1. Home
  2. Browse Decisions
  3. HANEY v. 3M COMPANY
 

HANEY v. 3M COMPANY

Civil Action No. MJG-12-1396.

CHARLES DEAN HANEY, Individually, and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Ambrose Haney, et al., Plaintiffs. v. 3M COMPANY, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, D. Maryland.

August 10, 2015.

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Charles Dean Haney, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew E Kiely , Matthew E Kiely LLC & Daniel Aaron Brown , Brown and Gould LLP.

Jeffery William Haney, Individually, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew E Kiely , Matthew E Kiely LLC & Daniel Aaron Brown , Brown and Gould LLP.

John Henry Haney, Individually, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew E Kiely , Matthew E Kiely LLC & Daniel Aaron Brown , Brown and Gould LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP & Kelly M Marzullo , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP, Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP & Terri Lynn Goldberg , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

The Marley Company, Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Noland Company, Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Rapid-American Corporation, Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP & Thomas M Goss , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Koppers Co., Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

3M Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Met-Pro Corporation, on behalf of its Dean Pumps division, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Theodore F Roberts , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

3M Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Claimant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

3M Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Met-Pro Corporation, on behalf of its Dean Pumps division, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

ITT Corporation, Cross Claimant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Met-Pro Corporation, on behalf of its Dean Pumps division, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

3M Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP, Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP & Theodore F Roberts , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Claimant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Conwed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M Alexander , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC & Jason A Steinhardt , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

3M Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Cleaver-Brooks Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Douglas B Pfeiffer , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Conwed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M Alexander , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC & Jason A Steinhardt , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

3M Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Trane U.S. Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Claimant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Conwed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M Alexander , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Walter E. Campbell Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Lloyd Flax , Law Offices of Richard L Flax LLC.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Trane U.S. Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Burnham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by F Ford Loker, Jr , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Conwed Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Jennifer M Alexander , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC & Jason A Steinhardt , Brassel Alexander & Rice LLC.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Emerson Electric Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Federated Development Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Ingersoll-Rand Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Lockheed Martin Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

Riggs Distler & Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Schneider Electric USA, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Superior Boiler Works, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robin Silver , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Leianne S McEvoy , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Walter E. Campbell Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Richard Lloyd Flax , Law Offices of Richard L Flax LLC.

Thos. Somerville Co., Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Trane U.S. Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Deborah K St Lawrence Thompson , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Michael Alan Brown , Miles and Stockbridge PC, Christopher J Madaio , Miles and Stockbridge PC & Michael J Halaiko , Miles and Stockbridge PC.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP.

Bayer Cropscience, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Columbia Boiler Company of Pottstown, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Patrick Burns , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Compudyne Corp., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Dean Pump, Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Elof Hansson, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Gould Pumps, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP, Patrick C Smith , Dehay and Elliston LLP, Steven J Parrott , Dehay and Elliston LLP & Kira A Cook , DeHay and Elliston LLP.

Graham Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Gerry H Tostanoski , Tydings and Rosenberg LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Defendant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

IMO Industries, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Joel D Newport , Moore and Jackson LLC.

ITT Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

Industrial Holding, Cross Defendant, represented by John Stewart Cobb , North and Cobb PA.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

John Crane, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Allan Woolson , P A Woolson PA & Scott J McDowell , P A Woolson PA.

Noland Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Scott Hamilton Phillips , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

Oakfabco, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Neil Joseph MacDonald , MacDonald Law Group, LLC.

Inc Owens-Illinois, Cross Defendant, represented by Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

Rapid-American Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Brendan Henderson Fitzpatrick , Venable LLP & Scott Mason Richmond , Venable LLP.

TACO, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Robert E Scott, Jr , Semmes Bowen and Semmes, Eric Michael Leppo , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC & Marisa Anne Trasatti , Semmes Bowen and Semmes PC.

The Marley Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

The Marley-Wylain Company, Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Union Carbide Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Danielle Grilli Marcus , Whiteford Taylor and Preston LLP & Laura M Higgs , MacDonald Law Group LLP.

Warren Pumps, LLC, Cross Defendant, represented by Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

Weil-McLain, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Benjamin D Whetzel , Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney Ltd.

Yarway Corporation, Cross Defendant, represented by Allyson N Ho , Morgan Lewis and Bockius LLP.

Hopeman Brothers, Inc,, Cross Claimant, represented by David W Allen , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP, Malcolm Sean Brisker , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP & Terri Lynn Goldberg , Goodell DeVries Leech and Dann LLP.

International Paper Company, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Clare Marie Maisano , Evert Weathersby Houff.

Owens-Illinois, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Randolph L Burns , The Burns Law Firm PC & Peter Andersen Moir , Quilling Selander Lownds Winslett and Moser.

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER RE: SUMMARY JUDGMENT [HOPEMAN]

The Court has before it Motion of Defendant Hopeman Brothers, Inc. ("Hopeman"), for Summary Judgment [ECF No. 849], and the materials submitted relating thereto. The Court finds a hearing unnecessary.

I. BACKGROUND

On February 8, 2012, Charlie Ambrose Haney ("Haney") filed the instant lawsuit in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City, Maryland against eighty-four Defendants (one of which was Hopeman) alleging damages due to exposure to asbestos. On May 8, 2012, the case was removed to this Court based upon the federal officer removal provision, 28 U.S.C. § 1442(a)(1).

Haney died on July 1, 2012 from malignant mesothelioma caused by exposure to asbestos. On October 13, 2013, Plaintiffs Charles Dean Haney, individually and as personal representative of the Estate of Haney, Jeffrey William Haney, and John Henry Haney (collectively "Plaintiffs"), filed the First Amended Complaint ("FAC") against fifty-six Defendants (one of which was Defendant Hopeman Brothers, Inc.), asserting claims in five Counts:

Count I Strict Liability Count II Breach of Warranty Count III Negligence Count IV Aiding and Abetting and Conspiracy Count V Wrongful Death

By the instant Motion, Defendant Hopeman Brothers, Inc. ("Hopeman") seeks summary judgment pursuant to Rule 56 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

II. SUMMARY JUDGMENT STANDARD

A motion for summary judgment shall be granted if the pleadings and supporting documents "show[] that there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact and the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law." Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(a).

The well-established principles pertinent to summary judgment motions can be distilled to a simple statement: The Court may look at the evidence presented in regard to a motion for summary judgment through the non-movant's rose-colored glasses, but must view it realistically. After so doing, the essential question is whether a reasonable fact finder could return a verdict for the non-movant or whether the movant would, at trial, be entitled to judgment as a matter of law. See, e.g., Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 322-323 (1986); Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242, 248 (1986); Shealy v. Winston, 929 F.2d 1009, 1012 (4th Cir. 1991).

Thus, in order "[t]o defeat a motion for summary judgment, the party opposing the motion must present evidence of specific facts from which the finder of fact could reasonably find for him or her." Mackey v. Shalala, 43 F.Supp.2d 559, 564 (D. Md. 1999) (emphasis added). However, "self-serving, conclusory, and uncorroborated statements are insufficient to create a genuine issue of material fact." Int'l Waste Indus. Corp. v. Cape Envtl. Mgmt., Inc., 988 F.Supp.2d 542, 558 n.11 (D. Md. 2013); see also Wadley v. Park at Landmark, LP, 264 F. App'x 279, 281 (4th Cir. 2008).

When evaluating a motion for summary judgment, the Court must bear in mind that the "[s]ummary judgment procedure is properly regarded not as a disfavored procedural shortcut, but rather as an integral part of the Federal Rules as a whole, which are designed `to secure the just, speedy and inexpensive determination of every action.'" Celotex, 477 U.S. at 327 (quoting Fed. R. Civ. P. 1).

III. BREACH OF WARRANTY, AIDING AND ABETTING, PUNITIVE DAMAGES

In the FAC, Plaintiffs present claims for Breach of Warranty (Count II) and Aiding and Abetting and Conspiracy (Count IV). FAC ¶¶ 10-14, 21-26. Plaintiffs also seek punitive damages in the amount of $50,000,000.00. See, e.g., id. at 16.

Hopeman contends that it is entitled to summary judgment on Plaintiffs' claims for breach of warranty, aiding and abetting, and punitive damages because:

Plaintiffs failed to establish clear and convincing evidence of actual malice to support their claim for punitive damages; Plaintiffs' breach of warranty claim is barred by the statute of limitations and for lack of privity; and There is no evidence to support a claim for aiding and abetting a conspiracy.

[ECF No. 849-1] at 10-15.

In their Response to the instant Motion, Plaintiffs do not address these contentions. Plaintiffs' failure to respond to Hopeman's summary judgment assertions regarding the claims for breach of warranty, aiding and abetting, and punitive damages constitutes abandonment of those claims. See Johnson v. Norfolk S. Ry. Co., No. CIV.A. MJG-12-3374, 2014 WL 4662384, at *2 (D. Md. Sept. 16, 2014) (citing cases); see also Grant-Fletcher v. McMullen & Drury, P.A., 964 F.Supp.2d 514, 525 (D. Md. 2013) ("Fletcher appears to have abandoned this argument by not opposing M & D's Motion for Summary Judgment on the issue.").

Accordingly, the Court concludes1 that Hopeman is entitled to summary judgment as a matter of law on Counts II and IV and on Plaintiffs' claim for punitive damages.

IV. NEGLIGENCE AND STRICT LIABILITY

Hopeman contends that Plaintiffs have failed to present sufficient evidence to permit a reasonable jury to find that Haney was exposed to asbestos from any product for which Hopeman is liable to the extent that the exposure was a substantial factor in causing Haney's mesothelioma.

In their Response, Plaintiffs state generally that "Haney was exposed to asbestos . . . while working as a machinist during the new construction of naval and merchant ships at the Bethlehem Steel Sparrows Point Shipyard." [ECF No. 937] at 2. Specifically, as to Hopeman, Plaintiffs state:

From July of 1956 to the spring of 1958, Mr. Haney was employed as an outside machinist by the Bethlehem Steel Sparrows Point Shipyard. It is at that jobsite that Mr. Haney claims exposure to the asbestos-containing bulkhead (wall) panels that Hopeman admittedly installed onboard the ore carrier.

Id. at 2-3 (internal citation omitted).

Accordingly, the claims against Hopeman are based solely upon alleged exposure to asbestos in Marinite panels installed by Hopeman on the ore carrier Hull No. 4549 ("the 4549") in 1956.

A. Exposure to Asbestos-Containing Marinite Panels

Hopeman states that it "has not and does not contest that it installed Marinite panels on" the 4549. [ECF No. 938] at 1. However, Hopeman contends that "Hopeman's documents show that it installed insulation as well, and that, based on the testimony of Mr. Haney, is the only material he observed Hopeman install" and, therefore, "[i]n the absence of proof that this was an asbestos-containing product, Hopeman is entitled to summary judgment." [ECF No. 849] at 9-10.

Hopeman installed the asbestos-containing Marinite panels on the bulkhead — or, interior — walls in the hull of the 4549. Ramsey Dep. 23:7-24:14. The proffered evidence referring to Haney's alleged exposure to the installation of Marinite panels on the 4549 is provided by deposition testimony from Haney.

Q. [By Plaintiffs' counsel]: During this six-month period when you were working at Beth Steel from the summer until December of 1956 — and you have told us you worked on all the ships that were in the wet dock in the engine and boiler room. . . . . Q. Do you recollect any — any contractors or outside workers installing walls or paneling? A. Putting up — putting up bulkheads, a sheet — sheeting over the, like, insulation. Q. And when those workers were installing that paneling on the bulkheads do you recall them having to saw those panels when you were work — walking through that vicinity? A. Yes. You had to cut them to fit.

Haney Disc. Dep. May 10, 2012, 442:4-8, 443:2-16 (objections to form omitted).

Later that day, there was questioning by counsel for Hopeman:

Q. Okay. The — the panels that were installed on the bulkheads, do you know what that panel material looked like? A. It is blackish on the outside. On the inside it was kind of a grayish . . . . Q. Can you tell me how the panel material would be installed on the bulkhead? A. They would measure it and cut it where it would fit the bulkhead.

Id. 456:1-457:2.

Q. Were there — were these panels — they fit on the wall, correct? A. Yes. Q. How were they fastened to the wall? A. They had these nail guns — excuse me. They had these nails with a sheet metal around it. And they could take it in through — through all this panel we are talking about. Q. Yes, sir. A. And could hit it with an arc and it would bond. I mean, that would secure it right up against the bulkhead. Q. And the arc was some type of weld; is that right? A. That's what it is.

Id. 459:3-18.

In his de bene esse deposition,2 held on May 24, 2012, Haney was again questioned about the installation of bulkhead panels:

Q. [By Plaintiffs' Counsel: What kind of work did you see contractors doing when the engine room? A. They was putting up the drywall on the Bulk heads. Q. Can you describe — A. Dry dock. You said drywall A. Well, drywall p;utting it on the bulk heads. Q. It was like — A. Sheets of it. Q. Okay. A. Like eight by ten, et cetera, et cetera. Q. All right. And you — can you describe how they were putting those panels up on the walls? Q. What kind of work were they doing? A. They were — they were putting on the insulation. Q. All right. But when you — you said they were putting these panels up, how were they doing that? A. They were putting it up on the walls, bulk heads. And they had these little pock things they would shoot at it like a nail, fuse them right in like a nail sticking out. And you got is the insulation in behind it, and secure it right down. Q. And when they were putting these panels up on the wall was it always a perfect fit? A. No. Q. Or did they ever have to cut it? A. They were cutting it left and right. Q. How were they cutting it left and right? A. With saws — saws, electric saws, pneumatic saws.

Haney De Bene Esse Dep. May 24, 2012, 62:2-64:9 (objections to form and compound omitted).

Later that day, questioning by counsel for Hopeman:

Q. And you said these panels were blackish color on the outside? A. Right. Q. And a grayish color on the inside? A. Yes.

Id. 178:11-15.

Hopeman contends that "Mr. Haney's description of the [paneling] material and how it was installed is inconsistent with the Marinite panels installed on [the 4549]." [ECF No. 938] at 1. Hopeman points to the 1995 trial testimony of Charles Johnson, a Hopeman employee, who discussed installing comfort insulation in the hull of ships before installing the divisional paneling system. See [ECF No. 849-10]. Hopeman also relies upon the 1996 deposition testimony of Otis Craun and Park Gardner, former Hopeman employees who installed divisional partitioning panels and bulkhead panels on ships at the Sparrows Point Shipyard. See [ECF Nos. 849-8, 849-9]. According to Hopeman, this testimony, when compared with Haney's, establishes that "[t]he material described by Mr. Haney is clearly this comfort insulation, and not a Marinite board." [ECF No. 849-1] at 9.

Haney's deposition testimony is far from conclusive on what he observed. At one point, he described observing "drywall [being] put[] on the bulk heads," and then, at another point, he described seeing workers "put[] up insulation." However, Hopeman mischaracterizes the deposition and trial testimony of its former employees, which it contends shows that the process for installing Marinite panels was "entirely different" from what Haney described. See [ECF 938] at 5.

Based on the evidence in the record, the Court cannot conclude that no reasonable jury could find that Haney observed the installation of asbestos-containing Marinite panels on the 4549. Accordingly, Hopeman is not entitled to summary judgment on this ground.

B. Substantial Factor Causation

However, even if Haney had been exposed to the installation of Marinite panels by Hopeman, Hopeman is entitled to summary judgment because Plaintiffs have not provided sufficient evidence for a jury to reasonably infer that Haney's exposure to the panels was a substantial factor in causing his mesothelioma.

In Maryland, "to prevail on claims of negligence or products liability, the plaintiff must prove proximate causation." Hurley v. Anchor Packing Co., No. CIV.A. GLR-12-460, 2014 WL 1794116, at *2 (D. Md. May 5, 2014), appeal docketed, No. 14-2271 (4th Cir. 2014). "To establish proximate causation in Maryland, the plaintiff must introduce evidence which allows the jury to reasonably conclude that it is more likely than not that the conduct of the defendant was a substantial factor in bringing about the result." Lohrmann v. Pittsburgh Corning Corp., 782 F.2d 1156, 1161-62 (4th Cir. 1986). Although proximate cause is generally an issue "reserved for the trier of fact[,] `it becomes a question of law in cases where reasoning minds cannot differ'" and "`the facts admit of but one inference.'" Pittway Corp. v. Collins, 973 A.2d 771, 792 (Md. 2009) (citations omitted).

1. Them Proferred Evidence

The only proffered evidence regarding the extent of Haney's exposure to the installation of Marinite panels on the 4549 by Hopeman3 is provided by deposition testimony from Haney.

Q. [By Plaintiffs' counsel]: During this six-month period when you were working at Beth Steel from the summer until December of 1956 — and you have told us you worked on all the ships that were in the wet dock in the engine and boiler room. When you would get on the ship, did you have to walk through companionways and other compartments to get to the engine and the boiler room? A. Yes. Q. And when you would walk through the companionways and the compartments to make your way down to the engine room was — was there work going on? A. Yes, there were. Q. Do you recollect any — any contractors or outside workers installing walls or paneling? A. Putting up — putting up bulkheads, a sheet — sheeting over the, like, insulation. . . . . Q. All right. And when they would consult these panels to fit was — what was the condition of the air like in those companionways and compartments that you were walking through? A. A little dusty. Q. Okay. And did you breathe that dust? A. Yes, until I got through it.

Haney Disc. Dep. May 10, 2012, 442:4-444:8 (internal objections to form omitted).

Later that day, there was questioning by counsel for Hopeman:

Q. [E]xplain to me how it is that you would get down to the engine room. A. I — I'd come off the main deck. Q. Right A. Down through the hatch. . . . . A. Two — two main ladders going down to the engine room. . . . . Q. How long would it take you to get from the deck of the ship when you got on the ship from the land to get down to the engine room? A. This is a lot of ifs and ands there. . . . . Q. I know. Well, just tell me on average how — how long it would take you. I understand that. . . . . A. I mean with — with — with — it is according to what you are carrying. Q. What would you be carrying when you were going down — A. Tool pouches. A tool pouch. . . . . Q. I just want to know how much time it would take you to get down there. And I understand it would vary a little bit but — A. Three to five minutes.

Id. 448:15-449:3, 449:16-450:2, 450:16-451:8, 451:17-20. Haney later reiterated that it took him three to five minutes to get to the engine room: "I am three to five minutes getting me down to the engine room." Id. 461:18-20.

During further questioning by counsel for Hopeman:

Q. Okay. During the period of time until December 1956 at the shipyard are you able to tell me how many times you saw the paneling material installed aboard ship? A. Eight or ten times. Q. Okay. Eight to ten times? A. Eight to ten somewhere.

Id. 466:10-16.

In his de bene esse deposition, Haney was again questioned about his work on the 4549:

Q. (by Plaintiff's counsel): Now, when you were working on the ore carrier in the engine room, how much do you think you worked on that ore carrier in the engine room during that six-month period at Beth Steel? A. Maybe a month or better. Q. And each day that you worked on that ore carrier in 1956 at Beth Steel, on any given day, how many times do you think you had to go from the engine room back to the dock? A. Six times, a dozen. . . . . Q. Each time you would go back and forth from the engine room back to the dock, did you have to pass through the areas on the ship where those contractors — A. Yep. Q. — were putting up the walls? A. Right.

Haney De Bene Esse Dep. May 24, 2012, 65:2-66:6 (objections omitted).

However, later that afternoon, there was additional questioning by counsel for Hopeman:

Q. When you were working at Sparrows Point, you told me when I was asking you questions that to get from the deck when you were on land to the ship down to the engine room and boiler room where you were stationed, it took you about three to five minutes to make that trip. That's true, correct? A. True. Q. All right. And you told me that from when you started at Bethlehem Steel Sparrows Point shipyard in June of (sic) July of '58 (sic) until the end of that year in December, that you saw panels being cut while you were making that trek passing through the area about eight to ten times. That is true, correct? A. Correct.

Id. 177:16-178:10.

2. Causation Analysis

Haney is considered a "bystander" because he did not work directly with the Marinite panels. See Eagle-Picher Indus., Inc. v. Balbos, 604 A.2d 445, 460 (Md. 1992). "The Court of Appeals of Maryland has established a `frequency, regularity, proximity' test for substantial factor causation in [bystander] asbestos-exposure cases." Hurley, 2014 WL 1794116, at *2. In Eagle-Picher Industries, Inc. v. Balbos, the Court of Appeals explained:

Whether the exposure of any given bystander to any particular supplier's product will be legally sufficient to permit a finding of substantial-factor causation is fact specific to each case. . . . [T]he factors to be evaluated include the nature of the product, the frequency of its use, the proximity, in distance and in time, of a plaintiff to the use of a product, and the regularity of the exposure of that plaintiff to the use of that product. "In addition, trial courts must consider the evidence presented as to medical causation of the plaintiff's particular disease."

604 A.2d at 460 (emphasis added) (citations omitted).

"To support a reasonable inference of substantial causation from circumstantial evidence, there must be evidence of exposure to a specific product on a regular basis over some extended period of time in proximity to where the plaintiff actually worked." Lohrmann, 782 F.2d at 1162-63. Plaintiffs have not met this burden.

Haney testified at two different points during his discovery and de bene esse depositions that he observed the installation of paneling "eight to ten times" while he took the three- to five-minute-walk from the main deck to the engine and boiler room. See Haney Disc. Dep. May 10, 2012, 461:18-20, 466:10-16; Haney De Bene Esse Dep. May 24, 2012, 177:16-178:10. The duration of the exposure while Haney worked on the 4549 was no more than six months (between July and December of 1956), and, in fact, according to Haney, was closer to "a month or better." Haney De Bene Esse Dep. May 24, 2012, 65:2-66:6.

Moreover, it is not clear that the "eight to ten times" Haney observed the installation of the Marinite panels all occurred while he was working on the 4549. See Haney Disc. Dep. May 10, 2012, 466:18-467:17 (Q. I know you were working on different ships. How much time would you spend on any particular ship at Sparrows Point until December of 1956? . . . . Did you work on the same ship for some period of time? A. No. Day to day."); Haney De Bene Esse Dep. May 24, 2012, 177:16-178:10 ("Q. [U] you told me that from when you started at Bethlehem Steel Sparrows Point shipyard in June of (sic) July of '58 (sic) until the end of that year in December, that you saw panels being cut while you were making that trek passing through the area about eight to ten times. That is true, correct? A. Correct.").

Haney's exposure to the installation of Marinite panels on the 4549 was significantly less frequent, proximate, and regular than the exposures that courts in Maryland have found adequate to satisfy the Balbos "frequency, proximity, and regularity" test. See, e.g., Sherin v. Crane-Houdaille, Inc., 47 F.Supp.3d 280, 295 (D. Md. 2014) ("Mr. Sherin has provided sufficient evidence for a jury to reasonably infer that the Balbos `regular, frequent, and proximate exposure' test is met. . . . Defining the relevant time period as 1969 to 1976, and performing basic math, Mr. Sherin visited between 672 and 840 construction sites during that time. . . . Dust from the joint compound adhered to his socks, shoes, pants, and jacket that were washed by Mrs. Sherin. . . . From Mrs. Sherin's laundry exposure and the medical testimony, a jury could reasonably infer that Union Carbide's asbestos fiber was a substantial factor in causing Mrs. Sherin's mesothelioma." (internal citations and footnotes omitted)); ACandS, Inc. v. Godwin, 667 A.2d 116, 124-126 (Md. 1995), on reconsideration (Dec. 1, 1995) ("For more than twenty years McNiel worked outside the partially open-sided No. 4 Open Hearth building and was required to enter it five to six times a day. He was also required from time to time for more than two decades to go to No. 5 Soaking Pit. Based on the evidence that Bethlehem employees regularly used Unibestos half-rounds and block, McNiel has satisfied the Balbos test as to PCC. . . . [T]he evidence places Russell at the Point doing pipe covering work for twelve to fourteen months while Unibestos was available to Bethlehem pipe coverers. Further, pipe coverers employed by Bethlehem were `always' around when Russell was working for a contractor. . . . There was sufficient evidence of substantial causation to take the case to the jury on behalf of Russell against PCC. . . . The Leaf brothers worked on the No. 5 Blast Furnace outage for a shift of twelve hours in a twenty-four hour period, seven days each week, for six consecutive weeks. Thus, there was sufficient evidence that the plaintiff Leaf was regularly and proximately exposed to Unibestos, which was frequently used.").

The evidence establishes that, at most, Haney passed through the areas where Hopeman installed the Marinite panels on the 4549 eight to ten times for three to five minutes each time over the course of roughly two months. According to the Court of Special Appeals of Maryland, this is not sufficient to satisfy the substantial factor causation standard for asbestos exposure cases. See Anchor Packing Co. v. Grimshaw, 692 A.2d 5, 40 (Md. Ct. Spec. App. 1997) ("As far as Zumas's exposure to Hopeman's cutting of panels on board ships in the wet dock area, there is no direct evidence that Zumas worked in proximity, regularity, or frequency to Hopeman's operations. Zumas testified that he would pass through the quarters to get to his work area, but he did not work inside the quarters. . . . The facts . . . do not establish Zumas's proximity, frequency, or regularity of exposure."), vacated sub nom. on other grounds Porter Hayden Co. v. Bullinger, 713 A.2d 962 (Md. 1998) abrogated on other grounds by John Crane, Inc. v. Scribner, 800 A.2d 727 (Md. 2002).

Plaintiffs contend that Haney's deposition testimony establishes that he observed the installation of Marinite panels "six times, a dozen" times per day. [ECF 937] at 4. However, Haney did not provide such testimony. Moreover, Haney's attorney — with ample opportunity to do so — did not in any way seek to reconcile that testimony with Haney's clear statements — made during both his discovery and de bene esse depositions — that he saw panels being cut and installed on the 4549 only "eight to ten" times.

The Court finds that Plaintiffs have not presented evidence sufficient to permit a reasonable jury to conclude that Haney was exposed to the installation of Marinite panels on the 4549 with the frequency, proximity, and regularity necessary to hold Hopeman liable for Haney's mesothelioma.

Accordingly, Hopeman is entitled to summary judgment on Plaintiffs' claims for strict liability and negligence.4

V. CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons:

1. The Motion of Defendant Hopeman Brothers, Inc., for Summary Judgment [ECF No. 849] is GRANTED. 2. The Cross-Claim of Hopeman Brothers, Inc., Against Defendant Owens Illinois, Inc. [ECF No. 687] is DISMISSED AS MOOT. 3. Judgment shall be entered by separate Order.

SO ORDERED.

FootNotes


1. See Custer v. Pan Am. Life Ins. Co., 12 F.3d 410, 416 (4th Cir. 1993) ("[P]laintiff failed to respond to the defendants' motion for summary judgment, despite repeated notices to do so. This failure to respond, however, does not fulfill the burdens imposed on moving parties by Rule 56. . . . Although the failure of a party to respond to a summary judgment motion may leave uncontroverted those facts established by the motion, the moving party must still show that the uncontroverted facts entitle the party to "a judgment as a matter of law." The failure to respond to the motion does not automatically accomplish this. Thus, the court, in considering a motion for summary judgment, must review the motion, even if unopposed, and determine from what it has before it whether the moving party is entitled to summary judgment as a matter of law.").
2. The United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit had stated that "[t]he Federal Rules of Civil Procedure make no distinction for use of a deposition at trial between one taken for discovery purposes and one taken for use at trial (de bene esse)." Tatman v. Collions, 938 F.2d 509, 510-11 (4th Cir. 1991). The court explained that "Fed. R. Civ. P. 32 provides that a deposition may be offered at trial, subject to the rules of evidfence, as though the witness were present and testifying. . . . It is irrelevant . . . that [the deposition] was initiated only for discovery purposes, or that it was taken before other discovery was comkpleted." Id. at 511.
3. Haney could not recall the name of the manufacturer of the panels or the company that installed them, but Hopeman has "admit[ted], at least for purposes of this motion, that it in fact did install Marinite panels during the course of its work on Hull 4549 during September and October, 1956." [ECF No. 849-1] at 9-10.
4. The Court has found that Hopeman is entitled to summary judgment on Plaintiffs' strict liability and negligence claims on the grounds that Haney's exposure to the installation of the asbestos-containing Marinite panels was not a substantial factor in causing his mesothelioma. Therefore, Hopeman also is entitled to summary judgment on Plaintiffs' wrongful death claims because there has been no "wrongful act." See Md. Code Ann., Cts. & Jud. Proc. §§ 3-901, 3-902.

Comment

1000 Characters Remaining

Leagle.com reserves the right to edit or remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.

User Comments

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases