ABBOTT LABORATORIES v. ADELPHIA SUPPLY USA

No. 15-CV-5826 (CBA) (LB).

ABBOTT LABORATORIES et al, Plaintiffs, v. ADELPHIA SUPPLY USA et al, Defendants.

United States District Court, E.D. New York.

January 4, 2017.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 15 U.S.C. § 1114
Cause: 15 U.S.C. § 1114 Trademark Infringement
Nature of Suit: 840 Trademark
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Sandr Healtcare LLC, Movant, represented by Matthew L. McBride , pro hac vice.

Snehal Patel, Movant, represented by Matthew L. McBride , pro hac vice.

Abbott Laboratories, Plaintiff, represented by Kristen L. Richer , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP, R. James Madigan, III , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP & Geoffrey Potter , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP.

Abbott Diabetes Care Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Kristen L. Richer , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP, R. James Madigan, III , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP & Geoffrey Potter , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP.

Abbott Diabetes Care Sales Corporation, Plaintiff, represented by Kristen L. Richer , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP, R. James Madigan, III , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP & Geoffrey Potter , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP.

Adelphia Supply USA, Defendant, represented by Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP, Steven Stern , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Yudah Neuman, Defendant, represented by Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP, Steven Stern , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Reuven Sobel, Defendant, represented by Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP, Steven Stern , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Moses Neuman, Defendant, represented by Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP, Steven Stern , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Save Rite Medical.com LLC, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Marc Kaplan, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Matrix Distributors, Inc., Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Christopher Benevent, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Seth Grumet, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

H&H Wholesale Services, Inc., Defendant, represented by Daniel Adam Schnapp , Fox Rothschild LLP, George J. Christopoulos , Kerr, Russell and Weber, PLC, pro hac vice, Jason Yert , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC, pro hac vice, Jeffrey H. Grant , Fox Rothschild LLP, pro hac vice, John J. Shaeffer , Fox Rothschild LLP, Robert J. Pineau , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC, Valerie Chisara Ezie , Fox Rothschild LLP, William R. Hansen , Fox Rothschild LLP & William A. Rudy , Fox Rothschild LLP, pro hac vice.

Howard Goldman, Defendant, represented by Daniel Adam Schnapp , Fox Rothschild LLP, Jason Yert , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC, pro hac vice, Jeffrey H. Grant , Fox Rothschild LLP, pro hac vice, John J. Shaeffer , Fox Rothschild LLP, Robert J. Pineau , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC, Valerie Chisara Ezie , Fox Rothschild LLP, William R. Hansen , Fox Rothschild LLP & William A. Rudy , Fox Rothschild LLP, pro hac vice.

Lori Goldman, Defendant, represented by Daniel Adam Schnapp , Fox Rothschild LLP, Jason Yert , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC, pro hac vice, Jeffrey H. Grant , Fox Rothschild LLP, pro hac vice, John J. Shaeffer , Fox Rothschild LLP, Robert J. Pineau , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC, Valerie Chisara Ezie , Fox Rothschild LLP, William R. Hansen , Fox Rothschild LLP & William A. Rudy , Fox Rothschild LLP, pro hac vice.

Papoutsanis USA, LLC, Defendant, represented by Judah S. Shapiro .

George Drogaris, Defendant, represented by Judah S. Shapiro .

Budget Health Corporation, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP, Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC & Wayne L. Gladstone , Harris Beach PLLC.

Lori Blue, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP, Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC & Wayne L. Gladstone , Harris Beach PLLC.

Anthony Meola, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP, Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC & Wayne L. Gladstone , Harris Beach PLLC.

Mark D. Henkin, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP, Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC & Wayne L. Gladstone , Harris Beach PLLC.

Dream Cereal Inc., Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Douglas Hauck, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Lev RX Corp, Defendant, represented by Alec Sauchik , Sauchik & Giyaur P.C. & Kristina Giyaur , Sauchik & Giyaur P.C..

Kira Levkouskaya, Defendant, represented by Alec Sauchik , Sauchik & Giyaur P.C. & Kristina Giyaur , Sauchik & Giyaur P.C..

Eliyahus Pharmacy, Inc., Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Ilias Mlabasati, Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Global Care Pharmacy, Inc., Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

D.K.Y. Enterprises, Inc., Defendant, represented by Safet Metjahic , Stanzione & Associates, PLLC & John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Kim Ping Jim, Defendant, represented by Safet Metjahic , Stanzione & Associates, PLLC & John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Irene Piker, Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

B & T Marlboro Pharmacy, Inc., Defendant, represented by Thomas A. Bizzaro , Smith Mazure Director Wilkins Young & Yagerman PC.

Anatoly Gorokhovsky, Defendant, represented by Thomas A. Bizzaro , Smith Mazure Director Wilkins Young & Yagerman PC.

La Ruche Pharmacy, Inc., Defendant, Pro Se.

Sunil B. Patel, Defendant, Pro Se.

Estates Pharmacy, Inc., Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Mohammed Nuruddin, Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Novex America, Defendant, represented by Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Dennis Cantor, Defendant, represented by Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Tri-State Medical Supplies Equip. Corp., Defendant, represented by Robert L. Rimberg , Goldberg & Rimberg PLLC & Evan Ross Shusterman , Goldberg & Rimberg, PLLC.

Erwin Ganzfried, Defendant, represented by Evan Ross Shusterman , Goldberg & Rimberg, PLLC.

Mordechai Kritzler, Defendant, represented by Evan Ross Shusterman , Goldberg & Rimberg, PLLC.

Value Wholesale, Inc., Defendant, represented by Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP, Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Steven Stern , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Medical Discount Services, Inc., Defendant, represented by Samuel Asher Blaustein , Dunnington Bartholow and Miller, LLP.

Brian Mesika, Defendant, represented by Samuel Asher Blaustein , Dunnington Bartholow and Miller, LLP.

Xpress Medical Supplies Corp., Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Muhammad Arif, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Saps Drug Wholesale, Inc., Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Vilas Asmin, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Rajesh Amin, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Nimesh Amin, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Ixthus Medical Supply, Inc., Defendant, represented by Albert Solochek , Howard Solochek & Weber, S.C., Frank J. Colucci , Colucci & Umans & Jason Pilmaier , Howard Solochek & Weber, S.C..

Karl Kunstman, Defendant, represented by Albert Solochek , Howard Solochek & Weber, S.C., Frank J. Colucci , Colucci & Umans & Jason Pilmaier , Howard Solochek & Weber, S.C..

Drugplace, Inc., Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Paul Leight, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Kevin Singer, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

HMF Distributing Inc., Defendant, represented by Derrelle Marcel Janey , Gottlieb & Janey LLP.

Wholesale Diabetic Supplies Inc., Defendant, represented by Derrelle Marcel Janey , Gottlieb & Janey LLP.

Ross Trager, Defendant, represented by Derrelle Marcel Janey , Gottlieb & Janey LLP.

Matthew Frank, Defendant, represented by Derrelle Marcel Janey , Gottlieb & Janey LLP.

Primed Pharmaceuticals LLC, Defendant, represented by Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP, Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Steven Stern , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Matthew Zeigler, Defendant, represented by Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP, Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Steven Stern , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

NE Medical Supply USA, Inc., Defendant, represented by Sumeer Kakar , Kakar P.C. & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Danielle Wayne, Defendant, represented by Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Sumeer Kakar , Kakar P.C., Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Nick Wayne, Defendant, represented by Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Sumeer Kakar , Kakar P.C., Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

TAS Medical Supply, Inc., Defendant, represented by Solomon E. Antar .

Tzvi Sklarz, Defendant, represented by Solomon E. Antar .

Product Performance Company, Inc., Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Jerrold Herman, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Stephen Herman, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Med-Plus, Inc., Defendant, represented by Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Roger Mezhibovsky, Defendant, represented by Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Delray Marketing, LLC, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Steve Michaels, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Globe Wanted, Defendant, Pro Se.

Massalah Trading U.S.A. Ltd., Defendant, represented by Howard E. Greenberg , Law Offices of Howard E. Greenberg, Esq., P.C. & Derrelle Marcel Janey , Gottlieb & Janey LLP.

Saad (Sam) Haddad, Defendant, represented by Derrelle Marcel Janey , Gottlieb & Janey LLP.

Havemeyer Pharmacy Inc., Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Michael Bassanell, Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

6122 Pharmacy, Inc., Defendant, represented by Todd Mizeski , Frier & Levitt, LLC.

86th Street Community Pharmacy, Defendant, represented by Eduardo J. Glas , Tseitlin & Glas, P.C..

Able Wholesalers of Tennessee, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Absolute Freight Services, Defendant, represented by Michael S. O'Rourke , Sandler, Travis & Rosenberg, PA & Robert J. Becerra , Becerra Law P.A..

Albert Kritzler, Defendant, represented by Evan Ross Shusterman , Goldberg & Rimberg, PLLC.

Alpeshkumar Vasani, Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Amexpo International, LLC, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

An-Noor Pharmacy Inc., Defendant, represented by Alec Sauchik , Sauchik & Giyaur P.C..

Bell Apothecary, Inc., Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

Benjamin Walvoord, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

Bhanumati Patel, Defendant, represented by Teresa Peacocke & Joshua Fingold , Joshua Fingold Esq..

Bob-Bila Distributors, Inc., Defendant, represented by Alec Sauchik , Sauchik & Giyaur P.C..

Brian Boeshart, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Bridesburg Pharmacy, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

Coolrelic, Inc., Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Dedac Nguyen, Defendant, represented by Bianca Lin , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP & John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Deepak Munshi, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Desai's Pharmacy Inc., Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Dwayne Porter, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

East Tremont Pharmacy Inc., Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Eduardo Gil, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

E-Pharm Wholesalers, Inc., Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Erik Berg, Defendant, represented by Christopher L. Ulrich , Cummings & Lockwood LLC.

Fifty50 Medical, LLC, Defendant, represented by Lijia Gong , Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz, P.C. & Toby M.J. Butterfield , Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz PC.

George (Rick) Lynch, Defendant, represented by Lijia Gong , Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz, P.C. & Toby M.J. Butterfield , Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz PC.

Glendale Prescription Center, Inc., Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Globalmed Limited, Defendant, represented by Andrew Alan Smith , Kennedy Berg LLP & Gabriel A. Berg , Kennedy Berg LLP.

Goodlife Pharmacy Inc., Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Goolam Sheikh, Defendant, represented by Alec Sauchik , Sauchik & Giyaur P.C..

Gregory Sargent, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Hannah Nguyen, Defendant, represented by Bianca Lin , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP & John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Hironori Mitsuishi, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Hsiu Sargent, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Jason Grama, Defendant, represented by Craig M. Blanchard , Law Office of Howard E. Greenberg, Esq., P.C. & Howard E. Greenberg , Law Offices of Howard E. Greenberg, Esq., P.C..

Jenny Nguyen, Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Jonathan Nikolas Woods, Defendant, represented by Jeffrey Alan Payne , Payne Law.

Joyce Mogil, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

Kiri Patel, Defendant, represented by Teresa Peacocke & Joshua Fingold , Joshua Fingold Esq..

Konie Minga, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

Lafayette Drugs, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

Leslie Boeshart, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Leslie Stewart Jones, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Lightbox Medical LLC, Defendant, represented by Jeffrey Alan Payne , Payne Law.

Lubna Arshad, Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Luis Soto, Defendant, represented by Michael S. O'Rourke , Sandler, Travis & Rosenberg, PA & Robert J. Becerra , Becerra Law P.A..

M & L Brothers Pharmacy, Inc., Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Manifest Pharmacy LLC, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

Mark Mogil, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

Maulik Shah, Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Medical Care Supplies Inc., Defendant, represented by Derrelle Marcel Janey , Gottlieb & Janey LLP.

Medical Discount Services, LLC, Defendant, represented by Samuel Asher Blaustein , Dunnington Bartholow and Miller, LLP.

MISAR LLC, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Mohammad Arshad, Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Mujjahid ul Huq, Defendant, represented by Alec Sauchik , Sauchik & Giyaur P.C..

Nachman Neil Feig, Defendant, represented by Martin I. Saperstein , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs. & Stanley R. Goodman , Goodman & Saperstein, Esqs..

Nessin Ussein, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

NWHOLESALEDEAL, Inc., Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Oliver Suess, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Oxford Pharmacy, Inc., Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Paul Michael Capper, Defendant, represented by Andrew Alan Smith , Kennedy Berg LLP.

Perfecto F. Hallon, Defendant, represented by Derrelle Marcel Janey , Gottlieb & Janey LLP.

Pharma Supply, Inc., Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Physician Choice Pharmacy LLC, Defendant, represented by Craig M. Blanchard , Law Office of Howard E. Greenberg, Esq., P.C. & Howard E. Greenberg , Law Offices of Howard E. Greenberg, Esq., P.C..

Power Distribution Enterprises LLC, Defendant, represented by Joshua Tropper , Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, P.C..

Priority Care Pharmacy LLC, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

Ralph Amato, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Randy Tammara, Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Saad (Sam) Haddad, Defendant, represented by Derrelle Marcel Janey , Gottlieb & Janey LLP & Howard E. Greenberg , Law Offices of Howard E. Greenberg, Esq., P.C..

Sam Zighelboim, Defendant, represented by Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP, Steven Stern , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Santa Zawaideh, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

Shenay Ussein, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

Shrinathji Rx Inc., Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Smartway Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Defendant, represented by Teresa Peacocke & Joshua Fingold , Joshua Fingold Esq..

Smartway PW Holdings Ltd., Defendant, represented by Teresa Peacocke & Joshua Fingold , Joshua Fingold Esq..

Spyridon Psonis, Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Stampmatic, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

Stephanie Huq, Defendant, represented by Alec Sauchik , Sauchik & Giyaur P.C..

Stephen M. Krause, Defendant, represented by Joshua Tropper , Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, P.C..

Steven Tammara, Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Steven Thuss, Defendant, represented by Mohammed Gangat .

TDC Pharmaceutical Corporation, Inc., Defendant, represented by Bianca Lin , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP & John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

TDP Trading, Inc., Defendant, represented by Bianca Lin , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP & John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Thuy Pham, Defendant, represented by John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

Vinh Huynh, Defendant, represented by Bianca Lin , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP & John Samuel Craig , Allegaert Berger & Vogel LLP.

William Semaan, Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

Z Worldwide, Inc., Defendant, represented by Richard S. Schurin , Stern & Schurin LLP, Evgeny Krasnov , Stern & Schurin LLP, Michael Barer , Stern & Schurin LLP, Steven Stern , Stern & Schurin LLP & Wayne Matthew Cox , Stern & Schurin LLP.

Gabecare Direct Rx, Inc., Defendant, represented by Frederick H. Fern , Harris Beach LLP & Marina Plotkin , Harris Beach PLLC.

86 Street Pharmacy, Defendant, represented by Eduardo J. Glas , Tseitlin & Glas, P.C..

Kong Cheung, Defendant, represented by Todd Mizeski , Frier & Levitt, LLC.

Lehigh Pharmacy & Supplies, Inc., Defendant, represented by Joshua Tropper , Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, P.C..

H&H Wholesale Services, Inc., Interested Party, represented by James E. DeLine , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC & Michael A. Sneyd , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC, pro hac vice.

Lori Goldman, Counter Claimant, represented by Daniel Adam Schnapp , Fox Rothschild LLP, Jason Yert , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC, Jeffrey H. Grant , Fox Rothschild LLP, John J. Shaeffer , Fox Rothschild LLP, Robert J. Pineau , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC, Valerie Chisara Ezie , Fox Rothschild LLP, William R. Hansen , Fox Rothschild LLP & William A. Rudy , Fox Rothschild LLP.

Howard Goldman, Counter Claimant, represented by Daniel Adam Schnapp , Fox Rothschild LLP, Jason Yert , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC, Jeffrey H. Grant , Fox Rothschild LLP, John J. Shaeffer , Fox Rothschild LLP, Robert J. Pineau , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC, Valerie Chisara Ezie , Fox Rothschild LLP, William R. Hansen , Fox Rothschild LLP & William A. Rudy , Fox Rothschild LLP.

H&H Wholesale Services, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Daniel Adam Schnapp , Fox Rothschild LLP, Jason Yert , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC, Jeffrey H. Grant , Fox Rothschild LLP, John J. Shaeffer , Fox Rothschild LLP, Robert J. Pineau , Kerr Russell and Weber, PLC, Valerie Chisara Ezie , Fox Rothschild LLP, William R. Hansen , Fox Rothschild LLP & William A. Rudy , Fox Rothschild LLP.

Abbott Diabetes Care Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Kristen L. Richer , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP, R. James Madigan, III , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP & Geoffrey Potter , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP.

Abbott Diabetes Care Sales Corporation, Counter Defendant, represented by Kristen L. Richer , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP, R. James Madigan, III , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP & Geoffrey Potter , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP.

Abbott Laboratories, Counter Defendant, represented by Kristen L. Richer , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP, R. James Madigan, III , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP & Geoffrey Potter , Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP.


NOT FOR PUBLICATION

MEMORANDUM & ORDER

Plaintiffs Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Diabetes Care Inc., and Abbott Diabetes Care Sales Corp. (collectively, "Abbott") initiated this action against pharmacies, distributors, importers, and online sellers who sell the international version of Abbott...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases