SANGIMINO v. BAYER CORP.

No. C 17-01488 WHA.

ELIZABETH SANGIMINO, et al., Plaintiffs, v. BAYER CORP., et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, N.D. California.

June 9, 2017.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 28 U.S.C. § 1331
Cause: 28 U.S.C. § 1331 Fed. Question: Personal Injury
Nature of Suit: 367 Personal Injury: Health Care / Pharmaceutical Personal Injury Product Liability
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Elizabeth Ann Sangimino, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice.

Elizabeth Ann Sangimino, Plaintiff, represented by Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Ananhi Gonzalez, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Michelle Scheifen, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Paige Tucker, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Melissa Byreley, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Jessica Gutherie, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Tarquenia Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Tekesha Sant-Val, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Kisha Vinson, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Katrina Daniels, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Solmarie Montes-Arroyo, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Jeanette Stiffler, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Barbara Turner, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Kiri Horne, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Amanda Sue Lory, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Chenoa Fore, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Cassie Lynn Downes, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Maria Mendoza, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Christine Minor, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Dana Davidson, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Tasha Oglesby, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Jeanette Powles-Dies, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Melissa Ragan, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Jodi Kirksley, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Akasha Terrier, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Krisila Baker, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Minerva Blackmon, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

A'randa Gary, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Tamara Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Telleia Little, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Lauren Max, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Chuteah McJunkins, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Elizabeth Sipe, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Kimberly Waters, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Hetty Mae Kodges, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Amanda Miller-McKnight, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Kristain Halfacre, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Pamela Jane Drew, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Michelle Campos, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Jennifer Holmes, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Tanya Muldoon, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Staci Sessions, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Andrea Jo Patschke, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Jennifer Palmer, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Esselene Lowe, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Wendy Berry, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Jennifer Stevens, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Mary Cox, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Ashley Purvis, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Katty Gonzalez, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Candise Braley-Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Caroline Corbin, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Carmen C. Scott , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Hazen Chandler, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Elizabeth Dudley , The Dudley Law Firm, LLC, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Nisha Thomas, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Elizabeth Dudley , The Dudley Law Firm, LLC, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Tammy Miller, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Elizabeth Dudley , The Dudley Law Firm, LLC, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Victoria Anderson-Lewis, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Willard J. Moody, Jr. , The Moody Law Firm, Jonathan A. Hogins , The Moody Law Firm, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Melissa Carter, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Willard J. Moody, Jr. , The Moody Law Firm, Jonathan A. Hogins , The Moody Law Firm, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Lina Jones, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Willard J. Moody, Jr. , The Moody Law Firm, Jonathan A. Hogins , The Moody Law Firm, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Abegail Tongol, Plaintiff, represented by Breanne V. Cope , Motley Rice, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , Motley Rice LLC, Willard J. Moody, Jr. , The Moody Law Firm, Jonathan A. Hogins , The Moody Law Firm, Kimberly Barone Baden , Motley Rice LLC & Louis M. Bograd , Motley Rice LLC.

Bayer Corporation, an Indiana corporation, Defendant, represented by Alycia Ann Degen , Sidley Austin LLP & Jonathan Fredrick Cohn , Sidley Austin LLP.

Bayer Corporation, Defendant, represented by Rebecca Wood , Sidley Austin LLP.

Bayer Corporation, an Indiana corporation, Defendant, represented by Bradley Dugan , Sidley Austin LLP.

Bayer HealthCare LLC, a Delaware company, Defendant, represented by Alycia Ann Degen , Sidley Austin LLP & Jonathan Fredrick Cohn , Sidley Austin LLP.

Bayer HealthCare LLC, Defendant, represented by Rebecca Wood , Sidley Austin LLP.

Bayer HealthCare LLC, a Delaware company, Defendant, represented by Bradley Dugan , Sidley Austin LLP.

Bayer Essure Inc., Defendant, represented by Alycia Ann Degen , Sidley Austin LLP, Jonathan Fredrick Cohn , Sidley Austin LLP, Rebecca Wood , Sidley Austin LLP & Bradley Dugan , Sidley Austin LLP.

Bayer HealthCare Pharmaceuticals Inc., Defendant, represented by Alycia Ann Degen , Sidley Austin LLP, Jonathan Fredrick Cohn , Sidley Austin LLP, Rebecca Wood , Sidley Austin LLP & Bradley Dugan , Sidley Austin LLP.


ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO REMAND AND DENYING AS MOOT MOTION TO DISMISS

INTRODUCTION

Defendants removed this product liability action from state court on the grounds that it presents a federal question. Plaintiffs now move to remand, and defendants move to dismiss. For the reasons stated below, the...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases