PHOENIX BEVERAGES, INC. v. EXXON MOBIL CORPORATION

No. 12 Civ. 3771(AMD) (JO).

PHOENIX BEVERAGES, INC. et al., Plaintiffs, v. EXXON MOBIL CORPORATION, EXXONMOBIL RESEARCH AND ENGINEERING COMPANY, and QUANTA RESOURCES CORPORATION, Defendants. EXXON MOBIL CORPORATIONS and QUANTA RESOURCES CORPORATION, Third-Party Plaintiffs, ACE WASTE OIL, INC., et al. Third-Party Defendants.

United States District Court, E.D. New York.

August 14, 2017.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 42 U.S.C. § 6901
Cause: 42 U.S.C. § 6901 Environmental Cleanup Expenses
Nature of Suit: 893 Environmental Matters
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Phoenix Beverages, Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Michael Goodstein , Hunsucker Goodstein PC.

Phoenix Beverages, Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C., pro hac vice & Anne E. Lynch , Hunsucker Goodstein PC.

Rodb LLC, Plaintiff, represented by Michael Goodstein , Hunsucker Goodstein PC, Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C., pro hac vice & Anne E. Lynch , Hunsucker Goodstein PC.

Windmill Distributing Company, L.P., Plaintiff, represented by Michael Goodstein , Hunsucker Goodstein PC, Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C., pro hac vice & Anne E. Lynch , Hunsucker Goodstein PC.

Up from the Ashes, Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Michael Goodstein , Hunsucker Goodstein PC, Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C., pro hac vice & Anne E. Lynch , Hunsucker Goodstein PC.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice & Maura W. Sommer , McCusker Anselmi Rosen & Carvelli, P.C..

ExxonMobil Research and Engineering Company, Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Noxell Corporation, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Puja Bhatia , Nossaman LLP, pro hac vice, Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan, pro hac vice & Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan.

New York City Transit Authority, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Gordon J. Johnson , Metropolitan Transportation Authority & Lawrence C. Jenkins , Lawrence C. Jenkins.

TDY Industries, LLC, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Duke K. McCall, III , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP, pro hac vice, John A. Vassallo, III , Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP, Michael James Ableson , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP & Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

Noxell Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan & Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan.

Noxell Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Puja Bhatia , Nossaman LLP & Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan.

Noxell Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Puja Bhatia , Nossaman LLP.

Noxell Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan & Puja Bhatia , Nossaman LLP.

Noxell Corporation, formerly known as Procter & Gamble Haircare LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan, Puja Bhatia , Nossaman LLP, Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan, Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan, Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan, Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan, Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan, Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan & Reed W. Neuman , Nossaman LLP/O'Connor & Hannan.

Kelly, Drye and Warren, LLP, Interested Party, represented by Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C..

DMJ Associates, LLC, Interested Party, represented by Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C..

Waste Management of New York, LLC, Interested Party, represented by Sharon Oras Morgan , Fox Rothschild LLP.

ExxonMobil Research and Engineering Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

ExxonMobil Research and Engineering Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Phoenix Beverages, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Michael Goodstein , Hunsucker Goodstein PC, Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C. & Anne E. Lynch , Hunsucker Goodstein PC.

Rodb LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Michael Goodstein , Hunsucker Goodstein PC, Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C. & Anne E. Lynch , Hunsucker Goodstein PC.

Up from the Ashes, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Michael Goodstein , Hunsucker Goodstein PC, Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C. & Anne E. Lynch , Hunsucker Goodstein PC.

Windmill Distributing Company, L.P., Counter Defendant, represented by Michael Goodstein , Hunsucker Goodstein PC, Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C. & Anne E. Lynch , Hunsucker Goodstein PC.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

ExxonMobil Research and Engineering Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Phoenix Beverages, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Michael Goodstein , Hunsucker Goodstein PC, Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C. & Anne E. Lynch , Hunsucker Goodstein PC.

Rodb LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Michael Goodstein , Hunsucker Goodstein PC, Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C. & Anne E. Lynch , Hunsucker Goodstein PC.

Up from the Ashes, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Michael Goodstein , Hunsucker Goodstein PC, Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C. & Anne E. Lynch , Hunsucker Goodstein PC.

Windmill Distributing Company, L.P., Counter Defendant, represented by Michael Goodstein , Hunsucker Goodstein PC, Stacey Heather Myers , Hunsucker Goodstein & Nelson, P.C. & Anne E. Lynch , Hunsucker Goodstein PC.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

AVCO Corporation, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David A. Roth , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP & Emily A. Kaller , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP.

Conocophillips Company, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Susan C. Gieser , Waters, McPherson, McNeill, P.C..

Crosman Corporation, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Danielle Elizabeth Mettler , Hiscock & Barclay LLP & Thomas F. Walsh , Hiscock & Barclay LLP.

Crown Cork & Seal Co., Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Thomas J. Perry , Golub & Isabel, P.C..

Emhart Teknologies LLC, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

NEAPCO, INC., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

NL Industries, Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Novelis Corporation, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Mark D. Kindt , Mark D. Kindt, pro hac vice.

Peabody Coastal, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Allison A. Torrence , Jenner & Block LLP & Katya T. Jestin , Jenner & Block LLP.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Robert R. Tyson , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC, Dennis A. Lalli , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC & Thomas R. Smith , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC.

Rexam Beverage Can Company, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Camille V. Otero , Gibbons, P.C..

River Terminal Development, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Sunoco, Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Harold L. Segall , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C., Bina R. Reddy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC, Hana V. Vizcarra , Beveridge & Diamond, PC, Michael G. Murphy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC & Timothy M. Sullivan , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C., pro hac vice.

United Site Services, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Richard Eric Leff , McGivney & Kluger, P.C..

United States Department of the Coast Guard, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

United States Department of the Navy, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

United States Department of Defense, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Waste Management of Maryland, Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Oksana Gaussy Wright , Fox Rothschild LLP & Sharon Oras Morgan , Fox Rothschild LLP, pro hac vice.

Wyman-Gordon Company, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by John Patrick Campbell , Schenck Price Smith & King & Sean Monaghan , Schenck Price Smith & King LLP, pro hac vice.

Alcoa Inc.,, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Gregory Seth Glickman , Hinshaw & Culberstson LLP, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

BASF Corporation, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Keith Patrick McManus , Bressler, Amery & Ross P.C., Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Beazer East, Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Lindsay P. Howard , Babst, Calland, Clements & Zomnir, P.C., pro hac vice, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Borg Warner Inc, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Gregory Seth Glickman , Hinshaw & Culberstson LLP, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Carrier Corporation, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole, Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Electric Boat Corporation., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Norman Walter Bernstein , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC, Mary Elizabeth Desmond , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Ford Motor Company, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Doreen A. Simmons , Hancock & Estabrook, LLP, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Honeywell International, Inc. (f/k/a Allied Signal), ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Kerry Ann Dziubek , Arnold & Porter, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Ingersoll Rand Company, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Northrop Grumman Corp. (a/k/a Grumman Aerospace Corp.) (a/k/a TRW, Inc.), ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Aaron Gershonowitz , Webster & Sheffield, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Quality Carriers, Inc. (f/k/a Chemical Leaman Tank Lines, Inc.), ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Gregory Seth Glickman , Hinshaw & Culberstson LLP, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Reynolds Metals Co. (a/k/a Reynolds Aluminum), ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Gregory Seth Glickman , Hinshaw & Culberstson LLP, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Rockwell Automation (a/k/a Rockwell International), ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Andrew Kolesar , Thompson Hine LLP, pro hac vice, Barry M. Kazan , Thompson Hine LLP, Emily S. Huggins , Thompson Hine LLP, pro hac vice, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole, Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Stanley Black & Decker (f/k/a The Stanley Works), ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Andrew Kolesar , Thompson Hine LLP, pro hac vice, Barry M. Kazan , Thompson Hine LLP, Emily S. Huggins , Thompson Hine LLP, pro hac vice, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

United Technologies Corporation (a/k/a Pratt & Whitney), ThirdParty Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole, Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Quanta Resources Corporation, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Donald B. Mitchell , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

United States of America, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office, Richard K. Hayes , United States Attorneys Office, Eastern District Of New York & Kevan Cleary , United States Attorney's Office.

AVCO Corporation, also known as AVCO Lycoming, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by David A. Roth , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP & Emily A. Kaller , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP.

Conocophillips Company, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Susan C. Gieser , Waters, McPherson, McNeill, P.C..

Crown Cork & Seal Co., Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Thomas J. Perry , Golub & Isabel, P.C..

Emhart Teknologies LLC, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

NEAPCO, INC., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

NL Industries, Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Christopher R. Gibson , Archer & Greiner, P.C. & Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Peabody Coastal, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Katya T. Jestin , Jenner & Block LLP.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, Pro Se.

Rexam Beverage Can Company, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Camille V. Otero , Gibbons, P.C. & William S. Hatfield , Gibbons P.C..

River Terminal Development, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Sunoco, Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Michael G. Murphy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC & Timothy M. Sullivan , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C., pro hac vice.

TDY Industries, Inc, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

United Site Services, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Richard Eric Leff , McGivney & Kluger, P.C..

United States Department of the Air Force, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

United States Department of the Army, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Waste Management of Maryland, Inc., ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Kasey DeSantis , Fox Rothschild LLP, pro hac vice.

Wyman-Gordon Company, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by John Patrick Campbell , Schenck Price Smith & King & Sean Monaghan , Schenck Price Smith & King LLP, pro hac vice.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

ExxonMobil Research and Engineering Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., also known as Revere Copper & Brass Incorporated, Counter Claimant, represented by Thomas R. Smith , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., also known as Revere Copper & Brass Incorporated, Counter Claimant, represented by Thomas R. Smith , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Crosman Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Thomas F. Walsh , Hiscock & Barclay LLP.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

New York City Transit Authority, Counter Claimant, represented by Gordon J. Johnson , Metropolitan Transportation Authority.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

ExxonMobil Research and Engineering Company, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

New York City Transit Authority, Counter Claimant, represented by Gordon J. Johnson , Metropolitan Transportation Authority.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Crosman Corporation, Counter Claimant, represented by Danielle Elizabeth Mettler , Hiscock & Barclay LLP & Thomas F. Walsh , Hiscock & Barclay LLP.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

NL Industries, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

NL Industries, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

NL Industries, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Quanta Resources Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

NL Industries, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

ExxonMobil Research and Engineering Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

NEAPCO, INC., Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

United States Department of the Air Force, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

United States Department of the Navy, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Crown Cork & Seal Co., Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas J. Perry , Golub & Isabel, P.C..

Waste Management of Maryland, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Sharon Oras Morgan , Fox Rothschild LLP.

AVCO Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David A. Roth , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP & Emily A. Kaller , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert R. Tyson , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC & Thomas R. Smith , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC.

Simmonds Precision Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

United States Department of the Coast Guard, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

United States Department of the Army, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

NL Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

River Terminal Development, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Northrop Grumman Corp. (a/k/a Grumman Aerospace Corp.) (a/k/a TRW, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Aaron Gershonowitz , Webster & Sheffield.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Alcoa Inc.,, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Peabody Coastal, Cross Defendant, represented by Katya T. Jestin , Jenner & Block LLP.

Rockwell Automation (a/k/a Rockwell International), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Borg Warner Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Seth Glickman , Hinshaw & Culberstson LLP & Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Emhart Teknologies LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

United Technologies Corporation (a/k/a Pratt & Whitney), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Electric Boat Corporation., A General Dynamics Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Norman Walter Bernstein , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC & Mary Elizabeth Desmond , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Rexam Beverage Can Company, Cross Defendant, represented by William S. Hatfield , Gibbons P.C..

Crosman Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Elizabeth Mettler , Hiscock & Barclay LLP & Thomas F. Walsh , Hiscock & Barclay LLP.

Wyman-Gordon Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John Patrick Campbell , Schenck Price Smith & King.

Honeywell International, Inc. (f/k/a Allied Signal), Cross Defendant, represented by Kerry Ann Dziubek , Arnold & Porter & Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Novelis Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Mark D. Kindt , Mark D. Kindt.

Sunoco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael G. Murphy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC & Timothy M. Sullivan , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C..

Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

New York City Transit Authority, Cross Defendant, represented by Gordon J. Johnson , Metropolitan Transportation Authority & Lawrence C. Jenkins , Lawrence C. Jenkins.

BASF Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David Paul Schneider , Bressler, Amery & Ross, pro hac vice.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Reynolds Metals Co. (a/k/a Reynolds Aluminum), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Quality Carriers, Inc. (f/k/a Chemical Leaman Tank Lines, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

River Terminal Development, Cross Claimant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

NEAPCO, INC., Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

United States Department of the Air Force, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

United States Department of the Navy, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Crown Cork & Seal Co., Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas J. Perry , Golub & Isabel, P.C..

Waste Management of Maryland, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Sharon Oras Morgan , Fox Rothschild LLP.

AVCO Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David A. Roth , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP & Emily A. Kaller , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert R. Tyson , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC & Thomas R. Smith , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC.

Simmonds Precision Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

United States Department of the Coast Guard, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

United States Department of the Army, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

NL Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Northrop Grumman Corp. (a/k/a Grumman Aerospace Corp.) (a/k/a TRW, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Aaron Gershonowitz , Webster & Sheffield.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Alcoa Inc.,, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Peabody Coastal, Cross Defendant, represented by Katya T. Jestin , Jenner & Block LLP.

Borg Warner Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Emhart Teknologies LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

United Technologies Corporation (a/k/a Pratt & Whitney), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole, Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP & Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Electric Boat Corporation., Cross Defendant, represented by Norman Walter Bernstein , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC & Mary Elizabeth Desmond , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Rexam Beverage Can Company, Cross Defendant, represented by William S. Hatfield , Gibbons P.C..

Crosman Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Elizabeth Mettler , Hiscock & Barclay LLP & Thomas F. Walsh , Hiscock & Barclay LLP.

Wyman-Gordon Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John Patrick Campbell , Schenck Price Smith & King.

Honeywell International, Inc. (f/k/a Allied Signal), Cross Defendant, represented by Kerry Ann Dziubek , Arnold & Porter.

Novelis Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Mark D. Kindt , Mark D. Kindt.

Sunoco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael G. Murphy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC & Timothy M. Sullivan , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C..

Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

New York City Transit Authority, Cross Defendant, represented by Gordon J. Johnson , Metropolitan Transportation Authority & Lawrence C. Jenkins , Lawrence C. Jenkins.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Reynolds Metals Co. (a/k/a Reynolds Aluminum), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Beazer East, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Carrier Corporation, (Carlyle Compressor Division), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Quality Carriers, Inc. (f/k/a Chemical Leaman Tank Lines, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

River Terminal Development, Counter Claimant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

NEAPCO, INC., Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

United States Department of the Air Force, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

United States Department of the Navy, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Crown Cork & Seal Co., Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas J. Perry , Golub & Isabel, P.C..

Waste Management of Maryland, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Sharon Oras Morgan , Fox Rothschild LLP.

AVCO Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David A. Roth , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP & Emily A. Kaller , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert R. Tyson , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC & Thomas R. Smith , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC.

Simmonds Precision Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole, Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP & Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

United States Department of the Coast Guard, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

United States Department of the Army, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

NL Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

River Terminal Development, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Northrop Grumman Corp. (a/k/a Grumman Aerospace Corp.) (a/k/a TRW, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Aaron Gershonowitz , Webster & Sheffield.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Alcoa Inc.,, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Peabody Coastal, Cross Defendant, represented by Katya T. Jestin , Jenner & Block LLP.

Borg Warner Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Emhart Teknologies LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

United Technologies Corporation (a/k/a Pratt & Whitney), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Electric Boat Corporation., A General Dynamics Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Norman Walter Bernstein , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC & Mary Elizabeth Desmond , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Rexam Beverage Can Company, Cross Defendant, represented by William S. Hatfield , Gibbons P.C..

Crosman Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Elizabeth Mettler , Hiscock & Barclay LLP & Thomas F. Walsh , Hiscock & Barclay LLP.

Wyman-Gordon Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John Patrick Campbell , Schenck Price Smith & King.

Honeywell International, Inc. (f/k/a Allied Signal), Cross Defendant, represented by Kerry Ann Dziubek , Arnold & Porter.

Novelis Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Mark D. Kindt , Mark D. Kindt.

Sunoco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael G. Murphy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC & Timothy M. Sullivan , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C..

Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

New York City Transit Authority, Cross Defendant, represented by Gordon J. Johnson , Metropolitan Transportation Authority & Lawrence C. Jenkins , Lawrence C. Jenkins.

Reynolds Metals Co. (a/k/a Reynolds Aluminum), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Quality Carriers, Inc. (f/k/a Chemical Leaman Tank Lines, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

River Terminal Development, Cross Claimant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

NEAPCO, INC., Cross Defendant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

United States Department of the Navy, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Crown Cork & Seal Co., Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas J. Perry , Golub & Isabel, P.C..

Waste Management of Maryland, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Sharon Oras Morgan , Fox Rothschild LLP.

AVCO Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David A. Roth , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP & Emily A. Kaller , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert R. Tyson , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC & Thomas R. Smith , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC.

Simmonds Precision Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Northrop Grumman Corp. (a/k/a Grumman Aerospace Corp.) (a/k/a TRW, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Aaron Gershonowitz , Webster & Sheffield.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

NL Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Peabody Coastal, Cross Defendant, represented by Katya T. Jestin , Jenner & Block LLP.

Borg Warner Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Emhart Teknologies LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

United Technologies Corporation (a/k/a Pratt & Whitney), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Rexam Beverage Can Company, Cross Defendant, represented by William S. Hatfield , Gibbons P.C..

Crosman Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Elizabeth Mettler , Hiscock & Barclay LLP & Thomas F. Walsh , Hiscock & Barclay LLP.

Wyman-Gordon Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John Patrick Campbell , Schenck Price Smith & King.

Novelis Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Mark D. Kindt , Mark D. Kindt.

Sunoco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Michael G. Murphy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC & Timothy M. Sullivan , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C..

New York City Transit Authority, Cross Defendant, represented by Gordon J. Johnson , Metropolitan Transportation Authority & Lawrence C. Jenkins , Lawrence C. Jenkins.

United States Department of the Coast Guard, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Reynolds Metals Co. (a/k/a Reynolds Aluminum), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Quality Carriers, Inc. (f/k/a Chemical Leaman Tank Lines, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

United States Department of the Air Force, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

United States Department of the Army, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Alcoa Inc.,, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Electric Boat Corporation., A General Dynamics Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Norman Walter Bernstein , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC & Mary Elizabeth Desmond , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Honeywell International, Inc. (f/k/a Allied Signal), Cross Defendant, represented by Kerry Ann Dziubek , Arnold & Porter.

Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Carrier Corporation, (Carlyle Compressor Division), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

River Terminal Development, Counter Claimant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Wyman-Gordon Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Sean Monaghan , Schenck Price Smith & King LLP, pro hac vice.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Wyman-Gordon Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Sean Monaghan , Schenck Price Smith & King LLP, pro hac vice.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

NEAPCO, INC., Cross Claimant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

Ford Motor Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

TDY Industries, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

United States Department of the Navy, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Crown Cork & Seal Co., Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas J. Perry , Golub & Isabel, P.C..

Waste Management of Maryland, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Oksana Gaussy Wright , Fox Rothschild LLP & Sharon Oras Morgan , Fox Rothschild LLP.

AVCO Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David A. Roth , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP & Emily A. Kaller , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert R. Tyson , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC & Thomas R. Smith , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC.

Simmonds Precision Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Northrop Grumman Corp. (a/k/a Grumman Aerospace Corp.) (a/k/a TRW, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Aaron Gershonowitz , Webster & Sheffield & Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

NL Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Peabody Coastal, Cross Defendant, represented by Katya T. Jestin , Jenner & Block LLP.

Borg Warner Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Emhart Teknologies LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

United Technologies Corporation (a/k/a Pratt & Whitney), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Rexam Beverage Can Company, Cross Defendant, represented by William S. Hatfield , Gibbons P.C..

Crosman Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Elizabeth Mettler , Hiscock & Barclay LLP & Thomas F. Walsh , Hiscock & Barclay LLP.

Wyman-Gordon Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John Patrick Campbell , Schenck Price Smith & King & Sean Monaghan , Schenck Price Smith & King LLP, pro hac vice.

Novelis Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Mark D. Kindt , Mark D. Kindt.

Sunoco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Bina R. Reddy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC, Michael G. Murphy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC & Timothy M. Sullivan , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C..

New York City Transit Authority, Cross Defendant, represented by Gordon J. Johnson , Metropolitan Transportation Authority & Lawrence C. Jenkins , Lawrence C. Jenkins.

United States Department of the Coast Guard, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

River Terminal Development, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Reynolds Metals Co. (a/k/a Reynolds Aluminum), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Quality Carriers, Inc. (f/k/a Chemical Leaman Tank Lines, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

United States Department of the Air Force, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

TDY Industries, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

United States Department of the Army, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Alcoa Inc.,, Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Seth Glickman , Hinshaw & Culberstson LLP & Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Electric Boat Corporation., Cross Defendant, represented by Norman Walter Bernstein , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC & Mary Elizabeth Desmond , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Honeywell International, Inc. (f/k/a Allied Signal), Cross Defendant, represented by Kerry Ann Dziubek , Arnold & Porter.

Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole, Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP & Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Carrier Corporation, (Carlyle Compressor Division), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

NEAPCO, INC., Counter Claimant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

NEAPCO, INC., Cross Claimant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

TDY Industries, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

United States Department of the Navy, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Crown Cork & Seal Co., Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas J. Perry , Golub & Isabel, P.C..

Waste Management of Maryland, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Oksana Gaussy Wright , Fox Rothschild LLP & Sharon Oras Morgan , Fox Rothschild LLP.

AVCO Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David A. Roth , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP & Emily A. Kaller , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert R. Tyson , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC & Thomas R. Smith , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC.

Simmonds Precision Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Northrop Grumman Corp. (a/k/a Grumman Aerospace Corp.) (a/k/a TRW, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Aaron Gershonowitz , Webster & Sheffield.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

NL Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Peabody Coastal, Cross Defendant, represented by Katya T. Jestin , Jenner & Block LLP & Keri L. Holleb Hotaling , Jenner & Block LLP.

Borg Warner Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Emhart Teknologies LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

United Technologies Corporation (a/k/a Pratt & Whitney), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Rexam Beverage Can Company, Cross Defendant, represented by William S. Hatfield , Gibbons P.C..

Crosman Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Elizabeth Mettler , Hiscock & Barclay LLP & Thomas F. Walsh , Hiscock & Barclay LLP.

Wyman-Gordon Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John Patrick Campbell , Schenck Price Smith & King & Sean Monaghan , Schenck Price Smith & King LLP, pro hac vice.

Novelis Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Mark D. Kindt , Mark D. Kindt.

Sunoco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Bina R. Reddy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC, Michael G. Murphy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC & Timothy M. Sullivan , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C..

New York City Transit Authority, Cross Defendant, represented by Gordon J. Johnson , Metropolitan Transportation Authority & Lawrence C. Jenkins , Lawrence C. Jenkins.

United States Department of the Coast Guard, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

River Terminal Development, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Quanta Resources Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Reynolds Metals Co. (a/k/a Reynolds Aluminum), Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Seth Glickman , Hinshaw & Culberstson LLP & Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Quality Carriers, Inc. (f/k/a Chemical Leaman Tank Lines, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

United States Department of the Air Force, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

TDY Industries, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

United States Department of the Army, Cross Defendant, represented by Kevan Cleary , United States Attorney's Office & Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Alcoa Inc.,, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Electric Boat Corporation., Cross Defendant, represented by Norman Walter Bernstein , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC & Mary Elizabeth Desmond , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Honeywell International, Inc. (f/k/a Allied Signal), Cross Defendant, represented by Kerry Ann Dziubek , Arnold & Porter.

Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

NEAPCO, INC., Counter Claimant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

NEAPCO, INC., Cross Claimant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

TDY Industries, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

United States Department of the Navy, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Crown Cork & Seal Co., Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas J. Perry , Golub & Isabel, P.C..

Waste Management of Maryland, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Oksana Gaussy Wright , Fox Rothschild LLP & Sharon Oras Morgan , Fox Rothschild LLP.

AVCO Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David A. Roth , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP & Emily A. Kaller , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert R. Tyson , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC & Thomas R. Smith , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC.

Northrop Grumman Corp. (a/k/a Grumman Aerospace Corp.) (a/k/a TRW, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Aaron Gershonowitz , Webster & Sheffield.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

NL Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Peabody Coastal, Cross Defendant, represented by Katya T. Jestin , Jenner & Block LLP.

Borg Warner Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Emhart Teknologies LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

United Technologies Corporation (a/k/a Pratt & Whitney), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Rexam Beverage Can Company, Cross Defendant, represented by William S. Hatfield , Gibbons P.C..

Crosman Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Elizabeth Mettler , Hiscock & Barclay LLP & Thomas F. Walsh , Hiscock & Barclay LLP.

Wyman-Gordon Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John Patrick Campbell , Schenck Price Smith & King & Sean Monaghan , Schenck Price Smith & King LLP.

Novelis Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Mark D. Kindt , Mark D. Kindt.

Sunoco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Bina R. Reddy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC, Michael G. Murphy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC & Timothy M. Sullivan , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C..

New York City Transit Authority, Cross Defendant, represented by Gordon J. Johnson , Metropolitan Transportation Authority & Lawrence C. Jenkins , Lawrence C. Jenkins.

United States Department of the Coast Guard, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

River Terminal Development, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Quanta Resources Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Reynolds Metals Co. (a/k/a Reynolds Aluminum), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Quality Carriers, Inc. (f/k/a Chemical Leaman Tank Lines, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

United Site Services, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Eric Leff , McGivney & Kluger, P.C..

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

United States Department of the Air Force, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

TDY Industries, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

United States Department of the Army, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Alcoa Inc.,, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Electric Boat Corporation., A General Dynamics Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Norman Walter Bernstein , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC & Mary Elizabeth Desmond , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Honeywell International, Inc. (f/k/a Allied Signal), Cross Defendant, represented by Kerry Ann Dziubek , Arnold & Porter.

Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

NEAPCO, INC., Counter Claimant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

NEAPCO, INC., Cross Claimant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

Crown Cork & Seal Co., Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas J. Perry , Golub & Isabel, P.C..

Waste Management of Maryland, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Oksana Gaussy Wright , Fox Rothschild LLP & Sharon Oras Morgan , Fox Rothschild LLP.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert R. Tyson , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC & Thomas R. Smith , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Peabody Coastal, Cross Defendant, represented by Katya T. Jestin , Jenner & Block LLP.

United Technologies Corporation (a/k/a Pratt & Whitney), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Rexam Beverage Can Company, Cross Defendant, represented by William S. Hatfield , Gibbons P.C..

Crosman Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Elizabeth Mettler , Hiscock & Barclay LLP & Thomas F. Walsh , Hiscock & Barclay LLP.

Wyman-Gordon Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John Patrick Campbell , Schenck Price Smith & King & Sean Monaghan , Schenck Price Smith & King LLP.

TDY Industries, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

Sunoco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Bina R. Reddy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC, Michael G. Murphy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC & Timothy M. Sullivan , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C..

Emhart Teknologies LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

River Terminal Development, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

United States Department of the Air Force, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

TDY Industries, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

United States Department of the Coast Guard, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

NL Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Alcoa Inc.,, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Honeywell International, Inc. (f/k/a Allied Signal), Cross Defendant, represented by Kerry Ann Dziubek , Arnold & Porter.

Ingersoll Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

AVCO Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David A. Roth , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP & Emily A. Kaller , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP.

BASF Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David Paul Schneider , Bressler, Amery & Ross, pro hac vice.

Novelis Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Mark D. Kindt , Mark D. Kindt.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

United States Department of the Navy, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Northrop Grumman Corp. (a/k/a Grumman Aerospace Corp.) (a/k/a TRW, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Aaron Gershonowitz , Webster & Sheffield.

Borg Warner Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

New York City Transit Authority, Cross Defendant, represented by Gordon J. Johnson , Metropolitan Transportation Authority & Lawrence C. Jenkins , Lawrence C. Jenkins.

Reynolds Metals Co. (a/k/a Reynolds Aluminum), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Quality Carriers, Inc. (f/k/a Chemical Leaman Tank Lines, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

United Site Services, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Eric Leff , McGivney & Kluger, P.C..

United States Department of the Army, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Electric Boat Corporation., Cross Defendant, represented by Norman Walter Bernstein , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC & Mary Elizabeth Desmond , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC.

Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Carrier Corporation, (Carlyle Compressor Division), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

NEAPCO, INC., Counter Claimant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

Ford Motor Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Doreen A. Simmons , Hancock & Estabrook, LLP.

Crown Cork & Seal Co., Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas J. Perry , Golub & Isabel, P.C..

Waste Management of Maryland, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Oksana Gaussy Wright , Fox Rothschild LLP & Sharon Oras Morgan , Fox Rothschild LLP.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert R. Tyson , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC & Thomas R. Smith , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Peabody Coastal, Cross Defendant, represented by Katya T. Jestin , Jenner & Block LLP.

United Technologies Corporation (a/k/a Pratt & Whitney), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Rexam Beverage Can Company, Cross Defendant, represented by William S. Hatfield , Gibbons P.C..

Crosman Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Elizabeth Mettler , Hiscock & Barclay LLP & Thomas F. Walsh , Hiscock & Barclay LLP.

TDY Industries, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

Sunoco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Harold L. Segall , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C., Bina R. Reddy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC, Michael G. Murphy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC & Timothy M. Sullivan , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C..

Emhart Teknologies LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

River Terminal Development, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Quanta Resources Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Stanley Black & Decker (f/k/a The Stanley Works), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

United States Department of the Air Force, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

TDY Industries, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Duke K. McCall, III , Bingham McCutchen & Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

United States Department of the Coast Guard, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

NL Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Alcoa Inc.,, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office & Richard K. Hayes , United States Attorneys Office, Eastern District Of New York.

Honeywell International, Inc. (f/k/a Allied Signal), Cross Defendant, represented by Kerry Ann Dziubek , Arnold & Porter.

AVCO Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David A. Roth , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP & Emily A. Kaller , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP.

BASF Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Keith Patrick McManus , Bressler, Amery & Ross P.C..

Novelis Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Mark D. Kindt , Mark D. Kindt.

United States Department of the Navy, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Northrop Grumman Corp. (a/k/a Grumman Aerospace Corp.) (a/k/a TRW, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Aaron Gershonowitz , Webster & Sheffield.

Borg Warner Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

New York City Transit Authority, Cross Defendant, represented by Gordon J. Johnson , Metropolitan Transportation Authority & Lawrence C. Jenkins , Lawrence C. Jenkins.

Reynolds Metals Co. (a/k/a Reynolds Aluminum), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Quality Carriers, Inc. (f/k/a Chemical Leaman Tank Lines, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Gregory Seth Glickman , Hinshaw & Culberstson LLP, Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

United Site Services, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Eric Leff , McGivney & Kluger, P.C..

United States Department of the Army, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Electric Boat Corporation., Cross Defendant, represented by Norman Walter Bernstein , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC & Mary Elizabeth Desmond , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC.

Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Carrier Corporation, (Carlyle Compressor Division), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

NEAPCO, INC., Counter Claimant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

NEAPCO, INC., Cross Claimant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

Ford Motor Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Doreen A. Simmons , Hancock & Estabrook, LLP.

Crown Cork & Seal Co., Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas J. Perry , Golub & Isabel, P.C..

Waste Management of Maryland, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Oksana Gaussy Wright , Fox Rothschild LLP & Sharon Oras Morgan , Fox Rothschild LLP.

Revere Copper Products, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert R. Tyson , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC & Thomas R. Smith , Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC.

United States Department of Defense, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Peabody Coastal, Cross Defendant, represented by Katya T. Jestin , Jenner & Block LLP.

United Technologies Corporation (a/k/a Pratt & Whitney), Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Rexam Beverage Can Company, Cross Defendant, represented by William S. Hatfield , Gibbons P.C..

Crosman Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Elizabeth Mettler , Hiscock & Barclay LLP & Thomas F. Walsh , Hiscock & Barclay LLP.

Wyman-Gordon Company, Cross Defendant, represented by John Patrick Campbell , Schenck Price Smith & King & Sean Monaghan , Schenck Price Smith & King LLP.

TDY Industries, Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

Sunoco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Harold L. Segall , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C., Bina R. Reddy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC, Michael G. Murphy , Beveridge & Diamond, PC & Timothy M. Sullivan , Beveridge & Diamond, P.C..

Emhart Teknologies LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

River Terminal Development, Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

Quanta Resources Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Riesel , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. & Jennifer Lynn Coghlan , Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C..

United States Department of the Air Force, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

TDY Industries, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Duke K. McCall, III , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP, John A. Vassallo, III , Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP & Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

United States Department of the Coast Guard, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

NL Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Charles Ritson , Archer & Greiner, P.C..

Alcoa Inc.,, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

United States of America, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office & Richard K. Hayes , United States Attorneys Office, Eastern District Of New York.

Honeywell International, Inc. (f/k/a Allied Signal), Cross Defendant, represented by Kerry Ann Dziubek , Arnold & Porter.

AVCO Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by David A. Roth , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP & Emily A. Kaller , Greenbaum, Rowe, Smith & Davis LLP.

BASF Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Keith Patrick McManus , Bressler, Amery & Ross P.C. & Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Novelis Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Mark D. Kindt , Mark D. Kindt.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

United States Department of the Navy, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Northrop Grumman Corp. (a/k/a Grumman Aerospace Corp.) (a/k/a TRW, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Aaron Gershonowitz , Webster & Sheffield.

Borg Warner Inc, Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

New York City Transit Authority, Cross Defendant, represented by Gordon J. Johnson , Metropolitan Transportation Authority & Lawrence C. Jenkins , Lawrence C. Jenkins.

Reynolds Metals Co. (a/k/a Reynolds Aluminum), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Quality Carriers, Inc. (f/k/a Chemical Leaman Tank Lines, Inc.), Cross Defendant, represented by Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP & Thomas D. Lupo , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

United Site Services, Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Eric Leff , McGivney & Kluger, P.C..

United States Department of the Army, Cross Defendant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office.

Electric Boat Corporation., A General Dynamics Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Norman Walter Bernstein , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC, Mary Elizabeth Desmond , N.W. Bernstein & Associates, LLC & Theresa Concepcion , Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP.

Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

Carrier Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by James Patrick Ray , Robinson & Cole & Megan E. Baroni , Robinson & Cole LLP.

NEAPCO, INC., Counter Claimant, represented by Timothy E. Corriston , Connell Foley.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC, pro hac vice.

TDY Industries, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Duke K. McCall, III , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP, John A. Vassallo, III , Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP, Michael James Ableson , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP & Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC.

TDY Industries, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Duke K. McCall, III , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP, Michael James Ableson , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP & Stephen Scotch-Marmo , Morgan Lewis & Bokius LLP.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Donald B. Mitchell , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Emhart Teknologies LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Donald B. Mitchell , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

Emhart Teknologies LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Jerome Muys , Sullivan & Worcester LLP.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC.

United States of America, Counter Claimant, represented by Kevan Cleary , United States Attorney's Office.

Quanta Resources Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Allen G. Reiter , Arent Fox LLP, Donald B. Mitchell , Arent Fox LLP, Adrienne M. Hollander , Arent Fox LLP & Matthew Scott Trokenheim , Arent Fox LLP.

United States of America, Counter Claimant, represented by Sandra Lynn Levy , United States Attorneys Office, Richard K. Hayes , United States Attorneys Office, Eastern District Of New York & Kevan Cleary , United States Attorney's Office.

Exxon Mobil Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Andrew E. Anselmi , McCusker, Anselmi, Rosen & Carvelli, PC.


NOT FOR PUBLICATION

MEMORANDUM DECISION AND ORDER

The plaintiffs. Phoenix Beverages, Inc. and its affiliated companies, initiated this action on July 31, 2012 against Exxon Mobil Corporation, ExxonMobil Research and Engineering Company, and Quanta...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases