1. Home
  2. Browse Decisions
  3. IN RE DARVOCET, DARVON, AND PROPOXYPHENE PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION
 

IN RE DARVOCET, DARVON, AND PROPOXYPHENE PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION

Master File No. 2:11-md-2226-DCR, Civil Action No. 2:13-058-DCR., 2:13-060-DCR, 2:13-061-DCR, 2:13-073-DCR, 2:13-074-DCR, 2:13-075-DCR, 2:13-076-DCR

IN RE: DARVOCET, DARVON, AND PROPOXYPHENE PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION Bowen, et al., v. McKesson Corp., et al., Mitchell, et al., v. McKesson Corp., et al., Baltazar, et al., v. McKesson Corp., et al., Dadoush, et al., v. McKesson Corp., et al., Gomez, et al., v. McKesson Corp., et al., Saunders, et al., v. McKesson Corp., et al., Jasmin, et al., v. McKesson Corp., et al.,

United States District Court, E.D. Kentucky, Northern Division, Covington.

February 27, 2015.

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Diane Dickerson, Executor plaintiff, represented by Christopher P. Williams , Diaz Law Firm, PLLC, Gerald Joseph Diaz, Jr. , Diaz Law Firm, PLLC, James R. Franks, Jr. , Wheeler & Franks Law Firm, P.C., James Russell Segars, III , Diaz Law Firm, PLLC, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte & William R. Wheeler, Jr. , Wheeler & Franks Law Firm, P.C..

James Daugherty, Plaintiff, represented by Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Diane Dickerson, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher P. Williams , Diaz Law Firm, PLLC, Gerald Joseph Diaz, Jr. , Diaz Law Firm, PLLC, James R. Franks, Jr. , Wheeler & Franks Law Firm, P.C., James Russell Segars, III , Diaz Law Firm, PLLC, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte & William R. Wheeler, Jr. , Wheeler & Franks Law Firm, P.C..

Judy Schiller, Plaintiff, Pro Se.

Burneva Williams, Adminstratrix for the Estate of Marion Williams a/k/a Marion T. Williams Estate of Marion Williams Estate of Marion T. Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Michael J. Stachowski .

Joan Bossert, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Donna Bostick, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Jerald Bowen, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

William Bowman, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Regina Boykin, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Geraldine Bracken, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Mabel Braddy, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Marjorie Brasher, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Abbei Brawley, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Sybol Bray, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Wanda Brewer, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Angelia Bridges, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Margie Brinkley, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Gordon Britt, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Trina Broadnax, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Curtis Brown, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

James Brown, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

John Brown, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Patricia Brown, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Pearline Brown, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Robert Brown, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Antoinette Brush, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Linda Bryan, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Carletha Buggs, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Jozetta Bullock, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Ginger Burchett, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Mary Burke, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Leroy Burns, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Carolyn Byrd, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Joseph Caldwell, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Christopher Calkins, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Phyllis Campbell, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Cathy Carroll, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Neldra Carroll, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Robert Carver, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Ervin Cassell, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Retha Castellon, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Mabel Chambers, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Joseph Cheney, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Charles Childs, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Gladys Chism, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Lynne Claughton, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

John Clibrey, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Don Coffee, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Laretia Colbert, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Carolyn Coley, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

George Connor, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Charlie Cook, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Marilyn Bullock, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Rocky Abernathy, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Edward Baltazar, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA & Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump.

Maria Estrada, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA & Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump.

Ericka Graves, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Robert Hunsdon, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Timothy Jernigan, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Deanna Bell, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Sandra Boelter, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Carolyn Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Pamela Cinnamon, Plaintiff, represented by Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Janice DeWitt, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Brenda Engst, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Timothy Evans, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Brenda Groleau, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Constance Kasper, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Marilyn McCormick, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Barbara Villapando-Baxter, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Kathy Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Diana Lopez, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Robert McNeal, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Paula Missey, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Joye Osborne, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Melonie Powell, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Pamela Zahn, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Yvonne Bricker, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Judy Clark, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Nicholas Coppa, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Dorothy Edwards, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Paul Visor, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Adam Jordan, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Pamela Kelly, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Kimberly Motes, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Essie Cole, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA, Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump & Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte.

Calogero Gambino, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Maria Gambino, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Marlene Gano, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Richard Gano, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Antonio Gonzalez, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Carlota Gonzalez, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Barbara Goss, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Jerry A. Goss, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Donna Shepard Mitchell, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Thomas Mitchell, Member Case 2:13-cv-60, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Jesus Grijalva, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Raquel Grijalva, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Charles Grimes, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Laura Grimes, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Mary Groll, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Steven Groll, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Debra Grubbs, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Michael Grubbs, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Dwayne Haagen, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Judie Haagen, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

David Hall, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Shirley Hall, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Barbara May Hall, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Aaron Harris, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Patricia Harris, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Betty Hartman, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Beverly Haynes, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Oscar Haynes, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Robert Hickman, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Sharon Hickman, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Debra Hoffman, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Kathryn M. Hoffman, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Stephen Hoffman, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Walter Hoffman, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

James Hall, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

James Hogan, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Tiffany Hogan, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Rhonda Hollan, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Troy Hollan, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Barbara Holmes, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Harold Holmes, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Florence Howard, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Jesse Howard, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Carol Hubbard, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Robert Hubbard, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Idamae Hudgins, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Joseph Hudgins, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Bobbie Dennis, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Valdemar Guadiana, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte, Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA & Trevor Bruce Rockstad , Davis & Crump.

Louis Lee, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Jeffrey Lerner, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Kathleen Lesiak, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Tim Lessenden, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Evelyn Dadoush, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Richard Kennedy, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Sara Kerby, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Johnnie Key, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

George Krainert, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Elizabeth Kramer, Plaintiff, represented by

Elizabeth Kramer, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC.

Elizabeth Kramer, Plaintiff, represented by Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Michael Kraxberger, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Karen Krueger, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Olgierd Kubiak, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Wendi LaValley, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Vickie Langston, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Judy Leaf, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Lillian Lee, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Thomas Lickiss, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Robin Lindsay, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Karen Linewaver, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Lillie Logan, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Douglas Long, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Dani Lowry, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Ronald Lucas, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Bruce Ludwig, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Tammy Lusk, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Patsy Lyons, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Lynda Macwhinney, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Julia Malone, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Deborah Sue Manno, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Shelia Mantooth, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Linda Marino, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Ruth Marshall, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Michael Martz, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Martha Mason, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Cletus Mastilock, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Linda Mathieu, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Scott Matlock, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

William McCanna, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Ryan McClemens, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Dottie McClure, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Ray McCord, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Theresa McCord, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Michelle McCormick, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Angela McCoy, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Thomas McCune, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Alison McGhee, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Harolene McKenzie, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Washington McLelland, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Maureen McKay, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Derrall E. Daniel, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Lechia Daniel, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Sandra Daugherty, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Deborah Davidson, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Ralph Davidson, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Georgia Lee Deckard, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Rollie Deckard, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Evelyn Dicarlo, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

James Dicarlo, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Dixie Gomez, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Florentino Gomez-Gonzalez, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Drew Dieterich, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Fred Donze, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Louise Donze, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Dorothy J. Dose, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

John Dose, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Clarenece M. Doty, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Jeannie Doty, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Jennifer Dreikorn, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Edward Lentzx Dreikorn, II, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Cordell Duke, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Norma Duke, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Doyle Dunn, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Janice Dunn, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

George Dunn, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Linda Dunn, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Delores Ann Eller, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Robert Eller, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Daniel T. Encinas, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Sandra Encinas, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Earl Femea, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Joanne G. Femea, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Eugene Fields, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Patricia Ann Fields, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Edna Flanagan, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Edward Flanagan, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Beverly Fleck, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Howard Fleck, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

James Fleetwood, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Joan B. Fleetwood, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Daniel R. Fluharty, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Terry Fluharty, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

George Fox, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Rhesa Mae Fox, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Archie Franz, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Joan Franz, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Dona Frazier, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

John Frazier, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Juan Ramon Macias, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Jason Rotbergs, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Shani M. Taylor Rotbergs, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Kenneth Roth, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Sally Roth, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Debbie Routon, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Roger Routon, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Joyce Ruby, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Michael Ruby, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Dru Cilla Ryals, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Timothy Ryals, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Lena Sainz-Macias, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Richard Saunders, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Austin Sapp, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Lynn Sapp, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Cynthia Schwartz, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Ronald Schwartz, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Donald Scoggins, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Wanda Sue Scoggins, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Diyona Scott, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Percy Scott, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Martha Serafin, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Matthew Serafin, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Charles J. Setliff, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Elvie Setliff, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Charles Sewell, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Sandra K. Sewell, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Clarence Sexton, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Patsy L. Sexton, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Carl Sharps, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Rema A. Sharps, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Harold R. Sharrer, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Julie Sharrer, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Earl Shipp, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Mary Shipp, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

James Silbaugh, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Judy Ann Thomas Silbaugh, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Erin Simpson, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Matthew Simpson, Plaintiff, represented by

Matthew Simpson, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC.

Matthew Simpson, Plaintiff, represented by Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Howard Sims, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Mallory Bell Sims, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

John Skelton, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Yvette Skelton, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Gary D. Small, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Joan Small, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Edna F. Smay, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Gary Smay, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Marianna Smith, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Thomas Smith, Plaintiff, represented by James Paul Sizemore , Sizemore Law Firm, Matthew J. Sill , Sill & Medley PLLC & Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte.

Mary Balestracci, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Brice Barnes, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Patti Beller, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Jeff Boring, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Edward Carrell, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Juana Jasmin, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Steven Jordan, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Peter Ligotti, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Hugh Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Glenda Bullman, Plaintiff, represented by

Glenda Bullman, Plaintiff, represented by Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP.

Glenda Bullman, Plaintiff, represented by Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Joseph Halbrooks, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Mary Kinser, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Shamaria Lawler, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Jessie Lucas, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Lorna McCalla, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Pamela O'Connor, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Linda Ransom, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Denise Weaver, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Janis Yarbrough, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Mary Czura, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Angela Daniels, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Eliner Gibson, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Betty Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Shirley Huddleston, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Deborah Hughes, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Barry Long, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Violet Mintess, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Nina Perry, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Constance Porter, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Oralie Rollins, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Alice Szromba, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Theresa Thayer, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Barbara Breese, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Margaret Kerr, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Carolyn Profitt, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Vickie Thorne, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda J. Greenburg , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Elise Rochelle Sanguinetti , Khorrami Boucher Sumner Sanguinetti, LLP, Richard W. Schulte , Wright & Schulte, Stephen Dennis Behnke , Wright & Schulte & Stephen J. Randall , Pearson Randall & Schumacher, PA.

Felicia Lightfoot, Plaintiff, Pro Se.

Xanodyne Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Defendant, represented by Gina M. Saelinger , Ulmer & Berne, LLP, John M. Alten , Ulmer & Berne, Joseph P. Thomas , Ulmer & Berne, LLP, Kimberly Lewis Beck , Ulmer & Berne, LLP, Michael J. Suffern , Ulmer & Berne, LLP & Joshua A. Klarfeld , Ulmer & Berne.

Eli Lilly and Company, Defendant, represented by Dominique C. Price , Ice Miller LLP, Kevin L. Murch , Ice Miller LLP, Audra Jae Ferguson-Allen , Ice Miller LLP, Charles H. Stopher , Boehl, Stopher & Graves, Edward H. Stopher , Boehl, Stopher & Graves, John D. Martin , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough, LLP, Kimberly C. Metzger , Ice Miller LLP & Mary Nold Larimore , Ice Miller LLP.

Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc., Defendant, represented by Ginger Pigott , Greenberg Traurig, Lori G. Cohen , Greenberg Traurig LLP, Victoria D. Lockard , Greenberg Traurig LLP & W. Kennedy Simpson , Thompson, Miller & Simpson, PLC.

Mylan Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Defendant, represented by Bradley A. Matta , Pietragello Gordon Alfano Bosick & Raspanti LLP, Clem C. Trischler , Pietragello Gordon Alfano Bosick & Raspanti LLP, Emily J. Hicks , Pietragello Gordon Alfano Bosick & Raspanti LLP & James A. Comodeca , Dinsmore & Shohl, LLP OH.

Propst Distribution, Inc., Defendant, represented by Carla De La Barra Helstrom , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Carolyn Taylor , Morris Polich & Purdy LLP, Tammara Tukloff , Morris Polich & Purdy LLP & Winston E. Miller , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Vintage Pharmaceuticals, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam Richard Salvas , Seegar Salvas LLP, Carla De La Barra Helstrom , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Mark Steven Cheffo , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Rachel B. Passaretti-Wu , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Susan J. Pope , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Tammara Tukloff , Morris Polich & Purdy LLP & Winston E. Miller , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Qualitest Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Defendant, represented by Carla De La Barra Helstrom , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Carolyn Taylor , Morris Polich & Purdy LLP, Mark Steven Cheffo , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Rachel B. Passaretti-Wu , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Susan J. Pope , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Tammara Tukloff , Morris Polich & Purdy LLP & Winston E. Miller , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Endo Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Defendant, represented by Adam Richard Salvas , Seegar Salvas LLP, Carla De La Barra Helstrom , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Mark Steven Cheffo , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Rachel B. Passaretti-Wu , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Susan J. Pope , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Winston E. Miller , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Vintage Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Defendant, represented by Carla De La Barra Helstrom , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Carolyn Taylor , Morris Polich & Purdy LLP, Mark Steven Cheffo , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Susan J. Pope , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Tammara Tukloff , Morris Polich & Purdy LLP & Winston E. Miller , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Generics International (US), Inc., Defendant, represented by Adam Richard Salvas , Seegar Salvas LLP, Carla De La Barra Helstrom , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Mark Steven Cheffo , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Rachel B. Passaretti-Wu , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Susan J. Pope , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Winston E. Miller , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Generics Bidco I, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam Richard Salvas , Seegar Salvas LLP, Carla De La Barra Helstrom , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Mark Steven Cheffo , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Rachel B. Passaretti-Wu , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Susan J. Pope , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Winston E. Miller , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Generics International (US PARENT), Inc., Defendant, represented by Adam Richard Salvas , Seegar Salvas LLP, Carla De La Barra Helstrom , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Mark Steven Cheffo , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Rachel B. Passaretti-Wu , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Susan J. Pope , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Winston E. Miller , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Endo Pharmaceuticals Holdings, Inc., Defendant, represented by Adam Richard Salvas , Seegar Salvas LLP, Carla De La Barra Helstrom , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Mark Steven Cheffo , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Rachel B. Passaretti-Wu , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Susan J. Pope , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Winston E. Miller , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Covidien Inc., Defendant, represented by Bryan T. Pratt , Shook, Hardy & Bacon, Deborah A. Moeller , Shook, Hardy & Bacon & Jennifer Kirkpatrick Nordstrom , Garvey Shearer, PS.

Covidien PLC, Defendant, represented by Bryan T. Pratt , Shook, Hardy & Bacon, Deborah A. Moeller , Shook, Hardy & Bacon & Jennifer Kirkpatrick Nordstrom , Garvey Shearer, PSC.

Mallinckrodt, Inc., Defendant, represented by Douglas Wayne Robinson , Shook Hardy and Bacon LLP, Tony M. Diab , Shook Hardy and Bacon LLP, Bryan T. Pratt , Shook, Hardy & Bacon, Deborah A. Moeller , Shook, Hardy & Bacon & Jennifer Kirkpatrick Nordstrom , Garvey Shearer, PSC.

McKesson Corporation, Defendant, represented by Farley J. Neuman , Goodman Neuman Hamilton LLP, Patricia L. Bonheyo , Goodman Neuman Hamilton LLP & Pavan L. Rosati , Goodman Neuman Hamilton LLP.

Brenn Distribution, Inc., Defendant, represented by Carla De La Barra Helstrom , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Carolyn Taylor , Morris Polich & Purdy LLP, Susan J. Pope , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Tammara Tukloff , Morris Polich & Purdy LLP & Winston E. Miller , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Brenn Manufacturing, Inc., Defendant, represented by Carla De La Barra Helstrom , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Carolyn Taylor , Morris Polich & Purdy LLP, Susan J. Pope , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Tammara Tukloff , Morris Polich & Purdy LLP & Winston E. Miller , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

Generics Bidco II, LLC, Defendant, represented by Mark Steven Cheffo , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Adam Richard Salvas , Seegar Salvas LLP, Carla De La Barra Helstrom , Frost Brown Todd LLC, Rachel B. Passaretti-Wu , Quinn Emanual Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, Susan J. Pope , Frost Brown Todd LLC & Winston E. Miller , Frost Brown Todd LLC.

NeoSan Pharmaceuticals Inc., Defendant, represented by Chad R. Ziepfel , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP OH, Nicholas J. Pieczonka , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP OH, Ryan Christian Edwards , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP & Russell Stanfield Sayre , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP OH.

aaiPharma LLC, Defendant, represented by Chad R. Ziepfel , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP OH, Nicholas J. Pieczonka , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP OH, Ryan Christian Edwards , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP & Russell Stanfield Sayre , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP OH.

aaiPharma, Inc., Defendant, represented by Chad R. Ziepfel , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP OH, Nicholas J. Pieczonka , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP OH, Ryan Christian Edwards , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP & Russell Stanfield Sayre , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP OH.

AAI Development Services, Inc., Defendant, represented by Chad R. Ziepfel , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP OH, Nicholas J. Pieczonka , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP OH, Ryan Christian Edwards , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP & Russell Stanfield Sayre , Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, LLP OH.

Mylan, Inc., Defendant, represented by Bradley A. Matta , Pietragello Gordon Alfano Bosick & Raspanti LLP, Clem C. Trischler , Pietragello Gordon Alfano Bosick & Raspanti LLP, Emily J. Hicks , Pietragello Gordon Alfano Bosick & Raspanti LLP & James A. Comodeca , Dinsmore & Shohl, LLP OH.

Watson Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Defendant, represented by Sam B. Blair, Jr. , Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz & Summer H. McMillan , Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz.

Cornerstone BioPharma Holdings, LLC, Defendant, represented by Kai Peters , Gordon & Rees, LLP.

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

Consistent with the opinion of the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit ("Sixth Circuit") [MDL Record No. 3008] vacating this Court's July 25, 2013 Order and remanding the above-captioned cases, this matter is pending for consideration of the Plaintiffs' motions to remand. [MDL Record Nos. 2608, 2612, 2613, 2659, 2663, 2664, 2665] This Court's July 25, 2013 Order granted the Plaintiffs' motions, thereby remanding these cases to the California Superior Courts from which they were removed. The Defendants appealed to the Sixth Circuit. That court held the appeal in abeyance pending an en banc decision by the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ("Ninth Circuit") regarding whether a petition for coordination under § 404 of the California Code of Civil Procedure was a proposal for a joint trial, rendering the cases a "mass action" as defined in the Class Action Fairness Act of 2005 ("CAFA"), 28 U.S.C. § 1332(d)(11)(B)(i). The Ninth Circuit has now answered that question in the affirmative, finding that "[a]sking for coordination or consolidation `for all purposes' or `through trial' to address common issues of law or fact is a proposal to try the cases jointly and creates federal jurisdiction under CAFA's mass action provision." Corber v. Xanodyne Pharm., Inc., 771 F.3d 1218, 1225 (9th Cir. 2014) (en banc). Further briefing of the Plaintiffs' motions is not necessary. Having reconsidered the Plaintiffs' motions in light of Corber, the Court finds that it has jurisdiction over these cases under CAFA and the Plaintiffs' motions to remand will be denied.

A mass action is removable if the citizenship of any plaintiff is different from the citizenship of any defendant and the total matter in controversy exceeds $5,000,000. 28 U.S.C. § 1332(d)(2). Under CAFA, a "mass action" is defined as "any civil action . . . in which monetary relief claims of 100 or more persons are proposed to be tried jointly on the ground that the plaintiffs' claims involve common questions of law or fact." 28 U.S.C. § 1332(d)(11)(B)(i). Any civil action in which "the claims have been consolidated or coordinated solely for pretrial proceedings" is excluded from this definition. 28 U.S.C. § 1332(d)(11)(B)(ii)(IV).

The Plaintiffs' alleged proposal for a joint trial occurred on October 23, 2012, when they filed a Petition for Coordination of their related California state-court cases with the California Judicial Council. They sought to coordinate these seven products-liability actions alleging the use of propoxyphene products, "as well as other such cases that may be filed before [the] Petition is decided." [MDL Record No. 2710-2, p. 8; MDL Record No. 2710-5] Under California law, coordination of civil actions is appropriate

if one judge hearing all of the actions for all purposes in a selected site or sites will promote the ends of justice taking into account whether the common question of fact or law is predominating and significant to the litigation; the convenience of parties, witnesses, and counsel; the relative development of the actions and the work product of counsel; the efficient utilization of judicial facilities and manpower; the calendar of the courts; the disadvantages of duplicative and inconsistent rulings, orders, or judgments; and, the likelihood of settlement of the actions without further litigation should coordination be denied.

Cal. Civ. Proc. Code § 404.1. The Plaintiffs' Petition was granted on May 16, 2013. [MDL Record No. 2710-8] Here, the question of jurisdiction turns on whether the Plaintiffs' claims were "proposed to be tried jointly" when they asked that the cases be consolidated under state law.

The Ninth Circuit was faced with the same question in Corber. That court looked to the language contained in the petitions for coordination to assess whether the plaintiffs proposed that the cases be tried jointly. Corber, 771 F.3d at 1223 ("[W]hen we assess whether there has been a proposal for joint trial, we hold plaintiffs responsible for what they have said and done."). The Corber court rejected application of a bright-line rule requiring that "a petition to evoke CAFA must expressly request a `joint trial' to be a proposal to try the cases jointly. Id. at 1225. Application of this rule would "ignore the real substance of Plaintiffs' petitions." Id. The Ninth Circuit looked at the totality of the circumstances, rather than the explicit language, to examine whether the matter qualified as a removable mass action under CAFA. Id. at 1220.

Instead, the court looked to the language the plaintiffs used to request coordination. First, the plaintiffs requested coordination "for all purposes," which "must include the purposes of trial." Id. at 1223. Second, the specific reasons relied upon by plaintiffs in their petition supported the conclusion that a joint trial was requested. Id. A joint trial was the only means by which the plaintiffs' cited bases, such as "the danger of inconsistent judgments and conflicting determinations of liability" could be accomplished. Corber, 771 F.3d at 1223.

The Plaintiffs' argument that they were simply parroting the requirements for consolidation under the language of § 404.1 of the California Code of Civil Procedure was rejected. Id. at 1224. In rejecting this argument, the Corber court noted that the plaintiffs listed several bases in support of the petition which were not included in the § 404.1 factors, "requested more than pre-trial coordination," and "repeatedly" stated that the factors catalogued in § 404.1 "all supported coordination, including the fact that `one judge hearing all of the actions for all purposes in a selected site or sites will promote the ends of justice.'" Id. The court stopped short of suggesting that all petitions for coordination under § 404 are proposals to try cases jointly for purposes of CAFA, noting that a petition expressly limiting coordination to pre-trial matters would not fall within the definition of a mass action. Id.; see Aiona v. Bayer Healthcare Pharm., Inc., No. C-14-4745, 2015 WL 293496 (N.D. Calif. January 20, 2015) (finding that petition which explicitly and repeatedly stated that coordination was sought "for pre-pretrial purposes only" did not fall within the ambit of CAFA).

The Ninth Circuit's reasoning in Corber is persuasive, and this Court adopts it here. The Plaintiffs' petition and supporting documentation use language almost identical to that considered by the Ninth Circuit in Corber. The Plaintiffs clearly and repeatedly indicated that coordination was sought "for all purposes," which would include joint trial. [MDL Record Nos. 2710-2, 2710-5] The Petition itself references coordination to facilitate "hearing all of the actions for all purposes." [MDL Record No. 2710-5] Further, there is no language in the petition or supporting documentation that would exclude coordination for trial purposes, or limit coordination for pre-trial purposes only. The Plaintiffs also specifically reference a "coordination trial judge," indicating that the plaintiffs intended a joint trial, even if not explicitly stated. [MDL Record No. 2710-2, p. 9]

Additionally, as in Corber, the Plaintiffs relied on certain factors which indicated that a joint trial was proposed as part of the coordination of cases. The Plaintiffs indicated that "absent coordination of these actions by a single judge, there is a significant likelihood of . . . possible inconsistent judicial rulings on legal issues" and that "the parties may suffer from disadvantages cause by duplicative and inconsistent . . . judgments." [MDL Record No. 2710-2, pp. 7, 9, 11] Further, the Plaintiffs indicated that common issues to be addressed after coordination include "issues pertaining to liability, allocation of fault and contribution, as well as the same wrongful conduct of defendants." [MDL Record No. 2710-2, p. 11] Such issues would be raised, most likely, during trial. Thus, the specific factors referenced by the Plaintiffs further support the conclusion that they were proposing a joint trial.

In summary, by asking for coordination of the cases "for all purposes" and relying on specific reasoning suggesting a joint trial, the Plaintiffs proposed a joint trial which created federal jurisdiction under CAFA's mass action provision. 28 U.S.C. § 1332(d)(11)(B)(i). Accordingly, it is

ORDERED that the Plaintiffs' motions to remand [MDL Record Nos. 2608, 2612, 2613, 2659, 2663, 2664, 2665] are DENIED.

Comment

1000 Characters Remaining

Leagle.com reserves the right to edit or remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.

User Comments

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases