IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPLAINT OF SEA STAR LINE, LLC

Case No. 3:15-cv-1297-HES-MCR.

In the Matter of The Complaint of Sea Star Line, LLC, d/b/a TOTE Maritime Puerto Rico, as Owners; and TOTE Services, Inc., as Owner pro/lac vice of the S.S. EL FARO for Exoneration from or Limitation of Liability.

United States District Court, M.D. Florida, Jacksonville Division.

December 9, 2016.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 46 U.S.C. § 31301
Cause: 46 U.S.C. § 31301 Commercial Instruments and Maritime Liens
Nature of Suit: 360 P.I.: Other
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Sea Star Line, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice.

Sea Star Line, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jerry Dean Hamilton , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP, Keith W. Heard , Burke & Parsons, pro hac vice, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice, Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA & Karina Mabel Cerda-Collazo , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP.

Tote Services, Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jerry Dean Hamilton , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP, Keith W. Heard , Burke & Parsons, pro hac vice, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice, Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA & Karina Mabel Cerda-Collazo , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP.

Patrick John Smith, Defendant, represented by Ben Bireley , Arnold & Itkin LLP, pro hac vice, Cory D. Itkin , Arnold & Itkin, LLP, pro hac vice, Jason A. Itkin , Arnold & Itkin, LLP, pro hac vice, Jason Ari Smith , Mombach, Boyle, Hardin & Simmons, PA, Michael P. Hamaway , Mombach, Boyle, Hardin & Simmons, PA & Kurt B. Arnold , Arnold & Itkin LLP.

Claimant Ace American Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Thomas Albert Boyd, Jr. , Boyd & Sutter, PA.

Jennifer Mathias, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey Mathias, Defendant, represented by Allen K. Von Spiegelfeld , Banker Lopez Gassler.

Federal Insurance Company as subrogee of J.C. Penney Corporation, Inc., Defendant, represented by David Y. Loh , Cozen O'Connor, pro hac vice, Joseph Frank Rich , Cozen O'Connor & Robert W. Phelan , Cozen O'Connor, pro hac vice.

Continental Insurance Company as subrogee of Goodnight Acquisitions LLC a/k/a Goodnight International Inc., Defendant, represented by David Y. Loh , Cozen O'Connor, pro hac vice, Joseph Frank Rich , Cozen O'Connor & Robert W. Phelan , Cozen O'Connor, pro hac vice.

Goodnight Acquisitions LLC a/k/a Goodnight International Inc., Defendant, represented by David Y. Loh , Cozen O'Connor, pro hac vice, Joseph Frank Rich , Cozen O'Connor & Robert W. Phelan , Cozen O'Connor, pro hac vice.

Crawford, Defendant, represented by G.J. Rod Sullivan, Jr. , Sullivan & Company.

Bemis Healthcare Packaging, Inc., Defendant, represented by David L. Mazaroli , Law Office of David L. Mazaroli, pro hac vice & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

Bemis Healthcare Packaging de Puerto Rico, Inc., Defendant, represented by David L. Mazaroli , Law Office of David L. Mazaroli, pro hac vice & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

Bemis Company, Inc., Defendant, represented by David L. Mazaroli , Law Office of David L. Mazaroli, pro hac vice & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

Mars Chocolate North America, LLC, Defendant, represented by David L. Mazaroli , Law Office of David L. Mazaroli, pro hac vice & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

Mars Pet Care US Inc., Defendant, represented by David L. Mazaroli , Law Office of David L. Mazaroli, pro hac vice & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

Costco Wholesale Corp., Defendant, represented by David L. Mazaroli , Law Office of David L. Mazaroli, pro hac vice & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

ACE Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by Lawrence C. Glynn , Caruso Glynn, LLC, pro hac vice & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

Seguros Universal, S.A., Defendant, represented by Lawrence C. Glynn , Caruso Glynn, LLC, pro hac vice, William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA, Lawrence C. Glynn , Caruso Glynn, LLC & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

Travelers Property Casualty Company of America a/s/o Bunzl USA Holding, Defendant, represented by Martin Hayes Sitler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Travelers Property Casualty Company of America a/s/o A.M. Capen's Co., Inc., Defendant, represented by Martin Hayes Sitler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Travelers Property Casualty Company of America a/s/o Dawn Foods Products, Defendant, represented by Martin Hayes Sitler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

TMM Marine American Insurance Companies a/s/o Dunkin Brands International, DMCC, Defendant, represented by Martin Hayes Sitler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance Company a/s/o Nexeo Solutions Holdings, LLC, Defendant, represented by Martin Hayes Sitler , Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin.

ABF Freight System, Inc., Defendant, represented by Brian T. Scarry , Horr, Novak & Skipp, PA.

Certain Underwriters and Insurers at Lloyds of London Subscribing to Policy of Insurance PC1412719000, Defendant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Mamo Transportation, Inc., Defendant, represented by Christopher E. Cotter , Roetzel & Andress, LPA, pro hac vice & Paul Anthony Giordano , Roetzel & Andress, LPA.

BMW of North America, LLC., Defendant, represented by Martin F. Casey , Casey & Barnett, LLC, pro hac vice & Thomas Albert Boyd, Jr. , Boyd & Sutter, PA.

Lloyds Syndicate 2623 a/s/o Interra International, Inc., Defendant, represented by Martin F. Casey , Casey & Barnett, LLC, pro hac vice & Thomas Albert Boyd, Jr. , Boyd & Sutter, PA.

AJC Logistics, Inc., Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Eaton Corporation, PLC, Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

3M Company, Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Kraft Food Group Incorporated, Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Reyes Holdings, LLC, Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Hubbell Caribe Limited, Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Save Logistics Incorporated, Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Mead Johnson & Company, LLC, Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Lynden Air Freight, Inc., Defendant, represented by Thomas Albert Boyd, Jr. , Boyd & Sutter, PA.

Foot Locker Incorporated, Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Caterpillar Americas, Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Carlos A. Tuche Funicia and Puerto Rico Green Transportation, Defendant, represented by David Y. Loh , Cozen O'Connor, pro hac vice, Joseph Frank Rich , Cozen O'Connor & Robert W. Phelan , Cozen O'Connor, pro hac vice.

Industrial Fire Products Corporation, Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Eagle Logistics Systems, Inc., Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

BASF Corporation, Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Alexis Parker, as Personal Representative of Roosevelt Clark, Defendant, represented by Thomas Albert Boyd, Jr. , Boyd & Sutter, PA.

Rochelle Hamm as Personal Representative of Frank Hamm, III, Defendant, represented by Thomas Albert Boyd, Jr. , Boyd & Sutter, PA.

Marlena Porter, as Personal Representative for the Estate of James Phillip Porter, Jr., Defendant, represented by Thomas Albert Boyd, Jr. , Boyd & Sutter, PA.

Vicky Green, as the Personal Representative of LaShawn Rivera, Defendant, represented by Thomas Albert Boyd, Jr. , Boyd & Sutter, PA.

Roche Operations, Limited, Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

BASF Corporation (Puerto Rico), Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Tyson Foods, Inc., Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Lamex Foods, Inc., Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Excel Cargo Services, Inc. d/b/a Caribex Worldwide, Defendant, represented by Craig Liszt , Roig Lawyers & David Harlen Sump , Wilcox & Savage, P.C., pro hac vice.

Truck Brokers, Inc., Defendant, represented by Joseph A. Parrish, Jr. , Taylor & Associates, Attorneys at Law, PL & Stephanie S. Penninger , Benesch, Friedlander, Coplan & Aronoff, LLP, pro hac vice.

Kimberly-Clark Trading & Services, Ltda, Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Donna Griffin, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Catherine Popham Decunto , Durant & Schoeppel, PA, Matthew Edward Auger , Suisman Shapiro Wool Brennan Gray & Greenberg, P.C., pro hac vice & Stephen H. Durant , Durant & Schoeppel, PA.

Navigators Insurance Company, Third Party Defendant, represented by Andrew P. Collins, II , Milton, Leach, Whitman, D'Andrea & Eslinger, PA & C. Ryan Eslinger , Milton, Leach, Whitman, D'Andrea & Eslinger, PA.

Donna Griffin, Counter Claimant, represented by Catherine Popham Decunto , Durant & Schoeppel, PA, Matthew Edward Auger , Suisman Shapiro Wool Brennan Gray & Greenberg, P.C., pro hac vice & Stephen H. Durant , Durant & Schoeppel, PA.

ANNA KRAUSE, as Personal Representative of the Estate of PIOTR KRAUSE, deceased, Claimant, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

BOZENA TRUSZKOWSKA, as Personal Representative of the Estate of ANDRZEJ TRUSZKOWSKI, deceased, Claimant, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

AGNIESZKA ZDOBYCH, as Personal Representative of the Estate of RAFAL ZDOBYCH, deceased, Claimant, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

AGNIESZKA NITA, as Personal Representative of the Estate of MARCIN NITA, deceased, Claimant, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

MALGORZATA PODGORSKA, as Personal Representative of the Estate of JAN PODGORSKI, deceased, Claimant, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

Estes Express Lines, Claimant, represented by Lawrence J. Roberts , Lawrence J. Roberts & Associates, PA.

PUSATERE, EMILY, as Personal Representative of the Estate of RICHARD PUSATERE, deceased, Claimant, represented by John H. Hickey , Hickey Law Firm, PA & Brett Douglas Sager , Hickey Law Firm, PA.

Karen Schoenly, Claimant, represented by Thomas K. Equels , Equels Law Firm & Judson H. Orrick , Equels Law Firm.

Tina Riehm, Claimant, represented by Stephen J. Pajcic , Pajcic & Pajcic, PA, Thomas Fitzpatrick Slater , Pajcic & Pajcic, PA, Benjamin Edward Richard , Pajcic & Pajcic, PA & William S. Burns, Jr. , Pajcic & Pajcic, PA.

Tracey Hatch, Claimant, represented by Michael Sather Pajcic , Pajcic & Pajcic, PA, Stephen J. Pajcic , Pajcic & Pajcic, PA & Benjamin Edward Richard , Pajcic & Pajcic, PA.

CHAMPA, VALMA, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Louis Champa, Jr., deceased, Claimant, represented by John H. Hickey , Hickey Law Firm, PA & Brett Douglas Sager , Hickey Law Firm, PA.

SAIA Motor Freight Line, LLC, Claimant, Pro Se.

Mildred Solar-Cortes, Claimant, represented by Ben Bireley , Arnold & Itkin LLP, pro hac vice, Cory D. Itkin , Arnold & Itkin, LLP, pro hac vice, Jason A. Itkin , Arnold & Itkin, LLP, pro hac vice, Jason Ari Smith , Mombach, Boyle, Hardin & Simmons, PA, Michael P. Hamaway , Mombach, Boyle, Hardin & Simmons, PA & Kurt B. Arnold , Arnold & Itkin LLP.

Tinisha Renee Thomas, Claimant, represented by Ben Bireley , Arnold & Itkin LLP, pro hac vice, Cory D. Itkin , Arnold & Itkin, LLP, pro hac vice, Jason A. Itkin , Arnold & Itkin, LLP, pro hac vice, Jason Ari Smith , Mombach, Boyle, Hardin & Simmons, PA, Michael P. Hamaway , Mombach, Boyle, Hardin & Simmons, PA & Kurt B. Arnold , Arnold & Itkin LLP.

Jill Jackson-d'Entremont, Claimant, represented by Daniel O. Rose , Kreindler & Kreindler, LLP, pro hac vice & Robert F. Spohrer , Spohrer & Dodd, PL.

Claudia Aparecida Shultz, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven Wink Shultz, deceased, Claimant, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA & Ralph Joseph Mellusi , Tabak, Mellusi & Shisha LLP, pro hac vice.

EFOODS INC., Claimant, represented by Raymond John Rotella , Kosto & Rotella, PA.

Great American Insurance Company of New York, Claimant, represented by Brian T. Scarry , Horr, Novak & Skipp, PA, David T. Maloof , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC, pro hac vice & Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

RLI Insurance Company, Claimant, represented by Brian T. Scarry , Horr, Novak & Skipp, PA, David T. Maloof , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC, pro hac vice & Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Claimant Indemnity Insurance Company of North America, Claimant, represented by Thomas Albert Boyd, Jr. , Boyd & Sutter, PA.

ADDREISHA SHIRLIEA JONES, Claimant, represented by Elizabeth P. Kagan , Kagan Law Firm, PL & Scott A. Wagner , Moore & Company.

THOSE CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS (SYNDICATE 1955, SYNDICATE 2987, SYNDICATE 1183 AND SYNDICATE 0457) SUBSCRIBING TO POLICY # B0180 PC1422840 AS SUBROGEE OF DEL VALLE BRANDS, INC. AND f/u/b/o DEL VALLE, Claimant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

The Continental Insurance Company, Claimant, represented by Brian T. Scarry , Horr, Novak & Skipp, PA.

Terri Hargrove, Claimant, represented by Ben Bireley , Arnold & Itkin LLP, pro hac vice, Cory D. Itkin , Arnold & Itkin, LLP, pro hac vice, Jason A. Itkin , Arnold & Itkin, LLP, pro hac vice, Jason Ari Smith , Mombach, Boyle, Hardin & Simmons, PA, Michael P. Hamaway , Mombach, Boyle, Hardin & Simmons, PA & Kurt B. Arnold , Arnold & Itkin LLP.

Maverick C&P, Inc., Claimant, represented by Marlin Kareem Green , Brown Sims, PC.

Laurie D. Bobillot, Claimant, represented by Michael P. Hamaway , Mombach, Boyle, Hardin & Simmons, PA.

Kenneth W. Randolph, Claimant, represented by Michael P. Hamaway , Mombach, Boyle, Hardin & Simmons, PA.

Elaine Meklin, Claimant, represented by Michael P. Hamaway , Mombach, Boyle, Hardin & Simmons, PA.

Karl Meklin, Claimant, represented by Michael P. Hamaway , Mombach, Boyle, Hardin & Simmons, PA.

Patricia Quammie, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Theodore Quammie, deceased, Claimant, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

Donna Griffin, Claimant, represented by Catherine Popham Decunto , Durant & Schoeppel, PA, Matthew Edward Auger , Suisman Shapiro Wool Brennan Gray & Greenberg, P.C., pro hac vice & Stephen H. Durant , Durant & Schoeppel, PA.

Joanna Johnson, Claimant, represented by Willie Edward Gary , Gary, Williams, Parenti, Watson & Gary, PL.

UPS Ground Freight, Inc., Claimant, represented by Christoph M. Wahner , Countryman & McDaniel, pro hac vice & Marc Alan Rubin , Spector Rubin, PA.

Willa Crawford, Claimant, represented by G.J. Rod Sullivan, Jr. , Sullivan & Company & Matthew D. Shaffer , Schechter, McElwee, Shaffer & Harris, LLP, pro hac vice.

Claudette Riley, Claimant, represented by Jacob J. Munch , Munch & Munch, PA.

Nissan North America, Inc., Claimant, Pro Se.

Cheryl Crawford-Glenn, Claimant, represented by G.J. Rod Sullivan, Jr. , Sullivan & Company & Matthew D. Shaffer , Schechter, McElwee, Shaffer & Harris, LLP, pro hac vice.

BMW of North America, Inc., Claimant, represented by David Weese Marston, Jr. , Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP, Martin F. Casey , Casey & Barnett, LLC & Christopher Kimbrough Smith , Lash & Goldberg, LLP.

Gargiulo, Inc., Claimant, represented by Dennis Michael Campbell , Campbell Law Firm, PLLC.

Personal Representat Dena Ann Lightfoot, Claimant, represented by Brian Mark Pederson , Childs, Hester & Love, PA, Linda Marie Hester , Childs Reed, PA & Wade Douglas Childs , Childs Reed, PA.

Terri C. Davis, Claimant, represented by Christopher Charles Hazelip , Rogers Towers, P.A. & Robert E. Warren , Law Offices of Robert E. Warren.

Ruben Aquino, Claimant, Pro Se.

ArcBest Corporation, Claimant, represented by Brian T. Scarry , Horr, Novak & Skipp, PA.

JARVON WHIGHAM, Claimant, represented by Brett Douglas Sager , Hickey Law Firm, PA, John H. Hickey , Hickey Law Firm, PA & Sarah Lobel , Hickey Law Firm, PA.

Starr Indemnity and Liability Co., Claimant, represented by Carole A.R. Rouffet , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney, pro hac vice, James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney, pro hac vice & Robert A. Craven , Law Office of Robert A. Craven, PL.

Katie Griffin, Claimant, represented by Mark A. Boyle, Sr. , Boyle & Leonard PA, Michael W. Leonard , Boyle & Leonard PA & Justin M. Thomas , Boyle & Leonard PA.

Aqua Gulf Transport, Inc., Claimant, represented by Brian T. Scarry , Horr, Novak & Skipp, PA, David T. Maloof , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC, pro hac vice & Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Century Packaging Corp., Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

QBE Seguros, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Pet Plastics LLC, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Certain Underwriters and Insurers at Lloyds of London Subscribing to Policy of Insurance PC1412719000, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Able Sales Company, Inc., Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Certain Underwriters and Insurers at Lloyds of London Subscribing to Policy of Insurance LC151592500, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Mendez & Company, Inc., Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Certain Underwriters and Insurers at Lloyds of London Subscribing to Policy of Insurance LC1516254000, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Puerto Rico Supplies Group, Inc., Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Certain Underwriters and Insurers at Lloyds of London Subscribing to Policy of Insurance PC1412443000, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Suarez and Company, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Certain Underwriters and Insurers at Lloyds of London Subscribing to Policy of Insurance LC1515551000, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Dade Paper & Bag Co., Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Certain Underwriters and Insurers at Lloyds of London Subscribing to Policy of Insurance DC1500194000, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Quirch Foods Co., Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Certain Underwriters and Insurers at Lloyds of London Subscribing to Policy of Insurance DC1500466000, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Plaza Provision Company, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Universal Insurance Company of North America, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Certain Underwriters and Insurers at Lloyds of London Subscribing to Policy of Insurance LC1515422000, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Supermercados Econo, Inc., Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Certain Underwriters and Insurers at Lloyds of London Subscribing to Policy of Insurance LC1516397000, Claimant, represented by Thomas M. Eagan , Maloof Browne & Eagan, LLC.

Zurich American Insurance Company, Claimant, represented by Carole A.R. Rouffet , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney, pro hac vice & James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Ingersoll Rand Company, Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Pfizer Pharmaceuticals LLC, Claimant, represented by Carole A.R. Rouffet , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney, pro hac vice & James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Pfizer, Inc., Claimant, represented by Carole A.R. Rouffet , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney, pro hac vice & James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

AGCS Marine Insurance Company, Claimant, represented by Carole A.R. Rouffet , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney, pro hac vice & James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

AGCS Marine Insurance Company a/s/o Walgreen Co., Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Starr Indemnity & Liability Co., Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Starr Indemnity and Liability Co. a/s/o Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Mars Chocolate North America, LLC, Claimant, represented by David L. Mazaroli , Law Office of David L. Mazaroli.

Mars Pet Care US Inc., Claimant, represented by David L. Mazaroli , Law Office of David L. Mazaroli.

Mars Masterfoods USA, Inc., Claimant, represented by David L. Mazaroli , Law Office of David L. Mazaroli.

ITL International Inc. d/b/a Mars Caribbean and Central America, a division of Mars, Inc., Claimant, represented by David L. Mazaroli , Law Office of David L. Mazaroli.

Fedex Freight, Inc., Claimant, represented by Marc Alan Rubin , Spector Rubin, PA.

The Hanover Insurance Company, Claimant, represented by Joseph W. Janssen, III , Janssen & Siracusa, PA & Nathan T. Williams , Kennedy, Lillis, Schmidt & English, pro hac vice.

FM Global, Inc., Claimant, represented by Joseph W. Janssen, III , Janssen & Siracusa, PA & Nathan T. Williams , Kennedy, Lillis, Schmidt & English, pro hac vice.

Mutchler Inc., Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Deborah Roberts, Claimant, represented by Michelle Bedoya Barnett , Alexander DeGance Barnett, P.A. & Ronald J. Cullenberg , Cullenberg Law Offices.

Kimberly-Clark Global Sales LLC, Claimant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Kimberly-Clark Puerto Rico, Inc., Claimant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Those Certain Underwriters Subscribing to Policy # 019341836, Claimant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

The Gap, Inc., Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Linde Gas of Puerto Rico, Inc., Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Sea Star Line, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael M. Gropper , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP & Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice.

TRIVONDA PORTER, Intervenor, represented by Mitchel E. Woodlief , Law Office of Mitchel E. Woodlief.

ANNA KRAUSE, as Personal Representative of the Estate of PIOTR KRAUSE, deceased, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

BOZENA TRUSZKOWSKA, as Personal Representative of the Estate of ANDRZEJ TRUSZKOWSKI, deceased, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

AGNIESZKA ZDOBYCH, as Personal Representative of the Estate of RAFAL ZDOBYCH, deceased, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

AGNIESZKA NITA, as Personal Representative of the Estate of MARCIN NITA, deceased, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

MALGORZATA PODGORSKA, as Personal Representative of the Estate of JAN PODGORSKI, deceased, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

SHIP OR LAND OPERATIONS AGENCY, INC., Third Party Defendant, represented by Daniel W. Matlow , Daniel W. Matlow, PA.

MICHAEL DAVIDSON and/or the ESTATE OF MICHAEL DAVIDSON, Third Party Defendant, represented by Patricia M. O'Neill , Blank Rome, LLP & William R. Bennett, III , Blank Rome, LLP, pro hac vice.

INTEC MARITIME OFFSHORE SERVICE CORP., Third Party Defendant, represented by Daniel W. Matlow , Daniel W. Matlow, PA.

ANNA KRAUSE, as Personal Representative of the Estate of PIOTR KRAUSE, deceased, Counter Claimant, represented by David Alexander Villarreal , Law Office of David A. Villarreal, P.A. & Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

BOZENA TRUSZKOWSKA, as Personal Representative of the Estate of ANDRZEJ TRUSZKOWSKI, deceased, Counter Claimant, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

AGNIESZKA ZDOBYCH, as Personal Representative of the Estate of RAFAL ZDOBYCH, deceased, Counter Claimant, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

AGNIESZKA NITA, as Personal Representative of the Estate of MARCIN NITA, deceased, Counter Claimant, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

MALGORZATA PODGORSKA, as Personal Representative of the Estate of JAN PODGORSKI, deceased, Counter Claimant, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

Tote Services, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael M. Gropper , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP & Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice.

Claimant Indemnity Insurance Company of North America, Counter Claimant, represented by Thomas Albert Boyd, Jr. , Boyd & Sutter, PA.

Tote Services, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael M. Gropper , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP & Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice.

Claimant Ace American Insurance Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Thomas Albert Boyd, Jr. , Boyd & Sutter, PA.

Tote Services, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael M. Gropper , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP & Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice.

PUSATERE, EMILY, as Personal Representative of the Estate of RICHARD PUSATERE, deceased, Counter Claimant, represented by John H. Hickey , Hickey Law Firm, PA & Brett Douglas Sager , Hickey Law Firm, PA.

Sea Star Line, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael M. Gropper , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP & Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice.

Tote Services, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael M. Gropper , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP & Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice.

PUSATERE, EMILY, as Personal Representative of the Estate of RICHARD PUSATERE, deceased, Counter Claimant, represented by John H. Hickey , Hickey Law Firm, PA.

Sea Star Line, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael M. Gropper , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP & Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice.

Tote Services, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael M. Gropper , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP & Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice.

Patricia Quammie, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Theodore Quammie, deceased, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Jason Robert Margulies , Lipcon Margulies & Alsina, PA.

MICHAEL DAVIDSON and/or the ESTATE OF MICHAEL DAVIDSON, Third Party Defendant, represented by Patricia M. O'Neill , Blank Rome, LLP & William R. Bennett, III , Blank Rome, LLP, pro hac vice.

CHAMPA, VALMA, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Louis Champa, Jr., deceased, Counter Claimant, represented by John H. Hickey , Hickey Law Firm, PA & Brett Douglas Sager , Hickey Law Firm, PA.

Sea Star Line, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael M. Gropper , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP & Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice.

Tote Services, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael M. Gropper , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP & Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice.

MICHAEL DAVIDSON and/or the ESTATE OF MICHAEL DAVIDSON, Third Party Defendant, represented by Patricia M. O'Neill , Blank Rome, LLP, Richard E. Berman , Blank Rome, LLP & William R. Bennett, III , Blank Rome, LLP, pro hac vice.

Tote Services, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael M. Gropper , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP & Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice.

UPS Ground Freight, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Christoph M. Wahner , Countryman & McDaniel, pro hac vice & Marc Alan Rubin , Spector Rubin, PA.

Sea Star Line, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice & Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA.

Tote Services, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jerry Dean Hamilton , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice & Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA.

Terri C. Davis, Counter Claimant, represented by Christopher Charles Hazelip , Rogers Towers, P.A., Robert E. Warren , Law Offices of Robert E. Warren & Joshua A. Woolsey , Woolsey Law, PLLC.

Sea Star Line, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jerry Dean Hamilton , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice & Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA.

Tote Services, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice & Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA.

ACE Insurance Company, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Lawrence C. Glynn , Caruso Glynn, LLC, pro hac vice & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

ACE Insurance Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Lawrence C. Glynn , Caruso Glynn, LLC, pro hac vice & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

Seguros Universal, S.A., Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Lawrence C. Glynn , Caruso Glynn, LLC, pro hac vice & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

Seguros Universal, S.A., Counter Claimant, represented by Lawrence C. Glynn , Caruso Glynn, LLC, pro hac vice & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

Sea Star Line, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jerry Dean Hamilton , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice & Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA.

THOSE CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS (SYNDICATE 1955, SYNDICATE 2987, SYNDICATE 1183 AND SYNDICATE 0457) SUBSCRIBING TO POLICY # B0180 PC1422840 AS SUBROGEE OF DEL VALLE BRANDS, INC. AND f/u/b/o DEL VALLE, Counter Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Tote Services, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jerry Dean Hamilton , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice & Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA.

JARVON WHIGHAM, Counter Claimant, represented by Brett Douglas Sager , Hickey Law Firm, PA, John H. Hickey , Hickey Law Firm, PA & Sarah Lobel , Hickey Law Firm, PA.

Sea Star Line, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice & Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA.

Tote Services, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice & Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA.

Mamo Transportation, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Christopher E. Cotter , Roetzel & Andress, LPA, pro hac vice & Paul Anthony Giordano , Roetzel & Andress, LPA.

Sea Star Line, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jerry Dean Hamilton , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice, Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA & Karina Mabel Cerda-Collazo , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP.

Fedex Freight, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Marc Alan Rubin , Spector Rubin, PA.

Sea Star Line, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jerry Dean Hamilton , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice, Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA & Karina Mabel Cerda-Collazo , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP.

Tote Services, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jerry Dean Hamilton , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice, Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA & Karina Mabel Cerda-Collazo , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP.

ACE Insurance Company, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Lawrence C. Glynn , Caruso Glynn, LLC & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

ACE Insurance Company, Counter Claimant, represented by Lawrence C. Glynn , Caruso Glynn, LLC & William E. Cassidy , Cassidy & Black, PA.

Sea Star Line, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jerry Dean Hamilton , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice, Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA & Karina Mabel Cerda-Collazo , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP.

Truck Brokers, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Joseph A. Parrish, Jr. , Taylor & Associates, Attorneys at Law, PL & Stephanie S. Penninger , Benesch, Friedlander, Coplan & Aronoff, LLP, pro hac vice.

Sea Star Line, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jerry Dean Hamilton , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice, Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA & Karina Mabel Cerda-Collazo , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP.

Tote Services, Inc., Counter Defendant, represented by Chester Hooper , Holland & Knight, LLP, George D. Gabel, Jr. , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jennifer L. Kifer , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jerry Dean Hamilton , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP, Lawrence Joseph Hamilton, II , Holland & Knight, LLP, Michael A. DeIulis , Holland & Knight, LLP, Suzanne M. Judas , Holland & Knight, LLP, Timothy J. Conner , Holland & Knight, LLP, Vincent J. Foley , Holland & Knight, LLP, pro hac vice, Allan R. Kelley , Fowler White Burnett, PA & Karina Mabel Cerda-Collazo , Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel, LLP.

AGCS Marine Insurance Company, Cross Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Fedex Freight, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Marc Alan Rubin , Spector Rubin, PA.

Pfizer, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

AGCS Marine Insurance Company, Cross Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Pfizer Pharmaceuticals LLC, Cross Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Excel Cargo Services, Inc. d/b/a Caribex Worldwide, Cross Defendant, represented by Craig Liszt , Roig Lawyers & David Harlen Sump , Wilcox & Savage, P.C..

Pfizer, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

AGCS Marine Insurance Company, Cross Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Pfizer Pharmaceuticals LLC, Cross Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

UPS Ground Freight, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Christoph M. Wahner , Countryman & McDaniel & Marc Alan Rubin , Spector Rubin, PA.

AGCS Marine Insurance Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Carole A.R. Rouffet , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney, pro hac vice & James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Goodnight Acquisitions LLC a/k/a Goodnight International Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joseph Frank Rich , Cozen O'Connor & Robert W. Phelan , Cozen O'Connor.

The Gap, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Lynden Air Freight, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Thomas Albert Boyd, Jr. , Boyd & Sutter, PA.

AGCS Marine Insurance Company, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Carole A.R. Rouffet , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney & James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Arrowpac Inc., Third Party Defendant, represented by Deborah R. Reid , Deborah Reid, esq..

AGCS Marine Insurance Company, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Carole A.R. Rouffet , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney, James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney, Carole A.R. Rouffet , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney, James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney, Carole A.R. Rouffet , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney & James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Econocaribe Consolidators, inc., Third Party Defendant, represented by Andrew W. Anderson , Chartwell Law Offices, LLP, Gustavo Adolfo Martinez-Tristani , The Chartwell Law Offices, LLP & Raul J. Chacon, Jr. , Chartwell Law Offices, LLP.

AGCS Marine Insurance Company, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Carole A.R. Rouffet , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney & James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Starr Indemnity & Liability Co., Third Party Plaintiff, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

Caribbean Shipping Services, Inc., Third Party Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.

Mutchler Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by James F. Sweeney , Nicoletti, Hornig & Sweeney.

UPS Ground Freight, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Christoph M. Wahner , Countryman & McDaniel & Marc Alan Rubin , Spector Rubin, PA.

FM Global, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Joseph W. Janssen, III , Janssen & Siracusa, PA & Nathan T. Williams , Kennedy, Lillis, Schmidt & English.

Eagle Logistics Systems, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Lindsey C. Brock, III , Rumrell, McLeod & Brock.


ORDER

In Admiralty

Before this Court is Claimant Valma Champa's "Motion for Extension of Time for the Reinstated Mediation Deadlinen (Dkt. 534, filed Dec. 6, 2016), and Petitioners' Response in opposition thereto (Dkt. 535, filed Dec. 8, 2016). In her motion, Claimant...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases