., JAMES A. GRADY, WILLIAM D. GREENE, SANDRA GUTHRIE, GERALD GUTZEIT, FRANKLIN P. HALL, BRENDA C. HAMMOND, LORETTA CAUSEY HANNON, FRANCIS HANRATTY, JAN HANSON, CHRIS HARDESTY, RONALD C. HARRISON, JR, JOHN W. HEASLEY, CONI HEIDLE, DARLENE HEINEN, ROBERT HELSEL, JAMES LOUIS HEMPHILL, GAIL ROGERS HIBBLER, LARRY W. HICE, DANNY HIGDON, PATRICIA A. HILL, RICHARD D. HILL, JAMES HILLAN, LEANNE HINKLE, (FORMERLY MCCURLEY), JOHN HLOHINEC, JIMMY D. HOCK, CHARMAIN A. HORVATH, DAN P. HOURIHANE, STEVE HOWELL, GEORGE HUYE, JOHN IAPOCE, SANDRA INMAN, CHARLES S. JACKSON, RICK JAHNS, ROBERT JAYSON, LELAND JELINEK, KAREN JUNEMAN, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF ROGER JUNEMAN, DAVID N. KAPEC, KATHLEEN KENNEY, ROBERT J. KILLEEN, ROBERT E. KIMBLE, THOMAS KROHNER, MARIA KRUMM, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF GARY J. KRUMM, AMOS KUYKENDOLL, WILLIAM LANDMARK, GREGORY LANE, BRUCE LARRABEE, JENNIFER LATHAM, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF CHARLES E. LATHAM, CAROL E. LEBLANC, JOSEPH LEE, SHARON E. LIBBRA, TERRY GENE LIBBRA, JANET LINDSAY, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF RONALD LINDSAY, JAMES W. LONGMAN, JOHN LUCAS, JAMES E. LYNCH, MICHAEL MACISCO, JOHN MALEK, STEVEN MALLORY, JOHN MALLORY, PATRICIA MARAZO, NICHOLAS S. MARINOS, EUGENE MARONEY, JOHN MARSH, RICHARD MASI, GLEN MASON, SCOTT A. MATTINGLY, THOMAS W. MATYJASIK, THOMAS MCCALL, RUDOLPH MCCLINON, JR., CASEY MCCOY, SHERRY MCDONALD, THOMAS MCEVANS, III, JAMES P. MCGUIRE, JOHN F. MCKENZIE, ANTHONY MCMURRAY, PETER S. MCVITTIE, JERREL L. MEAD, MARY MENDOZA, ORTON W. MESSENGER, SUSAN E. MESSINA, RONALD METZGER, PAMELA MEYER, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF MICHAEL MEYER, ARTHUR R. MILES, JR., JAMES T. MILLER, FRANK E. MILLER, JR., JEAN MINAL, FRIEDA MINGA, BARBARA ANN MINK, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF DANIEL MINK, ROBERT MINTON, JOE MONTANARO, RICHARD MOORE, STAFFORD W. MOORE, DINAH MORGAN, SYLVIA E. MOSLEY, D. CRAIG MULLEN, KELLY PATRICK MULLIGAN, DARRELL NAMIE, HERBERT A. NEWMAN, CHESTER NOWAK, RICHARD PAUL NYDEGGER, THOMAS A. O'DELL, WALTER ORR, JIM OVERMILLER, BARBARA OXNER, (PREVIOUSLY JONES), MARTHA PARRY, FRANK M. PATTERSON, TERRY PAULK, DANIEL T. PERRY, KEN PHILBRICK, FRANK L. PHILLIPS, STEPHEN WAYNE PIGG, CLIFFORD L. PINCKNEY, RITA E. PINO, RONALD M. PINSONEAULT, JOHNNY A. PLEMONS, ROBERT POLLOCK, DENNIS H. PORTER, DENNIS POWERS, BLAIR QUASNITSCHKA, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF LINDA KIRBUS (FORMERLY QUASNITSCHKA), PAUL QUATTRONE, MARZIANO P. RAGNONE, JAMES RAUEN, DONALD P. REIMER, MARIA G. RESNICK, LINDA REYNOLDS, STAN RICKS, DICK ROBERTS, THOMAS ROBY, DAVID ROMAN, LLOYD T. ROSENSTEEL, RICHARD K. ROSKOWE, RICHARD ROSSELL, RONALD J. RUBIN, ROBERT RUSSO, KAREN RYAN-WHITE, EDWARD M. SAAD, JOHN J. SANCHEZ, JACK SANDERS, MICHAEL L. SANDERS, SHEILA SANDERS, GAIL C. SANTALUCIA-DALY, PHILIP J. SARCONE, RICHARD SAULLE, MARCOS E. SAYAGO, GERALD H. SCHIELE, DOUGLAS SCHIFFMILLER, TIMOTHY L. SCHWARTZ, DAVID L. SEIDEL, ROGER SEROLA, LEONARD SHAW, ROBERT G. SHEA, JR., SHELDON F. SHEFF, WOODROW SHELTON, JR., DARRYL SHERMAN, MIKE SHOBE, LAWRENCE J. SIMMS, DOUGLAS A. SIMS, ERIC B. SIMS, CHINESTA SKIPPER SMITH, MARIE SMITH, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF DAVID WILLIAM SMITH, RONALD W. SMITH, ARMANDO D. SOLER, DEBORAH ANN SORRELL-ULRICH, DAVID ST. JOHN, SARAH ST. JOHN, THOMAS STEIN, MICHAEL M. STERN, CAROL STEVENS, (FORMERLY STEHLE), JOHN STOUT, DONALD STRIPLIN, CELESTE M. SULLIVAN, KURT A. SUMMERS, PAUL SVABEK, EDWARD SWANSON, MARILYN SWANSON, MICHELLE TABLER, RUSSELL A. TAPIE, WANDA TATUM, CHARLES TAYLOR, WRIGHT B. TAYLOR, III, ROBERT W. TELKINS, STEPHEN THOENNES, GARY THOMAS, MONTAGUE A. THOMAS, III, JEFFREY TOBIN, JOSEPH TOMEC, MARY TURLEY, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF ROBERT H. TURLEY, ALBERT TURNER, DAVID J. TUSKEY, CORNELL G. VANDEGRIFT, MILFORD T. VAUGHT, JR., LOUIS VEAL, DALE A. VILLEMAIN, CLETA VINING, JOSEPH S. VIOLA, JR., RONALD WANEK, BRIAN J. WANLESS, ARTHUR WASHINGTON, TIMOTHY JACKSON WATWOOD, MARK E. WEGNER, FINDLEY WEST, NEIL WHICKER, WALKER WILLIAMS, RODNEY W. WILLIAMS, SR., BARRY WILSON, ROBIN WILSON, FRANCES WISNIEWSKI, JAMES MICHAEL WOOD, LINDA WOSHNER, ROBERT A. WRIGHT, JR., BARBARA D. WRIGHT, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF KEVIN A. WRIGHT, LEONARD YARBROUGH, DONALD YOUNG, JAMES M. ZAHNER, RONALD D. ZARBAUGH, ROSE ZUMWINKLE, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF WILLIAM ZUMWINKLE, MANUEL ZUNIGA, CHARLES D. ZYBURO, IAN O'CONNOR, CATHERINE HAUGEN, AS SUCCESSOR FOR THE ESTATE OF LAWRENCE CAPOUCH, SHARON CIRILLO, AS SUCCESSOR FOR THE ESTATE OF JAMES CIRILLO, SHERRY EARL, AS SUCCESSOR FOR THE ESTATE OF RICHARD EARL, MARIAN GOELZ, AS SUCCESSOR FOR THE ESTATE OF GARY GOELZ, PATRICIA AURAND, AS SUCCESSOR FOR THE ESTATE OF RICHARD AURAND, SUZANNE TWOHIG, AS SUCCESSOR FOR THE ESTATE OF GEORGE TWOHIG & KIMBERLY SMITH, SUCCESSOR FOR THE ESTATE OF ALLEN FOSTER, Plaintiffs, represented by COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP & JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP.

WILLIAM MCLAUGHLIN, LEONARD LICHTY, VICTORIA LICHTY, WILLIAM COTTON, MARY DIGIULIO, MARYALICE DOYLE, WILLIAM LEE, WARREN MILLER, EUGENE WELLER, BRUCE DENLINGER, WILLIAM QUAIROLI, DEBORAH L. SPEDDING, GAIL WOLFE, ROBERT MCCARREL, PHILLIP SINGER, KENNETH FRANCK, JAMES ARCHER, LAWRENCE O'HARA, ROBERT WELLER, ATHENA WAGNER, PAUL TRIMBORN, ROBERT REBB, WILLIAM SHOVER, JOHN JUNKNIEWITZ, BRADLEY STECKEL, PAUL LONG, JANET HAGGERTY, JOHN CHERUP & JOSEPH ROSATI, Intervenor Plaintiffs, represented by JULIA MUNLEY , MUNLEY LAW, COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, JAMES C. MUNLEY , MUNLEY LAW, PC, JOHN M. MULCAHEY , MUNLEY LAW PC & KATIE NEALON , MUNLEY LAW PC.

ANN W. HARRIS, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, JAMES C. MUNLEY , MUNLEY LAW, PC & JULIA MUNLEY , MUNLEY LAW.

EARL SIEGFRIED, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, JAMES C. MUNLEY , MUNLEY LAW, PC, JAMES ALDO VAGNINI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP, JOHN M. MULCAHEY , MUNLEY LAW PC, JULIA MUNLEY , MUNLEY LAW, KATIE NEALON , MUNLEY LAW PC, ROBERT J. VALLI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI, LLP & SARA WYN KANE , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP.

LAWRENCE ANZIVINE & JACALYN L. HOGAN, AS SUCCESSOR FOR THE ESTATE OF WILLIAM HOGAN, Intervenor Plaintiffs, represented by COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, JAMES ALDO VAGNINI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP, MATTHEW BERMAN , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP, ROBERT J. VALLI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI, LLP, SARA WYN KANE , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP & SIDNEY L. GOLD , SIDNEY L. GOLD & ASSOCIATES, PC.

JAMES BANNON, BRUCE BONDS, CHARLES CADY, CHRISTOPHER CHALLENDER, BENNY CHUNN, NICHOLAS COSTANZO, JOSEPH DI BLASI, JOHN DINEEN, CEBIE EDWARDS, GERALD FLORES, DONALD FRANCHINO, VIRGINIA GANGE, ROBERT GEBLER, PAUL GILLIHAN, LEONARD GREGONLINE, DAVID GROSSNICKLAUS, LARRY HALL, RAYMOND HATTAWAY, THOMAS HAWKINS, JOHN HOGAN, DENNIS KARLAN, DONALD MATTINGLY, DONALD MCCRARY, JAMES MORGAN, WILLIAM MURTHA, BRIAN PURTLE, CHARLES RANDAZZO, EDWARD RESNER, DONALD RIGGINS, JAMES SHUMAKER, LYNN SOWARD, ARTHUR SPEARS, III, NICHOLAS STAVOLA, BRIEN SULLIVAN, ROBERT SUTTER, WILLIAM TARRIER, MICHAEL VALENTE, RUBY WATKINS, GARY WEAVER, CHRISTOPHER SULLIVAN & JOYCE MORGAN, Intervenor Plaintiffs, represented by COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, JAMES ALDO VAGNINI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP, ROBERT J. VALLI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI, LLP, SARA WYN KANE , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP & SIDNEY L. GOLD , SIDNEY L. GOLD & ASSOCIATES, PC.

WILLIAM FARR, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, JAMES ALDO VAGNINI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP, ROBERT J. VALLI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI, LLP & SIDNEY L. GOLD , SIDNEY L. GOLD & ASSOCIATES, PC.

RODNEY TABOR, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by ALAN L. YATVIN , POPPER & YATVIN, JESSICA F. SALONUS , GILBERT RUSSELL MCWHERTER SCOTT BOBBITT PLC, JONATHAN L. BOBBITT , GILBERT RUSSELL MCWHERTER SCOTT BOBBITT PLC, COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, HOWARD D. POPPER , POPPER & YATVIN, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, JAMES ALDO VAGNINI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP, JUSTIN S. GILBERT , GILBERT RUSSELL MCWHERTER SCOTT BOBBITT PLC, ROBERT J. VALLI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI, LLP & SARA WYN KANE , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP.

JUDI ALLEN, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by ALAN L. YATVIN , POPPER & YATVIN, COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, JUSTIN S. GILBERT , GILBERT RUSSELL MCWHERTER SCOTT BOBBITT PLC, ROBERT J. VALLI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI, LLP & SARA WYN KANE , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP.

FREDA SANFORD, KAREN EMMERT, CHRIS ROGERS, ISABELL HUIE, JOHN SIMERLY & MICHAEL SIMERLY, Intervenor Plaintiffs, represented by ALAN L. YATVIN , POPPER & YATVIN, COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, JAMES ALDO VAGNINI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP, JUSTIN S. GILBERT , GILBERT RUSSELL MCWHERTER SCOTT BOBBITT PLC, ROBERT J. VALLI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI, LLP & SARA WYN KANE , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP.

EDWARD M. LIDDY, IN HIS CAPACITY AS PRESIDENT, CHAIRMAN AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF THE ALLSTATE CORPORATION AND ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by EDWARD F. MANNINO , AKIN GUMP STRAUSS HAUER & FELD LLP, JOHN B. LANGEL , BALLARD SPAHR ANDREWS & INGERSOLL LLP, KATHERINE M. KATCHEN , AKIN GUMP STRAUSS HAUER & FELD, LLP, CHRISTOPHER TODD COGNATO , BALLARD SPAHR LLP, ELIZABETH MCMANUS , BALLARD SPAHR, ERICA ZOLNER , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, JORDAN M. HEINZ , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP & RICHARD C. GODFREY , KIRKLAND & ELLIS.

ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY, ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER Q. KING , DENTON US LLP, DONALD R. LIVINGSTON , AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS HAUER & FELD LLP, DONNA M. WELCH , KIRKLAND & ELLIS, EDWARD F. MANNINO , AKIN GUMP STRAUSS HAUER & FELD LLP, HARIKLIA KARIS , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, KATHERINE M. KATCHEN , AKIN GUMP STRAUSS HAUER & FELD, LLP, PETER A. BELLACOSA , KIRKLAND & ELLIS, RICHARD C. GODFREY , KIRKLAND & ELLIS, TIA T. TROUT PEREZ , KIRKLAND & ELLIS, W. RANDOLPH TESLIK , AKIN GUMP STRAUSS HAUER & FELD LLP, BRIAN BORCHARD , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, ERIC FIELD , AKIN GUMP STRAUSS HAUER & FELD, ERICA ZOLNER , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, GREGORY TSONIS , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, JORDAN M. HEINZ , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP & SCOTT W. FOWKES , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP.

THE ALLSTATE CORPORATION, THE ALLSTATE CORPORATION, Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER Q. KING , DENTON US LLP, DONALD R. LIVINGSTON , AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS HAUER & FELD LLP, DONNA M. WELCH , KIRKLAND & ELLIS, DREW G.A. PEEL , RACHLIS DUFF ADLER & PEEL LLC, EDWARD F. MANNINO , AKIN GUMP STRAUSS HAUER & FELD LLP, KATHERINE M. KATCHEN , AKIN GUMP STRAUSS HAUER & FELD, LLP, PETER A. BELLACOSA , KIRKLAND & ELLIS, RICHARD C. GODFREY , KIRKLAND & ELLIS, W. RANDOLPH TESLIK , AKIN GUMP STRAUSS HAUER & FELD LLP, ERICA ZOLNER , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, GREGORY TSONIS , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, JORDAN M. HEINZ , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP & SCOTT W. FOWKES , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP.

GARY NEWSOM, Intervenor Defendant, represented by ALAN L. YATVIN , POPPER & YATVIN, COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, JAMES ALDO VAGNINI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP, JUSTIN S. GILBERT , GILBERT RUSSELL MCWHERTER SCOTT BOBBITT PLC, ROBERT J. VALLI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI, LLP & SARA WYN KANE , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP.

THOMAS SCHNEIDER, Movant, represented by COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, JAMES ALDO VAGNINI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP, ROBERT J. VALLI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI, LLP & SIDNEY L. GOLD , SIDNEY L. GOLD & ASSOCIATES, PC.

PHILLIP ANDERSON, Movant, represented by ALAN L. YATVIN , POPPER & YATVIN, COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, JUSTIN S. GILBERT , GILBERT RUSSELL MCWHERTER SCOTT BOBBITT PLC, ROBERT J. VALLI , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI, LLP & SARA WYN KANE , VALLI KANE & VAGNINI LLP.

EEOC, Interested Party, represented by CARL FELIX MILLER , EQUAL EMPLOYMENT U.S. OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION, IRIS SANTIAGO FLORES , EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY COM, BRIAN M. ERCOLE , MORGAN LEWIS, COLEEN M. MEEHAN , MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP, DAVID W. MARSTON, Jr. , MORGAN, LEWIS AND BOCKIUS LLP, JACQUELINE C. GORBEY , MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP & MICHAEL D. LIEDER , SPRENGER & LANG.


ORDER-MEMORANDUM

AND NOW, this 29th day of January 2018, upon considering Defendants' Motion for summary judgment on Plaintiffs' ADEA disparate treatment claims (Count IV) (ECF Doc. No. 1250), Plaintiffs' Response (ECF Doc. No. 1257), Defendants' Reply (ECF Doc. No. 1261...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases