HANEY v. 3M COMPANY

Civil Action No. MJG-12-1396.

CHARLES DEAN HANEY, Individually, and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Ambrose Haney, et al., Plaintiffs. v. 3M COMPANY, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, D. Maryland.

August 10, 2015.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Charles Dean Haney, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew E Kiely , Matthew E Kiely LLC & Daniel Aaron Brown , Brown and Gould LLP.

Jeffery William Haney, Individually, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew E Kiely , Matthew E Kiely LLC & Daniel Aaron Brown , Brown and Gould LLP.

John Henry Haney, Individually, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew E Kiely , Matthew E Kiely LLC & Daniel Aaron Brown , Brown and Gould LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP & Kelly M Marzullo , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP, Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP & Terri Lynn Goldberg , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

The Marley Company, Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Noland Company, Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Rapid-American Corporation, Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP & Thomas M Goss , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Koppers Co., Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

3M Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Met-Pro Corporation, on behalf of its Dean Pumps division, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Theodore F Roberts , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

3M Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Claimant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

3M Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Met-Pro Corporation, on behalf of its Dean Pumps division, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

ITT Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Met-Pro Corporation, on behalf of its Dean Pumps division, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

3M Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP, Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP & Theodore F Roberts , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Conwed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M Alexander , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC & Jason A Steinhardt , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

3M Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Conwed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M Alexander , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC & Jason A Steinhardt , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

3M Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Trane U.S. Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Conwed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M Alexander , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Walter E. Campbell Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Lloyd Flax , Law Offices of Richard L Flax LLC.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Trane U.S. Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Conwed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M Alexander , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC & Jason A Steinhardt , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Walter E. Campbell Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Lloyd Flax , Law Offices of Richard L Flax LLC.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Trane U.S. Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Claimant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP, Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP & Terri Lynn Goldberg , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

Owens-Illinois, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Randolph L Burns , The Burns Law Firm PC & Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.


MEMORANDUM AND ORDER RE: SUMMARY JUDGMENT [HOPEMAN]

The Court has before it Motion of Defendant Hopeman Brothers, Inc. ("Hopeman"), for Summary Judgment [ECF No. 849], and the materials submitted relating thereto. The Court finds a hearing unnecessary.

I. BACKGROUND

On February...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases